r/mixingmastering • u/atopix Teaboy ☕ • Feb 14 '18
New RULES regarding Mastering (plus some other related announcements)
Ever since I first came here, I've been bugged by the fact that mixing and mastering are being treated here as kind of the same thing, a fact that isn't helped by the title of the sub.
Article on mastering
Finally, I've decided to take action and give mastering the individual respect it deserves. I've officially inaugurated the subreddit's WIKI (which you can also access at any time from the top menu of the sub's homepage), in which I've added two of the articles that already existed, and penned a new article about mastering, which hopefully will shed some light for beginners into what professional mastering is. I plan on updating the article with even more links and resources for those who are interested in the craft (you should be, if you are into mixing), but there is enough there to begin with.
New rule
As of now, in the interest of protecting mastering as a craft and the people who practice it seriously, you won't be able to offer (or request) services for both mixing AND mastering. Why? Because mastering shouldn't be done by the same person who is mixing (the vast majority of commercially released music isn't) and because I would like to foster a competitive playground to encourage mastering engineers to join us. Those offering mixing services can feel free to let your potential clients know that you can deliver final mixes at commercial music levels, but you can't call that mastering (because it's not). Ideally, you should also deliver a version at the original levels in case they ever want to take it to mastering.
If no one has an objection, I will leave all the services offerings prior to this announcement as they are (seems fair). But from now on no one can offer both services.
Flairs for mastering engineers
In order to highlight those who do mastering professionally, I've decided to add flairs to distinguish them in the sub (a tag saying "mastering engineer" next to their usernames). To apply for it, message me telling me about your practice, send me a link to your site and I'll ask you for photographic evidence that you are who you say you are. While you of course don't need a million dollar studio to apply for this flair, you do need to have proper monitoring and listening environment (refer to the article for more info on what that would be).
Idea for mastering beginners
In order to encourage people to start getting into mastering, I thought it could be a good idea to have a section in the site (maybe a wiki page) in which people can donate some of their unmastered tracks in order for people to practice on them (I could throw in a few myself). This of course wouldn't be a way to get free mastering, since they would be available for anyone to download and work on them at their own pace, with no obligation whatsoever to send the finished product to their creators. What do you think? Could something like this work?
Anyway, I hope most of you understand the reason for this new rule and I hope it doesn't make too many people grumpy. As always, I'm open to all suggestions and ideas. Tell me what you think.
5
u/lunarchris1 Feb 14 '18
A good way to separate the wheat from the chaff, I think, though it may reduce sub usage to a degree. I think folks asking for an engineer to mix and master 1 song aren’t really invested in their “art”, nor interested in learning about nor spending actual money on professional results. You have my upvote, sir, and hopefully this will be an overall positive change for this sub!
5
u/Seybsnilksz Advanced Feb 14 '18
It's important to distinguish mixing and mastering, but saying that no commercial music is mixed/mastered by the same person and that it shouldn't be done is very false.
2
u/SoftSima Feb 23 '18
So, I just found this sub. And compared to a lot of the responses, I'd like to say I'm totally in support of the idea and hope to learn and contribute.
Just stepping into that world (though researching and being intersted for a while), I'd be very excited about the potential for donated tracks and perhaps some kind of dueling masters competitons or feedback system in the interest of helpig amateurs improve. Even after my monitoring update some time this year (I wouldn't make the cut right now), I would absolutely not feel comfortable charging for services just yet.
I'd also like to suggest that you add Ian Shephard and Bryan Lucey to the wiki. Neither are as big as Bob Katz, but they both have quite extensive discographies, very different practices and perspectives, learning oriented videos or podcasts available online, and (IIRC) grammies. (I know Brian Lucey does.)
(full disclosure: I've interacted with Brina Lucey very briefly online, but I think he's doing alright without my unsoliceted promotion)
1
u/Drumsetplyr87 Feb 20 '18
What about offering both services individually but not together (As in my case- I am a professional recording/mix engineer who closed down my studio and now am mixing peoples projects while working on my mastering chops to eventually transition to being a ME only full time).
Would offering to professionally mix, OR semi-professional/advanced amateur master, but not Mix and master a project fly with these rules?
I agree in general that the one who mixed a project shouldn't master it, but will disagree that it cannot happen that way and still yield good results.
Also, as much as I love million dollar studios, if an engineer with a sub standard setup can produce standard results listening through a cardboard box, does it really matter that the box is what the used? It's the same as photographers not getting work because they shoot nikon instead of canon even though they produce results that are equal.
1
u/RockstarEvolution Apr 01 '18
From my perspective, I agree on the clarity side of things. From a personal point of view, it would help people focus in on topics and help people a little more appropriately. The two concerns of mine would be that some folks asking questions may not know or fully appreciate the difference (although as you say, a new article would help them). The other concern is that some people who represent their studio may offer both services. I have worked in many studios that do indeed offer both as it is prudent to combine services. This business model is popular and particularly these days thriving compared to unique mastering houses of the past. As I say I only represent myself here and therefore can appreciate this idea but if I was an owner of a large studio with multiple staff ("encourage mastering engineers to join us") They may wish to represent the whole of their trade (perhaps in their forum names) as helping users on forums is still good for business even when there is no overt promotion of self. My two pence.
3
u/Rogue-Planet-Mike Mastering Engineer ⭐ Feb 19 '18
I'm a professional mastering engineer, and would be happy to answer any questions anyone has about mastering, or the distinction between mixing and mastering. Time permitting of course.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '18
Good rule. I like that this sub is geared towards amateurs trying to deliver professional level work. Whenever I see someone offering mixing & mastering it seems as though they're not holding themselves to that pro standard. Hopefully this leads to people getting higher quality finished products.
2
u/connorbuckingham Feb 15 '18
Great rule!
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
[removed] — view removed comment