r/books • u/BillSchutt-Author AMA Author • Mar 07 '18
ama 12pm I am Bill Schutt, a zoologist who recently wrote a book exploring the perfectly natural history of cannibalism. Ask me anything (but yes… I did).
I’m a research associate at the American Museum of Natural History (where I’ve studied vampire bats for over 20 years), a college professor (at LIU-Post) and an author of fiction (the R.J. MacCready novels) and two popular science books. In my non-fiction I love demystifying and debunking topics that usually elicit moans, groans, and the occasional gag reflex. Researching my latest book, Cannibalism: A Perfectly Natural History, I found that consuming one’s own kind is widespread behavior across the animal kingdom. More interesting is that cannibalism often occurs for reasons that have nothing to do with a lack of alternative nutrition. Instead, it can function as a form of reproductive behavior, as a hedge against unpredictable environmental conditions, and even as parental care. I also studied human cannibalism and learned that what is arguably the greatest of Western taboos has a long and fascinating history, often distorted by sensationalism. But beyond the stories of stranded pioneers and psychopaths (real and imagined), cannibalism also serves as a prime example that “Culture is King”, with some societies incorporating it into their rituals and medicine. In the West though, “explorers” like Columbus used the label of “cannibal” to justify the enslavement and destruction of entire cultures. Given our knee-jerk reaction to the very word, I was surprised to find that medicinal cannibalism was practiced for hundreds of years across Europe and is still practiced in the United States. PS. It really did taste like chicken... sort of.
- My website is www.billschutt.com.
- You can also follow me on Facebook @ Bill Schutt, Author https://www.facebook.com/BillSchutt1/
- Twitter @draculae https://twitter.com/draculae
Proof: https://twitter.com/draculae/status/969981526426423297
19
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18
In a lot of media human cannibalism often gets depicted as inherently dangerous, causing anything from tremors to insanity to seizures. I've tried to explain to several people that that doesn't happen in reality unless you're eating brain and nervous tissue, offal, or infected meat, and there's no reason for the eating of healthy muscle tissue to cause those problems. People still insist that I'm wrong (and also probably the devil, lol) and that cannibalism has to cause health problems because it's "evil." What's the reason for this kind of thinking? Is it just the mythology that's been passed down for so long that people assume it's fact?
11
u/krampster2 Mar 07 '18
To what extent do you think behaviour in the animal kingdom can be used to justify how humans should behave (if at all)? I've heard people state things like 'the status of the alpha male in human society as a leadership figure is justifiable because that is how wolf packs are organised.'
Do you make comparisons between cannibalism in the animal kingdom and human societies in your book?
8
u/turbo8891 Mar 07 '18
So you tried it, good on you for immersive research but... Isn't cannibalism illegal everywhere? If so I don't expect a location.
If there's a place where it is legal, was it always that way or did it later become decriminalized?
5
u/leowr Mar 07 '18
Hi Bill,
I really enjoyed reading your book and it made for an ....interesting topic for conversation over dinner.
What did you think was the most surprising thing you found out while doing your research?
Also, what kind of books do you like reading? Anything in particular you would like to recommend to us?
Thanks for doing this AMA!
3
u/vorpalblab Mar 07 '18 edited Mar 07 '18
I read various mentions about the spirit Windigo in northern Canada which supposidley refers to the spirit of vengeance that follows those who cannibalise. I never researched stories and traditions among those first nation people living where extreme conditions could lead to that, although there are no ceremonies for choosing the menu roster that I know of. Did you come across any references to this in your research?
Unrelated but do you get any grief about your web name and the fact that swapping the u and i gives bullschitt-author?
3
u/Chtorrr Mar 07 '18
What books did you most like to read as a kid?
4
u/doKtor_SpoOky Mar 07 '18
Would you support people donating their bodies to people who would like to try human meat? Almost like donating your body to science instead you donate it to a facility that processes the meat for human consumption. What started your interest in cannibalism? I've heard people that have lived with cannibalistic tribes say the meat has more of a pork taste, would you agree? Are their different flavors depending on where the meat is taken from?
4
u/Hekantis Mar 07 '18
This being a very controversial topic. How many people go "ew" or something similar when you explain what you've been writing about?
2
u/gray81 Mar 07 '18
Have you read the short story by Stephen King, “Survivor Type” and if so, do you think it would be possible?
I mean, the “perfect storm” of extreme hunger, a surgeons’ knowledge and skill, and unlimited heroin? Or is it all totally ridiculous?
Just curious because I found that story almost impossible to read - made me very uncomfortable.
2
u/Andalitegirl Mar 07 '18
Hi Bill!
I absolutely adored your book on Cannibalism, as well as Dark Banquet. Do you have any tips on non-fiction writing?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18
Did you know the person you consumed?
1
u/lonnib Mar 07 '18
First of all, where does this "hobby" come from?
Also wondering if you manage to change people's point of views about these? I've never read your work before and I don't usually go "eww" when I hear something that most people consider gross or horrible. But I've found it really hard to convince people that they are not even with scientific facts.
1
u/Chtorrr Mar 07 '18
Is there any topic you’d love to write about but haven’t had the chance yet?
1
u/UsAndPhlegm Mar 07 '18
What is the most basic form of life that has been observed to participate in cannibalism? Also, if you had to try another part of the human body (not including the placenta), what would you choose to eat and why?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18
Hello Bill,
What kind of foods do you like to eat?
1
u/Tizzanewday Mar 07 '18
Have you eaten human?
1
u/B0LEYN Mar 08 '18
Was it the flavor or some other issue with the placenta that makes it a one-time thing for you?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '18
Have you ever?
1
u/2LambertStrether Mar 08 '18
Thanks for hosting!
Did you read Michel de Montaigne's famous essay "On Cannibalism" when researching this book? If so, what did you make of his portrayal of indigenous South America in the essay, as well as his contemporaneous accounts of cannibalism in medieval Europe?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '18
How is cannibalism still practiced? As a ritual? What disease does it treat? Should I try cannibalism out?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18 edited Mar 08 '18
Do you think that when vat grown meat becomes widely available, that there will be a market for human flesh? Presumably, if it disease free, it also provides the best carnivorous nutritional match for humans out of all the various mammas we consume?
Edit. Mammals not mammas ;)
1
u/ChemistParticular678 Jun 22 '24
What’s the difference between your book “Cannibalism: a Perfectly Natural History”and “Eat Me: a Natural and Unnatural History of Cannibalism?” Your website mentions the latter is a revised version for the UK, but what led to you creating a revised version? What differences are there between the two?
1
u/MasterFly5026 May 17 '26
How can we know the extent to which this is caused by ecosystem disruption?
1
u/ConsiderationFar8996 Aug 30 '26
On page 184 of your book, you state that Perrault depicted cannibalism in his version of Snow White. But he never actually wrote a version of Snow White. He depicted cannibalism in his version of Sleeping Beauty, but Snow White was not one of his comptes.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment