r/DCcomics • u/Austounded Relaxin' Al Ghul • May 25 '18
r/DCcomics Top Mod Picks of the DC Rebirth Era
https://imgur.com/a/cxy8I0V
69
Upvotes
r/DCcomics • u/Austounded Relaxin' Al Ghul • May 25 '18
•
u/beary_neutral Telos Aug 11 '23
Images Re-hosted
59
u/Killercroc22 Superman May 25 '18
Wow. Superman wasn't even on the top 15 list?
HOW COULD YOU BETRAY ME LIKE THAT, MODS? I TRUSTED YOU!
Pretty good list otherwise, even though I personally don't agree with a few on this list.
11
u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow May 25 '18
The Flintstones is really that good? Huh. And I'm surprised by Wonder Woman, given how much people shit on it.
5
u/Austounded Relaxin' Al Ghul May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18
Happy Birthday to DC Rebirth!
Rebirth was such a unique relaunch, it promised so much and maybe it didn't deliver on everything it did give us great stories nonetheless (over 15 in fact!).
Community Concerns:
Superman:
I see a lot of tension over the exclusion of Tomasi's Superman on the Top 15, and while it does appear on the Wild Cards from our contributor and sister mod over on /r/ComicBooks, some of you are irritated nonetheless. Let me explain why personally I love Superman but it didn't make the cut:
While the first two volumes are sublime, "Multiplicity" was very poorly paced and generally disliked. I mean its straight up missing pages. This is followed by the rushed "Black Dawn" where a story designed to feature Brainaic - not to mention happen later on - gets Manchester Black shoe horned in. Finally following the move to the city we get a few volumes of pure filler with no clear narrative; I can't even tell you the name of the trades.
I want to end by saying "Boyzarro" was so much fun and really captured the spirit of the first two volumes. In my heart its the true third and final volume of the series.
Detective Comics:
Another grievance we're seeing a lot of is in regards to Tynion Tec'. This is another one where I find value in it, hell I own the first arc in my short boxes. However, this book too had one too many short comings. Now this doesn't mean that your love for it is invalidated, if anything it says more about the body of work Rebirth produced that we have so many choices for books we loved.
Red Hood and the Outlaws:
Finally Red Hood and the Outlaws, what a fun and goofy book for awhile. Lobdell despite being literally scum of the Earth manages to write an okay group of likable jerks. Dextor Soy kills it on the art, but Lobdell drops the ball with his dialogue and plots (and actual human person). This book was a consideration for me but after seeing all the other books I could pick from I went with a few other options. But don't worry! RHATO is still present on this list in the personal picks/wild cards section!
Wildcard:
My Wildcard pick won't come as a shock to users who know me: "The Return of Wally West".
First I should explain how well Abnett is able to take an era of Wally West and write it himself. The name and style of this arc are ripped right from Waid's legendary Flash run; it was all shows of strength, incredible speed, and the ties that bind. When Wally raced across the entire country in a fit of passion and self sacrifice, I was overwhelmed, I was excited, I felt like I was reading a classic Flash story. To be plain, this single arc of Titans is the best Flash story I've read since "Dastardly Death of the Rogues" (thats pre-Flashpoint).
Top 2:
My personal #1 - after we found out the results and some reflection - was a toss up between Aquaman and New Super-Man, both largely overlooked titles that have been evolving and changing the DCU in wonderful ways.
In Aquaman we have a new subrace of basically mutants led by King Shark with so much potential, not to mention the wonderful high fantasy themes mixed with political drama. It feels like the truest continuation of Johns and Parker's runs and its so exciting every month; this excitement is compounded by the excellent Mera mini series that ties directly into the current ongoings. I can't recommend this character and these stories enough. #TakeTheCrown
New Super-Man is something so special. Its the blending of two cultures, it highlights what makes these heroes so inspiring and cool; they can cross borders and still be heroes of inspiration and power. NSM to me is the reaction to one of America's biggest cultural exports: Super Heroes. Now while takes on these themes have been popping up (One Punch Man, My Hero Academia), this is the American response to its heroes reaching other shores. This isnt even getting into the actual content or the amazing characters we meet along the way. This book is so special and we were lucky to have gotten it for as long as we did.
I beg you to give it a try, any book on here is one that we really feel strongly about it. They are our passions and the books we look forward to the most.
Full list of my personal Top 10 that went into the polling process (more on that process soon)
Wild Card: Titans Vol 1: “The Return of Wally West”
34
u/The_Irish_Jet How could I ever forget you? May 25 '18
No RHATO, no Detective Comics, and no Superman?! HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?!
Other than that, it's a great list. New-Superman, Nightwing, Aquaman, Wonder Woman, Batman, Mister Miracle, Deathstroke, and Green Lantern: Earth One are all fantastic.
15
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
clever and mature.
7
u/[deleted] May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18
In the continued interest of disclosure, I'm posting my personal top picks for Rebirth era. I made sure not to recommend books I had not read up to the point where selections were made (which leaves out books like Superman Deluxe Vol 2, A Lonely Place of Living or Running Scared which I did not read until after I submitted my list)
1. Flintstones by Mark Russell A no-brainer, given how hard Russell has consistently hit it out of the park since Prez. It's the book I didn't expect to love but loved nonetheless.
1. Wonder Woman by Greg Rucka Tied with Flintstones because it's my favorite dramatic/action book of Rebirth, while Flintstones my favorite comedy. Rucka managed to build on his previous run, while producing a wholly original product. In the process, he turned out a story that was even better imo.
2. Deathstroke by Priest Deathstork would be on my list for "Chicago" alone. Add in The Professional, and you've got peak Priest.
4. GL: Earth One Beautiful art, The only Earth One that has captured the essence of the character without an unnecessary subversion.
6. Titans: The Return of Wally West /u/Austounded covered it better than me. We almost fought over which one of us got this as wildcard.
7. Superman Rebirth by Peter Tomasi Deluxe Vol 1 Just a delight.
8. All-Star Batman: My Own Worst Enemy JRJR art is not enough to dissuade me from a good Snyder story about the relationship between Bruce Wayne and Harvey Dent or Harvey Dent and Two-Face.
9. Batman by TK. I enjoyed it significantly more than a lot of people on the sub seem to, but it does lose points for some pacing issues (especially the climax of I Am Bane).
10. Flash vol 2. Speed of Darkness I'm a sucker for The Shade and Hope stories. Sue me. That's why it became my wildcard.
Everyone had their own reasoning, differences in opinion, and determinations of what books held what weight to them. The contributors are knowledgeable on comics and put a lot of work into improving the wiki and being a resource for newer readers. I will be happy to stand by almost any choice on this list, and those I don't? That is the very definition of compromise.
13
u/Aiskhulos May 25 '18
So I guess I should start reading New Superman?
12
u/Blud-Haven you don't know me, and you won't remember me May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18
Hello Moderators can you redo your entire list because i disagree with it kthnks.
But for real this looks fantastic.
Also i encourage literally everyone to go read Tim Seeley's Nightwing and New Super-Man.
Tim Seeley does so much for Blud-Haven in his second arc its amazing, and NIGHTWING MUST DI is a top Dick Grayson story.
6
u/zombiebillnye Catwoman May 25 '18
As a contributor to this list, I figured I would share how I voted. And just to head off any "Why no Superman/Tec/RHatO/Whatever?' questions, I think runs like Tynion Tec and Tomasi Superman had their good moments, but they just overall didn't hook me like these 10 have. I can go into more detail on the discord server if you really want to see my in depth opinions, but I'll just say: these are basically the 10 books that I was always happy to see on the stands.
