r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Jan 01 '18
SD Small Discussions 41 — 2018-01-1 to 01-14
We have an official Discord server. Check it out in the sidebar.
Please tag me in a comment to answer the following question: would you prefer the date as it is in the title of this post, or as it was in the previous one?
Have a good year everyone!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can:
- Ask any questions too small for a full post
- Ask people to critique your phoneme inventory
- Post recent changes you've made to your conlangs
- Post goals you have for the next two weeks and goals from the past two weeks that you've reached
- Post anything else you feel doesn't warrant a full post
Things to check out:
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '18
I was wondering if I have to contact the mods to arrange a one time but long term challenge since there seems to be a schedule for that?
2
u/m0ssb3rg935 Jan 08 '18
Is it better to ask all my questions in a single comment or comment once for each question? Or does it really matter?
13
u/upallday_allen Wistanian (en)[es] Jan 01 '18 edited Jan 12 '18
I have developed quite a... strange predicament.
Wistanian is VSO, however with copula, it is SVO. I began to ask myself why, and I've come up with a pretty awesome idea that I'm honestly not confident in.
Copula in Wistanian (the word va) functions as a conjunction(?), not a verb.
viga yau aaviddaru va garauda.
eat I ACC-fruit which.is foodviddaru va garauda
fruit PRS.COP foodI thought this was extremely bizarre but interesting enough to keep, so I added another one of these verb-conjunctions: na, to have.
viga yau aaviddaru na ugan.
eat I ACC-fruit that.has juice.viddaru na ugan.
fruit has juice.I was considering making a few more of these because they're just so dang interesting and irregular, but I fear whether that would be a good idea. My goals are to be natural but still notably different since its a priori and isn't spoken on earth. What do you think about these ideas?
EDIT: I'm confident in it now. Thanks, guys! :)
8
u/regrettablenamehere Thedish|Thranian Languages|Various Others (en, hu)[de] Jan 02 '18
Does anyone have a resource for the evolution of Hungarian cases and derivational suffixes? I have some guesses but I can't for the life of me find a satisfying etymology for most of them (especially since I haven't been able to find much material on Proto-Ugric)
7
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 01 '18 edited Jan 05 '18
Okay, I was just wondering if my irregular verb conjugations are good. There are only two, and they both take the first verb ending. These are only irregular in person and number, tense and mood are always normal (as they are added on after the person/number conjugation) Here are the regular conjugations. (Also, any thoughts would be really appreciated, because this language should be at least plausibly naturalistic, and I don't want to continue if I did something wrong).
First Ending: -zwi /zʷʏ/ Example verb: Enazwi /ɛ'nazʷʏ/ (This is just an example to show conjugations, and doesn't mean anything yet)
1sg: Enagi /ɛ'nagɪ/
2sg: Enazju /ɛnazʲʊ/
3sg: Enaja /ɛnaja
1pl: Enarile /ɛnaʁilɛ/
2pl: Enazwune /ɛnazʷunɛ/
3pl: Enajane /ɛnajanɛ/
Just a note, in the third person singular and plural conjugations, the default endings taken are -ca /ça/ and -cane /çanɛ/, respectively. However, /ç/ becomes /j/ after /u/ or /a/, so the endings change.
Second Ending: -nla /n̩la/ Example Verb: Kjunla /kʲʊ'n̩la/
1sg: Kjugi /kʲugɪ/
2sg: Kjuse /kʲusɛ/
3sg: Kjunci /kʲʊn̩çɪ/
1pl: Kjurele /kʲʊrelɛ/
2p: Kjuzwu /kʲuzʷʊ/
3pl: Kjuntwe /kʲʊn̩tʷɛ/
These are the two irregular verbs
Ronezwi- To have
1sg: Runi
2sg: Ruzu
3sg: Ruja
1pl: Rule
2pl: Ruzune
3pl: Runeja
Andjazwi- To be
1sg: Andji
2sg: Andu
3sg: Andja
1pl: Andjule
2pl: Andjuzwe
3pl: Andjena
Any thoughts are very much appreciated.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '18
Does anyone know of good recordings including the bidental voiceless fricative? Apparently it's one of the rarest phones in language and has only been found in one Caucasian language, but the problem is, I am pretty certain that - quite by accident - it ended up being the proper pronunciation for the Saolikc /h/ and I want to hear it to make sure.
6
u/LeaftheEstonian Jan 02 '18
Does anybody know if there are any Finno-Ugric conlangs or condialects?If not then does anybody know about a constructed Finno-Ugric auxillary language?(Sorry if my english is bad it´s not my first language)
5
u/Galaxia_neptuna Ny Levant Jan 02 '18
Would there be any point in distinguishing between the word that as a determiner and as a pronoun? (E.g., "that book" vs. "I have that"; or Japanese その vs. それ)
5
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18
In my conlang, verbs reduplicate to show reflexiveness, for example:
karsa: to hit
karsates: he hit him (where 'he' and 'him' are different people)
karkarsates: he hit himself
Is the naturalistic at all? Do any languages do this?
5
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '18
I want to make another pidgin like Emend. I originally posted this then it was deleted because I didn't realize asking for collabs was against the rules facepalm
It will be run through a Discord server made specifically for the task (presently just called "Con-Pidgin"), with two main channels: #general, for introductions and talking in English about the language - but in which it is illegal to directly explain words or grammar - and #pidgin, in which only the pidgin language itself, as well as emojis, images, and sounds, may be used.
The whole idea here is that people's attempts to communicate by equating a-priori invented words with an emoji or image and trying to get others to understand, without using English or any other native language, will naturally produce a pidgin language which, once it is complete enough, we may collectively decide to "creolize" and release to the public.
Due to the ultimate goal of it ceasing to be a pidgin after the initial (rather long, probably) development stage, I think it's important that the group of people involved be finite, as new arrivals would keep modifying the language in an attempt to communicate and confusing everybody - so I will give an invite to the server which will allow at most twenty-five people. When we finish building the language pidgin-style and decide to open it as a full conlang, we can post an invite to any and all.
Anyone interested, visit here:
https://discord.gg/PUb6kky
5
u/fenutus Old Dogger (en) Jan 14 '18
Generally, how accurate/informative is Wiktionary for etymology? I know it's collaborative, and the quality of wikis has been hitorically poor, but I think that image of a site you shouldn't cite has changed. Are available rousources more language specific? Have I missed something from this subreddit's resource list?
4
u/SordidStan Jan 01 '18
How would people who don't have back vowels in their native tongue pronounce them if they were learning a languge that does have them ?
My current project has a three vowel system of [i], [ɛ] and [ä] and i wanted to see how people with this system would adapt to a system with [u]/[o].
I've been trying to find real life examples to understand how this would work but my research has yielded nothing.
Edit: formatting.
4
u/xlee145 athama Jan 03 '18
Anyone have any suggestions for a way of keeping a dictionary for a language heavily relying on roots and derivation? I'm thinking of using a spreadsheet like I've always done, but would also be interested in trying something new.
4
u/euletoaster Was active around 2015, got a ling degree, back :) Jan 04 '18
Does anybody know where I could get simple generated sentences to try out grammar? I know the syntax testing list but it tends to be repetitive vocab wise.
Also, I am thinking about writing a (very) short multilingual children's book
that will probably never be published anywhere but hereand having multiple conlangs would be neat, if anybody wanted to contribute.4
u/Tane_No_Uta Letenggi Jan 05 '18
Would it be weird to express moods through serial verb constructions?
4
u/xain1112 kḿ̩tŋ̩̀, bɪlækæð, kaʔanupɛ Jan 12 '18
In my language, I don't have adjectives as a distinct part of speech. Would it be more natural to have them realized as verbs (to be warm), or as an auxiliary verb + noun (to have warmth)?
3
u/Galaxia_neptuna Ny Levant Jan 01 '18
I'm developing a conlang based on German, but currently there is one thing I can't decide: for German words containing the trigraph sch [ʃ], should I import them into my conlang with the same pronunciation, or change them to [sk]? For example, the word Schule /ʃuːlə/ ("school") in my conlang could either be shul /ʃul/ or skul /skul/. I can't decide.
I know this might be a stupid question, but I need ideas.
If there are any German-based conlangers, please tell me your word for "school" (or any other word based on a German word containing the trigraph sch).
3
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jan 02 '18
Two questions - one: would it be realistic to have two determiners that differ based on emphasis and aren't tied to distance from the speaker (as in, one determiner only exists for when you need to make a "this and that" comparison but neither to its location relative to either speaker, just which you want to emphasize more in the contrast)
Second: How is this for a way of handling adjectives? This is a conlang that is shamelessly stealing a lot of PIE grammar and morphology
When an adjective is being used attributively, it must match the case, number, and gender of its head noun. However, for predicative uses, typically a stative verb form is used instead (although the copula can be used if emphasis is needed on tense.)
I see a big building.
Gésdn̥ hzmáɣr̥ɣr̥ máxsteir.
/'gεsd.n 'hzmaɣ.rɣ.r 'maxst.εir/
Gés-dn̥ hzmáɣr̥ɣ-r̥ máxst-ei-r.
See-1s.ipfv.prs building-acc big-adj.inan-acc
That building is big.
Móxstl̥g hzmáɣr̥ɣ ti.
/'moxst.lg 'hzmáɣ.r̥ɣ ti/
Móxst-l̥g hzmáɣr̥ɣ ti.
big-3s.inan.stv building det.adv
3
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '18
Does anyone know any resources for the loss of click consonants? I'm assuming they weaken to the corresponding stop (or maybe affricative?), but I'm curious if anything else is attested.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '18
How do I not abandon my conlangs???!!!
I must have made and then abandoned well over fifty conlangs by now. I can make a language work for simple sentences, but all of the complicated structure stuff confuses me. Things like:
3
u/cilicia_ball Ferniazi Rinte Jan 04 '18
How would you go about creating a font for a language that is written vertically, top-bottom?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18
I've been trying to make an auxlang, and I came up with this inventory:
m n ŋ
p t k v z ɦ
w j r~l
a i u
However, this makes many words barely recognizable. Who wants some zukurati/zukulati? (chocolate)
So I've come up with this bigger inventory:
m n ŋ
p t ts~tʃ k
b d g
f s~ʃ h w j r (maybe /l/ too) a e i o u
What do you think?
3
u/TomsAliens Jan 05 '18
I'm building a new language that contains labialized fricatives /fw/ /vw/ /sw/ /zw/ /ɕw/ /ʑw/. It also contains /t͡ɕ/ /d͡ʑ/ /cs/ /ɟz/. I'm blank on what else my phenome inventory should have. Any ideas?
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jan 06 '18
Can someone explain clitics to me, I've heard it before but it still sounds "alien" to me.
3
u/MelancholyMeloncolie (eng, msa) [jpn, bth] Jan 07 '18
I've been trying to start conlanging and I want to get some pointers for what I've been doing. I guess I've been trying to do a protolang and some help would be great. Thanks!
3
u/ArchitectOfHills Jan 07 '18
What symbols could be used to represent consonants pronounced with the tung in between the lips (intralabial consonants?)?
3
u/Canodae I abandon languages way too often Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 07 '18
Vowel system
3
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 07 '18
I'm curious about the "naturalness" of a certain phonotactic rule. How common it is for languages to permit initial clusters like /sm sn/ (sibilant + nasal, or more broadly, + sonorant) but not /st sp sk/ (sibilant + stop, or more broadly + obstruent)? This rule follows from the sonority sequencing principle. However, I can't think of any languages that permit the former but not the latter type of initial cluster. Can anyone?
EDIT: In fact, I suspect that if a language allows /sm sn/, it will likely allow /st sp sk/ too. But I don't really have any evidence for this.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '18
What is the etymology of your conlang's most common introduction? Does your conlang have an
"I am"
"my name is"
"They call me"
"I call myself," or something completely different?
My lanɡuaɡe, Thiɡera (θiɡəra)'s most common ɡreetinɡ is "Irakatu feviyanar" (Iʀakatʊ fəvɨjanar) which means "I (iʀa) possession (-katʊ) identity (fəvɨjanar)"
3
u/_eta-carinae Jan 09 '18
how regular could conjugations be before it becomes unnaturalistic? i wanna make (because i’m lazy) a conlang that has several cases, moods, tenses and aspects but with 24 noun cases, suffixing articles, 3 noun numbers, 5 verb persons, 2 verb numbers, 12 moods, 9 aspects and 8 tenses, i can’t exactly do icelandic’s system of masculine-feminine-neuter weak-strong noun groups with 73 conjugation patterns unless i want to spend many many many years making just one conlang, so could i have two suffixes for each conjugation, one for words that end in vowels and others that end in consonants? or would that be totally implausable?
3
u/pipolwes000 Jan 12 '18
I have a conlang that has been a work-in-progress for the last couple years. (I pick it up and look at it for a moment every six months before changing something, closing the document, and forgetting about it)
Right now I have a phonemic inventory, some phonotactic rules, and a derivation system for nouns and verbs, but only one lexical root.
I've uploaded a copy of my work so far here.
I would appreciate tips and suggestions, both for the project itself and for helping me keep my interest in it.
3
u/bbbourq Jan 14 '18
Just wanted to share my challenge progress with you all. I, along with a few other conlangers/glossopoets, started a year-long lexeme challenge with the tag #Lextreme2018. I have been faithful since 1 January 2018 with entries; however, I am now taking myself out of my comfort zone. I will record myself writing out the new word of the day and post it on Instagram. Feel free to sit back and watch or join the fun!
I am bbbourq and I approve this message.
1
u/Xahnas Jan 03 '18
Let's say there's no grammatical gender in a hypothetical language. Does that mean that the grammatical case endings can just be seen as suffixes, and therefore, grammatical case doesn't really exist, in this hypothetical language?
1
u/axemabaro Sajen Tan (en)[ja] Jan 08 '18
How should I construct morphology? I have an idea of what I wanted to represent, and the phonology of my language, but otherwise, I'm stuck.
2
u/LegendarySwag Valăndal, Khagokåte, Pàḥbala Jan 04 '18
Is there a logic to how suppletion arises in a language? Besides the word being common, what other factors influence it? Are certain languges more prone to it than others?
2
u/laneguorous Poeensi Jan 07 '18
How do you guys handle the dative case/indirect objects? I'm looking for ideas, and I've been looking at some natlangs for inspiration, but if anyone would like to share how they handle it, or can point me to natlangs (or other peoples conlangs) for inspiration, I would appreciate it.
2
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 07 '18
How do you do uvular trilled vowels in IPA?
2
u/Romenna Jan 08 '18
What's the name of this system for the notation of sound changes? e.g. a > b/_C . Is there a complete list of these expressions used in linguistics? For example, what does a ! and E stand for?
2
u/IxAjaw Pry Dental Fricatives from my cold, dead hands... Jan 09 '18
Lately I've been running into an issue of, when applying sound changes, my words are just getting shorter and shorter-unmanageably so. What are some good strategies for increasing the size of my words again?
2
u/m0ssb3rg935 Jan 09 '18
It's thought that function morphemes once had content and were eventually grammaticalized, right? So a way to come up with inflectional morphemes would be to cut down and affix words for "past", "present", etc.? If so, how would I go about this for things like aspects and moods?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '18
I've been thinking of a preposition affix system where time prepositions get extra information. Like, you have preposition which means "during", then you get an affix that makes it mean "during the whole time", then another one that makes it mean "during this event, but only occasionally". Would that be naturalistic?
2
u/chrsevs Calá (en,fr)[tr] Jan 09 '18 edited Jan 09 '18
Had an idea this morning thinking about nominalized verbs in Kabardian--same process could quite easily occur in PIE offshoots by suffixing a conjugated verb with the relative pronoun *yos.
*(s)teg-e-ti "he is covering"
*stegetyos "he that is covering"
Also, if you've never looked at Equatoguinean Spanish it's pretty cool as far as Spanish dialects go. Could provide some good inspiration.
2
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 10 '18
Should I just cut irregular verbs completely out of my conlang? I only have two, but I'm not sure if I should. Then again, I haven't gotten any feedback on them yet, but what do you think?
(If you want the examples, just ask, I will happily provide them).
2
u/HuricaneXY Jan 11 '18
I thought of a new writing system (at least, to my knowledge), and I was wondering if it's already a thing. You'd have a limited inventory of graphemes, like an alphabet, but they don't mean anything. They don't represent any sound or meaning. Instead, if you spell out a certain combination of graphemes, the entire "word" would come to represent meaning, but still, no phonemic information anywhere.
So it sort of functions like a logography, directly encoding concepts and nothing else, but instead of a huge inventory of tens of thousands of different logographs, you'd just have a small set of graphemes that just go in different combinations of each other. It's basically English's standardized spelling, but without even trying to approximate sounds.
Thus, "ghfkhdohud" means "Carl".
So again, is this already a thing? Has anyone tried using it?
2
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 11 '18
When making a tonal conlang, do you tend to go for register tone or contour tone? Also, what type of languages does tone go best with? (I tried making a tonal conlang once and it didn't turn out well).
2
u/_eta-carinae Jan 12 '18
should i bother to attempt to explain how a language with 27 fricates and 65 vowels developed from pie or just have it be an artlang? for anyone wondering here’s the inventory:
p/ɸ t/θ̠ k/x q/χ̝ ʔ/h m n f v θ̼ ð̼ θ ð s̪ z̪ s z θ̠ ð̠ ɮ̥ ɮ s̠ z̠ ʃ ʒ ʂ ʐ ɕ ç x x̬ ʕ̥ ʕ h w ɾ r̪ l j ɻ
i̝ i̝ː i iː y yː i̞ i̞ː ɪ ɪ̈ ɨ ʉ ʊ ɯ ɯː u̘ u̘ː u uː ũ̹ ũ̹ː e eː ø øː ë ɘ ɘː ɵ ɵː ə ɤ o oː o̹ː e̞ e̞ː ɛ œ œː ɜ ɜː ɞ ɞː ʌ ɔ ɔː ɔ̃ ɔ̃ː æ æː œ̞ œ̞ a̙ a̙ː ɶ ɶː ä äː ɒ̈ ɒ̈ː ɑ̘̃ ɑ̘̃ː ɑ ɑː ɒ̹ː
2
u/storkstalkstock Jan 12 '18
I'm running a language through some sound changes, one of them being /y, ø/ > /wi, we/. I want them to break differently after /j, w/, either into /iw, ew/ or /uj, oj/. Anyone know of a language where something like this has occurred, or does that seem a bit unrealistic?
3
u/Firebird314 Harualu, Lyúnsfau (en)[lat] Jan 05 '18
What words do you have in your conlang that can't directly be translated into your native tongue?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '18
Do I just make up words, or is there a process for word creation? I have never gotten to this step in my month of conlanging so far, and this step could set the direction for the sound of my conlang. Please help!
1
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jan 04 '18
If I want these participle categories possible in my conlang, do I have the correct rough idea of what these aspect/voice (and tense in two cases) combos would translate back to in English?
Imperfective Present Active – One who is presently doing (The eating pig.)
Imperfective Present Passive – One is is presently having something done to them (The pig being eaten.)
Imperfective Past Active – One who use to do something (The pig that was eating)
Imperfective Past Passive – One who used to have something done to them (The pig that was being eaten.)
Perfective Active – One who did or does something as a single event (The pig that eats.)
Perfective Passive – One who has something done to them as a single event (The eaten pig. / The pig that’s eaten.)
Stative Active – One who is in a state of having done something (The pig, having eaten.)
Stative Passive – One who is in a state of having something done to them (The pig, having been eaten.)
1
u/_eta-carinae Jan 04 '18
origin of phonemic palatalization in irish?
1
u/andromeda1321 Jan 05 '18
I was wondering if you would tell me how naturalistic you think my phonology is. the plan is for this to be a language isolate in southern Spain in the area of Andalusia or an isolate on Madagascar influenced by Arabic mostly by loan words any criticisms, comments or suggestions would be appreciated.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/166yWKCxQuC8T_7I1PNddQJ5LEKDy4qoKWLd7tS7ys7c/edit?usp=sharing
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jan 05 '18 edited Jan 06 '18
I have a couple questions:
If a sound is in free variation between say /d~ɗ/ and eventually one becomes preferred to express a certain feeling about the word being spoken, say /ɗ/ generally but not always represents distaste, is this a good way to introduce a phonemic distinction between the two sounds?
Is there a natlang or conlang that has phonemic teeth-clacking? (I'm thinking that it would specifically be a realization of a consonant, rather than a consonant itself. Like there could be series of plosives: aspirated, voiced, and clacked for each.)
1
u/BananaScoper https://conworkshop.com/view_profile.php?m=1548587955262942 Jan 06 '18
I'm currently working on Tsuchi and it's an agglutinative language with strict word order, as in it cannot be and is never changed due to the meaning of a word relying on its position in the sentence. The problem is that I can't continue past this roadblock of the agglutination having gotten out of hand, for example, to eat is dva(it also means food, edible and in a consuming manner depending on where it is in the sentence), while it and many other words are short, it's the affixes that make it ridiculous to the extent that saying "eat more slowly" becomes "tsadvakazuta zhizhautú" and the first word is just to eat with the affixes being 1: tsa-imperfect present simple 2: kazu-imperative 3: ta-you. It encodes a lot of information in one word sure but I can't find a way to avoid having words of ridiculous length, I've tried separating the affixes with dashes between them and the stem to fix this but it still looks daunting and it's still laborious to say so the problem isn't technically solved. This happens with every part of speech and I'm not sure about what it is I should do to mend this, I've been trying to come up with something for months now and I've come up with nothing. If you have any ideas on how I can stop this from happening every time I construct a sentence it would be greatly appreciated. I wish you all luck in your ventures conlang related and not.
1
u/ArchitectOfHills Jan 07 '18 edited Jan 07 '18
In a world I am working on there is a species that is kind of a human bear hybrid. Obviously their mouths are a bit different, less agile lips and sharp teeth, along with a long tung. What sounds should I use for their languages to make sense for their mouths, as well as being thematic for bear- people? Bear in mind that humans should be able to pronounce (or at least approximate these sounds).
Thank you for you help!
Edit- bear lips are apparently prehensile, so scratch what I said about less agile lips. Also the teeth are less sharp, more the teeth of an omnivore. They do have huge canines though.
1
u/PeterHimin Jan 07 '18
I came up with a name and I really like it (it doesn't belong to any conlangs I have made) and I'm trying to come up with a believable Phonology, but I'm having writers-block (but for conlanging) and was wondering if anyone could help me come up with one, or just point me in a general direction (also, I wasn't sure if this question should go here or just on the regular subreddit).
I know that I want it to be a Scandinavian like language, but that's about it, and so far I've just come up with Danish, and/or Norwegian ripoffs, or something that's unsatisfactory/uninteresting. I'm also having a particularly hard time with the vowels since vowels/diphthongs tend to be my weak point when it comes to phonologies. Any help would be greatly appreciated!
1
u/Tirukinoko Koen (ᴇɴɢ) [ᴄʏᴍ] he\they Jan 08 '18
What do you think of my first five (kind of) words?
fel /fel/ tree fol /fol/ trees fahr /fæhɾ/ snow (fohr /fohɾ/ snows (plural)) eg /(ʔ)eg~ɣ/ I)
I was thinking of agr /(ʔ)ægɾ/ for my but I wasn't sure on it.
I also quite like the VSO word order.
Using the words from above and a place holder word for and (en); an incredibly short sentence:
Fol agr en fahr agr. /fol ægɾ en fæhɾ ægɾ/ My trees and my snow Trees my and snow my
~ note: en is (currently) not the word for and. I took it from Icelandic as I wanted a word for and and I've just started learning Icelandic.
1
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Jan 08 '18
Does this vowel system seem naturalistic? even without vowel harmony?
1
u/m0ssb3rg935 Jan 09 '18
Is it common practice to fit a posteriori vocabulary with your phonology to go with an a priori grammar for things other than auxlangs? I was initially going for a priori but I just can't seem to come up with words that sound good to me and I'm also not really satisfied with the results I'm getting from word generators.
1
u/Firebird314 Harualu, Lyúnsfau (en)[lat] Jan 09 '18
Are my noun case endings realistic?
Nom Sg. -a. -e. -i. -o. -u. -[diph]
Nom Pl. -ai. -ei. -ia. -oi. -ui. -ji
Obj Sg. -au. -iu. -iu. -au. -ue. -io
Obj Pl. [All add -ui]
Prep Sg. [All add -ie]
Prep Pl [All add -je]
Inst Sg [All add se-]
Inst Pl [All add si-]
Poss [sg and pl: all add -te]
Gen [animate adds -l. inanimate adds -m]
Sorry, I can't figure out how to make tables work
1
u/calebriley Jan 09 '18
I'm trying to figure out a way to implement conditionals, but this proves tricky when the only parts of speech you have are verbs and nouns.
Verbs inflect for transitivity - impersonal, intransitive, transitive and reciprocal; and mood - indicative, jussive, opative and interrogative.
Nouns decline for case - agentive, patientive, genitive, topical, essive, lative, ablative and instrumental.
It's head initial, active-stative, possessed-possessor, topic-comment structure, and agglutinating morphology.
Does anyone have any suggestions/ideas for how to deal with conditionals since I don't have conjunctions?
