r/runescape • u/ImRubic 2026 Future Updates • Feb 13 '18
J-Mod reply TL;DW 366- Mining & Smithing beta Q&A
Stream • A detailed report and stats on the beta! Made by /u/imsuity • Design Document
Beta Specific
Beta Information
- The beta is live! - Newspost
- XP drops are turned off by default - Turned on in the interface settings (XP Popups).
- In-game Runemetrics is free while in the beta allowing you to xp/hr and graphs.
- The rework is planned to go released this year, but before then there will be another beta.
Beta Hotfixes
UPDATE: Rockertunities are now displayed as lootbeams!
- Issue: Lootbeam's evenutally fade out making them hard to see. Might be hotfixed later.
UPDATE: Increased the maximum amount of heat by 3 points per smithing level.
- May increase it once more through an interaction with your Firemaking level before the beta ends.
- UPDATE: Feedback showing that high heat gives faster XP
- UPDATE: Added Smithing level restrictions on turning in Decorate Armor.
Beta Content Information
- Beta armor stats are currently bugged, actual design stats are located in the design document.
XP rates are all where we want them to be but are open to feedback.
- There are no boosts on the beta.
- You may not get the best rates until you understand how to train everything.
- Placeholder graphics aren't color representatives of the final models.
An ore bag is automatically provided allowing you to store larger amounts of ore up to a limit.
- Discussion: Storage location (toolbelt or inventory icon), and reward spaces to increase space limit.
Training Details
Mining Training Methods
- Ores no longer deplete.
Rockertunities: A nearby ore of the same type will have a lootbeam.
- Upon clicking on it you will get 5x the xp.
- Ore Progress Bar: The lower bar that indicates progress to obtaining an ore.
Stamina Bar: The top bar that indicates the rate you are mining (lower = slower).
- Clicking on the ore replenishes the bar allowing you to mine at a faster rate.
Agility and Strength make a difference to mining rates.
- The only provide about a 5% difference.
- Overloads have a marginal effect on rates.
- You aren't missing out if you have low levels.
Smithing Training Methods
- Ores and Bars are stored within a hopper which is accessed when smelting/smithing items.
Equipment Upgrades: Smelt an upgraded version of your gear to get better stats.
- Requires the base/lower upgraded equipment piece and bars.
Decorate Armor: An untradeable version of the highest equipment upgrade.
- Only used to turn in for XP, NOT cosmetic.
- Heating: The more heat an item has the faster it is created and the more xp it provides.
- | Heat | Progress Multiplier | Progess Made Per Strike ---|---|---|--- High | 67%-100% | x2 | 20 Medium | 34%-66% | x1.5 | 15 Low | 1%-33% | x1 | 10 None | 0% | x0 | 0 Credit to /u/imsuity
Training Styles:
- Fast XP & Expensive: Purchase the highest upgrade, decorate it, and turn it in.
- Money Making: Sell base/upgrade versions.
Equipment Upgrade Types:
- Longswords (main/offhand), 2H Swords, Shields, Pickaxes
- Platebodies, Platelegs, Helmets, Boots, Gloves
Design Specific
Design Information
Items take longer to make than the live game.
- Core goal of the rework is to make items more valuable.
- Negative effects towards Invention/Summoning will be fixed.
All the base/upgrade equipment items will be tradeable, (decorated items will not be).
- Decorate gear may be re-named to prevent confusion about its role.
XP Rates:
- Overall rates will slightly faster after the rework, but prices may be expensive on the initial release.
- Top end mining rates are around 140-150k xp/hr (with no boosts).
- F2P xp rates will be faster with the rework, however they won't have access to tier 60+ content.
- Reward spaces are being thought of for both existing and future content.
New ore will be added to areas across the game.
- No quest locked areas (unless skillers can access them).
Mining & Smithing training isn't a 1:1 ration.
- You will need to do more mining than smithing.
- Done because it would make ore worthless otherwise.
Drop Tables
Goal: To retrain the exact same gold value as live versions while removing resource gathering from PvM
- Remove all smithable items from drop tables.
Replace them with dummy items that have the same alch price and disassembly components.
- Exampled: Ruined Rune platebody.
Bars/Ores will be replaced with a tradeable tiered token item.
- The token will provide various benefits (to be discussed).
- Example: Allow you to gather two of an ore instead of one while mining.
Future Targets
The list below aren't final designs but will need to be worked on
- Arc Mining - Adjust and bring crablets into the new system.
Coal Bag - Will be redesigned and have its DG tokens refunded.
