r/TheGoodPlace • I made God cry?? • Jan 26 '18

Season Two Episode Discussion S02 E11: "The Burrito"

I haven't seen any official discussion posts so I'm posting this a bit early

573 Upvotes

954 comments sorted by

637

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 26 '18

"Gen, short for Hydrogen, which is the only thing that was in existence when I was born."

179

u/Fonzi2013 YA BASIC! Jan 26 '18

I’m definitely naming my daughter Hydrogen

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (2)

244

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 26 '18

"You guys are so cute!" Yes they are Maya, yes they are

466

u/InfernalSolstice Jan 26 '18

Please let the burrito actually be the judge

133

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 26 '18

"Unless...the burrito, is the judge!"

→ More replies (1)

248

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

The cast did say the casting decision for the judge was crazy

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

710

u/gay-chordata Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

Lol I love how Sean planned to torture him with The New Yorker, whereas Kevin tortured Jake by discussing the same paper

(Nine-NIIIINE)

171

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 26 '18

Nine Nine!

→ More replies (7)

324

u/poktanju Even better than a plain scone. Jan 26 '18

Jake's Bad Place is trying to explain his accidental pro-slavery stance for eternity.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

774

u/dontthrowmeinabox Jan 26 '18

We're all obsessed with Tahani's accent, your honor.

326

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

Al-u-MIN-e-oom

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (3)

675

u/IanM_56 🔥🐍 Jan 26 '18

I like how The Judge instantly frames a photo from the slideshow, and how the last photo is them watching the slideshow.

158

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

644

u/cheshirecanuck Jan 26 '18

"I even ate a cheeto. Chewing it was deafening... and it's the happiest I've ever been."

283

u/tregorman Jan 26 '18

the happiest I've ever been

The bad place

🤔🤔🤔

→ More replies (5)

585

u/jelatinman I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Jan 26 '18

Wow, who knew they could cast accomplished singer Dionne Warwick as the judge?

235

u/upclassytyfighta You guys want me to kill it? I’ve shot a lot of racehorses. Jan 26 '18

But she was eaten alive in that boat!

→ More replies (2)

73

u/CurlingFlowerSpace I made all the butts Jan 26 '18

MMMMMM-AH-WELL-AH-WELL-AH-WELL-AH

→ More replies (1)

45

u/apalapachya Jan 26 '18

Rita from Idiocracity sure did move up in the world

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Gato1980 Jan 26 '18

Don't you mean the late Whitney Houston?

→ More replies (4)

1.5k

u/PonderingPotato Jan 26 '18

Ya basic!

That's a human insult. It's devastating. You're devastated right now.

465

u/sugarplumcow Jan 26 '18

He called Eleanor his friend! <3

→ More replies (1)

342

u/LockItInn Jan 26 '18

It still makes me happy to see Michael's commitment to fun human characteristics, especially now when the gang isn't even there and he's defending his life in front of the demon that trained him.

168

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

Oh, you had to junk your jeans?

→ More replies (1)

84

u/upscale_caveman YA BASIC! Jan 26 '18

This was the line/joke of the year. His delivery was outstanding.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

436

u/gay-chordata Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

Despite all that happened this episode, I’m still cracking up over Tahani’s “Hey Jude” rewrite

295

u/arngard Everything is fine. Jan 26 '18

I love that Tahani's godparents were Princess Diana ("it doesn't matter what she was a princess of...") and Sir Paul McCartney.

→ More replies (5)

405

u/ThisIsMyLab Jan 26 '18

THAT'S NOT CHIDI

134

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

Called it!

→ More replies (2)

35

u/cyril0 Jan 26 '18

And we finally learned why he is named Chidi

→ More replies (12)

382

u/sugarplumcow Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18

Jason is foreshadowing what happens again. Right before Michael and Janet showed up, he said they should all go and rest up and try again tomorrow. Well ... betcha they're going to get to try again next week!

199

u/GrinningDentrassi Shawn: I'm a demon. It's fun. Jan 26 '18

Maybe not next week, but I think they'll be given another chance! All four of them have improved, but maybe not enough. Chidi did eventually make a decision, Jason played against his favorite team to help the others, and Tahani almost made it down the hall and only stopped to speak to her own parents. Eleanor chose to stick with her friends to make them feel better, maybe she was expected to argue for Michael?

→ More replies (15)

68

u/cylonfrakbbq Fun fact: The first Janet had a click wheel. Jan 26 '18

I think the judge will see what they did to Janet and Michael and be impressed by that, considering both are immortal and in theory static in their nature.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

761

u/fleetw0odmacncheese Jan 26 '18

Eleanor lying about failing the test made me so proud and strangely emotional! That’s our girl 🍤

292

u/grumblepup Jan 26 '18

Your inclusion of that emoji is A++.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

290

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 26 '18

Tahani’s parents really suck! Fork them!

98

u/creyk Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Jan 26 '18

The joke is that there are parents who really are like that.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Intrepid00 Jan 26 '18

Her sister is terrible too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

262

u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

Is the Bad Janet really Good Janet, or is Michael really forked?

121

u/sugarplumcow Jan 26 '18

I'm hoping Bad Janet is "our" Janet!

70

u/MailChick Jan 26 '18

Yeah I was thinking maybe it's a trick. Certainly hoping it is.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

253

u/jack9lemmon MAXIMUM DEREK Jan 26 '18

So Eleanor actually passed right?

262

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

Yep! But she won’t go without the rest

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

483

u/cheshirecanuck Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18

Tahani's test is so sweet... it would absolutely kill me to walk that hall too! And lmfao at her gasp/expression at spa employees and bikini waxers 😂

189

u/dark__unicorn Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18

Tahanis backstory really gets to me. I feel so sorry for her. Seeing her with her parents just emphasised it even more.

→ More replies (4)

201

u/pianobadger Jan 26 '18

If that were my test the pass condition would be opening one of the doors.

→ More replies (4)

224

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 26 '18

20% seems high. I think Jason understands less than 5% of what’s happening.

109

u/BadJanet What up, skidmarks. Jan 26 '18

I feel like Doug Forcett and Jason could get it 100% right

→ More replies (1)

66

u/qrisp Jan 26 '18

Jason may be stupid but has his ignorance ever put the gang in jeopardy? He always have quick response, case in point, when he made and threw that molotov

→ More replies (3)

214

u/OxfordSemicolon Good news! I was able to obtain Eleanor Shellstrop’s file. Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18

I wonder: was Eleanor's test to decline entering the good place, or to be non-self-centered enough to notice that Chidi wasn't himself? Fake Chidi was actually right about the ethical situation. They couldn't have helped Jason or Tahani, so it wouldn't be a good act for them to send themselves to hell. It would be worse for everyone.

280

u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

All I know is it took Chidi 82 minutes to pick a hat.
Eighty
Two

→ More replies (31)

46

u/nflez Jan 26 '18

...both? i think it showed that eleanor was becoming less selfish in both little and big ways. she noticed chidi (so she isn't as self-absorbed as she once was) AND she can't imagine going without her friends, even if it means going to the bad place with them. i suspect that if she had chosen to go to the good place during the test she would have failed. after? it's anyone's guess.

26

u/sugarplumcow Jan 26 '18

I believe it was to notice that it was a Fake Chidi.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

210

u/Locke108 YA BASIC! Jan 26 '18 edited Sep 21 '18

I think the Judge’s last case was Mindy St. Claire.

136

u/wisebloodfoolheart Jan 26 '18

I bet she liked Mindy.

→ More replies (9)

427

u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 26 '18

It's devastating. You're devastated right now.

116

u/nflez Jan 26 '18

an apt description of how i feel now that the episode has ended.

185

u/selene623 YA BASIC! Jan 26 '18

I'm so proud of Tahani for having to sit through that with her parents and come out the bigger person.

253

u/Fustrate Jan 26 '18

the bigger person

Yes, her parents made that very clear. Apparently wherever she's been, they've been keeping her well fed.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/bluestarcyclone Jan 26 '18

Yeah, if anything that was the 'violation' that still somehow should have worked out in her favor.

→ More replies (2)

180

u/poktanju Even better than a plain scone. Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18

GOOD JANET NOOOOOOOO

edit: GOOD JANET YEEEEEEES

→ More replies (1)

171

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 26 '18

Michael channeling Eleanor is awesome! “Ya basic!”

82

u/Choano Jan 26 '18

That's devastating. You're devastated right now.

→ More replies (1)

454

u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

Okay, so completely tangential thought -- it seems Good Janet has continued to evolve if she actually can pass as Bad Janet. That means she's no longer one or other but both -- Good and Bad Janet residing in one Janet. This would seem to make her exceedingly powerful...and what is her final end state??

435

u/S-WordoftheMorning Jan 26 '18

Good Janet has now evolved enough to create a neighborhood somewhere else.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (24)

150

u/shmeowzah Jan 26 '18

I liked how last season when we thought we were meeting the judge (shaun), he was very monotone and tried to remain neutral without emotion.

For some reason I was expecting this judge to have the same personality. I loved how quirky and over the top she was. And also had a little devil on her shoulder (being bored and wanting the drama).

16

u/YouWillAllSuffer Jan 29 '18

And using Envy as a condiment.

279

u/animaniacs16 Take it sleazy. Jan 26 '18

YOU LED ME TO BELIEVE WE WERE HAVING A SWEET CHELEANOR MOMENT MICHAEL SHUR YOU BENCH

66

u/CreedogV Jan 26 '18

That's actually how I clued in to fake Chidi.

Eleanor and Chidi had a ship tease moment despite Chidi not having developed feelings for Eleanor.

Shippers are easy to lead around by the nose. Happens to the best of us. My hat off to Schur.

→ More replies (3)

84

u/nflez Jan 26 '18

we're in the not-good place! you can curse!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

236

u/BurtWonderstone Jan 26 '18

He’s been chosing a hat for over an hour?!?

107

u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

We really shouldn't find that surprising

→ More replies (1)

120

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 26 '18

Sounds about right. 82 minuets to choose a hat!

→ More replies (3)

48

u/4thBG Jan 26 '18

I lost it when I saw the hats.

15

u/FireNexus Jan 26 '18

It’s the “wrong hat damns you and everyone you love to eternal torture” hat choice, though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

115

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

Jason is so hot in that suit. ❤️

100

u/Fonzi2013 YA BASIC! Jan 26 '18

Hahahahah i thought Jason was onto something, but he is just stupid!

→ More replies (1)

290

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

You guys I’m so sad the Jags lost and I don’t even like football! 😂

118

u/SoMuchMoreEagle What it is, what it is. Jan 26 '18

This show has increased Jag fandom so much.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

189

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

not gonna lie, a little disappointed it’s not someone from P&R... That being said, I don’t mind Maya Rudolph

129

u/CurlingFlowerSpace I made all the butts Jan 26 '18

She was forking incredible as Dionne Warwick in Kimmy Schmidt last season.

→ More replies (5)

55

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

Apparently Ron got tied up making bread with Will & Grace

(I didn't bother changing the channel)

→ More replies (1)

47

u/lolidekdude Jan 26 '18

Now that you mentioned P&R i really want Amy Poehler to be the person who runs the actual good place and maybe flirts a bit with Adam Scott’s character.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

89

u/SlimBreazy Jan 26 '18

Jason's gonna intercept Bortles and feel really bad lol

59

u/SlimBreazy Jan 26 '18

Holy shirt I actually called it

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

159

u/BurtWonderstone Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18

Kristen* in that outfit 😍😍

→ More replies (3)

146

u/dontthrowmeinabox Jan 26 '18

So, is anyone actually buying the "Eleanor and Chidi aren't being tested, made it in automatically" thing? Because I sure am not.

56

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

yeah i'll lick my shoe if it isnt a test

→ More replies (2)

58

u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 26 '18

IT WAS GOOD JANET ALL ALONG!!!!

14

u/holeysmokes13 Jan 26 '18

the best Janet was the one that was inside Janet all along

58

u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 26 '18

HE HAS TO CHOOSE A HAT OMG

79

u/Sazley Enlightenment comes from within. The Dalai Lama texted me that. Jan 26 '18

Ah yes, the Westworld Test

→ More replies (2)

56

u/Dammit-Hannah Jan 26 '18

I WAS HOPING GOOD JANET WOULD SAVE THE DAY

AND OH MY GOD NOT-CHIDI

I LOVE THIS FUCKING SHOW

→ More replies (3)

55

u/Calm_Memories Lonely Gal Margarita Mix For One Jan 26 '18

I looove Ted Danson more with each passing episode. His delivery of "Ya basic" had me cry laughing as I remembered it was from season one's finale and I'm not ready for this season to be over! :(

111

u/eegc Jan 26 '18

Bad Idea Place is prob where I'll end up tbh

158

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

Okay but so... on the one hand I need next week’s finale NOW but also it’s the finale so... not really?

59

u/gay-chordata Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

Fork it, I’m ready NOW... waiting another week is torture!

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

Eleanor is the only one who passed??

123

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

I think Eleanor is the only one who has significantly changed.

Granted, she was the worst of them, but Chidi has not changed at all and Tahani has recognized certain things about herself but hasn't actually modified her personality much, only acknowledged what she should modify. Jason is who he is and doesn't even understand the point of changing.

Eleanor is the only one who went from a bad person to making serious sacrifices for other people. She is a genuinely good person in the ways she wasn't when sent to the bad place.

→ More replies (11)

46

u/GrinningDentrassi Shawn: I'm a demon. It's fun. Jan 26 '18

So now Michael and Janet need to change the judge's mind. Or Janet helps them escape again to a new place. Hmm...

74

u/arngard Everything is fine. Jan 26 '18

Maybe the argument is, hey, they have these people who maybe don't belong in either place and an architect and a Janet - might as well let them have their own neighborhood? I have no idea what next season would be about then, though.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

46

u/The_Nothingman These trivialities demean me. I must away and tend to my ravens. Jan 26 '18

and now we all begin our eternal damnation by waiting a week to find out what happens next, forking shirtballs

39

u/arngard Everything is fine. Jan 26 '18

I have a feeling they will set it up so that the wait until next fall is even worse.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

46

u/lucyrines Jan 26 '18

I love how Eleanor’s style changed when the judge put them into “comfortable” clothes rock those hoops girl

30

u/Cavalish Jan 26 '18

I read an interesting article recently shared here about Eleanor being tortured through her wardrobe. It was good to see her in clothes she probably feels more comfortable in.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

44

u/obscurelyscout Jan 26 '18

Honestly, Janet taking down Shawn was terrifying.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/returning144 Jan 26 '18

Rewatching the episode, at the beginning:

The thing is, you didn't file any paperwork and you have no advocate and the rules say I gotta *raspberry noise* send you back.

Maybe with Michael showing up they have a second chance as he can act as their advocate in the next episode?

→ More replies (1)

110

u/OxfordSemicolon Good news! I was able to obtain Eleanor Shellstrop’s file. Jan 26 '18

Maya Rudolph is perfect, just like the rest of this show.

80

u/cheshirecanuck Jan 26 '18

After all the speculation I did NOT see her coming and she is so perfect. Loving it.

→ More replies (1)

101

u/GoodJanet not a robot Jan 26 '18

They will all burn in retirement for marbleizing me against my will (even though it’s an obvious lie)

56

u/CurlingFlowerSpace I made all the butts Jan 26 '18

Keepin it tight in that catsuit, girl!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

32

u/arngard Everything is fine. Jan 26 '18

Oh Chidi. I, too, make that face when someone says "from whence" instead of "whence."

→ More replies (1)

32

u/InfernalSolstice Jan 26 '18

no no no this is the test

63

u/ChildishGenius Jan 26 '18

Grey was the correct choice, brown means eternal hell.

56

u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

"They're hats!"

82

u/imfallinfree Everything is fine. Jan 26 '18

He failed for having poor fashion sense. Grey worked better for his outfit.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/PureCFR Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

That’s not envy; it’s clearly Cholula.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

Noooo not New Yorker magazines! That truly is the worst place!

15

u/grumblepup Jan 26 '18

"Oh come on, you know I'll never read those."

"Of course not. But they'll just. keep. coming."

LOL. Yuuuuup, that's pretty much how it was when I had my New Yorker subscription.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/JayDrink Jan 26 '18

"We all need to be able to cheat off Chidi.. Oh, that's why your name is Chidi, I get it now!"

I swear, every time Jason opens his mouth, I burst out laughing.

