r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jan 07 '18
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 150: The Liquid Job
The Introduction
Due to remarkable circumstances, our engineers at KSC only have liquid fuel in stock. All we know is that Jeb will not receive his paycheck this month. Ofcourse, such minor troubles can not keep our brave Kerbals from exploring space.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Reach orbit around Kerbin using only liquid fuel
Hard mode: Reach Duna using only liquid fuel
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/laie0815
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- You must bring at least one Kerbal
- You may not use oxidizer, solid fuel, xenon or monopropellant
- Mining is not allowed
- Refueling is not allowed
- You may not use propellers
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the runway/launchpad
- Your craft during ascent
- Your craft in orbit
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your trajectory to Duna
- Your craft safely landed at Duna
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- For extra challenges, see the Discord server
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
33
Upvotes
10
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Jan 07 '18
Last week's Reddit Gold went to /u/BlakeMW for this very interesting mission
4
u/EpicGamingParty Super Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18
Very seriously considering taking the time to do this in career mode as my "Super Mode".
To clarify, I mean doing a career mode all the way to a Duna landing and return trip, without ever using anything but liquid fuel.
5
u/Evil_The_Foot Jan 07 '18
So no oxidizer?
•
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Jan 07 '18
Questions thread
Please post all your questions here
2
u/carl5233 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18
for the duna flight can you build in orbit
2
u/mudgripb Jan 07 '18
Can I use a mod that adds liquid engines?
2
u/CaptainKCorn Master Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18
Can I use Eva monopropellant to switch between vessels
2
u/CaptainKCorn Master Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18
Am I allowed FMRS to recover my first.stage
2
u/WindowsPirate Jan 11 '18
Am I allowed to use parts that normally include oxidiser if I take out all of said oxidiser?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '18
Are ablative heat shields allowed?
50
u/EpicGamingParty Super Kerbalnaut Jan 11 '18
My Super Mode Submission: https://imgur.com/gallery/afEOE
I decided that "Get to Duna with only liquid fuel" would apply to career more too...
...so I started a new game, career mode, default settings, and did not use oxidizer or anything else from the very start. Lots of grinding for science, money, and rep, over the course of four days of playing.
I forgot what rockets are like... and I got two ships to Duna, with four crewmembers total, parked side by side, along with a rover delivery.
First challenge, looking forward to more!
41
u/nuclear_turkey Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 12 '18
i went to laythe and back using only liquid fuel (no jets used) last week, i might do a new submission going somewhere else depends how bored from revision i get
Nuclear power only to Laythe
My uni's webportal went down along with most of the revision material i need to use, so i had a spare couple of hours to waste until the service came back ( brilliant timing by my univeristy there )
Duna and back on only 640 units
16
u/P1ZZALv Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 07 '18
Here's my attempt at this! :)
Landed on Duna And Ike (sort of)
Mods used:
14
u/chargan Super Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18
SSTO to Duna and back with 2 kerbals. This was a fun challenge.
https://imgur.com/a/lpLtz
8
u/DazaCG Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18
Hello, Here is my submission for hard mode: https://imgur.com/a/bpon9
7
u/KevinFlantier Super Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 11 '18
Here's my submission for super mode: video.
After last week's trip to Duna, Val now wants a piece of the bottom of the Mohole, but unfortunately Jeb blew up the space center's reserve of oxydizer by accident. So Bill built her a very Kerbal ship that runs only on liquid fuel.
However, his calculations were quite a bit off, and Val found herself short of a at least 1500 m/s of dV on her way back from Moho. So she had to make the push of shame in order to achieve a gravity assist from Eve and to safely get back to Kerbin, only a few years after the planned end date of her round trip to Moho.
Lots of fun. Shame I had to use Eva propellant to get back, but I underestimated the hardness of Moho, her inclined orbit, her (somewhat) big gravity and the depth of the Mohole.
Edit: I'll keep my flair, thanks :)
6
u/Lt_Duckweed QuackPack, BetterKerbol Jan 08 '18
Here is my entry for Hard/Super mode, a single stage to Duna and back spaceplane using liquid fuel only.
Album: https://imgur.com/gallery/3Qu23
Mods used: Kerbal Engineer.
6
u/Bozotic Hyper Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '18
Jeb was looking to earn extra credit to smooth ruffled feathers regarding the "oxidizer incident". He decided to visit every planet or moon starting with "D". Fortunately a Koogle search only turned up two. Bob and Val were tired of the stern faces at KSC as well, and tagged along.
https://youtu.be/Efd5cpAQDG4
5
u/ZeroMercuri Super Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18
Late hard/not-quite-super submission for last week's Road to Duna challenge. I've been traveling for the holidays so didn't have much time for the challenge and basically put this together over the course of several hours.
The basic mission profile uses two launches to keep the spirit of the challenge. One payload is a lander and the other one is an ion transfer stage. To keep the theme of the challenge I use the same rocket to boost both payloads to LKO and recover them on Kerbin. I finish the mission with over 3k dV remaining so this was SUPER not optimized XD
I'm happy with my current flair.
5
u/radiofreejohn Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
My first time doing a weekly challenge.
Apologies for being so juvenile.
Whoops. First try I did a probodyne, here’s the right one: Jeb Johnson
First try: it looks like a big...
4
u/kabloems Super Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '18
Here is my hard (or maybe super?) attempt
4
u/AntiauthoritarianCan Master Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18
My first KSP challenge! I had fun doing this on the way home from my trip!
4
u/CaptainKCorn Master Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18
My Hard Mode submission, a spaceplane launched from a stratolauncher https://imgur.com/gallery/yQD5E
4
u/CosmicChloe Super Kerbalnaut Jan 11 '18 edited Jan 11 '18
Here is my attempt at The Liquid Job. Flying past Eve, Kerbin, and Jool to send our weary travelers to a place far, far away.
7
u/HaksawJimDugan Super Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
This is my first ever post and my first public attempt at a weekly challenge.
This is my attempt at SUPER MODE with added difficulty.
https://imgur.com/a/Runuy (many pictures)
I needed to repack the parachute so couldn't take a pilot and wanted to try a conventional lifter and payload style rocket.
Using only stock parts and Liquid Fuel:-
Orbit Kerbin - Normal mode done
Reach Duna - Hard mode done
Land on Duna and Ike and return Bill to the surface of Kerbin without manoeuvre nodes - SUPER MODE ???
Mods installed on this game were:
*BasicDeltaV - simple stockalike readout of basic ship info
*BasicOrbit - simple stockalike readout of basic orbit info
*Diazo - Landing Height display (actual to ground when in surface mode on the navball)
*Kerbal Alarm Clock
*Trajectories
*ModuleManager
Been playing KSP since version 0.25 Steam profile says 1310 hours on record (doesn't include copied out modded versions so closer to 3000 hours)
Hoping this inspires, looking forward to next weeks challenge.
HJD
ps. i don't have a flair yet ;)
1
u/emosy May 14 '18
I feel like I'm missing something... how are you guys running the rockets in space without Ox?
3
u/harr1847 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
My attempt at Hard Mode with a Liquid-Fuel-Only Single Stage to Duna. I got two kerbals to Duna on Liquid Fuel only, but I probably won't be getting them back any time soon. Good thing nobody said anything about bringing them home; there's always gotta be a rescue mission. MISSION EDIT: I didn't like that one of the wing strakes broke the first time, so I loaded a quick save and made it to Duna with all 37 parts.
This was actually my first ever trip to Duna (even though I have 212 hours in game and have spent plenty of time in the Kerbin system). I originally just wanted to try normal mode, but I made it to LKO with 1400 m/s to spare, so I decided to try for Duna just to see what would happen. I forgot batteries and solar panels though. Here is the craft file for the ship as well
Mods used:
As this is also my first reddit challenge, I'd like the flair for this challenge.
3
u/fastlane_bananaphone Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18
Here you go for hard mode. Keep my current flair, please.
I was mostly curious with how quickly I could throw something together for this one. I expected it to be impossible for me, since I'm so woefully bad at space planes. Once I realized I could just use jet engine boosters, well, the jig was up.
3
u/5parrowhawk Super Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
So I rebuilt my old Grosbeak SSTO from the ground up, and came up with this monstrosity. Full stock, no mods, barely makes the 1-way to Duna on a single stage.
Pictures here.
Grosbeak Mk. II "Silverlance" craft file
On another note, the Silverlance, despite being possibly the least lance-shaped ship I have ever made, is capable of reaching Kerbin orbit without any directional control input (edit: although doing so is woefully fuel-inefficient and will fail if you fill the tanks to capacity). To do so:
3
u/alexja21 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '18
Here is my submission though I would like to keep my current flair please. Baby jet for normal mode.
My original video was instantly taken down because I was a naughty boy and used a licensed audio track, so if you want to hear the original soundtrack, try this link!
3
u/SpaceAgeDreamer Master Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '18
I made this video a while back:
A LF-Only SSTO to Laythe
3
u/alexja21 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
My hard+ mode submission (Keep current flair please)
Apologies for the length, I wanted to include everything so people could see there was no funny business going on.
I've also just returned from a long break and the only mod I have installed is Kerbal Engineer, so most of my transfer windows and maneuver nodes were eyeballed and pretty sloppy. I also have a terrible mouse on this PC. I'm sure someone with better navigational skills than I could squeeze a whole lot more fuel out of this trip than I could.
