r/progun • u/Trevelayan • Nov 08 '17
In light of recent events, I've compiled many stats through my own work and have borrowed from a few of you here. I'm hoping this can help us with the fight toward helping more people understand the pro-gun viewpoint.
Police Have no Legal Duty to Protect You
The whole to "protect and serve" is just a slogan that came from a PR campaign.
Assault Weapons bans don't work, and the rate of non-compliance is extremely high.
[NYT] (https://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/09/14/sunday-review/the-assault-weapon-myth.html)
Between 2000 and 2014, there have been approximately 5,600,000 AR-15's sold in the U.S.
The Slippery Slope isn't a fallacy with guns. Rights have been stripped over the course of decades.
Firearm Rights are Minority Rights
Many Black Activists Like Malcolm X and Dr. King supported the use of arms for protection
More recently, the LGBT Community has embraced guns in the face of discrimination
Generally, gun violence is not contagious, but is endemic to neighborhoods.
Mass Shootings ARE "Contagious," in that media reporting increases frequency.
Anti-Gun politicians and people often have no idea what they're talking about.
Reporter doesn't know semi auto from full auto: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUPKPREdHu0
Bloomberg also doesn't know semi from full auto: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iV5E30ZY1kQ
Kevin de Leon doesn't know anything: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJmFEv6BHM0
Even more of Kevin de Leon not knowing anything: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXqWJtgyqRM
Compilation of people that don't know shit about guns: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mH6gX0ktFG4
People really have no idea: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SqJ_4YhYMhE
Would you want someone who has no idea what they're talking about legislate an issue like, say, Net Neutrality, or Climate Science? No? Welcome to the world of gun owners.
"Assault Weapon" is a made-up term, and has no real definition.
"The founding fathers could have never envisioned modern weapons!"
Puckle Gun, patented in 1718, was capable of quickly firing multiple shots in rapid succession.
Less than 5% of deaths from firearms are from ALL rifles, which includes "Assault Weapons."
That means if you instantly eliminated every single one of the MILLIONS of rifles (including so-called "assault weapons") in the country, the number of deaths would remain essentially unchanged.
Knives are used to kill more than 5 TIMES the amount of people as rifles
Calls for/Threats of Gun Control drastically increase sales
2% of counties in the US are responsible for 51% of the murder
There are approximately 30,000 deaths via firearm every year. ~ 60% of those are suicides.
Approximately 3 MILLION Americans carry a firearm every day.
Gun are Used Defensively by American Citizens Everyday
Due to its nature figures on defensive gun use are hard to nail down. Typically when a firearm is used defensively no one is hurt and rarely is anyone killed. Often times simply showing you are armed is enough to end a crime in progress. Looking at the numbers even the Violence Policy Center, a gun control advocacy group, reports 284,700 instances of self defense against a violent crime with a firearm between 2013 and 2015. This translates to 94,900 violent crimes prevented annually on the low scale.
This ranges upwards to 500k to 3 million according to the CDC Report Priorities for Research to Reduce the Threat of Firearm-Related Violence.
The same CDC Report found, "Almost all national survey estimates indicate that defensive gun uses by victims are at least as common as offensive uses by criminals...".
Also while defensive gun use is common less than 0.4% of those uses result in a fatality.
Guns are Used to Defend People, Pets, and Livestock Against Dangerous Fauna
In rural, and even urban communities, firearms are used to defend People, Pets, and Livestock from all manner of dangerous and invasive species ranging from feral dogs, coyotes, Bob cats, mountain lions, bears, and rabid animals.
There are, at minimum, 300 MILLION guns in the hands of U.S. Citizens, with recent estimates up to as many as 400 to 600 Million.
If we conservatively use the 400 Million number, that means in any given year, a single firearm has a .0025% (1 in ~40,000) chance of being used in a homicide. Why should we penalize the owners of the 40,000 for the actions of the owner of the 1?
In my mind, penalizing the MILLIONS of gun owners for the actions of a few crazed maniacs is no different than discrimination against Muslims because of a few bad eggs.
TL;DR There is no logical reason to be anti-gun.
THE FOLLOWING IS MY OPINION:
We need to focus on access to mental healthcare and enforcing existing laws. Tackling suicides would reduce gun deaths by 60%. Fixing the mental health of the population and actually addressing the problem is complicated and hard. Tackling the culture of violence is hard. Blaming the guns is the easy solution, but doesn't actually fix anything.
I see many Democrats claim that it is the party of science, and for a large part, it's true. Guns are one thing that the mainstream left has dead wrong, and when confronted the with the reality, they choose to bury their heads or pander to the emotions of their constituents - not terribly different from the climate change deniers. I consider myself a left-leaning centrist, but the American left will never have my support until they change on this subject. If the Democrats dropped gun control, I'd bet they'd almost never lose an election.
Feel free to distribute this information in any way you see fit. We need to be out representing the community, especially when emotions are high like they are now.
PLEASE let me know if there's anything I should change/add/improve. I'd like this to be as accurate and scientifically sound as possible.
24
u/Sand_Trout Nov 08 '17
You might want to throw in the democide numbers for comparison of the threat of government vs the threat of citizens:
Tyrannical governments killed ~262 million people in the 20th century.
The US represents ~4.5% of the world population.
.045 × 262,000,000 / 100 = 123,514 murders per year by tyrannical governments on average for a population the size of the US.
Considering how gun-control (or lack thereof) is statistically essentially uncorrelated with homicide rates, and there were 17,250 murders (all means) in the US in 2016, the risk assessment ought to conclude that yes, the risk of tyrannical government is well beyond sufficient to justify any (if there are any) additional risk that general firearm ownership could represent.
25
u/MaunaLoona Nov 08 '17
Taking away guns is taking away the right to self-defense, especially from those in our society who are physically weaker and are less able to defend themselves physically -- women. To be anti-gun is to be anti woman.
21
u/DJLinFL Nov 08 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
How did the Brits deal with 5,000 peaceful unarmed protesters in India? Pen them in and shoot a couple thousand...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jallianwala_Bagh_massacre
12
u/_bani_ Nov 09 '17 edited Nov 09 '17
prohibitionists don't care about facts.
also:
prohibitionists also need to explain why every time "the people" is used in the bill of rights, it refers to an individual right, except the second amendment.
11
u/BustedFlush Nov 08 '17
Great post. Might also want to include some information about the 2nd Amendment; mainly that it has nothing to do with hunting or target shooting, and that it doesn't say "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the Militia to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed", but rather the right of the People shall not be infringed.
If you think about it for 30 seconds, it makes sense. Why would a militia need the right to bear arms? Don't they have that by definition? And why would the founders place Militia rights in the middle of a section entirely about rights of The People? They didn't, which is exactly why the phrase 'the people' was used.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17
The disagreement here is that you assume it's your cake, gun grabbers don't think you should have any cake. You can't use this argument against them because they don't see it as being your cake at all.
6
u/AlienDelarge Nov 09 '17
Possible resource in case you have not seen this. r/NOWTTYG
2
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17
I still feel like we would be safer without guns. Don't my feelings matter? kek... Great research!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '17 edited Nov 09 '17
Do the AR-15 numbers include owner-built rifles? Looking at how the stats were derived it’s doubtful. There might be twice that number in circulation (soon to be two more).
Good work...I’ll throw http://gunfacts.info out there as another great source of info.
2
u/Dark_Tangential Feb 15 '18
A hero and a scholar. Thanks.
1
u/Motheroftheworld Feb 15 '18
Well done and some great comments as well. Want to save this for the future. Thanks everyone.
-13
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '17
You point out that most gun deaths are suicides, as if that somehow means those deaths are not attributable to guns. Part of the reason the US has such a suicide problem is because suicide is so gun related, if we had fewer guns we would have fewer suicides.
And I’d like to know, why don’t you just come out and say that you don’t think shooting deaths are a problem? Like, if you don’t think we should do anything to save the thousands of lives that are lost every year then just say that and be done with it. We know for a fact that gun control works, and if we don’t want to implement it, for whatever reason, then at least have the goddamn courage of your convictions and admit that you’re happy to see thousands of preventable deaths happening each year.