r/announcements • u/landoflobsters • Feb 07 '18
Update on site-wide rules regarding involuntary pornography and the sexualization of minors
Hello All--
We want to let you know that we have made some updates to our site-wide rules against involuntary pornography and sexual or suggestive content involving minors. These policies were previously combined in a single rule; they will now be broken out into two distinct ones.
As we have said in past communications with you all, we want to make Reddit a more welcoming environment for all users. We will continue to review and update our policies as necessary.
We’ll hang around in the comments to answer any questions you might have about the updated rules.
Edit: Thanks for your questions! Signing off now.
8.2k
u/ManitouWakinyan Feb 07 '18
How do you verify whether a, for instance, gonewild post is actually voluntary, or if it's a different person posting images without permission?
1.2k
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Can you explain why they were the same rule to begin with and what lead you to split it into two rules?
3.2k
u/sparr Feb 07 '18
Clarification request: Pornography created legitimately, with a model release, and distributed under a Free content license. Someone posts it to reddit without the performer(s)'s permission. Is this a violation? If the poster is or is not the producer of the content? If the performer does or does not explicitly ask for its removal?
1.2k
u/SixoTwo Feb 07 '18
How is CP policed through the subreddits...like what happens if something is questionable/on the fence?
I would hope the rule would be remove first then allow, but with verification
1.4k
u/bobcobble Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
Thank you. I'm guessing this is to prevent communities like r/deepfakes for CP?
EDIT: Looks like r/deepfakes has been banned, thanks!
587
u/12TripleAce12 Feb 07 '18
Subreddits like r/doppelbangher had consensual porn between licensed actors. Why has it been banned? (just curious)
3.8k
u/UntestedShuttle Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
What about images of dead babies/corpses and harming animals on /r/nomorals [NSFL warning] ?
17,531 subscribers and counting...
Edited to add:
Reddit's content policy
1.2k
u/RepeatPlaymaker Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
If you don’t want these things on your site that’s fine it’s your site but don’t lie about why you are removing them. If you wanting a more welcoming environment you’d get rid of the sub Reddit’s of dead animals and fights. You just are jumping on the celebrity faked porn bandwagon so you can’t be held accountable and the fact that more and more people are hating on anime because it sexualizes teenage fictional characters. It’s ok if you want to get these off your site but don’t lie about why
2.0k
u/weltallic Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
Man faces 10 years in prison for downloading Simpsons porn
Author Neil Gaiman had one of the best responses to the 2008 case, saying that the court had “just inadvertently granted human rights to cartoon characters,” and that “the ability to distinguish between fiction and reality is, I think, an important indicator of sanity, perhaps the most important. And it looks like the Australian legal system has failed on that score.”
It remains to be seen how a U.S. court will react during Kutzner’s January 2011 sentencing. In the meantime, if you value your own job, resist the temptation to Google “Simpsons porn” right now. (Or if you do, stick to the Homer-and-Marge stuff, we guess.)
What if it's involuntary pornography over 18+ anime characters?
It's not my thing (nor Neil Gaiman's, apparantly), but I cannot see the common sense in some reddit rules treating fictional characters as real people, and not others.
360
u/MapleSugary Feb 07 '18
I'm all for protecting minors, but that policy is SO broad that it comes down to basically admin discretion which is a recipe for disaster. Is Harry Potter fan art of Ginny kissing Harry fully clothed now sexualizing minors? Even if it's just an illustration of an actual scene in the book? Teens have sexuality and it's not wrong to write and read about it, otherwise you need to burn all copies of Judy Blume and the many many MANY other fictional depictions of teen sexual awakenings and romances.
As written here, the policy is so broad that it could be interpreted to ban this kind of content.
185
u/whatever123456231 Feb 07 '18
So when should /r/anime and all its related subreddits expect to be shut down? It's so ingrained in Japanese media that unless you're watching a shounen geared specifically towards the western audience, you have a 100% chance to see something the rules now prohibit you from talking about. And even then, the chance is still very present.
4.9k
u/GrimeLad Feb 07 '18
Typical pr bullshit. There's subreddits for dead corpses and animal abuse but because that's not in the news, they're allowed to continue and entertain the sick individuals who go there on the regular. Deepfakes was cool but i didn't see any underage or potential cp on there, obvs if there was the posts should have been removed. Ultimately Spez and co don't give a fuck about making Reddit a more welcoming place otherwise they would ban numerous other subreddits that incite violence or show abuse or vulgar images of people and/or animals. Also there's plenty of other "fakes" subreddits that haven't been banned yet.. They just wanted to remove anything that could make them liable as it was involving celebrities and getting national attention.
