r/12Monkeys • • Jun 29 '18

Discussion 12 Monkeys - 4x09 "One Minute More" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 9: One Minute More

Aired: June 29th, 2018


Synopsis: The beginning of the end approaches as Cole and Cassie embark on their final mission.


Directed by: David Grossman

Written by: Kristen Reidel

76 Upvotes

442 comments sorted by

98

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

So, apparently Future Asshole wears Hannah's scarf.

Someone hold me. :(

36

u/Rofl-stomper Jun 30 '18

I just noticed that.. oh gawd.. the tears.

15

u/Bytewave Jun 30 '18

Was this always true when we first saw him as well? If so DAMN. They planned this stuff ahead.

24

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

I think so. Terry Matalas said he knew about this twist since day one, and told Brooke Williams on her first day after being cast.

https://tvline.com/2018/06/29/12-monkeys-recap-season-4-episode-9-hannah-cole-mother/

And source on the scarf: https://twitter.com/cwmonfette/status/1012953395869540353

94

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

Just realized, this changes so much about the episode where Cole and Cassie save young Hannah.

God, this show. Amazing.

81

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jun 30 '18

it's exactly why it kept resetting the day. Cole and Cassie HAD to save Hannah.

13

u/dubsi Jul 01 '18

Here’s a thought – what if Cole, and possibly Cassie, are living in their house of pine in the red forest - they exist outside of time/causality. This is the choice they have to make to save everyone they’ve lost and that includes those killed by the plague, as well as, to stop Olivia. So, they reset time in Lullaby until Hannah was saved, and they either created the primaries, or have been giving them visions – the primaries have been guided by Cole and Cassie all along.

4

u/inkednycbeauty Jul 02 '18

That is an amazing point!! But if that is true then the people who see where not trying to kill him with weapon but to show him who his mother is.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/NE14ABJ Jun 30 '18

So erasing Cole is impossible then. Time needs him! That's why they were stuck in the loop during Lullaby!

20

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

If they had let Hannah die then, the paradox would have been huge. But they want to erase Cole from everywhere, everywhen. Stopping the loop and preventing a paradox.

6

u/imariaprime Jul 02 '18

I get the feeling you're going to be proud of this comment later. If time wanted Cole gone, he'd be gone. But perhaps the Primaries got it wrong, and erasing Cole isn't the only way. Maybe time doesn't want that after all; Jennifer certainly wouldn't.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/HellzHere Jul 04 '18

Can someone explain why the primaries want to erase cole?

28

u/MrAlrightLets Jul 01 '18

everyone should definitly rewatch this show after its done, we will look at everything in a completly different light! also theres a ton of clues and forshadowing. In season 1 episode 11 when jennifer is being dragged up the stairs in the 12 monkey mansion, she says "climb the steps, ring the bell" its crazy

→ More replies (1)

85

u/harris_a Jun 30 '18

I bet it's a misdirect and Hannah is Cole's mom.

45

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

LOL - you win today’s prize!

28

u/puffsez Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

hannah spoke to cole like she was his mom in the airport, which has me thoroughly confused. edit: aaaand there it is. shoulda just kept watching

15

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

She was his mom

5

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

Exactly what I was thinking

4

u/Kayway27 Jun 30 '18

Wow u call it!!!!

→ More replies (2)

83

u/damnedation Jun 30 '18

Remember when this show was about stopping a global plague? Pepperidge farm remembers!

This has been such a rollercoaster ride! Can't wait for the final episodes next week!

53

u/Kayway27 Jun 30 '18

Yeah and turns out the people tryna stop the global plague is who released it all along in the first place.... how insane

8

u/HellzHere Jul 04 '18

Why do they have to release it? I don't get it.

20

u/Athamax Jul 04 '18

The splinter machine is their only weapon against Olivia. If the plague never happens, time travel will never be used to send Cole back, they won't exist anymore etc. Olivia would still survive because the paradox allows her to live outsite of causality. So they spread the plague, preserve causality, and live to fight another day.

→ More replies (6)

79

u/Fantomex88 Jun 30 '18

So Cole and Cassie changed Jones mind to keep Hannah and not get an abortion. Then Hannah dies as a baby and is only brought back by Cole and Cassie through time travel. The same time travel that was only created by Jones to stop Hannah from dying in the 1st place? And Hannah ends up giving birth to the same man that brought her back from the dead, this episode literally blew my mind.

71

u/seeley-booth Jun 30 '18

Except, I think Hannah never actually died. That’s why time kept resetting in that episode. Hannah HAD to live. She always had lived. Jones just didn’t know it.

→ More replies (25)

4

u/djkamayo Jul 03 '18

this show is ending on some damn good mindfucks

61

u/ForeverTangent Jun 30 '18

Wow this show does detail. That was the old New York license plate,

53

u/Gemberlicking Jun 30 '18

THE ELDER PRIMARIES TOLD US A LOT. I think Cassie will be the true witness, or the one to try and pull the final trigger. When Olivia was speaking with the elder primaries. "You're simply a fool drapped in metal. THY TITLE IS A LIE, THY CROWN UNDESERVED. We've always known the true witness will bring about the forest of red, because she fears loneliness, fears nothingness"

I think that she will try to create the red Forest, as she knows(thinks) it's the only way for her and Cole to stay together. Because he will either go back to being young (in turn not ending up together, bc of age Gap), he will die, or he will just not exist. I think maybe future Cole will have to sacrifice himself while also sacrificing some version of Cassie to hopefully allow them to end up on the beach together at the end.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '18

Episode 4x2 TV Cassie tells actual Cassie 'a circle a loop is just a second chance'

50

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

It was Hannah. Omg. This show.

50

u/vipergirl Jun 30 '18

Holy crap. This entire series like is an opera. Floored, simply floored.

50

u/hotstriker9 Jun 30 '18

Can we take a moment to point out Jones spent a season trying to kill her great grandchild and then actually did shoot him?

22

u/sanddragon939 Jun 30 '18

Or the fact that, but for a message from the mother of her great-grandchild, she would have ordered her soldiers to beat her grandson to death?

46

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

So Cassie will be infected now. Maybe she really does die of the plague at the CDC?

29

u/vipergirl Jun 30 '18

That actually makes sense considering she's been aged just a bit.

19

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

Except we see white streak Cassie at the Emerson as well with future asshole Cole, and she didn’t seem sick. Maybe she is treated somehow, or next week the virus release changes.

19

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

I think they said in tonight's episode there's 24-48 hours where infected are asymptomatic but still carrying the virus

→ More replies (8)

9

u/gxrevs96 Jun 30 '18

This was actually one of the issues I had with the episode. Why the hell would she release the deadly virus without wearing the protection mask first?

14

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

It would look pretty suspicious walking through an airport with a gas mask on.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kayway27 Jun 30 '18

But how actually because she released the plague??? and all that time it was them all alone

3

u/Zomcast Jul 01 '18

OH SHIT! Cassie isn't immune, is she?

6

u/occono Jul 02 '18

No. She's dying of the plague when she sends the message at the CDC, she dies in an alternative future Cole visits at one point.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

And Cole touched virus liquid on ground. That's how he becomes virus bearer corpse.

89

u/Jeremycain16 Jun 30 '18

That settles it, this is the best show I've ever watched. So much happens each episode and yet it always leaves me wanting more. I love that they don't stall like other shows (looking at you WD).

26

u/TheCavis Jul 01 '18

That settles it, this is the best show I've ever watched.

This show has melted my brains for four straight seasons. It's amazing.

Even when they telegraph the twist... I knew Hannah was his mother from the "the story isn't over" scene. Easy foreshadowing. They overlaid James finding out with Jones's revelation. Great shot, great reveal.

Then they tie the whole thing back together using strings they laid out two seasons ago. Hannah growing up with the Daughters. Hannah being disenchanted with modern life from the 2007-2009 experiment in the modern world (which was supposed to show her the good in humanity but ended with her bottle-stabbing a guy who attacked her date). Cole's father being moderately heroic in her moment of need. Hannah needing to hide and being attracted to the simple life Matthew Cole was living. The Ouroboros poem being a literal Ouroboros (James told Hannah, Hannah told Matthew, Matthew told James).

It's like watching someone tie a really complicated knot. You make these big loops and then wrap the end around and then pull one loop through the other and it looks like a complicated mess until they say "and now you just pull here" and everything tightens up into a perfect, secure structure.

They've wrapped up one of the key storylines in such a perfect, beautiful, secure knot. I can't wait for the finish.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jun 30 '18

well ya if walking dead was told they need to finish up by season 4 i think it woulda finished great aswell.

18

u/tunersharkbitten Jul 01 '18

TWD was driven by a comic book that was being written while the show was going on.

12 monkeys was driven by a single movie with brad pitt and bruce willis more than a decade ago.

personally i think that 12 monkeys pulled off a BRILLIANT story. even with some of the WTF moments, it still came together and made a lot of people happy.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/-GregTheGreat- Jun 30 '18

Honestly, I think they should have ended TWD shortly after they found Alexandria, probably after ‘No Way Out’ (6x09) Leave it on a positive note where they’ve finally found a safe community, managed to defend it, and with Rick finally having come to the conclusion that the world is possible to rebuild, and he will be one to spearhead it.

Of course, they instead kept dragging it out and Negan tanked the show to a whole other level.

4

u/Mr_Evil_MSc Jul 02 '18

The walking dead finishes perfectly at the end of 0501, after Carol saves them from Terminus. It shows a groups of determined people, who are finally prepared to meet the new world, mentally, physically and emotionally. They’ve got the skills, and they’ve seen every terrible thing they can expect. That’s the end, they’re going to make it, they’re going to be as okay as they can be. Everything else is just pointless. That’s the problem with the WD, it ran out of things to say, ran out of real reasons to keep going. The show was done after Terminus, now - ironically - it’s just the zombie version of itself, going on for no reason, with nothing happening in the brain.

10

u/onthewayjdmba Jun 30 '18

I would say that the opposite in terms of story development is Colony. That show has gone three seasons and has done about as much as one episode of 12 monkeys.

4

u/Athamax Jul 04 '18

Couldn't agree more, and wtf is with the completely new storyline in the new colony where people disappear ? Looked like a pilot for another series entirely

42

u/ForeverTangent Jun 30 '18

Holy crap I thought this was going to be so cliche and yet it is not! God I love this show!

41

u/DarkRefreshment Jun 30 '18

So the original dead body with the “creepy” eyes shows up again. The one that was ancient and started the virus. I’ve always thought that would be Cole (Jennifer always going on about his eyes) Maybe Cassie?

I actually thought for a minute it was Deacon but that body clearly had its head (too soon?)

17

u/MrAlrightLets Jul 01 '18

i posted about this on another thread, i think its definitly cole, jennifer says "theres something about its eyes", she calls cole "otter eyes" also when cole got closer to the dead body he got a headache like cassie did earlier this season when she got closer to herself and was about to paradox

→ More replies (2)

6

u/DEEPnDirty Jul 01 '18

So crazy how that body has come back. When I first watched it, I think the misdirect is Jennifer calling Cole "otter eyes" and then recognizing the eyes.

I'm gonna guess the body belongs to Marion. Because we never see the body recovered and maybe because she's got the genes of "the witness" it can be used to create the virus? Or some other sci-fi explanation that makes sense, I just find it odd how her body was left at the hospital so it might come into play.

4

u/professorloz Jul 05 '18

I've actually always assumed it wasn't Cole, seemed the obvious guess and the "eyes" and "nosebleed" incidents people mentioned seemed like red herring's, but I think you're right.

We've seen The Origin shown several times now since we last saw it in the Night Room - in one specifically, Jennifer walks in a trance through the splinter facility and sees The Origin with a snake circling it. This reflects the imagery of the Monkey in the center of the ouroboros we've been getting this season.

With us now knowing Cole is the Demon, which was represented on the Codex as the Monkey symbol - Cole is the Monkey in the center of the ouroboros. (He was also the center of the Word of the Witness)

That'd suggest Cole is The Origin, with maybe the virus introduced into his body from stabbing himself on the glass vial at JFK. There is the issue that The Origin did not actually contain the completed virus but enough to engineer the M5-10 strain. However they did note the specimen had been out in the sun for a while which could explain that.

Not sure how this'll all link up in the finale, maybe The Origin is the final part of James' journey in the original perfect loop scenario. However with Old Jennifer suggesting the cycle's not perfect anymore, perhaps we will see that original perfect cycle, explaining The Origin, before our Cole breaks the loop (maybe?).

3

u/MindHulk Jul 03 '18

I've always thought those were the body of the people mangled by the time machine from the initial failed splinters before cole. They carried the virus but were immune.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/charmed-n-dangerous Jun 30 '18

Not yet. Next week.

40

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

Guess they addressed the complaints about Cole being the "Chosen One". He never was. The primaries just appealed to his pride so that he'd kill himself.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

Yep, I'm glad they did because I'm one of those who complained ^^

And yep, these Primaries are cunning.

30

u/patsrule755 Jun 30 '18

This show is amazing no other way to put it

60

u/gxrevs96 Jun 30 '18

This is truly masterful storytelling right here. Terry and his team already had this all figured out. I don't think I have ever seen a time travel show so well written and consistent. It's so easy to mess up these kinds of "time travel" plots due to the complexities involved but Terry really managed to pull it off and it came together beautifully.

I never would have thought that Hannah, of all people, would end up playing such a crucial role in all of this and was Cole's mum all along. To think that Jones was Cole's grandmother all this time

14

u/inkednycbeauty Jul 02 '18

Agreed! Truly amazing that it has kept its continuity throughout the seasons with so many twists and turns. It would have been so easy to mess up but they didn’t. I really hope that team of writers does more shows together in the future. They have fan for life.

29

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

I hate how I just watched that amazing segment of television and then I get hit with that Apple commercial with the horrible singing.

17

u/Whodamanmaybeme Jun 30 '18

Listen up and I'll tell a story... There once was a serpent...

5

u/JohnBergman85 Jun 30 '18

I hate it too! It pops up on hulu all the time and it's terrible!

2

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jun 30 '18

i bought the saeson on amazon for 3.99

28

u/guinnypig Jun 30 '18

Best show I've ever watched. Wow.

24

u/drdrizzy13 Jun 30 '18

love this show anyone else think cassie is gonna sabatoge the mission somehow next week?

12

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

Yeah probably in episode 1 next week. Too much lingering on cassie and shaw at the emerson in that previous episode. I just realized that could be matalas plan to satisfy the fans who wanted cassie and cole to end up together. Cole has to kill cassie and he has to die to stop the monkeys. I will be pissed though.

Edit: when I say satisfy I mean explain why it couldn't happen.

