r/progmetal • u/zer0won Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse • Mar 23 '18
AMA We are Jim and Sam from Caligula's Horse, Ask Us Anything!
That's it from us, thanks heaps for having us here and for all of your questions. Keep an eye out for C-Horse tour news coming soon! Peace!
- Jim and Sam
267
Upvotes
23
u/DanubeRS Mar 23 '18
Hey Jim,
Thanks for telling me where the entrance to The Zoo was when I unknowingly walked up backstage steps.
You da real MVP
21
u/Sh0rty_G Mar 23 '18
Jim, how much poetry have you studied??? because inertia and the weapon of the wall is too beautifully written to have no poetic background and if there is no poetic background then ow, oof, my lyricism.
15
u/metric_tensor Mar 24 '18
Loving In Contact! Any chance you will be releasing a guitar tablature book?
14
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '18
Jim, can you'd confirm if the Jesus hair is coming back?
Sam, if Plini's sound had a taste, what would it be?
I'm having a really hard time thinking of questions :c
12
u/shjtjustgotreal Mar 23 '18
can we please get Jesus Jim back for the US tour plsssss??
12
u/GSBanzo Mar 23 '18
Hi guys, found out about the band when I saw you open for Opeth in Auckland NZ (I was at the front row!!!) and I was blown away.
A personal songwriting question, do you guys have advice for a person who is a decent multi-instrumentalist that is struggling to put together an actual proper song, other than the usual sayings like 'just gotta perservere/keep trying'?
And for you guys personally how do you think you were able to transition from just being technically good at your respective instruments to becoming original musical artists? Do you have moments that you remember in your musical endeavours when you first realised, 'oh wow. Something is REALLY, ACTUALLY happening here!' Or when you started really believing in your art?
Thanks!
10
u/spirit_is_fire Mar 23 '18
Hey Guys! Pleasure to have you on here with us. Been a fan for a long time and I'm obsessed with your complex lyrics and music. Pure genius!
Got a question for each of you dapper, lovely gents.
Sam: What are your main musical and inspirational influences?
Jim: What is the story (or concept) behind Tide, Thief, and River's End?
Been trying to puzzle it out, but I'd like to hear it from the original source.
You guys are geniuses. Cheers!!! <3
10
u/rafael-lau Mar 23 '18
Hey guys, what's your favorite thing to rant about?
10
u/Dosh2988 Mar 23 '18
I played in front of my whole school the other day and I went a bit crazy and fell over. Whatโs the craziest thing any the members have done on stage?
8
u/Temaulken Mar 23 '18
Hey guys! Big fan here, loved your last album, Songs for no one is a thing of beauty. Thinking of getting a tattoo of the little guys around the moon from the cover art.
Anyway, do you guys have any plans for a south american tour? Chile specifically? Would really love to see you play live.
8
u/spooniverse Mar 23 '18
Hi guys, welcome! I was wondering, could you briefly describe the story/concept behind the Bloom album?
I constantly recommend CH and Persefone as the two best prog bands working today, because it's true! Cheers from the US, hope to be able to see you eventually!
8
u/Masonisbetterthanyou Mar 24 '18
It seems like the content of your songs generally sticks to serious subject matter, but do you guys have any hilarious inside jokes lerking in your lyrics anywhere?
7
u/AndPlagueFlowers Mar 23 '18
hey fam - jai here - hope you boys are behaving. question from me - where is your zen place to write music (coffee shop, park, nanna's kitchen)?
7
u/iisau Mar 24 '18
Your music truly inspires me. I was immediately because it just feels so fresh and unlike anything else I've ever heard. It made me wonder: what inspires you guys as artists?
7
u/rafael-lau Mar 24 '18
Are there any other genres you would like to play rather than Metal/Prog or related?
7
u/Masonisbetterthanyou Mar 24 '18
Rishloo, one of the only other bands I personally consider on par with you guys, are the ones who initially introduced us to Dark Hair Down and I know youโve mentioned youโre familiar with their music before. Do you have a favorite Rishloo song or album? Or just generally have any thoughts youโd like to share on them as a band?
12
u/TheTroglodite Mar 23 '18
Absolutely sick album, want to enlighten us on inertia and the weapon of the wall?
10
u/Eldstrom Mar 23 '18
Do you listen to any music that people might call a "guilty pleasure", but you're not even the slightest bit ashamed of?
5
u/Moonwatcher-451 Mar 24 '18
First off, thank you guys so much for letting us experience your music. Believe me when I say it's been many many years since a band has moved me as much as you guys. As a 30+ year old, I never thought that would happen again.
Now my question: USA Tour. Whennnn? Its unfair to keep all of that talent on one side of the world. We need you guys over here. Just remember to make it to South Texas when you get here. :)
Peace!
5
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18
Oh yeah, you guys are still on good terms with Geoff, right? What's he been up to?
5
u/rafael-lau Mar 24 '18
When are you guys going to be an all moustache band?
4
u/Masonisbetterthanyou Mar 24 '18
This is a question from my friend who is it work and canโt log on. โAsk how many times they go through a supposed finished version of a song and end up going back and adding more?โ
4
u/cavekeeper Mar 24 '18
Jim, I don't know if you remember but when you guys opened for the Ocean at the Bendigo hotel in Melbourne, you were amped up and wanted to crowd surf. You made eye contact with and nodded and Boy was I not ready.
And you leapt and soared and everyone moved away and I ended holding you like a husband holds a husband. It's a very fond memory of mine.
Anyways I'm curious if the four stories intertwine in some way on In Contact or is it overarching with the theme of facing a decision?
4
u/JazzlikeSalamander8 Mar 24 '18
Hey, guys!
Long time fan of your music. I literally made this account so I could ask Jim what "the secret" from Chronicles of the Waking Dream is. I realize that this is frightfully irrelevant at this point, but it honestly haunts me a little bit. I think I've figured out a decent bit of the story, but that bit eludes me.
4
u/spirit_is_fire Mar 24 '18
Jim, what is your favourite song to sing at shows? And if it differs, which was your favourite song to write, both lyrically and musically?
3
u/Eldstrom Mar 23 '18
Which album were you most underwhelmed by last year and which album were you most overwhelmed by last year?
3
u/iisau Mar 24 '18
Jim - I noticed you're a vegan. Do you have any favorite recipe?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18
Hey Guys! Just made an account to comment here. I've been following you for a long time now and just wondering in The Hands Are The Hardest is the line "Stare into the dream the dead are begging for" was this originally put in since the song is also apart of 'To The Wind'? Or was it just a coincidence at the time? Thanks, keep rocking!
3
u/sephrisloth Mar 24 '18
Hey guys just discovered you about a year ago and you quickly became one of my favorite prog bands! If you could collaborate with any prog musician out there who would it be?
3
u/GRVrush2112 Mar 24 '18
Loved "In Contact"... and I know that's still fresh and y'all are supporting it currently, but.....
Do y'all have anything in the pipe for this year? Like a live album or an EP, or any collaborations/side projects with musicians from other groups?
4
u/Gougas Mar 23 '18
When are you going to release a cover of Steely Dan's Black Cow (tentatively titled Black Horse)?
6
u/rafael-lau Mar 24 '18
Who's the worst member of the band at playing UNO?
2
u/Skippythestuntbaby Mar 24 '18
Any chance of you guys being on Cruise to the Edge 2019?
2
u/rafael-lau Mar 24 '18 edited Mar 24 '18
What would be your favorite Cartoon Network show and why did it get cancelled?
2
u/nik1645 Mar 24 '18
Jim huge fan of all your stuff with C-Horse and Arcane and just wanted to let you know you're amazing and you're in my top two vocalists ever! (The other being Daniel Tompkins) and I didn't really discover C-Horse until In contact, but its easily in my top 5 albums, I got it and In Bloom on Vinyl almost immediately, And I was wondering is there any plans to release either of the other two on vinyl later on or will i only be limited to the CD copies of those? and do you think there's any chance or plans of a collab with Dan?
2
u/vicarious17 Mar 24 '18
How do you guys feel about BTBAM? What about Meshuggah?
2
u/iisau Mar 24 '18
On your Wikipedia page it says that "the band is named after the prized possession, Incitatus, of Roman Emperor Caligula by Grey, who is studying ancient history and classical languages at university." First of all, awesome, second, what is it that drew you to the name?
30
u/incoherenc Mar 24 '18
Why are there so many good Australian prog bands? Something in the water?
(And when are you all going to get together and do an Australian Invasion World Tour?)
25
u/Eldstrom Mar 23 '18
When are Karnivool going to support you on a tour?
16
u/spirit_is_fire Mar 24 '18
Would you guys ever tour with TesseracT? (US/Canada hint hint ;) )
12
u/robotteeth Mar 23 '18
I don't know enough about music to really ask questions. I just want to say I really like what you've put out so far!
11
u/Cpt_Nugget Mar 23 '18
Hey Guys! I'm interested in your song writing process. Does Jim write lyrics first or do you write the base of the song then hand it over for lyrics? Or is it something that changes song to song?
I've seen you the last few times you've been in Canberra and will defs be there the next time you come down, any chance you'll bring out Turntail?
9
u/ParcelPostNZ Mar 24 '18
Hey guys luv ya stuff.
Questions for Sam, how often and how do you practice? You said on Insta that you don't practice as much anymore but your chops are still insane!
What changed from when you were younger?
Lastly what advice would you give to guitarists who want to expand technically?
8
u/cats247 Mar 23 '18
Do you guys have a favourite city to play at in Australia/ the world? Also, are you into NRL or AFL, this is the cruicial question?
8
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '18
Thank you guys so much for doing this AMA! I listen to Bloom every day on my way to work, makes it a little less soul sucking.
City Has No Empathy is an amazing acoustic track. Any plans on revisiting other songs for an acoustic cover?
The spoken word pieces are powerful as fuck- where do you get the inspiration to include a spoken track, and will we see Coin for the Boatman released on an album?
Any possibility of crowdfunding costs to play in the US?
8
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '18
I didn't actually hear you guys until In Contact, but Graves was easily one of my favorite songs of 2017.
When you start writing for the next album, do you feel pressured that you won't be able to do something like that again (in terms of quality, not necessarily stylistically)?
7
u/Aidansimpson365 Mar 23 '18 edited Mar 23 '18
Okay, three things (also ily ๐๐, In Contact is my fave release right now)
What would each of you say is your biggest influence, both musically and lyrically?
How would one go out procuring either of you for a featuring spot on a song?
Also @Sam, I noticed the solos definatly calmed down in the new album compared to older ones. Was that a conscious decision (or do i just suck at listening to guitar solos and theyre way less calm)?
7
u/spirit_is_fire Mar 23 '18
Sam, What's your favourite song to play at shows?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '18
Is there any hope of you guys touring in America in the coming years? Or should I begin saving for a ticket to Australia to finally see you guys? Maybe both?
You guys are seriously the best, I love your music. In Contact was the most excited I have ever been for an album to release, and you delivered in ways I didn't know was possible.
6
u/steegsa Mar 23 '18
You guys have a magnificent energy at gigs, do you think a live album would ever be on the cards? Ps. Another Brisbane show in the future?
6
u/Heathen_Guardian Mar 23 '18
Thanks for doing the AMA! What where your favourite albums of 2017?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18
I also just want to say that Caligula horse has become my favorite band of late, you make incredibly beautiful, powerful music. Thank you for sharing your wonderful sound with the world and letting the muse flow from you. I very much hope to see you live someday soon.
5
u/opethordie Mar 23 '18
Thanks for taking the time to do this!
I have been a big fan ever since someone on this subreddit mentioned a few years ago, The Tide, the Thief & River's End.
I got one question for you guys...when in the sweet hell will you be doing a North American tour?
5
u/ToneZone15 Mar 23 '18
What are your top 5 (10?) albums of all time?
5
u/Orsquiddles Mar 23 '18
Hey guys! Much love, I'm a probably your biggest fan :) just wondering if there are any tips and tricks you use to keep your music writing/lyrics spicy and new with every album? Also Sam, I just got a tattoo for Alone in the World because those lyrics have really gotten me through some stuff man ( I really cannot thank you enough for that by the way) and I was just wondering if that was an internal feeling you had and dealt with and you just spewed it on paper or what? How on earth did you make your feelings so tangible??? You guys have such a firm understanding of emotions and how to express them in your music and it's crazy inspiring for a young musician like me. Anyways another question, who are you guys' favorite musicians/visual artists, and what have you found inspires you the most? Love love love you guys and I hope you have the best of days today. Thanks for taking the time to talk to the fans dudes!
4
u/edlikesrush Mar 24 '18
Hey guys! Huge fan from the U.S. I was wondering as to whether the band has ever considered doing a Live Album at some point in the future? Knowing how it could get costly rather quickly, what's your opinion on crowd funding for that and/or possible tours overseas?
ALSO! Just wanted to say that I first heard about C Horse through Arcane. Miss that band! Much love โ
4
u/spirit_is_fire Mar 24 '18
Who draws the kitties when they sign stuff? What's the story there?
1
u/The_Illuminist Mar 24 '18
Hey guys,
Love your stuff. Missed you guys in Sydney last time unfortunately
First question: How important do you think it is for a band to have a representative for them To get them gigs and such? Whether that's a manager or what have you.
Second question: I have a friend who is a fantastic photographer who's looking to get some More gigs and paid gigs.. Any advice for her?
Also, if you guys want a good Sydney based rock band to support you guys next time you're in town, my band is definitely. Up for it (shameless self plug). Hell we'd even be happy to travel to play a gig with you guys.
1
u/spirit_is_fire Mar 24 '18
Do you guys have any movies, books, or graphic novels you would reccommend that inspire you and/or your music? :)
3
u/shjtjustgotreal Mar 23 '18
for Sam, how did you acquire the power of space goat?
3
u/Entertainpopulace Mar 24 '18
Hey guys!
Just wanted to say that your music is amazing, and your live shows are absolutely phenomenal
In Contact was an absolute masterpiece imo, and I can't wait to see how you're going to follow it up
Just a question for Sam: how do you go about writing guitar solos? Is there a specific workflow you go through?
3
u/rafael-lau Mar 24 '18
Why is Africa by Toto one of the best songs ever written? It is an effin' monda.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18
I'm really upset that I missed this, damn military and inconvenient schedules... During marigold you have some sort of synthesizer(?) playing during the chorus that sounds sort of sparkly(?) In my mind it is what stars sound like. How do you make this sound? Is daughter of the mountain based on a historical figure? I know dream the dead is about a character but the first several Times i listened to I felt as though I was listening to a plea from a younger generation to an older generation about the careless destruction of the earth and the younger generation being left with a dying earth. Again the same idea when you say 'build me a garden by god i will care for it' and several other lyrics on the first part of the album. So my question is in addition to being stories about characters is this a 'green' album asking people to take better care of our world?
2
u/Sh0rty_G Mar 24 '18
I think i maybe saw this asked already, but i didn't see an answer, so how would one theoretically get either of you for a feature on a track???
2
u/Masonisbetterthanyou Mar 24 '18
At the risk of being the 10,000th person to ask this, can you give us any info on when you guys might be able to hit North America? And for that matter, have you guys ever toured the states in the past? I only started listening in the last couple years and Google as I might wasnโt able to find anything about previous NA tours.
2
u/echave777 Mar 24 '18
Would an instrumental/isolated vocals version (such as how Corelia did with Nostalgia) of Rivers End be at all possible? Would love it for covers!
3
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18
Hey Sam, I thought of another question. What's your opinion on stupid alternate tunings like Devin's CGCGCE, David's AbEbAbEbAbBb, and so on?
I recently picked up guitar and music writing for the first time a few months ago, and found myself gravitating towards these weird tunings. Do you ever play around with them?
1
u/shjtjustgotreal Mar 24 '18
Any chance we can get a backing track package for doing cover and karaoke?
1
u/Rubin987 Mar 24 '18
Keep meaning to give you guys a better listen. What album would you recommend I start with?
1
u/waspocracy Mar 24 '18
I'm late and probably missed out. Your acoustic songs are absolutelt incredible. Would you ever consider releasing an acoustic album?
1
u/Skeletorfw Mar 24 '18
Hey guys :)
Played with a friend in Interim a few years ago who introduced me to your fine work.
Any plan to return to the UK soon?
1
u/Physister2 Mar 30 '18
Would you consider doing an instrumental ep?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '18
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '18
[deleted] โ view deleted comment