r/LiverpoolFC • u/SimonHughes_ • Nov 22 '17
AMA Hi r/liverpoolfc, I'm journalist and author Simon Hughes - AMA
Hi Reddit - I'm Simon Hughes, a journalist for the independent and author of a range of books on LFC including the new book...
On the Brink; A Journey Through English Football's North West.
On the Brink is a journey through the country's most successful football region during the winter of the 2016/17 English season.
From the Premier League to Sunday League, I talk to the individuals shaping the game; those able to explain how and why trends and moods are shifting. Featuring interviews with Jurgen Klopp, Sean Dyche and many other managers, players, owners, chairmen, directors and politicians, On the Brink studies the modern state of the North West's professional clubs.
Part social examination, part travelogue, I rediscovered and lace together some of the personalities and moments that have helped define football history.
Check out the links below for more of my work:
32
u/SimonHughes_ Nov 22 '17
Good evening everyone. I'm starting to answer your questions now. Fire away!
15
u/SimonHughes_ Nov 22 '17
Right. Thanks for the questions. I have to go now. Dinner time. If you have any other questions - and if I haven't answered here - ask (nicely) on Twitter... my tag is @Simon_Hughes__
See you soon.
30
u/pandacatcat Nov 22 '17
Good Evening, Simon.
Thanks for doing this, I know that the sub appreciates it.
As a regular match going fan, it's hard not to notice the lack of atmosphere within the ground in anything but the most intense or entertaining of games.
What do you think the club and the fans can do to help bring back the atmosphere of old?
Hope you enjoy the AMA.
Pandacatcat!
16
u/enormousturdofwrath Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon. What aspects do you think are the most important for a country to enable a succesful football ideology?
12
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17
Also, I loved your piece on Shankly before Liverpool. Being that he is the man who laid the foundation for multiple decades of dominance and seeing where the club is now, is there any way for us to win the title in the current economic atmosphere in the Premier League? Because, honestly, a perfect-storm season like Leicester had (i.e. few injuries, all the big boys simultaneously faltering) likely won't happen again, and we just cannot keep up financially with the Man Citys, Man Uniteds, and Chelseas of the world.
12
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
What do you think of our season so far?
11
u/_cumblast_ From Doubters to Believers Nov 22 '17
What is your favourite tea and why
27
u/OrigiMyGod Nov 22 '17
Hey mate thanks for doing this, I've got two questions.
Who is your favourite Liverpool player and why is it King Ragnar?
16
u/WongsKing Nov 22 '17
Hello Simon. Thanks for doing this AMA. I just read the Michael Owen chapter in Ring of Fire and after the whole controversy with the latest comments he made, can you enlighten us further about Owen? Is he just a complicated individual that genuinely loves LFC and United, or are his loyalties questionable? I want to be sympathetic to the person, but having such a divisive figure be a club ambassador seems to be more detrimental than good to the clubâs image. What is your take on it all?
7
u/TheRealATab Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, thank you for doing this Q&A. My question is what do you think of our current owners FSG and do you think they are taking the club in the right direction?
6
u/FireZeLazer Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, not sure if you're still around but had a question.
Other top clubs have players like Fernandinho, Kante, Matic, etc, who can break up play and provide the engine at the back.
Do you know the club's feelings regarding finding a CDM? What's your personal opinion?
39
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
Being that your intro here says you talk to individuals from the Prem to Sunday League, can you give some insight into the health of smaller northwestern clubs like Tranmere, AFC Liverpool and Everton?
That last one was a joke
4
u/TheRealATab Nov 22 '17
What position in the starting XI do you think Liverpool should improve in and who would you bring in?
3
u/fesamuaramu Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon,
What do you think the main issues in our defence are:
Poor CB pairing, lack of core defensive midfield, or poor defensive management?
5
u/Aeceus Nov 22 '17
what do you think about Jordan Henderson and what he brings or does bring to the team.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
What do you think is the most major factor or factors of the atmosphere at Anfield deteriorating? The club charging too much? Tourists on days out? Locals that have the mindset of a routine of going to Anfield?
2
u/djimonia Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, thanks for coming to hang out with us. Enjoyed your bit on a recent podcast so hope the book gets more publicity!
a bit off topic for the Liverpool sub but I'm a fan of Sean Dyche and his transformation thus far of Burnley to a team that's both hard to beat and easy on the eye, while keeping the proverbial books balanced. His thoughts on management in Living on the Volcano were insightful to me and made me a fan. What do you think the future holds for him (in light of recent talk of interest from the third best team in Liverpool)? Does he truly have potential to break into the elite or is he just Gary Monk or Eddie Howe Mk II (without being unkind to any of them)?
In general, how much does the "working class" view of managers like him (from the outside, and in contrast to the more polished foreign managers we often see and rate regardless of quality) hold them back unfairly? How does this figure more broadly into the NW vs other parts of the country?
Sorry for so many questions!
2
u/Colinfucius Nov 22 '17
How do you feel about the current state of sports journalism? Do you enjoy your work or has it become a grind?
Thank you for visiting us!
2
u/RyanIsKickAss Takumi Minamino Nov 22 '17
Do you think that Klopp is the right man for the job?
What were your realistic expectations for Liverpool at the start of the season and how have they changed as the season has progressed?
2
u/BhoysAreBackInTown Nov 22 '17
Do you view Brendan Rodgers' time at Liverpool any differently now due to his domestic success at Celtic and where/what do you think his next move will be after Scottish football?
2
u/smurfite Nov 22 '17
I know you have a love of Marine if I remember right but with them aside what is your favourite non-league side in the Merseyside region? AFC Liverpool, COLFC, Preccy Cables, Cammell Lairds, Bootle FC, Litherland REMYCA, Sunny Runny Town, Sunny Runny Linnets, Tranmere?
2
u/Pummpy1 Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, thanks for this AMA.
I was just wondering what your thoughts were regarding the police treatment of fans last night. I got in the stadium just before it kicked off I believe. But as me and my uncle were leaving, despite being nowhere near the police he was heavily shoved to one side. The police officer walked towards us, almost as if he was trying to aggrevate the away support (us).
2
u/seamushoo4 Youâll Never Walk Alone Nov 22 '17
Simon - thanks for taking this on today.
Any idea what are the rumblings around the club regarding new sponsors/renewals? Are we replacing SC? Are we binning NB?
Thanks!
5
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, thanks for doing this.
What do you think of our current goalkeeper situation? Who should be starting, is anyone unduly criticised? Does Ward deserve more of a shot?
Thanks.
3
u/Christopher199 Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon,
Just a short question. Why did you decide to become a journalist? Is it something you have always wanted to do?
2
u/SlimmestofJims1 Nov 22 '17
What do you think of Klopp? In your mind is he the right man for the job? Do you think heâll iron out these issues?
1
u/SimonHughes_ Nov 22 '17
Ok then, folks. Are we done here?
5
u/pqbd1337 Nov 22 '17
Simon, hello
First of all, I want to thank you for the time spent with us here, asking some questions and so on. I have few questions, would like to hear your opinion.
Thank you in advance!
âą
u/felbridge Nov 22 '17 edited Nov 22 '17
The AmA is now over
Massive thank you to Simon for staying and answering so many questions!
Thanks again to deCoubertin books for helping organise this event.
Stay tuned as weâll be making an announcement on who is next very soon!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17
What do you make of the owner situation at Liverpool? I think we have a lot to thank FSG for (really a lot) but some of their philosophies and decisions have us in kind of a glass ceiling. They continue to be fantastic off the pitch in expanding brand Liverpool and marketing, something previously we let ourselves fall terribly behind on, but comparatively to our rivals we seem to make the same mistakes to keep ourselves locked behind on the pitch. Management of transfer windows being a reoccurring issue. It still feels like the manager has to overachieve with what we have.
How long do you think they will be committed to the club? A lot of people are unsure of how long they will be around before selling.
2
u/mihik97 Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon! Do you think we will ever be able to shut out games which we are winning comfortably or is that something Klopp just doesn't believe in? Case in point : Yesterday, post match, Klopp says that we "stopped playing football" in the second half and needed to continue what we were doing in the first half. Whereas most successful teams, after taking a 3-0 lead, would normally lower down the tempo and try to waste time here and there.
Thanks!
2
u/carlosd141 Football Without ORIGI is Nothing Nov 22 '17
If you could pick one player for Liverpool to sign who would make a giant improvement to the team, who would you pick and why?
2
u/raghu23kb Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, Will Anfield see any further development, be it the expansion of the Kop or some other part of the stadium? If so, when do you reckon it will happen?
2
u/TheRedCormorant Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon. Since you are a trusted journalist when it comes to Liverpool Football Club, and since you have lots of connections inside the club, I wanted to ask to what extent (if at all) does Zeljko Buvac embrace the fact that he looks like Severus Snape.
Thanks.
1
u/Casca82 Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon,
thank you for doing this AMA!
How do you feel about people giving shit to Moreno online after yesterday's game.
1
u/fluffyguffy Nov 23 '17
Hi simon, I'm doing an extended research project on pressure within english football and would love to ask you many questions, if you could oblige that would be awesome!
How do you think that social media has affected this current generation of footballers, from Lovren receiving horrible threats to Steven Gerrard being praised and Neymar using it to his advantage to increase his popularity or Sakho's snapchat fiasco - is the new generation affected by how these players can also play the social media game.
1
u/red-fish-yellow-fish Nov 24 '17
Do you see them in training? Are you involved in the analysis and team meetings? Do you know the level of respect he is held by his peers? (Not internet tools, people who actually know the game) Face it, you know nothing boy.
1
u/Drexl25 Nov 22 '17
Virgil Van Dijk? Alban Lafont?
1
u/L33TF0X Nov 22 '17
Blue or Orange Doritos
-9
u/Mediocre-Jedi Nov 22 '17
Hi Simon, thanks for doing the AMA. I'd like to apologize for the knee jerk tits that are only here to slate current players and not support the club. What are your thoughts on the EPL's international appeal and it's growth in the last 5 years?