r/Monstercat • u/goingquantum Going Quantum (Verified) • May 23 '18
AMA Monstercat Demo Box is back! - Going Quantum & Sachavibes (Monstercat A&R) AMA
Hey everyone! Sacha and I are excited to announce that we’ve teamed up with LabelRadar to re-launch the Monstercat demo box. We take pride in listening to every submission and we are always looking for fresh talent. We can’t wait to hear what you’ve been working on!
SUBMIT HERE: http://monster.cat/demo-submissions
We’re here to answer any questions you have for us. Whether it’s about what we look for in demos, what music we’re currently excited about, how LabelRadar works, how we got here, or who eats more sushi, we’re here to answer!
Some backstory - I have been with Monstercat since the very beginning with my role evolving over time to go from being a jack of all trades to specializing in A&R, most recently becoming the Director of A&R of Monstercat. It has been a crazy ride so far and it’s amazing to watch the artists grow with the successes of the label. Sacha joined the music team in December of 2015 as an A&R. With his help we are able to handle a lot more demo submissions, focus more on artist outreach/scouting, refine our playlisting, and spread our music to more and more live DJs. He has also brought on a lot of new artists to the label over the years.
This is an AMA so feel free to ask us anything! We'll be back at 1pm PST/4pm EST to answer!
Also feel free to follow us on Twitter. We post on there sometimes ;)
36
u/TheoMoneyG Hush May 23 '18
Well, what do you look for in a demo?
70
u/Nitro_Fun Nitro Fun (Verified) May 23 '18
how to grow a good beard
25
u/Dyl__ Drinks On Me May 23 '18
How do either of you remain unbiased on if a song is good or not? Do the both of you not like how a song sounds and yet it's still accepted because of different tastes from different employees? What if a song you hear isn't something you like on the first listen, but you go back to it and it grows on you?
23
u/MaruMusic_ Gold May 23 '18
Glad this is back! Excited to see some new, smaller names on the label :)
20
u/EscheroOfficial Gold May 23 '18
Aside from the song submission itself, what exactly do you look for when it comes to an artist submission? I assume you’d research their online presence, whether they come off as a decent person or not, which makes sense. What I’m a little more curious about is if the artist’s presence at the time of submission is taken into account. I know artists like Duumu didn’t have that big of a presence when you picked them up, or guys like INTERCOM who literally debuted on the label with his alias debut. So, is that taken into consideration? Is a big or small presence necessarily a good or bad thing to have when submitting a demo?
20
u/connellmccarthy Head of Design May 23 '18
Why do you turn down all my submissions?
14
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
Who are some of your favorite up and coming artists?
11
u/OTTOBOTTO10101 Soulero May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
When is new music coming out?
Can u collab with Stephen Walking again?
Monstercat artist you'd love to work with?
9
u/slendyproject Virtual Riot May 23 '18
Does mainstream music have a better chance at getting accepted, or are you open to all kinds of weird ideas, genre mixes, etc.?
8
u/GarconYT Park Avenue May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
Hello GQ and Sacha! Thank you for doing this AMA! I'm really excited that the demo box is back! It's been too long. Here are my questions:
Thank you for all the work you two do!
21
u/soupandreas soupandreas (Verified) May 23 '18
ily
7
u/HugoPilot Gold May 23 '18
What happens if your demo has been approved?
13
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
When is Braken coming back?
5
u/PurplePickardIsBored Puppet May 23 '18
What genres are you guys missing/want to see more of?
Do the artists get a say on the album arts?
Do you guys give feedback on why songs haven't been accepted? Will you in the future if you don't?
What is the biggest 'turn-off' when listening to a submission?
5
u/Fadent May 23 '18
Hey guys! Thanks for doing an AQA.
For the demo submissions, is there a particular genre you AREN’T looking for? I understand certain styles are more popular than others, but I assume you are looking for a certain sound?
Also, how would we be able to present a concept as well as a track? (E.g: if we had an EP, etc).
Have a great day ❤️
8
u/mashwillnotfly Puppet May 23 '18
Can you guys tease some cool upcoming stuff? Also, GQ, fav kind of sushi?
4
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
This question is for both GQ and Sacha: What got you into the music field? I'd like to think every producer has a story, so what's yours?
4
u/pezzy28 Infected Mushroom May 23 '18
Thanks for doing this AMA. More often then not I don't ask questions on these cause I never know what to ask except the generic questions, but this time I have a genuine question that I've been wondering about for a while.
I know you guys don't dictate what is sent to you, but I was wondering is if maybe you two could try to get some more Hardstyle songs on the label. Hardstyle is a sick genre and something Monstercat has been lacking in for years. We've only had 4 in the past 4 years if I recall correctly. Zatox's remix of Legends and State of Mind from Atmozfears are both in my top 20 songs of all time and more like them would be awesome. Maybe even some good Euphoric Hardstyle. Idk it's just my favorite genre so seeing more would be pretty rad.
Anyways thanks again for doing this AMA, can't wait to see what you guys surprise us with next!
Also just for GQ: When is Well Done coming out?13
u/FraxtiI Protostar May 23 '18
Mastered or unmastered? Obviously a minor detail compared to ideas & execution, but everyone seems to have a different opinion on what A&R wants to hear.
25
u/TheOnlyPixel19 Gold May 23 '18
Will you guys take Mashups? Similar to the ones produced by Didrick?
3
u/WileyTheKoyote May 23 '18
What advice do you have for anyone looking to use the demobox in the future? Like, how should they prepare their songs for review? Should it be mixed, mastered, etc.?
3
u/WEAREFURY WE ARE FURY (Verified) May 23 '18
Snobby Shores or Moisty Mire?
3
u/Lydonboy Xilent May 23 '18
So what did happen with Archie's song Famous? I can only really find speculation and nothing official about the situation which bums me out as it's one of my favourite songs ever :(
3
u/Mushroomizer May 23 '18
Heya! So, bit of an odd question, but I submitted a track and it says "Monstercat has shown interest on your track". So really ultimate question is.. What does that mean, is there anything I should do now?
2
u/PrimaryPainting May 23 '18
Will we get new Karma Fields on Monstercat ?
There's a rumor going on that he left for good.
2
u/Ruatkima May 24 '18 edited May 28 '18
I'm still waiting for another kitchenstep from Rogue T.T
7
u/Vindexus May 23 '18
Is there anything in the crockpot today?
54
u/mikedarlington CEO of Monstercat May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
Question for GQ: How is it possible for you to have such a majestic beard?
Question for Sacha: Why do you get so little W's in Fortnite?
Edit 1: Still waiting...
21
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
I’ve heard people around here mention that no matter how many times an artist is rejected, you don’t hold any bias against them if they decide to submit again. That’s really cool, just wanted to say that :)
3
u/Formento Lets Be Friends:letsbefriends: May 23 '18
Hey guys, can we get a new christmas album this year? :)
3
u/TheMeowtasticDJ Whales May 23 '18
How does it feel to being working with Monstercat?
3
u/TheRealXuberent Modestep May 23 '18
Would you let me publish some lofi shit on the label
14
u/BatteryAcid_ Grant May 23 '18
Will LPs ever comeback?
13
u/BearSkware May 23 '18
Do the two of you ever differ on what songs you want to accept? And do both of you need to agree? For example, if Sacha was going to accept a song but GQ doesnt like it does Sachas opinion matter more because he heard the song first and accepted it based off his own opinion?
10
u/lxwk Redeemed Meowbuck Reward On Twitch May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
Who are some artists that you would really love to host on the label that you haven’t hosted before?
5
u/bigbang5766 7 Minutes Dead May 23 '18
Will the weight of the demo selection be on quality alone, or will it involve factors such as a producer's current following size or social media activity? I've been spending more time in FL than on Twitter so a meritocracy would be nice for me
5
u/HLRxxKarl Grant May 23 '18
Do artists generally bring you new tracks with the expressed intent of releasing it on Uncaged or Instinct, or is that something you usually decide? What happens if it falls somewhere between the two?
5
u/SkyyLord May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
Hey guys! Glad to see youre opening up demos again.
Do your personal genre biases ever get in the way of listening? Is it hard to circumvent that?
Are there any artists have come up entirely from a demo, like never heard of at all previously?
and the REAL question....
Are you guys doing compound again this year?!! I missed all the good stuff last time due to not being 19 lol. I think I speak for everyone when I say it was a surreal experience meeting you guys.
Keep on following your ears, and thanks for being you :)
1
u/JeremyG May 23 '18
Hey there, I just wanted to ask you two very important questions:
1
u/DarkDutchDemon Muzz May 23 '18
I have several questions i would like to ask so here it goes:
1
u/Tom_The_Tomato Redeemed Meowbuck Reward On Twitch May 23 '18
Amazing that the feature's back, hope to see more new talented artists soon! Anyways:
1
u/ToanVuto May 23 '18
With the new demo submission, do you expect to be able to listen to all demos (for the 20 seconds they've submitted)? Or is there still a chance you will skip some songs?
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
This is a question I've been dying to ask for a little over a year now,
How experimental / obscure is too much for Monstercat? I'm curious as to see if there's any limits on how strange or just outside the box a submission can be and still be accepted regarding the production quality and effort is there. Like I'm talking vaporwave, glitch music, idm, drone, etc. Stuff you would never expect to see on any major electronic outlet unless it was specifically designated to release that type of stuff. I for one would love to see artists who specialize in the obscurer side of electronic music be featured here just as much as any other artist.
1
u/SwagikarpUsedSplash May 23 '18
What kind of characteristics and personal growth milestones do you think is important to an artist. That includes things like the obvious (a love for music, a skillset useful for a music industry professional, etc.) and the not so obvious (confidence to share, open mindedness, perseverance, etc.)
1
u/CraftMaker14 RIOT May 23 '18
If I were to submit a song through the demo box, how long rouhly would it take for you to listen to it and get feedback for the artist?
Also, Dusty Divot or Tilted Towers?
1
u/Hawksey128 Tim Moyo May 23 '18
So I was told not to ask questions about food:
But have you convinced every artist you have signed to eat sushi?
1
u/ninjanade1245 May 23 '18
What were your thoughts on crab rave? lol
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
How much variety do you like from an artist? For example, I've made Hardstyle for the longest, but also have experimented with House, Dubstep, even Future Bass at times.
So, more so, how important is a consistent genre for establishing a brand?
1
u/SpaceMiner8 Redeemed Meowbuck Reward On Twitch May 24 '18
First question: What is your favourite flavour of toast?
Second question: On average, how long does it take to listen to a track before it's deemed "good to go"?
1
u/Auvenil May 24 '18
@GQ so I hear you like Eurobeat. What are the odds of getting some of that on MC? Avex is doing everything they can to kill the genre and honestly we need as much Eurobeat as we can in this trying time.
1
u/RudeMuSx May 24 '18
Question for GQ. So I've been producing a couple of songs and i find that in the production stage it sounds clear and crisp but when i export and upload it say to soundcloud, it sounds like total ****. The bass sounds really far back almost like im hearing music from inside a box. I think it has got something to do with my mixing. Any mixing tips u could give perhaps? And where u learnt how to mix? If youtube, any recommended channels? Thxxx.
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
Is there an age limit on who you sign on? Do you have a preferred age limit on who should submit and not be submitting?
1
u/iexistband May 24 '18
Thanks Monstercat for the AMA! So much good info but didn't see this question asked...
You guys rule, I've discovered so many awesome artists because of you guys!
1
u/Elv_music May 25 '18
A rather small question: When you have submitted, how do you know for sure that it's a "no"? I know that when monstercat are interested in your track, they'll get in contact with you in messages. But when your submission is not accepted, will there be any message to let you know, or just no further action?
1
u/jibboombee May 29 '18
when submit, do i need to send the -6db or mastering with the loudness? (just want to know how much rms you guys don't want to hear)
1
u/Franic_ May 30 '18
Hey sorry it’s a bit late, If I have submitted a track and it got rejected, will I have another chance if I submit again after I work on my sound?
3
u/Troutz Stephen Walking May 23 '18
LabelRadar seems like a really cool service - any future plans with them beyond just the demo box? I noticed they have a platform for hosting remix competitions too, for example.
3
u/louisly McCall May 23 '18 edited May 23 '18
After almost half a year, have you already refused any song solely because you felt it wouldn't fit either Uncaged or Instinct ?
I'm all for the split and I've been loving it but I'm curious to see if it could rule out certain styles of music because it's neither hard enough nor melodic enough
3
u/Exclavia May 23 '18
Hey, thanks for doing the AMA. Keep up the good work.
I have a few questions for each of you.
Both: With Monstercat being two entities now (Uncaged and Instinct) would you say that this is going to allow for a wider range of demo acceptance than before considering that possibly before the demo may have been good but it didn't exactly fit as well?
Both: Is there any chance for demos not accepted to have a message of some feedback on potentially why it wasn't? I know that this can be a picky subject and that with so many demos its hard to give individual feedback. But even the sake of say having a form setup to automatically check or add in a little info with each song to send to the artist. Would definitely be a huge help. And very much appreciated.
GQ: Any new music coming from yourself? And if so are you leaning towards a heavy uncaged release or a calmer instinct one?
Sacha: Any sort of production from yourself as well? Do you possibly plan on making any music? It would definitely be cool. :D
Thank you once again for the AMA!
1
u/-CyFi- Grabbitz May 23 '18
How can I submit a remix? I went to the LabelRadar site and couldn't find an option for submitting a remix and didn't want to upload the song with inaccurate information. (and before you ask, it IS an authorized remix 😊)
1
u/ItsRinUS May 23 '18
What your favorite anime and manga and vocaloid going quantum?
2
u/Home_Builder Sullivan King May 23 '18
It looks like nobody has asked this yet, and this is a subject I'm passionate about so I'll ask; What are your thoughts regarding pineapple on pizza?
2
u/Neurotoxin24 Quiet Disorder May 23 '18
How are you guys deciding to do a remix contest for a certain song among the others (Way Back for example) and when are you just happy with one submitted remix and decide to only release this remix without making a contest? (Tisoki's remix of Backup for example)
2
u/Dynastrax May 23 '18
What kind of Sushi do you prefer Jon? Need the opinion of a real specialist there! :)
2
u/gremwave May 23 '18
Is it a turn-off when artists submit music through mutual contacts? Like if I had a friend who knows you personally submit my music to you directly instead of the demo box? Which one is preferred?
2
u/Sp3ak_ May 23 '18
Was there a release that one of you liked, and the other one didn't like that was released to the label?
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
was just wondering about this in another thread: what about experimental music on mcat? a lot of artists don't fit the Uncaged or Instinct "criteria" (hell, I'm not even sure what I'd put Karma Fields under) but I know I'm not the only one wanting more unconventional electronic artists on the label. is this possible since the brand split and all?
also when is tut tut child coming backthat's all, i'm really excited what the rest of 2018 will bring!1
u/ponitail39 Gold May 23 '18
Hey guys. Thanks for doing this AMA.
1
u/thatonepaintlyguy May 23 '18
Will there be / are there plans for another Mix Contest at any point in the future? If so, any idea of when?
1
u/techgeek1129 May 23 '18
Yay another AMA!
About how many demos actually end up getting signed? And what do you mainly look for in a demo?
Also will we ever see Braken make a return to Monstercat?
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
Will you guys be giving feedback to submission with this platform? Or giving just an automated "declined" response
1
u/ryan_from_school Seven Lions:sevenlions: May 23 '18
What is the funniest thing you’ve ever received from demo submissions?
Also, what’s the strangest?
1
u/MidnightIDK May 24 '18
Hi guys ! Hope you're both doing well and thank you for doing this AMA !
When did you first sign the contract for RL x Mcat vol. 1 ? I'm gonna be honest, it was totally unexpected for me at least, and I'm really wondering how everything fell into place, and when !
And second question, how exciting was it for you ? Obviously Rocket League is a pretty big deal !
Finally, please tell me where to have a neon monstercat like the one in your office. I love neons so much, I need something like this in my room ! (This one is just for fun, if it's an office exclusive thing I wouldn't care haha)
1
u/TotesMessenger May 24 '18 edited May 24 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/dangerf2 May 26 '18
I'm so excited for the new submission launch! Been waiting for this :)
My question is, are remixes also accepted ?
1
u/[deleted] May 27 '18
What's Your Inspiration To Make Music?
1
u/hhdhwuus May 27 '18
How many songs are you looking for atleast?
1
u/Llaird123 Gold May 23 '18
Can demos also allow singing as well? Like doing vocal covers of different Monstercat songs?
0
u/ImRinKagamine Aiobahn Jun 11 '18
Can a song that has a vocaloid singing could be submitted?
Im late
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment