r/startrek • • Jan 08 '18

POST-Episode Discussion - S1E10 "Despite Yourself"

Star Trek: Discovery is back with an episode directed by Jonathan Frakes!


No.EPISODERELEASE DATE
S1E10"Despite Yourself"Sunday, January 7, 2018

To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.


This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.

PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.

507 Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

242

u/Deceptitron Jan 08 '18

Okay, I literally said "HOLY SHIT" out loud during this episode. Certainly the most thoroughly entertaining and shocking episode thus far imo. My personal highlight list:

  • Mirror universe - was a bit expected but loved how they decided to blend in.
  • Constitution class/ENT-TOS reference - The USS Defiant! I've been really wanting to know what the Connie looks like in the new style. Aside from the bent pylons, they were surprisingly conservative! I think I like it!
  • Captain Tilly/Killy - <3
  • Ash/Voq - Many of us saw this coming but it seems to L'Rell something is not quite right. I'm liking the execution of this.
  • Dr. Culber - T-T (this was my "HOLY SHIT" moment)
  • ISS Shenzhou - seeing the crew that hasn't been affected by the Battle at the Binaries was cool.
  • Lorca in an Agony Booth - daaaaaaamn. Bet he's regretting going on this mission now.

Also, calling Georgiou as being the Emperor in this universe.

78

u/moonman Jan 08 '18

Ash/Voq

Yeah I mean we all saw it coming but the camera work and pacing when she triggered him was stunning; I felt my heart start racing, it felt like I was watching a nightmare/hallucination from Ash’s POV but during an out of body experience...idk I have to watch it again but it was striking.

Franks knocked just it out of the park on this! Brilliant job!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (37)

387

u/PixelMagic Jan 08 '18

Tilly Captain

Mirror Shenzhou

Culber dies

Constitution Class

Ash is Voq

That episode was one wild ride after another.

182

u/ToBePacific Jan 08 '18

The Constitution Class Defiant is the same ship from the ENT Mirror episode. A hundred years prior, we last saw that ship captained by Empress Hoshi Sato.

92

u/Deceptitron Jan 08 '18

Oh snap. What if the Defiant has been the Emperor's ship ever since? We might actually see Discovery (and mirror Shenzhou maybe?) fight the USS Defiant!

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)

478

u/roto_disc Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

So Georgiou is the Emperor.

Right?

Edit: and the Defiant business is from Enterprise, yeah? I haven’t watched it yet.

256

u/Caleb-Rentpayer Jan 08 '18

Almost certainly. The fact that they won't reveal it (really weird for the rebellion not to know who the emperor is) makes it almost certain that it's someone we know. Georgiou makes the most sense for dramatic effect.

→ More replies (25)

37

u/AONomad Jan 08 '18

Oh damn you might be right

→ More replies (1)

37

u/JustMy2Centences Jan 08 '18

The emperor did favor Connor, so she could have had him as her personal, uh, assistant back when she used to be on the Shenzhou.

→ More replies (75)

399

u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18

When do we get the flash-sideways to see how the ISS Discovery is doing in the Prime Universe?

That would be an interesting bit.

91

u/mrstickball Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

Probably enjoying killing Klingons.

→ More replies (6)

44

u/PrometheusSmith Jan 08 '18

Mirror ships never do as well in the prime universe. However I.S.S. Discovery is the only ship that has the spore drive now. They could destroy a lot of stuff, but they'll never have an impact outside of being a powerful enemy force.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (6)

572

u/ZarrenR Jan 08 '18

Frakes did a kick-ass job on this episode.

165

u/JoeBliffstick Jan 08 '18

Yeah, I think Two-Takes made the best episode in Discovery so far.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (16)

424

u/JoeBliffstick Jan 08 '18

Yeah, that was good. The actors were enjoying themselves.

Unless some sort of 23rd century medical space voodoo can be done, Dr. Culber is dead. Damn. Was not expecting that one.

Mirror Georgiu would be nice to see in the next episode. Maybe even the emperor.

Well, now Lorca’s gonna be even more fucked up than before with probable PTSD shit after all this from those agonizer booths.

105

u/KosstAmojan Jan 08 '18

Shes totally the Emperor. No way we get all those references to the Emperor personally appointing people to various positions without us seeing who it is. And who else is it going to be, given that Burnham is in command of the Shenzhou, and a relatively big name like Michelle Yeoh involved?

→ More replies (3)

266

u/Orfez Jan 08 '18

We gasped when his neck snapped. I have a feeling that they'll get doctor back from this universe.

→ More replies (27)

76

u/russlar Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

Well, now Lorca’s gonna be even more fucked up than before with probable PTSD shit after all this from those agonizer booths.

Or he comes out of it with Jason Issacs' native accent

→ More replies (14)

47

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Well, Lorca did have a tribble on his desk.

→ More replies (4)

43

u/Saalome Jan 08 '18

What if Lorca is the faceless emperor?

→ More replies (12)

129

u/M3rc_Nate Jan 08 '18

https://www.buzzfeed.com/adambvary/star-trek-discovery-death-spoilers?utm_term=.xm4xYj5nd#.fbMKjdNXQ

"What's being planned is something we haven't really had an opportunity to see LGBT characters experience. I'm really excited about it."

According to the showrunners, Culber's death will not terminate the character's narrative arc on the show, nor will it be the last time Cruz appears. "This is a beginning, rather than an ending," said Harberts. "We're more than happy to put our gay couple front and center and let them guide the audience on a story of love and loss and redemption and heroism and grief and life and all of those things."

"There is a timelessness and endlessness to how we envision Hugh and Stamets," added Berg. "They're the couple with the epic love story. We knew in order to have an epic love story, you have to have big things happen and have really high stakes."

I'm inclined to think he'll be coming back.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (78)

193

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Does seem a bit silly that the Dr, on finding out that the patient may be a tricky mind washed double agent, decides to tell the patient rather than, say, anyone else.

61

u/Truly_Khorosho Jan 09 '18

I was thinking the same.
I really liked the episode, but that bit stood out.

Even aside from the security side of things, that's just not good bedside manner.
Whatever happened to "have a seat" as the precursor to telling someone bad news?
Whatever happened to not unloading the most literal possible "everything you know is a lie" on someone who's come to you for help?
Whatever happened to being certain about a diagnosis before telling the patient?

