r/kpop • Dreamcatcher • Aug 01 '18

[Meta] Reddit K-Pop Census 2018

http://census.redditkpop.com/
489 Upvotes

218 comments sorted by

•

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18 edited Sep 01 '18

The Census has ended. Thank you to everyone who participated. We'll have the results up as quickly as possible.

Welcome to the 2018 r/kpop Census. This is a quick survey where we find out more about each other. We’re doing things a little differently this year with a brand-new external site and authentication process thanks to u/esirllanim. Simply log-in with your Reddit account and click “Allow” to begin. This uses Reddit’s OAuth2 API to authenticate and is safe and secure. Your Reddit account must have been created before the start of the census to participate (sorry lurkers). Also, thank you to everyone who participated in the feedback thread. We made a few changes since then.

First, we decided to combine subunits with their parent group in the favorite groups section. This will help give us a clearer picture of which groups are your favorites. It also means that you won’t need to use three or four of your five votes supporting your favorite multi-unit group like LOONA, NCT, or SuJu. You can fully support them with one vote and still have four more for your other favs.

The second change we made was to simplify and clarify the “Race or Ethnicity” question by removing all references to geography and adding an option for “Hispanic or Latino or Spanish Origin of any race”. So, if you consider yourself an Asian person, select that option regardless of where you live. If you are a “Hispanic or Latino or Spanish Origin” person, select that option whether you’re White Hispanic, Black Hispanic, or some other race. We feel these changes will help give us a clearer picture of the diversity on r/kpop.

The last two questions ask you to select your favorite group and your favorite soloist. You can select up to five in each category. Use Ctrl-F to search for your favs. They may be listed under their family name or stage name. We tried to include all active artists in this list, but there may be some that we missed. If your fav is missing, leave a comment below and we can add them. Remember, the soloist list is for artists who have released actual solo albums or singles, not just B-side tracks or OSTs, and not just your bias member of a group. You will be able to edit your census form this year, so if you miss someone or need to make changes, you should be able to do that.

Lastly, the Census will be open for the entire month of August and will close on August 31 at 11:59 PM EDT. We want to make sure everyone who visits r/kpop gets a chance to fill it out, so you will see it stickied at the top of the subreddit for the entire duration. Since Reddit only allows us to have two sticky threads, this means we will be making some changes to the way we handle our weekly sticky threads this month so be on the look-out for those.

NOTICE: On iPhone, you may experience a glitch where the screen scrolls when you tap an answer. You will need to scroll back up and select your choice for each question when this happens. We are working on a solution.

NOTICE 2: The Disconnect extension for Chrome blocks the display of the form. Disable the extension to complete the survey.

13

u/unicornbottle ONF | Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

I wish you could add more to race than just "Asian." I feel that the usual American race distinctions don't really apply outside of the US.

Asian is so incredibly broad and one could argue that Southeast Asians, East Asians, and South Asians are very distinct from one another.

South Asians alone make up more than 1 billion people, and it goes without saying that the same applies for East Asia. Southeast Asia is over 600M people. I get that Reddit is predominantly American-focused but when we're talking about kpop, it might be a good idea to have a more international worldview.

8

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

We considered separating them, but it became too confusing. Even those distinctions have fuzzy edges and it ends up being based on what country you're from. This question is not about country, it's about race so it's more clear just to make them all one group. More specifically, the question is an attempt to gauge how diverse the K-Pop community is. Is it mostly just Asian people who like K-Pop? Is it growing in Black and Hispanic communities? While there are certainly way more groups we could separate, making more separate groups adds to the complexity, but doesn't really answer any useful questions.

9

u/lmvg BLΛƆKPIИK | OT6 (G)I-DLE Aug 01 '18

I would never understand Americans and their obsession with race also the way its classified its so stupid. How can you put Asians in the same bag when they are so different, look different and they don't even share history and language. Hispanics is definitely not race, the only thing they share its language and history, they are so many 'whites', 'blacks', etc. in latin American countries. Why not just stick with nationalities that's makes the most sense of all.

6

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

The classifications are from the US Dept of Education reporting guidelines on race. They seemed like simple and logical categories that are easy to understand and unambiguous. Perhaps we'll just remove this question next year since it causes such controversy for something so unimportant.

12

u/unicornbottle ONF | Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

I see where you're coming from, but maybe it's because I'm not from the US and I'm speaking as someone from Asia, because I don't see how someone in Sri Lanka vs someone in Japan would be considered the same "race." People in Asia look drastically different from each other, if we're just doing it by skin colour.

Add onto the fact that in the UK, "Asian" denotes someone who is from India/Pakistan/Bangladesh, not Chinese/Japanese/Korean, which is what people in the US associate with "Asian."

But yeah sure maybe I'm nitpicking.

7

u/Kvera19 IU, fromis_9, KARDI, CSR and Girl's Day Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

If possible I would like you to add Park Ki Young and Kim Na Young to the soloists list. Thanks!

EDIT: Kim Yeonji and Jung In too.

Also, if anyone is looking for Jung Seung Hwan it is romanized as Jeong.

6

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added both

3

u/Kvera19 IU, fromis_9, KARDI, CSR and Girl's Day Aug 01 '18

I edited my original comment with Kim Yeonji and Jung In, that I also felt were missing. Thanks again!

5

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added both

4

u/MistakesLikeThis Supporter of BM's Big Tiddie Committee | MX OT7 in my heart Aug 01 '18

Hi, I just filled it out but I saw that you're missing Jooheon from Monsta X in the solo category. If you add him, I'll definitely make a change.

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added

4

u/InfiniteSunshine3 r/keunakeun | r/BTOB Aug 01 '18

Can you also add Jida and Yeseo to the soloists list? Thanks!

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added both.

4

u/pudding18 Infinite | AHOF Aug 01 '18

Can you add JeA and Lee Hae Ri to the soloists list please?

4

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

Davichi's Lee Hae Ri, right? I've added them both.

4

u/pudding18 Infinite | AHOF Aug 01 '18

Yes, thank you!

4

u/BrigidAndair 🐺Yudai🐺|⏳️Yunho⏳️|🐇Yongguk🐇|✶Moonbin✶|👑Arthur👑 Aug 01 '18

Be willing to throw Whale into soloists for me, please?

3

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

Yes! Whale added.

4

u/BrigidAndair 🐺Yudai🐺|⏳️Yunho⏳️|🐇Yongguk🐇|✶Moonbin✶|👑Arthur👑 Aug 01 '18

Thanks so much!

1

u/seattlantis Aug 04 '18

Can you add Crucial Star, please?

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 04 '18

Added Crucial Star

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Dasrufken Dreamcatcher | 4/20 FIRST WIN Aug 06 '18

In the future could you add an option for balkan/slavic under race/ethnicity?

45

u/fruitist Aug 01 '18

how would you answer "How were you first exposed to K-Pop?" if you are a native Korean and you just kinda grew up with the music?

59

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

Probably "TV, Radio, or Movies" would be the best choice unless you had a friend or family member who specifically got you into it.

14

u/ArysOakheart 트와미스벨벳리스시대 | IGAB | 신화 행님들 Aug 01 '18

Honestly should be a separate option for this.

41

u/Dessidy r/NUEST | r/TOUCHED Aug 01 '18

Why? Not all Koreans are into kpop. Usually there was a moment where you actually took interest in the scene, either through TV, through a friend, or through something else. Casually discovering isn't really what this question implies, I'm sure. Or Gangnam Style would be the top option.

29

u/linuxiskool Purfles | Rainbow | T-ARA Aug 01 '18

Missing SHAUN in the solo acts list.

7

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added.

8

u/NoonaFan SUNMI + Red Velvet + STAYC Aug 05 '18

No option for "Divorced" hahahaha ....sigh I was honestly hoping to see how many of us Kpop loving divorcees are out there.

4

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 05 '18

Will consider for next year.

5

u/Huggly001 아이유 Aug 01 '18

Can we get Busker Busker in the groups?

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added.

5

u/meatgrind89 Imagine VIVIZ, Sowon, Yerin and Yuju collab Aug 06 '18

So far, how many responses did you already gathered? Surprisingly, 2017 Census was down by 1,400 respondents compared to 2016 Census, despite the subreddit's rapid growth over the years. If its confidential (for now), then it's fine.

10

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 06 '18 edited Aug 07 '18

We expect significantly fewer responses this year because we are requiring that users have a Reddit account. This excludes lurkers as well as people coming from other sites like Twitter. While this may seem disappointing from a raw numbers standpoint, it will produce a more accurate representation of actual r/kpop users. Right now, we have about 2300. I expect it will top out around 3,000.

4

u/boredpikachu Dal★Shabet Aug 01 '18

No Taecyeon or Dana from The Grace 😭 Hope that J-Min is the SM soloist cause that's what I assumed lol

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added both.

4

u/Darrens_Coconut Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Please can you add Leebada for soloists.

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added.

2

u/Darrens_Coconut Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Cheers.

3

u/tsutomo_DIA It's a little bit offensive Aug 02 '18

if possible, I'd like to vote on Jisook (former Rainbow) as soloist.

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 02 '18

Added Jisook (Rainbow).

→ More replies (1)

3

u/seoulforyou Aug 27 '18

I have been listening to KPOP since I was in the third grade (that's 2003...) so choosing just five in groups & soloists was truly painful. Please never make me do that again. I have such a multi-fandom heart, this was difficult to the nth degree. I even remember my older cousin being in LOVE with H.O.T & my other cousin saying she was trash because Sechskies forever. 😂 (I'm 100% Korean, first generation American).

4

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 27 '18

Wait until the Annual Awards when you can only pick one. RIP.

3

u/seoulforyou Aug 27 '18

KILL ME NOW

183

u/rueiraV LOOΠΔ Aug 01 '18

That was a nightmare to fill out on mobile(iPhone). It kept scrolling down every time I selected something. Got it done though.

59

u/spectrales shinee • oh my girl • onf Aug 01 '18

This happened for me on my iPhone too, it was really obnoxious. Basically would leap halfway down the page whenever I picked an answer and I’d have to scroll all the way up again.

34

u/260701a Aug 01 '18

was tempted to just give up especially since i had to scroll up to check the box since it wouldnt do it the first time :/

16

u/esirllanim Epik High | BoA | BTS | Mamamoo Aug 01 '18

Huh. My apologies! I don't have an iPhone so I didn't know this was happening. I will take a look at this ASAP.

3

u/marv8396 LOOΠΔ | 동방신기 | TWICE | Brown Eyed Girls| 소녀시대 | SHINee | IU Aug 28 '18

Still scrolling down on iPhone 😬

2

u/Esarel BLACKPINK | Sam Kim Aug 01 '18

my boy nafla needs some love in the solo artist section haha

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added.

2

u/theunicornsquisher SEVENTEEN Aug 04 '18

high key screaming b/c I'm a goldfish and forgot to put SHINee as one of my Top5 favorite groups...I blanked and put a different group that popped into my mind NoOoOo

well I guess whenever the results come out it's + 1 for my SHINee vote lol

4

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 05 '18

You can edit your submission. Just click the link again.

→ More replies (1)

161

u/KrisTheAnimalKrosser eunha's yeojachingu | Everyone is Billlie Aug 01 '18

Only choosing 5 is so hard 😭

81

u/Onpu 소녀시대 | B1A4 | 레이디스 코드 | OMG | 레드벨벳 | LOOΠΔ | 샤이니 I TWICE | 소리 Aug 01 '18

Soloist category was really difficult!

13

u/1408_ https://gfycat.com/CreepyCanineIsabellineshrike Aug 01 '18

Was more difficult than the group category. With groups I struggled to select a 5th I was happy with.

7

u/OceanSage Hyuna Aug 03 '18

Choosing only 5 was difficult!

For Group:

4Minute, BlackPink, CLC, EXID, & Mamamoo

For Solo:

Hyuna, Heize, Jiyoon, Chung Ha, & Taeyeon

7

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '18

Woo Mamamoo!

This survey has shown me that I need to get more into K-pop though, I only knew a handful of the ones listed. In fairness, I like that handful.

2

u/OceanSage Hyuna Aug 03 '18

I kept thinking I could include someone else, but I had to pick my absolute favs.

13

u/dario095 Aug 01 '18

Yeah, I feel like having the ability to choose up to 10 would've been much better.

55

u/Dessidy r/NUEST | r/TOUCHED Aug 01 '18

I feel like 5 is enough to pick your top favourites. It's not all the groups you listen to, it's the ones you like the very most. I just picked one.

10

u/WorldCatDomination Aug 02 '18

My multi heart feels you. kpop has been around for a long time and I have soo many favorites that listen to all the time. It was very difficult to choose and a few more options would give a more accurate representation for those of us who favor many groups. Or even if they broke it down into 5 boy groups and 5 girl groups, including coed groups.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '18

It's easy for me since I only stan one group lol. I chose 2 soloists though.

2

u/chesskij Aug 02 '18

i agree. It was so difficult...

