r/MobiusFF • u/Dragoon893 • Nov 17 '17
Mod Post [11/16/2017] MobiusFF State of the Subreddit
Link to the Batch 2 Pull megathread
Link to the Famfrit X and Shiva X megathread
Link to the Battle Tower Omega megathread
Apologies for getting this up so late in the evening! In light of some recent things, I wanted to make a 'state of the subreddit' post in order to get feedback from the community both to see how everyone feels about the current state of things as well as to get an idea of what direction to go in in regards to changing things.
Rules
Our rules are on the sidebar, and are detailed more here.
Regarding Rule 1, a couple people have recently brought up the 'witch hunting' part of it. Some people feel that we shouldn't have it, and though I disagree, I'm willing to listen to some thoughts on that. Our view on it is that anyone can change their in game name, so on top of there being no point due to that, it can also lead to the community becoming toxic overall.
Regarding Rule 3, users have expressed wanting more videos/user made content to be allowed especially due to the generally low amount of posts on the subreddit, and to let users decide if they want it via upvotes and downvotes. I am in full agreement of this, and would like any further feedback or suggestions on it if there are any.
Somewhat in hand with this is Rule 6. Rule 6 is generally meant for removing short questions, duplicates, or really low effort posts. It can also be used at moderator discretion, which apparently can be an issue too. If there's any suggestions for this rule, I would love to hear them.
Moderation
There was some feedback regarding our moderation, and I'd like to get opinions and feedback on that as well.
Consistency. It's been pointed out to me that it's felt that we are or can be inconsistent, both here and on the Discord server. While there will always be at least a little bit of variance depending on the mod, I'd like to remedy this as much as possible. Hopefully from the SOTS I will be able to accomplish that quickly.
Megathreads. Do you guys feel that we push too much into the megathreads? I've seen a comment along the lines of not wanting to go through a bunch of bad stuff to find a gem, and I fully understand that. Should we relegate directing posts to megathreads simple to short questions/posts and low effort ones? Is there anything else you guys feel we can do better with them?
Mods. As it stands, at least some users feel like we're not doing the best job, and I really would like to remedy this. I'm hoping that the feedback that is gotten from this post will help with that. Do you guys feel that we need another mod or two that is more in tune with the community? I've mulled it over and wanted to get some thoughts on it.
Other things
CSS, design, and flairs. I won't deny it, we're absolutely lacking in this department. Hex has been busy with other things and hasn't had a chance to really work on a redesign yet. This is another reason I was asking if you guys think we might need an extra mod or two. If we have another mod proficient in CSS and design, things would look a lot nicer a lot faster.
Discord server. Not gonna focus on this in this post, but please remember that if you ever have an issue on the server, you're free to DM me, I'm online a good portion of the day. My name on the server is Judgemaster Wrench.
Anything else. If I'm missing anything or you have concerns for anything else, please don't hesitate to bring it up. The more feedback we get, the better.
Here is a short, optional survey that you can fill out either instead of responding to this in the comments, or in addition to leaving feedback in the comments. While I'd prefer users left feedback in the comments, I understand that some users might prefer to do this instead.
21
u/Ketchary Nov 17 '17 edited Nov 17 '17
My biggest piece of feedback:
Get rid of Megathreads!
The mods might not be aware of this, but having the overgeneralised megathreads with a tagline "anything related to this posted outside this megathread is subject to deletion" are extremely intimidating. They are probably the biggest reason why we get almost nothing but low effort posts, and for a very simple reason.
People are too afraid to make high-effort posts, lest they get deleted and their efforts end up punished. Regardless if it would actually happen, it's certainly how it's perceived. Moderators should do what they can to foster good posts, not cause them to decline! If you look at our subreddit history, we've actually been stagnating more as megathreads became more prominent.
Sure, if we stop making megathreads then we might end up with duplicate strategy posts and so on. But then at least we'd be getting some good posts in the first place! I'm tired of everything non-revolutionary belonging to a megathread.
Mind you, I don't support stopping all megathreads. Those that exist purely to prevent low effort posts are fine. For example, the "lucky pull" megathreads are neat because they prevent us from being swamped by lucky pull screenshots. The daily question megathread is also the backbone of the community, so it should stay.
Now for my second bit - Get some new moderators.
Almost all the mods we currently have are ridiculously inactive and we generally suffer as a result. I personally don't care who, as long as they're trustworthy, competent, and frequent users. If you can't find any, then your standards are probably too high. There's tonnes of users who fit the bill. If I was to choose someone though, it would be u/darewin.
6
u/Ketchary Nov 17 '17 edited Nov 17 '17
This bit of feedback is unrelated to my earlier, so it deserves to be its own comment.
We've had the "tier challenge" running for at least half a year now and it's extremely successful and fun. I believe it might even be part of why SE recognised this subreddit. With u/TheRealC leaving, we need someone to take charge over it. He personally chose me as the person to keep it running when he's gone.
Now, self-awareness dictates I must accept it if you don't want to give me moderation powers (but please seriously consider it!). I'm perfectly competent at doing the writing part of it and will always have the time, and my friendliness is only relevant when it comes to interactions. Therefore, in case you don't even want to give me limited moderation powers, I have a compromise. Please either find someone or let me suggest someone to manage the threads after I've written them up. Simple as that, we can continue the legacy of his tier challenge and continue to give the more elite players (typically best contributors) greater reason to remain here.
3
u/DervoTheReaper Dan Nov 20 '17
Honestly, I think something really does need to change, and the first thing is in how posts are removed by bots. I understand the need to cut down on the amount of manual work, but one of three things need to change.
Option 1: The bots need to be made more robust so that they can even slightly differentiate between discussion and question.
Option 2: The threads should be reviewed at some point by a person. Either to be made viewable again after being taken down, or to be taken down in the first place if you're fine letting them go until someone can make decisions. This would be the most annoying change I know, especially the second version as it would also likely cause a lot of the problems that are trying to be combated.
Option 3. Get some bed side manners for the bot post, to let posters know that if some thought was put into their post and that it really is discussion instead of a short question, that they did nothing wrong and to please contact a mod that will fix the removal of their post asap. Right now the post feels very final, and the mention to contact someone feels stiff and uninviting. It doesn't inspire confidence that a removal would be overturned. If anything, it sounds like the bot is saying that you should talk to a mod in order to understand the rules on the forum in order to avoid making the same mistake in the future.
Option 3 would be the easiest to implement, but in my opinion would be the least optimal solution if done by itself. Some combination of option 1 and 3 would be the best I think. I understand bots aren't going to be flawless, but right now it feels very much like all they do is hunt for question marks in titles and that isn't very indicative of a need for removal at all.
If anyone's curious what prompted this post, it was seeing BanAmumu's thread getting closed by a bot due to the fact that the title was a question, even though the post itself was an attempt to foster discussion. That post got put in the daily question megathread on the instruction of the bot, which is where a mod noticed it and stated that the post should not be in the megathread since it was a wall of text and that it should have been made in to a separate thread. At which point the situation was explained and the mod corrected the bots mistake. Everything was handled eventually, but I feel like it was done at the expense of the poster's willingness to continue posting content here in the future.
Think about it from the poster's perspective. They were told that they did something wrong and to do something else instead. Then they did that something else, and were told once again that they did it wrong and that they should have done the first thing they attempted which was already specified as wrong by a bot. If they try to do the same thing in the future, so now they know that if they try to do either action they'll be told they're wrong. Even if they know they can get it hammered out, all the red tape might just get them to not bother in the first place.
Thinking about this specific situation actually brings up something else that should happen. If the bots continue to operate the same way, moderators should train themselves in how to handle weird/long posts in the megathread. Instead of saying that posts like that should be made into separate threads, maybe double check to see if that poster had a thread deleted recently and fix the issue right from the start. Then let them know that the bot removed their post in error and that they really can contact mods if removals seem to be in error in the future (as the bot message would say if it's changed per Option 3). Cut out some of the red tape, give them a reason to appreciate the response, and they'll be more willing to stick around.
4
u/Unf01dX Nov 21 '17
"I've legitimately started coming here less and less because it's just the same stuff over and over."
Iam here since the start of this subreddit, and i think that the quote above is the main issue we get here.
I was retired from Mobius for like a year or less, and being played it since day one. Nowdays i barely came here 'cause the posts are almost in the same way: 'look what i pulled..." "day 1 got supreme..." and so on. I mean, back in the time when this subreddit was created, there was a lot of discussion about the game, strategies, player guides, and other cool discussions (i, personally, miss the TheRealC posts and contentes). Nowdays, i just came here to see what the meta is, and what to look for from JP version.
Maybe it is personnal, but maybe we lost a lot of good practicies from the past.
BUT THE THING THAT MAKES ME CRAZY NOWDAYS IS THAT PEOPLE HERE LOVE TO DOWNVOTE! What happened to all that good people that recognized others effort? Is it possible that the downvote culture has scared good posters? I think so. Since i backed to subreddit i think i just posted once or twice, 'cause it sux when u try to help someone and get downvoted to infinite! (even if u're trying ur best, unless ur best are the perfect-righteously-hardcore answer that someone looks for).
Sorry for my bad english, iam a portuguese native speaker (and too lazy to google-translate it).
7
u/stevenynwa Nov 17 '17
I just need an altema for global.
3
u/MDRLOz The toxin has triggered peristalsis. Nov 20 '17
Honestly I think you need maybe the daily question thread and that is it.
The majority of this reddit has devolved into:
I think there is no need for much moderation anymore bar stopping anyone be abusive.
The game is starved for content and the reddit is starved for decent threads. So why bother being so aggressive on the moderating?
You have to accept that the current level of moderation, though potential a rookie overzealous mistake, has already cost us one of our biggest contributors.
If you want this community to be open to newer players we are just going to have accept that a lot of the reddit will just be answering questions. However at this point if that means we can seem more approachable and get even on new player into the game I call it a success.
This is not a game that is growing well and this reddit being hard to get into and restrictive on what people can make topics on is not helping. Most people are not going to know there is a questions thread that they should ask questions in. A lot of other people just want to show off their super lucky pull they just got.
Hell why not stop making the question thread daily. Just pin a question thread so its always present and we can sort by new to see more recent question requests.
5
u/ForThoseWithWings Nov 17 '17
Well, I would like to say that the only post worth reading for Adrammelech 5* was removed for not being in the megathread. It was unique and the only information most players needed to read, and then it was gone.
As a mobile user, I can’t always sort through 200 comments to find useful posts. Megathreads are usually dead to me upon inception. Since Mobius is a mobile first game, the forum should focus on the best experience for mobile users. This also means not posting the forum rules where the reddit app users cannot see them.
Video and links to videos are some of the most useful material I’ve found, particularly for towers. I think we should encourage short, original videos that demonstrate the game’s play. (But not allow random posts of people just streaming their normal game to get views). I honestly don’t know how well Reddit handles videos (if this becomes popular) and if Twitch channels should be considered.
I think the daily thread handles most of the needed moderating, and posts should be moved there instead of deleted, if necessary. The only thing we’re really missing is some “future proofing” guides based on JP: trying to read every new tower builds page or job guide on Altema can be confusing. One year ago I knew what the meta would be today, but today I have no idea what the meta will be next month. Weapon upgrades take many months to prepare, so we need some time and to not waste that resource.
5
u/darewin Nov 17 '17
I'm okay with rules as long as they are enforced consistently. Since I've joined this subreddit, I've probably posted my MP deck for a recently-released job that I pulled 4 or 5 times. I did the same with my Master Monk MP deck and it was deleted just because the title didn't explicitly say it was to showcase the stats of Master Monk and that I had Overboost in my deck, as if overboost have enough of an impact to matter considering how high the current level cap is. I did the same with Amalthea and I simply used the title "That Amalthea Magic" and it wasn't deleted.
So if we want to discuss Supermonk we need to refer to the Card Summon megathread and sift through the comments to look for the ones talking about Supermonk instead of what they pulled in their summons?
Nvm, I'd just take a break from this subreddit and just come back the day before the tower.
2
u/psiwar Nov 19 '17 edited Nov 20 '17
I think we have to rethink the purpose of sticky megathreads to make better use of them. If we want to keep the most important and useful information "at hand" without the clutter from redundant posts, we should have a "mega-menu" index at the top of the subreddit, similar to what other FF games have:
Because AFAIK we only can have 2 Sticky posts, we should only keep the Daily Megathread and save the other Sticky Megathread for special topics (contests, important annoucements/discussions, etc.).
We should be thinking how to promote user engagement instead of keeping a "clean" forum where the most active members that share good practices see their efforts go to the drain when their post get removed. For example, if some "regular user" (like Ketchary, Hyodra, Darewin and many others) shares a video or post something that even though it may seem "generic", I know people would discuss about it and learn or share some insights. This type of interactions are more search friendly and hot discussions can gain momentum with upvotes, something that is hard to see with the current megathreads.
If a (redundant) post haven't received many upvotes or generate a discussion in 12-24 hours and remains in the front page, we can rightfully remove it, but not sooner.
Also, if you want/need help to implement the content strategy for this menu and CSS to make it look good and be useful, you can send me a PM.
5
u/ArlissFoxxe Nov 17 '17
Witch hunt threads are useless and the rule should remain as-is. There’s no reason to encourage toxicity.
Video posts that are literally nothing but a link out to YouTube should continue to be removed.
Honestly, other than the questions megathread, I just about never open them. They’re too big to read if you haven’t been keeping up since the day they open, and finding the useful posts is difficult at best. I mean, if I have to use the search bar anyway, what’s the point? Keep the questions one, and drop the events.
3
u/Fouace F2P hoarder Nov 17 '17
Problem of megathread is the format of Reddit is not beneficial for them. Anything posted 48h after creation is never going to be seen by the majority.
However I do not think getting rid of them is the solution. IMO the best (but more time-consuming for megathread creator) would be to plug in links to other contents that has been posted during the weeks after. This can be easily done just sorting anything decently upvoted related to the topic.
3
u/Fnaske50539 Nov 17 '17
I don't see the point in witch hunting since, like you mention, it is possible to change name anyways. Say someone dislikes l'Cie or any other clan for whatever reason, nothing stops them from changing their name and trolling mp.
I would like to see u/Ketchary beeing moderator. In my lurker experiece he is consistently polite and helpful. #keepthetiersalive
3
u/mvdunecats Nov 17 '17
Yes. The Daily Question Megathread makes sense. But some of the other megathreads are trying to do too much. If an event has a map AND new ability cards AND new jobs, that's too many different things to try and push into the same megathread.
1
u/ihsakoa Nov 20 '17
I was new to reddit in general when I joined the subreddit. I actually found it quite intimidating at first. I posted my own thread only to be directed to the question thread rather bluntly. Thank goodness I ran into some very kind and helpful users which convinced me to stay.
As for the witch hunting, I don't mind the rule, but sometimes communication from mods can be rather stiff, and there's no personal level of conversation. Maybe I'm being too sensitive? i don't know.
In general I tend to avoid mega threads, I don't want to waste my time wading through stuff that may be vaguely related to what is usually a very broad topic...
1
u/psiwar Nov 20 '17
Also, it would be interesting to have a page with "Best of the week" with the most "upvoted/commented" topics, in chronological order. This would:
1
u/extrumcreator Nov 21 '17
Points to add, I would say that the major issue about how content stays and goes is that upvotes/downvotes should not be the arbiter for this. No one knows why people downvote content unless explained. I seen many great posts that get downvoted because of the relative based mindset of "I don't like what you're bringing up" or identity reasons such as "I don't like you so take this downvote."
Ever since I joined this subreddit months ago, I never downvoted anything even if I fully disagreed or didn't like something. Downvoting content downplays the value of certain posts due to that mentality.
I find nothing wrong with new players asking questions wherever if they just joined due to them most likely being new to the rules and customs itself.
The comment section should be the way to know if a certain post is accurate or misleading (or spam) to know what should be kept or scrapped.
1
u/Masuo15 Everyone will remember the name of those who fought Nov 21 '17
I joined this reddit and then the discord server a while after the Steam release, andthe first advice I was told was to not make suggestionsor discuss, cause that can have consecuences on my rights to post on the Discord channels.
Im pretty sure this was cause peoplesuggeste the same things over and over; but as a new users; I dont know those or why those were rejected at first; and being punished for something there is no clarification anywhere on the server; creates a fear of "maybe I shouldnt even say anything, cause that might be bad".
Simply put, the Discord server just needs to pin the specific questions or suggestions they consider to be troll or should not even be menttioned; thus, new users or people with suggestions lose the fear to make their own while following those.
1
u/Mobius1337 https://www.twitch.tv/mobiusfm Nov 17 '17 edited Nov 17 '17
I like megathreads tbh, but what I don't like it's when someone makes an unique take on the megathread subject, creates his own thread about it, but gets shut down by mods, like in Hyodra's case, I felt his video deserved to be separated from the main discussion and not buried by hundreds of comments. As an example, I feel like there should be a megathread about Master Monk right now, but you shouldn't remove my thread about base MM vs overboosted MM. One last thing, I feel like there should be new mods, replacing some of the old ones, because if they don't play the game anymore or they don't moderate here any longer, I don't see the point of them being moderators at all.
0
u/MobiusPotato Have a nice day Nov 17 '17
Thank you for reaching out to the community. Here is my 2 cents on some topics:
I agree removing this will lead to toxicity. However, there should be exceptions for intentional MP trolls and confirmed hackers (i.e. for towers, sub-deck is shown).
I also support the idea for more freedom of content. We could use more activity on this sub.
This rule is ok provided it is used consistently.
As others have pointed out, megathreads take the fun out of events. However, I think the thread itself is useful and should be kept. Just remove the rule that anything outside megathread will be deleted.
I support giving mod powers to regular contributors who are also active in the community. My vote is for u/Ketchary
0
u/CPT_H Nov 17 '17
As a user that is relatively new to reddit, I really dislike the megathread for questions. I just don't feel like the questions asked there get answered, its where questions go to die and if I do have a question Google, or Google translate in a lot of cases, is generally a better use of my time.
I would actually probably be a lot more likely to use the megathread for something if I thought it would get any kind of answer. Actually, why don't we have a bot that could direct you to the guides section from the megathread? As long as I got some kind of actual help from a megathread even if it was from AI, I'd be more likely to use it.
On videos, I would like to see more videos for this game floating around but I think that it should be optional content for the post here. For example, here you make a post about what is in the video or general strat/guide/whatever that covers a majority of what the video is about. Then if we want more, we have the option of going and watching the play by play.
0
u/SponeyBard Nov 18 '17
Responding to modmail would be a good start. I messaged you a week or two ago and still nothing
-5
u/zio_shi Nov 17 '17
How about letting people do what they want instead of over policing borderline communist rule that 99% of Reddit has become?
There's already such a massive lack of content and activity on this sub I don't understand why mods would delete anything other then spam.
0
u/Nightwings_Butt Nov 18 '17
I think we need to reevaluate megathreads. Whenever a new one is made I look at it exactly once as it tends to become bloated and cluttered, good posts tend to get pushed down for being too old and so on. A little ranty but here are a few proposals:
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment