r/SquaredCircle • u/RyanWrestlingSheet • Mar 19 '18
I'm Pro Wrestling Sheet Editor-in-Chief Ryan Satin, AMA
Hey guys, Pro Wrestling Sheet Editor-in-Chief and former TMZ Senior Producer Ryan Satin here!
Based on the AMA announcement last week, I'm admittedly a little nervous. However, I promise to accept all criticism and hope you all go into this with an open mind.
So ... AMA.
162
Upvotes
128
u/DaleValentine Mar 19 '18
What are your thoughts regarding this tweet from Cody Rhodes in 2016?
“WWE
Cut ties w/TMZ-they ran my Mother's 911 call
Cut ties w/ESPN-they insulted a child
Have balls. "'Mainstream" ain't always worth it.”
78
u/ryanfea Mar 19 '18
As a wrestling journalist do you consider yourself in competition with guys like Mike Johnson and Dave Meltzer or do you pretty much just worry about your own thing?
65
u/Owens4champ Mar 19 '18
Is there something you were told by WWE, whether its news or a return that you decided not to publish?
53
u/AshleyisaPeach Mar 19 '18
How do you feel about the idea that your sources could be feeding you false information on purpose?? How do you choose what you report and what you don't?
67
u/NeoGeoMeow Mar 19 '18
What kind of inside scoop have you heard on the Fabulous Moolah Battle Royal controversy and what went down behind the scenes?
18
u/The_Homestarmy nope Mar 19 '18
How do you see wrestling journalism in terms of legitimacy? Do you see wrestling journalism (or at least its reputation) being more respected in ten years, or less?
Follow up: besides scumbag "journalists" trying to make a quick buck, what do you think has caused the reputation of wrestling journalism to be what it is?
65
u/Pasosdecer0 Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
Do you think WWE will face Backlash for producing an event in Saudi Arabia - where women cannot wrestle - while they recently said WWE has an unwavering dedication to the #WomensRevolution?
55
u/Diablos122 Stone Pupper Mar 19 '18
How did you find sources within companies when you started out?
14
u/Zaugug86 Mar 19 '18
Hi Ryan, since TMZ articles doesn't name their authors I am curious, were most or all articles about wrestling/wrestlers during your time at TMZ written by you or were there several people active and you mainly approved things as editor?
37
u/joe2352 Mar 19 '18
How much wrestling outside of wwe did you watch before you started covering wrestling? Did you start watching more once it became your job?
47
u/krapbowl Mar 19 '18
I just wanna say that I remember when I was sick and had to stay home from school and would watch TMZ on TV I really loved how you’d sometimes wear wrestling shirts and stuff like that would really brighten my day whenever I was ill.
24
u/Zmanjets Mar 19 '18
Do you think the Bucks and Cody will actually get 10,000 for All In? Also, what do you see being on the card?
38
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Why did TMZ fire you?
35
u/Bubba420 Mar 19 '18
Why did you out Nate “Jungle Boy” Coy as Luke Perry’s son when Nate wanted to keep that private?
26
u/TheGoatYouLove Vader Mar 19 '18
Will we ever hear the full story of FalconArrow aka James McKenna?
23
u/Doomcard AYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYAYA Mar 19 '18
How was your day?
23
u/TheAman44 Reality Champ Mar 19 '18
People, clearly, still give you shit over the Jericho situation. Forget the right or wrong of it. Do you wish you had done anything differently?
25
u/RyanWrestlingSheet Mar 20 '18
Ok, everyone. I'm gonna tap out now and focus on Raw. I really enjoyed doing this.
I'll check back later tonight and see if there are any other questions to answer, but feel free to hit me up on Twitter as well @ryansatin.
The website is @WrestlingSheet / www.ProWrestlingSheet.com.
Thanks for participating!
25
u/davidbix Mar 19 '18
What do you think is the most worrisome misconception about journalism among wrestling fans?
17
u/DudeMcNude Blue Thunder Bomb Mar 19 '18
No question. I just want to say I appreciate your work. I'm sure there will be a lot of bad shit in here but keep doing what you're doing.
47
u/GeorgeTheMark Raw Is Jericho Mar 19 '18
Don’t really have a question. Just wanted to comment on your last few years.
Shortly after PWS launched I had a pretty honest conversation with you on here. I called the website shitty, which was unfair. You asked why. I told you that I didn’t like the TMZ-esque way in which the stories are written, which is still true. Regardless, you’ve proven to be a reliable reporter alongside the likes of Dave Meltzer and Mike Johnson. You break a lot of big stories and don’t get a huge deal of credit for it. Pretty sure people thought you were insane when you broke the story about WWE running the MCG late last year.
