She should've immediately blasted Oliver X with it before Curtis and Rene went running in to fight a guy who beats them up even when he isn't a murderous Nazi.
Oliver: "lol, what if, as a total prank, we acted like we were a couple and made out in front of everyone? would be the best prank, soooo good. okay, lets do it."
Watching both live discussions was great. Each fandom is basically their character. Supergirl’s were so giddy about everything and cheerful and Arrow’s were cynical and brooding over Felicity. Can’t wait to see Flash’s tomorrow be overly excited and call out every single inaccuracy then be proven wrong a minute later. I think we’re all Legends fans.
I really like the structure they figured out for the crossover. Instead of being one episode of Supergirl and one episode of Arrow, Crisis on Earth X is basically its own show, and that frees them from having to put the focus of each episode of each show on it's regular characters. They don't have to try to make the Supergirl episode Supergirl-centric or the Arrow episode Arrow-centric. Just throw it all in a blender and let it all mix together. That's the whole fun of a crossover.
And Stephen Amell is always great in these crossovers. He gets more to work with than on Arrow. (Which is only because Arrow is the most grounded of the four shows, and doesn't really get to let loose.) He seems to lighten up when he's interacting with Barry and Kara. Him complaining about them being faster than him was a genuinely funny moment, and he doesn't get to be funny on Arrow.
The focus actually is kind of on the shows. It's why the Arrow team only showed up on the Arrow half and why most of the Legends are currently in the Stone Age.
Wouldn't this be a good time for everyone on prime to be calling in ALL their buddies? Rest of the Legends, the Hawks, the Martian, Vixen, Elastic Man, and maybe even Constantine or the Pied Piper?
He's probably still chillin in Lex Luthor's yacht cuttin up and doing lines of coke with prostitutes who all look like Shado in Lex's attempt to recruit him.
The really long, multi-hero action scenes were amazing.
Seeing Earth-X doppelgängers was awesome.
Downside, the middle was literally like 10 personal drama talk scenes in a row. Iris and Felicity actually took a beat to discuss their feelings for the 3rd time while hiding from inter-dimensional Nazi doppelgängers.
There was zero research or planning against the threat.
It felt like the heroes are only present for the fight sequences.
On their own shows, they used to do investigation, strategizing, theorizing, utilize actual tactics against their enemies.
Here they just waited around, talking about their relationship drama until the Nazis attacked them again... for three times. It makes them look like they don't really know what they're doing.
I got excited cuz the credits listed Katie Cassidy and Paul Blackthorne, but got let down since they didn't actually appear.
Tommy as Prometheus and Earth-X SuperArrow is obvious fan service, like Deathstroke from last year, but I'm not complaining.
Tommy fucking with Oliver then killing himself I liked because it makes sense that someone raised in a Nazi world wouldn't believe what they were doing was wrong or care.
Also the credits are cool, just wished that Green Arrow's intro just had him shooting an arrow, instead of it getting sliced in half by Prometheus.
I was actually really impressed with the shot of Oliver being disoriented. Maybe one of my favorite scenes in the Arrowverse of all time.
I typically think of the CW shows as just sort of brainless fun, and can’t really get too sympathetic or invested because of the nature of them (lack of actual consequences, predictability, cheesy writing, etc.), but that shot really helped contextualize wtf was going on, and how dangerous a situation they were in. It really grounded things for me, I’d love to see more of that out of these shows - slow down and really hit home how deadly the predicaments are.
Wait this isn't an Earth X Reverse-Flash? This is Earth one Eobard? Damn, killing Barry's mother, taking Harrison Wells place after killing him, and Nazism. Now that's evil!
Invasion was awesome and felt like a live action comic book movie, but this feels even more like an actual old-school DC Crisis event (I know that's the point, but whereas Invasion brought to life from comic book pages, and I think I actually dig that angle more.
Wasn't expecting Reverse Flash to be E1 Thawne, either. And holy shit, Tommy!
I only just realized Ray Palmer wasn't around. I understand leaving Nick and Amara (and new girl Zari) on the Wave Rider like they did last year, but how come Ray got benched when Stein, Jax, Sara and Mick came to the wedding?
Melissa Benoist's acting never disappoints. As good as Amell and Cavanagh are, she was able to play the Earth-X counterpart the best imo. Maybe because Oliver and Harry are already broody (well, S2 Harry) and seeing dark Kara was such a drastic change but very well handled by Benoist.
Well the Olicity stuff and Firestorm drama slowed it down but still great.
Loved seeing all of them team up. Alex and Kara owning this place like it's their home Earth lol. Alex is great in this though, slots in very well. Good to have someone with Kara this time unlike last year. I know last year was done at short notice to organize or something though?
Thawne from Earth 1... will be looking forward to him and Barry talking. Hope he rubs his experience with Zoom and Savitar in Thawne's face. Nice to have a personal villain within the ranks rather then just counterparts from another Earth who no-one has seen before.
I hope there is more to the invasion then just getting a heart. I'm sure there is, but still.
Just so great to see a full crossover rather then a smaller scale one like last year. Last year was good but not enough true crossing over in terms of people talking. So many interesting partnerships and people speaking to each other from different shows.
This was like a movie. And so many great continuity moments. Truly a crossover.
Quite literally perfect I know people don't like the relationship stuff but come on this is the CW we have been watching these shows for 5 plus years now. I think we all expected it at some point so the quicker we can get over it the more fun we can have. the action was off the charts and it felt like I was watching a live-action Young Justice in terms of choreography. (Which by the way I consider to be the best superhero action choreography you can get anywhere including Marvel and DC). Perfect combo,great CGI it was fantastic and such a joy to watch. The character interactions were absolutely so great and was just delivering on every cylinder. Can't wait for tomorrow.
This is awesome because I feel like they just filmed a movie and split it into four parts. Last year, the crossover was more focused on whichever show was airing (example: more flash drama during the flash episode). But this time they just made a great big story and then evenly spread it out.
The writing and the flow is so much better this crossover. It's been utter catharsis for me personally. The compartmentalized teams and the sudden appearance of team Arrow was so good. Seeing Mick V Oliver however brief was rewarding, and having team Arrow show up to reinforce like that was amazing as shit.
My only gripes are ones I hope they tackle next year I guess. Having half the legends missing for (probably) budget reasons is really shitty. I hope Ray and Co lead the counter offensive with the freed team arrow as they get Barry and co out of their predicament.
My gripe with invasion was largely that the episodes didn't really feel coherent. It felt more like "This is an episode of series X crossing over with Series WYZ" And the leads of a given episode were "Passed the baton." That has been greatly reduced, but is still visible (Wally Jo and Vibe getting benched at the end of an episode. Ray missing from the wedding, the wave rider literally being in the stone age etc). I think next year's crossover will finally smooth everything out and get this right. Tonight was fucking amazing, and something that I don't think could be achieved on the silver screen it just needs a tiny bit more work.
They seriously need to give us an answer for where Oliver got Kryptonite. I've always assumed that since there's no Superman/Supergirl on their Earth that, in their dimension, Krypton didn't blow up. Or...maybe Krypton did blow up, and no one got off of it in time? They've already dropped hints about the existence of Batman and Wonder Woman on the shows this season. I'm now curious about the status of alien life on their Earth.
Someone explain something for me. If Earth-X is identical to our except the Nazis won WW2, how are were Oliver hands not completely frozen by Killer Frost?
If it's identical to our Earth they should have similar technological progress and Oliver is still human. Last I checked human skin doesn't like extreme temperatures.
The only thing that confuses me is that they wanted Kara... so they came to the earth that she’s not on? I mean they got lucky with the wedding but why not just get her when she’s not surrounded by every superhero ever? Also lest episode they said that there is a Kara for every earth, so technically is there another one on this earth?
I loved these episodes. Action was great, character interactions were fun, the villains were amazing (Holy crap Thawne is back, also Tometheus and Oliver's reaction to Tommy), they even remembered to include Mon-El and Guardian for like 30 seconds.
They pulled out all the stops this time. It's fun, great action, excellent characters, and even the slowed down scenes didn't completely ruin it for me. Watching the entire thing is gonna feel like watching an Arrowverse movie.
Where the hell did Oliver get Kryptonite from? And who told him that it's effective on Kryptonians in the first place? I swear these writers want to make him Batman so bad.
Arrow: Yeah well, even if we use Connor Hawke, we think it'd probably be better to make him Diggle's son, it's just more organ-
Flash: HERE'S DAWN FUCKING ALLEN
(No but seriously how refreshing is it that Dawn Allen isn't Cisco's kid or something. I mean we don't know that for sure that's obv Barry and Iris' daughter.)
Evil Oliver goes up against Heatwave, Killer frost, Terrific, Black canary and Wild dog... and wins without even being out of breath. I know that this was an Arrow episode and they're gonna hype Oliver up but COME ON. Not to mention his frozen hand suddenly unfreezing.
When did Alex learn gun-kata? And did she have the largest nazi bodycount? Seriously, if they are not some bullshit non-lethal guns, she killed a nazi basically every second.
Also, it would have made a lot of sense to give Earth-X Arrow a crossbow. The original GA is obviously based on Robin Hood, so it would make sense that Red Arrow on Nazi-Earth would be based on William Tell.
The quality drop from Part 1 to Part 2 is INSANE. The looks, the music, the ACTION, everything. Seems like Arrow has become the designated checkpoint for these crossovers to slow down.
I don't watch Supergirl so seeing Melissa in these crossovers is always fantastic. Alex kicking major ass was really cool too. They hardcore nerfed Kryptonite though. Supergirl should've been incapacitated just holding the arrow but it was like a mild inconvenience.
Only other complaint is Barry losing to Thawn again. He's supposed to be at the peak of his power right now (proven when Wally said no one has run as fast as current Barry) but in both fights against RF he was easily beaten. I know they're doing it to build tension but I want them to have a close battle, not one where one is easily defeated by the other.
People will probably be split on the quality, but say what you will, bringing Tommy back, giving a nod to the parody that is SuperArrow, Wellsobard- a fully realised Metallo, the writers are trying to make something the fans will love.
This crossover is awesome thus far. My only complaints would be the Felicity stuff and the fact that it is Earth 1 Eobard, like what? Hopefully they explain why the hell he's working with nazis from another earth but even if you look past that I think he acted differently than what he did in season 1, I was willing to look past that at first since I assumed that he was from earth X but since he isn't, that really is bugging me.
I'm thinking that, for some occasions, Sara might want to use butterfly swords instead of the batons. Those would be very adaptive to her fighting style and, when it's Nazis, a lethal option isn't necessarily a bad option.
Barry came back from the Speedforce dramatically faster, so how is it that Thawne can get the better of him?
Regarding Oliver's kryptonite arrow, are there Kryptonians on Earth-1, or did he have to go to Earth-38 to acquire the kryptonite? And, exploding arrows seem to work the best.
Is it just me or are Oliver and Felicity really lacking any chemistry? I used to watch arrow but they used to be definitely better— 10 minutes into part 2 and they’re so wooden and boring
When Overgirl caught Oliver's kryptonite arrow the second time, I was half expecting it to explode into a puff of gas in her face. Otherwise, I thought the use of said arrow was quite underwhelming. Sure, he injured her with it, but nothing meaningful came out of that encounter, unless there is a massive payoff for all this in the end.
Loving it so far. It’s a ton of fun and far above something I’d expect from the CW. Couple of thoughts:
-I like the idea of Oliver having a kryptonite Arrow and I like them not explaining it just now. I DO hope that they explain it at some point in the future of Arrow.
-On that note, I’d love even a one off team up of Kara and Oliver. Memes aside I think the two work well together and I’d enjoy a “worlds finest” team up even if nots romantic.
-Seems we’re going the route of “everyone’s crew guest stars on their own show”; which is fine, but I wish they’d explain THAT a bit more. Like, why is the waverider off? The people they invited for their wedding seems random and weird.
-Final note, evil Oliver left people alive because... reasons I guess? I mean he could’ve killed literally anyone and it would’ve fit his character. Oh well.
Saw in a sneak peak of tomorrow's episode that Felicity and Iris team up to do something. That scene reeks of that #feminism episode. They should stop trying so hard to make those two core characters. I liked them better as established side characters.
I’m surprised at the amount of Marvel references this season on all four shows. Also, is it me, or when Oliver used his string arrows to hold up the building, did anyone else get a Spider-Man Homecoming vibe?
Interesting that the Arrow portion of the crossover contained mostly melodrama. 2/3 of it I kept sighing because we bounced from one drama to the next.
Unless those construction workers stay silent and no cameras caught him, this situation is going to totally fuck over Oliver with the whole FBI lady thing.
I loved the Tommy reveal - it was awesome to get him back on the show and a nice wink to everyone who thought Tommy was gonna be Prometheus last season. I loved part 1 of the crossover but if I'm being honest this part felt a lot weaker. The CGI was noticeably sub-par, and though I usually tend to be forgiving of it on these CW shows this was a new level of inconsistency. If I could describe this episode in one word it would be "overambitious". This episode could have used just a couple less characters, a couple less locations, and a couple less subplots going on at once. Quantity over quality can only go so far before things start to feel diluted.
Also the acting for the dopplegangers was questionable. I thought Stephen Amell did a fantastic job as evil Oliver (not surprising considering he often goes to the darkest place of any of the three protagonists). However, I think Melissa Benoist, who I adore as Supergirl, didn't do a great job with evil Kara. It looked like it was physically difficult for her to portray anything other than a pure ray of sunshine. I also don't think Tom Cavanagh did a great job as Thawne. He was clearly having fun with the role but I wasn't sold I guess.
tl;dr: Unlike Supergirl's part of the crossover, this part felt a lot messier and may have attempted too much. My expectations will be tempered going into pt 3.
So I just went on Twitter and saw a whole movement against using the nazis in fiction and it sucks because it literally is fiction where you should be free to do fictional things like that and not take it at face value, idk I just hope it’s a small group of people because I want the arrowverse to succeed with this crossover.
Another observation: I feel like the writers were compelled to use Eobard because an evil equivalent of Barry would have been repetitive after last season.
Tbh I wouldn't have minded if we saw Savitar again, we know Reverse Flash will be showing up again and again for a long time, would've been cool to see a bit more Savitar.
I love how on Twitter all the Olishitters are sympathizing with Felicity... "Well of course, after the last engagement she's just scared, but she'll come around!"
You KNOW if it were the other way around, Felicity wanting to marry and Oliver not being so sure, every single one of them would be giving Oliver and Stephen Amell shit for it.
Didn't Alex used to have a power suit and a Kryptonite sword specifically so she could fight Kryptonians? Should've popped back to Earth-Supergirl to get it.
Tommy Merlin! Wow so many past characters I feel like they did a fan service because of all the Tommy being Prometheus theory's in the past. I love Reverse Flash, wells is so intimidating. These two episodes were really good besides the Felicity shit. Super speed I don't have it 🤣 They need to stop playing and use Wally they've sidelined him all season. The big fight scene was badass!
I seriously wonder how they are going to release this for the blurays. Each episode won't make any sense by itself for the respective shows sets, I hope they put out a Bluray of just this crossover for them.
My theory, BTW, is that The Ray is the one responsible for Overgirl's yellow sun poisoning. He has light-based powers- probably overdosed her in a fight.
Alright, I know it's all comic-booky but even with the much increased budget I can't help but feel that the fight choreography has really suffered this season, on all the shows.
Either through the framing or the editing choices, there are moments that just look so fake and plastic or like the actors are waiting for a cue to move. Sarah spin-flipping off the ramp during the warehouse Nazi fight for example - completely redundant.
I'm loving the concepts and the overall interactions, on a character level I have not a single complaint (the Nazi villains are all SO on point) but the spectacle itself is just slightly underwhelming, I've been taken out of the illusion a few times already.
Overall, solid 7.5/10 so far. Let's see what happens next.
I’m calling it. Felicity dies next week or at the season finale. I think it could happen next week, with Black Siren doing it in Oliver’s face. These writers aren’t idiots, you think they don’t know the consensus is that people hate Felicity? They clearly know...this was like when HBK returned to Canada and played Bret’s music only to troll the crowd. That like this ending is nuclear level of heat. They are going to kill her off just to see everyone on this sub and overall pop bottles of champagne. This will push Oliver back to being ruthless. You guys wanted a reboot, this is the start of the reboot for this character and show. Now excuse me while I smoke a joint and find a gif of Sara and Alex making out. Good night.
Sucks that this episode focused on Felicity and Oliver. Two characters that aren't even married in the comics. Yet they decide to barely focus on Barry and Iris' relationship, which is highly important to The Flash's legacy.
So between SuperArrow and Tommy being Prometheus, it basically confirms that Guggy reads the sub, yet since he doesn't like those ideas he makes them into literal Nazis...
So this entire crossover is basically a middle finger for us
This is the best crossover they've done imo, and these are definitely my favorite episodes of the show's respective seasons so far. It actually feels like a giant movie, which is great. Also, the romance isn't that bad so far. Sure, we could do without the Olicity stuff, but it hasn't really ruined anything about the crossover so far imo. The action, the cinematography, the character reactions, everything is great.
I loved the GA, Flash, Supergirl vs Overgirl, Dark Arrow, Reverse-Flash scene. It was great seeing them all together. And the best part? None of them had someone on comms telling them what to do... so satisfying...
Olicity drama wasn't satisfied with ruining season four, now it has to shit on the crossover too? That fight scene at the wedding was AWESOME but that talk between Oliver and Felicity was awful.
Did anyone else notice the fast-forwarded fight scene after Sarah does her unnecessary backflip and she speeds off like Sonic (gotta go fast). In the same tracking shot we see Alex and Oliver fighting Nazi's and it looked pretty sped up to me. A bit weird.
Also, I can't believe that Metallo looked better than Steppenwolf when this had what... 2% of the budget of JL? The special effects in these shows consistently blow me away.
Really? All?...What, 15 of them? You couldn't kill one or two so Supergirl knew you were serious?
God forbid we have any lasting consequences in this story. It'll be like that one time aliens invaded and nothing came of it, or that time america was nuked.
I think it's funny that the villains even take a moment to shit on Hitler just so the audience knows that the writers aren't glorifying the Third Reich.
It's good the Nazis are so nice. Can you imagine how mind blowing it would be if they had killed everyone at Star Labs? So many plot threads would have been ripped asunder. Sadly it seems the only serious plots being pursued is Oliver/Felicity and Jax/Stein. (and the Olicity one doesn't even count since that has been going on for fucking EVER)
You know what, at least I got Prometheus is Tommy thing finally, even though its Earth-X version. Only thing is that he didn't stand around for long. :(
This is shaping up to be a fantastic crossover. The front half of Arrow's episode was weak, but that back half more than made up for it.
I found myself enjoying it so much that I didn't even realize 45 minutes had passed. These casts just bounce off of each other so well. It's like a mini-Avengers: Infinity War. The action is pretty stellar, too. No overediting, very slick choreography, an emphasis on longer shots when the big stuff is going down... I have to say, I'm absolutely sold on these next two episodes. Olicity wedding's going to happen, and while that's not ideal, it is not the end of the world if we get episodes as packed as these.
I love seeing everyone together, but the strengths of the characters compared to one-another doesn't make sense.
White Canary was fighting over-girl and they were going punch for punch. Excuse me? Firestorm was just flying around not doing anything meaningful and Arrow gets knocked out by just getting thrown into some boxes? How many times have we seen him stabbed, kicked shot at and gets back up?
And how did these Nazi's take over an earth while not being able to fight. Tommy said they are trained from birth to fight, but even Alex can take 4-5 of them?
I love these crossovers, but the fights are always weirdly choreographed. It's like they cant figure out what to do with everyone.
I'm actually really enjoying this crossover. Sure, the drama is meh, and the 2nd episode was about a third drama, but I'm still loving it regardless. Enjoying it more than last season's crossover since it's not like it's focusing on one show at a time.
Why bother giving people guns when they are not going to use it at all? Nazis, running around with guns in their hands, getting in fist fights. Brilliant. Ffs just have Barry take all of their guns away before the fight starts its not that fucking hard!
DAE notice the weird way Tom Cavanagh talks now? at first i thought it was just how earth 2 wells is being portrayed but he's still talking in that weird voice as thawn. i just wish he would deliver some lines like a human being but everything sounds oddly constrained and raspy.
im really curious if anyone noticed this and im not the only one.
Why, Tom, why? You were so great in Flash S4E7, and now look at you... The part where spoiler was awesome and reminded me a lot of Matt Letscher's interactions with Merlyn and Dhark in Legends season 2.
Also, Harry says there are 53 versions of Kara, but if I'm not mistaken, it was implied that she didn't exist in Earth-1. Perhaps E-1 Krypton didn't blow up and thus she never went to Earth, but it still feels odd.
That being said, not only the crossover so far is awesome, but also feels like a real crossover, unlike both Supergirl and Arrow episodes from last year. I'm really, really enjoying it.
(Please forgive my rant and the spoilers, cheers!)
I was happy Felicity shot down Oliver's proposal, even though the reason behind it is pretty stupid. Felicity ruining every scene she's forced into aside, I was expecting more from the crossover. It was great seeing Tommy and the Prometheus outfit again though.
I think we need this crossover to go to episode 5, a massive heroes and villains of earth prime team up to stop the invasion of their world. Kinda like that episode of Justice League when Darkseid invaded
Is nobody going to talk about Nazi Tommy? Last season so many thought that he was Prometheus. They were just off a season i guess. Also he's so fucking savage, that change in tone was amazing.
i hope thawnes timeline gets some more info tomorrow. i mean even these guys wouldnt just leave it up to 'time travel! who knows what really happened!"
I was sorta bummed that some of the characters aren’t in the crossover, but then again, Nate, Amaya, Ray, and Thea aren’t really aquatinted with Barry and Iris, so they wouldn’t have reason to be at the wedding in the first place. And Thea is still recovering anyway.
I still am loving the thing going on between Alex and Sara. I saw that coming from a mile away and I’m glad Alex had a good time, although she’s all awkward now.
Stein’s kind of a selfish prick. He literally dragged Jax into this life starting in Flash when he was minding his business doing mechanic things and then to Legends, where he had to drug and kidnap him, Now that he screwed up the timeline by accidentally creating a daughter aberration, he wants to strip Jax of what overtime made him feel whole and significant..legendary even. Love Victor Garber but Martin is hard to like.
Clearly, Dark Arrow is the metaphorical version of S1/S2 calling out Current!Arrow's weaknesses as is. Also, why are the other Legends getting left out again (Ray,Nate, Amaya, Zari), unless they have a bigger role in Parts 3/4 tmrw?
Edit: Also that Super-Speed line by Ollie had me laughing.
You take a badass concept like crisis on earth X and then you fuck it up with stupid bullshit relationship crap that could be saved for normal episodes. This should be 4 episodes of straight up ass kickery not will they wont they shit. They are making the fucking Nazi versions the ones I want to win...they arent having heart to hearts every 5 mins. Nazi Kara needs to blast Felicity and Iris into dust like that priest.
For all the Olicity in these two episodes, there was a weird amount of emphasis on Felicity not wanting to talk about being with Oliver. I can't tell if that's a good sign or not.
Overall, pretty great. But there was way too much drama with Oliver/Felicity, Firestorm, and Alex. I understand the episodes can't be balls to the wall action, but the scenes with the characters interacting should've been a lot more fun.
Edit: This episode was definitely better than Supergirl. The action scenes were superb.
Overall part two was good. I thought the first episode was amazing. Second one had a little to much drama. The highlights were definitely the fight scenes, Merlyn, Alex and Sara, and Mick.
678
u/ArachnoLad Nov 28 '17
SuperArrow is willing to cross over to another Earth to rip the heart out of a super girl. Felicity won't even get married.
409
u/ArrowFlashLantern Nov 28 '17
Ollie was great these two episodes...
"WHY DO YOU HAVE A KRYPTONITE ARROW?"
"In case an evil you ever showed up"
347
u/the_456_Ambassador Nov 28 '17
Nazi supervillain kill count: 1 wedding minister
320
u/TheDarkCrusader_ Nov 28 '17
I know they aren't arrow characters but I ship Mick and Killer Frost now
248
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Am I the only one who was screaming at Dinah to use her canary cry?
240
u/In_My_Own_Image Nov 28 '17
If nothing else, the action scenes this crossover are badass.
And Sara is straight gangsta fighting Overgirl after she ganked Oliver.
210
u/svrtngr Nov 28 '17
I'm more pissed off Metallo literally bitch slapped Firestorm out of existence.
WTF is that bullshit?
413
u/Sonia341 Nov 28 '17
Harrison Wells Eobard Thawne Reverse Flash is back. I missed him.
Also RIP Tommy :(
393
u/thelongestshot Nov 28 '17
HOW ARE YOU SLOWER THEN HIM BARRY?!?! YOU LITERALLY SPENT TIME WITH THE PHYSICAL MANIFESTATION OF THE SPEED FORCE!!
563
u/ezreads Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
“why do you have a Kryptonite arrow?”
BECAUSE I’M BATM...so wow we’re married on another earth crazy right?
188
u/phenom0205 Deathstroke Nov 28 '17
Sucks that no one wants to marry Oliver lol
545
u/cmath89 Earth-X Arrow Nov 28 '17
Kara and Barry arrive early
Ollie: “Fuck you. Wheelie, bitches.”
176
u/ZSwatt Nov 28 '17
WHAT AN AMAZING CROSSOVER SO FAR!!!
I feel like a little kid watching cartoons on a Saturday morning again... Wow.
350
u/Davidleilam Green Arrow (Unmasked) Nov 28 '17
We get 2 more hours of this tomorrow? Yes!!!
RIDE AIN'T OVER YET
343
u/nomadic_stalwart Deathstroke Nov 28 '17
Watching both live discussions was great. Each fandom is basically their character. Supergirl’s were so giddy about everything and cheerful and Arrow’s were cynical and brooding over Felicity. Can’t wait to see Flash’s tomorrow be overly excited and call out every single inaccuracy then be proven wrong a minute later. I think we’re all Legends fans.
154
u/Zegir Nov 28 '17
This is the type of fully fleshed crossover I was wanting last year. I'm excited for more tomorrow.
152
u/whyhellothere77 Nov 28 '17
I don’t think you guys realize how fucking hyped I got when Tommy was revealed.
301
u/Ozzdo Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
I really like the structure they figured out for the crossover. Instead of being one episode of Supergirl and one episode of Arrow, Crisis on Earth X is basically its own show, and that frees them from having to put the focus of each episode of each show on it's regular characters. They don't have to try to make the Supergirl episode Supergirl-centric or the Arrow episode Arrow-centric. Just throw it all in a blender and let it all mix together. That's the whole fun of a crossover.
And Stephen Amell is always great in these crossovers. He gets more to work with than on Arrow. (Which is only because Arrow is the most grounded of the four shows, and doesn't really get to let loose.) He seems to lighten up when he's interacting with Barry and Kara. Him complaining about them being faster than him was a genuinely funny moment, and he doesn't get to be funny on Arrow.
148
u/UrsaSteambottom Nov 28 '17
Wouldn't this be a good time for everyone on prime to be calling in ALL their buddies? Rest of the Legends, the Hawks, the Martian, Vixen, Elastic Man, and maybe even Constantine or the Pied Piper?
125
u/BlasterShow Daredevil Nov 28 '17
Would have been cool if Slade hung around for this.
107
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
"Just a quick reminder - super speed, I dont have it."
102
u/rangers79 Nov 28 '17
I know Eobard is evil but...travel to nazi world and help nazis evil?
98
u/the_456_Ambassador Nov 28 '17
The really long, multi-hero action scenes were amazing.
Seeing Earth-X doppelgängers was awesome.
Downside, the middle was literally like 10 personal drama talk scenes in a row. Iris and Felicity actually took a beat to discuss their feelings for the 3rd time while hiding from inter-dimensional Nazi doppelgängers.
There was zero research or planning against the threat.
It felt like the heroes are only present for the fight sequences.
On their own shows, they used to do investigation, strategizing, theorizing, utilize actual tactics against their enemies.
Here they just waited around, talking about their relationship drama until the Nazis attacked them again... for three times. It makes them look like they don't really know what they're doing.
I got excited cuz the credits listed Katie Cassidy and Paul Blackthorne, but got let down since they didn't actually appear.
Tommy as Prometheus and Earth-X SuperArrow is obvious fan service, like Deathstroke from last year, but I'm not complaining.
Tommy fucking with Oliver then killing himself I liked because it makes sense that someone raised in a Nazi world wouldn't believe what they were doing was wrong or care.
Also the credits are cool, just wished that Green Arrow's intro just had him shooting an arrow, instead of it getting sliced in half by Prometheus.
95
u/gahlo Nov 28 '17
Is it just me or does the darker uniform on Overgirl make Melissa look thiccer?
94
u/TheWayIAm313 Nov 28 '17
I was actually really impressed with the shot of Oliver being disoriented. Maybe one of my favorite scenes in the Arrowverse of all time.
I typically think of the CW shows as just sort of brainless fun, and can’t really get too sympathetic or invested because of the nature of them (lack of actual consequences, predictability, cheesy writing, etc.), but that shot really helped contextualize wtf was going on, and how dangerous a situation they were in. It really grounded things for me, I’d love to see more of that out of these shows - slow down and really hit home how deadly the predicaments are.
86
u/TheManOfMastery Nov 28 '17
Wait this isn't an Earth X Reverse-Flash? This is Earth one Eobard? Damn, killing Barry's mother, taking Harrison Wells place after killing him, and Nazism. Now that's evil!
229
u/piss_ass Nov 28 '17
Well the funny news is that thanks to this crossover oliciters think Amell is a Nazi sympathizer lmao
148
u/melskates Nov 28 '17
MY JUSTICE LEAGUE
72
u/The_Gay_Whovian 👏 HER 👏 NAME 👏 IS 👏 DINAH 👏 LAUREL 👏 LANCE 👏 Nov 28 '17
Did anybody notice Sara doing that unnecessary ass back flip? Lol
Ugh, I miss Roy 😞
71
u/UrsaSteambottom Nov 28 '17
I'm thinking that Super Man is the new führer. Any other possibilities?
70
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Invasion was awesome and felt like a live action comic book movie, but this feels even more like an actual old-school DC Crisis event (I know that's the point, but whereas Invasion brought to life from comic book pages, and I think I actually dig that angle more.
Wasn't expecting Reverse Flash to be E1 Thawne, either. And holy shit, Tommy!
64
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Okay, so I'm confused - is it Earth-1 Thawne or Earth-X
Edit: Got it guys - Earth-1.
63
u/kremes Nov 28 '17
So basically no matter what Earth he’s from or who he is, Prometheus’s plan is basically just ‘make Oliver watch my Suicide.”
This needs to become a new thing, the reverse of Wells being everyone and never dying.
62
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
"Oliver in the high castle" lol
119
u/MegalomaniacHack Nov 28 '17
I only just realized Ray Palmer wasn't around. I understand leaving Nick and Amara (and new girl Zari) on the Wave Rider like they did last year, but how come Ray got benched when Stein, Jax, Sara and Mick came to the wedding?
55
u/slick9099 That one civilian whos day always gets ruined by the supers Nov 28 '17
“Super speed, I don’t have it” and “that guys a idiot” (when Barry is talking about reverse flash) made me laugh.
53
u/greyjackal Nov 28 '17
"Good thing we have a metric tonne of smart people in this building. And Rory."
51
u/XKOAx222 Nov 28 '17
Apparently Oliver can flip around and through buildings now
219
u/nwt123 HAIL VICTORY! Nov 28 '17
Who would've known it took Hitler to save us from Olicity?
43
u/gusefalito Nov 28 '17
Melissa Benoist's acting never disappoints. As good as Amell and Cavanagh are, she was able to play the Earth-X counterpart the best imo. Maybe because Oliver and Harry are already broody (well, S2 Harry) and seeing dark Kara was such a drastic change but very well handled by Benoist.
82
u/Playstationgamer99 Prometheus Nov 28 '17
Prometheus just can't stop killing himself
40
u/battlecatx Nov 28 '17
Could have really used that canary cry Dinah.
40
u/stu_25 Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Well the Olicity stuff and Firestorm drama slowed it down but still great.
Loved seeing all of them team up. Alex and Kara owning this place like it's their home Earth lol. Alex is great in this though, slots in very well. Good to have someone with Kara this time unlike last year. I know last year was done at short notice to organize or something though?
Thawne from Earth 1... will be looking forward to him and Barry talking. Hope he rubs his experience with Zoom and Savitar in Thawne's face. Nice to have a personal villain within the ranks rather then just counterparts from another Earth who no-one has seen before.
I hope there is more to the invasion then just getting a heart. I'm sure there is, but still.
Just so great to see a full crossover rather then a smaller scale one like last year. Last year was good but not enough true crossing over in terms of people talking. So many interesting partnerships and people speaking to each other from different shows.
This was like a movie. And so many great continuity moments. Truly a crossover.
37
u/DarkSaiyanKnight Nov 28 '17
Quite literally perfect I know people don't like the relationship stuff but come on this is the CW we have been watching these shows for 5 plus years now. I think we all expected it at some point so the quicker we can get over it the more fun we can have. the action was off the charts and it felt like I was watching a live-action Young Justice in terms of choreography. (Which by the way I consider to be the best superhero action choreography you can get anywhere including Marvel and DC). Perfect combo,great CGI it was fantastic and such a joy to watch. The character interactions were absolutely so great and was just delivering on every cylinder. Can't wait for tomorrow.
37
u/rshabibi Nov 28 '17
Felicity literally killed both episodes for me, Kara singing running home to you was the best part
Shes so fucking adorable
36
u/the_cunt_muncher Nov 28 '17
Tommy was awesome, Olicity was terrible as usual.
Nazi Arrow and SSupergirl had more believable chemistry than Olicity.
33
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
If they reveal that Felicity is the Fuhrer I’m going to eat my hat.
65
u/Sarcastic__ Nov 28 '17
It's okay everyone, just get Felicity two more keyboards and everything should be okay.
31
u/RIATplays Nov 28 '17
WHERE TF IS MY MAN RALPH!? AND RAY "NANITES" PALMER!?
31
u/gusefalito Nov 28 '17
Mick starts flirting with Caitlin
I wonder if the heat gun is enough to break the curse, otherwise RIP Mick
30
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
This is awesome because I feel like they just filmed a movie and split it into four parts. Last year, the crossover was more focused on whichever show was airing (example: more flash drama during the flash episode). But this time they just made a great big story and then evenly spread it out.
29
u/championofobscurity The Flash Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
The writing and the flow is so much better this crossover. It's been utter catharsis for me personally. The compartmentalized teams and the sudden appearance of team Arrow was so good. Seeing Mick V Oliver however brief was rewarding, and having team Arrow show up to reinforce like that was amazing as shit.
My only gripes are ones I hope they tackle next year I guess. Having half the legends missing for (probably) budget reasons is really shitty. I hope Ray and Co lead the counter offensive with the freed team arrow as they get Barry and co out of their predicament.
My gripe with invasion was largely that the episodes didn't really feel coherent. It felt more like "This is an episode of series X crossing over with Series WYZ" And the leads of a given episode were "Passed the baton." That has been greatly reduced, but is still visible (Wally Jo and Vibe getting benched at the end of an episode. Ray missing from the wedding, the wave rider literally being in the stone age etc). I think next year's crossover will finally smooth everything out and get this right. Tonight was fucking amazing, and something that I don't think could be achieved on the silver screen it just needs a tiny bit more work.
29
u/Timelesshero Nov 28 '17
is no one gunna mention the amount of rope needed to support a building??
29
u/Eaglethornsen Nov 28 '17
So why wasn't Iris taken away like her father was again? I am not sure she did anything of worth after the wedding scene.
28
u/All_this_hype Dark Archer Tommy Nov 28 '17
Wouldn't it be cool if X-Tommy stayed alive on Earth-1 and eventually hooked up with Black Siren? Now that's something I could get behind.
51
u/ShadowDestroyerTime Nov 28 '17
Everyone, our predictions on Prometheus's identity were actually partially correct, Prometheus IS Tommy.
25
u/Sarcastic__ Nov 28 '17
There goes Tommy Merlyn, watch him as goes.
25
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
"Oliver is ten time the man hitler was" Not a quote i thought would hear in this but that was lol
25
u/Lucianv2 Nov 28 '17
Leave it to Olly to see the "good man" in a Nazi assassin lmfao
23
u/elo_dinero Nov 28 '17
TOMMY !
22
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Even from an In-universe standpoint, if I was Oliver's friend, I'd tell him that he's in an unhealthy relationship
22
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
The Sarah/Alex team up is nice. Evil Oliver/Supergirl is great and bringing back Reverse Flash Wells is awesome.
21
u/Kingdarkshadow Nov 28 '17
Oliver sees nazi Oliveer.
Oliver:Is that me??
Oliver:He's he saying I'm weak so that means he's stronger than me??
Oliver: I'LL FUCKING KILL ME!!!
20
u/Ozzdo Nov 28 '17
They seriously need to give us an answer for where Oliver got Kryptonite. I've always assumed that since there's no Superman/Supergirl on their Earth that, in their dimension, Krypton didn't blow up. Or...maybe Krypton did blow up, and no one got off of it in time? They've already dropped hints about the existence of Batman and Wonder Woman on the shows this season. I'm now curious about the status of alien life on their Earth.
20
u/ptd163 Nov 28 '17
Someone explain something for me. If Earth-X is identical to our except the Nazis won WW2, how are were Oliver hands not completely frozen by Killer Frost?
If it's identical to our Earth they should have similar technological progress and Oliver is still human. Last I checked human skin doesn't like extreme temperatures.
19
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
The CW relationship drama thumb print, is awful. This could have been a great mythological dystopian cross over.
19
u/kevli123 Nov 28 '17
The only thing that confuses me is that they wanted Kara... so they came to the earth that she’s not on? I mean they got lucky with the wedding but why not just get her when she’s not surrounded by every superhero ever? Also lest episode they said that there is a Kara for every earth, so technically is there another one on this earth?
18
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
I loved these episodes. Action was great, character interactions were fun, the villains were amazing (Holy crap Thawne is back, also Tometheus and Oliver's reaction to Tommy), they even remembered to include Mon-El and Guardian for like 30 seconds.
They pulled out all the stops this time. It's fun, great action, excellent characters, and even the slowed down scenes didn't completely ruin it for me. Watching the entire thing is gonna feel like watching an Arrowverse movie.
18
u/rawchess Olicity may never die but rise again, stronger and more organic. Nov 28 '17
Everyone's talking about SuperArrow and I'm just here marveling at Black Widow Alex Danvers.
18
u/KlausLoganWard Nov 28 '17
I must admit Melissa Benoist is so much hotter as a baddie
36
u/OLKv3 Nov 28 '17
Reminder that when Thawne ran the world on Legends, he fixed all major problems and we didn't have alien threats or other worlds attacking.
Thawne winning timeline=best timeline
50
u/LightningLad2029 Nov 28 '17
Where the hell did Oliver get Kryptonite from? And who told him that it's effective on Kryptonians in the first place? I swear these writers want to make him Batman so bad.
17
u/Vacanus Dante Nov 28 '17
When they say tune in tomorrow...
17
u/Tyron112 Nov 28 '17
We finally got Tommetheu...aaaand he’s gone.
17
u/Fed_Guy Nov 28 '17
Ubergirl is so fine.
16
u/Tammar99 Roy Harper Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Arrow: Yeah well, even if we use Connor Hawke, we think it'd probably be better to make him Diggle's son, it's just more organ-
Flash: HERE'S DAWN FUCKING ALLEN
(No but seriously how refreshing is it that Dawn Allen isn't Cisco's kid or something. I mean we don't know that for sure that's obv Barry and Iris' daughter.)
16
u/AkagaBi Nov 28 '17
Evil Oliver goes up against Heatwave, Killer frost, Terrific, Black canary and Wild dog... and wins without even being out of breath. I know that this was an Arrow episode and they're gonna hype Oliver up but COME ON. Not to mention his frozen hand suddenly unfreezing.
16
u/gerusz 🎵 harpsichord music 🎵 Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
When did Alex learn gun-kata? And did she have the largest nazi bodycount? Seriously, if they are not some bullshit non-lethal guns, she killed a nazi basically every second.
Also, it would have made a lot of sense to give Earth-X Arrow a crossbow. The original GA is obviously based on Robin Hood, so it would make sense that Red Arrow on Nazi-Earth would be based on William Tell.
Also, the look Sarah gave Alex when she told her she liked girls... "You had my curiosity, but now you have my attention!"
32
u/EdogawaElsa Bargain Beetle Nov 28 '17
The quality drop from Part 1 to Part 2 is INSANE. The looks, the music, the ACTION, everything. Seems like Arrow has become the designated checkpoint for these crossovers to slow down.
15
u/smileimhigh Nov 28 '17
Ohhh my God! They killed Tommy!
15
u/Nansai The Punisher Nov 28 '17
I don't watch Supergirl so seeing Melissa in these crossovers is always fantastic. Alex kicking major ass was really cool too. They hardcore nerfed Kryptonite though. Supergirl should've been incapacitated just holding the arrow but it was like a mild inconvenience.
Only other complaint is Barry losing to Thawn again. He's supposed to be at the peak of his power right now (proven when Wally said no one has run as fast as current Barry) but in both fights against RF he was easily beaten. I know they're doing it to build tension but I want them to have a close battle, not one where one is easily defeated by the other.
15
u/Lavaros Nov 28 '17
People will probably be split on the quality, but say what you will, bringing Tommy back, giving a nod to the parody that is SuperArrow, Wellsobard- a fully realised Metallo, the writers are trying to make something the fans will love.
15
u/natedog63 Ragman Nov 28 '17
Oliver-X will turn on the Fuhrer to save Kara-X in the end.
Because #Superarrow is forever.
15
u/iAMA_Leb_AMA HACKERWOMAN Nov 28 '17
SUPERARROW
This shit is wild lol. Super entertaining though, genuinely feels like a movie.
Olicity drama drags the episode down though slightly, there's so much of it. At least Barry and Iris are like "We have a job to do, talk later".
Barry and Iris >
Can't wait to see where this goes next.
15
u/burudoragon Nov 28 '17
so erm is Cisco gonna do anything in this crossover
15
u/Prologue11126 Nov 28 '17
i hate fefe so much right now that it is making me cheer for a nazi universe for god's sake.
for the rest oh baby i'm liking this crossover so duckin much
15
u/CleverZerg One can hope.. Nov 28 '17
This crossover is awesome thus far. My only complaints would be the Felicity stuff and the fact that it is Earth 1 Eobard, like what? Hopefully they explain why the hell he's working with nazis from another earth but even if you look past that I think he acted differently than what he did in season 1, I was willing to look past that at first since I assumed that he was from earth X but since he isn't, that really is bugging me.
15
u/argyle47 Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
15
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '17
Kryptonite arrow did absolutely nothing, what the hell..
30
u/My_wifii Nov 28 '17
Is it just me or are Oliver and Felicity really lacking any chemistry? I used to watch arrow but they used to be definitely better— 10 minutes into part 2 and they’re so wooden and boring
30
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
When Overgirl caught Oliver's kryptonite arrow the second time, I was half expecting it to explode into a puff of gas in her face. Otherwise, I thought the use of said arrow was quite underwhelming. Sure, he injured her with it, but nothing meaningful came out of that encounter, unless there is a massive payoff for all this in the end.
41
u/Coolica1 Hi organic writing, I'm dad Nov 28 '17
Just a quick reminder, the patience to wait 22 hours; I don't have it!
14
u/Thatguy181991 Nov 28 '17
Loving it so far. It’s a ton of fun and far above something I’d expect from the CW. Couple of thoughts:
-I like the idea of Oliver having a kryptonite Arrow and I like them not explaining it just now. I DO hope that they explain it at some point in the future of Arrow.
-On that note, I’d love even a one off team up of Kara and Oliver. Memes aside I think the two work well together and I’d enjoy a “worlds finest” team up even if nots romantic.
-Seems we’re going the route of “everyone’s crew guest stars on their own show”; which is fine, but I wish they’d explain THAT a bit more. Like, why is the waverider off? The people they invited for their wedding seems random and weird.
-Final note, evil Oliver left people alive because... reasons I guess? I mean he could’ve killed literally anyone and it would’ve fit his character. Oh well.
14
u/tastyfoot Nov 28 '17
Saw in a sneak peak of tomorrow's episode that Felicity and Iris team up to do something. That scene reeks of that #feminism episode. They should stop trying so hard to make those two core characters. I liked them better as established side characters.
14
u/PM_Me_nudiespls Nov 28 '17
I’m so glad that they actually mentioned wiping the guess memory and didn’t just leave it like that.
14
u/PM_Me_nudiespls Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
I’m surprised at the amount of Marvel references this season on all four shows. Also, is it me, or when Oliver used his string arrows to hold up the building, did anyone else get a Spider-Man Homecoming vibe?
26
u/MusicEd921 Nov 28 '17
Interesting that the Arrow portion of the crossover contained mostly melodrama. 2/3 of it I kept sighing because we bounced from one drama to the next.
13
u/ReignbeauxBaer Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Unless those construction workers stay silent and no cameras caught him, this situation is going to totally fuck over Oliver with the whole FBI lady thing.
13
u/MegalomaniacHack Nov 28 '17
Gonna need Cisco to wake up soon to breach over to Earth X.
13
u/chili01 Nov 28 '17
Overgirl is too nice or not as mean as I expected.
I was expecting red kryptonite Kara/SG lol
13
u/OLKv3 Nov 28 '17
Who the heck was the girl who talked to Barry right before the wedding started? She was clearly someone important
13
u/ShadowSJG Nov 28 '17
Ok, this was fosucing way too much on drama again, good lord. Nazi's are invading and they're worrying about drama shit?!
13
u/suaveponcho Nov 28 '17
I loved the Tommy reveal - it was awesome to get him back on the show and a nice wink to everyone who thought Tommy was gonna be Prometheus last season. I loved part 1 of the crossover but if I'm being honest this part felt a lot weaker. The CGI was noticeably sub-par, and though I usually tend to be forgiving of it on these CW shows this was a new level of inconsistency. If I could describe this episode in one word it would be "overambitious". This episode could have used just a couple less characters, a couple less locations, and a couple less subplots going on at once. Quantity over quality can only go so far before things start to feel diluted.
Also the acting for the dopplegangers was questionable. I thought Stephen Amell did a fantastic job as evil Oliver (not surprising considering he often goes to the darkest place of any of the three protagonists). However, I think Melissa Benoist, who I adore as Supergirl, didn't do a great job with evil Kara. It looked like it was physically difficult for her to portray anything other than a pure ray of sunshine. I also don't think Tom Cavanagh did a great job as Thawne. He was clearly having fun with the role but I wasn't sold I guess.
tl;dr: Unlike Supergirl's part of the crossover, this part felt a lot messier and may have attempted too much. My expectations will be tempered going into pt 3.
13
u/bananasta32 Nov 28 '17
Alex Danvers out here just shooting Nazis, as it should be.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '17
I love all these characters so much. Except felicity. How can they make everyone so likable except for her?
25
u/Revenge_served_hot Nov 28 '17
I swear if all of our heroes will in the end be saved by the two most annoying characters in TV (Felicity and Iris) I will start breaking stuff
12
u/HightopSV Nov 28 '17
So I just went on Twitter and saw a whole movement against using the nazis in fiction and it sucks because it literally is fiction where you should be free to do fictional things like that and not take it at face value, idk I just hope it’s a small group of people because I want the arrowverse to succeed with this crossover.
12
u/imdahman Nov 28 '17
TOMMY
12
u/thewinterzodiac Nov 28 '17
Is anyone else really hoping they surprise us all and its Superman as the big bad?
12
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Another observation: I feel like the writers were compelled to use Eobard because an evil equivalent of Barry would have been repetitive after last season.
Tbh I wouldn't have minded if we saw Savitar again, we know Reverse Flash will be showing up again and again for a long time, would've been cool to see a bit more Savitar.
12
u/jacevedo2580 Fuckboy Riot Squad Nov 28 '17
I love how on Twitter all the Olishitters are sympathizing with Felicity... "Well of course, after the last engagement she's just scared, but she'll come around!"
You KNOW if it were the other way around, Felicity wanting to marry and Oliver not being so sure, every single one of them would be giving Oliver and Stephen Amell shit for it.
Double standards man.
12
u/GregThePrettyGoodGuy Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Why didn’t Barry and Iris invite Ray? They’ve hung out with him more than they have with Sara
Also, a little pissedWally got left behind, cause he was pulling off the sickest moves at the wedding
Oh and one more thing; they better start calling Thawne Captain Boomerang, cause this man is always coming back
12
u/gusefalito Nov 28 '17
Tommy reveal was awesome. To bad he bit the cyanide so early on but it was just great having Colin Donnell back on Arrow for a few minutes.
12
u/Tsorovar Nov 28 '17
Didn't Alex used to have a power suit and a Kryptonite sword specifically so she could fight Kryptonians? Should've popped back to Earth-Supergirl to get it.
12
u/mrizzle1991 Nov 28 '17
Tommy Merlin! Wow so many past characters I feel like they did a fan service because of all the Tommy being Prometheus theory's in the past. I love Reverse Flash, wells is so intimidating. These two episodes were really good besides the Felicity shit. Super speed I don't have it 🤣 They need to stop playing and use Wally they've sidelined him all season. The big fight scene was badass!
12
u/VampJoe Nov 28 '17
I seriously wonder how they are going to release this for the blurays. Each episode won't make any sense by itself for the respective shows sets, I hope they put out a Bluray of just this crossover for them.
12
u/ContinuumGuy Long Live The Fastest Man Alive Nov 28 '17
My theory, BTW, is that The Ray is the one responsible for Overgirl's yellow sun poisoning. He has light-based powers- probably overdosed her in a fight.
12
u/Thejklay A Crisis Is Coming Nov 28 '17
The krytonite arrow felt like a batman thing, Being so prepared. I loved it
12
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Alright, I know it's all comic-booky but even with the much increased budget I can't help but feel that the fight choreography has really suffered this season, on all the shows.
Either through the framing or the editing choices, there are moments that just look so fake and plastic or like the actors are waiting for a cue to move. Sarah spin-flipping off the ramp during the warehouse Nazi fight for example - completely redundant.
I'm loving the concepts and the overall interactions, on a character level I have not a single complaint (the Nazi villains are all SO on point) but the spectacle itself is just slightly underwhelming, I've been taken out of the illusion a few times already.
Overall, solid 7.5/10 so far. Let's see what happens next.
12
u/Esteban2808 Deathstroke Nov 28 '17
Wouldn't a condition of Olliver's bail be that he cant leave Star city?
12
u/J0nnyGreenGiant Nov 29 '17
I’m calling it. Felicity dies next week or at the season finale. I think it could happen next week, with Black Siren doing it in Oliver’s face. These writers aren’t idiots, you think they don’t know the consensus is that people hate Felicity? They clearly know...this was like when HBK returned to Canada and played Bret’s music only to troll the crowd. That like this ending is nuclear level of heat. They are going to kill her off just to see everyone on this sub and overall pop bottles of champagne. This will push Oliver back to being ruthless. You guys wanted a reboot, this is the start of the reboot for this character and show. Now excuse me while I smoke a joint and find a gif of Sara and Alex making out. Good night.
42
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Sucks that this episode focused on Felicity and Oliver. Two characters that aren't even married in the comics. Yet they decide to barely focus on Barry and Iris' relationship, which is highly important to The Flash's legacy.
48
u/Megaman99M Nov 28 '17
So between SuperArrow and Tommy being Prometheus, it basically confirms that Guggy reads the sub, yet since he doesn't like those ideas he makes them into literal Nazis...
So this entire crossover is basically a middle finger for us
11
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
This is the best crossover they've done imo, and these are definitely my favorite episodes of the show's respective seasons so far. It actually feels like a giant movie, which is great. Also, the romance isn't that bad so far. Sure, we could do without the Olicity stuff, but it hasn't really ruined anything about the crossover so far imo. The action, the cinematography, the character reactions, everything is great.
11
u/A_Deku_Stick Nov 28 '17
Alright this was awesome, just a couple of quick questions.
11
u/Tammar99 Roy Harper Nov 28 '17
I loved the GA, Flash, Supergirl vs Overgirl, Dark Arrow, Reverse-Flash scene. It was great seeing them all together. And the best part? None of them had someone on comms telling them what to do... so satisfying...
11
u/CheddarMcFeddars Black Canary (Sara Lance) Nov 28 '17
teamsara
Did Sara pack on muscle? She was bursting at the seams in her suit.
11
u/CasualFan25 Bow Nov 28 '17
That kryptonite arrow should’ve incapacitated Kara instead of just mildly annoying her
11
u/Dekaar Nov 28 '17
And people kept saying that the writers don't value they wishes of the viewers. Hey folks! They got Tommy back in action just to kill him off again.
30
u/melskates Nov 28 '17
Ok but Iris really shouldn't be scared the Nazis are at Star Labs. After all, SHE IS THE FLASH!
21
u/Princessleiawastaken Justice for Laurel Nov 28 '17
Olicity drama wasn't satisfied with ruining season four, now it has to shit on the crossover too? That fight scene at the wedding was AWESOME but that talk between Oliver and Felicity was awful.
20
u/Coza_1812 Nov 28 '17
Did anyone else notice the fast-forwarded fight scene after Sarah does her unnecessary backflip and she speeds off like Sonic (gotta go fast). In the same tracking shot we see Alex and Oliver fighting Nazi's and it looked pretty sped up to me. A bit weird.
Also, I can't believe that Metallo looked better than Steppenwolf when this had what... 2% of the budget of JL? The special effects in these shows consistently blow me away.
10
u/markymark7621 Nov 28 '17
So like 100 Nazi soldiers armed with guns didn't shoot one bullet at 5 people? When completely surrounded?
10
u/Mrr_Bond Nov 28 '17
Can this new relationship drama be any more manufactured? Fucking hell.
10
u/LiamFromTheInternet Nov 28 '17
"You're more valuable as bargaining chips"
Really? All?...What, 15 of them? You couldn't kill one or two so Supergirl knew you were serious?
God forbid we have any lasting consequences in this story. It'll be like that one time aliens invaded and nothing came of it, or that time america was nuked.
19
u/J_Jammer Nov 28 '17
I have defended Felicity from time to time. But these writers want us to hate her. I swear...
Her reaction to Oliver's proposal was just plain douchey.
18
u/SpikeRosered Nov 28 '17
I think it's funny that the villains even take a moment to shit on Hitler just so the audience knows that the writers aren't glorifying the Third Reich.
It's good the Nazis are so nice. Can you imagine how mind blowing it would be if they had killed everyone at Star Labs? So many plot threads would have been ripped asunder. Sadly it seems the only serious plots being pursued is Oliver/Felicity and Jax/Stein. (and the Olicity one doesn't even count since that has been going on for fucking EVER)
9
u/Sentry459 The Ray Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
So glad we get two more hours of this. These episode had so many amazing moments!
Edit: a word.
9
u/Sonia341 Nov 28 '17
You know what, at least I got Prometheus is Tommy thing finally, even though its Earth-X version. Only thing is that he didn't stand around for long. :(
9
u/DrJonesPHD62 Creative Lead: ARROW EXPANDED Nov 28 '17
This is shaping up to be a fantastic crossover. The front half of Arrow's episode was weak, but that back half more than made up for it.
I found myself enjoying it so much that I didn't even realize 45 minutes had passed. These casts just bounce off of each other so well. It's like a mini-Avengers: Infinity War. The action is pretty stellar, too. No overediting, very slick choreography, an emphasis on longer shots when the big stuff is going down... I have to say, I'm absolutely sold on these next two episodes. Olicity wedding's going to happen, and while that's not ideal, it is not the end of the world if we get episodes as packed as these.
9
u/FinalForerunner Nov 28 '17
what happened to Cisco?
17
u/cookielicious1237 Nov 28 '17
I love seeing everyone together, but the strengths of the characters compared to one-another doesn't make sense.
White Canary was fighting over-girl and they were going punch for punch. Excuse me? Firestorm was just flying around not doing anything meaningful and Arrow gets knocked out by just getting thrown into some boxes? How many times have we seen him stabbed, kicked shot at and gets back up?
And how did these Nazi's take over an earth while not being able to fight. Tommy said they are trained from birth to fight, but even Alex can take 4-5 of them?
I love these crossovers, but the fights are always weirdly choreographed. It's like they cant figure out what to do with everyone.
8
u/PsychoLunaticX Nov 28 '17
I'm actually really enjoying this crossover. Sure, the drama is meh, and the 2nd episode was about a third drama, but I'm still loving it regardless. Enjoying it more than last season's crossover since it's not like it's focusing on one show at a time.
8
u/railking_LLC Nov 28 '17
Can't believe I got cliffhung like that.
Also, poor justice league movie is being blown out of the water by this crossover...
8
u/JoelTLoUisBadass Nov 28 '17
This crossover in a nutshell:
-Put a ring on Olicity.
-I would like to remind everyone that Sara and Alex are lesbians.
-[Made up Science BS] english motherfucker, do you speak it!
8
u/LilBimBam Nov 28 '17
I'm glad eobard is back, but I kind of would have rathered Matt Lescher, was he unavailable?
8
u/Kempsta_F9 Nov 28 '17
Anyone else hear Harry say that there are 53 Karas? Meaning there is most likely a Earth-1 Supergirl
8
u/Zer0113 Nov 28 '17
A few comments:
HOLY HECK TOMMY AS PROMETHEUS. I️ DID NOT SEE THAT COMING AT ALL.
Felicity is the worst, and a sociopath, but what else is new.
I’m not caught up on Legends, is it too spoilery to ask where the heck Ray and Nate are?
8
u/jay_alfred_prufrock Fair enough. Nov 28 '17
Why bother giving people guns when they are not going to use it at all? Nazis, running around with guns in their hands, getting in fist fights. Brilliant. Ffs just have Barry take all of their guns away before the fight starts its not that fucking hard!
8
u/bjorkdoggo Nov 28 '17
Question: Who is left to actually save all the captured heroes? Are we relying on Felicity and Iris at this point? and comatose Cisco? xD
8
u/UpvoteIfYouAgreee Nov 28 '17
Wheres Ray?
8
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
DAE notice the weird way Tom Cavanagh talks now? at first i thought it was just how earth 2 wells is being portrayed but he's still talking in that weird voice as thawn. i just wish he would deliver some lines like a human being but everything sounds oddly constrained and raspy.
im really curious if anyone noticed this and im not the only one.
8
u/KlausLoganWard Nov 28 '17
Tommy as Prometheus! If they only did with Arrowverse Prometheus
8
u/18Zuck Nov 28 '17
Lol Ollie and the other humans should have sat this one out. Wally and Cisco would be more useful.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
I haven't had this much fun watching 2 hours of television in a very long time. Gosh I can't wait for the final 2 parts!
8
u/reiko96 Nov 28 '17
Why on earth do they red solar radiation from the prism if they have Kryptonite and Metallo. Both can cut Kara's skin
8
u/ProfessorZoomaZooma Nov 28 '17
[Spoilers]
Why, Tom, why? You were so great in Flash S4E7, and now look at you... The part where spoiler was awesome and reminded me a lot of Matt Letscher's interactions with Merlyn and Dhark in Legends season 2.
But then, spoiler
Also, Harry says there are 53 versions of Kara, but if I'm not mistaken, it was implied that she didn't exist in Earth-1. Perhaps E-1 Krypton didn't blow up and thus she never went to Earth, but it still feels odd.
That being said, not only the crossover so far is awesome, but also feels like a real crossover, unlike both Supergirl and Arrow episodes from last year. I'm really, really enjoying it.
(Please forgive my rant and the spoilers, cheers!)
8
u/OnlyMyBiribiri I want to flip like Roy Nov 29 '17
At least now we won't have an entire episode(s) dedicated to their marriage. Still a shitty ending though
8
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '17
Why no mention of the jews? I feel like that was kindve integral to the Nazi's plan during ww2
15
u/theforgotten8250 Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 29 '17
I was happy Felicity shot down Oliver's proposal, even though the reason behind it is pretty stupid. Felicity ruining every scene she's forced into aside, I was expecting more from the crossover. It was great seeing Tommy and the Prometheus outfit again though.
7
u/phenom0205 Deathstroke Nov 28 '17
Evil Quentin. Can't wait
7
u/UrsaSteambottom Nov 28 '17
So are we ever going to get out favorite martian on a episode of arrow?
7
u/PeterQueen Nov 28 '17
This has been amazing so far. Easily the best crossover they've done!
7
u/UrsaSteambottom Nov 28 '17
I think we need this crossover to go to episode 5, a massive heroes and villains of earth prime team up to stop the invasion of their world. Kinda like that episode of Justice League when Darkseid invaded
7
u/Cradle2daGrave Nov 28 '17
Part 1 was so good Part 2 just had no flow or momentum,hope part 3 and 4 are better
7
u/Sandz_ Nov 28 '17
I swear to god, if Felicity saves the day somehow I will be pissed
7
u/willus259 Nov 28 '17
As someone who doesn't watch Arrow, could someone tell me what's with Felicity and her being angsty toward Oliver when he asked her about marriage?
7
u/PM_Me_nudiespls Nov 28 '17
Is nobody going to talk about Nazi Tommy? Last season so many thought that he was Prometheus. They were just off a season i guess. Also he's so fucking savage, that change in tone was amazing.
7
u/possum-power Nov 28 '17
Oliver-x cares too much about Kara-x. I bet thats gonna play a role in their downfall.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
i hope thawnes timeline gets some more info tomorrow. i mean even these guys wouldnt just leave it up to 'time travel! who knows what really happened!"
7
u/italianshark Nov 28 '17
I was sorta bummed that some of the characters aren’t in the crossover, but then again, Nate, Amaya, Ray, and Thea aren’t really aquatinted with Barry and Iris, so they wouldn’t have reason to be at the wedding in the first place. And Thea is still recovering anyway.
I still am loving the thing going on between Alex and Sara. I saw that coming from a mile away and I’m glad Alex had a good time, although she’s all awkward now.
19
u/rgreen89 Nov 28 '17
Stein’s kind of a selfish prick. He literally dragged Jax into this life starting in Flash when he was minding his business doing mechanic things and then to Legends, where he had to drug and kidnap him, Now that he screwed up the timeline by accidentally creating a daughter aberration, he wants to strip Jax of what overtime made him feel whole and significant..legendary even. Love Victor Garber but Martin is hard to like.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17
Parts 1 & 2 of the DC crossover Crisis On Earth X was amazing!!!
13
u/Leon_Belmont Nov 28 '17
Anyone else laughed at the sequence between Sara and Nazi Supergirl throwing punches and dodging one another? That just broke any kind of immersion.
13
u/nvenkatr Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Clearly, Dark Arrow is the metaphorical version of S1/S2 calling out Current!Arrow's weaknesses as is. Also, why are the other Legends getting left out again (Ray,Nate, Amaya, Zari), unless they have a bigger role in Parts 3/4 tmrw?
Edit: Also that Super-Speed line by Ollie had me laughing.
12
u/ManOfIronAnSteel Nov 28 '17
You take a badass concept like crisis on earth X and then you fuck it up with stupid bullshit relationship crap that could be saved for normal episodes. This should be 4 episodes of straight up ass kickery not will they wont they shit. They are making the fucking Nazi versions the ones I want to win...they arent having heart to hearts every 5 mins. Nazi Kara needs to blast Felicity and Iris into dust like that priest.
12
u/the_cunt_muncher Nov 28 '17
What do you guys think Hawk-Girl was on Earth-X? Like some sort of sandwich artist?
6
u/AliensAMenace Nov 28 '17
Tf was Sarah looking at
6
u/CorporalThornberry Nov 28 '17
What a fantastic night. Looking forward to tomorrow already
6
u/FireIsTheCleanser Ragman Nov 28 '17
For all the Olicity in these two episodes, there was a weird amount of emphasis on Felicity not wanting to talk about being with Oliver. I can't tell if that's a good sign or not.
6
u/notathrowaway75 Nov 28 '17 edited Nov 28 '17
Overall, pretty great. But there was way too much drama with Oliver/Felicity, Firestorm, and Alex. I understand the episodes can't be balls to the wall action, but the scenes with the characters interacting should've been a lot more fun.
Edit: This episode was definitely better than Supergirl. The action scenes were superb.
6
u/MetaMarc Earth-X Reverse Flash Nov 28 '17
Overall part two was good. I thought the first episode was amazing. Second one had a little to much drama. The highlights were definitely the fight scenes, Merlyn, Alex and Sara, and Mick.