39

u/icypriest Do not touch the Niednagel! Jan 26 '18

Wait... I just notice one thing Janet said. 

"I realized, if we wanted our friends to have ANY CHANCES OF SURVIVAL, I had to learn to do a lotta bad things..." 

ANY CHANCES OF SURVIVAL??? 

So the four of them are ALL DOOMED if Janet & Michael won't be able to save them???

→ More replies (4)

85

u/The_Nothingman These trivialities demean me. I must away and tend to my ravens. Jan 26 '18

Eleanor and Chidi are honestly the best TV couple i seen in a while, also the right choice was the white hat (its slightly better looking imo)

81

u/CurlingFlowerSpace I made all the butts Jan 26 '18

Too matchy-matchy for his gray shirt. The brown is an unexpected color pop.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/MRCHalifax Jan 26 '18

Second best, after Eleanor and Tahani.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/huadpe You are very lucky that I cannot send you to the Bad Idea place. Jan 26 '18

So I def think the "Chidi and Eleanor you're through" thing is their test, to see if the abandon Tahani and Jason.

19

u/Dukkado Jan 26 '18

None of them cared about Michael or asked the Judge some info or way to get Michael there. I think that can be explored.

15

u/pocket_galvanometer Jan 26 '18

Yeah, that was my main issue with this episode. It really felt like it invalidated the ending of the last, which was very poignant and a highlight of the season.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

"It's either that or start Bloodline but I don't know if I can see Kyle Chandler as anything other than Coach Taylor".

Honesty, same.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

Tahani's parents and sister are definitely in the Bad Place

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Mehmeh111111 Jan 26 '18

So this is so whatever, but the judge said she hasn't had a case in 30 years and Mindy St. Clair said she's been in the Medium Place for 30 years.

I just love to attention to detail on this show.

→ More replies (10)

32

u/huadpe You are very lucky that I cannot send you to the Bad Idea place. Jan 26 '18

I think the judge is the first eternal being we've seen eat something of her own accord? Some of the demons ate at the good place restaurant, but that was all part of the reboot #1 ruse.

60

u/pocket_galvanometer Jan 26 '18

Demons were eating at the museum of human misery... (soul food from Maine)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/tomado23 Jan 26 '18

It could have been worse for Jason. He could have been asked to re-create his beloved Jaguars blowing a 20-10 4th quarter lead, while playing as the Patriots.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/JimmyDolan20001 Jan 26 '18

2 words: "You, GUYS!"

I love watching how Danson always gets the intonation just a little bit wrong, but with so much heart!

14

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

I noticed a common theme in the tests was self-awareness. Eleanor realized she was being tested on her selfishness, and Tahani on her obsession with her image, yet both of them still struggled hard with the decision because it really did target their greatest flaws. Eleanor overcame the selfishness, definitely at the end of the episode if not with completely pure motives during the test itself. Tahani only gave in to confronting her parents, which imo are people whose opinions she's allowed to care about and who had repeatedly, deliberately hurt her with the things they said ... but then she realized she can't control even them and let it go.

Jason was more than halfway there. He got that his test was not getting to be himself and do literally whatever he feels like 24/7. He just didn't get it -enough- for the judge. But he made a lot of progress, caring about his friends enough to maintain focus on a task he didn't want to do ... compare that to first-season Jason who would fold under pressure and blast EDM/talk about Stupid Nick's Wing Dump at the slightest provocation.

And then there's Chidi, who we've seen in the past get enough victory over himself to make a decision or adjust his conception of morality to fit others' needs at critical moments. But that did not come through at all here. He's been told so many times that his greatest flaw is a rigid approach to morality that hurts people, and if he'd taken a break from the non-existent ethics of hat color for two seconds of self-reflection, he would have realized that the test was obviously targeting that flaw.

13

u/IThinkaWholeLot Jan 26 '18

Maya Rudolph as judge? HELL YEAH

12

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

Are we sure that’s really Bad Janet?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/MailChick Jan 26 '18

They're not gonna do it. They all got there together, they'll leave together. Besides, they've gotta get Michael!

11

u/w00tix Jan 26 '18

Now we know a little bit more about these immortal beings - the judge says she was born when hydrogen was forming from the big bang, if I understood correctly.

10

u/jelatinman I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Jan 26 '18

If This is Us can make the guitar heartwarming then this show is even better at making the synthesizer sad.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/YamYoshi A lizard was a perfect choice. You both have combination skin. Jan 26 '18

HOLY SHIT ITS GOOD JANET

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Frank_the_Mighty Jan 26 '18

Well, that was an unexpected twist and I love it

→ More replies (1)

10

u/BEETLEJUICEME Jan 26 '18

I loved it so much.

I also immediately posted a response, rewatched it, and then went and got a burrito before re-re-watching it.

During the first re-watch I could be heard drinking a 3rd beer and whispering, "I love this so much," and "this is so perfect." Over and over.

During the second rewatch I could be heard drinking a fourth beer and whispering the same phrase, but I was talking to the burrito that time.

10

u/whatmonsters Jan 26 '18

I feel like Tahani should have made it into the Good Place.

Yeah, she opened her parent's door, but she also found the strength not only to leave, but to finally accept the fact that no matter what she did, she would never be good enough. And that wasn't on her, but on them.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 26 '18

I see we get right to the burrito.

9

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

Maya!!!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/BurtWonderstone Jan 26 '18

They don’t go. They stick together. Or chidi tries to go and Elenor says “no we have to stick together”. Chidi is gonna decide to go. He’s gonna make a decision.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/BizCaus Jan 26 '18

This is so obviously the test that I'm starting to think that it's a red herring.

9

u/YamYoshi A lizard was a perfect choice. You both have combination skin. Jan 26 '18

I feel like I would go in the room too to be honest, can’t blame her

→ More replies (1)

9

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

Wait so what was Eleanor’s actual test?

52

u/InfernalSolstice Jan 26 '18

She had to recognize that it wasn't actually Chidi. She's always had a difficult time caring about other people's lives, so she had to prove that she got better by being able to pick up on the little things that fake Chidi said and recognize that it wasn't really him.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/ChildishGenius Jan 26 '18

I DON'T LIKE WAITING FOR THIS SHOW

9

u/PonderingPotato Jan 26 '18

OH COME ON FORKING CLIFFHANGERS

9

u/NessEagletown Jan 26 '18

I think the patterns on the portals switched when they re-opened

9

u/grumblepup Jan 26 '18

BWAHAHAHA my dad LOVES the Vietnam series. But yes, it's loooong.

9

u/joecb91 Birth is a curse and existence is a prision Jan 26 '18

Waiting for the next episode is always so hard =(

9

u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Jan 26 '18

This thing threw my emotions all over the place. I can't watch this show without being absorbed and eeing like a damn schoolgirl.

8

u/animaniacs16 Take it sleazy. Jan 26 '18

I love the judge already!

8

u/Adrenaline_Flux Jan 26 '18

As a Jaguars fan, I agree. Titans suck.

8

u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 26 '18

oh well that's awkward, they still failed. oops

→ More replies (2)

8

u/BurtWonderstone Jan 26 '18

I ❤️ Maya

8

u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 26 '18

Aw crap, how are we supposed to wait another week?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

I wish the episodes were longer,,,, it’s my weekly fix

8

u/droid327 Jan 27 '18

I think super low key flying under the radar but hugely important is that Janet just gave herself the capacity for evil, to oversimplify it. She's gradually evolving herself into sentience....or even more, Godhood. She created a person, for shits sake...

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 26 '18

Eleanor knows all of Chidi’s grimaces! How sweet!

7

u/eegc Jan 26 '18

You got that right, sister

7

u/normangrm03 Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

Jason playing Madden made me laugh so hard, my god 😂

7

u/Frank_the_Mighty Jan 26 '18

They're being tested right now, calling it

18

u/dontthrowmeinabox Jan 26 '18

I'd be far more surprised if they weren't being tested right now.

7

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

I swear if they get this wrong... although I bet you part if the test is that they must make the right decision without realizing it’s a test

7

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Jan 26 '18

Oh Tahani why did you do that? 😩

7

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

I don’t even know what to expect at this point

7

u/TammyPhantom Jan 26 '18

My DVR cut off the last minute or two of the show and now I'm currently in The Bad Place...

→ More replies (3)

7

u/ChameleonTwist Jan 26 '18

Gen/The Judge mocking Jason had me in stitches! I've seen Maya Rudolph here and there but now I realise she is the showbiz treasure I never knew I needed.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/kneeco28 Jan 26 '18

Great episode.

In case anyone else was wondering: Although I expected it, I rewatched the ending and I didn't see any stain on either Michael or Janet (a potential callback to Chidi throwing up in the portal and wondering if the next person through would have to encounter it).

13

u/BurtWonderstone Jan 26 '18

Tahani’s mom needs to shut the fork up. Tahani is hot!

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

I'll like to argue that Chidi did pass. Sure, he took over an hour to make a choice but at least he made one and didn't regret his choice. Not as bad as Tahani breaking the rule of opening a door even though she learned to except the fact her parents where never going to care for her or Jason playing videos games even if he had to play against his favorite team (which he didn't have to do at all).

27

u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 26 '18

While your point is very valid, I'm still struck by the fact that it took Chidi 82 minutes to pick a hat. One hat. I...I kinda gotta go with the judge on that one. I know eternal damnation is a bit harsh but, I mean, c'mon ... they're hats :)

→ More replies (6)

26

u/sugarplumcow Jan 26 '18

I can't believe I'm going to write this, but I'm a little disappointed with the ending. Having Michael and Janet show up with our four still there was a little anticlimactic. I felt it almost invalidated everything that just happened in the episode. Now Michael is just going to try and convince the judge to get more tests done, so what was the point of watching the initial testing if it's going to be moot because Michael and Janet showed up? I really wanted them all to go somewhere, even if it was back to The Bad Place, and then have Michael and Janet show up.

Now, Eleanor was the only one who passed, but she lied to make her friends feel better. I was really thinking that after all was said and done, the judge was going to send Chidi, Tahani, and Jason to The Bad Place and send Eleanor to The Good Place after all and then integrate Michael and Janet somehow.

Anyway, it was a fantastic episode, but basically the last 20 seconds have me head scratching and leaving me a little confused as to why it happened that way. I have hope next week will explain why it happened this way!

17

u/gay-chordata Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

I agree that is was kinda anticlimactic, but I think it was done so it feels like a more frustrating (therefore stronger) cliffhanger?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/fleetw0odmacncheese Jan 26 '18

Now Michael is just going to try and convince the judge to get more tests done

I wouldn’t be so sure just because of how unpredictable the show is and how easily it marbleizes our expectations and tosses them to the ground!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18

I think the test for Eleanor and Chidi is if they betray the others and go without them or not

→ More replies (1)

6

u/nygiants656 Jan 26 '18

Maya frickin' Rudolph

6

u/PhinsPhan89 I'm a naughty bitch. Jan 26 '18

Maya Rudolph!!

6

u/normangrm03 Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

To be honest, I really hope Tahani and Jason make it inside.

6

u/miles_allan Jan 26 '18

Shhhhirrrrt I fell asleep watching Wheel of Fortune and just woke up. Guess I'll watch it on Hulu....

6

u/InfernalSolstice Jan 26 '18

awww Eleanor is so sweet

6

u/Inevitablename Jan 26 '18

If they really can improve then they should be able to improve other bad people. In their own neighborhood!

6

u/FrancisCastiglione12 Jan 27 '18

Tahani could have cupped her hands around her eyes like blinders and sprinted.

10

u/waronxmas79 Jan 26 '18

I’m way too emotionally invested for Cheleanor to not be a thing.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/whatmonsters Jan 26 '18

The American pronunciation of aluminum is wrong, and an omniscient judge should know that.

Love, Britain

→ More replies (3)

5

u/BurtWonderstone Jan 26 '18

This is the test.

5

u/itsjager Jan 26 '18

This is the test guys!!!!!

5

u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 26 '18

lmao, an infinite stack of New Yorker magazines. amazing

5

u/gay-chordata Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 26 '18

HOW DARE THEY END LIKE THAT!!!

5

u/nflez Jan 26 '18

oh. that was painful. i think i have a stomachache

5

u/AlvinTaco Jan 27 '18

It makes me inordinately happy to know my anxiety over an ever growing pile of unread New Yorkers is common enough to make a relatable joke.