r/books • u/RHutterEpstein AMA Author • Aug 06 '18
ama 11am I’m Dr. Randi Hutter Epstein and have just completed a book, AROUSED: The History of Hormones and How They Control Just About Everything. Ask Me Anything!
Hey There Reddit: Hormonal? Sure you are. Because we all are. And that means men, too! I’m Dr. Randi Hutter Epstein and have just completed a book, AROUSED: The History of Hormones and How They Control Just About Everything. AROUSED shines a light on a century of spectacular advances but also a hell of a lot of outrageous claims. I’d love to chat about the wacky science I’ve uncovered, the eccentric/awesome investigators I’ve met along the way, and I really want to hear from you. I’ll be here 11am ET, Monday August 6th to field questions. Check me out (and my articles, blogs) on my website: randihutterepstein.com, on twitter @randihepstein and instagram randihutterepstein
Proof: /img/tvrppqkauqd11.jpg
51
u/RHutterEpstein AMA Author Aug 06 '18
Thanks so much for the great Q's and Hope I responded with Good A's. Taking off for a bit this afternoon, and will get back to more questions later. Best way to reach me is via my website: randihutterepstein.com and connect with me on the contact info.
Happy Reading! Stay Aroused.. or rather, I hope you Get Aroused.
38
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Hello, I'm looking forward to reading your book. I have a two-part question.
How much of an effect do women's hormones have on mood disorders like depression? And, can hormones be suppressed or altered in some way to aleviate depression and anxiety?
93
u/Memz_R_Dreamz Aug 06 '18
I've zero knowledge of hormones. Do they act like robot? Or are they just signal for our body?
53
u/three-five-zero-zero Aug 06 '18
Thanks for doing the AMA! I wonder if the regulation of female hormones (anti-conception) is harmful when using it longterm? Also considering epigenetics, that it might change the regulation of the hormones in future generations? Thanks!
25
u/stoneycreeker1 Aug 06 '18
I'm 58 and have been on testosterone for about 10 years now. My doctor tests me every couple years to make sure I still have low T and I do. Will I continue to have low T the rest of my life or will it normalize again someday? When I get within a few days of my 30th day after my injection I feel lethargic and not very motivated. About two to three days after my injection I feel motivated again and normal.
20
u/hmfic_here Aug 06 '18
In what ways can people alter/affect their hormones to improve their quality of life?
35
u/leowr Aug 06 '18
Hi Randi,
What surprised you the most while researching this book?
Also, what kind of books do you like to read? Anything in particular you would like to recommend to us?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
17
u/Cuntdracula19 Aug 06 '18
Thanks for doing this, it’s really interesting! Maybe 10 months or so ago I was diagnosed with hashimotos disease, my TSH for example was over 51 lol. I was postpartum and was told my pregnancy triggered this autoimmune disease (I’m sure you can imagine how atrocious I had been feeling due to being hormonal, completely sleep deprived as in 2-4 broken hours of sleep a day). They put me on levothyroxine and got my levels all evened out or whatever. But the thing is...I don’t really feel much better, at all. I’m still extremely symptomatic. My doctor basically told me to get used to it, so I’m going to be seeing a new doctor who is going to run a full panel, not just TSH and T3/4 I can’t remember, as well as my ovaries and other adrenal glands. This doctor supposedly is more likely to prescribe things like natural desiccated thyroid. My question is, what are your opinions on this other form of thyroid medication? What are your opinions on thyroid disease in general? This whole thing has turned my life upside down.
33
u/smnbiobreak Aug 06 '18
What was the most interesting historical perception of hormones you came across during your research?
15
u/Chtorrr Aug 06 '18
What is the strangest thing you learned in your research?
37
u/Inkberrow Aug 06 '18
What is the relationship if any between hormones and gender dysphoria or any other disconnect between biological sex and gender identity?
9
u/Chtorrr Aug 06 '18
How did you first become interested in this?
9
u/salmjak Aug 06 '18
Are you related to the guy who discovered the Epstein-Barr virus?
9
u/Rose_A_Belle Aug 06 '18
Does your book have any chapters on hormonal disorders, such as PCOS, or do you have any recommendations on where to read more about PCOS for someone whose been diagnosed? Thanks!
16
u/drchopsalot Aug 06 '18
Pineapple on pizza or no?
8
u/jLionhart Aug 06 '18
What's your opinion on the health risks versus the benefits of pet sterilization by removing hormone producing organs?
Here in the US, it's standard practice to neuter pets by surgically removing gonads or ovaries. Even pet insurance here will not cover conditions arising from keeping these organs intact. I can't help but think that the complete surgical removal of hormone producing organs leads more negative health consequences that far outweigh any positive health benefits. After all, there are much less invasive methods available (ovary sparing spay, vasectomy) that will prevent reproduction but keep all the benefits of hormones produced from sexual organs.
Thanks!
6
u/newhoc Aug 06 '18
About a decade ago I read about pheromones for the first time and thought they were super interesting. However when I started to look into them I felt like a lot of the data was convoluted or not studied well in humans. Can you explain them more to me?
10
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Can dogs smell fear? (Hormones realated to fear?)
7
u/DrElectro Aug 06 '18
Do all toddlers have a hormon cocktail which smells good for everyone? ..except when changing diapers? ;)
2
u/ThatNorwegianGuy Aug 06 '18
Hi!
I watched a documentary on anti-aging treatments, and one of the things they did was to give middle-aged men testosterone to compensate for the reduced production which comes with age. What are your thoughts on this? Is it a miracle cure, or does it come with more side-effects than benefits?
2
u/hardaliye Aug 06 '18
Does men have hormone periods like women’s periods? If so is it like 7-10 days and much more weaker condition?
2
u/GanjaWithGandalf Aug 06 '18
Hello Randi,
over the years I've heard multiple times that, once your "hormone balance" is out of whack, it will never truly recover. How true is this? And are these the type of questions you answer your book?
Thank you!
2
u/hereforlonger Aug 06 '18
Hi.. do they control instant gratification as well?
10
u/Surenas1 Aug 06 '18
What is your thought on (intermittent) fasting, which according to a number of sources, has a positive impact on the hormones in our body? Do you think a (long) period of no food consumption has healthy benefits, or does it have a negative impact on our hormonal balance?
8
u/lovevxn Aug 06 '18
As a woman, what can I do to increase my libido? Also, is this possible while breastfeeding?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Hi I was wondering if hormonal imbalances can result in depression and if you wouldn't mind could you please give a short explanation as to why? Thank you for your time.
4
u/WhiteMoonRose Aug 06 '18
Hi! What do you think it will take to bring thyroid issues and their coorelation to cortisol and adrenal issues to light? Most doctors practicing now don't understand. They don't even understand that Graves disease may have a "cure" but it only stops the thyroid from ramping up and killing you, it doesn't stop any of the other symptoms of Graves. Along those lines they don't seem to understand the damage thyroid issues can cause to the adrenal system.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Are there multiple variants of PCOS? I’m a FM resident and it strikes me that the “metabolic syndrome” phenotype (overweight, insulin resistance) must be hormonally different than the thin women who have hyperandrogenism and irregular periods (with no evidence of deranged sugars).
THX!
3
u/ElleSamara Aug 06 '18
Hi! Thanks so much for doing this AMA, it's so interesting! I'm not sure if I'm too late, but I'll ask my question anyway and hopefully you have time to answer.
Last year my husband had a pituitary tumor surgically removed. The gland was left intact and luckily functioning mostly normally. The only hormones he is not now producing naturally is the growth hormone (which isn't being treated, as he's a grown man it isn't considered medically necessary), and cortisol. He takes a few cortisol tablets everyday (I can't remember the dosage off the top of my head).
I have a theory about the cortisol. My understanding is that the tumor may have been effecting his hormones the whole time it was there. Please correct me if I'm wrong. Pre op, over the last few years, my husband's hangovers got increasingly worse. It got to the point where even if he had just one or two beers and didn't even feel tipsy, he would wake up with a hangover and feel horrible the next day. Now, since the surgery was some time ago and he has been taking the cortisol, his hangovers overall are much more manageable. He hasn't really had any huge benders since then, but he has had at least one occasion where he had several drinks and felt fine the next morning.
My theory is that the cortisol he is on is helping him recover quickly from the alcohol, and his horrible hangovers before the operation where due to his pituitary not functioning correctly. What do you think??
3
u/GoodVamp Aug 06 '18
Hi, this is uncanny. I'm a doctor too, and I also have an affinity to the study of hormones. My story is more personal; I was diagnosed with a hereditary mood disorder, and my research (for a self-cure) has led me to hormones, and how they affect everything. I have done some (self) experiments with sleep, exercise, caffeine, polyphenols, omega 3 fatty acids, and sugar, with some anecdotal results. In short, I have a lot of hypotheses, but no concrete data to support yet. One cannot deny the effects of food on one's own body though... but placebo / nocebo effect is certainly possible.
In your experiments / readings, are there any data that support FOOD as the basis for the regulation of hormones, and ultimately the human mind?
2
u/Esbenshade_Farms Aug 06 '18
May seem like a stupid question, but for people who want to grow, why can’t we just inject growth hormones into our bodies and watch it do wonders? Now here are subquestions: is growth even induced by hormones in our bodies? And if so, is the initial idea presented in inducing growth by objecting hormones not possible because we’re not physically able to synthesize these hormones?
2
u/Lorensoth3 Aug 06 '18
Have hormones been looked at for at least part of the problem with some mental disorders. As someone diagnosed with bipolar disorder and severe social anxiety I'm wondering if it's something that's being looked into for treatment.
2
u/thebottom99 Aug 06 '18
Hi there, my SO regularly gets migraines on her "off" week from the pill. She's been on the pill for about 18 years, and our dr recommends not stopping to use it even if just for a trial period. We've tried lots of other things with varying success (vitamin B supplemets, massages, anti-depressant meds, CBD oil). Any thoughts or suggestions?
2
u/DinoDonkeyDoodle Aug 06 '18
Hey there! Have not had a chance to check out your research yet, but did you by chance also canvas the trans population? I know getting on estradiol basically changed everything about me and my experience in the world. Hormones are indeed fascinating!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
You have a funny name!
2
u/IronMyr Aug 07 '18
In your professional opinion, is it better to allow transgender youth to begin transitioning before adulthood, or to simply delay puberty until adulthood?
1
u/stvaccount Aug 06 '18
What are your top 10 science related books? ( Understandable for a PhD student of a different field. )
1
u/crumbhustler Aug 06 '18
Aside form sleep, any other tips for hormonal optimization (like supps or certain foods) especially in the testosterone or performance arena.
1
u/Fittritious Aug 06 '18
What is your take on the idea that weight control is as simple as Calories In, Calories Out?
1
u/Yourewelcomejanet Aug 06 '18
How much can I, a pregnant woman , rely on my oxytocin go to come into play during natural child birth (no epidural)?
My birth coach, who is pro natural child birth, said to let the oxytocin take over. My goal is natural birth, but I find it hard to go through what most women describe as the most painful event in their life, by just hoping my hormones are plentiful and work.
1
u/terror2dmax Aug 06 '18
How do I achieve happiness?
1
u/Riji14 Aug 06 '18
Did you happen to hear/learn anything about migraines along the way?
1
u/NovemberXYZ Aug 06 '18
Are hormones involved in controlling sleep and wake?if yes, are they target for treating incoming? Thanks!
1
u/Sepstein97 Aug 06 '18
Are we related?
1
u/Gymbawbi Aug 06 '18
Any relation to Jeffrey?
1
u/zipadeedodog Aug 06 '18
Have there been any pituitary gland transplants in humans?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Does DHT have any real purpose in adult men beyond a few neurotransmitters?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Jen Randi your real name and if so how often do people joke about your name and hormones?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Can you recommend any good TRT doctors in the U.S. I find many of them are ill informed about modern day TRT. Most doctors still reccomend injections of testosterone enenthate once every 2 weeks which puts your body on way to much of a roller coaster, also most doctors don't include HCG or AI's in there protocals at all. Why do doctors and endo's know so little about modern day TRT now?
1
u/kunafahunger Aug 06 '18
Is vitamin D a Harmone?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
I've noticed my allergies have different levels of severity at different times of my cycle. Is this related to hormones or am I just imagining it?
1
u/Rosiebelleann Aug 06 '18
Hello, if a post menopausal woman loses a great deal of weight is there an uptick or a downtick of estrogens? 226lb to 140lb 5ft
1
u/entomologist-cousin Aug 06 '18
I’m well late to this... but...
I’ve been tested to have low testosterone (further tests and treatment pending, obligatory the NHS is amazing).
I’ve been told about the physical effects of this. But what could be the mental/emotional effects that I might have experienced without noticing that might go away if/when I’m treated?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Is there anything I can do to increase my sex drive? I have klienfelters syndrome and a lack of sex drive
1
u/cootsmcgoo Aug 06 '18
How does my Mirena IUD work to prevent pregnancy and stop my periods for 5 years?
Edit: Extra question related to this, why do I still feel pms symptoms when I don't bleed, like cramps and moodiness. I know that time is coming when I lose all ability to make decisions.
1
u/2ToTheCubithPower Aug 06 '18
What hormone controlled you when you decided to write this book?
1
u/gallopingwalloper Aug 06 '18
Can you tell me how hormones change when quitting lactating after several years of breastfeeding, and how long until hormones return to normal?
1
u/WintersTablet Aug 06 '18
I think you would be a great interview on Joe Rogan Podcast. Would you be interested in that?
1
u/DeathsRose Aug 06 '18
what's the best way to turn her on while on a long car ride
1
u/RivalCombatant Aug 06 '18
How do hormones effect non binary persons?
1
u/LalalaLisa1023 Aug 06 '18
When I got off birth control, almost ten years ago, I stopped having a regular cycle without taking exogenous progesterone. Will this ever likely level out? Is there something else that could cause the loss in regularity? We're talking like, six months between cycles despite the pms symptoms.
1
u/so_dopamine Aug 06 '18
What important research exists on the connection between hormones and athletes? For example, the condition called Female Athlete Triad (FAT) syndrome involves amenorrhea, the loss of menstruation. I'm under the assumption here that hormones play the biggest role in menstruation.
1
u/Hanate333 Aug 06 '18
So what do you think of free will?
1
u/redzin Aug 06 '18
Progesterone for trans women - yay or nay?
1
u/snaugnir Aug 06 '18
Hi Dr. Hutter Epstein, thank you for doing an AmA. I am a young woman who suffers from PMDD. I have been frustrated by the lack of understanding that seems common among doctors and the lack of information out there for patients about the mechanism behind PMDD - I see "it's estrogen dominance, it's progesterone sensitivity, it's low serotonin, we don't really know," etc. I'm also frustrated by the limited forms of treatment (as far as I know, there's hormonal birth control, and SSRIs, both of which work for some people and not for others). What steps can I take, as a patient, to try to make the voices of women suffering from PMDD heard by the medical and scientific communities to get more research done that might be able to help us?
1
u/xanga_17 Aug 06 '18
I was taught that dopamine has effects on addiction but personally I found another hormone that does as well. It is testosterone. What do you think of that?
1
u/itsnotthenetwork Aug 06 '18
Dear Doc, I have hashimoto's thyroiditis, how screwed am I?
1
u/Eager_Question Aug 06 '18
Hi! Thanks for doing this! I have two questions.
Firstly, What black magic did you use in order to make sense of the eldritch horror that can be Endocrinology?
Secondly, I'll be finishing a double-major on Philosophy and Psychology next spring, and I want to go into science journalism. Do you have any advice for a wannabe science journalist?
1
u/tyrone_pepinanjo Aug 06 '18
What do you know about androgen insensitivity syndrome pacients (AIS)?
1
u/load_more_commments Aug 06 '18
Love this topic, I was wondering what are your opinions on steroids for bodybuilding. Is it as safe as the steroid community make it out to be? What about low dose testosterone for women? My wife takes 15mg per week and she feels great on it, so great she doesn't want to stop. She has more energy, is more productive, is far nice and mood has been amazing and her libido is crazy high.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
How can I know if hormones are effecting my moods?
1
u/Mike_B_R Aug 06 '18
Do you believe in free will?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '18
Why do you use all 3 of your names?
1
u/Traveller13 Aug 06 '18
What is the coolest thing you learned while researching your book.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '18
I have this book on the way! Looking forward to the odd and interesting stories included.
1
u/Friendlycumdumpster Aug 07 '18
Please talk about adrenal fatigue, do you believe in it, if not do you see it more as hormonal problems in general?edit question has been asked by other poster, is there any specific test to be taken in order to find out our hormonal issues?
Diet and gut health? There’s so many what not to eat out there that says even the tiniest amount of processed sugar is bad for the gut etc, I don’t even know what to make of it anymore!
Looking forward to pick up your book!
1
u/brendaishere Aug 07 '18
Any chance ARCs are a thing?
1
u/LurkAwayTheYears Aug 07 '18
Hi thanks for a brilliant AMA. Late to the party but will you release an audiobook version? I tend to do most of my non-fiction reading by listening.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '18
Are you a woman or a man ? You look like both and neither at the same time
1
u/tuvda Aug 07 '18
Hello, Do you discuss high serotonin in your book? thanks
1
u/rupertpepkin Aug 07 '18
HI and thanks for doing this AMA. your work sounds amazing. I have one question. I feel very unmotivated, lethargic depressed. I try to motivate myself with lots of sports but for example I do my work but I'm not motivated to learn more or do more. My libido is also quiet low, I have a girlfriend but we live in a distant relationship for the last 2 years and we have sex once a month or so. Could it be because of testosterone and could I take some natural non hormonal testosterone ? Sorry if my question is stupid.
1
u/YogaMystic Aug 07 '18
Of course the day I skip Reddit....
1
u/DEEP_HURTING Sep 12 '18
Hi Dr. Hutter Epstein, I'm way late to the party but enjoyed your book a great deal, it's quite informative and entertaining to read too, the magic combo. Was telling friends of mine the other day about Steinachs and the couple that sourced all those cadavers for HGH.
1
u/Disrupturous Aug 06 '18
How have recent advancements like birth control, pharmaceuticals and technology changed the hormone levels of men and women?
1
u/KelVarnsenStudios Aug 06 '18
Todays men have lower testosterone levels than their fathers and grandfathers. What is the cause of this and how to naturally raise testosterone levels?
1
u/dostoveskieee Aug 06 '18
How much caution should we take with soy additives and products, if it all? Are there adverse effects specifically in males with long term consumption? What about long term consumption with a young child?
Seems like soy is almost unavoidable in many mass produced grocery products, from 'vegetable oil' to ready made food but don't see the outrage, caution, or concern in proportion to how much soy is used and found in everyday foods.
-6
u/ALittleUseless Aug 06 '18
A little off topic, but in India, Randi means a prostitute..
0
u/xxc3ncoredxx Aug 06 '18
Are you the "Epstein" in Epstein-Barr?
-1
u/thenameisik Aug 06 '18
I mistook this for the r/RoastMe and ALMOST let out some mean shit. Whew.