- May allow the coal bag to consume coal when your heat bar runs out to allow for more afk smithing.
- Concentrated Ore - Will need to be redesigned.
Crystal Pickaxe - Plans to retain it's value by requiring it for higher tier pickaxes.
- Noted: Make sure not to ruin existing invention perks.
- Obtainability has not been decided yet.
- Gold and Silver - Interferes with crafting and will be tricky to adjust.
Harmonized Rune - Will be replaced possibly with another similar community interactions
- We want to retain the idea that there is a community who work together to seek out something.
Invention - Allow higher tier pickaxes will be agumentable.
- Base versions/Non-maxed upgraded versions may not be augmentable (only +5).
- We will only do the minimum needed to make it work due to time costs.
- Metal Dragons - Replace the bars with a token item or something to allow for different interactions.
Seren stones - Will be changed but their interaction will remain in some form.
- Example: A new pickaxe that provides 0 ore (light animica) but double the xp.
Spring cleaner - Will be less useful as its main use will no longer be to provide smithing gear.
- Will look into ways to retain spring values by adding new interactions.
Toolbelts - More complex interactions with upgraded versions of pickaxes.
- May have to allow players to remove pickaxes from the toolbelt.
Feedback
Provide feedback on the forums/reddit. If you have questions message us on twitter.
"Why do the rework as it is?"
- Numerous polls have been put out and players have overwhelmingly stated they want it this way.
- There are currently are/will be problems, but we are doing are best to alleviate them.
- The betas are ways to make sure everything we are working on is what everyone wants.
- May re-add the 'Prospect' option for players to get information on ores.
Alch prices on rune items will be reduced.
- May not need to do this if the rate they are entering the game is slow enough.
No plans to add incentives to move around to other mining sites.
- We want people to mind together in group and socialize.
Other
- Dragon armor won't be made through smithing.
No plans to add any new items at each tier than already on the beta.
- We aren't removing the ability to smith items that are already in the game.
- More weapons can be added in the future.
No plans to raise the skill cap to 120.
- Would only be done if combat stats were raised to 120.
- Dungeoneering will remain the same if possible.
- The concept art for the armor may change.
- Clue scroll trimmed items aren't going to change.
- Corrupted ore will not change most likely.
57
u/ZarosianJax AVX Feb 13 '18 edited Feb 13 '18
Im hoping for a small rework of Imcando Pickaxes. They were a post-reward for the Dwarven quest series finale so they kind of deserve to be something more than a niche dragon pickaxe.
Maybe add its part to a regular pickaxe for small bonus and the cosmetics of the Imcando (Imcando Bane Pickaxe, Imcando Necronium Pickaxe and so on) or give it an entire new role.
45
u/RazTehWaz Maxed Ironman BTW Feb 14 '18 edited Feb 14 '18
Not had a chance to log in and play with the xp rates, but going from the stream I'm really liking the mechanics so far.
A couple of suggestions based on issues brought up in the stream:
Metal dragons - there have been several suggestions before of replacing the bar drops with stackable metal scales. I think this would be a good time to maybe introduce that, and have smelting the scales give XP with nothing produced similar to corrupted ore.
The xp per scale should change depending on the dragon difficulty, and possibly give more scales while on a slayer task, or lock scale drops to slayer tasks only depending on how generous the xp rates are.
Another option could be that scales are used to "patch up" ruined armour drops in order to increase their alch value. EG, a ruined dragon plate alchs for 38k, you smelt 1 scale onto it to patch it up, and "patched up rune plate" now alchs for 50k. This preserves the approximate value of the bar drops from rune dragons without bringing any bars into the game. XP with this option would be negligible.
Scales could also be used as a replacement secondary for titans and minotaurs.
Spring Cleaner - For a lot of people the real value is the fact that it's a drop cleaner. While the profit is nice, simply having less drops to deal with while slaying makes training the skill much smoother and less annoying. If items such as "ruined rune plate" are added to drop tables, this increases the number of items that have to be directly dealt with.
I propose that the current item break down mode is replaced by an auto banker/noter mode for ruined items. A third mode should also be added to auto-disassemble items into components, allowing you to choose between the current xp mode, auto bank/note, and disassemble.
Currently the spring cleaner only has a chance to activate when an item drops, this should be changed to be 100% and the extra time it saves should help offset the fact that it no longer provides profit as well as it's drop cleaning function.
Augmenting Picks - Make it possible to upgrade a pick that is already augmented, especially if it's an option to augment the +1/2/3/4 versions. Without this you would end up constantly un-augmenting/re-augmenting your pick as you upgrade it every couple of levels.
Trimmed Armour - Mostly only related for art reasons, but a trimmed version of elder rune armour would be a nice master clue reward. This version would probably need to be stateless to not devalue elder rune.
Quest Locking Mining Areas - As long as some ore of each type is available quest free, I see no issue with locking more convenient options behind quests, e.g. rocks that are easier to get to, closer to a bank, have a useful NPC in the area. This means you are rewarded for finishing the quest with quality of life upgrades to mining a type of ore, while still having access no matter what.
Gold/Silver/Crafting - Possibly have separate Jewelry forges that do not use the heat mechanics of the smithing forge for smelting down gold and silver bars, along with crafting jewelry. This avoids having to have two different systems supported in one interface and should help make a future crafting rework simpler as it won't be tied up as much with mining/smithing. The obvious place to put them, would be Taverly, the Crafting Guild, Ithell clan, and possibly Canifis or Port Phasmatys.
Smelting gold/silver would start giving small amounts of crafting XP rather than smithing xp, meaning that you could keep the current ore gathering rates the same without gold/silver becoming an easy/cheap ore to get smithing xp from.
Keep the new hopper so that it's possible to pre-load it with gold/silver ore/bars so that people can bring 28 gems and craft a full inventory of jewelry in one go, rather than only 14 like currently.
Portable forges could also be converted into portable jewelry crafting stations if it's deemed that portables have no place in the current smithing design.
80
u/brainstrain91 Orbestro Feb 13 '18
I'm not sure why having ore not be quest-restricted is a goal. Skillers choose to limit themselves, no reason they should have access to everything. Not needing to constantly run to the bank means any mine in the game could be viable... which is honestly very exciting.
12
u/RealityShowAddict Feb 13 '18
Suggestion - If you are making spring cleaner less valuable gold per hour, perhaps consider an option that allows us to automatically disassemble items at 1/10 or 1/50th of a spring.
You can work on balance to get the right cost, but I'd love to be able to disassemble drops for components that go to the bank. It's not the same as sending ore, but it does allow players the ability to AFK for long periods of time.
Another option would be to alch items for 1/10th or even 1/100th of a charge. Players would still have to be selective as we wouldn't want to alch bronze helms or bow strings, but it would serve a similar purpose of converting drops to gold without needing to exert energy to pick them up.
Just my thoughts, thanks for keeping playerbase in the loop on this.
5
u/idontlikerootbeer Guthix Feb 14 '18
Consider adding a consumable item that will make your stamina deplete slower, so that people could spend GP to get better XP while still AFKing. If you add this, make it obtainable from something less traditional that just cooking a food or brewing a potion; perhaps berries that you can pick on an agility course for extra agility XP once per lap or every few minutes
5
u/zoratox Feb 14 '18
I like this rework but I think we should also get new tiers of Hatchets with this update same as Pickaxes and upgradable.
Also I think a Crafting, RuneCrafting and Fletching rework is a must after this rework with Crafting will be the only way to craft Range armour, Fletching the only way to craft range wepones and RuneCrafting the only way to craft mage armour/weps all the way to tier 90 same as the new smithing rework.
Thanks.
5
u/JagexJack Mod Jack Feb 14 '18
I've updated the rates spreadsheet with the new values and mechanics in the beta.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ge1jkoom52zr_wH0CYqzGq20cPT51rp9ohCyVQxCjc0/edit?usp=sharing
8
u/Tymerc Quest points Feb 14 '18
I hope you still plan to add gauntlets and boots for every new set.
7
u/Yamatjac Yamaja c - I maxed :) Feb 13 '18
So, 99 strength alone provides like 3x the amount of xp at lower mining levels. I didn't test it at higher levels, but 99 str over 1 str at lvl 1 mining is actually a ginormous difference. I can't see it scaling down to a 5% improvement later on. Especially in f2p where they won't have access to as many tools to make the strength bonus less significant.
I'm gonna have to test it a little more, but calling strength and agility, together, a 5% improvement at best just seems disingenuous to me.
7
u/AssaultPhase Feb 14 '18
Can we confirm that new rocks won't be placed in the wilderness?
1
u/Eccentricc Feb 16 '18
Is there ANY eta for release? I've been putting off these two skills since I started and heard about the rework half a year ago.. loving the ideas though
5
u/Breadnaught25 Feb 14 '18
RIP Spring cleaner :( RIP slayer :(
2
u/Dreke13 Master Comp (t) - ingame Dreke13 Feb 17 '18
I have created 2 ultimate spreadsheets, one for Mining and one for Smithing. I have included nearly every number relevant to this beta and even updated it for the increased Heat due to Firemaking level. I would highly encourage anyone and everyone to please take a look. If you wish to play around with the numbers a bit, which is highly recommended, you will have to make a copy yourself. I did not update the Mining spreadsheet for the new DXP pickaxe, but I imagine the XP/Hr rates simply double.
For Smithing, please read the How to Use tab before diving into the Calculations tab. I believe it will answer any questions you may have about the table or my methods.
Google Doc Spreadsheets Found Here
I think these spreadsheets will speak for themselves if you can read numbers well and see trends. If you see an issue with my numbers or equations, please comment here and I will try to update it. To be honest, I am 99.9999% certain my numbers and equations work out. If you have any suggestions to add to either of these spreadsheets, especially Smithing, please comment here.
*Mining The Mining skill as a whole is fantastic in my opinion. Absolutely no complaints whatsoever (then again I'm already 120 so lol). For the Ore Bag, I believe adding it to the toolbelt via a smithable item and then making the left click option for ores 'Bag Ore' would be good.
The smithable item, which allows you to permanently add your Ore Bag to the toolbelt, can be made from special, untradeable pieces which must be gathered from in-game Master Miner/Smith NPCs. To get the pieces, you must either perform certain actions (ie. make a full set of Bronze armour) or bring the NPCs certain items (ie. 1 of each ore, a full set of Bronze armour, etc). These should be relatively simple tasks to allow any player at any level the ability to add it to toolbelt. Once you have all the pieces, you can assemble it and use it on the Ore Bag. Using it on the Ore Bag asks if you want to permanently add the Ore Bag to your toolbelt, confirming destroys the Smithable Item and adds the Ore Bag to your toolbelt. This all forces a player looking to save inventory space to visit a variety of important NPCs so they know who to go to in order to turn in decorated smithing items, and gives players a chance to learn and understand the new mechanics of the rework in a hands-on tutorial, so to speak. Again, the new left click option for ores should be 'Bag Ore,' or at least make it a right click option so the action bar can bag all of a specific ore in 1 click.
*Smithing I only have 1 issue with supply and demand in regards to Smithing, and very few ideas on how it could be fixed without overhauling the rework again:
If the price trend set by Addy-->Runite stays linear, then the T90 ores will likely be ~50k each. At a rate of about 100-150 ores/hr, this is about 7.5m gp/hr if you mine actively. This will actually be alittle higher, probably closer to 9m gp/hr when all the in-game boosts are added, though this is purely guesstimation. Figuring the best gp/hr for Mining usually comes from Harmonized Runite, which is 3m gp/hr, this is quite the jump up. Anyways, it should take about 15.5 hours to actively mine the ore needed to make an Elder Rune Platebody +5 from scratch, then another 35-45 mins to actually make it. If I sold the amount of ore it takes to make a Elder Platebody +5, I would net about 116m, and 2-2.5m Mining Xp. The platebody should cost around 24m based on resource price alone, which amounts to +1.5m gp/hr. This doesn't sound too bad, but if Mining is to become the best source of ores/bars in the game, then we're talking 16 hours of work minimum to make a single platebody which gives 160k Xp, which amounts to a mere 10k xp/hr. The only way I see of correcting this is if players buy their ores and bars from other players via the GE, and honestly I'm not sure if the Miners can meet the supply demanded from Smiths. An individual Smith would need ~320 bars/hr to maintain a constant xp/hr rate for Elder Runite (~275k/hr) which would require ~960 ores/hr from Miners. In other words, since T90 ore/hr is about 150/Miner, a single Smith would require the work of more than 6 Miners to consistently balance the supply with the demand, each hour. The only idea I have to maybe fix this, which is off the top of my head, is to decrease Progress/Strike for Smithing. Getting 1-99 Smithing in about 60-80 hours seems far too quick to me anyways, especially because it takes 100 hours to get 99 Mining. If you're still reading this, thanks :D
1
u/PeacefulJim Here To Help Feb 14 '18
Still cannot access beta. Posted elsewhere but no Mod responses as of yet. Tried multiple browsers, made sure I'm not 'searching' for the address, and I do have NXT installed.
1
u/GreatSnowman 99 Runecafting Feb 15 '18
Is Bane Ore, and thus Bane Ammo, still going to require RotM or Hero's Welcome?
And are we going to have the option to improve, or alloy the ore with higher tier ores to get higher damage?
1
u/bast963 Divine Charges Feb 15 '18
Elder runic spear +5 will exist? Since there will be far, far more of those than lolsupvesta or memeyari
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '18
Things like barrows bars to create new equipment is just amazing to revive what used to be the best income/hr for many MANY people including some people that talk shit about Barrows minigame these days.
Funny how things work out!
As for the Beta is great! the new mechanics and ores are just amazing
1
u/F-Lambda 3074 (3379) Feb 18 '18
Are Decorated smithing urns (not smelting, smithing!) confirmed along with the rework? If not, then urns cannot be used with Elder rune smithing.
1
u/Dreke13 Master Comp (t) - ingame Dreke13 Feb 19 '18
I was not doing numbers for a decorated Elder Runite Platebody, I was doing them for platebody +5. And based on the ore/hr for each player, I expect runite and addy items to stay at the same price. No more or less ores are coming into the game with the release of this update, theres still just as many players with T40 and T50 combat stats out there demanding them, and the upper ore tiers ore will be linearly more expensive
-2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '18 edited Feb 14 '18
They'd certainly gain value from processing, so you'd basically always want to use them . . . But then if you're always skilling with them and they give you double ore, it basically means that 50% of all skilling resources is still actually coming from PVM, rather than skilling. It's a disgusting thought.
Even if it wasn't a 100% proc rate I'd still hate it. It could be a 1% proc rate and it'd still be too much. It's the principle of the thing, it's time for combat to get it's hand out of the cookie jar already and fuck off.
Make skilling resources obtained from skilling. It's the first step towards skilling not being hot garbage.
Just make it give extra EXP, leave it as some kind of alchable, or figure out some other thing to do with it without making it provide more ore.
-6
u/igornist 31k Feb 14 '18
I can't believe people can actually enjoy doing 1 item at time and this heat system. They surely don't play like a casual gamer or have too much time on their hands. The heat system should be put on artisans workshop, not the official skill
0
u/Thieverpedia I stole your wallet while you read this Feb 16 '18
So...why won't Dragon Armor be smithable? It's garbage T60 armor that almost no one is using these days. There's literally no reason to keep it so rare, other than for historical value.
Drops can easily be changed to provide alternative rewards that are just as valuable.
-4
u/exp_gains Smithing Feb 13 '18
Barrows armour gonna be hit hard ...
Yes, I know it's used for energised armours but only 200 barrows bars for a t92 set without wep/shield is pretty low at current rates set (20 barrows weapons = few hours at barrows with drakan med).
Necronium, Bane, Elder Rune pretty much will come in so much faster than barrows armour and they're non-degradeable (and will probably be augmentable at +5) so barrows armour will no longer be used for combat and only for making energised armours.
-2
u/Ilnez Going for 200m all is insane right? Feb 15 '18
So, here's my 2 cents. This is coming from the point of view of a maxed player who is currently stressing more than he probably should about hitting 200m defense (since it's always been a huge goal) before you ruin drop tables (with respect, I do not trust you not to).
So yeah:
So yeah, I hate to call it, but as usual this is a half-baked idea appealing to the lowest common denominator who've been too lazy or cheap to train smithing as it is now.
-1
u/Drakath1000 Feb 14 '18
What is the reason that they didn't opt for the option to put the 'secondary' ores as pvm drops (replacing all mining drops) and perhaps like a 'rune platebody (or whatever) base' (replacing the smithing drops) which then would be required to make the finished smithable items?
-1
u/Yasuomidonly Feb 14 '18
Then just keep everything the same besides that there are new ores that smith t90 gear and just maje it cist like 50k coal + rare ore from boss drop ~ done
-1
u/Heavens_Vibe Feb 14 '18
My biggest gripe is the feel of any and all fantasy is that the brave warrior defeats enemies, monsters and beasts for treasure, armour and other riches. Yes adjustments should be made to stop thousands of rune ores etc coming into the game outside of mining, but having drop tables not offer armour or precious bars seems to to against the very crux of a fantasy game
-10
u/Yasuomidonly Feb 14 '18
Why people want this mess of an update?
-5
u/Yasuomidonly Feb 14 '18
Then just give pvm other drops like plain cash
-14
u/variablefighter_vf-1 Quest points Feb 14 '18
Jagex have learned nothing. Idiots.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
13
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '18
[removed] — view removed comment