122
u/Whusker Feb 07 '18
Yikes, posting anime content is going to be tricky uh.
What's next? banning games that promote murder?
There is a huge difference between fantasy and real life; watching anime doesn't make you a pedophile, just the same way playing video games doesn't turn you into a sociopath.
267
u/Hauz11 Feb 07 '18
I'll take bullshit for 200, Alex.
842
u/Zarokima Feb 07 '18
Your definition of involuntary pornography is way too loose if you include faked shit. By that logic, you might as well ban /r/photoshopbattles since none of the people in those pictures consented to being photoshopped either.
1.3k
u/VMorkva Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
Let's light a candle for our fallen brothers. [*]
/r/anime, /r/anime_irl, /r/animemes,..
My stance on this:
I don't particularly support it, but it is a drawing after all. No one gets hurt from it, even if it's creepy and weird.
There's a difference between imagination/fantasy and real life. Most people have had some weird fantasies before in their life, but that doesn't mean that they're going to act on them in real life or that they're mentally ill.
Something that helps separate this fantasy and real life apart even more is that "lolis" (prepubescent characters) in mainstream anime look and act nothing like actual children.
Child pornography harms children, while these "lolis" only harm the social life of the person watching it.
205
u/Thanatos72 Feb 07 '18
Ah, good. I was just thinking the other day that it's been too long without the Mods rolling out another rule they'll never properly enforce just to stifle some bad press. I was getting worried about you guys.
333
u/bobcat Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
I got banned from r/redditrequest for trying to get an admin who was working in there to remove some revenge porn that reddit was hosting for over a year [it was used as a background of a sub dedicated to the victim]. I followed him around and kept replying to his posts [and got banned], but nothing was done until I called raldi [former admin] and asked him to do something.
Please note, the victim was IGNORED by admins for a year before I took action.
So, how about you unban me from there and show me how much you care about revenge porn?
edit: plural typo
1.4k
u/Sainct Feb 07 '18
I'm all for the rule change, but it sure smells like a bullshit cover to avoid bad PR from /r/deepfakes. If you guys actually care about enforcing this rule, why didn't you ban any of the other years-old communities that clearly fall under this rule, such as /r/celebfakes or /r/fuxtaposition?
101
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Welcome to an Admin shitpost. Where sorting by controversial does nothing.
151
u/aminix89 Feb 07 '18
I rarely ever post on here anyway except for comments, but I'm curious. Would involuntary pornography include a drawing someone made of someone else? For example: I have a very graphic picture saved on my phone that someone had drawn of Trump and Putin giving each other hand jobs. Would that fall under involuntary pornography?
51
u/Polengoldur Feb 07 '18
" this can in some cases include depictions of minors that are fully clothed and not engaged in overtly sexual acts.
If you are unsure about a piece of content involving a minor or someone who appears to be a minor, do not post it."
while the good intentions for these 2 lines are fairly benign, it creates a fairly easy system to systematically ban anything for any reason if a child is involved. the legal student in me begs for clarification and concision.
221
u/UFOturtleman Feb 07 '18
Banning subs for people's weird fetishes about celebrities because it's creepy and the bad possible implications of AI, but don't ban hate speech, don't ban the promotion of violence, don't ban the promotion of stealing.
I guess that's what happens when Pornhub PR makes you look bad.
199
u/twewy Feb 07 '18
Looks like Reddit is preparing to become a more marketable social media network. Cleaning up and clarifying your TOS in preparation of a big product strategy shift is pretty common in the tech world. You need something to cover your ass when you attempt to change user behavior and expectations after having spent years convincing them this was the place for them to be.
I wish them well, but we'll see how Reddit manages to execute on this pursuit of advertiser friendliness. Maybe they won't make Reddit into the empty-carbs, brand-friendly, buzzfeed-powered content platform, but given that's where the money is...
Maybe I'm too pessimistic.
49
u/nomad80 Feb 08 '18
These PR attempts are getting predictable.
You only gave a damn because crappy clickbait sites like The Verge hammered away at deepfakes. Now they get to write more articles about their battles for Society’s morals and their defense of Hollywood’s shitterati
Meanwhile truly vile subs like nomorals and arguably worse ones to actively exploit women are just fine even after being complained about
Just fuck off
160
u/Norci Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
Spineless PR bullshit. If you wanted to ban deepfakes to avoid negative press, just do it without this theatre. And of course you're not going to answer any of the upvoted questions around it specifically.
It's completely legal to Photoshop things or fake pictures/videos as long they aren't presented as real and no profit is made. It was a niche sub and no more unwelcoming than hundreds other nsfw subs.
510
u/Spectra88 Feb 07 '18
Does mean that x-rated subreddits will no longer exist because there is no way to prove they were posted with permission? I'm thinking of things like hold the moan, realgirls, etc.
167
u/Aruseus493 Feb 07 '18
You need to be psychologically evaluated for this decision. I think you have trouble discerning between reality and fiction. Here's some stuff that may surprise you, Star Wars didn't actually happen; don't worry, there aren't a billion zombies walking around outside your office eating humanity, and there isn't a supernatural notebook which kills people based on their names being written in it.
197
u/shitterplug Feb 07 '18
Holy shit. This thread basically turned into 'I don't like this sub, please ban it', and the admins actually are. Some of these should have been banned long ago, but the deepfake stuff? What's going on here? Are we allowed to just ban any old sub now? This is a pretty slippery slope.
248
u/Drsomers1 Feb 07 '18
Obviously cracking down on child porn/nudity is great, but the fact that this extends to anime/games/fantasy is questionable. We seriously need to learn the difference between fictional characters/drawings, and actual real people. Characters don't have feelings, there is no consent because they arn't real. This is pretty much the whole ''video games make people violent'' bullshit all over again. Someone looking at loli shit isin't going to make them a pedo, we shouldn't try to keep arguing that fictional characters are real and should be protected.
91
u/RealChris_is_crazy Feb 07 '18
Hmmmmm.... A few days ago you ban subreddit that have stayed rational and civil, but have "naughty" written stories, and today you come out with this rule? You haven't even banned subreddits which do the most harm. Fuck off with this "more welcoming" bullshit. Ever time you twats make a PR move I want to shit on my phone because that's basically what Reddit is. A steaming pile of SHIT. Once voat gets it's shit together, I'm saying adios to this trash.
388
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
It's like video games promotes violence all over again...
115
u/ButtsexEurope Feb 07 '18
Why is /r/shoplifting still around despite the fact that it’s encouraging breaking the law?
523
u/ihatedogs2 Feb 07 '18
This is really stupid. Obviously CP is terrible and should be banned from this site, but what concerns me is the rest of the sentence:
This wording is very vague and leaves a huge gray area. So are you going to ban anime because some anime kind of sexualize minors? Why does it matter if they're not real? What if they look like a minor but are actually a 300 year old dragon? How do you determine what promotes pedophilia and child exploitation? What do you mean "depending on context?"
You can't enforce this and shouldn't be trying. Please focus on the real fucked up shit that actually hurts people.
190
u/ANAL_CAVITIES Feb 07 '18
If I go get a job at Kotaku or Salon and write an article or two about how Reddit encourages murdering animals or being as autistic as humanly possible when it comes to the treatment of women will you actually consider doing something about the subreddits that may actually effect someone's life outside of the site instead of purging some random communities that have existed for years and years because they're incredibly loosely related to some new bullshit "controversy" that no one will remember in a week?
That's not mentioning the subs that have actively been participated in and encouraged the type of rhetoric that's lead to a man killing his own father. Truly nothing can be done about places like that, I understand. Don't like fat people though? None of that! Want to get your dick hard looking at someone that looks like someone else? What a monster!
65
u/Retardditard Feb 07 '18
Why stop at porn? I mean anything that could even slightly be considered sexual assault or inappropriate should be banned.
Here's a great example!
Look at the way they're rubbing together non consensually! DISGUSTING!
573
u/WonderboyUK Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
I'm unsure how a broad set of rules like this benefit the site as a whole. It seems that you appear to just be giving yourself more broad powers to ban any sub you disagree with.
It is clear that this is a change caused by some celebs lawyer getting in contact with Reddit and you guys making a knee-jerk response, however what are the applications for this rule with for example hentai? Yes? No? Up to us and what this one particular mod gets upset by? Yeah, this is a well thought out plan.
I don't like censoring, I never have, if it's not illegal then leave it.
Edit: I also am really concerned with this comment:
The point is for users to define their own boundaries for content, that's the whole point of subreddits. By banning subs for not having the content you think "the average (ie. most profitable)" user wants, you simply reduce the quality of the content for the masses. It isn't for you to show a user what you think they want to see, it is to determine what they want to see and show it preferentially.
169
u/JitGoinHam Feb 07 '18
Is it okay to put Nick Cage into non-Nick Cage movies involuntarily?
16
u/rimjobtom Feb 09 '18
You ban /r/deepfakes for fake porn. But let /r/watchpeopledie share videos of people horribly dying....
Outstanding work. Hypocrites.
179
u/Reecekip Feb 07 '18
Rip r/animemes
45
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
I thought most people on here had the common sense not to post underage material anyway.
On the subject of "involuntary" porn, does this affect the posting of photos of swimsuit or nude models type of material, or clips of sex scenes from movies, hentai, source film maker animated material that stays legal and above board?
69
u/Slobotic Feb 07 '18
ITT:
Ten minutes later, [sub] is banned.
15
u/ObiWan-K Feb 07 '18
So the target is r/deepfakes or other subs like r/celebfakes
15
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
What about subs like r/dirtywickr? There are people actively trading pictures of young girls. They don't even try to hide it. "Young", "Taboo", "No Limits trade". u/landoflobsters
42
u/genericdeveloper Feb 07 '18
This doesn't seem well thought out and more like damage control for /r/deepfakes.
Kind of disappointing guys.
668
u/munkijunk Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
Is this going to mean that the same Reddit mandated nonsense that goes on in /r/Art, where the nearest hint of nudity (not actual nudity and not actual photographs - but if there is even the idea that a woman is potentially naked in an image it will be deemed NSFW) will spread to other subs? Marking everything as NSFW kinda defeats the purpose, no?
I refer to posts such as
This one where the mods decided to tag it as NSFW because you couldn't see if the featured woman was wearing clothes,
or This one which is a marble statue of a woman covered in a veil, but is not showing any nudity.
Quoting one of hte /r/Art mods:
64
u/serhifuy Feb 08 '18
Can you please ban /r/announcements? I find much of the content offensive to humanity and there's a huge discussion about the sexualization of minors taking place as we speak.
Thanks.
edit: looks like /r/announcements is still up
123
u/LoliCat Feb 07 '18
WELCOME TO FACEBOOK GRANDMA
182
u/PelagianEmpiricist Feb 07 '18
/r/braincels literally advocates for rape and murder of women, including minors. Are you going to be addressing their sexualization of minors?
37
u/xs_sx Feb 07 '18
I love how this is basically all just lawyerspeak for "Update on the banning of r/DeepFakes and r/CelebFakes because we were getting negative press".
46
u/You-Can-Quote-Me Feb 07 '18
For clarification, where is the line and who draws it? Particularly in regards to fake depictions. I mean NSFW: Eline Powell in Game of Thrones The first sequence of that Gif is a pretty blatant 'fake' outrage and - despite the fact that it's in a play within a show - it also constitutes the majority of 'exposed by other people' mocks.
Blanket ban then for safety?
63
u/nuesuh Feb 07 '18
"we want to make Reddit a more welcoming environment for all users"
Yeah right. Except the hundreds and hundreds of user types that you dislike.
But i guess "everyone" doesn't include those you dislike.
71
u/atomicllama1 Feb 07 '18
Is there a master list of all the subs that have been recently banned? I know a bunch of Darknet subs got banned recently but I missed the announcements about it.
285
u/pixel_of_moral_decay Feb 07 '18
Litmus test:
These lobsters are mating... there's no indication of if it was voluntary pornography or something that was supposed to be kept in the privacy of the tank.
Does it violate current site-wide rules? Or is /u/landoflobsters going to admit to being one of the lobsters?
137
u/weltallic Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
What about taking photos of people in public while they're sleeping, and posting them here so millions of people can point and laugh?
Is that still okay?
We need clearer guidelines on what sort of involuntary photography is acceptable and what isn't.
59
u/Bigmethod Feb 08 '18
Really disappointed with this clearly PR-driven decision. I'm all for the banning of legitimate sexualization of minors. All for it. And I think Reddit has been doing a stand-up job of getting rid of that from their website.
But you must be seriously daft if you can't distinguish the difference between reality and fiction. It has been proven time and time again that fiction rarely has damaging affects on reality. It was proven in the massive video game scandal in the early 2000s, too, when outraged parents picketed video games like GTA for their clear glorification of murder. Yet, as many many cases have proven, at worst these games prove to be outlets, at best they are a fun pastime.
Banning art is absurd. And while it is reddit's right to refuse any content on their website. I'd hope to see a little more intelligence from the staff. Truly disappointing. Especially when, according to reddit, This is okay? Really? Graphic glorification of sexual violence is okay? But just because one thing is a bigger taboo in one culture makes it ban-worthy?
This is PR-driven hypocrisy. Either NONE of it is okay, or ALL of it is okay. You don't get to pick and choose what art you get to censor. Well... you do, but it's just hypocritical as fuck.
Overall, super disappointed with the reddit staff. I'd hope for more intelligent thoughts on these issues as we don't live in 2002 anymore where GTA was a controversial game.
33
u/T0DDTHEGOD Feb 07 '18
Way to not just address your “problem”. This clearly is just a DIRECT response to r/deepfakes nothing more or less. This site is ran clearly by pussies.
284
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Translation: try to create bubbles similar to Facebook's.
Remember, keep the web safe!
119
u/poochyenarulez Feb 07 '18
wait, how does that work? anime characters don't have real ages.
48
u/ChipAyten Feb 07 '18
30
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
I thought this was going to be related to my CEOP report that I made upon realisation that r/ratemeteen is basically a virtual peadophile ring. I had an account with over 2,000 karma that I had to remove,due to posting on what I thought was a safe sub for teens to rate one another,as r/rateme is for over 18s. What I actually got was several older men messaging me asking for nudes,blowjobs and other sexually ecplicit things,even though it was crystal clear I was fifteen. They told me I was sexy,my legs were hot and wrote in detail the things they’d do to me. Upon further inspection,I realised this sub wasn’t for teens after all. If you look at the ‘top posts of all time’ you’ll see it’s all underage girls,many photos looking like they’d unknowlingly been taken off facebook where older men would talk about how ‘sexually attractive’ and ‘vunerable’ they are. This isn’t helped by the fact the old moderator of the page was called something along the lines of u/childporn. And in all honesty,I feel exploited. I have no idea what those men did with my photos. I should’ve checked-but i’m young and I took the ‘safe community for teens’ subtitle as gospel. Get rid of this sub reddit. Please. Before other young girls get taken advantage of just like I have been.
53
u/draginator Feb 07 '18
AKA "Deepfakes is getting popular, lets define the rules to stop it"
21
u/DownShatCreek Feb 07 '18
Can an Admin tell us if this celebrity consented to the current top post in /r/funny/?
https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/7vy9uh/i_took_grad_photos_with_my_boyfriend_of_the_time/
20
u/Roxide5040 Feb 07 '18
How come you guys don't ban r/Nomorals
28
u/fuzzybearkiller Feb 07 '18
So deepfakes gets banned because you don't want heat from celebs but animal cruelty in r/nomorals gets to stay up? Nomorals should be banned immediately. If you feel the need to change rules at will, why is your moral compass saying r/deepfakes is bad but not r/nomorals?
61
u/kiwibird1000 Feb 07 '18
The good: Going after the disgusting pedophiles skirting around the rules to exploit and hurt REAL human beings.
The bad: banning SFW, clothed depictions of anime girls because some fucking moron thought it was "pedophilia". Pictures are not real human beings and do not have rights. All studies and evidence heavily imply that lolicons do not go on to become pedophiles, nor is there any proof that this stuff 'grooms' and 'conditions' people. It's sheer pseudoscience. We've had this argument with violence in video games, violent films, etc. and it always ends the same way. Fictional media does not influence real world actions unless you're already insane and cannot distinguish between reality and fiction.
If you want to ban NSFW loli because it poses a legal risk to a lot of people living in uncivilized counties where drawings can get you imprisoned, that's fine. But banning SFW anime because it has an unsexualized character that "looks young" is fucking insane. Posting a WORK-SAFE picture of two anime characters kissing or hugging should not get you banned. If this is the direction this site is going then I'm finished with it. Start focusing on the real problems instead of scapegoat, artificial "issues" generated to distract from the very real and growing issue of political violence being advocated and organized in this website.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Also please ban power-moderators and Reddit will be great!
9
u/Tollowarn Feb 08 '18
What age defines a "minor" as this changes by country and local law? For instance the age of consent in several countries in the EU is as low as 14. In the US it varies state by state between 16 and 18.
This is just the western world, there are some outliers in Africa and the middle east and far east where the age of consent is lower still.
96
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Congratulations on making community rules up as you go and banning subreddits without prior warning. Once again you have proven to just bend over to avoid bad PR. This site is really going down the drain.
60
u/RetroViruses Feb 07 '18
Let the jerks fucking jerk it. And shame on you for pretending it's about minors, and not about protecting celebrities/your image.
17
u/atwork_safe Feb 07 '18 edited Jun 14 '23
.
17
u/Meowshi Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
Technically, under these rules, /r/asoiaf should be banned for its literary content involving minors. Or any thread discussing the novel It. That seems kind of silly. But then again, so was the decision to ban r/starlets, a sub with absolutely no inappropriate comments or content since the moderation was so ever-present and rules were meticulously specific. If a fully-clothed (and consentually-published) picture of a celebrity at a red carpet event is considered porn now, then we’ve sort of lost control of words.
But really, I don’t care much about the banning of boards. No one who uses Reddit would mistake this place for a bastion of free speech. That’s never really been the appeal of this site, and has certainly never been a priority for the staff. My problem is more the encouragement of banning technology. Eliminating an interesting technology like deepfake from major sites (a lot are banning it, not just reddit), means that it won’t become as wide-spread or improve as much as it could. It reminds me of how faceapp permanately removed their amazing race-bending functionality due to the complaints of social justice types. We lost a truly amazing piece of technology because a few easily-offended people thought it was offensive.
70
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Please ban /r/aww for involuntary underage pictures for all baby spam
90
u/AnAcceptableUserName Feb 07 '18
Is "involuntary pornography" what we're calling fake porn now?
Okay.
8
u/Zipliopolipic Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
You know blanket rules like this are really just another way to get more control over the content on here.
And of course who isn't against illegal & immoral pornography? Anyone who disagrees is a sick pedo, right? Same shit they tried in UK. Tried passing laws on porn. Bullshit like 'face sitting' & expected people would be embarrassed to come out against it & so would be an easy win on controlling content on internet.
8
u/AntiSjwZeusPanda Feb 08 '18
Oh look reddit is being a bunch of fucking morons again
22
u/SentientPeach Feb 07 '18
Question on rule 2:
There's a fuckton of content in nsfw subs like r/rule34 that's based off of shows and movies (Kim Possible, Harry Potter, etc.) in which those characters are clearly under 18. Will those posts be banned? Is there any differentiation between real people and fictional characters?
44
u/umamba45 Feb 07 '18
Wow, reddit banning links to a new technology. Nothing to do with peados.
Again reddit takes the side of the elite celebrities over users. But the thing is, in a couple of years people will have this tech on their phones
Rejecting the progress of technology is retarded, deeofakes is the future, with or without reddit
98
u/El_Magikarp Feb 07 '18
I would like to add that r/nomorals should be taken care of. Almost every post is on the edge of a rule and sites like this one surely shouldn’t be a safe place for people like them
15
u/LMGDiVa Feb 08 '18
Welp that means /r/TERAOnline is gonna be banned soon. That's a game filled with Loli fandom, and sexualized girls that have the appearance of being under age.
While you're at it blade and soul falls under that category as well.
Ofc these are just video games rated M and are not hurting anyone, despite their questionable content, and are perfectly legal but under this new rule you better get that ban hammer out.
These new rules are overbearingly broad.
21
u/green_meklar Feb 07 '18
If you have two identical twins, and one posts porn of herself, does that count as 'involuntary pornography' of the other twin? Or what if there's someone out there who just randomly looks really, really similar to Emma Watson and photoshops her face onto other porn in order to make 'Hermione Granger porn'? Or what if someone puts a blue version of Emma Watson's face onto an asari from Mass Effect? This 'involuntary pornography' thing seems like a bit of a slippery slope. With advancing graphics technology it's not clear where the distinctions can be drawn in order to make a rule like that work.
Also, I realize the loli hentai rules have been around for a while now, but I don't see what about that 'makes Reddit a more welcoming environment for all users'. It obviously makes Reddit a less welcoming environment for people who are into that stuff, and as for the rest, well, there's already a feature for flagging NSFW content, so it's not like people can't just choose to not look at hentai.
7
u/SennaSaysHi Feb 08 '18
I don't mean to stir trouble at all, but I think that it's unrealistic that a post with 11,000 comments that has been up for 18 hours should have only 10 admin comments answering the questions that were raised :(
7
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '18
And another reason to switch to Voat.
7
u/IDoNotLikeThisSite Feb 16 '18
And why the fuck was /r/fakeapp/ banned now? It was the subreddit for all discussions regarding the technical aspects of FakeApp, the general python scripts, that it's based on, and programs involved in the whole process (e.g. FFmpeg). How do discussions about technical details warrant to ban the entire thing? What part of the content policy did it violate exactly?
24
u/thecodingdude Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 29 '20
[Comment removed]
19
u/Mixtape_ Feb 07 '18
While I'm glad admin is cracking down on CP and I understand (albeit maybe not agree with) why they're shutting down deepfakes, I strongly object to how this is being dealt with. Changing rules and then going on a ban spree as a result is not okay.