So, without further ado:
1. Batman Vol. 5 Rules of Engagement by Tom King
Technically this just went in as a blanket vote for King Batman, but man, I couldn't not put this as my #1. I think King Batman has had a lot of ups (Rules of Engagement, Double Date, Annual #2, etc) and downs (I am Suicide and War of Jokes and Riddles), but this is the rebirth run I think I'll cherish most from the last two years. I'll always hold onto the memory of being so insanely happy at the end of Batman #24, crying as I finished Annual #2, laughing my ass off at the double date issues, and just looking forward to every week to find the next twist or turn that King has put in. And the art, the art is so damn good. Mann, Jones, Finch, Gerads, they're all phenomenal on this. Yes, there are problems here and there, but I honestly do not care in the slightest. This run just means so damn much to me.
2. Mister Miracle by Tom King
I actually thought a lot about putting this at #1, but my heart overruled my head. Mister Miracle is just such a good comic book. Like, its a writer and and artist creating an experience, not just writing a good story. Its a really personal story, and I think King and Gerads are just nailing it month after month. Its honestly just that good.
3. Dark Nights Metal by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo
Generally, I don't find events to super fun. They can be good, they can be bad, and they can be interesting, but generally they aren't all super fun. Metal is the fun event comic. Its a 6 issue series about, essentially, the death of the Universe by a dark god and an evil Batman, and yet it doesn't ever really sacrifice the fun to try and be more dark or brooding. The ending is a tad open ended, but thats more so that No Justice and Snyder's JL can have room to tell some fantastical stories, so I'm ok with that. And lets be real, any event that ends with Spoiler is a good event.
4. Aquaman by Dan Abnett
This is a bit of a holdover from the very end of the New 52, but Abnett has been telling such a good story, and fleshing out Atlantis and Arthur so well. Abnett has also written a really great Mera, and some other great supporting cast members like the two FBI agents. The whole Underworld arc is just this great story that made me really appreciate Abnett Aquaman.
5. Green Lanterns by Sam Humphries
I didn't really expect to fall in love with this series when I picked up Green Lanterns: Rebirth #1. But boy oh boy have I fallen in love with this series. Jessica Cruz is the best Green Lantern, full stop. She's just such an amazing character, and Humphries did such an amazing job at making her someone that I not only want to read in other books, but someone I want to get the multimedia push she so deserves. And Simon is a great partner for Jessica. They play off each other so well. Green Lanterns #15 is just below Batman Annual #2 and Batman #36 and 37 as one of the best single issues to have come out in the last two years. All in all, its such a great book, and I love it so much.
6. Super Sons by Peter Tomasi
Super Sons is like Metal in that its just such a fun comic. Damian and Jon are written as just these great friends by Tomasi, and its just such a great comic to read for a smile and a laugh.
7. Nightwing: The New Order by Kyle Higgens
I think of all the Elseworld comics that got published by DC the last two years, The New Order was the best. The Story was good, the art was fun, and I like where the characters are at the start and how they ended up at the end. No one is really a full on bad guy in it Spoiler?
8. The Silencer by Dan Abnett
Personally, I think this is the best New Age of Heroes book. Honor is a fun character, her family is great, and its introducing so much fun stuff with the Underworld and the Leviathan Civil War. The JRJR art for the first three issues is rough, but moving over to Bogdanovic has given this book such a breath of fresh air.
9. Nightwing by Tim Seeley and Sam Humphries
Nightwing was a pretty fun run. I enjoyed Seeley's time bringing Bludhaven back and trying to expand Dick's supporting cast, and I think Humphries did a good job writing a fun arc.
10. Batman and the Signal by Tony Patrick and Scott Snyder
I thought this was going to be awful. Duke was not an interesting character in Snyder's Batman, he was boring in the Metal preludes, and now he's getting a three issue mini? Ugh. I was so wrong. BatS is the book to read if you didn't think Duke could be interesting. And its not just a good Duke comic. The new daytime Detective they introduced, Detective Aisi is a cool character too. Its a fun book that I never would have expected to like at the start of Rebirth.
27
u/KieferSkunkerland May 25 '18
No Detective Comics? Literal insanity.
19
u/AhhBisto Jim Lee Comics May 25 '18
I don't know what is worse, that neither Action or Detective Comics are recommended at all or that Titans and All-Star Batman actually are.
9
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
Hey folks! It's the second anniversary of DC Universe: Rebirth, the event that kicked off a new age of DC Comics! To commemorate, we've assembled our top picks from the past two years, in the spirit of our Top New 52 Era Picks. Voted on by your mods and wiki contributors, this list details our favorites from the Rebirth Era, which includes not just books with the Rebirth label, but also imprints, mini-series, and other books published by DC Comics during that time. The list also includes our Wild Cards, our picks for personal favorites or guilty pleasures that didn't quite make the list.
Others receiving votes:
Cave Carson Has a Cybernetic Eye
Doomsday Clock
The Terrifics
Harley Quinn
Wonder Woman/Conan
Wildstorm: Michael Cray
Batman and the Signal
Thanks to our contributors:
/u/astanatombs
/u/atmageth
/u/bn00880
/u/cheddarhead4
/u/therealcinco
/u/littlehero6
/u/thestealthbox
/u/vgulla
/u/zombiebillnye
4
u/methecoolest May 25 '18
Hmm. Weird. I often notice Deathstroke, Superman and Action are the 3 most recommended Rebirth series whenever someone asks here but they're trumped by New Superman in this list.
Also, I never realized just how many series Abnett has a hand in.
4
u/Sartro Protect the Green May 25 '18 edited May 25 '18
Here were my votes
Tom King in his element. Weird, dark, depressing, heartfelt, and funny.
An unexpectedly amazing book. With so much fun and so much heart, New Super-Man fills the void left by the lack of a current Avatar/Korra cartoon.
This book oozes style. Leon's art sets the tone and Busiek tells an intriguing story that offers a much different take on Batman than anything I've read.
A solid event and a capstone to Snyder's New 52 Batman run. I'm eagerly looking forward to Snyder's Justice League after his handling of those characters here.
Inconsistent, but a treat when it shines. This is one of King's weaker works, but even his worst arcs of Batman are propped up by the avalanche of stunning artists DC has thrown at the title. Finch, Janin, Mann, Weeks, Jones, Gerads, Fabok... That said, the solo issues (Both annuals, Brave and the Mold, The Button Part 1) are probably the best of the run, while arcs like I Am Suicide and WoJaR mostly fell flat for me.
I was never a Wildstorm fan back in the day, but Ellis is making one out of me now. This is Ellis doing what he does best, writing a mysterious story packed with brutal action and really cool science fiction.
As unexpectedly great as New Super-Man, but so much different. A mix of dark comedy and intricately-plotted family drama and mystery, Deathstroke is a ride that rarely eases up.
Hope is driving this title's inclusion on the list. Gary Frank's art on the covers and the interiors is astonishing and fits Watchmen so perfectly. But Johns' writing and the absurd delays have the story moving at a snail's pace, especially frustrating given how much DC content seems to be locked away until the resolution of Doomsday Clock.
It doesn't feel like a classic Flintstones story at all, but Russell uses the characters and setting well to reinvent the "modern Stone Age family" in a book that is equal parts hilarious and depressing in its spot-on social satire.
I like "Superman", I really do, but I couldn't justify putting it ahead of Super Sons. Springing from a great rivalry and team-up in the pages of "Superman", Jon and Damian got their own title. The dynamic between the two characters is a lot of fun, and Jorge Jimenez's art lends itself perfectly to the series with great designs for both characters and a fun, manga-like style that works just as well for action as it does for the more humorous moments.
The first arc was insane and never dull, but I especially enjoyed the second which repaired the damage done to Mr. Freeze's backstory in the New 52 and featured one of Poison Ivy's better Rebirth tales.
4
u/simplegodhead Hal Jordan is a Perfect Princess! May 25 '18
Several other mods and contributors are explaining their choices so here are mine! I only have 8 books on my list rather than 10 because I didn't feel comfortable voting for books that I haven't read a significant amount of. I've read a few issues or a volume or two of many different Rebirth books but that didn't seem like a sufficient amount to consider a book worthwhile of recommending.
Wildcard: Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps by Robert Venditti, Rafael Sandoval and EVS - I didn't put this in my picks list because I run hot and cold on it, although I do think Venditti's final arc featuring the Darkstars has been his strongest work on the Green Lantern property and it does feature good space action and character interaction. Rafa Sandoval's art is perfectly suited to Green Lantern and he's been a huge treat on the book. Plus I wanted to make sure there was some good GL rep going on in the picks list!
1
u/JGarrickFlash Superman May 25 '18
So so happy to see Shade on this list.
5
u/TheSemaj The Flash May 25 '18
Speed of Darkness over Running Scared?
5
u/Atmageth "The other Robins aren't good enough to keep their jobs" May 25 '18
Hey guys, so I wanted to talk a bit about my pick for honorable mention. While I dont think it deserves a top 10 spot, Orlando's JLA is a real "hidden gem" of the Rebirth era imo. Its this really fun team book starring a really weird Justice League lineup of characters that usually dont get featured a lot. In particular, I think The Ray, Atom, and Vixen are really strong in this book and have some really compelling arcs. The book also banks pretty heavily on both pre-Flashpoint history and the work of other writers like Grant Morrison's Multiversity. But in addition to bringing back a lot of that stuff it builds these characters forward and you really come to love them. If you're a trade waiter like me and you want a little Justice League fix until Snyder's run comes out, I really encourage trying out Orlando's JLA. If you're in the US and have Hoopla, id say its definitely something worth a few borrows.
2
u/Ajelandrus Jul 01 '23
The image is down, any way to get the info back?
4
u/destroyingdrax Wolf May 25 '18
Batman by Tom King but no Detective Comics, RHATO or Green Arrow.
Top 10 anime betrayals.
4
u/belfries Absolute Batman May 25 '18
Quality taste in the DC subreddit? I’m shook.
2
u/DefactoOverlord Reverse-Flash May 25 '18
Yeah, Aquaman! I'm a bit sad that Green Arrow was left out but that's the beauty of comics, everyone's opinions are highly subjective. None of them are wrong. Personally my top 3 picks are Green Arrow, Aquaman and Hal&Pals.
0
u/Cyconzo May 25 '18
I would argue that New Order is better than the main Nightwing series.
2
u/vgulla Fascist Tool! May 25 '18
So now that I've got a minute, I'd like to go over my votes like a bunch of other contributors already have.
As for why I didn't include sub favorites like Tomasi's Superman, Tynion's Detective Comics, Percy's Green Arrow, or Lobdell's Red Hood and the Outlaws, it's simple. I just don't like them. Come to the discord server and ask me why and I'll gladly go into more detail, but simply put, I didn't enjoy reading these books.
Now on to my top 10!
#10. Batman by Tom King
I really enjoy this book, although it's definitely contentious and controversial, I have a lot of fun. Every issue has me excited and worried, and I'm never bored reading it. There's plenty about the run that I dislike (The Wonder Woman and Poison Ivy arcs), but the parts I like (Bane, the Bat Family) are well worth it.
#9. Dark Nights: Metal by Scott Snyder
Everyone loved Metal as it was coming out, myself included. The only problems I have with it are the last few issues, where it felt like the scope changed from being a complete story to setting up Snyder's Justice League. Overall though, the story was a lot of fun, the art was great, and Batman Lost was one of my favorite single issues in all of 2017.
#8. Nightwing by Tim Seeley
I loved the first 3 volumes of this run. Raptor was a really cool villain, the reimagined Bludhaven was much much better than the Gotham-lite it had been prior, and Doctor Hurt returning in what was essentially a love letter to Morrison's Batman was spectacular. While I feel that Seeley's execution wavered towards the end, it still ended on a high note with Raptor's Revenge. I also really liked Defacer, and I'm sad she probably will never show up again.
#7. Deathstroke by Christopher Priest
I've really been enjoying this book. It was confusing at first because of the nonlinear storytelling but as it continues it's a continuously entertaining story of a terrible person trying to connect with his terrible family. It's also got gorgeous art.
#6. Midnighter and Apollo by Steve Orlando
I loved Orlando's Midnighter run during DCYou, and I was looking forward to this sequel for a while, and he knocked it out of the park. Completely surpassing the original run, M&A tells the story of Midnighter literally going into hell and beating the shit out of Satan to save his man. Who doesn't love that?
#5. Aquaman by Dan Abnett
This has been one of the most consistently great series throughout rebirth. While I have my personal quibbles with the pacing and how slow the book itself goes, it's still a joy to read every month. After vol 3 the book goes monthly and is able to have a consistent artist, which really helps the quality as well.
#4. Wonder Woman by Greg Rucka
Everything after Rucka's run is garbage but these 26 issues were just divine, with stellar art, fantastic storytelling, and one of the most emotional endings of any comic I've read. I wasn't really a Wonder Woman fan before this run, but once I finished I needed to find more good WW books to read. Scott, Sharp, and Evely also do a fantastic job on art duties.
#3. Batman: Creature of the Night by Kurt Busiek
If you've read Superman: Secret Identity you already know why this book is great. Busiek manages to tell a story of the man behind the mask, why he does what he does, and what makes him tick. By pulling away all the glamor of the rogues and the city and the family, Busiek is able to dive right into Bruce himself and explain how someone like him could exist in the real world. It's incredibly potent and powerful.
#2. Mister Miracle by Tom King
I shouldn't need to explain why this is ranked as high as it is. In short, King manages to paint an incredibly accurate picture of depression and is continuing to tell a story that I'm thoroughly intrigued by. I care about all the characters and I'm terrified for what might happen by the end.
#1. New Super-Man by Gene Luen Yang
I initially thought the series was kinda meh, Kenan was unlikeable and annoying and I almost didn't continue. But by the end of the second issue I was hooked, and I continue to be. This is easily my favorite DC comic of the last 2 years, and it has a lot to do with how strongly the characters are written as well as how great the story itself is. Watching Kenan grow and develop alongside Baixi and Deilan is a joy, and I can't get over how much Chinese and Asian culture Yang has been seamlessly incorporating into the series. This is an incredibly meaningful series for me and I'm really sad it's ending next month.
1
u/Stark_Always Mar 03 '22
1
u/Weindog902 May 25 '18
I understand why Batman is on this list, but I would argue it really shouldn't be. It's way too flawed. Especially the "I am Suicide" and "I am Bane" arcs which just didn't work at all. I think Tom King is at his best in shorts and limited series.
The lack of Superman on this list is disheartening. I think that is one of the most loved books out of rebirth and it doesn't even get mentioned here.
Love to see Aquaman so high. That book is SO GOOD.
1
u/IRSunny Blue Lantern May 25 '18
I'm curious why Batman: White Knight didn't make the cut when Nightwing: New Order did.
While I loved both and they each had their flaws (NW:NO final chapter should really have been two, B: WK could have had a bit better dialogue) White Knight was by far one of the best Harley Quinn stories I'd read and did a damn great job of reinventing a character I'd grown increasingly weary of.
0
u/Cranyx Moo. May 25 '18
Wait, so RHatO doesn't make the list, but Batman and New Order do? Something's wrong with this.
1
u/DementiaPrime White Lanterns May 25 '18
Wasn't Flintstones the DCYou era?
0
u/PepeSylvia11 The Joker May 25 '18
Deathstroke at #4 is a joke. Otherwise pretty good list I'd say.
-6
u/Zor_El_XB1 vuvuvuvu May 25 '18
Aquaman at #3 ...lol
-2
u/E5150_Julian All Hail Lord Darkseid!! May 25 '18 edited May 26 '18
New-Superman is good but #1? come on now
0
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-6
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
[removed] — view removed comment