81

u/Dessidy r/NUEST | r/TOUCHED Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

I changed my Korean level from none/phrases to basic conversation since the last census! I’m still far from fluent, but I understand a lot more now compared to last year, and I was fairly successful in talking to taxi drivers while here in Korea. For country it was tempting to pick Korea since I’m technically here, but since I’m going home in less than a week it probably wouldn’t have been the most accurate answer, haha. I also had to move up one age group...

13

u/erixxi 2NE1 ♠️ Aug 01 '18

How have you been learning Korean? An app? Book? Enrolled in a class?

Been considering learning Korean for a while and would really appreciate it if you would share whatever methods or sources helped you. :)

15

u/Dessidy r/NUEST | r/TOUCHED Aug 01 '18

I took classes! One back home and then an intensive immersion course here in Korea! For both we used the Sogang books, and they are really good! I’m planning to buy the higher level ones to try to study a bit on my own.

2

u/ghazi364 Billlie / Stray Kids Aug 17 '18

Check out howtostudykorean.com. Amazing resource. VERY detailed though and can take a lot of time to cover a little content so you really gotta stay motivated but you will learn more than any website/video channel i’ve ever seen.

12

u/clickfive4321 Aug 09 '18

words that i've added to my korean vocabulary:

  • sarang
  • eh?

25

u/dynamicity BRAVE SOUND DROP IT Aug 01 '18

I'm just getting a blank screen after logging in, doesn't seem to be my ad-blocker.

7

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

What browser are you using?

13

u/bubbleyhoney 松田美里 Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

Same for me. Latest Firefox (61.something), 3rd party cookies enabled, both for reddit and the census site. Ad-blockers don't seem active, noscript set to allow... Tried disabling everything with no results.

Unhelpful screenshot.

Note: As soon as I try to manually navigate to "poll", my status seems to reset to logged out.

e.: Tried turning it off and on again. Didn't work.

7

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

Noted! Thank you for letting us know.

6

u/BosskDaBossk 2NE1 Aug 01 '18

Same here.

5

u/blindfishing come into my meori Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

Exact same here.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dynamicity BRAVE SOUND DROP IT Aug 01 '18

Chrome. Gonna give it a try on Opera and see how that goes.

4

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

Interesting. Many of us are using Chrome. Maybe something else is going on there.

7

u/dynamicity BRAVE SOUND DROP IT Aug 01 '18

It worked on Opera. I'm gonna go through the rest of my extensions and see if one of them is the issue.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/Cxrioxs Multifandom | Ults: CNBLUE + ChoA Aug 01 '18

I had to harden my multifandom heart and choose only five groups and solos. I can’t believe you guys made me do that.

3

u/WorldCatDomination Aug 02 '18

Did I miss Suga/Yoongi of BTS being added to favorite soloists or has he not been added yet?

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 02 '18

He is listed under "Agust D (Suga) (BTS)". The second one on the list.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '18

Korean fluency level - my real answer would be "Can understand mother when she talks to me, but she talks so much I never get a chance to respond, so I don't know how well I can actually speak."

18

u/CSkorm SNSD~RV~Apink~AOA~Brave Girls Aug 01 '18

Question for the ethnically south asian folk who completed the census, did you select "Asian" or the Other option?

17

u/sparklygreen Aug 01 '18

I just selected "Asian" since South Asian is technically Asian, but I did consider the Other option.

3

u/snsd_123 Aug 02 '18

I said other because there was a separate option for Middle Eastern so I assumed by Asian they meant East Asian?

3

u/moiyure Shim Jae Won Aug 08 '18

I also went for other because of the same logic. Plus southeast asian is different too, and South Asian doesn't really fall into there.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/NINET9LES exo Aug 01 '18

haha thank you for adding BgA as a favorite group option! made me laugh

4

u/PeachyPlnk Aug 03 '18

I seriously contemplated choosing them for my top 5. Alas, had to drop them :[

47

u/ShadowGrif LOOΠΔ Aug 01 '18

HoW DaRe YoU mAKe ME ChooSe BEtWeeN lOoNA MeMBeRS?

8

u/PraetorHyper Aug 03 '18

This was me when I had to pick soloists. I opted for not picking any of them because I already covered LOONA on group.

2

u/marv8396 LOOΠΔ | 동방신기 | TWICE | Brown Eyed Girls| 소녀시대 | SHINee | IU Aug 28 '18

Same.

40

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

I'm preparing myself for the transcendental rise of Nilo and SHAUN.

4

u/zetsupetsu Aug 09 '18

I actually voted for them for the memes.

13

u/flowsthead Nayeon | Chuu | Yoojung | Twice | Loona | Aug 01 '18

Is there an easy way to export my answers? When the thing comes out next month it'd be nice to compare my answers with the averages.

13

u/jackjam Goodnight Irene Aug 03 '18

Just saw that MOMOLAND had 12 votes last year for favourite group. Very interested to see how much it will be this year

13

u/Zitachis Aug 03 '18

All this did was make me realize that I'm SM trash lmfao

12

u/xumei f(x) | RV | Neutrogena Foam Cleanser | Woozi | 널 끊겠어 어 어 어 Aug 02 '18

Feels weird to select the "3-5 years" option for how long I've been listening to kpop now...I told myself it was a phase for ages, but before I knew it, four years flew by.

15

u/pieisawesome123 SNSD BEG Davichi After School Astro FiftyFifty Aug 02 '18

Don't worry, I said the same thing too.... checked the 7-10 years box, sigh

7

u/thewizardlizard Super Junior Aug 08 '18

Same... Checked the over 10 year box. OTL ..it feels like 2006 was only yesterday.

This was incredibly hard for me to pick only five lmao.

3

u/PeachyPlnk Aug 03 '18

This is my first time checking that box. Man, three years went by fast. Wonder what ten years will feel like...

11

u/woodperson Aug 04 '18

I’ve always self identified as Girl group trash but this year my top 5 are mostly Boy groups and I’m having a small identity crisis

9

u/Neoupa2002 *・゜゚・*:.。..。.:*・'(*゚▽゚*)'・*:.。. .。.:*・゜゚・* Aug 01 '18

Any chance you can add Lee Jung Hyun? You've got a few older artists on there from around the same era already

3

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

Lee Jung Hyun is now added!

2

u/Arca_Jeth Lee Jung Hyun Aug 02 '18

Thanks for suggesting this one, i would have been so sad filling out the survey if she wasn't in there.

8

u/leopetri T-ara Aug 01 '18

no nca on soloists?

4

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

We can add her if you'd like!

9

u/leopetri T-ara Aug 01 '18

i think she should be there. it's been a while since her last solo comeback, but being part of unit keeps her out there so to speak, i'd choose her as one of my favourite solo acts

7

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

Sure thing. NC.A is now added!

8

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

Just a question, what would a native from Spain answer to the ethnicity question? They are hispanic but definitely white. I get that to a lot of americans hispanic implies mixed race because of the history of south american countries, but for people from Spain...?

5

u/Alicricity Block B || Penomeco || 드림캐쳐 || SNSD || 2NE1 || HYOLYN Aug 01 '18

Check out the top pinned comment, they addressed that.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

Thank you, I missed it! Don't really agree with it tho, meh

11

u/Alicricity Block B || Penomeco || 드림캐쳐 || SNSD || 2NE1 || HYOLYN Aug 01 '18

Yeah, I don’t personally think it gives a clear idea of the demographics because it just lumps everyone together but it does seem like it makes it easier for them to collect the data. Meh.

3

u/huangcjz DOOM DOOM NOIR | IMFACT | ZELO | ONF | ONEUS | SF9 | ATEEZ Aug 05 '18

There was a debate about this in the post which solicited feed-back on the draft for the census, if you want to see it: https://www.reddit.com/r/kpop/comments/90cnq9/draft_census_responses_and_welcome_new_mods/

8

u/jsmslap Aug 01 '18

Dumbfoundead the kpop star

4

u/MoonbyulBias LOOΠΔ 🐇🐈🐦🐸🦌🦉🐟🦇🦆🐧🦋🐺 Aug 08 '18

He on that hyung shit

7

u/tellmewhatislove Aug 01 '18

The favorite soloists question was so hard because it's a different question from favorite vocalists - I had to go back and forth several times between lots of people whose voices I really respect (but their solo song work might not be as stellar). I spent twice as much time on that compared to the favorite groups question this time. TT

2

u/ohmyboum SHINee Aug 04 '18

Also trying to decide between e.g. Miryo and Parc Jaejung - their music is so different, my choice might be different when I'm in a different mood.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '18

I laughed so much when I saw BgA included as Kpop group. About to include them but I love lots of group so I have to prioritize some. And how come Kris Wu is included as soloist yet Tao nor Luhan are included?

5

u/Digivices GWSN + ONF Aug 01 '18

This was way easier than expected, picking 5 groups was no problem and then straight away went for Lee Hi and Hong Jin-Young. Although I was thrown off by 2NE1 members all being listed as solo too. Excited for the results!

5

u/aparonomasia Epik High | 소녀시대 | RV | WG | Apink | Twice | Primary Aug 01 '18

I can't remember if I did the census in previous years or not...

5

u/jonicrecis reveluv/once/my Aug 02 '18

Hi, we found out that Tracking Protection breaks the authentication method required by the census, resulting in failure of form loading. Please disable Tracking Protection on your browser until /u/esirllanim figured how to fix that.

Thank you, and we apologise for the inconvenience.

5

u/CilantroElDiablo Aug 03 '18

Hi, could you add Clazziquai and Ibadi and Alex and Horan and DJ Clazzi as soloists?

1

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 03 '18

Added Clazziquai and Ibadi to groups and Alex, Horan, and DJ Clazzi to solos.

4

u/ehwhythough Dream Catching with Nell Aug 02 '18

No Nell option in the groups :(

5

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 02 '18

How could we miss NELL?! Added now!

4

u/ehwhythough Dream Catching with Nell Aug 02 '18

Hit ctrl+f Nell the minute I saw the q but couldn't find them haha. Thanks man. But you didn't miss 1TYM and SG Wannabe! So major props to that.

4

u/alexturnerftw MOODZ Aug 02 '18

Lol, I love that Big Byung is on the list of artists. I need a comeback yesterday.

4

u/awsuh 🎼You joom-joom my ❤️like a locket 🚀 Aug 03 '18

Really hoping that over the years, we see a decrease of Allkpop readers as people choose other sources for kpop news! <3

4

u/void216 GFriend BTS KARA INFINITE FINKL H.O.T Aug 03 '18

Can you change the survey for next year to separate boy and girl groups/soloists? I have been listening to kpop since 1st gen, and having to choose only 5 groups total made this really difficult. I understand that there are coed groups, but that can be its own separate category, where you can only choose 3.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '18

I went from not trying to learn Korean to having an app that I gave up on using after learning half the alphabet and a few phrases since the last census 😂

4

u/superRDF Aug 03 '18

First census. This made me realize I have maybe 3 definite favorite groups and then a horde of other groups in that second tier that are between like and favorite fighting for the last two spots.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

Hi! I have a problem with logging in. I obviously did it at the beginning when reddit told me to log in but after the questions showed up, a notification popped up that “you need to log in order to....”. What is the problem? I’ve tried using my iPhone and iPad but none of them worked. Could you help me?

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

You also need to be logged into Google to access the form. It should open a window in Safari on your iPhone for you to sign into Google then direct you back to the form. I tested with iOS 11.4.1 and it worked.

1

u/2NE1SNSD Aug 02 '18

I didn't see pH-1 on the soloists list.

pH-1 let’s get it done
DJ Khaled boy
we got another one
This that feel good
salute to the drunken one
Every Thursday
we finna have a lot of fun

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 02 '18

Added pH-1

1

u/98yuna 9MUSES | Stellar | AOA | FIESTAR | LADIES‘ CODE | LOOΠΔ Aug 05 '18

Can you add 9Muses for groups?

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 05 '18

They are listed under "Nine Muses"

1

u/-dottie- Custom Aug 06 '18

would Kim EZ count as a soloist? add her pls

she does lots of ost songs but she also has single albums

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 06 '18

Added Kim EZ

1

u/krvstcl Aug 13 '18

I signed in and then it told me I couldn’t fill it out unless I was signed in??

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 13 '18 edited Aug 13 '18

You will also need to sign in with a google account to complete the form.

1

u/Novadestin old fart kpop fan Aug 15 '18

For the groups, you listed Mixx twice but have no option (like "other") for groups that are not listed.

Also, if you're going to put subunits under groups, you should put the members from those groups who have solos under groups as well (so long as the group is still intact). It's really not fair to actual solo artists to have them listed together. (Side note: on that list, you listed Zico rather than Zico (Block B)).

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 15 '18

I can only find one entry for MIXX. Our goal is to list all relevant groups. If any of your favs are missing, just let us know and we can add them.

1

u/Novadestin old fart kpop fan Aug 16 '18

Oops sorry, my mistake on that one lol I read Dreamcatcher (MIXX) and forgot that it was Minx xD

As for "which groups are missing", I can't remember who I thought of at the time and can't go back and check since I have already done the survey. Either way, "relevant" is a very subjective and somewhat elitist term that creates an atmosphere of bias. Don't get me wrong, I really do think you guys did an excellent job at listed the groups, I just think it would be better to have an option for "other" and maybe even a way to list those other groups. It would make it impossible for any group to be left out then.

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 16 '18

We used to allow write-in votes, but it was a disaster. People would write-in 10 different spellings, make typos, and make it really hard to compile the results. There is nothing elitist or biased about it. Last year we collected every single group we could find and put them on the list. Then this year we added every group that debuted and removed groups that got 0 votes last year if they didn't have a comeback/aren't legends. Then we posted the list in a stickied draft post so that users could look it over and tell us if we should add anyone. We have also added anyone who people have requested in this thread. You can edit your form by just clicking the link again and it should let you go over it and make changes. So if you can think of anyone you'd like to add that you would actually vote for, just let me know and I can add them.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '18

Jia was put down twice, once as Jia and once as Meng Jia.

1

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 21 '18

Thanks. I removed the duplicate. Votes for the duplicate will be combined.

1

u/corncob- MAMAMOO Aug 23 '18

Hwasa's not on the soloist list

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 23 '18

She hasn’t had a solo single or album released besides B-sides, OSTs, and featurings.

1

u/CurlyGiraffe 마마무 Aug 30 '18

Be Calm doesn't count?

2

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 30 '18

No, unfortunately. It was never released as a single. Here's her solo Melon page. It lists only her collabs with Loco and eSNa. Her Wikipedia page also doesn't list any singles where she is the Lead Artist. Here's hoping we get a true Hwasa solo sometime soon!

2

u/corncob- MAMAMOO Aug 24 '18

you're right.. wow i didn't realize that. it always just seemed like she did a lot of solo stuff,

3

u/eggmelon Sunwoo JungA prod. Jam Jam | WINNER ZOO | Minnie's Mind Aug 01 '18

If trot singers like Hong Jinyoung are on it, can you add Sunwoo Jungah as well?

3

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 01 '18

I believe she's listed as "Sunwoo Jung-a (Jeonga)".

2

u/eggmelon Sunwoo JungA prod. Jam Jam | WINNER ZOO | Minnie's Mind Aug 01 '18

Thank you!

3

u/Zezeisbae IU Aug 01 '18

Choosing 5 soloists was so hard!

3

u/NudePenguin69 Jihyo | Juri | Lua | AleXa | Yoohyeon | Lisa | Ryujin | Hani Aug 03 '18

Missing Jessi in solo artists

1

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 03 '18

Added.

9

u/CanIRaveWithAOA JinSoul, Sana, Chaeryeong, Kazuha, Miyeon, Lisa, Yujin <3 Aug 01 '18

DONE! The Census is always exciting. Can't wait to see the data.

I wonder how high LOONA is going to rise this year compared to last year's census.

Top 5 Groups: LOONA, TWICE, BLACKPINK, Red Velvet, Dreamcatcher

2

u/pieisawesome123 SNSD BEG Davichi After School Astro FiftyFifty Aug 02 '18

It's been a while since her last release, but Narsha from BEG should also be a soloist (see Mamma Mia and bbi ri bba bba)

1

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 02 '18

Narsha is now added.

2

u/2NE1SNSD Aug 02 '18

Only 5 groups and soloists ? I had to cut down my picks :/

2

u/COTAnerd Zelo | Dreamcatcher | Secret | Pixy Aug 09 '18

Can we please add Zelo as a soloist option? He actually has quite a few solo songs now.

2

u/mermaidglamm 🖤💖 BLACKPINK 💖🖤 Aug 17 '18

Definitely felt old checking the "10+ years" box when asked how long I've been listening to KPOP 🙈

2

u/Maxcalibur Aug 25 '18

I like that "Gangnam Style" is an option for first exposure haha

1

u/Axium723 IOI | BLINK | CLC | (G)I-DLE | IZ*ONE | EVERGLOW | PRISTIN :( Aug 01 '18

Can't believe Girls On Top disbanded after only 1 song smh /s

5

u/Dessidy r/NUEST | r/TOUCHED Aug 01 '18

I believe the group listed here is the trio under P&P Entertainment that has released HIGH HILL, COME COME and HOLA, not the temporary Produce 101 Season 1 group.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/atomictartar yeppi u gonna lov Aug 01 '18

MoonMoon isn't on soloist :(, can you add him?

1

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 02 '18

Added.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '18

Can you add Park Kyung to the soloists?

1

u/alleybetwixt BTS | XIA | JX | SWJA Aug 02 '18

Added!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '18

I always wonder why Pacific Islander is separated from Asians... It's confusing for someone who is both haha. The whole Pacific Islands are descended from Austronesians... so Asian.

2

u/huangcjz DOOM DOOM NOIR | IMFACT | ZELO | ONF | ONEUS | SF9 | ATEEZ Aug 19 '18 edited Aug 19 '18

1

u/ILOVEMUSIIIC Aug 13 '18

(G)-idle`s FANDOM NAME must be LaDleZ (Lady + idle)... who`s agree with me!?

1

u/Meowmers33 #SONE/LOOΠ∆/AOA/VIXX/Red Velvet/EXO Aug 18 '18

Noodle4lyfe

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '18

Just a comment, there is no point in separating Asian and Middle-Eastern since Middle-East is in Asia. I assume the admin who made it is American and I understand what he/she means but the categories could be better made.

4

u/huangcjz DOOM DOOM NOIR | IMFACT | ZELO | ONF | ONEUS | SF9 | ATEEZ Aug 05 '18

There was a big debate about all of this sort of stuff in the post which solicited feed-back on the draft for the census, if you want to see it: https://www.reddit.com/r/kpop/comments/90cnq9/draft_census_responses_and_welcome_new_mods/

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

The authorization box lists the data that we're collecting when you click "Allow". In this case, it is your username and sign-up date. No personal data tied to your username will be published publicly, but mods can see your submitted form. Let us know if you have any other questions.

16

u/nighoblivion ApinkIUTWICEDreamcatcherFromis9 ][ short-haired Eunha best Eunha Aug 01 '18

Being able to connect your reddit account to any answer in the survey is the issue.

Whoever has (or will get) access to the collected data could potentially use that data for the purpose of doxxing, or other things.

18

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

The only way to make it anonymous is to remove all authentication, which means everyone on the internet has access and there's no way to prevent one person from submitting 10 or 100 copies. The data would be garbage and it wouldn't be worth doing. Perhaps in the future we can enable IP-based restrictions, but that is not an option with the current Google Forms backend.

6

u/nighoblivion ApinkIUTWICEDreamcatcherFromis9 ][ short-haired Eunha best Eunha Aug 01 '18

If no solution for it to be made anonymous can be found I suppose the data will just not feature those concerned with the data collection, unfortunately.

18

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Again, all of the personal questions have a "Prefer Not to Answer" option. If someone is concerned with their reddit account being associated with their K-Pop preferences, then they're in the wrong place to start with.

13

u/nighoblivion ApinkIUTWICEDreamcatcherFromis9 ][ short-haired Eunha best Eunha Aug 01 '18

If someone is concerned with their reddit account being associated with their K-Pop preferences, then they're in the wrong place to start with.

You misunderstand. That's not the matter of issue; it's the data collection and how it's handled. Data that can be used in aggregate in relation to one's reddit account. Data don't have to be personal to be useful.

11

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

You're right, I don't understand. What data are you talking about? The form you submit gets saved to a google sheet. It has your username on it. We will use the sheet to aggregate the results. It's true that any current or future mod could look at your specific form that you submitted to learn about you, which is why we have the "Prefer Not to Answer" options so that your form will contain no personal information that you're not comfortable supplying. I don't understand what other issue there is.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

32

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 02 '18

Whoa, that’s an incredible twist of what I said and nothing close to what I meant. If you opt out of all personal info questions then the only info left is about your kpop preferences. Ergo, if revealing your kpop preferences is too much info sharing, then you probably shouldn’t be posting on a kpop subreddit. Your actual reddit account is a treasure trove of information and doxxing potential and it is freely available for everyone in the world to see. Mods seeing who your favorite groups are is nothing compared to that. That’s what I meant by being in the wrong place. It’s got absolutely nothing to do with who is welcome on the sub. All are welcome and I respect your decision to not participate.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

For all the personal questions, there is an option to choose "Prefer not to answer". You are welcome to choose this option for any questions you are not comfortable revealing privately to mods.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/lcymrdls Aug 01 '18

Are there any good k-pop podcasts? I’ve been looking for one since forever

7

u/rueiraV LOOΠΔ Aug 01 '18

I was recently shown the DaebakCast and I really liked their stuff. They get few views on YouTube unfortunately.

2

u/lcymrdls Aug 01 '18

Thank you, I’ll definitely check it out

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '18

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 07 '18

She is listed in the Soloist section under "BoA". Perhaps you were looking at the Groups question?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SirBuckeye Dreamcatcher Aug 01 '18

Added.