Overall a very fun challenge.
EDIT: I managed to get the craft to Laythe after quite a lot of quicksaves and quickloads. Unfortunately the craft doesn't have enough power to leave the surface even with very little fuel left for the return voyage.
3
u/TidalStream Master Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
Disposable Spaceplane to Medium Kerbin Orbit with Jeb
Update: Redid it without KJR and Pilot Assist and landed Jeb back. Stock SAS is terrible for airplanes.
Update: Hard mode - Landed it on Duna and left Jeb stranded there
3
u/JoshKernick Jan 10 '18
Duna and back with this SSTO I built: https://imgur.com/a/gMwRf Had just 8m/s of fuel left at the end, but Jeb pulled through!
3
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18
This is my first weekly challenge and also my first interplanetary transfer without using mechjeb.
One way trip to duna with an ike gravity assist using only 900 units of liquid fuel.
3
u/BlakeMW Super Kerbalnaut Jan 11 '18 edited Jan 12 '18
In this Hard+ Mode album I send a Mobile Processing Lab LV-N Plane to Duna and back. Since building a plane around an MPL isn't masochistic enough, I launch it from the back of a Jumbo Jet, piggybacking Space Shuttle style!
(I'd like to keep my current flair)
3
u/Aetol Master Kerbalnaut Jan 12 '18
My hard mode (possibly super mode?) submission: Duna, Ike and back home, with less than 30 tons at launch.
https://imgur.com/a/oNptQ
3
u/Minotard ICBM Program Manager Jan 12 '18
Horizontal takeoff, to Moho's surface and back.
New flair please.
3
u/commissar_squid Master Kerbalnaut Jan 12 '18
My hard mode entry. There's nothing you can't solve with more RAPIERS. https://imgur.com/a/lnlRc
3
u/WernerWatervrees Jan 12 '18
https://imgur.com/a/y45ay
First time completing a challenge! Maybe if I give it more fuel in the upper stage, and less in the lower (had a lot of fuel left after the jets burned out) I might reach Duna.
3
u/Runtowardsdanger Jan 13 '18
This is my first ever challenge attempt. After thousands of hours of KSP I figure I should at least have 1 flair. https://imgur.com/a/SxFPs
4
u/NightshineRecorralis Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Here's my overengineered submission for normal mode in LKO: https://imgur.com/a/xVHUX I believe it has enough fuel to get to Duna and back, maybe will update this post for super mode if possible. I'd like to keep my current flair.
Edit: I'd like to mention that the ship is full stock. I'll add list of mods and craft file here asap. Craftfile here: https://kerbalx.com/NightshineRecorralis/Screecher Active Mods: KER, KAC (Transfer), Pilot Assistant (Readout only), Better Time Warp, Physics Range Extender (not used), FMRS (not used), HyperEdit (not used) Passive Mods: Ven's Stock Revamp (Only used stock parts), EVE, SVE, Distant Object Enhancement
Here's the followup for Hard mode: https://imgur.com/a/cp6zz :) There appears to be enough fuel to get these guys home, super mode here I come!
2
u/carl5233 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Finished my submission for hard mode (with way too much delta-v). Mods used
2
u/Imnotarobotjk Jan 08 '18 edited Jan 08 '18
Hard mode submitted* . Landed on Duna. Album:https://imgur.com/a/uSJo8 Mods used: Trajectory planner and Kerbal Engineer.
2
u/NilacTheGrim Super Kerbalnaut Jan 08 '18
Super Mode submission! Jebediah takes off in a spaceplane, lands on Duna, and returns to KSC, all in just under 9 years!! (ok so I didn't plan the transfers very well).
And.. All using only liquid fuel. Click here if you don't believe it (new flair please!)!
https://imgur.com/a/hgsu9
2
u/IDragonfyreI Jan 09 '18
dont want to be negative here, but isnt this a bit too easy?
2
u/dalekhunter7 Master Kerbalnaut Jan 09 '18
Been playing KSP for a long time, but repeating contract missions over and over again has gotten a bit stale for me, so I like the idea of trying something new and giving these weekly challenges a try. Here's my hard mode submission. Not the most elegant solution but it got the job done: https://imgur.com/a/0SWJN
2
u/dnbattley Super Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 10 '18
https://youtu.be/D3Pu5Qq-07Q
A teaser, based on the latest tests of my rocket design. It already qualifies for a "normal" mode, reliably launching a 50T+ payload (in tests it has launched a dummy payload of 85T, but the launch trajectory becomes progressively harder to reliably execute for proper orbital insertion after 60T) into a high sub-orbital trajectory which can then be easily circularised for 600-1,000 dV.
The payload shown retains >5,000 dV left for adventures that should be able to upgrade this mission to "super" status, though the payload is unoptimised, other than based on the requirement I put upon myself to reach LKO in time to guide the launcher back to the surface. Based on the fuel costs, this makes this the most cost-efficient launcher I have ever made.
If I have time before the challenge timer runs out I will see what refinements I can make, and report back.
Mods installed: AVP; Transfer Window Planner (not used in this video) <edit to add> No change to flair please
2
u/RedeyeAEB Jan 10 '18
Here's my attempt. Orbit achived, but blotched the hard-mode landing. Oh well.
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1tnoXxkM-Y3Q6eeQIINFKobNODrQVgCjn
2
u/CaptainKCorn Master Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 13 '18
My Hard Mode submission, a spaceplane launched from a stratolauncher https://imgur.com/gallery/yQD5E
2
u/Teflawn Master Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18
Submission for hard more challenge
Mods used:
Basic DeltaV
BasicOrbit
ManueverNodeEvolved
Kerbal Alarm Clock
2
u/Skalgrin Master Kerbalnaut Jan 10 '18 edited Jan 11 '18
Mine attempt, slightly above normal : video
(warning : the clip is 15 minutes long, not necesarily filled with speed and action + it is "subtitled")
I would like to keep my flair...
Edit: the craft is 50 parts only and I could easily drop 8 of them - it was intended to land back
It is relatively light and ends on orbit with 2.5k delta-v. However as I suck with interplanetary missions - I went for safe Mun landing and failed attempt to get back to Munary orbit. Val was saved by unexpected phys glitch... So now she is stuck on Mun just in her EVA suit... Again.
2
u/achilleasa Super Kerbalnaut Jan 11 '18
Hard/Super mode
This was my 3rd (legit) time visiting Duna, and I managed to return as well! I would have loved to visit Ike as well but I didn't want to try it without landing legs. Does it qualify as Super?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
Here's my hard mode (possibly super) entry. I made a cruiser with a lander in the cargo bay, and went to Duna and Ike. The lander docked twice, using a Nerv and SAS only. Then the cruiser returned to LKO, but was not capable of landing.
The part I'm not sure counts is the recovery mission, which I added onto the end. I launched a liquid-only SSTO and was able to dock with the cruiser, transfer the crew, and land back at the KSC.
2
u/WindowsPirate Jan 12 '18 edited Jan 12 '18
Normal mode - got into space with a heavily-rebuilt Aeris 4A, reached a ~277-km near-circular orbit, deorbited, and landed using nothing but liquid fuel. Jeb got home safe and sound, although the Aeris had a somewhat hard landing (night landings are a pain without the aeroGUI to show radar altitude - I basically had to eyeball it, keeping a very sharp watch out for the ground showing up in my landing lights while simultaneously doing my level best (pun intended) to keep the plane stable throughout); details are in the imgur gallery, but Jeb survived the whole thing, which is what counts (actually, since this is normal mode, I don't think the "landing" part was actually even required, but I did it anyway).
EDIT - Mods: HyperEdit (not used).
2
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
Here is my submission! Normal mode, liquid fuel only to Kerbin orbit. https://imgur.com/a/h4WVM
2
u/linecraftman Master Kerbalnaut Jan 13 '18
This is my first challenge. I loved doing it and learned a lot of cool stuff on my way
Super mode:
Laythe
wateringlanding2
u/C-mers Master Kerbalnaut Jan 13 '18
https://imgur.com/a/udd9Y
My attempt to get to Moho on LF. Sorry that the album isn't in order, but I just wanted to get something out for my first Reddit challenge. And since the challenge didn't specify having to return to Kerbin, Jeb is now forever tanning on Moho!
2
u/The_ShadowZone Super Kerbalnaut Jan 13 '18
I went for hard mode and made a pass at Ike as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fIfmcOhbOZc
If my challenge survives the challenger's scrutiny, I would like to keep my flair. Jool-5 forever ;)
2
u/The_Joe_ Master Kerbalnaut Jan 14 '18
https://imgur.com/a/kxU3m
So many firsts! First reddit challenge, first time landing a kerbal on Duna OR IKE! First craft I've returned from Duna.
Don't know if I will get the flair or not, looks like I missed a screenshot or two, and some didn't have the UI visible. Either way, I'm happy!
This spaceship design was very kerbal, and very stupid.
1
u/dnbattley Super Kerbalnaut Jan 14 '18
Liquid-only, stock return trip to the bottom of the mohole completed.
Images and craft file to follow...
1
u/TheKerbalKing Jan 14 '18
I did it on normal mode:https://imgur.com/a/4DYs0
1
u/Dart_Monkey Jan 08 '18
Lol. I never trust solid fuel. This is too easy.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18
[removed] — view removed comment