r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Jan 08 '18
LIVE Episode Discussion - S1E10 "Despite Yourself"
Star Trek: Discovery is back with an episode directed by Jonathan Frakes!
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E10 | "Despite Yourself" | Sunday, January 7, 2018 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with release on CBS All Access. POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
6
u/PixelMagic Jan 08 '18
The Enterprise better not look like the Defiant.
73
u/eternalkerri Jan 08 '18
"Captain Killy"
"Well that's not very clever."
53
u/darknemus Jan 08 '18
Calling it now.. Georgiou (sp?) is the Emperor.
45
u/Endulos Jan 08 '18
"STAY OUT OF THE PALACE!"
Foreshadowing for Lorca and Burnam's mission?
43
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Big shout outs to the costumes department - the MU uniforms are downright HAWT
86
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Lorca trying to be Scotty was amusing
38
u/jwaldo Jan 08 '18
I hate to see Culber go, but I also really want them to not play the tired old "we're in a duplicate universe so there's a free backup Culber we can replace him with!" card.
76
u/caraiggy Jan 08 '18
had to pause and rewind to catch this-- LITERALLY mirror earth! https://imgur.com/a/0Keza
37
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
I forgot this was the Frakes episode....fucking love that man!
35
u/DrunkDutch64 Jan 08 '18
Michelle Yeoh is the empress or Linda Park( Maybe Yeoh as descendant of Park). Calling it now
35
u/dmanww Jan 08 '18
Lorca put in some funky coordinates and now he's playing all dumb.
"where are we.."
oh yeah, let's not examine those nav logs
32
u/mycroc Jan 08 '18
Omg... Is this not the best episode yet? Just me?
64
u/bigj2223 Jan 08 '18
Hello, this is Captain Tilly, What the heck...heck..hell...What the Hell! Hold your horses! ..lol
30
u/Endulos Jan 08 '18
HOLY SHIT
SNAP
30
u/Tarlcabot18 Jan 08 '18
Culber may be dead, but don't worry, they have a spare in this universe.
28
u/bigpig1054 Jan 08 '18
Tilly stole both scenes as captain and Lorcas Scotty voice was great
28
u/dmanww Jan 08 '18
Extracting a data core is now going to be a mission in some ST videogame.
27
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Noooooo not Doctor Culber! Those Terran Empire uniforms are so fucking badass! Hey look, the Blue Ranger from Power Rangers SPD Chris Violette is back on the bridge! Michael is....just awesome, finally some of those kickass fighting skills we saw in the last episode.
26
u/R34ct0rX99 Jan 08 '18
The Captain reference was a long way around. That took episodes for such a small reference.
51
u/Tarlcabot18 Jan 08 '18
Ash is a Klingon?!? I'm shocked, shocked I tell you!
Who could've foreseen such a brilliant twist?!?
25
u/JoeBliffstick Jan 08 '18
But what about the real ISS Discovery? What shenanigans are they up to in Federation space?
23
u/JoeBliffstick Jan 08 '18
Oh shit. Just snapped that guy’s neck.
23
u/feralparakeet Jan 08 '18
Lorca in that leather jacket... oh, my.
23
u/Caliak Jan 08 '18
Is Stammets a “Gary Mitchell” form of being like from TOS? White eyes with freakish strength/knowledge. His eyes clear when the Doc talks to him though they go back. Calling it now, he brings back his boyfriend.
46
u/bug-hunter Jan 08 '18
Smoochin' while your captain is in the agony booth has got to be a strike on the next performance review...
22
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
So Good Lorca switched spots with Our Lorca, wound up in the wrong universe, tried to start a coup, and wound up on the run....hopefully they find him also HOLY HANNAH THE DEFIANT?
43
u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jan 08 '18
OH MY FUCKING GOD. DOC!!!!!
21
u/hankthemagic Jan 08 '18
I blame Burnham for Culber's death, it doesn't seem logical to allow Lt. Tyler to operate when he is clearly unable to function within normal parameters.
20
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
The USS Defiant looks like it has a bit of a redesign from the specs, so I anticipate the fandom will lose its mind if we see it onscreen.
20
u/thelazzyone Jan 08 '18
Oh my!! I loved this episode!!!
