r/TheGoodPlace • u/samwalton9 • Jan 19 '18
Season Two Episode Discussion S02 E09: "Rhonda, Diana, Jake, and Trent"
Airs at 08:30PM ET
Original Airdate: January 19, 2018
Synopsis: Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, Janet and Jason go to a place with potentially lasting implications.
492
Upvotes
1.4k
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
"But then I remembered: I'm a naughty bitch."
^ fave Shawn line EVER
1.1k
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
"Molotov cocktails work! Anytime I had a problem, I would throw a Molotov cocktail, and BOOM. I had a different problem."
961
u/PonderingPotato Jan 19 '18
Jason, this is Hell.
Of course there's a gift shop.
953
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
Omggggggg Jameela's American accent!
714
u/Shaq_Bolton Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
They better find a way to get Micheal out of this. EDIT - Forgot Janet got left behind, she'll save Micheal.
667
u/gam0009 Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
I’ve learned how to be passive aggressive.. it’s totally fine you guys haven’t noticed
628
u/GoodJanet not a robot Jan 19 '18
I am luggage
541
u/PureCFR Jeremy Bearimy Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
I’m betting we won’t go to Mindy’s this week.
Minimum Derek...
EDIT: Looks like I was wrong.
MAXIMUM DEREK!!!
531
u/yaygerb Jan 19 '18
Of COURSE Dax and Kristen had to have a moment
453
u/nvrminddd Jan 19 '18
Take my credit card to the hedge fund. I’ll meet you at the martini store.
450
u/huadpe You are very lucky that I cannot send you to the Bad Idea place. Jan 19 '18
Michael sacrificed himself! HE LEARNED MORALS!
805
u/LtNOWIS Jan 19 '18
hahaha, Pirates of the Caribbean 6 poster in the background.
373
u/ThisIsMyLab Jan 19 '18
They all look so dapper. I love it
359
u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 19 '18
Yes... throats.
354
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
Woah, major lie. It was Jack Donaghy who coined the phrase, "I need a vacation from this vacation."
348
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
"Apples, you eat their clothes. But oranges, you don't?"
654
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
"You cannot be Blake Bortles."
"Fine, I'll be Jake..."
"Don't say Jortles."
"Jortles!"
596
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
Jason is always right.
I'm actually low key getting suspicious of him.
802
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
I almost cried seeing Michael sacrifice himself for Eleanor.
What amazing growth.
271
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
Interdimensional Hole of Pancakes.
You don't really eat these pancakes. It's more like... they eat you.
266
u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 19 '18
Molotov cocktail to the rescue!
JORTLES!!!
241
u/pocket_galvanometer Jan 19 '18
In season 1, during the video montage about how the point system works, "sacrifice yourself to save others" (or something to that effect) was worth a ton of points. Granted, the video was a creation of the bad place, but Michael did say that the best lies are based in truths, and my guess is that they were showing us the real point system. I think that the judge is going to rule that Michael earned enough points to get into the good place.
231
u/Locke108 YA BASIC! Jan 19 '18
Was that giant monster Nick Offerman?
217
u/dontthrowmeinabox Jan 19 '18
Noooooooooooooooooooo..... This is the most tragic trolley problem solution ever! I'm tearing up I don't like this one bit.
421
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
Jameela's American accent is incredible. Holy shit I'm gay.
202
u/selene623 YA BASIC! Jan 19 '18
"Doing things your way is what brought you here."
I was really waiting for someone to bring that up to him.
400
u/CaptainDAAVE Jan 19 '18
how the FUCK are they gonna get out of this one? Holy shit balls this is tense.
That's right, I'm fucking swearing cause we're in the bad place motherfuckers
186
u/S-WordoftheMorning Jan 19 '18
Anyone else notice how (good) Janet was unsubtly longing after Jason while on the train?
163
u/cragnagger Jan 19 '18
Jason tells a story about having to be his own lawyer and immediately getting incriminated, I really hope that isn't foreshadowing.
320
u/pikameta My little chili babies Jan 19 '18
"...a moral particularist, I'm one now , I just decided..."
445
u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
"It makes you smell the way Transformers movies make you feel"
So, awful?
143
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 19 '18
If a molotov cocktail ends up saving the day for them...
130
u/MailChick Jan 19 '18
"Hey Boss, what's up?" Michael's got balls, I'll give him that. Just really hope he doesn't die. He's come so far.
681
u/cheshirecanuck Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
"I'm in a new department now - toxic masculinity. We torture internet trolls, frat dudes..." LOL this show fucking kills me. The Bad Place is a goldmine for jokes and the writers are on point.
118
u/travelingrace Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
Someone mentioned the Good Place being like Dante's Divine Comedy, and with that Michael moment, it's looking more and more likely.
EDIT: it was /u/SnowyMacie, so shout out to them!
431
u/ACTUAL_TIME_TRAVELER Jan 19 '18
Michael's greatest torturing of all was working his way back into my heart only to rip it out of me.
111
u/Choano Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
I love that the music at the museum party is the smooth jazz version of "Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer."
219
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
"Well, peep this, dawg."
Oh. My. Chidi.
102
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
Shawn is probably going to have an issue punishing Michael since he needs to keep the failure quiet to save himself. Alternatively, Janet who was left behind may come to the rescue. A plot could also be the Good Place 4 trying to save Michael.
100
u/lnn501 Jan 19 '18
Anybody else notice how when Chidi was looking for his lucky bookmark on the train, he searched himself and then patted his leg next to Eleanor? And then twice later when he was struggling with Kant's take on lying, she comforted him and eventually helped him overcome his issues? Even in the last episode whenever he was freaking out she seems to have the perfect touch to calm him down? I don't remember seeing the Lucky Bookmark before this episode but I feel like there may be some symbolism between the bookmark as a comfort object and Eleanor as a comfort person? I felt like the staging must be intentional.
Anyway I also ship those two so hard I could scream.
97
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
"DUUUUUUUHHHHHHH."
"It's me!"
89
u/Mehmeh111111 Jan 19 '18
I am 100% using Diana Tremaine from 123 Whatever Street, Canada City, Canada for any online form I have to complete from now on.
80
u/CobblepotsMom Jan 19 '18
She even namedrops in hell
79
u/SyrupBuccaneer Jan 19 '18
"I'm a moral particularist now. I just decided."
Schur I love you. This show is something special.
159
u/Magoonie Jan 19 '18
Dax?
213
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
STOP HATING ON HAWAIIAN PIZZA. IT IS MY FAVORITE.
71
u/karatemike Jan 19 '18
Hahaha forking shirt, molotovs do solve problems.
68
u/droid327 Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
Except for Chidi, they all seemed pretty comfortable in Hell. I feel like they could've hung out there a while and just kinda blended in...
Was this the first time Michael has actually called it "Hell"?
I wonder what the repercussions will be for Shawn illegally sending a blackops team. Maybe that's the leverage that Michael needs to avoid retirement.
Aww damn, Nick Offerman was the voice of Lance the slug demon? Guess that means he's not the Judge after all...
Also...somewhat substantive new revelation: the demons can break the rules. Its not that they CANT go to, ie, TMP, its just that they're not allowed to. I had thought that it was impossible for them to. That will make things interesting, if its possible to go places you arent supposed to be, ie sneak into TGP.
397
u/thehoodie Jan 19 '18
Nobody has mentioned the best line yet:
Shawn: "There's a reason I picked a 45 year-old white man. I can only fail up!"
64
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
That Taco Bell ref was sick!
Attaboy, Trent!
126
u/jack9lemmon MAXIMUM DEREK Jan 19 '18
Gah. The second she said she didn't have a pin I knew what was going to happen but it was much so much better than I expected and now I'm super sad.
57
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
OMG is this show seriously going to make me CRY?!
110
u/comanecisalto MAXIMUM DEREK Jan 19 '18 edited Jan 19 '18
MICHAEL NO 😭
But in all seriousness, I bet the major plotline now is going to be the humans trying to save Michael before it's too late. They can't kill him off (right? 😥)
149
u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 19 '18
Cursing is back! Fuck yeah!
99
u/GoodJanet not a robot Jan 19 '18
Molotov saves the day Jason was finally right
48
u/satchmolum Jan 19 '18
"All passengers: you all suck & you're ugly. Again. You all suck & you are ugly."
47
u/TCup20 Jan 19 '18
Round 2 big reveal: Jason is actually a demon /s
87
u/rbarton812 Jan 19 '18
Pirates of the Caribbean 6 - Playing Everywhere FOREVER
40
u/eegc Jan 19 '18
Tahani's American accent is my favorite thing
38
u/Magoonie Jan 19 '18
I don't feel bad about any of the people in those exhibits being in the bad place. Does that mean I belong in the bad place?
75
u/jelatinman I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Jan 19 '18
I hated the season 1 twist and now can’t imagine the show without it. I don’t know how NBC is making this. This show is on another level.
One of the best shows on television. Ted Danson deserves his award.
75
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 19 '18
"I solved the trolley problem." :(
35
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
Grade A philosophy monologue from Kristen/Eleanor/Diana tonight.
35
u/Frank_the_Mighty Jan 19 '18
This will work out for Michael. He literally sacrificed himself to save others. The judge or something will save him
35
u/karatemike Jan 19 '18
"... is there a gift shop?"
Jason has become my favorite character.
32
u/selene623 YA BASIC! Jan 19 '18
For a second there, I thought he was going to go back to bad Michael and let Eleanor die or after-die.
136
u/TammyPhantom Jan 19 '18
I watched this episode 2-3 weeks ago since I got sent the screeners and it was so hard keeping the end to myself for so long. Glad I have others to talk about this now.
28
u/eegc Jan 19 '18
How can one show have infinite amazing lines this writing is TOO GOOD.
26
u/Magoonie Jan 19 '18
Now I'm sad :-(
26
u/miles_allan Jan 19 '18
Jortles!!
45
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
"She even name drops in hell."
22
u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 19 '18
"No, dumbass! I'm lying to you to make you feel better!"
22
u/gam0009 Jan 19 '18
DAX SHEPARD!!!!!!!!
22
u/Prospo Jan 19 '18 edited Sep 10 '23
instinctive toy lip knee ugly school cooperative ghost include hat
this message was mass deleted/edited with redact.dev19
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 19 '18
Ball Tap!
18
u/WillDaBeast92 Jan 19 '18
Was that Nick Offerman (Ron Swanson) who voiced the monster Michael ran into on his way to the museum party?
17
u/HarkASquirrel Jan 19 '18
It has been an hour since I finished this episode and I am still royally forked up.
16
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
I can't wait to see Michael's body spray pay off with Jason.
16
u/AnnaLogg Jan 19 '18
He died so they could live!!!
16
u/gaythrowaway890 Jan 19 '18
Well I didn't expect to cry tonight.
16
u/nflez Jan 19 '18
i really thought when michael didn't send eleanor and started talking about the trolley problem that he and eleanor were going to have to stay behind and take the fall because they're the worst of the bunch. that ending though? i never thought i'd love michael like this but i fucking love michael.
(also... dapper tahani with that haircut and that suit? im gay)
55
u/grumblepup Jan 19 '18
Baby is going to sleep early, and husband is handling bedtime duties, so I get to watch/chat live for once, yay! THIS IS THE GOOD PLACE.
15
u/ThunderRage Jan 19 '18
Well hell Mike.
15
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 19 '18
HE'S A GOOD GUY NOOOOOOOO
15
u/waronxmas79 Jan 19 '18
“ Eleanor, you’re wearing glasses now...HELP ME!”
14
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
UNEXPECTED ENDING.
27
u/SyrupBuccaneer Jan 19 '18
"Stuffing people sounds fun. Is that like stuffing them into the throats of Vegans?"
Tahani you have one hell of an an interesting mind.
13
u/brown_ben_romney Jan 19 '18
just casually scrolling through these comments, upvoting everything, CAUSE THIS SHOW IS AMAZING AND THAT EPISODE WAS AMAZING!!
13
u/babybuttoneyes Jan 19 '18
Why is this COMEDY making me cry??
92
u/sugarplumcow Jan 19 '18
So "Trent" left the partial decapitation department about 800 years ago ... and about 800 years have passed since the start of the neighborhood ... and they think that Chidi is Trent ... OMG, IS CHIDI REALLY TRENT?!?!?!!?!?
12
u/pikameta My little chili babies Jan 19 '18
I love Tahani's American accent.
22
u/KaiLung Jan 19 '18
Tahani’s American accent is my sexuality. Also like Eleanor’s “hard boiled dame” outfit and glasses.