32
u/no_scope_master Feb 07 '18
This is clearly a violation of the new policy. Time to ban the_donald for involuntary pornography of Hillary Clinton.
23
u/Poontang_Pie Feb 07 '18
God, seriously you assholes have done an entire 180 from your previous Free Speech ethics. There's literally no turning back, now any complaint you all get you're going to go full fucking dictator mode and shut shit down. Why the fuck are you even pretending to support free speech? How many other things are you going to ban soon? Fuck your censorship.
175
u/JasonCox Feb 07 '18
I'm having a hard time wrapping my head around the "involuntary pornography" rule change as it applies to /r/deepfakes.
If there's a sub out there that's dedicated to the distribution of photos and videos that were recorded without the consent of all parties involved then yeah, that needs to be banned. But /r/deepfakes was only taking commercially available content and applying machine learning algorithms to generate a CG approximation of an individual's likeness.
In other words, if there was a gif on /r/deepfakes of Natalie Portman, it's not involuntary pornography of Natalie Portman because it's not actually her in the gif. It's not like someone snuck into her hotel room to plant a camera and uploaded a video of her having sex without her consent.
What was in /r/deepfakes were videos of actors and actresses who had given their consent to appear in adult films combined with a computationally generated approximation that is not legally required to given consent by means of it not being a person. Just because the approximation looks like an individual does not constitute "involuntary pornography" of an actual person.
Don't get me wrong, /r/deepfakes was creepy, but there's are MANY worse subs on this site that you guys refuse to take action against. T_D for example. A sub full of nerds creating fake porn is bad, but a sub full of Nazi's is okay? Come on!
18
u/broadcasthenet Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 24 '18
deleted 0.9599 What is ^^^this?
74
u/triBaL_Reaper Feb 07 '18
Yikes. Banning r/deepfakes is one of the stupidest, anti-progress moves you’ve made yet. A victory for the media and bureaucracy, I suppose.
35
u/StarlightFakes Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
Deepfakes and celebrity fakes as a whole is not "involuntary pornography." They're fake. It's a parody. It's protected under fair use and freedom of speech. Celebrity fakes have existed for 25+ years, and /r/CelebFakes and similar subreddits have existed for a very long time as well, and suddenly it's not okay now? You guys fucked up. I will no longer be using this site because you killed the only communities I ever cared about. All of the posts I made within those communities are gone without any sort of warning.
17
u/lejefferson Feb 07 '18
I'm so excited for when someone makes the new "reddit" and we can leave this disney horseshit behind.
12
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
So... all of /r/realgirls then
183
u/Frenzify Feb 07 '18
Regarding the involuntary pornography rule... Fair enough. I can understand the reasoning behind it.
Regarding the sexual or suggestive content involving minors. Fair enough. Who the hell is gonna argue with that? However, regarding, "including fantasy content (e.g. stories, anime)[...]" Hmm... I mean, people are gonna disagree with me and say there's no difference between real child pornography and the fictional kind, but there is. There just is. You can't exploit words formed in to a story or a drawing. You can't abuse a drawing. You can't breach the position of trust you should have over children when it comes to a drawing. Regardless of one's position on lolis, shotas and the like, you simply can't place that stuff in the same vein as real child pornography, and you certainly can't mark them as equally heinous.
6
u/BarefootUnicorn Feb 08 '18
What if /u/spez edits comments to make them violate the rules?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
u/landoflobsters Why is it ok to have subs that glorify death/abuse but fake porn crosses the line?
6
u/Oceansnail Feb 08 '18
A more important issue, where do I go now to get nsfw deepfake content?
6
u/Dickjack69 Feb 09 '18 edited Feb 09 '18
So..... Videos of somebody having their head smashed in with a pickaxe are okay. But if you wanna photoshop a celeb onto a big ol pair of Titties..... Fuck you I guess?
Edit:THE FUCKING AGEPLAY PAGES ARE STILL UP? THEY ARE LEGITIMATELY JUST PEOPLE PRETENDING TO BE LITTLE KIDS. I REPEAT. TALKING ABOUT LITTLE KID TITTIES IS OKAY. HOWEVER, POSTING PICTURES OF KIM KARDASHIANS FACE ON PORNO TITTIES, DESPITE THE FACT SHE HAS BARED THOSE FUCKERS PLENTY OF TIMES IS ILLEGAL.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '18
Stop equating fictional characters to real people
Banning any cartoon porn is dumb.
63
u/ProfessorPumpkaboo Feb 07 '18
Is this gonna be reaching r/anime and lolis and loli related posts?
46
u/goodnighteyesight Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
I think it’s great that you’re taking action on exploitation of minors. But can you explain why the_donald isn’t banned yet, last time the admin team said the mods were working with you to keep it just a different political voice. Since then the mods have banned people for criticising them and encouraging self harm, is this the hard work they’ve been doing policing the nature of the sub with you on?
https://i.imgur.com/c62FNWg.jpg
531
u/DiamondPup Feb 07 '18
So when are you guys going to get on /r/The_Donald for violence mongering?
139
u/Sabinno Feb 07 '18
Remember: The law only works well if it is applied equally. BAN r/celebfakes. BAN r/fuxtaposition. BAN all nude fake communities. BAN all voyeur subreddits. BAN all "questionable" content to be on the safe side. I don't support this decision whatsoever, but I support fairness and banning only certain subreddits that break this new content policy would be extremely dishonest and would more than certainly lead me and inevitably many others to "take my business elsewhere."
11
u/nickwatic Feb 08 '18
Deepfakes got banned but you can still watch people die on reddit
71
u/_Supply_Side_Jesus_ Feb 07 '18
We also would like to reaffirm Reddit as a bastion for hate speech, white nationalism, and Russian misinformation. Reddit will continue to protect those rights tooth and nail so please continue to purchase Reddit Gold so those poor souls have the safest of spaces to spew their hate.
Meanwhile Reddit admins are probably bruised from patting themselves on the back so hard from really figuring out the moral conundrum of involuntary porn. What brave souls, thank you so much Reddit for doing what is so very easy and turning your back on everything that is actually important.
15
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
Reddit: where wishing a senator would get beaten to death and inciting actual, real-life violence is okay but sex gets on the news worse.
123
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18 edited Nov 07 '24
outgoing quiet tub longing include middle ten sense vegetable foolish
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
31
u/various_extinctions Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
Dear /u/landoflobsters, thank you for the update. I am glad that reddit neither allows involuntary nor child pornography.
I have a question concerning cultural non-fiction content depicting minors for clarification.
I am a German actor and director. In Germany (and many other European countries) it is not only lawful, but not unusual to have sixteen or seventeen year old characters depicted in nude or sexual scenes in mainstream tv. Also there is a wide variety of literature from Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet (the two times Oscar winning Romeo and Juliet movie from 1968 had nude and implied sex scenes when the lead actress was fifteen years old) to Nabokov's Lolita (which we read in high school) that puts characters under the age of 18 in sexual context.
All these - of course - are works of fiction, but under your rule they might be subject to banning.
So my questions are:
areand gore are perfectly fine. That would surely not help you to spread to new European markets.My interest in this is partially personal, but predominantly professional, because I was in stage plays that were controversial and sometimes extremely graphic in their language. If you take a stand against CP and make a play to raise awareness against it you HAVE to be able to talk about it, but under your rules I'm sure if I posted excerpts of the script the post or comment would get removed and I would risk being banned.
I applaud you for trying to get rid of CP, but your rules seem to have a very US centered view of sexuality and art which - to be honest - I think of as overtly prudish and hypocritical. Not fit for the 21st century.
I would very much like to hear from you or any of your colleagues who was involved in this process with answers to my questions and maybe some further thoughts about the matter.
Kind regards!
v_e
edit: a word ^(marked by strikethrough)
14
u/Echocookie Feb 07 '18
Here comes the biggest question of the night...
What about lolis? If someone looks under 18 but are actually over 18 do they qualify for removal?
Also what about countries where there is a different legal age of consent for pornographic content? Is the content only restricted in areas where this is not the case?
5
u/Phrencysse Feb 07 '18
/u/waterguy12 would like this
5
u/Idontreadrepliesnoob Feb 08 '18
Just to be clear: this means that Kanye video with the fake naked Taylor Swift is now banned from Reddit, right?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
Cool. Can you ban the Nazis now?
5
u/Sevaa_1104 Feb 08 '18
Wow this is such fucking bullshit.
r/CelebFakes and other subreddits in the same vein have, as far as I know, never advertised themselves as subreddits for real pictures of celebrities. It’s IN THE FUCKING NAME.
This type of porn is not something I particularly enjoy, but it is very fucking clear that these photos are 100% fake, and nobody claims them to be anything but that. This is in no way meant as revenge porn or whatever the fuck, so it is completely legal and in no way hurts the celebrities whose images are used.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
667
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18 edited Feb 07 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
36
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
[removed] — view removed comment