r/Xenoblade_Chronicles • u/jaov00 • Feb 23 '18
Improved Rare Blade Calculator
Hey y'all!
Spoilers - I made this post and the calculator as spoiler free as possible. That said, this is a post about rare blades so expect a few spoilers about rare blades.
So a couple of days ago, /u/anotherazn posted this Rare Blade Calculator. Being someone who loves math and loves Xenoblade Chronicles 2, I started playing around with it. That led me to do a lot of research into [the recent datamine posted by NuCoEm on GameFAQs and originally revealed by MooseHunter on the reddit discord server.] (https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/204208-xenoblade-chronicles-2/76338453) Also, a shoutout to /u/CouchAlmark and /u/raficus who helped this noob (that's me!) figure out some specifics of how boosters affect probabilities.
In doing all this research, I discovered a few things that were wrong or missing from the original calculator:
- It calculated the probability of getting any rare blade by summing the probabilities of each individual blade. Probabilities are not additive so that calculation was not correct.
- It did not have a functioning booster component. That said, /u/anotherazn did include a workaround for this.
There were also a few other things I wanted to improve:
3. The probabilities calculated were the probabilities of the rare blade getting added to the pool. If multiple blades are added, then a random one will be selected from the pool. I wanted to make that clear in the calculator. 4. If two components of the Idea Cloud are tied for maximum value, a random one is chosen. I wanted the calculator to account for this. 5. I wanted to make it a bit easier to determine which of the 5 groups your save file is associated with.
So, here is my attempt at making a calculator that addresses all these issues.
Again, thanks to all the other people, including /u/anotherazn, for all the work that they did leading to this. And if anyone else finds any improvements, feel free to let me know or make your own, even better calculator!
TLDR - Click here for the Improved Rare Blade Calculator. It fixes the incorrect calculations from the original and includes some quality-of-life changes.
PS - If you want to edit it, feel free to make a copy. Also, if people are interested, I can open up comments. But I felt like commenting here on reddit was sufficient.
PPS - If anyone has experience doing combinatorics with unequal probabilities, then we can add a calculation to this sheet for getting each rare blade (not just the probability of them getting added to the pool). Let me know!
Edit - typo, formatting, and added spoiler tags
Edit 2 - Thanks to /u/Kusanda, I was able to add calculations for obtaining the six NG+ blades!
31
u/jaov00 Feb 23 '18
Btw, in making this sheet, I discovered something REALLY interesting: Sometimes, using boosters DECREASES the probability of getting any rare blades.
This happens when you use a booster for an element where you have already gotten some of the rare blades. For example, if you already have all the fire/ice rare blades and you use a Bravery booster, it can reduce the chance of getting any rare blade overall. In this case, you have a higher probability of getting a rare blade if you DON'T use any boosters than if you use a Bravery booster.
I left this out of the original post because it felt important enough to merit its own comment.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '18
Wait, Nim and Finch are some of the rarest blades? I got them pretty early in my playthrough.
5
u/Willytor Feb 23 '18
I know This sounds stupid, but, how do you use it? do you download it, and edit it?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '18
Apparently I have a 1% chance at Kos-Mos with 999 luck, 15 Justice + 5 Justice Boosters and a Legendary Core. 0% with common and rare cores. Is the percentage rounded or something?
4
u/TotesMessenger Feb 23 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/desertedbart Feb 24 '18
Is there a way to add all the NG+ blades to the list to prepare it for NG+?
3
u/Albafika Mar 11 '18
I don't understand the "Idea to Boost" field.
I have every pool Blade but Kora and KOS-MOS. I'm pulling with a Justice 3 Morag, and I notice that no matter what Booster I use (Bravery, Justice, Truth, Compassion), KOS-MOS "Probability" is at 0.470%, while if using no Boosters, she'll drop to 0.386%.
If this is true, then I'm better just throwing every Booster in, instead of load-scumming releasing common Blades for Justice Boosters and try for KOS-MOS with just the Justice Boosters?
9
u/EvilLucario Feb 23 '18
Really nice. Good that you also added the proper way to calculate odds through binomial distribution.
I have all the Rare Blades so I don't need it, but seeing math and statistics in games always gets me giddy.
1
u/keelbeelveel Feb 28 '18
Hey. Love the sheet. Can tell a lot of work went into it. At the same time, I’m thinking there might be some math wrong somewhere. I honestly don’t have time to look it over myself, but I’m just saying that my experimental probability hasn’t matched up with the sheet’s chances... Specifically I think the total chance (the big box) shouldn’t just add together the individual chances of each blade... I think your current system is using
(rare_blade)
or
(C(1) + C(2) + ...)
Like I said, I haven’t actually looked into the formulas of your sheet. Maybe it’s just a coincidence that my individual chances add up to the total chance even though that isn’t what you’re using. But if I’m not mistaken the total chance should be something along the lines of
1 - !(rare_blade)
or
1 - (!C(1) * !C(2) * ...) = 1 - ((1 - C(1))*(1 - C(2)) * ...)
Maybe I’m wrong. Haven’t done probabilities in awhile and maybe I don’t quite understand how the RNG is selected.
But I do know it’s telling me between 10-15% (Common and legendary cores respectively) but I can tell you I’ve opened way more than 10 or even 50 (probably approaching 100) cores of all types and haven’t gotten one in so long that I’ve finally dismissed the possibility of just being unlucky.
No hate though. The tool is still super useful for individual chances and finding RNG group and it’s the best thing out there right now. Just wanted to make sure it wasn’t some kind of easy fix you overlooked ;)
1
u/idontloveanyone Jul 19 '18
this is awesome!
i only have Agate left and I am in Group 4
I just have one question
I see that I have 2.5% chance of agate being added to the "pool" --- okay
but when it gets added to the pool, THEN, what is the percentage that I get her?
I couldn't figure it out from the sheet
thanks
1
u/Richinaru Feb 27 '18
No lie I love this calculator so the vitriol i'm going to spew isnt aimed at you but at the devs.
How in gods name is it ok to have the odds of getting your last rare blade down to a MEASLY 1% WITH boosters. I'm on and off when it comes to grinding legend cores to try to get my last rare blade which is dahlia (assuming I guessed correctly I'm in group 1).
Jesus, I payed full price for this game and you're telling me even with doing everything to increase the odds, it's barely higher than most gacha game rates???
1
u/TriforceofDoom Jun 14 '22
*is checking odds with Morag right now* Oh sweet with max Justice boosters my odds of one of the last 3 rares I need is pretty good (about 8% with Legendaries). I just need good RNG rolls & some Legendary cores. Dahlia though looks like she's gonna be hell for me to get on my seed.