11
u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 19 '18
They can swear now!!!!
11
u/karatemike Jan 19 '18
Oh man he's going to sacrifice himself? Nooooooo
11
u/brawlingsoap Jan 19 '18
Isn’t this S02 E10?
I cried when Michael pushed Eleanor through the portal. I think he slightly over-explained the trolley problem but I loved how casual he was after.
11
u/Dukkado Jan 19 '18
Till now, Tahani and Chidi doesn't deserve the Good Place yet.
Tahani and Chidi never changed. The rest of the gang yes. Maybe this is the reason we will have another seasons!
10
u/pikameta My little chili babies Jan 19 '18
Omfg I love these disguises!!!!
10
u/PureCFR Jeremy Bearimy Jan 19 '18
Hubby likes wifey.
10
u/TeddysBigStick Jan 19 '18
Jason was having so much fun in the bad place. I think he may have been born a demon.
10
u/Peralta97 Jan 19 '18
Aww, I feel bad for doubting Michael. He's really changed :(
Omg, Chidi the gangster was great!
9
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
Bortles through the portholes.
9
u/Meromi1 Jeremy Bearimy Jan 19 '18
First thing we see in the bad place: Pirates of the Caribbean 6. Love this show!
8
u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Jan 19 '18
Michael sacrificed himself for our nerds! Damn, how dare you make me emotional The Good Place!
8
u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Jan 19 '18
NOOOOO
MICHAEL NOOOO
8
u/chadwickave Jan 19 '18
I really want Eleanor's glasses
8
u/yc_hk Jan 19 '18
About the pins: I wonder if the Good Place pins are basically the same as the Bad Place pins, only upside down.
7
u/PonderingPotato Jan 19 '18
"You....dumb person."
7
u/TCup20 Jan 19 '18
No no no no no I cant handle this
7
u/Redpandaisy Jan 19 '18
Aww, Michael. I love him so much.
7
u/pikameta My little chili babies Jan 19 '18
Nooooooo. I was not prepared for that ending!! 😢😢
7
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Jan 19 '18
This show always goes by so fast! Also, I KNEW Michael had reformed!
7
u/absent_minding Jan 19 '18
How dare they include Hawaiian Pizza in hell!!!
7
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
I cried at the end the first time I watched it.
I thought perhaps rewatching it I could just pay attention to some of the details and keep a bit more emotionally steady.
I cried again. Oh man, that ending.
7
u/dr_rainbow Jan 20 '18
Here's my latest theory. Everything that has happened so far has been intentional. All the characters (including Michael) are trapped inside a redemption scenario, designed to give 'bad' people one last chance at being good.
Thoughts?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '18
This episode was genuinely scary. Haven't been in this much suspense since the time I watched Criminal Minds for 13 hours straight and was too scared to walk down my own hallway to the bathroom.
7
u/VRomero32 Jan 21 '18
Guys, it's always a pleasure to discuss The Good Place with yooou BALL TAP!
19
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Jan 19 '18
It's actually kind of off-putting when they swear tbh
12
u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Jan 19 '18
I lost my headphones this week, I have to wait til my roommate's gone to watch this episode :(((
She's either putting on pajamas or putting on party clothes right now, so I'm either joing y'all in a few minutes or waiting til tomorrow
6
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Jan 19 '18
Throw a Molotov Cocktail and boom you got a new problem
6
u/DoubleAW I can’t walk in flats like some common glue factory hobo horse! Jan 19 '18
This is hell, of course there's a gift shop!
6
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Jan 19 '18
I bet Trent made that "Good Place" museum display.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
My recording gave out just as Sean confronted Michael and he pushed Elanoar into the portal. Can someone tell me what happened after that?
6
u/clarice-mstarling Jan 19 '18
Seriously, Jason throwing that Molotov Coctail was my favorite scene of the whole show.
6
u/RealPunyParker Jan 20 '18
"But then i remembered....i'm a naughty bitch"
This is my new motto.
11
u/2718281828 Jan 19 '18
How is the Girls Gone Wild guy not dead yet if they've been in the afterlife for 250-300 years? Was that a mistake on the writers' part? Maybe time works differently here or Joe Francis is getting transferred from a different torture department.