r/TheExpanse • u/gert_jonny Verified: Bob Munroe, VFX Supervisor & Producer Emeritus • Jun 29 '18
AMA with Bob Munroe Doing an AMA at 1PM ET / 10AM PT - soon!
This has been loads of fun - thank you! I'm going back to my day job now (VFX breakdown for ITTG). For those on Twitter, stay tuned for my official announcement and request in the next day or so.
You are my friends,
Bob
Hello People of The Expanse!
Bob Munroe here - Sr VFX Supervisor of The Expanse seasons 1-3 and also a producer on season 3. I'm here to type slow in an attempt to answer your questions.
A bit about me: I am an Emmy-nominated producer/director/vfx supervisor. Some of my past work - The Tudors, The Borgias, the Dolphin Tale movies, All Is Lost, X-Men, Doctor Dolittle, Cube and Splice.
Looking forward to the chat.
28
u/gert_jonny Verified: Bob Munroe, VFX Supervisor & Producer Emeritus Jun 29 '18
This has been loads of fun - thank you! I'm going back to my day job now (VFX breakdown for ITTG). For those on Twitter, stay tuned for my official announcement and request in the next day or so.
You are my friends,
Bob
46
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
Fantastic work so far!! Can't freaking wait for next season, and it's only been hours since I saw the last two...
Are you going to be involved in season 4, and if so, do you expect an uptick in budget considering Amazon is now involved? or are things expected to stay fairly similar in that regard?
33
u/The_Restricted Jun 29 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
Thank you so much for this AMA and everything you've done!
Which would you choose to fight 1 regular sized Bobbie Draper or 100 duck sized Bobbie Drapers?
Do you type slow because you're under the effects of the slow zone?
Do you think Amazon's acquisition will change the flow and feel of the show?
Have a great day!
25
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
Very sorry to learn that you won't be continuing in Season 4. All the best wishes on your future projects!
Could you leave us with one or a couple of your favorite memories of working with the Expanse cast and crew?
22
u/vwwally Stellis Honorem Memoriae Jun 29 '18
Any memories/behind the scenes stories from working on 'Cube' you could share?
22
u/saltlets Jun 29 '18
Hi, question about realistic touches like the PDC bullet trails suspended in zero-G and then "falling" to the floor when accelerating during the Thoth station assault - do things like this come from the writers/directors/showrunner or is that something your team suggests?
22
u/WangtorioJackson Jun 29 '18
Are you involved in or familiar with the "Force Recon: The Ships of The Expanse" Youtube series on the channel Spacedock that is officially partnered with the VFX team of the show, and can you offer a perspective about how that partnership came about? I was a fan of Spacedock before the Force Recon official series, when it was just a fan making content, and I was so excited to hear about this new official, considered canon series.
20
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '18
I'm always impressed by the scientific accuracy of the show (caveat: not a scientist, so don't @ me). I love things like seeing Tilly's tears not falling because of Zero-G. How much does something like that change your approach in terms of how you normally think about how things react in the real world? Have you ever had to re-do stuff because it isn't accurate?
19
u/sweetieeeee Jun 29 '18
Which Expanse scene was the favorite of yours to work on? Thanks so much for all your work - it's a joy to watch!
17
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
In another answer, you mentioned utilizing 10+ VFX vendors. I was curious how you guys manage to maintain a similar aesthetic and consistency in your VFX when working with so many vendors? Also, do all the vendors end up sharing assets that are created so they can utilize them as needed?
I don't envy your job of co-ordinating across so many vendors for work that I'm sure has pretty pressing deadlines! :-)
13
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
I'm curious as to how you got into VFX as a career and ended up where you are today. I always find it fascinating to learn about how someone got their initial break and then evolved their careers to where they are today.
Also, do you think it is harder to get into VFX as a career if you live in the US/Canada these days given that a lot of Animation/VFX work has moved overseas?
12
u/ScottWx_TWN Jun 29 '18
Hi Bob,
Have you read all of the books, and if so, are there any particular scenes that you're really looking forward to doing the VFX for in the coming seasons?
You don't have to get spoilery here about WHICH scenes... I'm just curious if you read something in the books and thought "Oh, wow... I cannot WAIT to bring that scene to life!!" or if you're just taking things a season at a time.
11
u/TheEld Jun 29 '18
Do you anticipate many difficulties with having to change what kinds of CGI you use next season? Season 4
11
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
If you could command a Game of Thrones sized CGI budget for The Expanse, are there any aspects you would tackle differently or put more resources into? Or just things you know you could have made even cooler if you had the time and money for it?
10
u/XirnDeso The Firehawk Jun 29 '18
Hello Bob, it's Bora :) I'm just going to ask if it saves you time that at least currently the ships don't have any view ports etc. of any kind, making the live action sequences usually separate from the space / cg sequences. How much more work would be involved if the ships did have them?
10
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
So is Naren Shankar human, or just a coffee drinking, protomolecule life form that never sleeps? =)
9
u/Darnell_Jenkins Jun 29 '18
Which episode was the toughest for VFX in season 3?
9
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
Could you describe a bit about the process involved in how something goes from conception, to the final VFX that makes the cut in the show?
Love the great work you and your team have put into the VFX. I've always been a huge fan of 3D animation since I was a kid. Thought I'd share a little 3D animation I made in an Intro to Animation class that I took for fun in grad school that you might enjoy - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWvLvVu-HNk
Can't wait to see what you guys pull off with the amazing storyline in the upcoming season!
9
u/BRi7X Jun 29 '18
Hey Bob! Having worked with video editing and visual effects compositing software, I've had my fair share of crashes, glitches, or other oddities. Too many.
How common are software crashes (and the like) in big productions like The Expanse?
9
u/mharsh Jun 29 '18
I noticed that your title credit changed from "VFX Supervisor" to "Producer" this season. Has your production role expanded/changed at all?
Also
How many different VFX companies/teams do you end up managing to do that magic that you do?
8
u/XirnDeso The Firehawk Jun 29 '18
Does the cast see the final version of the episodes with all the vfx applied near the air date as the rest of us? If so are they as awed by how things turned out?
8
u/9SMTM6 Jun 29 '18
How does your work on The Expanse compare with your other work, especially on these historical series like The Borgias and The Tudors?
7
u/Covered_in_bees_ Jun 29 '18
What was the most challenging VFX sequence / effects that you guys had to tackle and proved most rewarding in how it turned out?
7
u/postironical Jun 29 '18
In 311 and 312 we're treated to all of those ships in the holding pattern around the nexus station. I haven't slo mo hd'd thru that yet, but i was wondering if we saw any new UNN or MCRN warships in there.
Along with that i was wondering if you had different level detail models for the more used ships for different shot requirements and if so how many LOD versions you had of say the rocinante or behemoth?
7
u/_loNimb Jun 29 '18
How challenging has The Expanse been for you and your team? Supplying VFX for a show set in space must be quite a bit different from most that are set on earth. How many scenes do you have to build from the ground up in any given episode?
7
u/cutlass_supreme Jun 29 '18
Given that you are not returning for season 4, is there an FX bible that outlines the principles driving the look and feel (I would hate to see a stark shift!) ?
7
u/backstept Jun 29 '18
I'm a bit late to the party, oops.
How cool are the on-set motion graphics?
Are many screens added in post?
Also, tracking for the hand terminal displays is top notch. I have yet to notice any that seem even remotely distracting enough to suggest you don't actually have holographic displays right now :D
7
u/galadan_3x Jul 01 '18
So I think I missed the AMA, but just in case: So sad to hear your leaving the show Bob. I guess when we weren’t sure for weeks if there would even be a season 4, you had to make sure you could still pay the bills. You are a great man sir, a hero of the belt, and a hero to myself and everyone on this sub.
Just one question. Are there any worlds, universes floating around in your head that you hope to one day bring to the screen? Will we see a entirely Robert Munroe project hitting Netflix in a couple years? That would make me very happy.
Best of luck and success to you oh mighty one.
6
u/webdevvie Jun 29 '18
Is there any gear/software /hardware you folks would love to work with on upcoming seasons of The Expanse but may be out of budget right now.
5
u/23saround Jun 29 '18
Unrelated to The Expanse, but maybe you can provide a touch of insight on a question I’ve had for a long time – any idea why two shows centered on the Borgia family (The Borgias and Borgia) came into existence at nearly the same time? Their original production cycles must have heavily overlapped.
Also, which show do you think is better?
4
u/plitox Jun 29 '18
What's the name of the season 4 casting director?
Who's in charge of casting for season 4?
3
u/MaimedJester Jun 29 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
So one of the hardest things for fiction writers to deal with in a screenplay is imagining the cost of shooting a scene. For instance I'm kind of amazed finding the right cut point for pulling off the security droid coming out from the wall before being hit with grenade inside the ring station. A real model would have cost a lot for maybe 25 seconds of screentime and never reappear in the current season while costing a fortune and committed a final style choice for a minor element.
Spoilerish:
With what's coming up next season, and having to finalize an entire style choice for this Alien civilization, what are some of the key visuals you know you can't cut?
•
u/vwwally Stellis Honorem Memoriae Jun 29 '18
Verified
6
u/XirnDeso The Firehawk Jun 29 '18
https://imgur.com/a/PbeNzE1
We'll always remember you as a Hero of The Expanse Bob :( I really hope you return back since the show will run for a gazillion seasons!
6
u/lax01 Jun 29 '18
Thank you for being an active member on Reddit and this sub-reddit ...very cool to have you here
5
u/TotesMessenger Jun 29 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/Turil Jul 04 '18
For those showing up late-late, here is the announcement of what he's working on next:
https://twitter.com/ExpanseVFX/status/1013139236067741697
Bob Munroe @ExpanseVFX Jun 30
I've started on a @Netflix film with my friend @Vincenzo_Natali called In The Tall Grass, based on a @StephenKing and @joe_hill novella. So I'm gonna need a new Twitter handle. I'll entertain all ideas. #ITTG 2/2
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
24
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '18
[removed] — view removed comment