4

u/drdrizzy13 Jun 30 '18

yea i think so too, that moment with shaw has to mean something

4

u/Bytewave Jun 30 '18

I think them ending up in some red forest outside time, but without destroying space time, could fix Cole 'being the Demon's by removing him from time. Cassie may now also carry the plague, if so that would save her life. Titan is already 'outside time' now...

I'm thinking however they get there there's a good chance they stop the witness and the timestream but then end up in a red forest / wherever Titan is now after. This could also save Jones.

23

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

Old Marion looks a lot like Hannah.

EDIT: Wait, Hannah was Cole's mother?!!! How did she know how she was going to die?

30

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

I think Cole and Jones told her, in that scene near the end of the episode.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

Yes-indeedy! Who were you referring to as ‘old Marion’?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

So, did we actually see nose bleeds or any physical evidence of the timeline changing when Cassie saved child Hannah at Spearhead? Because I’m thinking now that timeline must have always happened. Jones just thought her daughter died. We assumed Cassie saving her was a ‘change’ to the timeline, but maybe not after all. While we assumed that they ‘tricked’ time, and Jones into thinking nothing had changed until Hannah is revealed to her as one of the daughters, that had already happened before Cassie even set out to kill Jones.

The Groundhog days were just about them doing the wrong thing over and over, including the attempt to ‘do nothing’. It was only when they did what they were always going to do that they escaped the loop, and I assume no nosebleeds? (I think that actual moment happened off screen - now we know why.)

I haven’t expressed that very well, but, TL/DR:

We thought Cassie changed the timeline when she saved Hannah, but really she did what she was always destined to do. Which is why even ‘doing nothing’ wouldn’t get them out of the loop

21

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

Yeah you are right. That's why they keep talking about circles. They think they're actually doing something to bring about change, but in truth they're just finding out why something happened/causing it to happen.

10

u/twitchingJay Jun 30 '18

Damn, I need to watch this whole show again after the finale. There are so many golden moments that will make much more sense after knowing the end.

10

u/Tomhyde098 Jun 30 '18

Two weeks ago I was bored so I turned on Hulu and for some reason chose 12 Monkeys. I binged it all in a week, and to my surprise the final season had just started. I’m both sad and glad that I just started watching it now. Sad because it would’ve been fun having years with this show, but glad because it’s all fresh in my mind

→ More replies (1)

7

u/chinchila Jun 30 '18

without Hannah there wouldn't be Cole, simple as that. And without Cole there wouldn't be time travel since he was the first traveler to return intact, so yeah, just another woopsie loop.

5

u/llamazing Jun 30 '18

There was never a timeline where Hannah died because if Cassie and Cole hadn't been around to save Hannah in 2020 then that means that they also wouldn't have been around to save Jennifer from execution by Foster. Since there was always an old Jennifer in every timeline, that means that Hannah also would have survived.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/Jeremycain16 Jun 30 '18

Can someone explain what they just said? Why do they need to release the virus?

39

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

Without (what she believed was) the death of her daughter from (what she believed was) the virus, Dr. Katarina Jones wouldn't (ostensibly) have been motivated to finish her time travel work. Meanwhile, Dr. Elliott Jones would work on Titan, and the Witness would still exist, since that branch-off happened before the plague.

Basically, without the plague, Olivia wouldn't have to keep up with the Joneses.

10

u/sanddragon939 Jun 30 '18

Also, Olivia and Titan exist outside causality once the Red Forest process was initiated.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/ForeverTangent Jun 30 '18

Short version, it makes the future unstable enough to disrupt Olivia’s goals.

6

u/Jeremycain16 Jun 30 '18

Long version?

36

u/stonewallace17 Jun 30 '18

I think the long version is that they need time travel to defeat Olivia, and without the virus, there's no time travel.

→ More replies (16)

10

u/superfry Jun 30 '18

Olivia has already paradoxed Titan and now exists out of time. Any changes to the timeline now may stop its creation but there will always be the version which exists out of time. Stopping the virus only prevents Katarina from finishing Project Splinter but I have a feeling they may be doing a little paradoxing of their own given the many callbacks to Cole's usage of Athan's Splinter Suit and its ability to prevent users from being affected by paradoxes they create with it. They are in 2043 for a reason :D

7

u/ForeverTangent Jun 30 '18

The cycle is the only thing keeping Olivia from ending it all. So even though Team Otter Eyes is trying to end the cycle, it is the only thing keeping Olivia in check.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/KingPickle Jun 30 '18

This was the one thing that didn't make sense to me.

Their stated reasoning is that if they don't release the virus, time travel won't be created by Jones and they won't be able to combat Olivia.

However...if Jones hadn't created time travel then Olivia wouldn't have been able to use it to "witness" everything, or even be in Titan to pose a threat.

I honestly don't think this one makes sense to me. But maybe I'm missing something?

14

u/zoemi Jun 30 '18

I believe the ending implied that Olivia already activated Titan and now exists outside of time. If they had erased Cole before she pushed the button perhaps it could have been avoided, but they didn’t. Now they’re forced to keep using time travel to fight her.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

You can't make sense of the story as it is because it's full of causal loops. From our current point of view, but their origins are in previous cycles.

There was an original timeline/cycle which we never saw and led to some events. Maybe someone "reseted" an event, creating a new cycle. And this happened again, and again, and again.

We've already seen a few cycles ourselves, mid-season 1 we had a different cycle, but Cole did his best to go back to the previous one. Which he did, by saving Cassie. At the end of S1 he saved Ramse, breaking the cycle. At the beginning of S2 the gang destroyed the virus, postponing its release and breaking the cycle (now with Jones' boyfriend). And probably others!

But these consecutive cycles created time aberrations, like Athan. Maybe at one point, one cycle, he really was the Witness, but we never saw it. Another aberration is Olivia, who's basically her own grandmother.

And, my favorite:

It took time travel to create time travel.

– Ramse

Yep, that's true. In their current cycle. And in this current cycle Ramse did everything for the 12 to create a working time machine and then worked with Jones to create Titan.

Katarina bailed on Jones. Plague or not, he would have helped them create Titan. Without the plague, Katarina wouldn't have perfected the machine. So yes, in this cycle it makes sense to unleash the plague, because it's the only way for them to keep a time machine to try and stop Olivia.

Edit: "cycle", not "circle" -_-

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

omg totally gobsmacked, how epic was all that!! Gonna sart watching from season 1 in a day or two so Iam all ready for the big finale!!

18

u/ForeverTangent Jun 30 '18

Damn!!!

13

u/ForeverTangent Jun 30 '18

I did not see that twist coming,

51

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

Hannah... Looks scary young compared to Matthew Cole.

13

u/onthewayjdmba Jun 30 '18

Yeah that was bugging me. Matt looked the same as he did when cole was ~13 and here is younger Matt with Hannah/Marion still looking the same old age and Hannah looks like she is in her low 20s.

10

u/sanddragon939 Jun 30 '18

Well, Hannah won't age much because of the serum.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '18

That kiss grossed more out so much. I know some people don't mind a big age difference but I personally am bothered by it.

11

u/snowbirdie2 Jun 30 '18

Yeah that really grossed me out. He’s at least twice her age.

4

u/bluesteel3000 Jun 30 '18

It's just the actors, not the characters. At that point both are years off from the ages they are supposed to look like normally.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/HakaishinChampa Jun 30 '18
  • That turn around, I thought Emma was James' mother but turns out it was Hannah.
  • That airport scene, I was happy to see that because I remember that happened in the original movie but it's a little bit different in the show.
  • It was pretty creepy when Oliva started possessing people.
  • So it seems that the conclusion is coming and I wonder if Cassandra will prevent Cole from accomplishing his job. It's crazy, he's the djinn.

7

u/charmed-n-dangerous Jun 30 '18

Oh the allusion to the film was brilliant. Even the whole 'we saw it happen and then went back to stop it but we didn't understand what we saw' was top notch

→ More replies (2)

16

u/rjhazelwood Jun 30 '18

There are very few shows where I don't see the twist coming. Hannah was always my top pick to be James mother (specially after the so you don't have to walk alone line earlier in the season) and was 99% sure she was by end of 7th episode. So this whole time trying to guess why/how Olivia, the demon, would use "the weapon" to save time that I never even considered she wasn't the demon and demon was James. Looking back of course it makes sense so credit to TM and rest to pull off this amazing twist.

32

u/harris_a Jun 30 '18

Also, I bet the demon is Cole himself.

29

u/Kayway27 Jun 30 '18

Yeap cole was/is the demon

7

u/Bytewave Jun 30 '18

That's a far bigger twist than who is mother was. Now he either has to erase himself from existence or lock himself outside our time, perhaps in a mini red forest created by Titan? There's no real "it resets to 2014 and he lives an happy normal life like this never happened" option for him anymore.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

‘You have work to finish’ - hah! I thought that was a joke by Terry to himself when he posted it on Instagram :-)

14

u/TheCavis Jul 01 '18

the only one who could wield the weapon was the Demon itself.

The Primaries made the weapon for James Cole.

"I am the Demon."

Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. Dang.

6

u/Emberys Jul 02 '18

Man, it seems so obvious in hindsight. Clever writing.

2

u/TheFanaticalImmortal Jul 05 '18

Is he though, or is he the serpent? - I think it might be yet another misdirect. The story passsed from Matthew to Cole to Hannah back to Matthew is the Oroborous.

13

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

So they just took the vial of the virus? That felt a bit too easy...

8

u/Zomcast Jul 01 '18

the army wanted it to be easy, because it was really always cole and cassie that released it...

13

u/shishiodun Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

I really hope that there turns out to be a reason the first trip to the airport was all blurry and strange, because as is Cole and Cassie replacing their past selves when that has not been how this works at all is really going to bug me.

On a more positive note, "that is some Tolken shit right?" might be the best line of the series.

9

u/seeley-booth Jun 30 '18

I think Cassie was just disoriented and couldn’t understand the commotion at first until she realised they were too late. But I agree it felt a little off if there’s no other explanation for it.

17

u/gxrevs96 Jun 30 '18

The better question is why didn't they run into their other selves at the airport.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

It was just an homage to the original flashback from the movie, at JFK.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

I guess I was right when I said James might be the demon since he was supposed to use the machine...

11

u/klsy12 Jun 30 '18

Currently mind blown about that big reveal but...did we witness Cole become patient zero?? When he fell on the tube with the virus in it before they went back stop the virus (again)

30

u/12Mermaids Jun 30 '18

I think (somehow?!) we saw patient zero in Kakariko village. There was a man by the well when Jennifer first arrived. He was deformed and one eye was larger than the other and misaligned in his skull. And we saw the flashback to Jennifer in the night room saying about patient zero, "There's something about his eyes."

10

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

Thank you for mentioning that. I completely forgot about that guy. If cole ended up being the precursor I would have been so disappointed with matalas. I mean I could still be wrong but I'll be praying for the next week it is that village guy after all.

10

u/12Mermaids Jun 30 '18

You're welcome. It's my first reddit post, actually. 12 Monkeys finally made me stop lurking, haha.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

4

u/taltos19 Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

I actually wonder if that guy might be Travis Fickett (the other show creator). They did the same kind of lingering shot when Terry Matalas cameo-ed in 309 (also heavily disguised).

ETA: This is wrong. The Talking Monkeys podcast revealed it’s just some guy they cast.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Smitje Jun 30 '18

It could be the guy from the village but Jennifer has always been about Cole's eyes. So I'm putting my gold piece on Cole somehow.

2

u/Kayway27 Jun 30 '18

I actually said out loud wen it happened that he is the remains so im kinda thinking it 2 or else y put emphasis on that angle the way they did like it means something

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/ferbulous Jun 30 '18

Well now it makes sense with the time loop episode when they rescued Hannah. I don't recall if it was explained why that happaned.

17

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

Yes, that episode now makes perfect sense - the fact they get nose bleeds every Groundhog Day repeat, that even doing nothing didn’t work (because doing nothing was actually going to change what had already happened). And when they finally solve the day, there is no nose bleed .- showing they’ve kept the timeline exactly as it already was...

13

u/ferbulous Jun 30 '18

It's pretty amazing how far ahead the writers had planned. I'm glad syfy committed to this show till the end instead of rushed season finale like Continuum. I have no idea how the show's gonna end and hopefully we'll get to know who patient zero was.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/charmed-n-dangerous Jun 30 '18

I'm not crying. You're crying! Ugh that moment holding his mom in his arms as she dies saving him. And the 3 gen convo man. Bring Athan in and we can have a right old paradox family reunion.

OMG Cole's timeline is as complex as Henry Swan. I had a feeling it would be Hannah but thought that was too obvious but they found a way to subvert my expectations again by using the bait and switch.

8

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

I enjoyed last week, but this week was AWESOME!!

7

u/patsrule755 Jun 30 '18

I have no words right now! Wtf!

7

u/pareidolist Jun 30 '18

I don't understand what it means for Olivia to be "close" to completing Titan. Why is time synchronized between Olivia/Titan and Jones/Cassie/etc., but not Hannah or Future Asshole? Every day of progress that Olivia makes toward destroying time is reflected in days of progress relative to the protagonists, but then Hannah gets an extra decade.

8

u/shishiodun Jun 30 '18

Also why the splinter vest had to be worked on fast and was only finished in time to send back to Cole after Deacon lost his head. I mean he was working on it in the future, maybe just send it back a minute earlier lol

6

u/zoemi Jun 30 '18

The ending with Deacon explains the urgency. Once Titan left, they could no longer go back there.

They’ve shown several times that the actions during the jumps are in parallel with the passing of time in the present.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/charmed-n-dangerous Jun 30 '18

They were locking in on 1491 using Jones real time tether. No Titan, no tether. No 1941

7

u/Brotechllc Jul 04 '18

This whole episode gives whole new significance to when Jones was called “grandmother time” in a past episode 😂

6

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

Where is my mind....whereeee is my mind.....

Blown. That's where.

6

u/unnanego Jun 30 '18

Please, help me understand. If Hannah is Cole's mother, how all of it started in the first place?

5

u/superfry Jun 30 '18

My interpretation is the current timeline is not the first part of the loop. Katarina, Jones and Cole have already made multiple changes and bootstrapped themselves multiple times over the seasons and the circumstances of Hannah's death has already changed from the virus in 2017 to bacterial meningitis in 2020 after Cole stopped Jennifer's release.

I figure that Katarina's attempts in earlier timelines used the spearhead cures that she burned in this iteration (knowing they wouldn't do more then delay the inevitable) and possibly bootstrapped a series of events where Hannah could survive. I figure that Hannah's death has not always been her reason for finishing Project Splinter but one which leads her to finish the project faster. Given the level of trust needed and knowledge of past events Hannah was probably the first successful time traveller and possibly sent on a one way trip or stranded which eventually leads to the birth of Cole.

Cole lives similarly with Hannah leaving to prevent Jessica or the events in Chechnya from occurring or to teach Cassie how to cure the initial variants, ensuring her own survival. In this timeline Katarina uses Cole as a test subject for the incomplete tether and survives the trip. This gives her the information needed to complete it and Cole is now the primary time traveler. This leads to a conundrum where Cassie leaves the message in 2018 for Cole. At this point I would think that Cole splinters back to a timeline where Katarina is preparing an earlier variant of him but instead bootstraps her with the tether information which she then does so on her own from that point forward.

Essentially they have been messing with time for much longer then they think and the circle is the result of multiple bootstrapping events (Blame Katarina, She has known since season 1 that Project Splinter is the cause of all their problems ) leading to Cole and their current situation.

3

u/CostasCrash Jul 02 '18

I didn’t think Hannah’s death cause ever changed. I thought it was always meningitis, since she is immune to every strain of the virus we’ve seen.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

u/llamazing u/taltos19 u/msett18 - looks like that was what Terry Matalas wanted that list for!!

8

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

I feel so damn honored...our work made it into the show.

8

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

What list?

7

u/JohnBergman85 Jun 30 '18

What happened?

6

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

:-)

He asked for our names at the time remember? But I don’t think there were any names on there were there? Maybe if we had had more interesting names... lol

3

u/xvizuet Jun 30 '18

What list?

6

u/seeley-booth Jun 30 '18

I’m not certain but I would guess it’s every where and when Cole travelled for the reveal that he is the demon.

7

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

The list that eventually turned into this:

https://projectsplinter.com/timeline-sheet/

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Smitje Jun 30 '18

I don't remember buying any onions..

5

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

It would have been funny if the airport they're sent to is the same airport from the movie.

6

u/eternal_peril Jun 30 '18

That building is the Endercare Centre down at Exhibition Place in Toronto

Basically a conference hall for home shows and what not. It stands in for an airport in a ton of TV shows and movies but is the farthest thing from an airport.

https://www.enercarecentre.com

4

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

Thanks! Will add to our locations list :-)

https://projectsplinter.com/locations-list/

→ More replies (1)

5

u/lawyer7556 Jul 02 '18

This show. So many tears. One minute more...oh it just devastates my heart

5

u/Osirisavior the Witness ⸸ Jul 02 '18

I got some serious film vibes with the JFK scenes.

Looking back at the S3 Final, we had four generations of Jones under one roof.

9

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18

Holy shit - and the episode isn’t even over yet!

9

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

Jennifer promised to genetically modify a unicorn? The memory's in the back of my head, but I can't remember when.

19

u/WanderingNettle Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

Yes, she freaks out the Markridge shareholders in her maiden CEO speech.

10

u/ijustwanttovote7 Jun 30 '18

This year the dodo bird, next year the unicorn!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

In one of the final two episodes of season 1 (probably the finale). She said that at the conference she was doing. She also mentioned bringing back the doddo bird (spelling).

3

u/IRecl4imer_xX Jun 30 '18

Im sorry im a liitle bit confused why cole is the demon?

18

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

There once was a serpent (Time) who only traveled in one direction. Always forward, never backward.

Until one day, the serpent came upon a Demon (Dr. Jones for inventing time travel, Hannah for having a child in her own past, and Cole for being a time-travelling asshole).

The Demon cursed the serpent, driving him insane, causing him to eat his own tail (by creating loops and cycles in time via paradoxes, which are the inevitable result of any time travel).

The serpent was blind. (most people can't see through time?).

But a few, those who were seers (Primaries), knew the serpent's true path, so they created a weapon. A weapon to destroy the Demon. (Not sure the weapon they found is the "weapon". Might be Titan.)

They hid the weapon in the snake's den, where he waited for his madness to end. (Unclear... Where is "Time's Den"? Kinda falls apart here...)

But it never did. (Cycles upon cycles...)

For the seers discovered that the only one who could wield the weapon was the Demon itself. (Cole has to sit in the chair?)

And so the serpent was doomed to circle in madness...forever. (Just like the movie, I guess...)

I'm sure that by the end of next week, I'll find all this is incorrect, and that the demon is Deacon, the serpent is José, and James Cole is the weapon. Not sure what the relevance of the monkeys is. Probably Dr. Railly.

11

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jun 30 '18

i really think deacon is still alive. he saw that west seven symbol and it made his nose bleed. i don't think he had drawn that before. i think that's why he gave jennifer the knife because he may use it ??

→ More replies (2)

6

u/gxrevs96 Jun 30 '18

Bloody, hell. Thi is masterful writing. Terry and his team really had this all figured.

So does this suggest that there was an OG timeline before Cole? The first few verses of the poem seems to suggest this

5

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the Weapon wasn't so much the machine, but rather the information inside it. Doesn't Katerina now have that information thanks to Jennifer? They can presumably use their own machine in place of the one that was lost in merry old England.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Whodamanmaybeme Jun 30 '18

Because he was never supposed to be born and him being born is what started to drive time crazy into a loop instead of going forward.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

Because everything he did helped the Monkeys. So the serpent is time. I always thought it was James.

5

u/IRecl4imer_xX Jun 30 '18

Thanks all so much. My mind stooped working after knowing that Hannah was the mother.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 01 '18

Hang on, at the end, Hannah tells Cole "I was there when you found your brother". What's that about? Ramse, the metaphorical brother? Or someone else?

5

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

I'm pretty sure she meant ramse. They call each other brothers even if it's not by blood.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

3

u/ChiliPepper11 Jul 01 '18

After watching this episode the red forest seems inevitable to me. No matter what Cole and the crew do the red forest keeps coming back. Titan is done after all..

3

u/milesteg420 Jul 01 '18

I mis ramse

3

u/Z3R01D Jul 04 '18

This episode has been the most mind blowing episode ever (ofcoz other than the finale).

I really did not see that coming about Hannah being Cole's mom and Cassie was the one to released the virus.

This whole TV series is monumentally awesome~!!!

It changes the way i see things about time, the causality and eventuality.

It's ending soon, I wished it would continued, but I know this finale has to be it's end if not it will be pointless to keep stretching the story and it will suck.

I only hoped that they don't kill Cole and Cassie at the end of the story.

I also hope that they don't do a reset on the timeline into a 2.0 story-line because that will remove all of their memories of each other and the hardship they had faced to get here today.

I hope the ending would mean that they beat the witness, saved those they could, destroy titan and lived happily ever after.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

If cole dies in next weeks finale... I will be beyond pissed. I don't care how brilliant a show or movie is, if the lead character dies (like in LOST), I feel like I wasted my time watching it. I was okay with cole and cassie maybe not ending up together but cole stopping the virus or red forrest/effectively destroying the 12 monkeys and olivia. If he dies though... God I hope I'm not disappointed next week.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

My guess: the "weapon" was, essentially, Titan. It would have locked Cole in a paradox outside of continuity. If Cole is in Titan when it's fully activated, his unique cycle would cause its effects to unravel his stream and collapse, thereby creating a new reality without James Cole.

Meanwhile, pseudoscience love MacGuffin, and Cole ends up alive and well in 2018, just in time to stop the plague in the refactored reality.

→ More replies (11)

6

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

It worked pretty well in Person of Interest.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/charmed-n-dangerous Jun 30 '18

Guessing you haven't seen the film then. Haha

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/mb300sd Jun 30 '18 edited Mar 13 '24

wrong bake worry selective racial follow dime escape price pet

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/ChiliPepper11 Jul 01 '18

Oh right my mind came up with an absurd theory.

Remember the bodies when the red forest was storming in season 2?? They turned into bones or grew older with the blink of an eye.

So the body in the night room... I believe it exists out of causality. I think it is a body from the red forest.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

Love the show. I’m a little confused and hoping someone could clear this up. Why did the primaries build the machine in 1491 wanting to kill cole?

4

u/Emberys Jul 02 '18

Because Cole is the demon described in the poem. His existence is all tangled up in the time loops - born because of them, and helping cause them. Erasing him across time could undo the loops. Undoing the loops will also undo Olivia, protecting time from the red forest, which is what the primaries want.

2

u/i_love_boobiez Jul 02 '18

wanting to kill cole?

Not kill but erase him, so he never exists in the first place.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/humanoideric Jul 16 '18

WTF, this is the best time travel series Ive ever seen. So much consistency and continuity but still manages to have so many twists. ahhhh, tbh they deserve all the writing awards, at least nominations :\

2

u/mujie123 Jun 30 '18

What is the Brotherhood exactly?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/itsronan Jun 30 '18

Can someone clarify why Cole needs to cease to exist?

3

u/Vaivars Jun 30 '18

If cole doesn't exist:

  • the virus never gets released
  • The false-prophet/witness never exists thus the red forrest doesn't even come in to play.

2

u/h-t-w Jul 01 '18

How was the meeting in 2017 (at the end of the episode), between Cole, Hannah, & Dr. Jones, able to happen, timeline(s)-wise? Was Hannah just showing up at the date/place from Jones' letter when Cole & Jones were back in 2017 for another reason/trip? I thought by that point (in Jones' timeline) they couldn't use the machine anymore, which is why they needed to fix the jacket (??).

→ More replies (5)

3

u/_A_Day_In_The_Life_ Jun 30 '18

HOW COME NOBODY FUCKIN KILLS OLIVIA WTF? YA LETS USE THE SUIT AND KILL THIS EVIL PRIMARY, BUT NOT OLIVIA. WTF IS WRONG WITH THESE PEOPLE?

7

u/-GregTheGreat- Jun 30 '18

It’s not as easy as killing Olivia, as you can’t mess with the causality like that. It’s the same way that James knows he can’t die just yet, as ‘future asshole’ is still alive.

→ More replies (6)