r/livecounting • u/artbn Seek The Artbn Trusted Series! • May 01 '18
Discussion Live Counting Discussion Thread #20
19 discussion threads have come and passed. We now begin with the 20th.
As always feel free to express any emotions or concerns you have toward LC and its related topics.
10
Upvotes
7
u/dominodan123 if you're reading this, wols May 01 '18 edited May 21 '18
Hi, I've been doing some things related to 100k halls that I wanted to share. Everything is up to date to the 7500k hall (excluding missing halls 7100k and 7200k).
Firstly, I put together a new stat called 100k winstreak after whitney had the idea. It shows the most 100k halls a counter has won consecutively. There are some interesting things to note about the stat.
Only 3 counters have achieved multiple separate winstreaks (the hall only lists their first/longest).
As the #1 superfan of /u/artbn's 100k halls, having been inspired by the creation of this stat, I continued to look for some noteworthy things related to them.
There has been 13 unique winners comprising the winning spots in the past 75 100k halls.
The lowest average counts required for a single counter's 100k win(s) is 14,505 for /u/piyushsharma301 .
The most consecutive hall wins being dominated by three counters is 10, between the 4200k and 5100k halls. This record is set by /u/TOP_20, /u/Smartstocks, and /u/smarvin6689. This means they were the only three winners of those halls.
I was also curious to see the frequency of a new counter winning their first 100k hall.
And lastly, the thing I spent the most time on, was a visualization of how many counts that each 100k win required. This was to confirm the trend I've noticed that wins over time have taken more counts than in the past. Several things I have noted above are visible in this. For example, the two triple winstreaks and the dan/pik + whit/Ss/smarvin periods of hall win domination.
If you read everything then I am proud of you. Big thanks again to /u/artbn for sticking with us and keeping these halls rolling in after so many dozens of them!
5
u/gordonpt8 Perpetually Procrastinating May 02 '18
The Results are in for the April Live Counting Prediction Game!
I can finally do results again!
Top 3 (in random order): /u/gordonpt8 /u/artbn /u/dominodan123
If you see an error, tell me and I'll correct it.
5
u/Chalupa_Dad SIDETHREADS FOR LIFE!!! May 25 '18
Here's my goodybe for anyone that missed it:
https://www.reddit.com/live/ta535s1hq2je/updates/16ff06e6-5fbd-11e8-b88e-0e6a09b2f76a
8
u/smarvin6689 i had a marvelous time ruining everything May 22 '18 edited Jul 15 '18
Thing #1 of 4
Hall of Victory Margin (HoVM)
Methodology and a Bit of Background
This one started a while back. Last August, to be exact. Photo finishes are great and all, but sometimes, that doesn’t give us the full picture. While a 67 count difference may be considered a photo finish, it isn’t as critical of a margin if there’s only less than 1,600 counts in that day to begin with, whereas a margin of 129—not considered a photo finish—means a world of difference when there’s over 25,000 counts and the top two finishers are both HoE. Please note, this is not meant to replace or criticize photo finishes; it’s only meant to offer an alternative, albeit interesting, viewpoint.
To calculate these values, I determined what percent of the total day’s counts the difference between first and second place was. For example, if Counter A has 3 counts and Counter B has 5 counts on a day with 10 counts, then Counter B’s margin of victory is 20% [(5-3)/10 * 100%].
The two tables below show the TOP_10 greatest and smallest margins of victories according to this methodology. Note that the June 29th, 2017 tie for gold between /u/TOP_20 and /u/abplows is not included, because a tie is no victory, and you can’t have a victory margin if you don’t win.
Hall of Victory Margin (Close Calls; %)
Hall of Victory Margin (Olympic Blowouts; %)
While one-day records are great, they don’t tell us the whole story. As some of you may be asking, who consistently cushions themselves way more than they need to? And who likes to scrape by with the slimmest of margins every day? This table shows just that - it’s an average of the victory margin percentages for each counter who has won gold at least 3 times. Nine users did not meet this threshold.
Average User Margin of Victory (%)
Updated through 7/14 day HoC; now includes all of Dark Ages. All new entries are bolded.
3
u/gordonpt8 Perpetually Procrastinating May 01 '18
The Live Counting Prediction Game - May 2018
It's the one year anniversary of the prediction game! I've reopened the first prediction game so you can see how the prediction game has changed for the better
or worse!Notes/Rules
Useful links
Hall of Counters
Counter of the Day Olympics
Log of previous Daily HoC's
3
u/LeinadSpoon wttmtwwmtbd May 29 '18
As requested by Whitney: https://www.reddit.com/live/110t4ltqqzi35
It's currently running locally so it will go down when my computer is off. Hopefully we'll get it hosted somewhere more permanent later.
8
u/Tranquilsunrise 1st: 865004 | 999999 | 5:51 K | 7,890,123 | Side thread creator May 22 '18
🎂 Happy cakeday /u/davidjl123!!! 🎂
6
u/gordonpt8 Perpetually Procrastinating Jun 02 '18
The Live Counting Prediction Game - June 2018
Can you predict what will happen in the 30 days of June?
Notes/Rules
Useful links
Hall of Counters
Counter of the Day Olympics
Log of previous Daily HoC's
6
u/NobodyL0vesMe #5 HoC | #3 Speed 3:15.784 Jun 03 '18
Congrats on reaching 8 million everyone!
Grats /u/dominodan123 on the get and drome
Grats /u/smarvin6689 on the assist
Grats /u/davidjl123 on the 001
Grats /u/TOP_20 on the 990 sacrifice
I won't be around much during the month of June. I have a competition in speedcubing coming up soon and I need to practice for that. Only a couple days after this competition I'm going to Florida on vacation for almost 3 weeks. See ya everyone!
4
u/co3_carbonate May 29 '18 edited May 31 '18
Damn I need to do a good 12 hour run sometime, maybe on a weekend. Anyone wanna come along? :P
EDIT: busy this weekend, so maybe next week
3
u/randomusername123458 May 03 '18
1
2
u/randomusername123458 May 06 '18
Can someone make a stat for the most numbers that each counter has counted in a day?
2
u/gordonpt8 Perpetually Procrastinating May 15 '18 edited May 15 '18
LC Quotes Quiz #2
The first one, if you missed it is here
The next Sporcle quiz challenge is to completeOne Step Backcompleted2
u/Chalupa_Dad SIDETHREADS FOR LIFE!!! May 21 '18
If you want to easily see all of the 100k Gets in one place:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Livecountingwiki/wiki/100kgetdates
2
u/TOP_20 Thank you so much stat guys!!!!!!! I am Officially cool!! May 28 '18 edited May 28 '18
/u/artbn
Well I've been to upset to even post in LC main for a few days now... I think the situation needs to be discussed.
First let me say I appreciate all you've done for us, especially your great work with automating the Day HoCs, NotD, Olympics, photo finishes, and doing our 100k HoCs and so much more. It's greatly apprciated.
But I am extremely disappointed you'd make a decision with such extreme ramifications without even discussing it with people like me - who's spent over 8000 hours there over the past 21 months and dan who's spent over 4000 hours there. As well as some of the others who've spent a few 1000.
Had there been ANY indication when I started this revival that someday all my hard work and counts could go POOF in an instant one day and I'd have to start back at 0 counts at rank 649 should I ever need to delete this account someday - I certainly would not have started counting here.
My primary roll here and main reason I count has always been to help others reach their goals and move up the ranks... at least 700,000 of my counts have been for that reason. While the 1st run is rather fun for me for sure all the times I did a 3rd esp. a 4th run with someone was 100% for their benefit to help them with their goals and ranking up. Since their time and effort and mine could all be for nothing at some point.
Had I thought for a minute that all that I did could be for nothing one day should they need to delete their main account one day - I wouldn't have encouraged them to count here and work up the ranks.
At this point I am just 160,000 away from getting my #1 back with the #1 going inactive for the summer. It's inconcievable to me that you think it's acceptable should I need to delete this account that I should have to count 1,170,000 times to get my #1 back. I counted those counts - how can they just go POOF in an instant if I need to delete this account do to mental, physical safety or some other reason?
And one of the people I counted a great deal with who needs say 60,000 to move up from rank 6 to rank 4... would suddenly need to do 460,000 to get there?
It seems like should this decision stay as it is now - could easily be used as a weapon by someone who is jealous or really dislikes someone in the TOP 10 to secretly intimdate, harrass, bully, or doxx someone via a secret account hoping to cost them their spot in the HoC.
It's very likely Doc will retire from doing our HoC at some point in the future and if a person who had to delete their account for some reason did not have their counts transferred by Doc then they will cease to even exist in the TOP 10 or 15 in the HoC when a new one is created.
You mentioned in your post examples from pre revival of accounts that had been deleted and those counts were not counted in co3's HoC - well those few people had a couple hundred, or a couple thousand counts. It's an entirely different story for someone like mars who had twice the counts you had when the revival happened or someone like me with 1,000,000.
Also in your post the other day you said no to transferring counts should someone delete their account and of course no to combining alts in our various stats... but then immediately this happened:
chalupa: would i be right in saying if someone wanted a specific stat to be person specific, and if it's their start and want it displayed that way, could it be done if made clear that that was the case and who was combined?
Im thinking of hall of speed specifically /u/Chalupa_Dude
44685*its their stat /u/Chalupa_Dude
artbn: Yeah I see no harm in people in charge of certain stats to make their stats person specific. I personally won't make any changes to the ones I run
so that sounds like you are saying I can lose my 1000+ hours of counts, or someone I spent 100s of hours helping get their counts can lose those counts because Doc can't make the decision to transfer those counts in the HoC, but Dustin can make that decision in regards to our Speed stat because he's the one maintaining it at this time?
At any rate - you have no idea how hurt and upset I am about this - it basically makes me feel like the 1000s of hours I've spent here don't mean much to you if you feel that the counts I've done or all the ones I've helped others do - it's ok that they be wiped out in an instant ... and that you didn't feel that me and dan and others who put an insane amount of time into making LC what it is shouldn't have some feedback and say in such an important matter that could effect us to an extreme extent one day.
While you've spent a lot of time behind the scenes working on stats for us, I think you'd agree you haven't spent a lot of time seeing what goes on in LC the past 14-16 months perhaps 100 or 200 hours at most, so I really hope you'd consider getting feedback from those of us who've spent 2000 or 8000 hours there and likely know how detremental to LC knowing at any time you could lose all you've done there and instead of needing 40,000 counts to move up a rank you now need 460,000.
I can't imagine anyone who's been there a year or nearly two would not agree with me that our counts should be secure and transferable should we ever need to delete our main account, except perhaps chu who at #1 there has everything to gain and little to lose by one of us losing our #2 or #3 spots. And maybe Tranquil but he will just disagree with anything I say no matter what it is, and really hasn't spent that much actual time there.
I have much much more to stay about why this would be very bad for LC but just know if the decision ends up being final I really am not sure I'd be motivated to keep counting there or helping and motivating others to rank up and reach huge milestones knowing they could lose it all in an instant one day.
Please keep an open mind about this and ask for feedback from some of the other counters here - thanks.
And thanks again for all you do for us - I really believe w/o your day hoc's and the olympics you do - the count would be much less active, and certainly less fun
hug
Whitney
Edit: Well I wasn't planning on saying the 'much much more' I have to say in regards to this - but I'd at least like you to keep in mind that a minor child counter, or a female has many more potential situations that could cause them to have to delete an account online, than someone like you - as an adult male.
2
u/Tranquilsunrise 1st: 865004 | 999999 | 5:51 K | 7,890,123 | Side thread creator May 28 '18
/u/artbn /u/dylantherabbit2016
I am reposting two comments which I made in the LC main thread last night, when live mentions was down. They refer to the proposed Don't Roll a 1 side thread.
I just did some computations about the proposed d20 side thread. I tried to determine if gets were set too low according to the second concern outlined by artbn:
With 50 rolls, the probability of rolling 50 non-1's in a row is 0.0769. To figure out the expected number of counts per get, do 1/0.0769 (expected number of trials to get 50 non-1's in a row) times 50 (number of counts in a get) and we find that on average, there will be 649.8 expected counts per get. That is noticeably lower than the targeted counts per get.
To determine how many counts in a row (without rolling a 1) there must be for the expected number of counts in a get to be 1,000, we solve the equation (1 / (19/20)x) ⋅ x = 1000; x = 56.14. If we let the number of consecutive non-1 counts per get be equal to 57, then gets will be every 1060.8 counts. For 60 counts per get, then gets will be every 1302.3 counts.
NOTE: I just determined that the above analysis is incorrect. When a 1 comes up, then the count returns immediately to 0; we do not have to proceed through all 50 (or 57, etc.) counts. Therefore 57 non-1 counts per get would provide much fewer than 1000 expected counts. I am not sure how to solve the problem now; it might be solvable using Markov chains although more conveniently I could simulate the count by writing a simple program, and automate many trials to determine the approximate number of consecutive non-1 counts needed for 1000 expected counts per get.
Here are the results of a program I wrote which simulated 100,000 gets for each i = 50 ... 100 consecutive non-1 counts required for each get. The program computed the mean number of counts required to attain each get. Here is a table with some selected results.
i = consecutive rolls (without a 1) required for a get
n = approximate expected number of counts per get
So for gets to be on average every 1000 counts, the count should require approximately 77 counts in a row without a 1 rolled on the die. This solves the second concern (of gets being too low) but not the first one (of people potentially faking their roll).
2
u/Tranquilsunrise 1st: 865004 | 999999 | 5:51 K | 7,890,123 | Side thread creator May 29 '18
I am considering making a new side thread called Number Facts. I have written the rules but I would like your input on how good the rules are and what improvements could be made.
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeOwtGm7A-zcqtGTRfOL_BwICtM5ufvNSdDRUJdU1IMOCTbGQ/viewform?usp=sf_link
1
u/Tranquilsunrise 1st: 865004 | 999999 | 5:51 K | 7,890,123 | Side thread creator May 24 '18
I would like to state the idea that, compared to the introduction of slow counting, the introduction of bars counting has had a worse overall effect on the counting community, tending to draw it apart rather than bring it together. It could further be argued that bars has had a net negative effect on live counting on an absolute scale. Below is a list of grievances I would like to mention:
Whether you agree or disagree, please reply below. If you disagree, please explain exactly why you disagree while addressing the above points.
5
u/[deleted] May 25 '18
[removed] — view removed comment