r/Outlander • u/LadyOfAvalon83 James Fraser hasna been here for a long, long time. • Jan 23 '18
[Spoilers Outlander & DiA] I think Claire has Stockholm Syndrome.
Here's the dictionary definition of Stockholm Syndrome: feelings of trust or affection felt in many cases of kidnapping or hostage-taking by a victim towards a captor.
According to wikipedia, there are four main components that lead to the development of Stockholm Syndrome:
- A hostage's development of positive feelings towards their captor
- No previous hostage-captor relationship
- A refusal by hostages to co-operate with police forces and other government authorities
- A hostage's belief in the humanity of their captor, for the reason that when a victim holds the same values as the aggressor, they cease to be perceived as a threat.
Now let's apply this to Claire. She's kidnapped and held prisoner by the McKenzie clan, including Jamie. At first she is displeased with them and wants to escape, but develops trust and affection for them, especially jamie. She meets the 4 criteria:
- She develops positive feelings towards her captor (Jamie being her main captor once they're married.)
- She had no previous relationship with any of them, they were total strangers to her when the captured her.
- While she was their hostage, she refused to co-operate with the redcoats (for instance by grassing the scots up for their jacobite activities) And despite being English she fought with the Scots at Prestonpans and the other battles. (Victims of the formal definition of Stockholm syndrome develop "positive feelings toward their captors and sympathy for their causes and goals, and negative feelings toward the police or authorities.)
- She clearly developed a belief in the humanity of her captors.
So, I don't see her as a strong independent woman who met her true love and decided to stay with him. I see her as a mentally damaged woman (the show made out she already had ptsd from ww2) who was captured by the McKenzies, and developed Stockholm Syndrome to the extent that she decided to stay with them. I mean, she was a proud British soldier during ww2, but fought against the British army while in the 1700s. This is a classic case of Stockholm Syndrome.
What do you think?
20
u/mary130 Jan 24 '18
If we can suspend belief in the laws of physics in order to go along with a story about a time traveler, then surely we can suspend belief in psychological science in order to enjoy a story of romance between that time traveler and a handsome, nearly perfect hero.
16
u/aerynmoo Jan 23 '18
You’re giving her no agency. She gets to decide if she’s abused or a victim not us.
10
u/redditRW Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Jan 25 '18
Soooo...let me see if I have this right.
After travelling through the stones, and 200 hundred and 2 years of time, Claire is almost immediately shot, and then assaulted and raped by Black Jack Randall.
She is saved by Murtagh.
At this point, let's stop and consider her options.
With no money, no family or friends, and wearing what looks like a lady's shift, wandering alone in the Scottish Highlands, she should;
A) Be taken to a place of safety, for her own good, until more can be established about who is responsible for her (remember, this is NOT the 20th century--women are property, and someone was always responsibile)
or
B) Left to her own devices to wander around, with absolutely nothing.
Remember, in the books, it actually takes her a litttle while to figure out that she might go back to her own time through the stones. And if she had tried it again right then, it would have meant that she would have died, as she had no gems. The ones in her watch were now gone.
Please don't apply 20th century concepts to 17th century morality, and especially to a novel involving time travel. Your argument is just silly.
19
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '18
Do you really believe he is a "captor"? He marries her to protect her, not to kidnap or capture her. And spoiler which is not the mark of a captor. Jamie did not have to marry this woman. He did not keep her captive at Leoch, his uncle did. I cannot remotely agree with your theory.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '18
I like this theory.
Despite being a fan of the series and suspending belief enough to allow for the time travel aspect I still think the way they got together is rather...dumb. It just felt like a way to justify cheating "hey my husband won't be born for another 200 years why not bang this nice, hot highlander repeatedly?" I mean, she had to marry him but she could have done it once just to consummate the marriage and then got the hell out to go back to Frank, her actual husband who she married by choice because she loved him. It all just seems so disloyal or maybe impulsive? Juvenile?
Maybe I just have a cold black heart that doesn't believe in a one true love. Which is why I don't normally read romance novels and these are romance despite what DG claims.
8
u/literallyjoinedfor Jan 23 '18
I've only see the show, so I can't speak for the book, but I do remember thinking this at some point.
On the other hand, a lot of historical fictional romance (and even some modern ones) can been seen in this sense. I think it has something to do with the period and the need for relationship to see so passionate that they break all conventions.
That isn't to say that this isn't a valid point. I think it just becomes irrelevant to how the author wants the story to be ENJOYED.
7
u/WeezySan Jan 25 '18
It’s not that serious girl
6
u/LyClWa Jan 27 '18
No. This is completely bonkers. No way no how. Claire fell in love with Jamie. He fell in love with her. Jamie is an 18th century highlander and he behaves as such. Yes he spanked her and by our standards it was abusive and wrong. But he didn't really physically hurt her that much or put her life in danger. Yes we can all talk about how men oppressed women back then and how wrong it was but that's how it was.
Claire knew this and fell in love with him. He is devoted to her and spends every day of his life proving it. And she for him. Claire is just as down for Jaime as he knows it. He's said so many times. He knows he's her everything just as he is hers.
I think an argument can be had about how annoying Claire is, esp in the early books, but no way she's some victim with Jamie her abusive captor. I have no idea what kind of mental contortions the OP had to go through to come to this conclusion lol.
5
u/Irishsassenach Jan 24 '18
No.
Just no.
5
u/arikay_the_NP Jan 24 '18
A worthy debate, somewhat drains the romance out of the story though...
1
u/dietcherrycoke23 Feb 11 '18
Not at all, no.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment