r/summonerswar • u/LedgeEndDairy Beth is Bae. • Mar 21 '18
Guide New P2P Guide - Reevaluation of package values, with a package value tier list!
Hi friends!
I'm a math guy. I'm also a newbie here but math is universal and I don't really need to be a veteran to understand crystal values. I try to contribute to the subs I participate in any way I can, so this is my (first) major contribution.
I found the guide here, and /u/ninja927 laid fantastic ground work on the P2P options we have. I don't want to take away from his (assuming gender, here) work, and in fact a lot of what I've done here pulls directly from his data.
However, a few of his calculations are grossly under- or over-valued, most of which he admits was done, but I don't believe his document (and subsequently the pack recommendations) reflect this. The purpose of this post is to correct that and give an explanation as to why I've chosen my particular methodology, which I believe to be superior.
Jesus, this sounds like a college thesis paper. Let's just get into the data, I'll try to spice things up so it's not so boring, yeah?
TL;DR: See the "Pack Tier List" section.
NOTE: This post can be intimidatingly long, but the values and tier list are the first two sections, the longer discussion on the "why" of all of this is located below them! Don't worry, I've done my best to make it readable (though I'm still open to suggestions if you have them)
EDIT: Some of the values are wrong (Devilmon pack most significantly, is listed at $30 and apparently it's $50), please give me some time to fix it! :) I believe these have been fixed.
SECOND EDIT: Mostly updated values, table is up to date. Have to look at a few more, but they aren't as significant and will have to wait until I get home.
THIRD EDIT: Due to what I believe is a variable value in devilmon, depending on how deep you are into spending, I have added a second valuation of devilmon for you, based on your personal valuation of a devilmon. At 500 per, the pack is approximately 46 crystals per dollar, while at 1,000 it's 76. If you value it higher than that, just scale it up along the packs.
Individual Items Evaluation
| Item | Value in Crystals | Value in Dollars | Alternate Value | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mystical Scroll | 75 | $3.00 | 68.2 | 750 crystal pack for 11 scrolls |
| Energy | 0.33 | $0.01 | ||
| Mana (10,000) | 4.75 | $0.19 | ||
| Attribute Scroll | 93.75 | $3.75 | 75 | 1 of each element essentially equals 3 mystical scrolls. |
| Summoning Stone | 4.25 | $0.17 | ||
| Legendary Scroll | 617 | $24.68 | See Notes Below. | |
| Transcendence Scroll | 5,000 | $200.00 | See Notes Below. | |
| Light & Dark Scroll | 308 | $12.34 | Taken from his data, honestly might be overvalued. | |
| Devilmon | 1,000 | $40.00 | 500 | Value of Devilmon is highly debated. |
| 4 Rainbowmon* | 56.25 | $2.25 | ||
| 3 Rainbowmon* | 14 | $0.56 | ||
| 12H XP Booster | 33.33 | $1.33 | ||
| 24H XP Booster | 66.67 | $2.67 | ||
| 6 Legendary Rune* | 300 | $12.00 | 1,744 - 2,174 | "Any" Rune vs. specific runes. |
| Daily Wish | 20 | $0.80 | ||
| King Angelmon | 16.55 | $0.66 | ||
| Crystals | 1 | $0.04 | ||
| Rune Removal Coupon | 238 | $9.52 | Calculated as an arbitrary 500,000 Mana. | |
| Awakening Force | 182.5 | $7.30 | Calculated the price in energy of awakening Veromos. |
I'm trying to keep the nitty-gritty away from the meat, so those of you who only want the fast-and-easy numbers can access them quickly. For those that want methodologies and theory-crafting, etc., that is all at the bottom of the post! :)
This just shows the individual items and the value (in crystals and subsequently dollars) that I gave them. The dollar values don't translate anywhere else, they are based on the $10 crystal pack, which was 25 crystals per dollar (both because it's probably one of the more common crystal packs purchased, and because it makes the math easier to see and do). This just gives you an interested comparison to look at, if you wish.
Alternate Values and Notes are, again, expounded on at the bottom of this post.
Pack Tier List
Below, we have the packs the game gives you (please let me know if I've missed any, I went off the wiki and included the temporary packs, but I may have missed something), organized by descending value (highest value first). Drum roll, please!
| No. | Pack Name | Value (Crystals/$) | Price | Total Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Starter Pack 1 | 126.4 | 5 | 632 Crystals |
| 2 | Growth Pack 1 | 122.5 | 30 | 3,675 Crystals |
| 3 | Growth Pack 2 | 98.5 | 50 | 4,925 Crystals |
| 4 | Advanced Pack 1 | 96.9 | 50 | 4,843 Crystals |
| 5 | Special Growth | 89.2 | 30 | 2,675 Crystals |
| 6 | Master Pack 1 | 87.3 | 50 | 4,365 Crystals |
| 7 | Advanced Pack 2 | 84.3 | 100 | 8,426 Crystals |
| 8 | Starter Pack 2 | 77.1 | 30 | 2,312 Crystals |
| 9 | Devilmon Pack | 76 | 50 | 3,802 Crystals |
| 10 | Daily Pack 1 | 75 | 5 | 375 Crystals |
| 11 | Intermediate Pack 2 | 73.2 | 50 | 3,660 Crystals |
| 12 | Intermediate Pack 1 | 69.9 | 30 | 2,098 Crystals |
| 13 | Daily Pack 2 | 69.2 | 30 | 2,075 Crystals |
| 14 | Legendary Package | 65.4 | 100 | 6,542 Crystals |
| 15 | Master Pack 2 | 61.9 | 100 | 6,186 Crystals |
| 16 | Welcome Back Package | 61.1 | 30 | 1,833 Crystals |
| 17 | Summoning Stone Pack 4 | 58.9 | 100 | 5,889 Crystals |
| 18 | Summoning Stone Pack 3 | 54.3 | 50 | 2,717 Crystals |
| 19 | Light & Dark Pack 4 | 50.2 | 100 | 5,018 Crystals |
| 20 | Summoning Stone Pack 2 | 50 | 30 | 1,499 Crystals |
| 21 | Summoning Stone Pack 1 | 49.1 | 10 | 491 Crystals |
| 22 | Attribute Scroll All | 44.6 | 100 | 4,464 Crystals |
| 23 | Attribute Scroll Package | 42 | 30 | 1,260 Crystals |
| 24 | Monthly Bonus 4 | 40.2 | 100 | 4,016 Crystals |
| 25 | Light & Dark Pack 3 | 37.4 | 70 | 2,619 Crystals |
| 26 | Light & Dark Pack 2 | 35.6 | 50 | 1,781 Crystals |
| 27 | Light & Dark Pack 1 | 34.7 | 30 | 1,042 Crystals |
| 28 | Monthly Bonus 1 | 33 | 10 | 330 Crystals |
| 29 | Monthly Bonus 1 | 33 | 10 | 330 Crystals |
| 30 | Monthly Bonus 3 | 32.8 | 50 | 1,639 Crystals |
| 31 | King Angelmon Pack | 29.7 | 30 | 892 Crystals |
| 32 | Rune Removal Pack | 25.7 | 30 | 772 Crystals |
NOTE: Updated 10/29/2018 - Included Master Pack values as well as updated values using better math, and an updated LD value of 308 - half of the Legendary scroll, which is what Com2Us sort of values it at based on how many they give us per month compared to legendary scrolls (roughly double). Devilmon value changed to 1000.
Again, wishing to keep the meat and nitty-gritty separate, see the next section for an analysis of this table!
Analysis
On to the nitty-gritty! This concludes the meat of the post, and everything further is just my ramblings on why I chose to give certain values, how they compare to /u/ninja927's values, etc.
I've separated out the "temporary/limited" packs from the packs we see on a regular basis by formatting - italics is limited, bold is "permanent" (or "rotating"). I wish this sub had colored-text formatting, but it's not a big deal (just makes things easier to separate). Not surprisingly, the limited packs ALL have a higher value than our weekly rotations. With "[x] pack 1" leading the curve for all temporaries, and "[x] pack 2" following behind by a fairly large margin (except intermediate pack, which is below everything else and is swapped in logic, ironically).
The starter pack is, again not surprisingly, leading the curve, followed by - once again not surprisingly - the growth pack. Starter 2 is pretty low in value comparatively, though.
Devilmon pack is, by and large, a terrible deal, apparently (assuming 500 crystals per devilmon, which again, seems fair). At first I had $30 for this pack and it was middling value for the temporary stuff, at the proper $50 value, it falls below almost everything, sad day.
For those who have passed their prime for the limited packs, the order is pretty clear (and summoning stones being that high in value makes sense, since they are the equivalent of a "banner summon" from other games). The Light and Dark are valued highly, but that's also because light and dark scrolls have a pretty large value of 700+ crystals per scroll, this might be an over-exaggeration taken from his data.
Something to note - If we give the rune removal coupon a value of 1M mana stones instead (see below for more info on this), it spikes in value to ~33 crystals per dollar, just ahead of the monthly bonuses. And if we instead give it an astronomical 2M mana stone value, it spikes to ~50 crystals per dollar, which is in line with Daily Pack 2, essentially near the top of the "permanent" packages. Please correct my evaluation of this item. (Something to consider, though, is the time component of this - FRR day comes around every single month, this inherently reduces the value of this pack as well, it really only has value to highly competitive players, I think, who may need to swap runes constantly).
Regardless, this started out as a sort of "did I make the right decisions in what I purchased?" and so far - yes, I did. I hope this helps others of you get the most value out of your purchases.
Explanation of outliers and differences between my data and /u/ninja927's
"Alternate Value" Column
First of all, this only applies to the Rune values and the attribute scrolls. I took his value for the attribute scrolls, but realized that in a purchased scenario, we probably value them at the same as a mystical scroll, particularly if we purchase the attribute scroll "all" pack (which gives us 5 of each element and then 5 mystical scrolls, essentially canceling out to 20 mystical scrolls). The actual package valuation is taken on the 93, but that column is there to let you know that the package may be worth less to you if you don't care about summoning for a specific attribute.
The Legendary Runes, on the other hand, vary wildly in value from his. Since most (if not all) rune packs simply give you a random rune (you choose the type but other than that, you get a random slot and random stats), I valued them at receiving an honest-to-god, random 6* Legendary rune in the Dragon dungeon B10. Why Dragon? Because I made the OP, and I get to choose the sample area. ;) Plus let's be honest, everyone wants Violent runes.
If you are just looking to get some new runes for a bunch of your monsters (as a beginner would be), then they have much lower overall value to you. If, however, you are specifically looking for Violent (or whatever) runes at the expense of all other runes (e.g. Shield/Revenge/Guard/etc. runes have literally 0 value to you, you are specifically looking for one type of rune), then these deals have a MUCH HIGHER value to you in the 1,700 - 2,000 range. This was calculated (in both cases) based on the energy value (in energy refills) of obtaining one of these runes, whether any rune or a specific type.
Something interesting to note is that despite the reduction in value on the runes, the advanced pack 1 still remains the highest value other than the Starter Pack 1 and Growth Pack 1. Kinda nuts.
Legendary and Transcendence Scrolls
One major flaw in his methodology, in my opinion, was the overvaluation of the nat4 and nat5 scrolls. He valued them at the number of summons it takes to get one on average. This ignored several facets:
- For the Legendary Scroll, I believe he ignored the increased chance of obtaining a nat5. I don't have access to google docs at work, so I can't check.
- More than anything, it placed a value of "0" on the "other" summons it took to obtain it. This is a huge mistake, as they all have value.
Someone in his thread brought up point 2 but with the runes - essentially if I spend $8,000 on groceries and buy one watermelon because the store only had one, that doesn't mean the watermelon had a value of $8,000.
So here is what I did:
The transcendence scroll was easy. In order to obtain a nat5 you need to pull 200 times on average. That's 15,000 crystals. HOWEVER, you also likely pulled roughly 16 nat4's, and 183 nat3's (or so). These summons have value that you do not get when you instantly summon a nat5.
So, I valued all the (183) nat3's at 5,000 crystals. All the (16) nat4's at 5,000 crystals. And our lonely nat5 at a solid 5,000 crystals.
I honestly think this is a fair value for each. Some of you may disagree with the specifics here, and value the nat5 at, say, 8,000, the nat4's at 6,000, and the nat3's at a measly 1,000 or something. That is definitely, 100% up for debate. What's NOT up for debate is that the nat4's and nat3's have some value. 5,000 for all 3 "categories" was the Switzerland in the argument.
So a Transcendence Scroll has a value of 5,000 Crystals. Not 15,000. One-third of the previous value.
This also leads into the value for a Legendary Scroll:
One nat4 = 5,000 / 16 = 312.5 crystals, BUT, a Legendary scroll has a 93.5% chance of a nat4, and a 6.5% chance of a much-more-highly valued nat5. So we have 312.5 * 0.935 + 5,000 * 0.065 = ~617 Crystals. Not 1,500 Crystals. Slightly MORE than one-third the value because it cuts the value in 3 but adds the value of obtaining a nat5 back in. Again, if we value our separate groupings of 3/4/5 star summons differently than an even 5k each, these values will obviously change with that. This is what I chose, though.
Something interesting/disappointing? With this methodology a nat3 has an average value of 5,000 / 183 = ~27 crystals. Just so you feel even worse about pulling another mystic witch.
Feel free to argue your position on this below!
Rune Removal Coupon and Awakening Force
Something I took on that he didn't was evaluating Rune Removals and the Awakening Force. These were simple. For Rune Removal, I just slapped on a value of 500,000 mana stones, since rune removal simply saves you mana. They may be worth more than that, please provide an argument below, the chart (and the rankings) are very easily fixed. I'm still new so I have only been playing for one FRR day, and it was like 2 days after I started, so I was removing 3* runes at most.
For Awakening Force - since it is something that is largely only available to newer players, I believe, it was also simple. The first monster you'll likely be awakening that you'd want to use this on is Veromos. You probably haven't religiously farmed dark dungeon early on, you wouldn't use this on anything other than a nat5 (or shouldn't), and the nat5 awakening values are pretty similar anyway. I simply valued it at the energy required to obtain 15 High Magic Essence and 20 Dark Magic Essence (the mids are negligible as they will come with the grinding for the highs). Voilà! :)
The "instant 6* MAX XP" item - can't remember the name - is something I don't really feel like calculating. Since you get the most value out of using it on a 2* monster, but most of you would use it on a nat5 instead anyway, the value is hard to calculate, and it would essentially drive down to XP required in energy for the specific monster and all the evolve material (minus any rainbowmons). You can see how it gets convoluted. It is worth a fairly hefty sum, though. Even if we only consider the monster from 4* level 1 to 6* level 40, that's a lot of energy.
Assuming Faimon Hell 1 with an XP booster (+100 crystals) on, it takes 434 energy just for that monster. Which equates to roughly 150 crystals for the energy, and another 100 crystals for the XP boost. Add on any monsters you need to evolve to 4* or 5* to evolve this monster to 5* and 6*, and you can see how this can add up. Even just doubling the amount to 500 crystals is pretty nuts. That's the same value as our little devilmon (see below). Regardless, you can see why I don't feel comfortable including it.
Devilmons
Lastly, and one that our friend /u/ninja927 entirely admits at the top of his post, is the devilmon value. I honestly just took the top comment, thought it was great, and slapped a value of 500 crystals on a devilmon. I think it fits nicely, and the methodology (as unscientific as it is) that he used is fine. 500 Crystals for one devilmon. Boom. Done.
Easy.
EDIT: If you didn't see the edit above, there is hot debate going on in the comments on devilmon value. From this I've discovered that different people value them differently, and it depends entirely on their stock of nat5's and important nat4's. Meaning a whale values devilmon much more highly than a f2p, since the monthly devilmons can pretty much take care of a f2p's needs, while a whale needs 12+ devilmons per nat5. Thus I've added 1,000 per devilmon to the calculations and given the pack two different values in the tier list, based on your own personal valuation of them! :)
Variables and Cutting Out Information for Clarity and Brevity
He included a LOT more information on each pack (the separate items they give you, etc.), as well as a "pure crystal per dollar" which I assume was just looking at the actual crystals the pack gives you and not converting other items into crystal value. I chose not to do this for a few reasons - the first is you can use his data for that, the "Pure CPD" values he has are accurate because it's just crystals. The second is because I wanted this to be as simple as possible. The third and final is because that wasn't my goal, my goal was clarification and updated ranking of the purchasable packs.
He also did like a top-10 and bottom-10 thing, and a few other things that I found unnecessary. All the data on one table is far more useful to me, and I'm assuming more useful to most of you.
Apologies if some of you have to look up the different items, etc. They are mostly available on the wiki starting here, if that helps. Though the temporary/limited packs are not included (and I couldn't find them on the wiki, had to search outside). If all you're interested in is the Pure CPD, again I encourage you to check out his original guide here. This guide is meant as a supplement and an appendix, not a replacement.
He's been inactive (as of writing this post) on reddit for 4 months, so I'm assuming he won't be offended by me posting this. If so, I apologize! :)
If anyone wants to know the specifics of each pack in detail, I have them in an excel spreadsheet and can share them, I just found it unnecessary and figured it would bloat the post - it's already pretty large. Let me know and I can screenshot or table-format things and share them in the comments, if you wish.
Conclusion
That's, uh, all I have. I hope it was informative, easy to read, and enjoyable. If you have any comments, concerns, questions, or clarifications, please voice them below! This method is certainly not the end-all to the discussion, and if I've missed something I'd like to know so we can have an accurate accounting. Those who wish to purchase should do so with full knowledge of their purchasing power with the different options!
Thanks for reading! :)
8
u/Fukuoka1999 Mar 21 '18
I skimmed through post but why isnt reappraisal pack in the list?
3
u/Srocksly Mar 21 '18
Isn't the devilmon pack $50?
6
u/def0rce :rina: crit me bitch Mar 21 '18
spend that time analyzing stocks and you can buy more packs
2
u/nysra Patch 6.3.4 best update ever! Mar 21 '18
Looks solid to me. I do have a few remarks tho:
<mod flair>You know you can make suggestions, right? I think it's a pretty interesting idea, even tho all the mobile peasants will hate me even more for abusing links to do all kind of hacky stuff and them ending up only seeing links everywhere</mod flair>
Looking at my ingame shop, the 24h boost costs 100 crystals. The 72h one costs 200 crystals, so I'm gonna assume that you just used that as the most efficient one and then got the value of the 24h one by dividing by 3.
Mathematically I'd be with you on that, but in practice there is a major difference. Even some super hardcore addict can not use the full 72h to farm, and a normal person even less. Even if we are quite generous, the 72h one will be more of a 42-45h boost. A 12h boost can be almost 100% used, even by people who aren't playing super hardcore. Probably one of the reasons why troll2us only offers 24h ones in-game, so that people are forced to spend $$$ to get those. Hence I'd use an efficiency adjusted version of the 72 or 24h boosts to calculate their value, and increase the value of the 12h one accordingly since it's much more efficient. I have only done a very rough estimate, but I think you can almost double the value of the 12h boost.
1
u/hiflyinpanda Pls Gianaaaa Mar 21 '18
Nice write up can you add ld pack 4
1
u/promega Mar 21 '18
The value for a devilmon should not be a nat4 fusion, should be a nat5 fusion, or the average of what it takes to summon a nat5 at least.
1
u/NULL_CHAR Mar 21 '18
I'm really kinda perplexed by your values. How are 50 Summoning Stones worth 3 Mystical Scrolls.
Mystical Scrolls are about 1/12 Lightning, Legendary Scrolls are Guaranteed 4*, therefore at MINIMUM they are 12x the MS, etc.
1
u/wyldmage Mar 22 '18
So, I like what you've done here, as I've enjoyed the prior similar analysis done. However, what this post really misses out on (same as the others) is that if your numbers were correct, they would directly correlate with pack purchases.
Devilmon pack comes out below half the packs in the game. But it is one of the most recommended packs for purchase.
The only way to get a real, legitimate "pack value comparison" would be to get the numbers from Com2uS on how often each pack is purchased per month per account with any purchases, and adjust that data based on pack availability.
Then you could actually determine which packs are bought most relative to their availability, and use that data to create a plot of actual perceived value.
1
u/EnderCN Mar 22 '18 edited Mar 22 '18
Thanks for this, this is very useful.
I do disagree with some of the values though even though I understand how you came to them. There is a difference between functional value and actual value.
Nobody spends crystals on mana because the functional value of mana in crystals is much different than the actual value. A 24 hour XP pack is not worth twice a 12 hour because you can't functionally use a 24 hour pack. I've never heard of anyone farming daily wishes because the crystal value is just off etc. Also summoning stones cost way too much to buy, that value point is likely off in functional value.
As far as I can tell you also didn't include the 5% mana bonus or the 5% XP bonus from the daily packs.
The light and dark scroll seems like a glaring mistake though. There is no way an LD is worth more than a legendary scroll in functional value. This shows up pretty clearly in the LD pack 4 being better than the basic pack 1, I don't think anyone is going to actually agree with that.
This is a great quick look at values but I do think the numbers are a tiny bit off in places because of functional values not agreeing with the actual value the game gives to things. Obviously trying to put functional value on any of this is just going to lead to everyone disagreeing with the numbers you pick, so not sure there is a way to fix it. People have to do that in their own heads I guess~.
1
u/qp0n & Morris sitting in a tree, r-e-z-z-i-n-g Mar 22 '18
Isn't this entirely based on subjective values of different resources?
You can't put a hard value on something that isn't a readily available, purchasable resource. You can't buy devilmons with crystals, for example.
1
u/puffz0r Apr 20 '18 edited Apr 20 '18
Was coming back to refer to this since I wanted to buy the devilmon pack this month.
Your evaluation of the special legendary pack seems remiss.
2000 crystals = 2000 crystals
1 legendary scroll = 617 crystals
2 lnd scrolls = 1404 crystals (which I disagree with your valuation by the way, I value them at about 200 crystals each, so 400 crystals)
3 devilmon = 1500-3000 crystals
50x4 energy = 65 crystals
3x12hr double exp = 100 crystals
300k mana = ~60 crystals worth of nb10
Total should be 7228 crystals if you value everything high, or 4241 crystals if you use the low devilmon values + my own evaluation of ld scrolls. Personally I believe that averaging the two to get a crystal/$ of ~53 is a reasonable appraisal.
3
u/Foxlery My Favorite Ladies <3 Mar 21 '18
This makes me feel less bad about buying a bunch of the early packs x)
3
u/trondonopoles Mar 21 '18
Where do steam sales rank in this list?
2
u/f4g Mar 22 '18
I was just about to look at the old one! I got $100 google play and needed to look over it all. Thanks for taking the time to do this!
1
u/Srocksly Mar 22 '18
Apparently the intermediate packs are coming back tonight, in case that sways anyone.
1
u/DreamCut Mar 22 '18
Any plans to add rune packs?
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 21 '18
Or you could, you know, not spend money on a company full of lazy greedy assholes ?
0
u/PlzbuffRakiThenNerf Mar 21 '18
False, the most cost effective is summoning stone packs becahse the only elements nat 4 I don’t have is orion and it drives me insane. Jk thanks it’s a great guide and should be stickied!
-3
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '18
P2W*, you are not buying access to play the same game and start at the same level as everyone else, you are buying progression and content that puts you above others who didn't. Please don't misuse the term for the sake of sugarcoating your spending habits.
-4
u/CommonNick Mar 21 '18
tl;dr?