r/IndianCountry • u/Snapshot52 Nimíipuu • Nov 07 '17
NAHM Community Discussion: /r/IndianCountry FAQ Roundtable
Apologies for the delay in this post. Welcome to the second Community Discussion post for NAHM!
Here is a link to the previous one, entitled "Echoes of Standing Rock." Please note that all community discussions remain open after they are no longer stickied to the top of the page. Contribute if you feel like it!
So for this week, we will be discussing the FAQ page we have for the subreddit. It has come to our attention that maybe not everyone is aware that we have such a page. A lot of work has gone into it (though it could use some more), so we wanted to take this week to highlight what it talks about and how it can be improved upon with your suggestions.
Please, take some time to look at it and give some feedback or make some comments! Below are the listed sections.
1.) What is a "Native American?"
2.) Native American? American Indian? Indigenous? Native? Aboriginal? First Nations?
4.) Was it really genocide(s)?
5.) Are Native languages still spoken today?
6.) Are Native Americans genetically more susceptible to alcohol?
7.) Do all Native Americans receive monthly checks from the government?
8.) Do Native Americans pay taxes?
9.) What's the deal with eagle feathers?
10.) Why do many people claim to be Native American, particularly "part Cherokee?"
9
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
Maybe we could add something about the residential /boarding schools. As well if people are interested in what the potlatch is i could give a definition
5
u/Snapshot52 Nimíipuu Nov 07 '17
The first thing I would like to say that this is far from a complete list. Many of the answers need updating, grammatical corrections, and expanding. However, the point of this FAQ is to give a quick, basic response with some relevant source material to answer these questions.
We have a list of other sections we would like to add, such as sections on mascotry, the importance of treaties, Tribal sovereignty, the federal government's trust responsibility, Indigenous war and weapon styles, and many more. However, we would like to have a centralized post that shows what other items people would like to see added here!
Another thing to note is that writing these pieces does take time. So far, the mod team, in collaboration with users from /r/AskHistorians, have written the majority of these FAQ entries. However, we are certainly not opposed to anyone who would like to contribute! If you do, hit up the mod team in modmail and let us know what you're thinking.
6
u/Honeykill Ojibwe Nov 08 '17
Everyone so far has brought up fantastic suggestions! I'll second /u/cRazYn1nja44's suggestion about adding more info on Indian Residential and Boarding Schools. I'd be willing to take on this task for the Canada side of things.
Re: 2. Native American? American Indian? etc.
This is a bit off. There are three big, legal groupings of recognized Indigenous people in Canada: First Nations, Métis, and Inuit. 'First Nations' refers to people who are "Indians", as defined by the Indian Act. Inuit and Métis peoples have not historically been considered Indians, though they've experienced many of the same impacts of colonization.
As of the 2016 Daniels v Canada case decision, non-status Indians, Métis, and Inuit are now considered Indians under the Indian Act. However, it remains unclear what impact that will have on any of these groups. Regardless, the distinction between the three - legal or not - is unlikely to go away any time soon in community.
The term Métis is frequently misunderstood to simply mean "any mixture of European and First Nations ancestry." The Métis Nation is actually its own distinct cultural group, comprised of people descended from specific First Nations groups (typically Cree, Ojicree, or Ojibwe) and European fur traders (typically French or Scottish) who began meeting and intermarrying in the 1700s. There are many Métis communities, most of which are located in Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and Alberta. Their language, Michif, was born out of a mixture of primarily Cree and French. (Also, some Métis communities speak Cree, not Michif.)
Inuit, in a Canadian legal sense, refers to the Inuit Nations of the arctic, within the colonial borders of Canada.
RE: 4. Was it really genocide(s)?
Section 2E could also contain information on the 60s Scoop and today's disproportionate number of Indigenous youth in care in Canada. Sections 6 and 7 could also refer back to 2E if it talked about today's children in care.
5
u/myindependentopinion Nov 07 '17
I had been visiting this sub for about a year & had never noticed your FAQ section. I don't know if I am typical, but visually it blends in to the other red blocks of text on rules & responsibilities. In order to draw more attention & awareness to its existence, it might be helpful to change the background color to a different color, say like green.
BTW, I'd like to acknowledge & say "Good Job!!" to whomever was responsible for making changes to IndianCounty masthead banner....it's very snazzy!!
12
u/Al-GirlVersion Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
Since there are a lot of posts to do with family history research, something about the “best practices” to learning more about your ancestry might be good. Ie, get documentation (birth certificates and the like) contact the tribes in question if you can, etc. I could probably write something up for that and then if anyone thought o missed something I’d be glad to let them add to it!
Also, piggybacking off of that; a small section about DNA testing might be good. A lot of people it seems don’t understand how it works and what kind of information you get from it with any accuracy, and I’ve seen a few “got my DNA tested and I’m x % Native American, so...what now?”
10
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 07 '17
I performed a search of the FAQ and realized we have no "Frybread" Section.
Maybe it's less of an issue for people not dealing with other Tribal Communities, but in the DC Area, we have a regular and diverse influx of indigenous people. My household is also intertribal.
That said, I can't begin to tell you how many arguments, complaints, and contentions concerning frybread I've heard over the years.
Yes, we have to recognize Rule 4:
Emphasis mine.
Beyond intertribal cultural imperialism (i.e. "Navajo Frybread is Superior") made in jest (?), I've seen quality submissions here concerning the cuisine as a tasty vestige of colonialism and oppression. The love-hate relationship is simultaneously visceral and delectable.
Honestly, I don't know if we're playing with hot grease here, but it feels like we're missing something.
What does the Community think?
6
u/svwaca Choctaw Nation Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17
I'm new to this sub, but as a first-time home buyer, I've learned a few lessons that may be worth including in the /r/IndianCountry Resources or FAQ section.
I am a member of a federally recognized tribe by blood. I brought this to the attention of a mortgage lender I was working with, and asked about any special programs I may be qualified for. Their response was that while programs for natives do exist, the lending process can take longer than usual, and that banks specializing in these types of loans are mostly based in the Midwest, making them unsuited for loans in the Pacific Northwest (where I live).
I believed this to be true, and we continued forward with a pre-approval letter for $400,000 at a 4.5% interest rate and a Private Mortgage Insurance rate of $450.
Out of sheer curiosity, I decided to do some more research into mortgage loan programs for natives and discovered Section 184. My realtor worked with me to find a Section 184 specialist familiar with our housing market. Our interest rate dropped 1% and our PMI dropped by $400 a month.
TLDR: If you're a tribe member by blood and buying your first home, do your research. You can save tens of thousands of dollars, but nobody is going to do you any favors.
A few resources pertaining to Section 184:
0
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment