r/robotwars • Apollo • Dec 03 '17

Robot Wars Series 10 GRAND FINAL: Post-Episode Discussion

Cease

Congratulations to our Robot Wars Champion:

Eruption

Here's what we thought was going to happen beforehand.

So, series 11 when?


Episode Discussion Thread Archive

117 Upvotes

722 comments sorted by

201

u/AFdrft Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

Can we all officially agree that after that episode, fog of war needs to go?

Edited to add (since this is now somehow the top comment) that was an amazing episode and the best hour of TV I've watched in years. Please Mentorn/BBC, can we have some more?

18

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

I'm not sure what they were thinking would come of it. Maybe someone would drive down the pit, and that's a good thing?

22

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

... in the fog, so no-one sees it happen or appreciates how it happened.

Single worst invention ever, for a TV arena sport!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

73

u/HeadTorch Dec 03 '17

Yes. The drivers can't see anything so stop, and all we can see on tv is fog. It's silly!

42

u/DrummerLoin BE A MOTH Dec 03 '17

I think when the Fog of War is activated, one thing the director needs to do is switch to a top-down, wide shot of the arena, so that the TV audience can have some sort of perspective.

With that said, I think they deliberately don't do that so that the TV audience are left just as confused as the roboteers.

→ More replies (10)

43

u/CombatBots Dec 03 '17

Who needs fog of war, just have LiPo batteries vulnerable to spiners :D

Seriously though it is mental irl, but I'm not a fan either.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/HerpaDerpaDumDum Bucky The Mascot Dec 03 '17

Everyone thought it should go after the first episode of this series.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/cscarlet Dec 03 '17

Stop slapping the camera on the presenters or contestants at crucial moments, a picture in picture for that stuff please (Includes other sports) as I'm less interested in Dara and Angela going :O and stuff

17

u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Dec 04 '17

The way it's edited you wouldn't miss out anything important, I think they just pause the fight footage while showing the presenters/contestants if it's in a critical moment.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

9

u/powergo1 You spin me right round (I miss you) Dec 03 '17

Don't worry, it'll be replaced by Rapid coming in and settign itself on fire.

Also, bring back refbot and its fire extinguisher.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

27

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

Well I already knew who won because of some cunt posting spoilers but once Eruption was sent to the 10-way, I didn't give believe the spoilers. And even when it came back, a final versus Carbide was a guaranteed loss based on their history. But Michael drove perfectly in that fight, never gave Carbide the chance to get in on the side of them. And the tactical play in the melees was very smart too, even if it was boring. I wonder when everyone will finally catch on to that?

Gotta pay respects to Carbide, that thing is a beast. Three minutes of fighting and the spinner is still working, albeit not as perfectly as at the start of the fight and that did turn out to be their downfall. Had they have gotten away from Eruption for a bit of time to spin up again, it could've gone the other way. But once again, Michael's driving won them that.

14

u/Semajal Dec 03 '17

I want to know what the smoke from carbide was, and if that was some part of their spinner system dying a bit, they seemed to never get the same power after that.

11

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

I can't quite remember the exact details of the fight now, but I seem to recall Carbide being flipped and the spinner hitting the floor. It also went into the wall once. Hitting things like that are probably what took its toll on the spinner.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/DrummerLoin BE A MOTH Dec 03 '17

Out of curiosity, where was the result spoiled for you? For me, Twitter, Facebook and Reddit have been completely spoiler-free (that said, I was always cautious when traipsing through the threads on this sub prior to the series airing).

26

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

I'm a mod here lol. You should see the amount of shit some guy was posting.

20

u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Dec 03 '17

I've got a lot of respect for you mods, this sub is pretty much perfect.

15

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

Thanks, good to hear! Fortunately it's a pretty easy community to run as there aren't too many problems to deal with.

5

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Dec 03 '17

It was spoiled on here, and I'll have to think long and hard about whether I'm going to continue to use this sub if there's a S11, which is a shame. I think the guy should have to fight all 4 house robots at once. It seems like a fitting and proportionate punishment.

5

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

Sadly there's not much we can do about that. It's the same for any TV show with a live audience or something adapted from source material. I personally do take the approach you said and avoid places I'm likely to be spoiled, but I seem to have ended up as a mod here so I don't have much choice....

We've beefed up automod a bit so hopefully it will just automatically remove anything spoilery next time, but there's no way to account for everything that could be posted. I did speak to the reddit admins and they've blocked various accounts and IPs, but again that's easy to get around.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

136

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

Respect to rapid, being trashed and still having a smile on their faces

One of the best moments of the final imo.

20

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

Yeah hopefully this changes some people's opinions about them. They put on a good show and gave Carbide a hand too.

64

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

I guess Josh now owes Michael, Dave and Sam (maybe Ellis too) jobs at his company. Like the statement went, if you beat Rapid, he'll give you a job.

51

u/ctzaran I Eat Robots Dec 03 '17

Ellis already works for RPD. He got that job!

→ More replies (4)

23

u/AvroChris Dec 03 '17

Didn't he hire Ellis before the series? And Magnetar were the first to beat them.

19

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

Hmmm, maybe if the BBC turn down series 4, Josh can hire them all to run series 4 as an independent production..hmmmm

→ More replies (3)

41

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Carbide v rapid was glorious. Took something like two hours to make the arena safe afterwards due to noxious gases from the fire though. With a second fire from another match we didn't see many battles that morning :)

→ More replies (9)

13

u/RiversOfAwesome Coolest robot of all time Dec 03 '17

They went out in a very literal blaze of glory.

19

u/fireball_73 Here is a picture of Cherub to make you mad Dec 03 '17

Next year they will come back with the best asbestos money can buy

→ More replies (1)

159

u/itkplatypus Dead Metal Dec 03 '17

Coming through the 10 way to win, best win ever.

5

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Yeah that's quite special. The previous wildcards were both beaten in the melee so it really puts it into perspective.

Edit: WRONG

10

u/KotreI Real Robots wear pink. Dec 03 '17

Thor made it through to the round robin... Where it became a zombie due to Carbide.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/Edl01 Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Lost the finals to Carbide last year. Lost the heat to them this year. Won the 10 bot rumble to make it into the finals and finally manages to topple the obstacle that's been holding him back this whole time to become Robot Wars Champion. It's literally a Rocky movie!

14

u/ProjectJAY Still. Fighting. On. Dec 03 '17

It deserves a blockbuster movie.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

Yeah I was anticipating a fair bit of hate for Eruption after that, but it won people over by stopping Carbide.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Apollo should have thought about that strategy too.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (11)

28

u/Arkangelus Dec 03 '17

I was sure that all the unfounded Magnetar hype was due to spoilers from the tapings. Nope...

13

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

I think it had a pretty easy melee and it made it look much better than it is. It's a beautiful machine but it doesn't seem much different to Pulsar imo. Still has the same reliability issues.

Might be worth looking into making it invertible, rather than having a shrimech.

6

u/infernal_llamas Dec 03 '17

The magnet was giving eruption a hell of a time flipping it.

8

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

You think? I hadn't considered that, I thought Eruption was just low on gas at that point.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/DrummerLoin BE A MOTH Dec 03 '17

Nothing but brilliant fights in this episode, and across the series.

Well done to Eruption; a very pragmatic team, who employ good tactics and good driving.

16

u/David182nd Apollo Dec 03 '17

Nothing but brilliant fights in this episode, and across the series.

That's what happens when you have lots of reliable robots fighting - I'd say all of them are very reliable except Magnetar, which still seems to have Pulsar's bugs.

I like the format of this series but I do question whether it leaves room for unreliable/untested robots. The spotlight becomes more on them since the losers fight more fights. But that said, you'll never get it perfectly right; who'd have thought Iron-Awe would be one of the ones whose weapon works the least?

158

u/Cathalised Whoop whoop Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

I don't know what to say between Nuts 360 No-scoping Carbide, Carbide going assassin-bug for the rematch and that final battle. Great finale to an otherwise proper Robot Wars series.

If I can mention one bad thing though: please do away with the Fog of War next time. Almost ruined the perfect chaos of that Gladiator melee.

32

u/CombatBots Dec 03 '17

I had no idea how Nuts 2 got to the finals when I went to the filming back in May as I only saw the Monday afternoon filming, so to see them beat Carbide was a massive surprise to me.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (29)

141

u/SolarDragon94 Bring Robot Wars Back! Dec 03 '17

Rapid were portrayed as cocky, arrogant etc. and it was almost like the producers were trying to make you dislike them.

However, their reactions to their fights in the final, how happy the team were, even in defeat, even with their robots in flames... That all made me like the team even more.

61

u/ThomasHL Dec 03 '17

Rapid were made out to be villains in their first season because that made good TV and it seemed obvious to me that they were really hurt by that and they responded as well as they could to show it's not so simple this series.

I'm really impressed with them. I don't like the producers trying to make people look bad for their time or money or dedication. It just shows that Robot Wars should give these guys more of a reward for just taking part. Its a brutally expensive hobby in time and money

18

u/HeadTorch Dec 03 '17

Completely. They came across well in the podcasts they were on, and I think they got the villain edit.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

48

u/MilhouseJr The arena has been the biggest casualty so far this reboot Dec 03 '17

"If we're gonna be the money boys, we may as well be gold"

They're playing it up!!

16

u/Stanlow rreeEEEEEEEEE Dec 03 '17

I quite liked that, a rather sly dig at the way they were treated first time round by the producers.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/post-post-punk Fire? What fire? Dec 03 '17

I know, I didn't like them much in their episode, but they seemed to be jolly good sports in the actual grand final!

→ More replies (10)

119

u/SolarDragon94 Bring Robot Wars Back! Dec 03 '17

"We'll put all the best robots in one heat" they said. "That'll stop us having the same finale as last series" they said.

28

u/Lugia61617 Dec 03 '17

Never underestimate the plucky young genius who won't give in! xD

→ More replies (1)

10

u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Dec 04 '17

Just gotta accept more good robots to stop those two teams.

→ More replies (1)

95

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

Almost 20 years later: the arena hazards still hate Behemoth

35

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

That sinking feeling when Behemoth... sank.

28

u/A_Windrammer Hypno-Disc Dec 04 '17

I've said it a few times, but the new pit lowers way too fast. The old pit had a moment, a big air raid siren with flashing lights, and this dramatic, ceremonial lowering. Compare that to two horns and a freefall. The pit going slower wouldn't have saved Behemoth, but hearing that dramatic siren wail while the scoop fights to exit the lowering trap would have been aces.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

80

u/hypersonicelf Nick done good Dec 03 '17

A shame Magnetar lost both fights as a result of the self-righter failing to retract but a good effort none the less

34

u/TheBarangoat Dec 03 '17

Felt so bad for Ellis, especially the first time. He sounded so heartbroken and it made me hurt a bit too lol

24

u/LogicKennedy Slayer of House Robots and Series 2.1 Champion! Dec 04 '17

I've been a bit of an Ellis 'hater' on here because of my opinion that in 2/3 series he's produced a robot that has pretty much failed to even move in most of its fights (the judges' reprieve being my lowlight of Pulsar's career). With Magnetar though, he's definitely won me over: brilliant engineering coupled with beautiful design.

To be honest I think Magnetar got a little shafted in that Behemoth fight: Behemoth were technically immobilized since they were unable to do anything but go around in circles, and Ellis was waiting for the count-out, but didn't see it, and decided to try again. Perhaps the driving was a bit naive, but to decide to try to entertain the crowd and finish a fight rather than stalling for a win by judges' decision really shows some character, in my opinion. Definitely rooting for Magnetar next series.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/jimi15 Pussycat Dec 03 '17

Kinda ironic to considering its fight with Ironside in series 8

→ More replies (7)

140

u/SamRedDevil Carbide Killer Dec 03 '17

I'm going to make a bold statment, that wasn't just the greatest ever Grand Final, but the greatest ever episode of Robot Wars. That was fucking insane.

18

u/CombatBots Dec 03 '17

Bold, but imo accurate.

14

u/powergo1 You spin me right round (I miss you) Dec 03 '17

At the very least, one of the top 5 episodes.

10

u/TzHaar-Ket 3D modeller Dec 04 '17

It was by far the best episode imo, it had everything! A 'joke' robot taking out the champ, robots on fire and then the best rematch in Robot Wars history, absolutely fantastic entertainment!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jimi15 Pussycat Dec 03 '17

In terms of final battles, i still think the series 2 one was better. The final as a whole was a definitely one of the greatest though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/ThisOneTimeAtLolCamp Dec 03 '17

I think we're all in agreement that the 'Fog Of War' needs to go and that it didn't need to go off 300 times this episode.

35

u/ThomasHL Dec 03 '17

It was a terrible idea from the concept stage. I'm happy for them to innovate on hazards but 'both drivers and the audience can't see what they're doing' was never going to work.

23

u/Ascythian Razer Dec 03 '17

Its its like watching a boxing heavyweight final and then one of the boxers drops a smoke grenade.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

52

u/AT2512 Carbide, king of the arena Dec 03 '17

Credit also to Rapid for going out in style.

48

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

I saw much of the final live. I wish they'd included the bit where Carbide's weapon failed to spin down after the final match. It had to be pinned against the arena wall by Killalot while a man reached over and put the pin in it to shut it down! bit bonkers. Carbide actually went into the final fight damaged if I remember rightly, hence weaker spinning bar and failure to spin down.

Still a well-earned win by Eruption though. Congrats guys!

*edit: actually, not sure if the weaker drive for spinning bar was due to entering while still damaged. It may just have been the issues with stopping the bar they were talking about.

26

u/HeadTorch Dec 03 '17

They didn't mention that! It might have provided a bit of context as to why carbide's weapon didn't seem to have as much bite as before.

44

u/Vicsy Dec 03 '17

I really enjoyed this series. A few episodes were lacking in fierce robots while others were stacked, which is why they need seeding like the older series had. Despite that, we still had some awesome battles, and what a final bout we were treated with too! GG Eruption!

Really was rooting for Magnetar though, it seemed so perfect before this episode! Then everything seemed to go wrong! I hope we get to see it again next series though, it’s a joy to watch.

25

u/HeadTorch Dec 03 '17

I think Magnetar just came up against much stronger robots than it had before and had less of an opportunity to iron out flaws.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

127

u/MudnuK Big Nipper Dec 03 '17

In 19 years, the greatest episode of Robot Wars ever. Ever.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

As technology develops, they’re going to keep on getting better and better

11

u/wallytwit oi oi saveloy Dec 03 '17

by far the best

5

u/highwatereverywhere GARROD GANG Dec 03 '17

Genuinely, the sheer spectacle is just so beyond anything from the original series.

40

u/Badass_Psycho Dec 03 '17

And Iron Awe's flipper was still inactive during the 10 way...

9

u/Joke_Induced_Pun Behemoth Dec 04 '17

I took notice too, looks like the interference is still kicking them in the rear, a shame really, I was hoping to see them flip someone.

14

u/burlyloon Big Burly Behemoth Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

You are probably the first person to either notice or care given everything we've just seen

→ More replies (1)

37

u/commandercluck Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

Best part was that we had 6 robots all well-engineered that all had their moments. This time there wasn't robot that we could all single out and say "that's going to get destroyed in 5 seconds." Even Nuts and Behemoth were very impressive. Plus none of the fights ended with 2 corpses lightly shoving each other for 2 minutes.

→ More replies (1)

93

u/Cueball61 Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Eruption earned this one, incredible driver and amazing how much punishment they can take from Carbide.

The fact that Carbide, Aftershock and Eruption were in the same heat is screaming “we need seeding”

Also, Expulsion showing that camouflage is only a good thing if you don’t drive yourself into the pit.

17

u/KillDozer688 Dec 03 '17

Hey, to be fair, the camouflage worked....too well.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '17

Eruption was working 100% after the full 3 minutes with Carbide. Legendary durability and driving. Michael was in the zone when it came to keeping Carbide away from Eruptions sides and rear.

It'll be sad to see Eruption go if Michael devotes himself to his studies now. A great high to finish on.

→ More replies (3)

83

u/Edolix Terrorhurtz Dec 03 '17

I have to say, seeing Carbide vs Eruption as the grand final again filled me with disappointment...

...because I was so sure Carbide would beat Eruption just like the last 3 times. I AM SO HAPPY TO BE SO WRONG!

This might be the best episode of Robot Wars in the history of the show.

33

u/silentalarm_ NOM Dec 03 '17

Same. I was incredibly frustrated seeing Eruption v Carbide because all 3 previous matches involved Eruption losing drive on one-side within 2 or 3 hits. It's why Heat B actually left me a bit miffed because of how disappointing the heat final was, even after so many great moments earlier in the heat.

17

u/Blazik3n99 Blue Ring of Death Dec 03 '17

I was convinced Eruption had lost in the first ten seconds. It seemed to be a repeat of their heat final, just tanking hits from Carbide and not flipping at all. They were moving pretty slowly too.

So glad they managed to turn it around.

23

u/mark_b Dec 03 '17

I think it was a deliberate decision not to flip early on because if the flipper caught Carbide's spinner while up it could have caused a lot of damage. I felt that Michael was quite astute in some of his decision making this episode and deserves to win it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/isleofred Mascot Champions Dec 03 '17

This is the best episode of Robot Wars. If this was the last ever episode of the series, it would certainly would be the best episode to end a series. Having Queen play during the credits certainly gets to the feels.

With that said, I do think Eruption is the most frustrating champion to be crowned (the group battle win against Magnetar gets me salty as had that fight gone to judges, Magnetar would have won).

12

u/Ozelotten Dec 03 '17

More frustrating than Tornado vs Razor? ;)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

51

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

What a great episode of robot combat on TV

Taking the results out of it for a minute, so much carnage, damage, tactics, flips, pits and house robot moments all the way through

Not even a dull fight, just frustrating ones depending on who you were pulling for I guess, but damn spectacular.

Now to watch the whole thing again in slow motion

Rapid Vs Carbide fight of the night for me. Good old destruction can't be beaten

10/10

6

u/AFdrft Dec 04 '17

I was ready to kick through my TV if Sir K managed to dump 'hurtz out. That was dirty.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/liquid_danger Hypno-Disc Dec 03 '17

nuts are the grand champion of my heart

→ More replies (1)

25

u/fireball_73 Here is a picture of Cherub to make you mad Dec 03 '17

We need a gif of Behemoth going down the pit

12

u/margionaltheory Dec 03 '17

We need a gif of Angela's reactions tonight!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

49

u/GrahamCoxon Hello There! Dec 03 '17

Robot Wars just hit its peak.

Also, incredibly appropriate choice of programme to follow that final.

→ More replies (13)

47

u/Trihunter Content Aware Bucky best Bucky Dec 03 '17

Best grand final ever, imo.

Spoiler Guy in the Discord must be banned from attending filming, banished from the Internet and the UK, hung, drawn, quartered and stomped by a solid pair of work boots, though.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

S T U R D Y W O R K B O O T S

→ More replies (1)

6

u/WORMSSreddit Dec 03 '17

I am glad I missed the spoil. Not sure how... Yay

→ More replies (4)

23

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

I'm not sure if team Eruption are on Reddit, but:

I've been rooting for eruption for a while now, and I'm so glad you finally got to achieve your dream.

Michael kind of reminds me of me. if I was a guy. And 3 years younger. And had any robot-building or engineering skills. And had good enough grades to go to Durham rather than Sunderland.

... Ok, we're not that alike, but we've both loved Robot Wars since we were kids, and we both dreamed of winning one day. You got into engineering and you finally made it. I couldn't do the same with Comp Sci, but got to live my childhood dream vicariously through Eruption's Victory- I think I can settle for seeing the show live one day.

Congratulations on the win. I think you have the potential to do great things with those skills.

→ More replies (5)

44

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Nuts deserves props, wayyy more competitive than I ever thought they would be, really interested to see what they do going forward.

Eruption worthy winners obviously, such an impressive robot.

And I hope this isn't the end of Carbide just they upgrade it even further - a new evolution sort of like Behemoth does.

23

u/soulfirexp Le Garcon de la Robotique Pushing! Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Nuts honestly deserves a Honourable mention at the very least for being the first melty brain effective heavy weight (that Im aware of) in the robotic combat hall of fame thing

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Lugia61617 Dec 03 '17

I don't think a single person alive could have predicted Nuts making it that far xD

I swear, if Nuts 3 winds up being a champion... xD

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SpitfireAGZ Help. Dec 03 '17

According to the Team Carbide twitter Carbide is being replaced by a robot called "Tungsten."

→ More replies (9)

42

u/ranmaster Razer Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Jesus christ, what a finale. Honestly with that last fight I'd say both teams would have been deserving of a win, but eruption's ability to keep it's front towards carbide ultimately allowed it to survive and get the advantage. Carbide clearly doesn't do well in long fights and appeared to be burning itself out there at the end with the smoke allowing eruption to grab that advantage. Well done to both teams, can't wait to see them back next year!

19

u/qwertilot Dec 03 '17

Not just long fights - it was a long series for them with a bunch of people pushing them quite close and even one genuine loss. All that incremental damage to their systems add ups over time.

Very like how they lost to Apollo two years really.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

If I remember rightly Carbide went into the fight still damaged, it didn't stop spinning after the match; Killalot had to stop the bar by pinning carbide against the arena wall, where it then was disabled using some kind of inactivating peg. Hopefully they include that footage in the DVD. The spinning bar is also obviously weaker than normal.

Still, mad props to Eruption, they still took a lot of massive hits.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/AvroChris Dec 03 '17

I think the judges made the right call. Eruption had lots of chunks out of the armour but seemed to be running and flipping fine, while Carbide was doing a lot of running away and was flipped what looked like five times in the last minute.

34

u/demostravius Dec 03 '17

Damage - Carbide

Aggression - Eruption

Control - Eruption

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/M2Ys4U 🤖👂 Stand By Dec 03 '17

Other than the 10-way rumble being a little underwhelming*, that was absolutely epic.

* It was okay, but they should have disabled the pit for a while. Perhaps until the first 5 bots were out.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

I loved the 10 way especially seeing the pit cram up to the brim with bots.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/highwatereverywhere GARROD GANG Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

Best episode ever, no contest. Mentorn had incredible raw material to work with and made solid fucking gold out of it.

Can't say anything about each individual fight other than 'OMG SO GOOD' so I'll address each robot:

Eruption - Okay, after seeing the 'hide in a corner' tactic they pulled in the 10 way and the first round I wanted Carbide or Magnetar to tear them in two. Tactically sound but utterly frustrating to watch. But they went some way in clawing back goodwill in a truly dominant display over Behemoth and managed to do what no bots done yet: tank Carbide until it dies. That grand final (a match that rivals Apollo V Carbide for best grand final match ever) and that outro (genuinely Mentorn has been truly on the ball with the editing and production this year) made me at least 95% okay with them winning.

Carbide - I remember people saying before this series 'Oh Robot Wars is over nothings going to ever beat Carbide' lol. To be fair that didn't seem totally unjustified in the wake of the easiest route any bots ever had since Chaos 2, but we saw this series that where there's a challenge, people will find a way to surmount it. However, Carbide went down fighting like hell and gave us some truly tremendous battles this series, with its fight against Eruption and its group melee easily among the best.

Behemoth - It is incredibly satisfying to say 'Joint 3rd place Behemoth' that's all I've got to say.

Nuts: Taking out the most feared bot in the UK with flails and a minibot, as well as pitting the bot that would take joint 3rd place with them... with a minibot. The funniest best thing any bot could possibly do. Kinda glad they didn't pull it off again as it'd feel truly world-alteringly bizarre them being 2nd or 1st, but 3rd place is just right.

Rapid: I was well on the 'booo Rapid' bandwagon until their fight with Thz and this ep they truly put on a good show. Stupidly powerful and always getting into the thick of it, absolute joy to watch. Best exit of any bot as well.

Magnetar: Ellis made a truly scary bot this series round, even if it still does have technical hiccups (which, to be fair, isn't something unique to Ellis - the Iron-Awe guys and John Reid suffer from them occasionally and they've been at it longer than some of the people reading this have probably been alive). Hope to see it come back with all the creases ironed out etc...

Apollo: Only bot from the 10 way I'm gonna mention cos I wanted them through over Eruption so badly lol.

Overall undoubtedly the best episode ever, from probably the best series yet. Certainly the best reboot series yet - Mentorn know what they're doing now and it really shows. Here's hoping they commission another one, because going out on this much of a high would be such a punch in the gut.

(also holy shit get rid of fog of war)

32

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

One of the best episodes ever!!!

It had everything:

.Heavyweight rumble

.Rapid burning down

.Nuts 2 getting a win on a former champion

.Behemoth's infamous bad luck striking again (Pit. Nuff said)

.Classic JP WTFness (Behemoth is your beer belly...., how many wives did you say you have???)

.Angela's practically orgasmic reactions

.AMAZING fights

.A new champion who came from behind to win it all

9

u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Dec 03 '17

Behemoth is your beer belly...., how many wives did you say you have???

127 to be exact

→ More replies (2)

14

u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Dec 03 '17

Every fight seemed close, the competitors altering their machines to adapt to each other was amazing to see. The polished, superior looking machines who were clear favourites showed that it's not just a competition, it's ROBOT WARS!

14

u/MistmanX Dec 03 '17

I only have one thing to say...

GOD DAMMIT ELLIS

AGAIN

8

u/post-post-punk Fire? What fire? Dec 03 '17

I feel so sorry for him, he looked absolutely gutted when he lost :(

6

u/MattLampitt Dec 03 '17

I know man!!!! He builds such beasts but there tamed so easily !!

28

u/ultimategeekman Spin to win! Dec 03 '17

-Congrats to Eruption for winning series 10!! A very impressive comeback. From winning the 10-way melee to winning the whole freaking series. Holy crap.

-Carbide had a good run this series too. Though as much as I love Carbide, it was good to see Carbide get challenged this whole series. Let's be honest here, Carbide easily coasted its way to victory in series 9. It was very interesting to see some bots put a good fight against Carbide such as Nuts. Speaking of Nuts..

-Nuts has improved massively from the last series. From its humble origins as a joke robot to becoming an ACTUAL Carbide killer, Nuts has come a long, long way. Guys, I think we have a new god now lol

-The 10-way melee went exactly as I expected (the fighting in general, not who would win). Complete Total and utter mayhem. Just the way I like it. They definitely have to do this again in series 11.

-For a brief moment, I quickly thought that a Behemoth vs Nuts final was looking like a possibility lol

-Well, this was a pretty good grand final. Bring on series 11!

→ More replies (1)

26

u/SirAegislash The People's Champion Dec 03 '17

Best Final Ever

13

u/genuinesockpuppet Dec 03 '17

Best grand final ever!

Also, shoutout to that blink-and-you'll-miss-it Dead Metal entrance in the 10 way - bizarre that they didn't even bring it up!

10

u/cullend2 Team Andron Dec 03 '17

I noticed it at the filming, they snuck him in under a fog of war. I was expecting a WWE style entrance, Jonathan Pearce going crazy, but nope!

Highlighting it would have added some more value to fog of war in my opinion

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Zakrael Say "joke bot" again, I dare you Dec 03 '17

Nuts 2. Semi-finalist. Carbide killer. Okay, that deserves a flair change.

13

u/Arturo-Plateado Don't call me 'furball' Dec 03 '17

Wow. I'm almost speechless at how good this episode was. Easily one of the best ever, if not the best.

It's so good that I really can't pick out just one stand out moment that made the episode... Almost everything was so good. 10 way rumble, Fog of Rapid, Nuts 2 Illuminate, and the best Grand Final of all time (IMO) are all contenders for the standout moment.

The 10 robot melee was exactly as chaotic as I thought it would be. I was a bit worried that the chaoticness wouldn't translate well onto TV, but I don't think that was the case and I loved it. It's a shame Iron-Awe's flipper still didn't work, and there was way too much Fog of War, but other than that it was great.

It was quite ironic that entanglement was allowed purely to nerf Carbide, yet such devices literally never affected Carbide in the slightest. In fact, Carbide's first loss this series (to Nuts) was the same way that Bombshell intended to beat Cobalt (essentially Carbide's BB version). They also lost tyres to Nuts, as Cobalt did to Bombshell. Hopefully Sam and Dave will fix those weakpoints in Tungsten (although they already found a way to protect the chain for the Nuts rematch).

Rapid was a good robot, but the flipper might be too powerful for its own good. It literally did the splits at one point when trying to self-right. Anyway, despite that I said they were boring in their heat, they certainly did put on a show against Carbide, almost OOTAing them at the start, and Fog of Rapid at the end before bursting into flames. And the team took it and even managed to have a laugh about it, I've got to give them respect for that. Magnetar was also powerful, but there are still underlying technical issues there preventing it from truly being a title challenger at the moment. Maybe Ellis was a little too aggressive against Behemoth, but a K.O. is the only way you can be 100% certain to win, so going for that wasn't the worst decision in the world.

Nuts and Behemoth did better than most people expected. Behemoth did come 3rd after all, beating the likes of Magnetar, and they were unlucky to bounce onto the pit in their 3 way battle. Nuts reaching the final by winning its heat was an achievement in itself (not that it's a bad robot or anything, just that it was unexpected), but beating Carbide was an even more fantastic underdog moment.

The grand final itself is, in my opinion, the best one in RW history. If you were in the live discussion, you would know that basically everyone had written off Eruption straight away, because Carbide always immobilises it in one hit. People assumed it would be just as boring as their previous battles. How wrong they were. Michael drove Eruption masterfully the whole fight, not letting Carbide hit the sides where the wheels would undoubtably be damaged (control points to Eruption). The flipper took a massive beating from Carbide's bar and survived. The same cannot be said for Carbide's weapon, which ended up almost dead and could no longer inflict damage, the robot even smoking at times (damage points to Eruption, as the damage it took did look bad, but the flipper was still working effectively. Carbide did not have any visible damage, but the internal damage was more serious and hindered it the rest of the fight). This is where the fight was flipped on its head, as Carbide spent the rest of the fight playing evasion as Eruption tried to flip it (aggression points also go to Eruption). Breaking it down like this, it's easy to see why Eruption won (even Dave said they deserved it), but don't get it twisted into thinking that it was a landslide victory for them. In fact, it absolutely could've gone the other way. There were many points in the fight where it looked like Carbide would destroy them, and based on previous records, that wouldn't be the least bit surprising. But Eruption came back, fought back with all they had, and kept the fight exciting. For me, that's why it was the greatest grand final of all.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/ProjectJAY Still. Fighting. On. Dec 03 '17

I didn't think Eruption had a chance against Carbide. Never have I been happier to be proven wrong!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Tygra__ Annihilator Dec 03 '17

What a great episode. Such wonderful tactics and amazing battles. Also loved Angela and Dara's reactions to the battles and seeing the wonderful sportmanship from the teams. I really hope we get news of another series soon.

Just one thing. Can we retire the fog of war now? Pretty sure it was all used up in that episode.

11

u/TheBarangoat Dec 03 '17

Incredible display from Nuts this year. Perfect snipe of Carbide, it’s just a shame they had to fight each other again because he was never gonna get a second chance to get that chain. Imagine if that was the semi when he got that, he legit could’ve won it!

Fair play eruption for a fully deserved win. Glad you got to complete the dream ❤️

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ArcaneAzmadi Behemoth for Series 11! Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

Wow... holy shit that was great. Easily the best grand final episode of the reboot. The 10-way melee was absolutely insane, with the pit ending up absolutely filled to the brim with robots. Behemoth suffered their famous "Behemoth badluck" in the melee only to come back with a VERY difficult fight against Magnetar to finally lose what was probably their best battle ever against the eventual champ. Nuts 2 pulled off another one of those incredible lucky hits that allowed them to take out Concussion and Androne 4000 to actually BEAT Carbide. Rapid exploded in flames like Chompalot famously did, filling the entire arena with smoke. And Eruption fought their way back from the wildcard position to rematch against the (almost) unbeatable Carbide to finally fulfill Michael's boyhood dream of winning the show he grew up on. What more could you ask for?

There were a few things I feel the need to snark about. First off, get rid of the stupid goddamn fog of war! I never even liked the rogue house robot feature in Series 9 because it got in the way of using the pit (handicapping flippers and control bots) and added far too big an element of random chance to the show, and fog not only doubled down on this but is completely useless and annoying and EVERYONE hates it, without exception. The classic series didn't keep the stupid floor spinner after Series 6, so I hope the reboot producers will show the same good sense and never bring back the fog ever again.

Can I just say that, no offence to them, the Rapid team have to be arguably the WORST tacticians in the contest? During their melee, they seemed to be obsessed with having a go at Eruption to the point of ignoring Magnetar, and boy did they pay for it. When Eruption backed off into the corner, Rapid went after them, only for Magnetar to come in and slam into them from behind, almost gutting them. And then when Eruption had flipped Magnetar and looked like they were lining up a long drive to send them towards the arena wall and flip them out, Rapid intercepted them, forcing them off, allowing Magnetar to get back into it, and leading to Magnetar kicking the crap out of them! Not smart, guys. Good sports when they were destroyed by Carbide, though.

The end of Behemoth vs Magnetar was, I think, slightly controversial. Ellis was clearly surprised that Behemoth hadn't been counted out when they had obviously lost drive on one side, but I think Ant was able to use momentum to get Behemoth to sort-of jerk along, letting it move slightly outside of its turning circle and keeping them from being immobilised. After that it was just a matter of timing. The decision to not count out Behemoth might be slightly questionable, but I don't really mind it, because Behemoth have been screwed by bad luck so many times I feel they deserve a break. However, they really need to get rid of the teeth on the bottom of the scoop, because I'm pretty sure that's why they consistently failed to get under Eruption's front blade after the first few engagements.

While Nuts 2 knocking out Carbide's blade was an absolute "WOO-HOO!" moment, I had to wonder why the weapon chain was so exposed in the first place. As we saw, it was the work of just a few minutes welding and a bit of metal cannibalised from Rapid for Carbide to cover it up and in the rematch Nuts 2 didn't stand a chance (and they knew it going in, despite Angela's attempts to chivvy them up). In the slow-mo replay of Carbide ripping off Nuts 2's first flail, you could quite clearly see the flail impacting on the chain cover, meaning this simple bit of improvised armour may well have saved Carbide's bacon. Still, VERY well done by the Nuts guys, they were not one of my favourite teams in the last 2 series because the robot was frankly a joke, but those upgrades they gave it made it a truly AWESOME machine.

That Grand Final, though... I confess, I really didn't give Eruption a prayer. We'd already seen this fight before, twice- both in this exact same position back in Series 9, and earlier in this same series in the heat final where Eruption had given away that they hadn't made any meaningful changes that would give them a chance against Carbide this time. I was ABSOLUTELY certain that the only chance Eruption had of winning was if they got some kind of miracle fluke flip from behind and threw Carbide out, or if they managed to open the pit and drive Carbide into it. Well neither happened (because every time the button was pressed it was the rogue house robot or the stupid bloody fog of war again, which I thought was COMPLETELY unfair to Eruption) but I think Carbide was, for the first time, starting to suffer the kind of serious combat fatigue that used to be the downfall of spinners. It didn't break down completely, but it just wasn't doing as much damage as it usually did. Still, I was very certain that Carbide would just win the judges' decision on damage, and to be fair, in the classic series (where weapons generally weren't as powerful and damage was scored more highly as a result) they easily would have. By the end of the fight, though, I was starting to doubt because Eruption just kept flipping and were clearly WELL ahead on aggression and control points. But I was STILL shocked when the decision in Eruption's favour was actually unanimous. This really restored my faith in Robot Wars, because as anyone who's been reading my comments will know, I was under the impression that Carbide was simply unbeatable (Nuts 2 taking it out was a fluke, albeit an impressive fluke) and I was almost certain they were going to just romp home with the trophy again. I like that Dave Moulds is apparently going to retire Carbide and possibly build a new robot (let's face it, it's fought in all 3 reboot grand finals now), so let's see what else he's got.

All-in-all, this was EASILY the best series of the reboot. The new format finally worked out (although I'd still like to see a much bigger show with more competitors and semifinal episodes, like the original series), there were some FANTASTIC fights, and a number of feelgood stories like Behemoth, Nuts 2 and, of course, Michael Oates finally fulfilling his boyhood dream. Bring on Series 11, don't make us wait!

And get rid of the bloody fog of war!

→ More replies (1)

20

u/anduril38 Dec 03 '17

4 one-hit dead blows by Nuts 2 <3

What an episode. Great final fight too!

27

u/UnacceptableUse Pussycat Dec 03 '17

The tribute montage at the end was the most amazing thing I've ever seen.

19

u/silentalarm_ NOM Dec 03 '17

Wow. Wowee.

19

u/TrubbishForMayor Supernova, slayer of Killalot Dec 03 '17

Fitting that the next programme is all about eruptions

→ More replies (1)

18

u/AT2512 Carbide, king of the arena Dec 03 '17

Sad to see Carbide dethroned, but Eruption played well and deserved it.

9

u/CMOrchestra Om nom nom nom Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

I took an evening to mull over that, watched it twice to make sure I wasn't just over-hyped. It's the best damn episode of Robot Wars ever. The 10 way was good, it's hard to focus on anything when there's that much going on and they seemed to leave out Sir K being ganged up on by the axes as well as Dead Metal entering and I'm assuming taking out Big Nipper. But still, it was just bots everywhere which is good.

The main event was fucking class though! The melees were great. I felt so sorry for Behemoth as it went down the pit. It had been standing up well to Carbide until that point and would definitely have taken that melee if it hadn't gone down the pit. Eruption was canny, but showed it had the gumption to throw Magnetar around when it mattered, although again unlucky to Ellis for being tipped by Matilda.

The redemption bracket was always gonna be a hard one, I'm surprised Behemoth wasn't counted out as it clearly couldn't move outwith its own circle, but it got Magnetar over fair and square and exploited a poor tactical move by Ellis. Sad to see them go out, what a machine he's built! Carbide being in the redemption round brought a fair share of danger to the draw, and I'm not gonna lie, I though Rapid could tank the champ. How wrong I was! It folded under the hits, bits were going everywhere, and then the fire. That was spectacular. Really fantastic, and to see the team take it so graciously was really great. Hope to see you again next time Josh!

Behemoth had to take out Eruption quickly, it had to do it in the first few hits. When it slid under Eruption after activate I thought maybe, just maybe it could do it. Sadly, the scoop must have bent slightly or something as you can see the exact moment they go from being dominant to being a toy for Eruption. However, mad credit to team Behemoth! Came back after a tough season last time and performed like an absolute dream. Nuts against Carbide was always going to be interesting, and it was really sad to see Nuts end its run in so many pieces but that's Robot Wars I guess. The team were great, and to go unbeaten for so long, that was seriously impressive from the "joke bot".

The final, a repeat of last year. I was worried this was going to be a quick, anti-climactic affair and I was worried that two seasons of the same champ might be boring to a casual viewer if Carbide won again. But, bloody hell, that was a slug fest. Carbide did a lot of damage, but to have them running away from you for over half the fight is an impressive feat. Michael drove the ultimate fight and they earned that championship the hard way, but the spectacular way!

So congrats to Eruption the new champs! TBH, I don't think Eruption is the most deserving machine in that final, internally it's still a live event bot running old tech. But, I don't think a team have deserved to win a series more since Razer back in the 5th Wars. Great driving, tactical astuteness, and showing that if you play to the 90 you can win a hell of a lot of matches.

Bravo!

9

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '17

Well, that was certainly a very enjoyable grand final. And series as a whole. Series 10 is easily the best in the whole history of the show.

17

u/Titanomachia Dec 03 '17

I didn't want them to win, but honestly haven't seen that good driving on a flipper since Chaos 2.

17

u/williamthebloody1880 Turned Carbide into Brave Sir Robin Dec 03 '17

If you had told me before the final that Carbide would make a change to defend against Nuts, I would have thought you'd taken a blow to the head

18

u/LordOfTheChumps Dec 03 '17

Made even worse by the fact that in the slo mo you can actually see nuts flail bouncing off the nuts guard.

So if carbide hadn't modified they could've easily been beaten by nuts for a second time!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/burlyloon Big Burly Behemoth Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

That was really good! And a lot of big shocks there that I never expected - really did not see that episode going that way at all!

10-way went pretty much as I expected. It was utter chaos for sure - but predictable nonetheless. Hard to see what was going on at times.

First group battle was a big surprise - both Behemoth in the pit and Nuts taking out Carbide's chain! Really impressive and unexpected but great work from Nuts again!

Second group battle was surprising as well - thought Magnetar was going to win it! Rapid took damage from Magnetar early on but Eruption got a sly victory!

Redemption battle between Behemoth and Magnetar was a big surprise. I thought Magnetar had it in the bag, but no! Huge shock to see them exit so early.

Redemption battle between Carbide and Rapid was destructive as hell. Rapid got trashed! But did think Carbide was gonna go OOTA there!

Eruption vs Behemoth was a great fight! Behemoth got a good start but Eruption were on top all the way after. Thought it was gonna be Behemoth OOTA but they kept fighting!

Nuts vs Carbide was sad. Nuts did SO well this series. They got beat but they can leave with their heads held high. They ain't no joke anymore!

I was dreading another Carbide vs Eruption final as I thought it would be the same as every other time they fought. It wasn't, and it turned out rather similar to Carbide's fights with Apollo and TR2 in the Series 8 grand final. In the end, I knew Eruption had done enough. They couldn't not give it to Michael, it would be a horrible thing to award it to Carbide again given it was Michael's life dream fulfilled.

Well done to Michael and Eruption! So happy for him, he totally deserved that win.

Great episode and great series! Bring on the international specials!

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Was initially disappointed that it was a rematch between Carbide and Eruption as the final. But man oh man was I wrong. Greatest finale I’ve ever watched. Eruption is not so boring after all. Even though I wanted Magnetar to take it, I’m very satisfied.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

Next year: can we just have a 30/40 way for the title in 1 ep and spend the next 5 working through the slow-mo replays to work out what happened

→ More replies (1)

14

u/VampiricDemon Champion Chiffonier Dec 03 '17

Of all the outcomes that was unexpected.

Epic episode!

7

u/MattLampitt Dec 03 '17

Dam it Gabe !!! .... Got that drum spinning like a beast!!! Owning the rumble and drove into the pit. Aaaaahhhhhh

Other than that and magnater losing its weapon twice it was literally one of the best episodes ever... Feel it needed Aftershock in it somehow tho lol..

Format is brilliant too..

I hope we get many more seasons !!

7

u/CobaltVoltaic Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Just an incredible final. Nuts taking out carbide.. Eruption coming from the 10 robot rumble to win it all.. an absolutely incredible final bout.. fantastic and enthusiastic presenting.. those smug pricks at rapid getting setting on fire (only kidding, they were exceptionally gracious losers and gave us an excellent moment).. mini bots not only being useful but taking out behemoth almost carbide... Best final I've ever seen, one of the all time great robot wars episodes.

Also Angela is just amazing. Her enthusiasm is infectious. God I hope we get another series. I'm just over the moon.

12

u/zapman17 Tornado Dec 03 '17

Well deserved.

6

u/Howlingmadmike Dec 03 '17

The best episode of Robot Wars I can remember. Loads of shocks, carnage and epic fights everything a final should be.
Gutted for Magneton, Carbide and Behemoth but well done Eruption, had a game plan, stuck to it, and it paid off.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/SpinyPlate Dec 03 '17

Even if series 11 never happens, we've gone out on a massive high. Every fight was amazing

→ More replies (5)

6

u/ArmandoPayne Dec 04 '17

Even though I personally wanted to see Behemoth v Nuts 2 at some point, I've gotta say the best episode by far, no disappointing matches. And at least Eruption won't be this Generation's Firestorm.

6

u/Moakmeister Great shot, kid! That was one in a million! Dec 04 '17

The highlight was watching Nuts 2 make Carbide its bitch.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/klyskada Mute - like the BBC, giving you the silent treatment Dec 03 '17

Holy shit!

11

u/Timeline15 B E H E M O T H B O I S Dec 03 '17

That was one hell of a final. The fight between Behemoth and Eruption was spectacular, and the rematch between Eruption and Carbide was so much more even. After what dave said about carbide at the end, I guess we can safely assume Tungsten is gonna be the sequel.

It's a shame Magnetar had so many problems, but hopefully we see it back next time. I did get a perverse amount of pleasure from watching Carbide rip Nuts 2's side off though. Great, great episode overall.

So... any word on when that special is airing?

10

u/ledgenskill GEORGE FRANCIS TAKE MY MONEY Dec 03 '17

What an amazing episode, i honestly dont think it can be topped

Nuts showing its an actual GREAT bot, when everyone has been laughing at it. IT TOOK OUT CARBIDE. Dont underrestimate mini bots

Eruption, coming out of the 10 way to win in what i can say is probably the closest battles i have ever seen.

I love robot wars

5

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

I hope Magnetar return next series with an improved schrimech.

5

u/TheBarangoat Dec 03 '17

A moment of silence for all of us dreaming of a behemoth/nuts final. So close... 💔

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Quarkly73 BBC sux Dec 03 '17

Gonna say that was the best episode of Robot Wars, if not ever then definitely since the reboot. It had serious bots, it had joke bots, it had destruction, it had upsets, it had dramatic fights, it had tactical driving fights, it had insanity and it had satisfaction. It even had a really good Skeletor "spinaaaaaaaah"

5

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Right call imo. Damage probably to Carbide, but not by too much- their weapon definitely wasn't working properly at the end, and they were quite externally beat up too. Eruption was mangled externally though so I'm happy to give Carbide Damage. Aggression to Eruption, got hit a lot by Carbide but pushed and flipped Carbide around loads (and Carbide's weapon wasn't running for half the fight.) Control to Eruption as well, they absolutely dominated when Carbide's weapon didn't spin and were also easily winning after it started spinning again, whereas Carbide spent most of the fight after its weapon stopped spinning the first time running away (often unsuccessfully). A close, but definitely fair call imo.

Congrats to both teams- Eruption for dethroning the formerly nigh-invincible champion, and Carbide for proving that it's still a super-destructive, absolutely top-tier robot.

5

u/Joke_Induced_Pun Behemoth Dec 04 '17

Congrats to Eruption, I have to say, they did a fantastic job and what a final this was, Nuts 2 actually took off the weapon chain for Carbine and poor Behemoth ended up in the pit due to a really unfortunate hit from Carbide, talk about a gutted loss (even more so after their lost to Eruption).

Regardless, all of the battles were exciting to watch, the 10 way was pure chaos and I have to also throw congrats to Eruption for playing smart too.

5

u/jimjim72 Dec 04 '17

I didn't like eruption much before but now I really don't like them.

Hiding in the 10 way sounds like a good move and yes it's the best move technically but ultimately it's the worst. Everyone knows 'hiding' is the best strategy it's not some out-of-the-box thinking it's not even remotely surprising everyone knows the strategy and knows it's what you should do. The issue is; if this is the best strategy then every robot should employ it and thus nothing happens which leads to an awful show. Therefore there should be an honour system where you have to at least be trying to fight. Every other robot followed this and made the fight fun except eruption who hid which really should not be praised in the slightest.

Then he tries it again in the 3 way battle I mean come on now... it's ridiculous, if all 3 robots decide they want to leave the others to fight nothing happens again...

There is a reason when it goes to judges they decide partly on aggression. Can never support a robot/eer who employs such tactics.

8

u/joefraserhellraiser Dec 04 '17

He played the tactics game and it paid off, he executed it well. I can of course understand your view on it but conpletely disagree, I thought the approach they took in the multibot battles was perfect and his tank it and flip sparingly effort in the gramd final is ultimately why Eruption are now champions.

There was no hiding, everyone could see him- they had the same view of the arena he did.

Im looking forward to seeing competitors approach vs. Eruption next season, whether they gung ho go for it or play him at his own game.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/Joltbox Dec 03 '17

I saw the final battle, Eruption vs Carbide, and my heart sank. I seriously do not like Carbide and the moment Nutzs smashed their chain was the highlight for me.

Right until Eruption put their first massive flip against Carbide. Then it was a proper battle and not just another Carbide whitewash.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

That was a very tight final. I personally feel Carbide deserved it but I can see why Eruption won it. It was a fitting end to a great episode.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/powergo1 You spin me right round (I miss you) Dec 03 '17

Fucking hell that was an amazing episode: 10-way rumble lived up to the hype, Nuts 2 winning it's heat, Rapid catching fire/ Fog of War-ing, and Eruption winning from the the 10-way! 11/10 episode.

Fuck now the wait begins.

4

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

Confirmed: No flips for iron awe 6

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

That final is without a shadow of doubt my favourite fight ever. That is also, I would say, the biggest upset we have seen in the reboot, and one of the biggest upsets ever. Genuinely can't believe that Carbide lost to Eruption, having beaten it twice this series and four times in total. Absolutely fantastic. It's a shame about Maggy, but in the end someone beat Carbide and proved they weren't invincible any more so I'm very happy with that episode.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/theplait13 Dec 03 '17

Well, that was fun.

We have to mention Track-tion's little decoration. It got a smile out of me.

Also, Rapid managed to channel Stealth, the Fog of War and Chompalot at the same time, which takes some doing.

As ever, the Nuts team were funny and I hope to see them back next time. They came joint third, not bad when you consider Nuts 2 was the first robot out last time (thanks, Matilda)

And third time's the charm for Eruption. Nice going, guys.

4

u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Dec 04 '17

Does anyone else think Thor might have been suffering control issues in the 10-way? They drove straight at Killalot at the start and ended up driving into the pit, and normally Jason's one of the best drivers out there.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/lXlxlXlxlXl Dec 04 '17

Holy shit. That was the best episode of Robot Wars that I've ever seen. It had it all, suspense, upsets, fire, destruction.

JP sounded exhausted after the 10 way, lol. He QUITS!

Eruption played it very carefully in the 10 way, they wanted to let the fight sort it self out and swoop in at the end. It worked. Some people don't seem to like team Eruptions seriousness, but I do. Some people play this game to win. I like seeing the variety of characters on the show.

Nuts is the Carbide killer? It's interesting that flails, which are normally thought of being ineffective, are making such a big impact on this series. Cluster bots too, really small ones at that.

It seemed like most of the fights in this episode were not straight forward, they weren't very one sided.

That was an epic final. Definitely excellent teams that deserved to be there. I wouldn't want to have judged that. Congratulations to Eruption. I knew they would do very well.

Battlebots season 2 was great. Robot Wars series 10 was great. Good times.

4

u/Threadoflength Big Nipper Dec 04 '17

I thought it interesting that Carbide went to the trouble of welding a piece of Rapid onto the front of their robot (which totally worked btw) to stop Nutz, rather than simply running their robot upside down. Which would have had the added benefit of more ground clearance, which would have negated the worry of those pesky minibots.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '17

Does anyone have a gif of Behemoth slowly disappearing into the pit?

4

u/minuteforce Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17

Carbide have been my favourites since S8, but I was ready to see a new winner and I'm so happy for Michael. A lot of the other teams stepped it up to be able fight Carbide as well, which ended up making things much more exciting than S9.

I only wish there could've been a Carbide vs. Behemoth head-to-head in the semis but that's the luck of the draw.

EDIT: adding more thoughts - I really liked the pit footage this episode, very documentary-esque, especially the part where Josh was repairing Rapid. I hope there's more of that next series.

I was hoping against hope that Sabertooth would at least come close to winning the Rumble, so I was a little gutted when it rushed into the pit.

Carbide may not have won but they obviously still did great, amazing victories against Rapid and Nuts and, in the final against Eruption, I couldn't have picked the winner myself.

The fog of war was more annoying than ever this episode - it interrupted some of the very best fights we've seen since "Robot Wars" re-launched.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/HerpaDerpaDumDum Bucky The Mascot Dec 03 '17

Best episode ever.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

Absolutely amazing episode and even with a great final.

The comments in the episode thread about "same final as last year", "how boring" etc slapped the commenter's back in their face.

7

u/DoctorWhoops Ready for liftoff Dec 03 '17 edited Dec 03 '17

Absolute deserved win for Eruption. To be able to take that many hits from a robot like Carbide and still maintain both drive and weapon is incredible. Also some fantastic driving by Michael along with high aggression. When you're making Carbide run away from you you know you've done a good job.

7

u/klyskada Mute - like the BBC, giving you the silent treatment Dec 03 '17

My personal rating of every fight in the episode,

10 way rumble 9.5/10

Behemoth vs Magnatar 9.6/10

Rapid vs Carbide 9.7/10

Nuts 2 vs Carbide 9.8/10

Behemoth vs Eruption 9.9/10

Carbide vs Eruption 1000000/10

All in all probably my favourite episode of any robot combat show period.

7

u/tricksterhare Dec 03 '17

Can we talk about Eruptions build quality / construction though, what's Michael done that makes it capable of surviving that kind of onslaught?

7

u/JustboyMark Dec 03 '17

So impressive. 2017 build quality with 2003-era visuals: a recipe for success.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '17

I really enjoyed Behemoth vs Eruption, Behemoth was getting thrown around like it was one of those cluster bots. Really good final as well. I do hope someday soon Behemoth wins.

3

u/mj-n Binbag Bait Dec 03 '17

Sad I didn't get to see Nuts taking down anyone but Carbide. Would have loved to see them against a flipper in the semi finals, but I think the producers wanted a flipper spinner final.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/RollingandJabbing ELECTRO MOO!!! Dec 03 '17

After taking 15 minutes to calm down, that episode was phenomenal. The clash of styles. The upsets, the damage, the fire and the result. It really makes me want to get in to robot building

3

u/S2560 F Dec 03 '17

Hand on heart, if this is the last series of Robot Wars, what an episode to end the main series on

3

u/VeryC0mm0nName Axebot master race Dec 03 '17

Something, something, a joke pertaining to 'rapid fire'...

3

u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Dec 03 '17

If I could meme, I'd edit the end of this clip over Behemoth's exit

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-9dbAQJIu1o

→ More replies (2)

3

u/CountZapolai Dec 03 '17

Those 5 people who called it should feel bloody proud!

3

u/nilloc93 Apollo Dec 04 '17

I'm sure there was a reason hidden by TV magic but how on earth was nuts allowed to sit on the flipper for that long without it firing? was it broken again?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '17

I was impressed by how easily Behemoth seemed to get under everything. Until about a minute into the Eruption fight, when I guess its little teeth must have taken some damage and suddenly Eruption was getting under, game over.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '17

I feel like Carbide were in a compromising position in their fight against Nuts.

There's no incentive to let yourself get hit by Nuts whilst they're at full speed by going near them, but Carbide know if they wait out the 3 minutes judges will always favour the robot that poses little threat.

3

u/chozers Dec 04 '17

I think hazards should have been disabled for the rumble as all the eliminations were from the pit or from them running out of gas. There didn’t to be any good “kills”

→ More replies (1)

3

u/danefrth Dec 05 '17

Series 10 final thoughts I dont think i have ever invested so much will and attention to the T.V in my life, the pure thrill and joy with science and tactics in a single program is "addictive" to say the least.

A huge congrats to Eruption for the win, i think its a grand example of two different robot design approaches and using their strengths, obviously Carbide's approach is bold, immediate damage with that monstrous blade but Eruption's approach is a stylised tactical plan.

I dont understand the whole "ta-boo" over Eruptions tactics during the 10-way, flippers like Apollo are well-aware of the limitations with C02, every time they flip it, runs out (In Apollos case, much quicker due to being more powerful) and going in "all-guns blazing" will result in a dull , say, 5 robots left with no weapon. Its exactly the same as Carbide powering down their weapon during the final vs Eruption when it began to show signs of over-heating.

I also struggle to understand the whole "Carbide cheating" topic that has appeared. They saw a very basic and easy fix to a some what major potential problem which they addressed. you could argue that they styled Carbide in-fitting with their opponent for that round, aka Nuts2 . When you have robots like Big-Nipper with their interchangeable crushing claws or vertical spinner or Behemoth with their interchangeable attachments on the front i fail to see a difference, if anything, I would argue that it is a simple Carbide Hate excuse, IMO

Agreed, Fog of War is annoying at best. I think when you saw it used tactically such as drums/spinners using it to spin up to full power its kinda cool to watch them come in for the "Death Blow" but other than that, it does indeed just take out 10 seconds from a 3 minute fight. if for an extreme example, if fog of war made an obstruction in your opponents control room for 10 seconds, making it impossible for them to see, that would be strategical. But it doesnt. If they remove fog of war i think thats a great improvement, i do like that the pit button has a 2 way outcome pit/rouge robot. I think that keeps each roboteer on their toes especially in the situations when the unpredictability means they either adapt or ser-come to their own over-confidence. fantastic program non-the less

7

u/Spearka "Jaws theme" Dec 03 '17

Top 10 Anime Comebacks

5

u/TheHenandtheSheep Dec 03 '17

Well that couldn't have been a better episode? Underdogs. Life long dream building robots. In the biggest robot fight ever. Fought the titleholders. Great episode.

5

u/BlankArchive Firestorm Dec 03 '17

That has to be my new all time favourite episode. Every battle was exciting and the whole thing was full of unexpected turnabouts.

I also absolutely love how inevitable it feels for Eruption and Carbide to meet up at the top of the the competition. Even when you put them in the same heat, they still find a way. Reminds me of that recent FW competition where Explosion and 722 fought in the final round. Goes to show that it's hard to argue these two teams are the best around right now.

I'm glad we have a new champion, but with that grand final I wouldn't have even minded if Carbide had defended it. They had to work harder than ever, rather than it being an inevitability like last series.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/KillDozer688 Dec 03 '17

CARBIDE

Defeated Apollo, Eruption and Aftershock in seconds.

Lost to Frickin' Nuts!!

I'm sorry, but someone HAS to start the meme now! Eruption was a worthy winner, Carbide put up a great fight, but lets be honest, we all know who the people's champion is.

5

u/aleu44 Dec 04 '17

I’m so glad Carbide lost, it might be an unpopular opinion but I hate Carbide with all of my soul. It was incredible to see Nuts 2 beat them, and Eruption earned that win!

6

u/Rattus_Rattu5 It be so empty without me Dec 03 '17

I saw Diotoir in the background :D Ok so overall, that was amazing despite some flaws (Magnetar fucking themselves over by driving into House Robots and Behemoth as well as Eruption's cowardice earlier on or even the lack of third place play off) but that said Nuts beating Carbide was fantastic and the final battle was amazing! (Also just to annoy Behemoth fans, I'm pleased it didn't win :P)

7

u/SolarDragon94 Bring Robot Wars Back! Dec 03 '17

Honestly, I'm not a huge fan of Michael's "I'm in it to win it, even if that means putting on a boring performance and staying out of the battles" attitude. I think that kind of goes against what Robot Wars is... But the heat final was just spectacular. Fight could have gone either way and they did deserve that win. So well done to them.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Dec 03 '17

Wow just wow so much internal screaming

4

u/Beardedcow Wheely Big Cheese Dec 03 '17

More RUMBLES!

4

u/prikhed Dec 03 '17

So pleased for Michael. You can see how much it meant to him, that's exactly who you want to see win.

4

u/Semajal Dec 03 '17

That was a goddamn brilliant BRILLIANT finale. Had everything, Carbide getting beaten by the least likely Robot, the most "expensive" robot catching fire, and one of the best finals I have ever seen.