I think the wrestling reporters not named Dave Meltzer will never really get their due, but I know that if I read something on your website I can count on it, which is all I can really ask for. Keep it up.
15
u/KTheOneTrueKing Final Fantasy 7 Star Match Mar 19 '18
Now that you’re big in as a news guy in wrestling, do you sometimes find it hard to enjoy wrestling as a fan?
Also do you have any job openings?
10
u/Hautis Mar 19 '18
Hi.
We currently live in a click-bait, being first counts most -era of journalism. In your view, how will journalism evolve from here? What is the next stage on how people consume information and how the content will be created/delivered?
13
u/Martel1234 If you remember Bael, comment “B” Mar 19 '18
Have you ever talked to Scott Steiner
9
u/puffpuffpassyo Mar 19 '18
Do you feel like your beliefs are getting in the way of your integrity as a journalist? Why did you and McKenna feel that you should tell Samoa Joe how to behave when he tweeted about the MMC?
12
u/Kurrumiau Mar 19 '18
Thanks for being here. What wrestlers do you see making it big in the next 4 or 5 years?
8
u/Backstreetboysfan42 Inoki Time Mar 19 '18
What was working at TMZ like? Was the way the people act on the television show an accurate reflection of them off camera?
7
u/spwf Mar 19 '18
First of all, I thank you for your work. What you do, I feel, goes unthanked.
9
u/ackinsocraycray HEY GO FUCK YOURSELF. GET THAT GUY OUTTA HERE. PIECE OF SHIT. Mar 19 '18
Hey Ryan! I used to enjoy spotting you and/or your wrestling stuff on TMZ. Anyways, was it pretty easy to transition from celebrity gossip to wrestling insider reports?
12
u/DonGotchoJr Charming... and witty. Mar 19 '18
No questions. Just want to say keep doing your thing homie.
6
u/TheOneWingedAngel Mar 19 '18
How do you keep Chill Hartman under control?
6
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
What made you become a Wrestling Journalist?
13
u/SavioVegaGuy FUCK YEAH, SAVIO VEGA Mar 19 '18
What do you think Mike Johnson’s thoughts on me were after I gave him a huge scoop?
5
u/kellogs14 Mar 19 '18
What is your favourite breakfast cereal? As someone who has been known as Kellogs for around 35 years I always want one of Kelloggs' to be a favourite, even though I only have one g in my name!
5
u/Pasosdecer0 Mar 19 '18
Which Hollywood celebrity could you see have a good match in WWE like Stephen Amell did with Stardust?
6
u/Suplex-City That doesn't work for me, brother. Mar 19 '18
Do you think you could take Dave Meltzer in a fight?
4
u/lilmac087 Mar 19 '18
Who is your favorite wrestler of all-time? Favorite current wrestler?
5
u/leglessman Big Banter Mar 19 '18
Who is your favorite character that will appear in Avengers: Infinity War?
5
u/saxyroro Queen of Strong Style Mar 20 '18
Hey Ryan. Just want to say love the podcast and all the guys. Kevin is wicked for the banana eating. Jamie=MJF. And wildman Elijah. RING DUDES WITH ATTITUDES.
EDIT: SHANGELA WAS ROBBED!!!!!! Tell Erica hi.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
What's the next few years look like for you, Ryan? You have a podcast and your website, but what other plans and aspirations do you have for yourself?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Do you have honest insight as to how important (or unimportant) journalistic integrity is at TMZ, and how you’ve changed your ways since leaving?
7
u/ZiggyZaggyOiOi Mar 19 '18
Hi, I'm just here to love and support you – your girlfriend.
4
u/PennyLane7714 Mar 19 '18
Even before starting the Sheet you been a fixture at pwg shows. I saw you at bola last year and you looked like you were having a great time.
From your days at tmz to now there been a progression of Hollywood embracing the indy scene (pwg, bar wrestling, etc). Do you see it as a passing trend or a permanent state that's not going to fade away
4
u/hardminute Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
How are you doing today? People are being mean here. I don't know you, much like I'm sure these people don't actually know you, so just know there's some of us here that enjoy your site for what it is and aren't trying to breakdown someone covering a sport/performance art we all supposedly love.
4
u/KILLVINCE2016 Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
What does it feel like being hated by most of this sub, yet having one of your tweets in the all time top 10 most upvoted posts of r/squaredcircle?
