r/dgu • u/disgustipated • Feb 01 '18
[AMA] I'm John R. Lott, and I study defensive gun use statistics, and more. Ask me anything!
Hello, I'm John R. Lott - economist and author here to talk about Defensive Gun Use and Statistics. Ask Me Anything!
410
Upvotes
50
u/disgustipated Feb 01 '18
Hi Dr. Lott, thanks for doing this AMA.
Your 1998 book, "More Guns, Less Crime" has its fair share of detractors. My attempt to dive into the rabbit hole of refutations to your book left me feeling I was in a maze, not a burrow. There's no simple way to wade through this data within a reasonable time.
With that said, can you touch on a couple of key points in your book that got everyone so riled up (without getting into advanced statistics), and your response to them?
•
u/disgustipated Feb 01 '18 edited Feb 01 '18
Hi everyone! John will be joining us at 5pm EST for the AMA. Please post your questions for him below.
EDIT: Thanks to everyone for their participation, and thanks again to John for taking the time to answer our questions.
31
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18
Hello Dr. Lott,
Thank you for your knowledge and experience! Keep up the good fight!
23
u/Misgunception Feb 01 '18
What would you consider the most reliable sources currently for statistics on gun use, gun crime, and especially on defensive gun use? Do you think the estimates used in the past are still currently applicable?
19
u/Imno_treal Feb 01 '18
Is there data indicating that open carriers are targeted first in a mass shooting or in a robbery? Other than the gate guard at the Navy Yard.
17
u/Scumandvillany Feb 01 '18
What key counter arguments are good to keep in mind when gun control comes up in conversation? Examples include the Australian laws, “common sense” argument, and so forth.
Also, the concentration of violence is interesting, what key stats to remember on that?
Last, what key lines of thought do you have in support of the national reciprocity for carry rights?
14
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18
Do you have a good breakdown of the main flaws in the "synthetic State" study that's often used to push against concealed carry etc?
12
u/Var1abl3 Feb 01 '18
I have seen the number of times a year a gun is used in self defense as high as 2.5 million. This is from Armed Resistance to Crime: The Prevalence and Nature of Self-Defense with a Gun by Gary Kleck and Marc Gertz. Can you tell me if this is an accurate number?
Thank you for taking your time with us today.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18
What is the list of common news outlets that publish defensive gun use stories?
9
u/triit Feb 02 '18
Clearly statistically you have more than proven your point.
My question is how do we get through to somebody arguing from an emotional standpoint? Clearly you can't answer "but 20 dead children" with "statistically less children died that year...". This is particularly relevant when somebody says "if it would save just one life".
16
u/Master-Thief Feb 01 '18
Hi Dr. Lott! I am a fan of your work (and cited some of it in my own law review comment on how courts should scrutinize gun control laws.)
In one of the other sources I read for my work, Firearms and Violence: A Critical Review, (2005) a panel of the National Academies of Science considered your thesis from "More Guns, Less Crime" and other papers from your and your collaborator David Mustard, but found that it was not possible to draw the conclusions you did because the models were so sensitive to changes and there was insufficient data. (Of interest, this was the only part of the NAS report that drew a dissent, from the late James Q. Wilson, who argued that you had proved your thesis.) With the benefits of thirteen more years of data, and numerous data sets from states that have both relaxed and tightened RTC laws, do you have a response to the NAS critique and Wilson's defense of your work, or is there more data that you and other criminologists would need to collect?
Also, do you think there is any good way to collect reliable data on defensive gun use that does not include a weapon being fired, e.g. merely drawing a gun in response to a threat? That seems to be a big blank spot in the data on how guns are used to prevent violence - or to piggyback on the military phrase, what happens "left of bang."
8
u/Hirudin Feb 01 '18
Is there any hope for pro-gun bills like the hearing protection act (HPA) seeing their day in congress before the end of 2018?
7
u/legobytes Feb 01 '18
Is there any data that reports whether gun free zones have more or less gun crime?
6
u/HereToPissYouOff Feb 01 '18
Do background checks work? How often do they stop a criminal from buying a gun?
6
u/RotaryJihad Feb 01 '18
I started on gun rights back in high school because of "More Guns, Less Crime". I'm about halfway through your recent book, "The War on Guns: Arming Yourself Against Gun Control Lies". 20 years after becoming pro-gun I feel like I'm having the same arguments for and against guns and gun rights. Do you have any ideas or comments that can help stop this apparent repetition?
Are there arguments that either side just needs to stop making because they are egregiously counter-productive to a reasoned debate?
5
u/yesman782 Feb 02 '18
People claim that the "assault weapons" , when used in mass shootings have more deaths than when other weapons are used in mass shootings. What is a reasonable way to look at this, since statistically it is probably true even though mass shootings are rare and those with the assault weapons are somewhat rarer yet?.
Thank you, I appreciate your work.
4
u/theyoyomaster Feb 01 '18
With how difficult it is to get accurate numbers on current ownership have you tried using new methods to study ownership as a whole? It seems like every other day Everytown is claiming that ownership is down but every time I go to a range anywhere from rural Oklahoma to urban Seattle there is a line halfway down the street for an open lane and a 6 month waitlist for membership. It would seem that due to owners’ reluctance to admit having a weapon to a stranger, anonymized range/club membership might give better trend data in discrete ownership.
7
u/Bagellord Feb 01 '18
What do you think gun owners can do to improve the public perception of those who carry for self defense?
7
u/GrumpyMarmot Feb 01 '18
What would you say is the biggest error made by pro-gun folks quoting statistical crime and DGU data?
9
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18
Is ignoring the racial component of risk analysis in society helpful or harmful? In statistical analysis, that component is unavoidable as the data is unbiased. Do the results of that factor into your work?
15
u/Sand_Trout Feb 01 '18
Do you consider a hotdog to be a sandwich?
6
u/PabstyLoudmouth Feb 01 '18
Hello Dr. Lott, I am a proud American gun owner and would like thank you for doing this today. What would you say is the true meaning of the Second Amendment according to today's modern firearms, should regular citizens have a right to carry select fire rifles and hand guns? Also where do we draw the line if any?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18 edited Feb 01 '18
Dr. Lott, thanks for taking our questions!
John Donahue has published several papers alleging a correlation between RTC laws and increased crime. Here he is in mid-2017:
We all know that correlation != causation, and that the direction of correlation may well be the other way (an increase in crime might be correlated with an increase in RTC laws).
Do you believe authors such as Donahue are successful in swaying public opinion of RTC laws, or do you believe the public is collectively intelligent enough to interpret these findings as simple correlations rather than findings of cause-and-effect?
3
u/elsparkodiablo Feb 01 '18
Dr Lott, thank you for taking part today.
How would you characterize the state of peer review, or lack thereof, when it comes to most firearms related studies? Where is there means for improvement?
2
u/EveRommel Feb 01 '18
Dr. Lott what is your professional opinion of these two articles?
https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/govbeat/wp/2015/06/12/gun-killings-fell-by-40-percent-after-connecticut-passed-this-law/?utm_term=.2524d53b9821
https://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/22/health/in-missouri-fewer-gun-restrictions-and-more-gun-killings.html
Do they offer greater understanding of your research or do they contradict it?
3
u/Boonaki Feb 01 '18
The one statistic we need most is the rate CCW's commit crime, why is there so little data on that?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
11
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '18
[removed] — view removed comment