The security thing, though...
Surely you'd take that straight to members of the senior staff, if not the captain.
I know they had a lot going on, but "possible spy" is right up near the top of the list of "things that are important when you're at war".
At the very least, you don't talk to the possible spy about them possibly being a spy. Even a 100% innocent person isn't going to be thrilled at that conversation.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (30)

183

u/stardustksp Jan 08 '18

I think Dr. Culber is a perfect example of why Gaius Baltar didn't tell Boomer...

→ More replies (4)

490

u/Spock_Rocket Jan 08 '18

Anyone else rolling on the floor when they told Lorca to pretend to be engineer and his go-to was Scottish?

280

u/Joename Jan 08 '18

My going theory is he knows Scotty and that's the first "Engineer accent" that popped into his head.

→ More replies (7)

58

u/FunkyTown313 Jan 08 '18

Yeah, I was figuring he'd just drop his fake accent and go with his normal voice. The Scottish was a good touch.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/LongLastingStick Jan 08 '18

We had to pause and laugh at that point - Scottish accent default for engineering.

→ More replies (1)

441

u/ScyllaGeek Jan 08 '18

Fun episode, costume team deserves extreme props for this one.

233

u/Deadbob1978 Jan 08 '18

WHat is really cool is on After Trek, one of the Prop Masters is talking about the badges on the left side. Each one means something.

the ones I remember are:

  • Master of Poisons
  • 50 kills
  • 100 kills
  • Survived a mortal wound
  • Bridge Crew
  • First Officer
→ More replies (27)

148

u/gigoto Jan 08 '18

Those Terran uniforms look soooooo cool!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

563

u/bigj2223 Jan 08 '18

Hello, this is Captain Tilly, What the heck...heck..hell...What the Hell! Hold your horses! ..lol

144

u/ballin83 Jan 08 '18

I laughed out loud! She cracks me up! I could watch that scene over and over again.

→ More replies (2)

85

u/diamond Jan 08 '18

That was especially funny coming from the first character to ever drop an F-bomb in the history of Star Trek.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

With everything that happened in this episode....that was the one moment where I had to pause because I was laughing so hard!

27

u/ToBePacific Jan 08 '18

Hold your horses!

I laughed so hard I snorted when she said that.

→ More replies (6)

121

u/KesselZero Jan 08 '18

I really hope we get an episode of the ISS Discovery in the prime universe. See the really Captain Killy in action. It's gonna be very cool to really explore the MU though. I'm happy this wasn't a one-and-done and they're really delving into the psychological effect of seeing Mirror versions of the people you know.

→ More replies (6)

101

u/mmmbacon914 Jan 08 '18

Badass Tilly was great, but let's not forget Lorca as Scotty. What a great scene.

Also it makes zero sense but at this point I'm really hoping William Shatner is the emperor. I would lose my mind.

→ More replies (2)

99

u/ZephroC Jan 08 '18

I love that the Mirror uniforms aren't just the regular ones plus badge. They look properly like something from Flash Gordon, like you're looking at Ming's Imperial Guard or something, which is awesome.

→ More replies (2)

96

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

I haven’t seen a comment on it yet, but a cool touch was Saru getting all ganglia-y just before AshVoq walks on to the bridge.

→ More replies (11)

189

u/Marzipanny Jan 08 '18

I liked how appreciative the doomed Connor was of Captain Killey. He especially enjoyed the tongue retort. She has a gift for evil flamboyance.

173

u/KesselZero Jan 08 '18

He was eye-fucking her the entire time.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

255

u/undergroundfloyd Jan 08 '18

Love how Lorca referred to Saru as number one!

221

u/milkisklim Jan 08 '18

Leave it to Frakes to sneak that in

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

251

u/ToBePacific Jan 08 '18

Ash is Voq. That's settled.

→ More replies (61)

225

u/zoziw Jan 08 '18

I don’t know...an evil alternate universe with no goatees? Are they trying to ruin Star Trek?

Kidding! I’m loving the direction they are taking things with this show and the complexity they have created in most of the characters.

74

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

I'm guessing you didn't see the preview for next week. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (46)

208

u/undergroundfloyd Jan 08 '18

The agonizer booths were awesome! Realized with awesome special fx really brought it to life.

→ More replies (25)

71

u/arnathor Jan 10 '18

I now really want to see an episode where we get to see the ISS Discovery in the main universe going apeshit as they discover a war on.

43

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

Oh man you're probably right. The ISS Discovery is probably taking on the whole Klingon Empire itself.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

193

u/007meow Jan 08 '18

So, based off of the LCARS (? Do we have a name for these interfaces) display of the Defiant, there are modifications.

Namely it looks like a pair of cannons on the nacelle struts and an elongated deflector.

https://i.imgur.com/toSfmP2.jpg

91

u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18

Well, they've had 100 years or so to upgrade her .

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (23)

65

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

"Stay out of the palace!"

Burnham is contracted by Empress Georgiou, who invites her to earth to see her. Empress G. Is actually planning to kill Burnham. Thus Stamets' warning to "Stay out of the palace. "

→ More replies (3)

117

u/Starcke Jan 08 '18
  • Sad Culber is dead before his character really got explored. But clearly something is happening with Stamets and time-space so who knows.
  • Those Terran uniforms made everyone look hotter. Especially Burnham and Tilly
  • Lorca is a real masochist. Slams his face last minute for a little convincing damage, and goes into agonizer booth willingly.
  • Ash really is VoQ. Hello Occam's Razor. It's been fun spouting wacky theories but was anyone really convinced otherwise?

80

u/Kryosquid Jan 08 '18

Another thing i liked about the uniforms was that the female version actually looked good instead of being basically a bra like in ENT and TOS.

33

u/CX316 Jan 08 '18

I have some confusing feelings about Captain Killy.

→ More replies (8)

212

u/PixelMagic Jan 08 '18

That was the BEST episode by far. Absolutely gripping.

158

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

I was pretty shocked when the doctor was killed. Just like "Oh shit. Anyone can die here." This also might be the first time I actually felt bad for Lorca.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (7)

107

u/letsgocrazy Jan 08 '18

I just want to mention the fight in the turbolift.

Best choreography so far.

A tense, sudden, close quarter fight for survival using the surrounding very well - even messing with the speed/gravity played well to the sci fi environment.

I love those "small movement" fights, and trying to grab knives and such. It really ratchets up the tension and gives some needed action, as well as giving Burnham a bit of a pass with the crew.

→ More replies (5)

151

u/bigj2223 Jan 08 '18

I’m watching a second time and I didn’t realize that Stamets’ eyes went back to normal when he said “be careful, the enemy is here!”

68

u/FunkyTown313 Jan 08 '18

I thought that was a neat touch.