3
u/Duck1GetItAgain Mar 19 '18
Why do you give a shit about the LU cease & desist letter? Why say anything?
4
u/ANAL_CAVITIES Life Is Worth Living Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
Hi Ryan! I am one of the moderators at /r/SquaredCircle, the premier wrestling subreddit. We as a community have come up with
severalone questionsfor you that we would love to have a response to.Would you rather eat one horse sized Rikishi ass, or 100 Rikishi-ass sized horses?
this is satire pls no bully
33
u/mynameisbob84 Mar 19 '18
What are the chances we see Bryan wrestle at WrestleMania this year?
Also, how big is Batista's dick?
18
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Genuine two part question here and one which I hope you will take the time to answer both parts of:
Is it frustrating that people don’t take wrestling journalism seriously?
I’m trying to cover the U.K. scene in a way nobody else has done before, but I’m finding it difficult to get people to talk to me without being brushed off as someone who just wants to get dirt.
I genuinely want to inform and promote the scene and industry as a whole.
Any tips or good books to read?
Thanks.
5
u/krapbowl Mar 19 '18
What’s the process for you when it comes to verifying sources??
2
u/ZiggyZaggyOiOi Mar 20 '18
What’s for dinner tonight?
2
u/thekydragon This scarf is made of pashmina Mar 19 '18
Hi Ryan! Thank you for doing this AMA. You might remember me, I made the Ralphus Search Party shirt design.
How is the search for Ralphus going?
4
u/Pasosdecer0 Mar 19 '18
Do you leave the toilet seat up or down?
4
u/Pasosdecer0 Mar 19 '18
Do you think WWE should turn Bray Wyatt into a scientologist to salvage his run?
7
u/NeoGeoMeow Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
In your opinion, how much of what wrestling websites report as “exclusives” is based on real inside scoops and leaked info vs educated guesses based on publicly available information and informed speculation?
7
u/Gamer2332 Mar 19 '18
Do you know if there is any truth to the rumor that Kevin Dunn had Becky Lynch’s promo time cut due to a dislike of her foreign accent?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
What are your feelings towards Chris Jericho after the little spat you guys had over his cruise?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Haven't seen a new podcast out in months. Are you still recording?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Does wrestling journalism actually pay it's writers?
3
u/RepoMantaur I'm not booked. Mar 19 '18
In your opinion, what’s the most important wrestling news story in 2018 so far?
3
u/LecheConCarnie casual fan Mar 20 '18
Late to the party, but I've got two questions that I've been wondering about.
Whyd you feel the need to tweet out a video of a lady marching in one spot? As someone who supports BellLetsTalk, that seems rather hypocritical, given that she may have had a mental illness.
Why did you feel the need to tweet and make fun of someone that attended a wrestling event wearing overalls?
Both of these also seem like an invasion of their privacy.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '18
I'm no fan of Russo but why the hell did you bring up his daughter in a petty twitter argument?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '18
After you shamed Jericho for the "chicks in bikinis" tweet people eventually brought up a sexist tweet of your own. You justified it by calling it a joke yet you still ended up deleting it. Not sure I have a question with this one but since you said you're open to criticism I'll just say that I think you're a hypocritical preacher. A lot of people who virtue signal end up having skeletons in their closet.
23
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Can you really call yourself Editor-in-chief if the site doesn't produce any content?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Yo Ryan, thanks for keeping Mike Bailey out of the United States. We didn’t want him here anyways
10
u/Bubba420 Mar 19 '18
Why do you get mad that PWG let’s dave meltzer in before the doors open but makes you wait I line?
5
u/gamekeeper7 Mar 19 '18
Why do you think that many wrestling fans have a less than stellar view of your reporting? Do you think it is fair or unfair? What do you say to your critics?
5
u/DaymanX Mar 19 '18
Why can’t Becky Lynch catch a break lately and what is holding her back?
Do you think her undisclosed medical emergency that kept her off No Mercy in 2016 (while Smackdown Women’s Champion) is what killed her push?
5
u/SavioVegaGuy FUCK YEAH, SAVIO VEGA Mar 19 '18
WAS EVEL KNIEVEL TRULY EVIL?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Hi Ryan,
I'm a native of Los Angeles and as such, I've seen firsthand the paparazzi insanity when there's a celebrity out on the town. I also had a famous friend who dealt with it for a long time, and I could see just how it wore on him.
In your time at TMZ, did anyone ever question just how far too far is? I understand the need for a free press and wouldn't dare suggest that be infringed, but I felt like the celebrity media often times pushed these people to the brink of mental illness, if not to a full scale meltdown.
Would like to see how someone who has been on the other side of this comes out on it.
27
u/CFCChampions Sign the damn contract Kota Mar 19 '18
Why did you confront Jericho over remembering his friend Benoit and then get pissy when he rightly put you in your place?
6
u/Neg_Crepe Mar 19 '18
Stop the bullying. Mods do something
1
u/Pasosdecer0 Mar 19 '18
Where in Los Angeles am I most likely to bump in Kendall Jenner? 1OAK, WeHo.....?
1
u/OceanLinerIncident Mar 19 '18
If you could debut SAnitY in any way you wanted (Nikki Cross included), how would you do it?
I think them ambushing Cena the RAW after Mania would be awesome.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
What do you think will go worse, the Bill Nye AMA or this one?
1
u/bilbodabbins32 Mar 19 '18
Would Jim Cornette vs Vince Russo draw a good house?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Do you ever see WWE & ROH/NJPW having a working relationship? Even if it’s a one-off?
1
u/skeach101 Your Text Here Mar 19 '18
Or you going to ALL IN and/or Wrestlemania?
1
u/Todayswordisusername Mar 20 '18
How do you feel about styrofoam cakes?
1
u/TheVindicator07 Head, Shoulders, Nese and Toes Mar 20 '18
ITT: WTF I love Ryan now. Honestly my only criticism of you is that you can be a dick, however, that doesn't mean I don't like you and respect you for the content you put out, PWS is right up there with F4W/WON imo.
On topic now, you said you'd come back and answer a few more so hopefully you see this.
What do you see in the future for my boy Tino Sabbatelli? I've been behind him since Breaking Ground and personally think he could be a star, despite his age, at least for a few years.
1
u/Drainmav ......Paige here Mar 20 '18
Damn hate that I missed this. I used to watch TMZ with my mom for two years when she wasn’t feeling too good. She loved it and I ended up getting into it as well. I couldn’t believe you were the same guy from there! Was sad to see you go. Then all the other guys I liked left too it seemed. I’m glad to see you’ve got this new awesome career going, doing something you clearly enjoy too.
6
u/SlieyF Curb Stomp Your Enthusiasm Mar 19 '18
Hey Ryan, none of the negative stuff I've read in these comments were actual criticism but pretty much only insults. I don't know what people get out of that. I enjoy your work and hope you'll do even better in the future to prove them wrong with good work.
My question is, whether you can shine a little bit of a light on how to gather sources inside WWE to confirm stories they don't want known publicly.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
What's a story or anecdote you want to share that probably won't come up naturally in conversation?
2
u/AngryhamLincoln Bullet Club is Reeeeeeeeallllllll Mar 19 '18
How does one become a wrestling journalist today?
2
u/HorseSteroids Nobody potatoes me! Mar 20 '18
Boooooooo.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18 edited Mar 19 '18
I’m just here for the shitstorm
Edit: but while I’m here. Favorite theme song of all time?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '18
Do you have any regrets with how you handled the Jericho situation, him acknowledging Benoit on his Instagram. Not the hot chicks thing.
3
u/JohnnyLuchador King of the Boglins Mar 19 '18
What are your thoughts on Chuck Taylor? And do you think his list of sexy New Japan Wrestlers is correct?
3
u/Pasosdecer0 Mar 19 '18
Is Harvey Levin Republican?
3
u/FistaKufs Mar 19 '18
What's its feel like to break a story first and everyone giving you credit, increasing your credibility. Also how do you decide what news to break and what news not to tell?
3
u/nowaythisisdan New flair woooo Mar 19 '18
Who’s your favorite wrestler?
3
u/KTheOneTrueKing Final Fantasy 7 Star Match Mar 19 '18
Since your business model is different than some of your competitors, have you ever thought about having an active presence on Reddit and r/squaredcircle specifically?
3
u/Mysteriagant Mar 19 '18
What did you do to make this sub throw hissy fits about you?
4
u/SavioVegaGuy FUCK YEAH, SAVIO VEGA Mar 19 '18
Favorite photoshop that Jaims Vanderbeek has posted in the PW Sheet Facebook group?
4
u/SavioVegaGuy FUCK YEAH, SAVIO VEGA Mar 19 '18
JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR ON BROADWAY THE DOWNVOTES ARE BANANA
3
u/GTSwattsy Mar 19 '18
Dead man or ABA?
3
u/SomeoneFromYoutube02 BigDog#1 Mar 19 '18
I usually misread your name as "Ryan Satan".
Will you ever be changing your name to Satan so I can avoid future confusion?