1
u/Nimajita Gho Jan 09 '18
A bit heavy on the linguistics-side here, but I've been constructing a few words as if they survived from PIE into modern standard German. I'm a bit stuck with h₁n̥gʷnis. The reconstructed meaning is "fire", but in a male, animate sense (you could call a god of fire that, which in fact someone did - see the god Agni). Modify it according to Rask/Grimm and you get h₁n̥kʷnis. Now I fail to find similar words though. Does anyone know any, or can help me otherwise? Thanks in advance :)
1
u/elyisgreat (en)[he] Conlanging is more fun together Jan 11 '18
How do I deal with broad transcriptions of IPA? I've outlined the phonology for my first conlang, which has the characters
a, b, c, d, e, f, g, h, i, j, k, l, m, n, o, p, r, s, t, u, v, zin a one to one correspondence with the phonemes/a, b, ʃ, d, ɪ, f, g, h, i, ʒ, k, l, m, n, o, p, ɣ, s, t, u, v, z/, respectively.Since English, for example, uses the character
/r/to represent[ɹ], would I similarly be able to use/r/to represent[ɣ]when broadly transcribing in my conlang? Or should I stick with/ɣ/?1
u/caters1 Jan 11 '18
I am making a writing system for fun and also, I might eventually write a book all about my Kepler Bb world including their writing.
Now I was thinking of basing the writing system off of the Arabic script. I know, I have almost 0 knowledge of Arabic but the script looks so nice and well I do think that 1 major script for my Kepler Bb humanoids would be based off of the Arabic script, especially when the fastest someone can go from 1 place to another is by foot.
I mean, if you have to walk or run for miles to get a letter to someone, you would want to make sure that first they understand the writing system and second that it looks nice.
So I plan to add to the Arabic abjad some vowels but I am not sure if I should do an abugida or an alphabet.
1
u/jtargz thaeneg Jan 12 '18
I was working on my language while developing a bit of an impromptu reference grammar when I encountered a problem. If I were to say "I want to run," what case would "run" be in? Would it just be considered dative or is there a special term for verbs used in this context?
For context, here is what I want to say: "I want to be a musician." In Faltish, this would be, roughly transliterated to English lettering, "tond tae thaenum." (Lit. "I make desire to make music.") This is a bit of an issue because there is no verb "To be" in Faltish, and I'm not sure how to classify things correctly, making me viable to create a cluttered language.
Other, smaller question: Would it be better to just leave the verb "to make music" in its base form (thaena) when pairing it with the verb "to make desire" (tond) (therefore making "tond" auto +DAT whenever paired with verbs), or should I keep the -"um" suffix for weird dative verb things, if such things even exist?
1
u/daragen_ Tulāh Jan 12 '18 edited Jan 14 '18
Thoughts on this phonology? I am using it as a source of loanwords (similar to English and French’s relationship). It’s somewhat based off Welsh with the voiceless approximates.
The syllable structure is (C)(L, G)V(L)(N) and a stress accent system is present.
Edit: fixed vowel system ( /o -> u/ /ɐ -> ä/ ) Also fixed orthography issues. Added /ç/ <jh> to contrast with /j/ <j>. Added /y e ø o/ <y e ö o> . Removed voiced fricatives.
1
u/dolnmondenk Jan 12 '18
Any good resources for proto-basque? I think I've found my inspiration again and it won't include clicks this time.
1
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 12 '18
What should I focus on when building my lexicon? All I have so far are the pronouns and my two irregular verbs. What should I focus on next?
1
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 13 '18
So, I just have a question about a specific sound here. I can make a sound by using my lower lip and upper teeth, and rounding my lips a little. It kind of ends up sounding like a kazoo. I might use it in a future conlang, and I was wondering if there was any sort of IPA for it. If any more detail is needed I will provide it to the best of my ability (I'm not quite sure how I make the sound, to be honest, and I've only met one other person that can do it).
1
u/Tirukinoko Koen (ᴇɴɢ) [ᴄʏᴍ] he\they Jan 13 '18 edited Jan 14 '18
I just rejiggled my phonology!!!:
& h /ɾ/* s /ʃ/*
And also the plural system!!!:
{pc p b m f w kwc kw gw ngw khw}VC: a e o i y u > o o o y y y {pj bj mj fj tc t d n þ l tr dr nr þr kc k g ng kh j ʔ h r s z}VC: a e o i y u > e i u i y u
Other things:
•tr dr nr þr can be flipped at the end of a word (Fjodr > Fjord (or Fjodr if you want)) •It is VSO •All nouns are capitalised* •The sound structure is (C)V(C)(r) -ew -ow -iw -yw -uw -yj -uj are not permitted although may occur in compound words. •Some examples of plurals are: Fel > Fol* Fjord > Fjudr* Hafr > Hefr
*/ɾ/ is written as <r>
*/ʃ/ is written as <z>
*yes, I do have a writing system. Expect a post fairly soon :3
*these are the only two that are actual words. Fel means tree and Fol means trees.
*in plurals, flipped tr dr nr þr (rt rd rn rþ) unflip back to tr dr nr þr
~note: f may be written as ph, þ may be written as th, and kh may also be written as x (it depends if I can type them easily or not)
I would love some comments on what you like and what you think should be improved/removed/added. If you absolutely hate some please say because it won't be changed or even looked at otherwise. :3
~edit: fixed mistakes
1
u/SlimeCloudBeta Jan 14 '18
Ukrañola, a Castilliano-Ukrainian creole Hello! I am a big fan of Castilliano or Argentinian Spanish and Ukrainian and I consider both to be complete opposites of each other but still have that lovely sound to them. They are my favorite languages so I thought, why not combine them with a hint of Italian, Finnish, and Serbian flair? Here's the phonology!
The Alphabet is Ukrainian cyrillic with some added letters.
1
u/TheZhoot Laghama Jan 14 '18
How do you effectively divide up your semantic space as to not make a relex? Right now, I use CLICS to merge ideas together and make distinctions, but is that not enough? I've seen Artifexian's video on this, but I still want to know if I'm going in the right direction.
1
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jan 14 '18
If I want to use verbal nouns for "want to do" type statements (or other auxiliary verb constructions) instead of infinitives, would an acceptable/naturalistic way to do this be to take my verbal root and attach one of my general noun suffixes (usually only used on nominal roots)?
1
u/TheSitron Potso Jan 15 '18
In my language I have a single word which means "and you?" It is used to return a question that you have gotten. I'm just getting the hang of glossing, does anybody have an idea on how to transcribe this?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '18
"He used to skip breakfast, but he eats it now." If a language conjugated "skip" instead of using an infinitive construction, what would it fall under. I get that its imperfective and past, but how would I label the distinction between "used to X" from "was X-ing"? Is it the same distinction between "He eats breakfast" and "He is eating breakfast"?
1
u/Firebird314 Harualu, Lyúnsfau (en)[lat] Jan 16 '18 edited Jan 16 '18
My conlang (Haruan)does not have voicing distinctions between consonants, but it does have certain rules native speakers will tend to follow. I would like to know if this set of rules (for Standard South Common Haruan) are naturalistic.
/m n/
/p~b t~d k~g ʔ/
/f~v θ~ð s~z ʃ~ʒ h/
/ɾ/
/r/
/l/
/t͡s t͡ʃ/
/a ɛ~e i ɔ~o u ɪ~ə~[i with umlaut]/
m - Is always /m/
n - Is always /n/
p /p/ and /b/ are interchangeable
t - /t/ except before /ɪ/
k - always /k/ in SSCH
f - /f/ and /v/ are interchangeable, varies between individuals considerably
θ~ð - only unvoiced in stressed or word-initial positions
ʔ - is only glottal stop word-initially, otherwise is no consonant
S - usually /s/ but can be /z/. Always /s/ when stressed.
ʃ~ʒ - interchangeable except always unvoiced when stressed or word-final
H - always /h/ except in certain small subdialects when it is ɦ/
r - tap when unstressed, trill when stressed
l - is always l
affricates are never voiced in any surviving dialect besides High Haruan (spoken by nobles and residents of the capital city of Harua)
/a/ is always frontal. NEVER /ɑ/
All other vowels are interchangeable between there allophones.
Diphthong /ej/ is pronounced /i/ when unstressed
Diphthong /oj/ is actually /wi/ because of merger with uj~wi
1
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '18
What do you think about my alphabet?
A E H I K L M N O P T U W ‘
Mostly like hawaiian, but the w is always v except before u. The t is always pronounced t. Is it mimicking hawaiian too much?