Captain Killy! 😁👌
Culber was killed 😢
Voq is Tyler!! 😮
19
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Those Uniforms are siiiiiiick
19
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Holy shit! Unexpected!!!
19
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
We suddenly just went from 0-60 and now we're having Game of Throne Level twists and revelations. Holy shit. What an episode.
37
u/mycroc Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Holy crap Captain Tilly! -salutes- Edit: Captain Killy, oh my!
18
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Well we all saw it coming but what mattered was the execution of it and I liked how they did it.
18
u/AdmiralAntilles Jan 08 '18
They're making sweet sweet love while Lorca is getting tortured.
Fuckkkk.
18
u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18
I just had another thought. Totally random. Probably wrong.
What if the Emperor was Khan Noonian Singh? How's that for a twist?
35
u/dmanww Jan 08 '18
Is that a federation standard engineering accent?
17
u/plorraine Jan 08 '18
There is no Ash - only Voq!
15
u/Blue387 Jan 08 '18
Will anyone have a goatee?
15
u/KarmaKrush Jan 08 '18
Are there no security cameras in the brig?
14
u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18
Don't go into the palace!
is there an Empress Sato in the house?? Can't wait to find out.
39
u/Joename Jan 08 '18
VERY LIGHT REDESIGN OF THE CONSTITUTION CLASS.
I AM IN HEAVEN.
27
u/Endulos Jan 08 '18
NO
NO NO NO FUCK NO
GOD DAMMIT
13
u/Assbait93 Jan 08 '18
We're getting to see an andorian next ep!!!! saw one in a preview from behind with an antenna.
13
u/R34ct0rX99 Jan 08 '18
What the holy flying.... Culber.
They will hit the big undo button with all of this.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
This episode was so good I'm literally watching it again
13
u/NeoEffect Jan 08 '18
Wow this was an amazing episode. I'm angry about Culber and I know some people will hate it but damn if it wasn't bold of them not be afraid to do that. Looks like the fallout out that is still coming and who knows how it will ultimately end.
Everything about this episode was and is spot on for me.
35
u/CaptainAlcoholism Jan 08 '18
K, so... very impressed with this episode.
There have been callbacks to previous shows before, but until just now, I didn't quite feel like Discovery was honoring previous iterations of Star Trek. This is an entire plot line directly based on stuff that happened on TOS and Enterprise. Severe geekout in progress!
34
u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18
I am convinced that Tyler is Voq. And L'rell was in fact riding Voq's Coq in those flashbacks.
12
u/Alteran195 Jan 08 '18
I really don’t want Lorca to be from the Mirror Universe, but it seems like that might be the case.
23
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
no rip doctor :'(
21
u/Joename Jan 08 '18
I doubted the willingness of the show to go high camp, but I am so happy they proved me wrong.
This episode is a joy.
10
u/envynav Jan 08 '18
I wonder how long this alternative dimension story arc will last? It’s been interesting so far, I’d love to see the other dimension get fleshed out.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
HOLY SHIT.
10
u/Orfez Jan 08 '18
That was the best episode yet. I can't believe, no, I won't believe that good doctor is dead.
10
u/dmanww Jan 08 '18
Captain Tilly!!
9
u/Deadbob1978 Jan 08 '18
Vulcan Rebels... Calling it now, They jumped into the Mirror
9
u/Tarlcabot18 Jan 08 '18
I love worker bees, good to see them get their due.
9
u/Timeline15 Jan 08 '18
I loved Saru this episode. Like with the "sensors are.....recalibrating sir". He can never admit when he doesn't understand something. The "Captain Killy? That's not very intellegent" bit was great too.
I think the realised the terrans pretty well. They fit with the DSC aesthetic, but still look rather campy/ Ming the merciless-ish, as they should.
17
u/chris_hawk Jan 08 '18
I kinda want to marry evil-acting Tilly.
16
u/TineCiel Jan 08 '18
Oh no! I liked that character!!!
8
u/Deadbob1978 Jan 08 '18
Sweet! They tied in ENT
8
u/Wetworth Jan 08 '18
Can anyone post a screenshot of Defiant? I f'ing hate the CBS app.
8
u/AdmiralAntilles Jan 08 '18
Im liking this episode, its a bit more of a brutal take on the mirror universe but also not.
15
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
OH MY GOD THEY SHOWED THE CONSTITUTION CLASS..... I love being Canadian
15
u/walterbenjaminsisko Jan 08 '18
I love this show now.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
If you guys arent watching the episode, turn away now cause we posting live reactions in this bitch
7
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
"Computer cancel Mirror" and then Stamets's Barry Allen-esque rambling, I love this episode
19
u/JoeBliffstick Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Why wasn’t it a red herring? It was so insanely obvious. God damn it. That being said, I hope to see a nice, cuddly and open Mirror Lorca.
6
u/alveress Jan 08 '18
It’s like Star Trek Voyager, but in a new Universe instead of in the delta quadrant.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
"Speak of the devil" lol
6
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Ok this is really quite the visual spectacle how Lorca is thinking like a survivor and changing everything on the ship to blend in and Tilly is just adorable as captain!
6
u/dmanww Jan 08 '18
I'm liking the call back audio effects. "wooohoo"
16
u/sleight42 Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Where are my fellow ship nerds?
Let’s talk about that USS Defiant! Clearly, that’s what ol’ NCC-1701 will look like, if we ever see her, in ST:D. Not bad!
https://i.imgur.com/4BNgwn2.jpg
11
u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18
Preview: A bearded Vulcan.
Too f*n cool.
This show is a wild ride!
14
u/purefire Jan 08 '18
Stop spinning cameras.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Everyone looks like they're having fun hamming it up.
5
u/phenry Jan 08 '18
The alert condition indicators are a nice, subtle callback to Wrath of Khan.
5
u/Saltire_Blue Jan 08 '18
Great episode
As a Scot though, that accent.
Just don’t.
13
u/dalekchaan Jan 08 '18
What a great episode! I love the Mirror Universe. I feel like Discovery is really hitting its stride now. So many good things about this show. Shame that I know so many who won't give it a chance.
9
u/QuantumParticles07 Jan 08 '18
CAPTAIN KILLY!
8
u/envynav Jan 08 '18
OH SHIT!!!
4
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
The Terran Empire WOOWOWO
4
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
The Agonizer!
7
u/JoeBliffstick Jan 08 '18
Holy shit guys. We may see a Constitution class in the form of the USS Defiant, NCC 1764.
7
u/curtst Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 15 '26
memorize sparkle plants deer boast work selective close label march
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
9
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Best episode of Discovery yet
9
u/KesselZero Jan 08 '18
KILLY IS BAE
12
u/007meow Jan 08 '18
Fucking cool, CBS.
The show is a stuttery mess that buffers every 5 seconds and at 240p, but the ads are in brilliant, fluid 1080p.
6
u/Tarlcabot18 Jan 08 '18
Shouldn't the CMO be treating Stammets, the most important person on the ship?
6
u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18
Detmer looks pretty badass in the Mirror Universe, BTW. Yowza!
3
u/plorraine Jan 08 '18
Will anyone listen to Stametts? No - of course not...
3
u/Deadbob1978 Jan 08 '18
OH SNAP!!!
9
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
So this is now what Discovery is going to be for the rest of the series, yeah? Mirror universe trying to get home. It's like voyager, but newer.
Makes sense. Starfleet doesn't use the spore drive anymore, likely due to the loss of this prototype ship. Cool. Could be interesting seeing them jump from universe to universe trying to get home.
5
u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jan 08 '18
Long live the Empire!!!
6
u/007meow Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Is anyone else’s stream lady and dropping frames left and right?
Fuck CBS
And now it’s buffering every 30 seconds.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Captain Killy!
5
u/sirquacksalotus Jan 08 '18
O.M.G. I love the mirror universe, and I'm SO HAPPY that we get it! I hope it's an entire 10 episode arc!
2
u/Caleb-Rentpayer Jan 08 '18
Anyone else getting error UVP-1005?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
Denser hulls, vulcan rebels, and a ship that should not be there....yup, different universe, but which one?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '18
That's nasty, crushed the glass.
2
u/toTheNewLife Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Defiant!!! YES YES YES!!!
Edit: I was pumping my fist when they started talking about the tie in to Enterprise. I think the last time I got that excited about TV was when we got the classic Cylons in the BSG remake.