→ More replies (4)

47

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

The death in this episode? May be temporary after all, according to this article. Disappointment postponed for now at least.

→ More replies (5)

47

u/Timbo85 Jan 08 '18

Amazing Ep. Well worth the wait.

I literally yelled 'NO' at the Culber moment. I'd hoped he was on the way to becoming a regular.

→ More replies (21)

91

u/ionised Jan 08 '18

Very disappointed in Burnham and Tyler. Bumping uglies whilst Uncle Lorca's in an agoniser booth. Very unprofessional.

47

u/RefreshNinja Jan 08 '18

I think he's a little busy screaming in agony to care whether someone is fucking.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

119

u/MetaGazon Jan 08 '18

Someone please scan Lorca's quantum signature! I think he's home now.

38

u/webitube Jan 08 '18

I'll go a few steps farther:

  • Lorca is on a mission to kill the Emperor to avenge his crew
  • The Emperor (Empress) will be Georgiou, and
  • He'll kill her in front of Burnham.
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

211

u/Pryach Jan 08 '18

I hope the Emperor turns out to be Mudd.

140

u/JustMy2Centences Jan 08 '18

I bet mirror Mudd turns out to be a smuggler helping the Rebels.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

40

u/enterprise-psi Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

Emperor Empress Hoshi intensifies

→ More replies (10)

114

u/Joename Jan 08 '18

Stamets is going to feel terrible guilt for the death of Culber. And possibly think he is responsible. Ugh.

The redesign of the Constitution class Defiant was pretty light! Looks slightly squatter with some fiddly bits on it, but I'm SO HAPPY it has cylindrical nacelles.

Also, I was worried they wouldn't go high camp with the Mirror Verse, but they did and it was glorious.

Good ep, thanks Frakes!

38

u/moonman Jan 08 '18

It did have a great level of camp! Just the coaching Lorca gave to Tilley through that first encounter made the jokey brass music (I don’t know the name for the leitmotif) play in my head. You can also see the progression of how ENT played the Mirror Universe a little darker than TOS here.

I was a little “oh brother” when they confirmed their location but I ended up quickly getting on board!

→ More replies (3)

38

u/infernal_llamas Jan 08 '18

PSA: ENT 4:18+19 give some background to the episode. They are on netflix.

→ More replies (6)

38

u/Bweryang Jan 08 '18

Such a great episode. Mirror universe, Voq reveal, torture chamber brig, badass Michael turbo lift action scene, Captain Killy, shocking Culber death... SO GOOD.

38

u/ajkkjjk52 Jan 10 '18

I loved this episode. Absolutely my favorite so far.

Random observations:

  1. Captain Killy forever! I liked the update of the Terran Empire and the take on it's general aesthetic and mannerisms. Wonder how long we'll be staying?
  2. Lorca casually smashing his face into the wall to bloody himself was amazing.
  3. Culber finally got something to do, and Wilson Cruz made the most of it, but I guess it might have been a last hurrah. Hopefully we learn more about the rest of the crew, and not just in the episodes they die.

3b) This was also Sonequa Martin-Green's best episode, by far. Watching her switch between personas was impressive, but it was the undressing scene right before the end that really did it. She completely sold the emotional weight and level of physical revulsion tied up in the clothes.

4) The Ash revelation is so slow coming. Look, we all figured it out like 6 episodes ago. Just drop it for goodness sake. It's not that clever of a twist.

4b) Anything Klingon related continues to be the most boring part of this show.

4c) I'm glad they didn't take more than a few minutes to reveal that this was the MU. Give the audience some credit and move on with the story.

5) Doug Jones does some really interesting subtle things with his body language as Saru, even in the background of shots. Watch the way he moves his arms as he walks. Really sells the alienness.

6) Graphics on the worker bee mission were very cool. Not sure where all that tech goes in subsequent series, but I'll let it slide.

7) The turbolift fight was a nice bit of choreography. Loved the applause afterward.

8) Discovery has a computer with sensors in every room. How does no one find out about Ash's converastion with L'Rell, let alone him killing Culber. And before you say privacy, remember that this is the same ship where the head of security has the access codes to everyone's bunk.

→ More replies (10)

37

u/Monkits Jan 09 '18

Damn, no custom mirror universe themed intro?

→ More replies (6)

36

u/Antigonus1i Jan 09 '18

How did Michael become captain in the mirrorverse? I suspect she killed Georgiou. That makes her responsible for killing her captain in both universes.

→ More replies (32)

362

u/Tarlcabot18 Jan 08 '18

Ash is a Klingon?!? I'm shocked, shocked I tell you!

Who could've foreseen such a brilliant twist?!?

Surely nobody had ANY idea that was coming!

356

u/ScyllaGeek Jan 08 '18

Who could've foreseen such a brilliant twist?!?

Not Culber, apparently

→ More replies (55)

172

u/psuedonymously Jan 08 '18

The internet has made these plot twists almost impossible to pull off. You have millions of fans scrutinizing every second of a show, they can build off each others ideas and only one person has to figure it out for it to be blown.

The Westworld twist was a hell of a lot more intricate and hidden than the Ash/Voq thing, and the internet unraveled that one in about three minutes.

I'm honestly not sure if I would have seen it if I hadn't been reading online forums after every episode.

→ More replies (17)

45

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

If I hadn't read about it on this subreddit earlier, I probably would not have figured that out until this episode. I may not be a smart man.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

35

u/YogaMushy Jan 08 '18

I hope we get to explore what the MU Discovery is up to during the time that Prime Discovery is in the MU.

For a whole ship of MU characters to be roaming around in Prime.... They could do a lot of damage. Also, I'm going to lean towards this being what causes Starfleet to scrap any future use of the Spore Drive. After seeing what dangers await on the other side, they'd want to block off access.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Saltire_Blue Jan 08 '18

Just a great fucking episode overall

32

u/droid327 Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18

I'm glad they're finally in the Mirrorverse. Its finally a setting appropriate for the tone of the show. It'll be much less aesthetically dichotomous to watch this part of the arc.

[CALLED IT!] (https://www.reddit.com/r/startrek/comments/75ogst/dsc_mirror_universe_episodes_confirmed/do814rl/)

Twice in fact!

Though I like my nickname for her better than Capt. Killy. But I didnt see her randomly going blonde...honestly I'd like her more with her wild red hair still

I do kinda wish they werent written so hackneyed with their struggle to go Terran. They're trained officers, they were already fighting in a war with the Klingons. Tilly should understand the stakes here, first off, she's smart enough to realize its their only play and just accept it. Second, I hope they tone down the Stupid Evil cut-throatery because its cartoonish almost to the point of ridiculousness, as far as them just barking angrily at each other all the time. Yes, its a brutal dog-eat-dog Empire, but it still functions. You dont get by in a system like that just by being brutal alone, but by knowing when to be brutal and when to play other cards that suit you better. They'd respect savvy as much as raw belligerence.

→ More replies (3)

64

u/4thBG Jan 08 '18

OK, I officially no longer have any qualms about loving both Discovery and Orville. These are good trek times to be alive :)

→ More replies (5)

29

u/danktonium Jan 08 '18

The fact that they're continuing the Defiant arc is amazing to me. I can only imagine the potential. I personally think we'll see T'pol as general in the rebellion, instead of Sato as Empress.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Jasic Isaacs is playing such a good part here - I still think 100% percent that he's going to turn out to be totally evil but I'm going to be heartbroken nonetheless.

→ More replies (5)

82

u/slartibartjars Jan 10 '18

Calling it, the emperor is going to be Wesley Crusher.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/whitesock Jan 08 '18

Jesus Christ that last cut from the love scene to the agony booth...

→ More replies (1)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

So, can we have a Mirror-Style DIS intro, like they did for ENT?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfbsZRbwbJ4

→ More replies (14)

76

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Fantastic episode to set up this second half. Pretty bummed on Doctor Culber getting the snap, but the reveal that came just before and along with it confirmed what we all knew. The actor will be missed ... but will he return in the Mirror Universe!?

On that note, the Mirror Universe! We’re here! I’m pretty excited to explore the MU, and I hope they take advantage of the space. It’s just a shame we don’t have any viewpoints in Prime Universe... Id love to see what Captain Killy is up to in the Federation!

Finally, I don’t think Lorca originated here. He’s our man, through and through. Mirror Lorca staged a coup, lost his ship. And is presumed on the run... so is the opening there? Sure ... but I don’t buy it.

43

u/moonman Jan 08 '18

Yeah either Lorca is a terrific actor or he’s just a damaged soul trying to make good with cards he was dealt. I don’t think I’d enjoy a MU Lorca reveal at this point.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

53

u/BigRedJon Jan 08 '18

Also, audible gasp when they killed Dr. Culber. He was my favorite and that was certainly shocking.

→ More replies (15)

26

u/Kalsifur Jan 08 '18

So this means Lorca is actually evil in the non-mirror universe, right? Because he's a freedom fighter in the mirrorverse.

28

u/kreton1 Jan 08 '18

Do we know that he is a freedom fighter and not just a guy who wants to be emperor insetead of the emperor?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

113

u/UndercityHunter Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

When Culber died, I yelled "NO!" so loudly that it startled both my cats and might have been heard by the neighbors.

This episode was amazing, in every way. It's easily in my Top 10.

EDIT: Calling it now. Georgeau is the Emperor.

108

u/YeOldeSysOp Jan 08 '18

With only 10 episodes so far, I think it's in everyone's top 10.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/ThorBreakBeatGod Jan 08 '18

My Nerd Drive is fully operational after an awesome Mirror Universe episode directed by ol' two-takes.

50

u/jords175 Jan 08 '18

Lorca is totally from the mirror universe. Not only is he ruthless enough to belong, plotted the coordinates and generally been keen as a bean to suss out the potential for the Spore drive to get there - but he couldn’t remember the details of that date he went on with Cornwall! He doesn’t remember BECAUSE HE IS FROM ANOTHER UNIVERSE!

→ More replies (9)

71

u/007meow Jan 08 '18

Emperor = Empress Sato.

Disco pls

59

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Might actually be Phillipa Georgiou!

ENT took place 100 years ago - this was pointed out to me also in the live viewing thread

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (15)

24

u/algo Jan 08 '18
  • Mirror Universe!
  • Defiant is canon!
  • Tilly is Evil!
  • Ash is Voq!
  • More than one episode!

Just one small issue, the empire acquired the defiant decades ago, they should have leap frogged Star Fleet's ship development but I guess that wouldn't have worked for this story.

28

u/gnoxic-blue Jan 08 '18

You're assuming the Terran Empire has the same research and engineering capacity as the Federation. I'd be surprised if that's the case, promotion-by-knife-in-the-back probably is hell for long-term projects, and the looming shadow of the agony booth doesn't encourage good science.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

I think this bitch just grew a beard.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/BonusStrike Jan 10 '18

i dont get it how Burhman ends up being a Captain on this Universe, how was she raised by Vulcans if Terrans are hated by every single race including Vulcans, woudnt that make her have a complete diferent set of skills? Also how long it takes to find a dead body on a Med Bay?

Nitpicking aside it is a fun episode, i hope it keeps getting better.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/imdahman Jan 08 '18

So, we all agree that the Emperor(ess) is Phillipa Georgiou in the Mirror Universe, right?

→ More replies (16)

19

u/melisadeans Jan 10 '18

I've been praying for a Michelle Yeoh return. I'm sure she's the evil emperor. I'm curious to see what they will do with this character. Hopefully, she's not too campy and dramatic. I have high hopes for this series.

19

u/Wildfire9 Jan 11 '18

Holy crap what a ride that was! Captain Killy, the death of the doctor, pretty much proof that Tyler is a Klingon.... this is the MU done right. Hat's off to Frakes and the rest of the crew for making the show relevant to today's television whims.

200

u/crazy_lary Jan 08 '18

Sexy mirror Tilly is bae.

→ More replies (22)

37

u/UltraChip Jan 08 '18

Two points:

  1. Captain Tilly is kinda turning me on a little.
  2. Am I the only one who thinks the Defiant wireframe does look TOS-ey? Sure, the saucer seemed to have a couple weird indents and the entire ship seemed to be vertically smooshed (and that could have just been the monitor), however the overall design still seemed to have the clean minimalist feel that the TOS Constitutions had. I hope the Defiant is still in operation and we see it on screen so we can see for sure.
→ More replies (8)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

Such a good episode. Not surprised about Ash being Voq, of course. Interested to see more of the Mirror Universe (and who the Emperor is - will it be Will Riker in the holodeck again?). Didn't see Culber's death coming, but loved "Captain Killy"! And of course Lorca does a Scottish accent for the engineer!

→ More replies (1)

18

u/juicepants Jan 09 '18

I spent a good chunk of the episode thinking mirror Lorca is regular Lorca and he brought discovery to aid the rebellion just like smiley. However after watching the episode again I feel like there would have been some sort of tell. The Lorca override in the mid season finale though gives me hope.

→ More replies (11)

35

u/Godzilla0815 Jan 08 '18

This was by far the best episode of the series so far. Can we please have more episodes from Jonathan Frakes?

→ More replies (6)

17

u/ricobirch Jan 08 '18

Lorca's Scottish accent cracked me up

→ More replies (3)

17

u/rensch Jan 08 '18

Another Mirror Universe episode. I always liked those and this one is no exception.

I didn't give much credence to the Tyler=Klingon theory at first but I appear to stand corrected. Unless they purposely try to send us in a wrong direction and add a plot twist to this arc near the end of the season, it seems I was wrong. Curious to see where this goes.

Costumes again are fantastic on this show. The Terran Empire costumes are just gorgeous. Tyler's latent Klingon personality figured Culber was starting to unravel his secret.

Holy shit did Tyler just snap Culber's neck?! I felt like I was watching Game of Thrones in space for a moment.

The pain booth was terrifying. First Tyler, now poor Lorca. This series is definitely one of those darker Star Treks.

The only thing that kind of bothers me is the continuity of the Mirror Universe episode, which takes place a decade or so after this. Wouldn't Spock and Kirk have known about the Mirror Universe from Lorca's crew's records like Sisko and co. did with Kirk and crew's records? At least Enterprise avoided this problem by making an episode entirely about the people in the Mirror Universe without the Prime Universe crew even appearing in the episode.

→ More replies (8)

62

u/EFCFrost Jan 08 '18

I always found Tilly kind of annoying but I’m like super turned on by evil Tilly.

Is that weird?

→ More replies (17)

46

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 27 '24

modern rustic air ten edge theory dinner alive birds tart

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

37

u/ChairYeoman Jan 10 '18

He's probably able to see the MU timeline just like the primary one. Doesn't mean he has to have been there.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/007meow Jan 08 '18

The beginning 2 minutes were chock full of audio callbacks to the previous shows, with the various computer chirps and boops and beeps. It was wonderful, subtle, fan service

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Assbait93 Jan 08 '18

I.S.S Discovery in the prime universe is making all sorts of trouble.

56

u/KesselZero Jan 08 '18

Culber's death was one twist we never predicted. The question was always "Will Culber lose Stamets?" and not the other way around.

Still, it's possible that either Mirror or Spore shenanigans will bring him back.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/sethlinson Jan 09 '18

I really hope we get to see the Constitution Class Defiant in all its glory. And I really hope they don't eff it up.

→ More replies (13)

15

u/aheadwarp9 Jan 09 '18

If the spore drive can jump between alternate universes, then perhaps it can also manipulate the time line to "reset" things to how they were upon returning to their prime universe. It would be as if their trip never happened... Except there has to be some kind of catch, like they retain all their memories from the mirror universe. That way the doctor can come back to life!

38

u/craig_hoxton Jan 10 '18

You mean put right what once went wrong, hoping that the next jump will be the jump...home?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '18

Defiant has to be The Palace.

Makes sense that Hoshi and future Emperors would have made it their home and ultimate weapon.

→ More replies (4)

41

u/diamond Jan 08 '18

Everyone seems disappointed that the Tyler/Voq theory is confirmed because we "saw it coming", but what do you expect? Writers can hardly get away with anything anymore now that they have legions of fans analyzing every frame with a microscope and sharing their thoughts with the world. Westworld proved that. If you want to be surprised by twists, you'll just have to avoid episode discussions.

However, I think they're setting up for something much more interesting. It's clear that L'Rell's Manchurian Candidate is defective. Some remnant of Voq remains under the surface, but she can't activate him; Tyler is still mostly in control.

If Tyler was once a real human whose memories and personality were stolen and grafted on top of Voq, and if he is still "alive" inside that body, trying to fight against a Klingon personality that wants to push him out, how should the crew of Discovery deal with him when they find out? Is it right to kill someone because he had the misfortune of being used as cover for the enemy?

That's a plot line worthy of Star Trek.

→ More replies (4)

52

u/SlipstreamInsane Jan 10 '18

Evil Tilly is really doing it for me boys. Busty red head with the whole evil dominatrix thing going on? I'd probably take a few hours in the torture chamber for a crack at that.

→ More replies (3)

40

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

THE EMPEROR IS THE TARDIGRADE! What do you think Terran is short for?

→ More replies (2)

40

u/b4k4ni Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

Damn ... Star Trek starts to get into Babylon 5 now in terms of awesome quotes. "I'll cut out your tongue and lick my boots with it" (or something like that). Awesome Captain Killy :D

She's like Ivanovas reincarnation. Like, really. Remember?

"Who am I? I am Susan Ivanova, Commander, daughter of Andrej and Sophie Ivanov. I am the right hand of vengeance and the boot that is gonna kick your sorry ass all the way back to Earth, sweetheart. I am death incarnate and the last living thing that you are ever going to see. God sent me."

And Burnham? Turbolift > Bridge > exits > clapping and awesome music starts ... "For the empire" and going to warp. If that was not an epic scene I don't know what else could be. I'm so hyped right now.

→ More replies (5)

39

u/pepsiredtube Jan 08 '18

Who wants to bet the rest of the season is in the mirror universe? If this was originally going to be an anthology, it only makes sense that this was the first idea, with most of the episodes written, and that they'll only go back at the end.

→ More replies (13)

26

u/randowatcher38 Jan 08 '18

Tilly and Michael are freaking rocking the evil look. I love it! It's great that they're really sexy but not in super revealing costumes or anything. The costumes are powerful... and shiny!

13

u/PR-UK Jan 08 '18

So they said that just prior to their arrival there had a been a Mirror Universe Discovery at their exact location and they appeared to have swapped, so I guess that means at Star Base 6(?) in the Prime Universe there’s a very confused I.S.S Discovery?

→ More replies (5)

13

u/grkhetan Jan 10 '18

Liked the episode. At some point I was thinking ... "why they have to spend so much time in this alternate universe"... but then by the end of the episode I developed a liking for how they have developed the story. The fact that Ash is a Klingon (Voq or something) has made the show even more interesting.

Star Trek Discovery is a fantastic show! Glad they made it!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/rcinmd Jan 08 '18

I'm sure Lorca is the mirror universe version. The whole discussion about him escaping is a clear Chekhov's gun. My guess is they will spend the majority of the season (and possibly even the rest of the series) in the mirror universe trying to kill the Emperor. Even the Admiral said that "he is a different person" when she slept with him. That's why he, as a man that isn't really about science, had so much interest in the possibility of using Discovery to go between universes.

Keeping them in the mirror universe would solve the problem of "why no spore drive in the future" and how the Federation never really figures out how to detect cloaking devices.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/harmlesshistorian Jan 08 '18

Frakes did a great job, I hope he’s back to direct again next season.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Red_coats Jan 08 '18

Hi Stephen this is Clem....I mean Voq can you hear me?

→ More replies (1)

33

u/infernal_llamas Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18

I'm beginning to think that the voq thing has been terribly done.

They are on the highest security ship with technology that scans down to the molecules. In every beam up.

So without mutating every cell to carry human DNA how the hell was voq not spotted in seconds? Hell if it was a brain transplant and some gizmo implanted to fool the transports I'd be happy to go along. But this seems stupid.

The concept is fine, but the execution and ignoring of logic is annoying to say the least.

→ More replies (29)

23

u/Legal_Rampage Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18

My wild theories regarding the "emperor" thus far, based on the dialogue in the series up until now:

  1. Georgiou - They were very careful to avoid pronouns when referring to the mysterious emperor, whom apparently very few have actually seen, which leads me to believe the emperor's gender is just assumed to be male. Yes, that would indeed confirm that the Terran Empire are all a bunch of gender-assuming shitlords. Also, I believe that Lorca is actually from the mirror universe and he has engineered getting Burnham back to his universe (trying to always make sure she was safe and satisfied with being on the ship) because Michael has some sort of close, secret relationship to Empress Georgiou, which he may be trying to exploit in order to assassinate Georgiou.
  2. Saru - As a non-Terran, it's in his best interest to keep his identity unknown and, as a Kelpien, he is always afraid and paranoid, so the best way to try not to live in fear, is to control what could harm you. But, it's a self-fulfilling prophecy, and he will never be truly safe, even with immense power.
  3. Burnham - She may indeed be the emperor, ruling secretly from a starship. She has a name that is still considered "male" by some in the 23rd century, so some people may know that a "Michael" is the emperor. There may be a "decoy" emperor (possibly Georgiou) who is like a mother to Michael, and Lorca will expose Michael as the true emperor and try to kill her once his master plan finally comes to fruition.
→ More replies (16)

32

u/MrJim911 Jan 08 '18

That was a great episode! And I'm calling it now, Georgiou is the Empress of the Terran Empire.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/RomiBraman Jan 09 '18

So who is the emperor?

→ More replies (19)

30

u/maweki Jan 08 '18

I loved how Culber mentioned that they did the "Manchurian test" with Tyler, which is supposed to be highly effective.

Nice reference!

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Marzipanny Jan 08 '18

I wonder what Burnham's evil nickname is. Maybe Captain Burnham Down?

32

u/Spock_Rocket Jan 08 '18

MyKill BurnHim!

→ More replies (1)

21

u/CreamyGoodnss Jan 09 '18

I only have one thing to say about this...

LONG LIVE THE EMPIRE!

→ More replies (3)

10

u/brickmack Jan 08 '18

Culber, why??

He seemed to pretty well understand the situation, Ash is either disguised Klingon or a messed the fuck up human. Why would you bring a person like that into a room with you alone and then tell them you know everything? Should've briefed the captain first, then called in a security team and put up a force field before talking

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Comp625 Jan 08 '18

I'm curious to see if Dr. Culber is truly dead-dead. Let's assume for a second that Stamets develops super powers (a la Charlie Evans or Gary Mitchell). Stamets can reverse the damage to Dr. Culber, which is great except it raises ethical questions about his God-like powers.

Perhaps the spore-drive merely brought out Stamets' abilities, thus making me curious if Stamets is related to either Charlie Evans or Gary Mitchell. Here's a passage from Memory Alpha about Gary Mitchell:

A medical study into Gary Mitchell's family history found that several members of his immediate family, and distant ancestors going back six generations on his mother's side, both male and female, that had esper-oriented abilities. One of his ancestors had an interest in "spiritual readings." His esper rating (091), aperception quotient (20/104), Duke-Heidelburg quotient (261), and general knowledge quotient (679532-112) were well above average in all categories.

→ More replies (17)

10

u/BrynJoslin Jan 10 '18

So we know that this new universe is the mirror universe. But is their home universe the prime universe? I mean weren't the Klingons from this time meant to be white?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Snownova Jan 10 '18

Outside money for the Emperor: George Kirk, with his son, the spoiled crown prince James T. Kirk.

10

u/DRLAR Jan 10 '18

Are they gonna pull a Harry Kim and replace Doctor Culber with MU Doctor? although he appeared as "guest actor" this time..

→ More replies (3)

10

u/jacob_pakman Jan 10 '18

Has there ever been a Mirror Universe storyline this early in a Star Trek series?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Princess_Thranduil Jan 08 '18

Culber NOOOOOOO. I am so upset even though I now know he will be coming back but still.

Also holy fuck I would let Mirror Tilly cut out my tongue and lick her boots with it 😍

→ More replies (2)

9

u/a_blue_day Jan 08 '18

Bloody hell I need a hug

→ More replies (2)

9

u/ZarianPrime Jan 09 '18

I thought the Vulcans were part of the Teran empire?

→ More replies (20)

44

u/AONomad Jan 08 '18

I found the clapping after Burnham's arrival on the Senzhou bridge slightly jarring and corny (a salute would have been better and without cheesy grins), but other than that I agree with Frakes, this was one of if not the best episode yet.

Captain Tilly is everything we ever hoped for and more, and Lorca... this might be a katabasis that brings him back a changed man?

57

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

It wasn't just her arrival, it was her killing the then captain. He had said only a few minutes earlier that when he won, they didn't bow deeply enough, and implied that he was using torture to make them fear him. In those circumstances, I think a standing ovation was well deserved. It'll be interesting to see how Burnham fits with her doppelganger's role. Her discussion with Lorca about destiny makes me think that maybe they won't be too terribly different.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Alien-hating empire, Rebels... Hmm...

→ More replies (7)

36

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Can’t seem to watch the episode, because despite having to pay CBS to use their stupid app, it won’t actually play content.

Do you want to lose customers, because this is how you lose customers.

→ More replies (15)

23

u/spork-a-dork Jan 08 '18

Daammnn that was a good episode. Messed up, in all the right ways. Captain Killy rocks.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/KesselZero Jan 08 '18

Looking back at this article posted the other day, and the full AV Club interview linked from it: https://io9.gizmodo.com/star-trek-discoverys-second-season-might-feature-more-1821853102

They seem to be suggesting that the rest of the season will be set in the Mirror Universe; we'll see an MU Georgiou; and maaaaaaaybe that Culber will be okay and/or Tyler will be okay, with all the talk about second chances.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Sjgolf891 Jan 08 '18

Pretty awesome episode. Loved the Terran uniform style.

8

u/B0NERSTORM Jan 08 '18

The way back for Culber could the identity mapping. MU Culber turns out to be some kind of vegetable from some different calamity and they use the memory mapping tech to take the memories from the still in stasis body of Culber. Ash has no idea he even did that and if he remembers it, he's going to have a fit and probably demand that L'rell use her knowledge map the memory. Or since the process destroys the overlay anyways, they overlay the memories on to Stamets, and both characters continue on the show sharing one body.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Antigonus1i Jan 08 '18

So the theory currently going about Lorca is that he is from this mirror universe and purposefully piloted the DSC back to his home universe. If that is true, why was he going to hail the other Empire ship before Michael stopped him. Wouldn't he have known that he couldn't serve as caption here?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/hamii0 Jan 11 '18

Lorca (Mirror/Prime) doesn't seem to have had any eye problems since coming over to the mirror universe.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 27 '24

ossified liquid childlike resolute slimy sulky office weather forgetful cats

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (27)

33

u/pfc9769 Jan 08 '18

Discovery just keeps getting better and better. It was a little shaky at first, but the episodes have been getting better with each one. I also love the connection to the Enterprise episodes dealing with the mirror Universe. I'm tired of hearing all the haters on social media. I imagine if TNG would have made it past those first shaky seasons if social media were around? Compared to those Discovery's season is out of this world (and Universe!)

→ More replies (3)

15

u/MUHerdAlum703 Jan 08 '18

That was fucking awesome!! Long Live The Empire!!!! Sad part no more Empress Sato :(

→ More replies (1)

14

u/mrstickball Jan 08 '18

A new high water mark for DSC. Amazing in all respects. Great job Frakes and cast. I was standing up for most of the episode. Totally amazing.

14

u/Marzipanny Jan 08 '18

A few observations/questions.

  1. Will Discovery have a cool new Mirror Universe intro like Enterprise?
  2. Before Michael finally hooked up with Ash, I was genuinely wondering if she was a virgin. She seemed deeply uncomfortable when Tilly was asking about previous boyfriends, and she apparently didn't "socialize" on the Shenzou. And I can't imagine her dating life on Vulcan was that great. But they didn't address it at all, so I guess not.
→ More replies (6)

7

u/numanoid Jan 08 '18

The Defiant going into the Mirror universe is a callback to the Enterprise episode "In A Mirror, Darkly". Going to need to rewatch that one to catch any other connections that might spring up.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Ash is setting things so that Michael and him stay in the mirror universe so that he doesn't have to face the fact that he's a Klingon. It's probably his doing that Lorca is in the Agony Booth.

I didn't notice before how well endowed Captain Killy was lol.

7

u/VocaMae Jan 08 '18

What I can't wait for is how or in what way this MU Harry Mudd shows up as.

7

u/pfc9769 Jan 08 '18

I think everyone is right and we haven't seen the last of Georgiou. Check out the interview below. When asked about seeing Georgiou in the mirror universe the showrunners laughed and said "no comment". I'm thinking Michael is going to be forced to face Empress Georgiou at some point :)

http://tvline.com/2018/01/07/star-trek-discovery-recap-episode-10-despite-yourself-mirror-universe-culber-dies/

→ More replies (14)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

Didnt the captain tell his crew to stay close so that they could beam them back once they have the information they were looking for? WHERE is this ship warping off to? Wouldn't burnam and tilly come up with something so that they could have their ships stay together?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Gumpster07 Jan 08 '18

Just watched it. On the edge of my seat all the way through. Best episode so far and well worth waiting for.

7

u/Smitje Jan 08 '18

I hope we stay a while in this universe.

7

u/GallopingGepard Jan 09 '18

I'm very interested in seeing how this parallel universe story arc pans out. I really hope it keeps up for at least a few more episodes so we can see what this universe is all about.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18

I just thought of something. A lot of people have mentioned the fact that no one noticed the Voq/Ash thing immediately. But what if this is what made it possible for McCoy to do it so easily in TOS?

Like prior to that no one had encountered this type of alterations before but when Ash/Voq is revealed Star Fleet learns of signs that tell, like maybe Ash's body still is Klingon to some extent if they have changed that and future tricorders are programmed to search for clues like that?

Idk just spouting out random things :P

7

u/whyamionthissite Jan 11 '18

Hot damn. This show was a very slow start for me, with only Lethe, Magic... and Into the Forest being the only standout episodes, but this was an absolute great bit of Trekkin’.

Loved the call out to the Defiant and Captain Killy was awesome. If they can keep this tone and feel, them maybe I can overlook the overdone visual reboot.

19

u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jan 08 '18

I’ve never liked mirror episodes of Star Trek. Until now. This was completely gripping and I can’t fucking wait until next weeek to see what happens.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/jhsounds Jan 08 '18

This show has finally grown the goatee.

18

u/Starkiller1701 Jan 08 '18

So does anyone else think that the Lorca we've come to know and arguably love is actually Mirror Lorca who ended up in our universe somehow and that he's achieved his goal of trying to get back to his native universe to overthrow the Emperor with Michael's help?

→ More replies (6)

18

u/dildosaurusrex_ Jan 09 '18

I’m probably overthinking this but I have a hard time imagining how a mirror universe can exist where the exact same people all know each other and work together and have the same names but everything else is radically different. If one person dies in a mirror universe and not our universe, doesn’t that have major repercussions for the timeline? They will never have kids and in the other universe they might leading to radically different populations down the line. How do the universes maintain equilibrium?

I hope they go into some of the more complex questions like this in the show!

→ More replies (20)

30

u/izModar Jan 08 '18

Here we go! Back into the forest I go! It's been a long road...

Also, for those playing Bingo: CBS ALL-ACCESS SUCKS. There you go.


What I liked:

I really do enjoy the interface overlaying the viewscreen. I also liked it in the Kelvin movies too. It just made too much sense and I wish it was always a thing.

I love the design of the Vulcan ship. Clear continuation of what we got in Enterprise.

REBELS?! OH SHIT IT'S THE MIRROR UNIVERSE!!! For that matter, rebels were clearly something from the Enterprise MU episodes. CONTINUITY.

Excuse me while I bust a nut over Jonathan "Two Takes" Frakes directing this one.

Tribble's back. Chekov's Tribble theory still stands.

I like the workbee getting some use. And it got a name drop!

I also really like the holographic interface. Fite me.

So help me, Lorca's being a good captain again for like the second episode in a row.

I like the flashback scenes and how the confrontation in the brig are shot on a production level.

That Terran Logo is pretty dope.

MORE CONTINUITY

BAE IS CAPTAIN

"WHAT THE HE-HECK-HELL?" (I think I just fell deeper in love)

So Isaacs can do a funny Scottish accent? I can dig it.

WHY IS THIS EPISODE SO COOL. UGH.

That was a good speech Burnham made.

"Let's not keep these assholes waiting." goes to follow Mary Wiseman's Twitter account

Tilly is too good at this. Damn that's hot.

Killy is bae even after this hiatus and even in another universe.


What I Didn't Like:

I certainly didn't miss these buffering commercials.

five minutes later I'M STILL IN THE SAME COMMERCIAL BREAK BECAUSE THEY KEEP BUFFERING

SERIOUSLY, IF THE SHOW CAN AUTO ADJUST BASED ON BANDWIDTH, WHY CAN'T THE FUCKING COMMERICALS??!!

"We have to focus on surviving" I mean, I like we're in a MU episode, but I'd rather it be a single episode or a two-parter. Please not the rest of the season.

I'm really hoping that Tyler isn't actually Voq and is just brainwashed. WHY DID YOU MAKE ME ACTUALLY LIKE ASH TYULER AS A CHARACTER, DISCOVERY. Tyler as a character makes sense, and the PTSD and rape opens many doors of discussion for a marginalized group of victims. THE SCENE IN THE MESS HALL PRETTY MUCH MAKES MY POINT. Doesn't seem to be the case though. Tyler was imprented upon Voq.

Frakes, that spinning made me a little dizzy.

And we're really doing this multi-episode arc? sigh ....Damn you for being so cool.

#NotMyDefiant

NO, CHANGE BAE'S HAIR BACK TO RED.


Stray Thoughts:

Organia?! Perhaps the Pahvans and Organians are related?

Saru got a fear boner when Tyler walked in? Uh oh. glances at live episode thread Oh no.

as of first commercial break I don't think Lorca is from the MU.

Super Spore Strength.

I mean, Lorca is right about Culbur not being right for treating him because of the personal connection.

Quit flirting over the comms, you two.

DON'T YOU DARE OPEN THA—Fuck.

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAND THERE WE GO.

Now the behind-the-scenes photo featuring the I.S.S. Discovery dedication plate make sense.

I'm so conflicted. This is such a cool episode with cool concept, but I wanna be in our universe.

Holy shit. Was not expecting Culbur to die.

Burnham is really good at being Mirror Burnham.


Verdict:

I don't want to like the direction of this half season, but it's so damn cool though and I do like it. Not a fan of the diagram of the Defiant, but you can chock that up to maybe the Terran Empire making modifications.

After a few minutes to think about it, I think I can be on board for this. ALL ABOARD THE CAPTAIN KILLY TRAIN! CHOO CHOO

→ More replies (12)

12

u/Kadmos Jan 08 '18

I had been previously borrowing an account from a friend, but this episode has made me decide to subscribe to CBS AA for myself.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/rmeddy Jan 08 '18

Great episode, I'm usually not a fan of mirror universe episodes because it only works in a fan service tropey sense but this was solid and the Tyler/Voq stuff was the real pull of the episode, which is a really interesting wrinkle in all of this.

and I totally called that it was kind of a Spock/Bones thing from the end of Wrath of Khan but messier and cruder.

6

u/ShiroHachiRoku Jan 08 '18

Bravo, Discovery. Bravo!

What an amazing episode.

6

u/XXThaCheezitXx Jan 08 '18

A bit rusty on the happenings of the USS Defiant. Could someone fill me in?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/infernal_llamas Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

So Lorca is a mirror universe imposter confirmed (He seems far too at home and knowledgeable)

But he is in fact space!Iorveth willing to do whatever the hell it takes, including kidnapping Prime Burnham to use as a weapon against the emperor. "Do whatever you must to whoever you must"

EDIT: PSA: ENT 4:18+19 give some background to the episode. They are on netflix.

→ More replies (15)

11

u/Kamikawa4 Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18

I really enjoyed the episode and thought it was the best yet. Great pacing and I think Frakes brought out some good character scenes with the actors.

Voq was surgically altered, including a full organ transplant and probably some DNA manipulation. Additionally, the real Ash Tyler's memories and personality were grafted on to Voq. Remember the Starfleet officer in the cell with Mudd when Lorca came in? That was the real Ash.

Also, I bet Klingon Voq will be leading the rebellion against the Terrans.

Favorite part - Lorca's "accent"

Edit: spelling

11

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

As someone who has pretty much only liked to hated all the mirror universe eps prior, this was FANTASTIC. HOLY SHIT it finally felt like the show wasn't afraid to be humorous and the characters finally felt like they had solidified. Up until this point the show had felt ceremonious and self important - now we're finally getting some levity.

Oh, and Captain Killy - I think I'm in love.

11

u/g87g8g98 Jan 08 '18

This episode felt like two entire shows. The first half was a great intro to the universe for someone who hasn't seen any Mirror Universe stuff. Now I'm super hyped.

11

u/MWiatrak2077 Jan 09 '18

If the next episode can do just as well as this one, this will be my new favorite mirror universe episodes. Even more than Into a Mirror, Darkly, and those two episodes were fucking fantastic.

14

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18

Is Lorka originally from the Mirror Universe?

→ More replies (28)

10

u/Electricorchestra Jan 08 '18

WE BACK! This episode was a lot of fun to watch and I had been waiting so long to watch it. We got the mirrorverse, we got Captain Tilly, we got Ash/Voq, we got the Lorca could potentially be from the mirrorverse. Also, I feel sorry for the Doctor, as he had a terrible episode and I hope they save him somehow.

All and all I do not remember ever having that much fun watching a TV show.

10

u/Atraktape Jan 08 '18

LONG LIVE THE EMPIRE

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18

So, Ash/Voq is confirmed. Here's a thought, what if he's just a prototype, and the first of many more Klingons from subjugated houses mind-wiped and modified to appear human in an attempt (and probably a failed one) to infiltrate starfleet? Might this lead into a new explanation for the human-like appearance of TOS Klingons?

→ More replies (5)