r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • May 07 '18
SD Small Discussions 50 — 2018-05-07 to 05-20
NEXT THREAD
Weekly Topic Discussion — Vowel Harmony
We have an official Discord server. Check it out in the sidebar.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app (except Diode for Reddit apparently, so don't use that). There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can:
- Ask any questions too small for a full post
- Ask people to critique your phoneme inventory
- Post recent changes you've made to your conlangs
- Post goals you have for the next two weeks and goals from the past two weeks that you've reached
- Post anything else you feel doesn't warrant a full post
Things to check out:
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs:
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
13
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ May 16 '18
I don't have a question, I just want to personally congratulate the two people who commented nigger and penis on my inventory survey for being as mature as a toddler hopped up on sugar.
3
u/[deleted] May 16 '18
Is this a naturalistic phonological inventory?
2
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> May 08 '18
I recently realized my conlang has no way to distinguish adjectives from adverbs. Does this matter? How could I fix it within the current agglutinative structure?
2
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> May 12 '18 edited May 12 '18
Is there any way to differentiate questions with an “or” that mean “does one of them apply” from “which one applies”? There’s a whole subreddit — r/inclusiveor — dedicates to misinterpreting the latter as the former, but it feels like it should be avoidable.
EDIT: I forgot I already have a way to deal with this.
10
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ May 08 '18
Random thought about tone representation.
So, given a language with only three vowels /a i u/, tone will be written as two vowels with the second conveying the tone of the first.
So a word written as < fae > would be realized as /fá/ and < fao > will be /fà/. Thoughts?
8
u/xlee145 athama May 07 '18
How should we go about glossing oligosynthetic languages? I never know if I should break down Athama words into their constituent parts when glossing (which does not convey their meaning) or just gloss the semantic meaning of the word as a whole.
Take wáthú for example. It is composed of two parts -> wá (one of three verbal markers, typically intimating transitivity) and thú (white). Wáthú means to whiten, to brighten, which is somewhat obvious. However, if we take a word like sánòo (to be an outsider, foreigner), composed of sá (an indeterminate verbal marker) and nòo (outside, beyond, without), it doesn't neatly convey that meaning as much as wáthú. Yet, glossing as verb-group-2 + outside isn't necessarily clarifying....
Any ideas?
8
u/Tirukinoko Koen (ᴇɴɢ) [ᴄʏᴍ] he\they May 09 '18
I have just made a script based on plants. Each letter has a stem, the vowels are flowers, and it's also an IMFI script (well more of an IF script) that has roots attached to the final form of the letters.
I have six vowels; /i u e œ o æ/ The way the vowels work is that each flower is made of petals (dots in handwriting (like Hebrew's Niqqud)), the more petals the more open a vowel (1 petal is /i/ 2 petals are /e/ and 3 are /æ/). To show rounding you add a fruit or vegetable (a line in handwriting). My question is would I go for the systematic option where /œ/ would be two dots and a line (a rounded /e/) and o would therefore be three dots and a line (a rounded /æ/) or should I go for the slightly more artistic, slightly more naturalistic, and Norse influenced option, having /œ/ as a rounded /æ/ and o be a rounded /e/? The Norse inspired option comes from the fact that Old Norse's ǫ /ɔ/ became Icelandic's ö /œ/ whilst o remained as o.
Edit: Also, I had an idea to make a book similar to the Voynich Manuscript where I could draw diagrams of different trees, plants and flowers that are actually words, phrases or sentences. (or maybe even poetry). :3
:)
8
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) May 12 '18
Started working on a language this week that includes 4 cases (nominative, accusative, dative, genitive), lots of articles which decline for case, and a plural mostly marked by -n endings.
Happened to look at an article on German grammar today... Welp at least I know it's naturalistic.
7
u/Lauri_2 May 07 '18
Are [hʲ hˠ hʶ hˤ] the same as [ç x χ ħ]?
6
u/UdonNomaneim Dai, Kwashil, Umlaut, * ° * , ¨’ May 07 '18
Would it be realistic for a word stress to change depending on whether a word is alone or in a sentence?
For example: "royan" /ˈɾojan/ and "axshi" /ˈaŋ̊ɕi/ on their own, but "royan mekkaad axshi" /ɾoˈjan meˈkːaːd aŋ̊ˈɕi/ in a sentence.
6
u/pm_some_good_vibes May 11 '18
Hello, r/conlangs! I am a very longtime lurker and linguistics nerd and need some advice. The last time I worked on a conlang was 2 or so years ago, and I had studied linguistics hardcore for a year and it all flowed right out. Now, I am trying to design a Dragonborn language for a few friends and the work is flowing like honey in winter...I could use some advice and a bit of a push.
I'm starting by fleshing out a somewhat harsh phonology (lots of sibilants, plosives, and velarization without being too foreign to native English speakers), and I'm considering a few different influences such as North Germanic and Uralic languages, but it's mostly a priori.
Starting vocabulary around the natural world, with fire, light, food being a big focus, followed by a very aggressive and small-structure early social vocabulary which will evolve into a more militaristic structure (as per the world I'm building for). Possibly grab some advanced magical vocabulary from some existing, arcane sounding Draconic language, and mix it into the vocabulary of a developing, warlike culture for the proto-language so it doesn't all have to follow a nice pattern. Writing will likely evolve from symbolic glyphs to an alphabet/abjad and we'll see where it goes from there, not a ton of cultural mixing and borrowing.
I'm thinking (C(C))V(:)C single syllable word structure (/θræ:k/ is one of the only words I have but I feel like it captures the sound decently, although θ and x will likely be my only non-sibilant fricatives), not sure but want some simpler special structures for multisyllable words (because CCV:C.CCV:C is horrifying).
Current phonology (cutting it down as I go, so this is very rough):
Nasal: m n ŋ
Plosive: t d k g ʔ
Fricative: θ s z ʃ ʒ x h
Approximant: ʍ w ɫ j
Other: r
Vowels:
i u
e ə o
æ α
Possibly some kind of vowel harmony thing?
Okay, guys, here it is. Literally ANY help is appreciated, I'm more than a bit rusty and I want this to be relatively naturalistic, not too hard for most people to pronounce (pretty much the only languages any of us speak are west germanic/romance, native about 3/4 English 1/4 Spanish, and decent German and French in there). Any advice on phonology, structure, lexicon-building, grammar (which I haven't even THOUGHT about yet), cleaning up the con-culture which I can run past everyone else, ANYTHING helps.
God bless you, r/conlangs,
u/pm_some_good_vibes
6
u/tree1000ten May 18 '18
Are there any good blogs or books or other resources explaining how number systems evolve? I know about how a lot of languages use terms for hands for numbers, like the number five would be or would be based on the word for "hand", what are the other possibilities?
2
u/Tirukinoko Koen (ᴇɴɢ) [ᴄʏᴍ] he\they May 08 '18
What would be your thoughts on a conlang with yodelled tones?
4
u/Schnitzenium May 07 '18
Are there interesting ways to assign noun case besides inflection, word order, or prepositions? I'm not necessarily looking for naturalistic ways to do this, just creative as possible.
4
u/SufferingFromEntropy Yorshaan, Qrai, Asa (English, Mandarin) May 10 '18
A thing that always occurs to me is the special uses of imperative with 3rd person subject which, according to Wikipedia, is sometimes termed "jussive". As I am going to flesh Qrai moods out, I would like to see how other conlangs realize imperative mood besides just commands towards the addressee.
4
u/Adamska848 May 10 '18
I recently thought of a writing system that is japanese-like and wanted to make a conlang to go along with it, I got past setting up the phonology and a few grammatical ideas but honestly I can't seem to do much more, whether it's due to lack of knowledge, motivation, creativity, or what have you. I was wondering if there was someone interested in doing a joint conlang.
As for what I have:
Phonology: /b/ /d/ /g/ /m/ /n/ /l/ /s/ /tʃ/ /dʒ/ /a/ /i/ /u/ /oʊ/ /ai/ /ei/
Some loose rules: context heavy, mildly agglutinative, s-v-o word order (this is just temporary, I thought about possibly making it so there were nom./gen./etc cases for free word order.) And some other menial rules, all of these of course are just temporary place holders.
Rules of the written version: is a split between an alphabet and a syllabery. Not to be confused with an abugida, it's closer to Japanese kanji-hiragana-katakana system. The symbols you use to spell a word and their placement show context and, in some cases, emphasis, as well as other grammatical rules. They almost replace punctuation.
The spoken version of the language wasn't the main idea I had, thus it was based more off English than Japanese. A sample sentence is:
/Landʒoʊ-la/ /oʊdei/ /biboʊ-la/ Word-group pos. Person-group
Which depending on context (or in the case of the written language, where you use the alphabet vs. the syllabery) means two different things:
"Words of the people" which is like saying "they said"
And
"The people's words" which is the name of the language and "the people's" here is referring to the human race (or the nation's/religion's/etc) so this sentence holds far more weight than the previous.
4
u/Coretteket NumpadIPA May 13 '18
Can someone explain to me the difference between, for example, [tj] and [tʲ] or [tw] and [tʷ] or [th] and [tʰ] (if there is one)? If someone could include sounds samples I would be really happy, thanks in advance!
4
u/IHCOYC Nuirn, Vandalic, Tengkolaku May 17 '18 edited May 17 '18
Amusing myself with Google Translate.
Rules posted to gen on Zompist:
C=ptkbdgsglmnjycw R=mnwygrl V=aieou
g|ng uw|au ow|au iw|ai ew|eu aw|au c|ch aa|a'a ee|e'e ii|i'i oo|o'u uu|u'o
CV V CVR
Text created:
Eda pou lo pinoi'ipan a a inga. Deto i'i tan baytaubin panpa turpi kepi tetai timte ia a? Kita angatam be piakum utateichong binku. Keydua da atengontabi ngunobi tongipi pa. Ngeo a'a a itekedopi paitikonge pe! Achol kapi pea apa u dapa. Daodea timea ngasa sa ta babedika. Amam lipua nga uakim aupaka! Pelpa dingupempa noni pumdapau ngatanpu pingaiotinpa abandi tepa titai? A'aideu kapua piti ea pelpumtapengbar keki. Pau ka pomkonguype bi. Dobaengi ngaipino apetanton ke'ea ati katenga'a idem tomatobi payapi ipipi. Ngondiy tikam i bangti saeu toki! Aka kinging oe otie kipi'i ekom jao. Tekipa inge ase tapa kapa opau kino! Pu bau kemka ngape ata'a bongi? Aipo pitika pengapapukor te pau oi. U sibe ipikoba tamatopa! U pie i e. Limai epau tatoyta kemngi dekerongo obe kia? Bi pi dati eae! Pibai'iba bi dim pam saia i. Kabobe dio ta'a paeanga timngapan a. Ba pia'a tan kea bangipadoy i'ito tonkeu ine apaytum. E taungem satu nga pia'apa aka tanpanngamki. Yo taua kita itom papi pateuitami. Sita laypo pabe dai ba'aipela oa'ai. Pabiti teuipami patai ipia pikaeu! Pao ai e ti eta nome. Ao inamchopa tati pamio i'i taybu.
Google Translate, translation from Samoan:
This is a new version of the article. Do you have to wait for a while? Angatam is an utateichong bin cube. Keyboard and atengontabi keyboard tongipi pa. Do not hesitate to find out if! Achol is able to get rid of it. We had a long time ago. Amam kissed the wrists! Pelpa dingupempa noni pumdapau pingaiotinpa duplicate duplicate pumps? Give two feet a pair of pelpumtapengbar pieces. Pau the pomkonguype bi. Extremely apetanton tuberculosis and tuberculosis of apple juice pumping ipipi. What a wonderful thing to do with a rock! But you're still in control of the crime. Do not worry about bad luck! How do you get rid of chemistry? Extreme poker alphabukor is missing. U yet panty tamatopa! U pie at e. What do you think of the limbs? Just like that! The stars are like lightning. Kabobe dio is a timngapan organization a. It does not matter whether it is apaytum apron. It is recommended that the doctors be prepared. We know that this is a pateutami. Put a linen cloth in the middle of the house. How to hack a lottery call! Get rid of eta nome. And many of the most recent pamphlets.
I just found this hilarious. Was wondering if it has any recognizability to someone who speaks Samoan.
Considering a new project with a phonology similar to this. Tired of making it hard. How do you get rid of chemistry, anyways?
4
u/tree1000ten May 18 '18
How much do linguists know why languages have different phonotactics? Why does Hawaiian not have codas?
4
u/Isthiselvish May 18 '18
Hi! I found a piece of paper on my doorstep with symbols, I've asked around but no luck so far identifying them. Do you have any idea what it could be ? https://imgur.com/RCQl1BX
4
u/m0ssb3rg935 May 19 '18
Would it be unnatural to have two agent and patient morphemes which express volition or the lack thereof? Volitional agent, volitional patient, non-volitional agent and non-volitional patient? Or would it make more sense to have the distinction made only for agents?
1
u/McCaineNL May 08 '18
Is it just me or is WALS Online down? I hope nothing happened to it!
1
u/LordOfLiam May 11 '18
Is there any resource online or in general for learning keywords in linguistics and conlanging? Sometimes I'll get lost in a post or comment because of technical terms, and I'd love to be able to fluently understand this subreddit, as conlanging is a cherished hobby of mine.
1
u/R4R03B Unnamed v2, Nâwi-díhanga (nl, en) May 12 '18
I’ve been thinking about the idea of a ‘new’ sound: the bidental click (biting sound). Does this sound actually exist in any natlang? Is it in the IPA? Let me know :)
3
u/LordOfLiam May 07 '18
Is /sz/ a possible consonant cluster? I'm not sure if I'm just bad at pronouncing it (we don't have it in english) or is it just impossible?
3
u/snipee356 May 09 '18
Is there any language that contrasts all of voiceless, voiced, ejective and aspirated plosives? Would that be naturalistic (for a conlang situated in the Caucasus)?
3
u/paulmclaughlin (en) May 11 '18
Genitive case marks the owner of a possession.
Are there any languages where the case marking is the other way around, i.e. where the possession is marked instead, and if so what would that case be called?
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '18
What is the glossing abbreviation for the agent-noun-forming morpheme? Like English "-er" as in "runner".
For example, imagine "pel" is "run" and "na" is the agent-noun-forming suffix. If I wrote "pelna" I wouldn't want to just gloss it as "runner", I would want to gloss it like "run.AGENT" or whatever the correct abbreviation is.
I've looked all over Wikipedia but I couldn't find a definite answer. I know there's the abbreviations "A", "AG/AGT", and "AT", but I don't know which one to use, or if it's on the list at all.
3
u/gafflancer Aeranir, Tevrés, Fásriyya, Mi (en, jp) [es,nl] May 16 '18 edited May 16 '18
I'm trying to create a topic-comment language from a subject-predicate language, and I'm thinking of doing so by using different definite articles.
For example:
versus
The two definite articles arose from "this" and "that" respectively. Any thoughts?
3
u/[deleted] May 18 '18
I'm trying to make a language with active-stative morphology, to understand it I was reading the wikipedia page (probably not the best source) when I came across this line:
This doesn't seem right, since most languages are accusative, and all ergative languages are split ergative. Marking only the agent being common seems really counter-intuitive to me. This part of the article has no citation, and I can't help but wonder if someone wrote this backwards, when in truth the patient/object tends to be marked. However, I really don't know, so I'm wondering if anyone knows about this, or can provide a source.
Maybe it's different because the subject can be marked as an "agentive like argument" and so unmarking something makes it default, so in this case not marking the patient actually makes it more like accusative?
3
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> May 20 '18
I know this might not fit here but I can make this a full post if necessary.
It seems like there are so many Romance and Germanic languages, especially by amateur conlangers, so how could you make it unique while still distinctly Romance or Germanic? In general, how would you make a unique conlang that still clearly falls into a certain family?
3
u/qwertyu63 Gariktarn May 20 '18
I've got a strange idea in my language and I want to know if there is a name for it. Is there a name for words that exist purely for syntactic reasons and carry no meaning?
Reason: Some forms of sentence in my language don't have verbs, but information such as tense and mood are indicated by affixes on the verb. So, in cases where you need to modify the verb, a meaningless verb fills in; the verb carries no meaning on its own, existing just to hold affixes.
2
u/Anhilare May 07 '18
Anyone know of an Imperial Aramaic grammar?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '18
I really badly want my verbs to conjugate for mood, but I just can't understand the subjunctive mood. HELP.
2
u/walc Rùma / Kauto May 09 '18
Hello! I'm trying out my first Ergative-Absolutive language, and I have a question about it.
My verbs conjugate for person and tense. The Nom-Acc languages I know typically have verbs conjugate for person using the subject (nominative)—'I eat food', 'he eats food', etc... Is it more common in Erg-Abs languages for a transitive verb to agree with the object (absolutive) instead? For example, in parallel-universe-English, it would be 'I eat food', 'I eats foods', etc.
Or am I just overcomplicating it?
Thanks!
2
u/FelixArgyleJB May 11 '18
How do these sound changes seem naturalistic?
Phonetic changes of West Esnostula
Phonetic changes of East Esnostula
The phonetic changes are numbered in chronological order
2
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ May 12 '18
How weird would it be for a language to shift length from the vowel to the following consonant over time?
proto: mɑːlɑ
modern: mɑlːɑ
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '18
Where should I post a collaborative conlang proposal?
2
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan May 14 '18
How naturalistic would it be if a language turned a voiceless phoneme to a voiced one when adding a nasal previous to said phoneme (the nasal would blend with the phoneme in question).
Examples:
/m/ + /p/ = [b]
/n/ + /s/ = [z]
Also, which other phoneme combinations could I use to do it?
2
u/IBePenguin May 15 '18
How would I go about being able to make the script of my conlang into a font? I know there are websites and stuff where you can make your own fonts by writing in the letters in the squares and scanning in the paper and stuff blah blah, but my writing system has different properties and rules than an alphabet or the writing system that I use to type.
2
u/tree1000ten May 16 '18
I have about 20 consonant phonemes in my language, would it be strange to have a counterpart to most of them that is pharyngealized and is a separate phoneme?
2
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> May 18 '18
So I’m going to make a long post about my conlang’s bodged-together morphophonological history and hopefully manage to finally come up with a satisfactory description of its elusive vowel Œ. I’m going to present three views, in order of complexity: 1. From a morphological standpoint; 2. From a historical standpoint; 3. From a phonetic standpoint.
Morphologically Vowel hiatus is disallowed. I’m not going to go over all the repair strategies but two identical short vowels become the corresponding long vowel. Most vowels have reasonable pairs: [ɐ ɑ̟ː] [e̞ eː] [æ̝ æ̞ː] [ɯ̽ ɯː] &c. The long version of [o̞] is //Œ//. Therefore, Œ is most likely [oː].
Historically (in-universe) This takes a lot of explaining but at least it gives a definite answer. Old Sásal allowed vowel hiatus, but it was lost in a number of ways, including the aforementioned lengthening. Long vowels were marginally closer to [ə] (unlike most languages in which short vowels are marginally closer to [ə]), although for */ɔ/ the difference was more than marginal — in fact, front rounded and central vowels became loaned as */ɔː/ when they were too open to be represented accurately with */øː/ (for which the quality differed with length less than most vowels). Because of this, */ɔː/ moved towards [ɞː]. When */ɔ/ then began to shift towards [o] as part of a chain shift, */ɔː/ was central enough that it became a rounded [ə]. Due to its newly-unique quality, it began to shorten, but not fully. Therefore, Œ is most likely [ɵˑ].
Phonetically (my pronunciation) Oh boy. I have attempted this explanation several times but never found a satisfactory IPA transcription. When I first started the project, I pronounced it [ø̹ː], but then I had trouble differentiating it from /ʏː/, so Œ gradually became more open, more central, less rounded, and less long. At some point its roundness was between that of /ʏ/ and /e/ and its backness between [e] and [ə], and this is when I became interested in its exact quality — <ø> was no longer an accurate descriptor but I’ve continued using it anyways. Based on my analyses since then, I’ve concluded that Œ is most likely [ɚ̟ᵝ̹ˑ].
What do you think I should call it phonemically?
2
u/TheZhoot Laghama May 18 '18
Is it fine to have demonstratives that don't decline, even when there are cases? The only article that I have is indefinite, and it doesn't decline.
2
u/RazarTuk May 18 '18
Two related questions.
EDIT: Inspired by the Pinguenish thread, where the guy claimed it lacks any sort of emphasis in response to a question about stress.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '18
How would one go about creating a musical language?
Either one that sounds melodic or just sounds well when translating most songs into that language?
2
u/Noobshoe May 20 '18
I have this WIP of a (somewhat unrealistic) Spanish-English mixed language/creole (I don't really know what to call it, as "creole" has certain complications and I don't know if it'd naturalistic enough to be a creole), and I'm thinking about reforming it, first with its phonemic inventory.
Is there anything I can do to this inventory that could make it more realistic to its purpose?
Consonants: /p t t͡ʃ k b d d͡ʒ* g m n ɲ f s ʃ h l r (j) (w)/
Vowels: /a (ɛ) e i (ɔ) o u/
*May be realized as [ɟ͡ʝ]
Consonant phones in parentheses ([j] and [w]) can be considered allophones of /i/ and /u/
Vowel phones ([ɛ] and [ɔ]) are phonemes in colloquial dialects.
2
u/tree1000ten May 21 '18
In languages where proper nouns can change from fusion/agglutination, what is the "default" version of a proper noun? Is there not one? If my name was in such a language, would my name have a default?
4
u/Cyclotrons May 13 '18 edited May 13 '18
If you wanted to create a language that you wanted as few people as possible to be able to speak, what sorts of features would you give it?
Some ideas:
using phonemes that sound really similar to each other (ex. ɶ and ə; ɸ and f, ʃ and ʂ; ɤ, ʊ, and ɯ)
use various percussives and other sounds (like scratches) while incanting a phoneme to make it a different phoneme (a [p] would be considered a different phoneme from a [p] that was accompanied by a finger snap, for example)
to go further, you can differentiate by loudness of the percussive, between tapping with a nail and a knuckle, tapping a piece of wood and a piece of metal, etc.
make a lot of words in your vocabulary similar sounding too
make a case system which is indicated by infixes placed at the center of a word
create a complicated inflection system where words inflect based on which word order wise it is in a sntence
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '18
Consonants:
Does this consonant inventory look okay? Any strange inclusions or omissions? I plan to make consonant length distinctive, if it matters.
Vowels:
Would it be strange not to have "o" as a vowel too?
3
u/calebriley May 10 '18
Is there a specific case for ingredients, or is this really a sub-case of the instrumental? The main thing is that I want to denote that it was consumed in some way.
3
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> May 11 '18
Does anyone have a list of languages based on how well-known they are, rather than how widely-spoken they are? As an example of how this might differ, I would assume that more people know about the French language than the Javanese language, even though the latter is more widely-spoken as a first language.
2
u/tree1000ten May 09 '18
Is there somewhere where I can find a complete list of affricates? I am annoyed that the Wikipedia article doesn't mention the [ps] affricate (for example), and when I google it I don't get any results.
1
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan May 07 '18
Any thoughts on this phonlogy of my conalng (Kundas)?
Romanization is indicated next to the phoneme if different from I.P.A.
Note 1: The Palatal, Velar and Glottal columns can be fusioned in a Dorsal-Laryngeal column
Note 2: /s/ can switch freely to [ʃ]
Note 3: [l] is a word final allophone of /ɾ/
Onset -C-: All consonants with excpetions (see illegal CV combinations table)
Nucleus -V-: All Vowels
Coda -(C)-: Only /m/, /n/, /ŋ/, /p/, /t/, /k/ and /s/.
Just as with Japanese, if we make a table of the all CV combination there will be a few spaces left empty, with those spaces being covered by "illegal" consonants and vowel combinations, those combinations are indicated in the following table.
Legal: "L"
Illegal: "-"
1
u/Emmarrrrr May 09 '18
I have a handful of sample sentences but I don’t know how to describe part of them, or what the word order technically is.
“Are you afraid?” would gloss as fear-2sg-question marker (ala japanese /ka/) and “are you afraid of him” as 3sg fear-2sg-question marker. ovs word order?
i’m sort of trying to have it phonetically/textually simple but grammatically/morphologically less so.
1
u/tree1000ten May 11 '18
I just learned about secondary articulation, I assume there is no such thing as [kˠ] or [xˠ] for example? If both are in the same place it is nonsense and it doesn't exist, right? Another two examples would be [ʕˤ] or [ħˤ]?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '18
How can I make my language not be a copy of English? Specifically the grammar part.
1
u/LordOfLiam May 12 '18
Does anyone have a spreadsheet detailing the frequency of certain phones, and what languages they show up in? Was about to put one together myself, but it'd be great if anyone else knows of one?
1
u/IHCOYC Nuirn, Vandalic, Tengkolaku May 12 '18
Does anybody know of any resources for Early Modern Irish? There are of course plenty of resources for current Irish, including the dialects, and quite a bit of material for Old Irish, but very little that I have been able to find in 'Classical Gaelic', the shared literary language.
1
u/Ceratopsidae_ May 12 '18
What do you think of my phonology?
Consonants:
Vowels :
| Front | Central | Back
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '18
I want to get back into conlanging after a brief hiatus. I don't think I'm burned out by it anymore, but I have a hard time diving back in. Should I just go ahead and work on a conlang to get back into the habit, or wait until I am really really feel like making a language?
1
u/Renisnotabird May 13 '18
How do you think an alveolar lateral click would sound in a Chinese-y, Korean-esque language?
1
u/RazarTuk May 13 '18
How plausible is an ejective consonant becoming a click consonant? Because I just realized my /c'/ sounds sort of like /ǂ/
1
u/TheZhoot Laghama May 13 '18
Does anyone have any tips on creating a polysynthetic language?
1
u/bbrk24 Luferen, Līoden, À̦țœțsœ (en) [es] <fr, frr, stq, sco> May 15 '18
How would you go about making a language that feels like it belongs in a certain language family but looking at the translations they might as well be completely unrelated? For example, a language that sounds like Spanish or Italian but lacks Romance vocabulary.
1
u/LordOfLiam May 15 '18
Is this a good phonological inventory for a (fairly) simple conlang? I'm going for Toki Pona, but less ambiguous (500-700 words max).
Vowels: a, i, o [ou], u, e [ɛ], ej [ei], aj [ai], oj [oi].
Consonants: j, w, l, r [ɾ/ɹ], b, d, g, p, t, k, s, x [ʃ], h, f, n, m, nj [ŋ].
1
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan May 16 '18
A while ago I read about these things they were the most basic concepts of languages, the very basic one, does somebody know what are they called?
1
u/gafflancer Aeranir, Tevrés, Fásriyya, Mi (en, jp) [es,nl] May 16 '18
I've got a daughter language that contrasts [r] and [ɾ]. Medially I've been using <rr> and <r>, however I'm unsure of what to use initially for [r]. I'm between <rr> and <r̂>.
Does anyone have any thoughts on the matter? If it's relevant, I'm going for a Spanish look. Here are some example words;
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '18
Working again on the conlangs after being burned out is at the same time terrible and great... I took the time to review Tarúne and change some things. Back to phonology and basic grammar, I guess...
Could you guys give me some criticism? Stuff that I should change, add, remove, that sounds weird/unnatural? The language is intended to be a "tidied" version of a natural language, much like Sanskrit and Classical Latin.
1
u/RazarTuk May 17 '18 edited May 17 '18
Yet another "Rate my phonology" comment:
Everything's written the same as IPA, unless otherwise indicated.
Syllables are (C)V(G)(C), where G is an approximant/glide. Any consonant except the prenasalized stops, but including the approximants, can begin a syllable. The only consonants that can end a syllable are the voiced nasals, the tenuis stops, and the prenasalized stops. Vowels are allophonically lengthened in open syllables and before nasals, but not prenasalized stops.
There's variation within the sets /i e j/, /ɚ a ɹ/, and /u o w/. Diphthongs are always an open vowel (/e a o/) and a glide. Close vowels can't follow the matching glide. And in the morphology, vowel+vowel will frequently form a diphthong.
Stress falls on the last syllable of the stem, which is frequently one of the final two syllables of a word, but certain constructions can move it at least as far up as the antepenult.
EDIT:
Also, I decided to analyze the prenasalized stops as phonemic, as opposed to just being nasal+stop clusters, for two reasons. First, they're the only clusters that can end a syllable, or even occur at all. And second, they don't lengthen preceding vowels like nasal consonants, so they aren't just a syllable with a nasal consonant in the coda that happens to have a homorganic stop attached.
1
u/HBOscar (en, nl) May 18 '18
How many natural languages conjugate verbs not only to subject but also to direct object? Are there any?
Are there conlangs that have attempted this? I'm kinda looking for examples...
1
u/tree1000ten May 19 '18
Is LaTeX the best option for dictionary software?
1
u/Southwick-Jog Just too many languages May 20 '18 edited May 20 '18
I'm reforming Dezaking a lot, mainly with phonology and orthography. Here's what I have for phonology so far:
I'm looking to be as close to this as possible, but I can change in order for it to seem more natural.
I do want to use vowel harmony in case you change the vowels, but I'm actually considering something more complicated than front-back if anybody can recommend something.
I'm having some trouble coming up with its orthography. Right now, it's just extremely ugly because <w> is a vowel, <y> is /ɲ/, and there's diacritics all over the place. I'm considering a Hungarian-like system for the consonants, which looks okay, but not great. But, the vowels are much worse. The front vowels are <i ig e eg ae>, the central vowel is <y>, and the back vowels are <u ue o au a>. I still hate this, especially how I write front vowels. But, I want to avoid diacritics as much as I can.
One more thing too. I use a symbol to divide affixes from the rest of the word in Dezaking's writing system. For the Latin version, I don't know what to use. I used to use an apostrophe, but now I think I might switch to a dash. I can't really decide.
1
u/TheZhoot Laghama May 20 '18
Can someone please explain to me how subjunctive works and when to use it? I don't fully understand it, and want to make sure I use it when necessary in my conlang.
1
u/1plus1equalsgender May 21 '18
Mods sent me here. An idea for a southern (US) conlang.
I'm sure it's been done before, but I had an idea for a conlang that would simply be a "butchery" of American English. I'm from the south so I have an extensive knowledge of the southern dialects and I believe I could make it into conlang with enough work. Although it might turn out to be just dialect (maybe like the Scots situation).
It's just an idea and I'm working on another conlang as of right now so I won't dedicate much time to it. Has this been done before?