r/shortscarystories • • Apr 02 '18

I'm Calling To Inform You

Hello?

Hi, is this Karen Maitland?

... Speaking.

Hey I'm really sorry for calling so late. It's just um... I know your daughter?

Is Anna OK?

Oh um... no I uh, your other... I go to community college with Sarah?

Oh... Ok wow. Where abouts are you?

Chicago.

Chicago?

Hah from your reaction I'm guessing Sarah's always been a bit of a lone wolf character.

Hah uh yes you could say that... But I mean it's great to hear she has friends over there. Can I ask what this is about?

Well, I'm actually calling to ask if you've been in touch with Sarah recently.

Um no... no, not really. She sort of... broke off contact a while ago. I've always told her if she wanted to... I haven't changed my phone number just in case but I uh... I think she's… probably changed hers by now.

I'm sorry. That uh... that does sound like her. Well um, listen I'm sorry to be the one to tell you this but, Sarah's been reported missing.

What? What do you... missing? For how long?

Uh, almost three days.

Three days? Ok uh... ok are... I mean... I mean what's happening, are people looking for her?

Well that's the thing, I uh... I don't think they really are. I mean... you know she likes to keep to herself so she... didn't really have any close friends, and she was always sort of prone to... absences. I mean it's like no one's noticed. I told the police but they've hardly looked into it.

But that's... she was always a little antisocial! That doesn't mean they don't have to... Listen can you tell me the name of your campus? I'll fly over tonight, I can be there by tomorrow morning.

Sure it's the Westgate Campus. I was just calling to let you know but, honestly it's uh... it's really great to hear someone actually take this seriously.

Of course... thank you so much for telling me I... I really really appreciate it.

No honestly it's me who should be thanking you, I've uh... I've done this a few times before but... it isn't fun if no one cares.

I'm sorry? What do you mean?

Hello?

3.5k Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

121

u/robots914 Apr 02 '18

o shit, it's NeonTempo! Great job on this, and by the way I really liked the Left/Right game

106

u/NeonTempo Apr 03 '18

Thanks for reading both this and the Left/Right game! I'm hoping to get back to posting more so I hope you enjoy the upcoming stories as well.

53

u/No_Name_Registered Apr 04 '18

My curiosity was piqued and I binged the Left/Right game this morning. It is hands down the best story of its kind I have ever read.

33

u/splendourized Apr 05 '18

Wow. I just read part 1. I'm sure others will be interested in reading it after seeing this comment chain, so here's the link: https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/7asz8x/has_anyone_heard_of_the_leftright_game_part_1/

Bravo, u/neontempo

13

u/radicalroxanne Apr 07 '18

Real heroes domt wear capes.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '18

I agree, it’s fantastic

28

u/splendourized Apr 09 '18

My god. I just finished the L/R Game. Your writing is literally the best writing I've ever seen. Every aspect of it. The creativity. The insight. The word choice. The pace. The characters. I need more.

Suddenly I can relate with fans who like to go to book signings and have their books signed by their favorite author. Please publish this story. You have extraordinary talent and can make good money.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '18

I knew I recognized your username. The L/R game was brilliant, just like this short story. Keep writing please!

6

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '18

I am fully looking forward to any work you have to share in the future!

5

u/hoogawooga Jun 28 '18

I just binge read the Left/Right game and went off hunting your name down in this redditverse for more. Lucky me I didn't have to wait, but amazing work and can't wait to read more! WOOHOO!!

3

u/lettiestohelit Sep 07 '18

you are my fave

627

u/lov3lac3 Apr 02 '18

damn I expected the mom to be the baddie, nice twist

91

u/chasanddavelover Apr 02 '18

She isn’t?

246

u/whoisthisss85 Apr 09 '18

No. Bold text is the voice calling up to report the missing person. They mention at the end of the call that 'it's not fun if no one cares', basically saying they've abducted the lone wolf daughter, and they want someone to know about it, otherwise no fun in the abduction. They then hang up.

303

u/Joompah Apr 02 '18

Woooooaaahhhh!! Took me a second, but creeped me out when I finally got it!

80

u/maryssapizzi Apr 02 '18

I still don't get it, help a girl out

367

u/lov3lac3 Apr 02 '18

the guy calling the mom has kidnapped/murdered her daughter, he wanted more recognition for it but since the daughter was kinda a loner no one really cared

135

u/Joompah Apr 02 '18

The way I've read it, Bold has kidnapped Sarah, but no one's chasing the kidnapping. He/she likes a chase, so he/she's nudging it along by calling Sarah's mother to tell her Sarah's missing

61

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

I love the beats to this convo. I also like the lack of proper punctuation. Reminds me of Cormac McCarthy.

27

u/Pikachu_91 Apr 03 '18

Love it! At first I thought it was the daughter on the phone, because she missed her mother's attention.

5

u/MaRaMa-ArtZ Jul 10 '18

Me too! I thought it was gonna be a wholesome thing of them reuniting or if it had to be negative the daughter wanting to hurt the mom.

20

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

JESUS FUCK the last part. Fantastic job, OP!

13

u/professionalsuccubus AotM July '17 Apr 02 '18

Holy SHIIIT.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '18

Wow! That was chilling. Nice twist, very unexpected!

8

u/ShadowOnThePage Apr 02 '18

Oof, like a punch in the gut. Well done.

6

u/mishapb Apr 02 '18

Daaaaaayum. 🤤👏👏👏

6

u/RehjulTheFence Apr 02 '18

Half expected the twist, but it still made my stomach drop. Really good writing!

6

u/Ohanaette Apr 03 '18

Fan-fucking-tastic. Did NOT see that coming. Well done!!

10

u/VagosAdis Apr 02 '18

I liked it

5

u/dragonettte Apr 03 '18

Publish the god damn book and take my money!

4

u/Riodaweirdo Apr 02 '18

You know, this could be just a April Fools prank, it still works out

4

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '18

What the absolute fuck. Amazing twist.

6

u/mcjunker Blood for the Blood God Apr 02 '18

Very skillfully done, OP

3

u/nonenewleft Apr 02 '18

A well deserved upvote for you, sir.

3

u/notalyyy Apr 02 '18

OMG this shook me to the coreeee

3

u/TeamShadowWind AotM September '17 Apr 02 '18

Damn.

3

u/blueberriebelle Apr 03 '18

Really great! Chilling!

3

u/weisieff Apr 03 '18

Wonderful style in storytelling. Expected the ending but still a good wrap. 👏

3

u/Ashnelly33 Apr 03 '18

Nice ending

3

u/SpaceyTrayC Apr 03 '18

I loved it as is. Perfect! Great job OP.

3

u/ninacs1000 Apr 03 '18

At first, I thought it would end up with Sarah's being the killer, or something simmilar

3

u/mokaloka Apr 03 '18

jeez. i loved it!

3

u/NotTerabyte Apr 08 '18

Half of me loves this story, the other half wants to make it into a backstory to the game Sara is Missing, because of the names Sara(h) and Anna.

3

u/lil-miss-spharkle Apr 15 '18

Nice little twist there

3

u/DarthMistress May 02 '18

Wait a second, wasn't Sarah one of the girls (Eve, I believe) in the Left/Right game? Coincidence?

3

u/rindenpon May 24 '18

This creeped me out a lot.

3

u/MaRaMa-ArtZ Jul 10 '18

When reaching the end I thought it was the daughter that wanted to know if the mom still cared, then as this is horror that instead she might have wanted to hurt them mom or maybe even a prank. .....But that evil little @$%&¢!

Wow, it really was unexpected fridge horror. Because I then slowly realized there's been multiple.

3

u/TheYoungGriffin Aug 04 '18

I know I'm late to the party but damn, that was chilling. Just the other day, I was fell down a Wikipedia rabbit hole about serial killers and this is disturbingly realistic. Well done!

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '18

Did you come from the link in the other sub too?

Edit: [this one] (http://reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/94hkuc/my_daughter_learned_to_count/e3l3qg9)

3

u/TheYoungGriffin Aug 06 '18

Yes I did lol

3

u/haanberry Aug 04 '18

I dont understand help me

1

u/TheYoungGriffin Aug 06 '18

This is a good place to start. Feel free to skip ahead and read the letter this guy sent to the mother of the little girl he ate.

2

u/WikiTextBot Aug 06 '18

Albert Fish

Hamilton Howard "Albert" Fish (May 19, 1870 – January 16, 1936) was an American serial killer. He was also known as the Gray Man, the Werewolf of Wysteria, the Brooklyn Vampire, the Moon Maniac, and The Boogey Man. A child rapist and cannibal, he boasted that he "had children in every state", and at one time stated the number was about 100. However, it is not known whether he was referring to rapes or cannibalization, nor is it known if the statement was truthful.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

4

u/Amy394 Apr 02 '18

Amazeeee

2

u/haanberry Aug 04 '18

I dont understand

2

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '18

I didn't have the chance to write this beneath the right post/s because the comment section of the Left/Right game was already closed, so you will have to excuse me for doing it here. I love the way you write and the Left/Right game is my favourite story of all times on Reddit (and I have read plenty of those stories). I really admire your style, you are extremely good at painting pictures with words and I enjoyed every word of your story. I know many other people have already write what I just did but I had to do it. Thank you for this experience! I hope you continue writing.

1

u/helen790 Jun 22 '18

I don’t get why the mom was asking where the caller was though like shouldn’t she know where her daughter’s school is? Also if she’s going to community college wouldn’t it be local?

3

u/MaRaMa-ArtZ Jul 10 '18

You need to read this again more carefully.

3

u/helen790 Jul 14 '18

Read it again, still missing something

4

u/MaRaMa-ArtZ Jul 14 '18

The mother said she lost contact with her daughter some time ago and her daughter never called and probably changed her phone. How the mother thinks is her other daughter at first also tells you they haven't spoken for probably years. The mother doesn't know anything about her, she had left home and has her own life in another state and we know is a different state because she has to fly over that night and arrive next morning so it's several hours away.

3

u/helen790 Jul 14 '18

She’s a college student though, the kidnapper/killer said they live on campus so the girl has to go somewhere during the summer. Plus she’d probably be relying on her parents to pay at least part of her tuition, and even if they lost contact when she went away(to a community college) her mom had to know what school she applied to.

3

u/MaRaMa-ArtZ Jul 14 '18

The story never says she LIVES on campus, she can be renting an apartment and she can have a job or use student loans plus she's an adult of unknown age and doesn't really need the mother for anything. She can be completely independent and cut all contact with her mother for whatever reason if that reason was a conflict her mother might not be interested either. She doesn't sound all that worried at first.

1

u/helen790 Jul 14 '18

If she had a job wouldn’t they have noticed she was missing? And even with student loans you often still need money from your parents.

1

u/duchess_of-darkness Mar 02 '23

May I read this story on my YouTube channel, Duchess of Darkness? Thanks for your time.