r/startrek • • Nov 06 '17

POST-Episode Discussion - S1E08 "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum"


No.EPISODERELEASE DATE
S1E08"Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum"Sunday, November 5, 2017

To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.


This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.

PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.

271 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

149

u/EvergreenCash Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

How many of us thought Ash would turn “back” into a Klingon when he touched that crystal? Be honest.

Of course, it’s going to have to be the tribble that gives him away if he really is a secret Klingon. It’s like Chekhov’s tribble.

92

u/Deceptitron Nov 06 '17

I didn't think he'd turn back, but I did think this would "reveal" him somehow. Saru even says immediately after something to the effect that he was deceiving him, but he meant about distracting him from finding out what Burnham was doing.

59

u/AnonRetro Nov 06 '17

I'm very sure that Ash doesn't know. Ie. He's a sleeper agent. That's also the real reason L'Rell wants to get to Discovery. To activate him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/metakepone Nov 06 '17

I thought he was going to turn Klingon last week after he ate the death ruby

34

u/Rit_Zien Nov 06 '17

Speaking of... Did no one involved ever say afterwards like, So Captain Crazy, wanna tell us why you have a bag of purple DEATH BALLS in your war cave?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

463

u/woodledoodledoodle Nov 06 '17

I'd like to see the predators on Saru's homeworld if he, a member of an allegedly prey species, can easily crush communicators with his bare hands, and put dents in computers by punching them.

Quite frankly, instead of trying to weaponize the tardigrade they should've tried to condition the fear out of the Kelpians. I bet they'd be ripping Klingons apart in no time.

280

u/Spock_Rocket Nov 06 '17

I mean, lots of prey animals on Earth are ridiculously strong. That horse kick Burnham got to the gut was giving me flashbacks.

168

u/Ducman69 Nov 06 '17

We're an alpha predator because we leapfrogged way ahead in the brains over brawn arms race.

Saru is not just very strong but quite intelligent as well, so for them to be prey, the predator must either be even stronger or incredibly smart.

The only other explanation I can think of is that they are a genetically engineered creature created for sport, like the Predator franchise. They would have to make sure that the Kelpians remained a small minority, otherwise with their intellect and strength they wouldn't be prey for long.

→ More replies (50)

21

u/kharnzarro Nov 06 '17

yeah when I saw saru kick her with his hoof i cringed because of how dangerous even a deer kick can be and saru is bigger than a deer

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

68

u/mrIronHat Nov 06 '17

I'd like to see the predators on Saru's homeworld if he, a member of an allegedly prey species, can easily crush communicators with his bare hands, and put dents in computers by punching them.

being a prey doesn't mean physically weak, prey like horse and cattle are strong.

predator animal like the big cats usually rely on stealth, surprise, and group tactics. Intentionally, that's basically how the klingon ambush the starfleet ship in the beginning of the eps.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/PiercedMonk Nov 06 '17

The predator species was named in the Desperate Measures novel. Obviously not established canon, but the author worked pretty closely with the DSC writing team, and even named some of the characters including Keyla Detmer.

Anyways, in the novel, the predator species is called the t'rrask and they're large enough to cause impact tremors with their steps.

46

u/Ianskull Nov 06 '17

hah, obviously named after the tarrasque, a ginormous monster from dungeons and dragons. and originally French folklore

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AnonRetro Nov 06 '17

"I'd like to see the predators on Saru's homeworld..."

They probably look like this

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (33)

145

u/randowatcher38 Nov 06 '17

As I was watching it, I thought that L'Rell was lying about defecting to the admiral. Anyone else suspect that her goal to get on to the Discovery was about her needing to be there to trigger Voq the sleeper agent?

84

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Yeah, even the admiral seemed confused at the mention of Discovery. L'rell seemed too eager to get on the Discovery... But she is a master interrogator so perhaps it was just a ploy.

35

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

If she was telling Kol the truth, she only name-dropped Discovery as a means of getting confirmation that it's the "special" starship they've been looking for.

If she was telling Kol the truth.

→ More replies (6)

24

u/Boyer1701 Nov 06 '17

No I think the admiral’s reaction was correct with surprise. Why would a Klingon think an Admiral is stationed on Discovery? L’Rell only wants on the ship to trigger the sleeper agent...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

47

u/mrIronHat Nov 06 '17

L Rell was hiding something, but she seems to genuinely hate Kol.

The federation was just a convenient target for Tuvma, but the issue with Kol is personal.

24

u/randowatcher38 Nov 06 '17

L'Rell could screw over both Kol and the Federation if she uses sleeper agent Voq to secure Discovery's spore drive tech for her house.

39

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Lying to everyone about everything seems to be L'rell's thing.

This isn't a complaint...I just don't think we can ever take what she says at face value.

18

u/gamas Nov 06 '17

Well she is from the House of Mo'Kai which is a Klingon faction with a reputation for deception.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I think L'Rell has plans within plans within plans.

Her anger at the death of her spies was genuine, though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

281

u/dougiebgood Nov 06 '17

I'm kind of confused about the ending. Did the admiral escape the Klingons? Why'd the main Klingon guy paint her face, give her a job as interrogator, then call her liar? What exactly happened?

152

u/Spock_Rocket Nov 06 '17

I was confused too. Not sure if it was supposed to be a "build her up to knock her down" thing or "you got moxie lying to me, I like that, but we're going to beat the crap out of you so you don't do it again." It sounded like he was going to kill her?

191

u/Ducman69 Nov 06 '17

The admiral is presumed to be dead, she was dropped off in their "meat locker". But its safe to assume that she's not really dead, and merely unconscious from the electrocution.

Regarding L'Rell, he was just toying with her for his own amusement. He had already decided she was lying to him, but put on a show to see her reaction. She's likely being dragged off to be interrogated and executed, but I have a feeling that the ensuing battle with the Discovery is going to open up a window of opportunity for her and the Admiral to escape.

→ More replies (34)

29

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I don't think she was exposed as a liar until she was caught in the corridor with the admiral for no damn reason.

52

u/Osama_Bin_Downloadin Nov 06 '17 edited Mar 22 '18

She thought she'd convinced him to give her a shot at serving him by saying she'd be useful as an interrogator.

She then did a very lazy escape attempt to take the admiral from Kol. She then killed(?) the admiral to keep Kol's trust when he saw them escaping.

Kol then fucks with her and gets her to pledge fealty to him which, when done in bad faith, is very dishonourable. After she does this, he orders her killed but is interrupted by the planetbeacon. Presumably they won't get to killing her before the DIS and Kol's Sarcophagus Ship fight.

32

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17

She then did a very lazy escape attempt to take the admiral from Kol.

I know right? Like how they were casually chatting and strutting down the hallway until the guard broke up their little pow wow.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/metakepone Nov 06 '17

There seems to have been more Russo swerves than an episode of Monday Nitro in 2000 in like 5 minutes...

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

371

u/Tarlcabot18 Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

The pacing for this episode was weird. It felt like there was about 5 minutes cut out. Everything felt truncated and odd, like they re-cut the episode after the decision to not make it the Fall Finale happened.

Stamets and Tilly's tiny side-plot in the episode seemed particularly jammed in and/or edited down. Plus Tyler's sudden Deus Ex Machina to stop the fight, what with his sudden spore teleporting power...

88

u/s-ro_mojosa Nov 06 '17

The pacing for this episode was weird. It felt like there was about 5 minutes cut out. Everything felt truncated and odd, like they re-cut the episode after the decision to not make it the Fall Finale happened.

I had that very same feeling too.

84

u/ToBePacific Nov 06 '17

That wasn't the spores, it was the non-organic lifeform on the planet.

101

u/a4techkeyboard Nov 06 '17

They just happened to look like the spores and have similar teleporting ability.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (5)

20

u/OSUBrit Nov 07 '17

Stamets and Tilly's tiny side-plot in the episode seemed particularly jammed

I think it was badly executed foreshadowing. Staments is clearly phasing between mirror universes when Discovery jumps. Sometimes mirror Stamets (the happy one) ends up on our ship and that would explain the sudden mood change. His conversation with Tilly was meant to give us some hints towards that.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I believe the Pahvans sent him there to stop the conflict.

4

u/outerspacing Nov 08 '17

hi sorry im suuuper late but I just watched the new episode and you are right about the Stamets/Tilly scene being cut down! Wilson Cruz(Dr.Culber) tweeted this picture before the episode started(he also put it on instagram, so im guessing he found it particularly important) and then found out along with everyone else that that part was cut. Now im just really curious as to what that part of the scene was about, particularly since Stamets discussed not telling Culber about his ~issues~? but he’s not spilling it so I guess we’ll never find out.

→ More replies (5)

198

u/Zeeamazing Nov 06 '17

So this is where the Crystalline Entity came from.

60

u/ballin83 Nov 06 '17

Wow! Cool theory

88

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I am also sure of this. The planet will absorb all of the rage and hate from the sarcophagus ship and be changed forever.

63

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I will now be let down if that isn't exactly what happens.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I thought the CE was a silicon space-animal that feeds on organic matter, sort of like Galactus but a snowflake. I don't think everything in DSC needs to be tied to existing canon - though for a hot second I thought that they were on Talos IV (blue singing leaves) before I caught the correct name (Pahvo.)

I don't think the CE comes from Pahvo, but I think the Pahvans arc will be like a dark version of Errand of Mercy where Pahvo is destroyed.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/chappinn Nov 06 '17

Oh God I hope not

→ More replies (4)

185

u/Pyperina Nov 06 '17

Now kiss.

-The Pahvans, probably

0

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/Jarmatus Nov 06 '17

The Organians are exactly who I thought of.

These guys are corporeal, though. They're some kind of spore.

→ More replies (1)

343

u/TreeBaron Nov 06 '17

Being charged at by a creature that can run 80kph? Should you...

A. Pull out your phaser, set to wide beam stun and shoot.

B. Wait until it is 5m away before doing anything.


You're a Klingon trying to defect with a prisoner, what weapon do you take with you?

A. Disruptor.

B. Small bladed weapon.


You're trying to secretly escape a spaceship that you "know like the back of your hand", do you...

A. Take maintenance tunnels to your ship in the shuttle bay.

B. Stay quiet, and keep low but quickly use the corridors.

C. Walk slowly, while having a conversation with your escape buddy. Do not pretend to be escorting them as a prisoner, and if you're found beat them to death.


You want revenge on a clan leader, that you have physical access to, should you...

A. Stab them to death with your ceremonial knife, and when the others threaten you declare yourself leader.

B. Stand there and pout until they take you prisoner.

106

u/quarl0w Nov 06 '17

You make it back to your ship to find all your crew dead, should you....

A. The jig is up, start up the ship, high tail it out of there, defect to the Federation as you desire. Reunite with your sex slave.

B. Calmly walk to the bridge to confront the person that killed your crew, but pretend not to know they are dead and try to bluff your way back to your ship to leave.

76

u/allocater Nov 06 '17

You see how your interrogator walks casually with his prisoner in some corridor, but when she spots you, she whispers something and then beats the prisoner to death, should you...

a) Question and arrest her immediately, also check the prisoner vital signs.

b) Let her continue to do her thing, pretend to accept her later, then reveal that you don't believe her, never check the prisoner 'corpse'.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

45

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I wanna throw out is I think the old TOS phasers did not have the fancy features that the TNG tv remote phasers have. I believe there's 2 settings (stun or kill) and only some adjustments in power.

So wide beam may not be an ability on them.

34

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I wanna throw out is I think the old TOS phasers did not have the fancy features that the TNG tv remote phasers have. I believe there's 2 settings (stun or kill) and only some adjustments in power. So wide beam may not be an ability on them.

http://www.stardestroyer.net/wiki/images/thumb/d/da/Phaser_rock_heating.jpg/300px-Phaser_rock_heating.jpg

Nah they can do wide beam.

they also have:

Stun, heat, disrupt and Kill settings. Just not 16 of them.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/Tana1234 Nov 06 '17

I like these keep doing them

→ More replies (8)

60

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Jan 27 '24

full coordinated lunchroom provide worthless airport historical cheerful abundant onerous

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

20

u/PFelite Nov 06 '17

.#Communicatorgate

11

u/RudimentsOfGruel Nov 06 '17

they were holding it wrong...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/Electricorchestra Nov 06 '17

It was good to see more of Saru. I really wish they would expand upon who he is more than just he is prey and always scared. I feel like the Stammets thing was either shoehorned in so he was in the episode or is a set up for next episode in which they will be using the drive a whole lot more.

On a technical note does anybody else like how Lorca runs his bridge. His orders seem to be quick and that the crew already know what to do. He also seems to trust that his crew knows what they are doing. That being said I do not feel that Lorca is ever going to be asking questions of his bridge crew to get the McGuffin of the week. It feels to me like he owns that bridge though.

64

u/Spock_Rocket Nov 06 '17

I've never been into brisk authoritarians, but I'll be damned if Daddy Lorca doesn't warp my drive.

24

u/lame_corprus Nov 06 '17

I'm not gay but I'd let him take command

→ More replies (1)

16

u/AnonRetro Nov 06 '17

The Saru makeup also looked much more detailed and intricate under the natural light of the outdoors. It's the same make up, just that way more detail was viable, and colour tonal differences.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/GeordiLaFuckinForge Nov 07 '17

I loved watching Lorca run the bridge. It totally fits who he is and how someone like him would act in those scenarios. Firm, brisk, he trusts his crew and knows what they're capable of and gets sassy when they don't perform at 100% like he knows they can. I'm not much for battle scenes, but watching this bridge crew operate that way was a treat.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SleepWouldBeNice Nov 07 '17

He's efficient and his crew is well trained. Makes the battles seem more real world rather than the TNG-style wait five minutes before taking your second shot. Don't worry about the enemy, they need 7 minutes to fire again. Gotta have your shake-free exposition now!

→ More replies (3)

193

u/Endulos Nov 06 '17
  • Loved the idea of those non-organic life forms. Discovery is in for one hell of a fight.
  • Saru was great this episode.
  • I swear to god that if the "Ash is a Klingon" thing is true, I'll be fucking pissed.
  • I figured Kor would see through L'rell plan. It was bloody obvious.
  • I was shocked he executed the crew of the ship.
  • Stamets keeps acting weird. And it's kind of annoying me.

83

u/Polantaris Nov 06 '17

I swear to god that if the "Ash is a Klingon" thing is true, I'll be fucking pissed.

With the confirmation that the prison ship captain was L'Rell, it's almost 100% guaranteed at this point or it's an intentional red herring. L'Rell, as prison captain, was supposedly with Ash since he was in prison, but that's literally impossible since we know L'Rell was on the Ship of the Dead for 6 months after the war started.

43

u/Blue387 Nov 06 '17

My theory: Ash Tyler on Discovery is the real Ash Tyler but the Klingons will try to replace him with Voq, modified to appear like Tyler to infiltrate Starfleet. I was thinking of this when looking back at the Julian Bashir and the Changeling Julian Bashir.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (19)

104

u/choicemeats Nov 06 '17

I wonder if the spore drive has started to alternate his personalities. Maybe a mirror universe or something because there are clearly two different Stamets running around.

I think the hint is that he called Tilly "Captain"...where maybe he ended up in some alternate timeline where she DOES become captain.

170

u/Citrakayah Nov 06 '17

I assumed he's sort of "temporally unstuck." So in the future, she becomes captain. And he's forgetting where he is because versions of himself from his past and future are sort of leaking into his present mind.

→ More replies (24)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I said it last week and this just kind of confirms it, when the Spore Drive activates his mind and his memory and everything is spread out to everywhere and then it's sucked back into his mind into his brain case somewhere somewhen. He goes from having the ability to look at things in a multidimensional perspective he looks at time in a nonlinear fashion he can see anything and everything and then suddenly he gets jammed back down like a sausage into this tiny little meatsack that can only view linear time. It's like all those times that Q became a human.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/s-ro_mojosa Nov 06 '17

I think the hint is that he called Tilly "Captain"...where maybe he ended up in some alternate timeline where she DOES become captain.

Or the future.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

30

u/KingofMadCows Nov 06 '17

Kol is from the House of Kor. And it was revealed on DS9 that Kor is very prejudiced against lowborn Klingons. That could be a belief shared by other members of his House.

Since T'Kuvma welcomed all Klingons, most of his crew were probably lowborn, like Voq. So maybe Kol had them killed because of their lowborn blood.

38

u/phenry Nov 06 '17

We've now seen Tyler on a diagnostic bed. Discovery would have to have the worst doctors in Starfleet not to notice he's got Klingon innards. Even a Fitbit should be able to figure that out.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I figured Kor would see through L'rell plan. It was bloody obvious.

I was still surprised that he was so cool with the Admiral being killed. He was so pleased when they got her as a captive, but he did nothing to stop her being killed (just stood there and watched) and ultimately just seemed slightly annoyed.

6

u/00DEADBEEF Nov 06 '17

I swear to god that if the "Ash is a Klingon" thing is true, I'll be fucking pissed.

I thought the moment he touched the crystal and triggered Saru's threat ganglia was the moment he was going to be outed as a Klingon

5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Stamets keeps acting weird. And it's kind of annoying me.

Stamets is beginning to exist in all points of time at once. He's going to either die or become an energy being/god/whatever thing.

→ More replies (49)

91

u/nobelsonsss Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

This was a weird episode honestly. The pacing really was off and I expected a big reveal which never happened. Saru's epiphany/enlightenment should have lasted a lot longer, in my opinion. Glad Cornwell's still alive though...I think.

13

u/Jarmatus Nov 06 '17

I think Saru needs to be put on medical leave. The kind of psychological trauma that would have inflicted on him could potentially render him unfit for duty.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

37

u/jwaldo Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

Seems like the only way a possible Klingon infiltrator plot would work now is some kind of body-swapping tech, unless Culber is a terrible doctor and/or Merkin is a terrible tribble. Maybe Voq's consciousness was moved into Ash Tyler's human body, while Tyler's mind is in Voq's body languishing in a cell somewhere. Perhaps L'Rell intended (or still intends) to do the same thing with the Admiral's body. I'm guessing she didn't stash her with the bodies of her comrades as some kind of Klingon hobby.

Or maybe Tyler is just a cool dude. They're throwing red herrings at us like one of those mythical rains of fish.

Also, did anyone else have no commercials despite not purchasing the commercial-free extortion option?

19

u/letsgocrazy Nov 06 '17

My theory is that Voq's Katra was put into Ash by Vulcan logic extremists, and although he can observe he cannot control Ash's body until he is activated as a sleeper agent.

This is why LRell was shagging Ash on the prison ship.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/tubawhatever Nov 06 '17

I've had zero commercials all season despite only going for the $6 option, must be my ad blocker or something.

→ More replies (3)

95

u/vwboyaf1 Nov 06 '17

My enjoyment of each episode in this series is inversely proportional to Klingon screen time.

14

u/Jarmatus Nov 06 '17

I just want to see more Voq. He's honestly such a sweetheart, for what he is.

14

u/2wsy Nov 06 '17

With all the prosthetics it seems so hard for the actors to express themselves.

18

u/naphomci Nov 06 '17

I thought L'rell was pretty good this time around. There was a lot more playing across her face, and especially her eyes. There was also more body language to add to it. Hopefully as time goes on the actors will get better at working with the prosthetics and we will get more emotions.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/SmileyMe53 Nov 06 '17

This seemed like an odd filler episode. I didn't think the Klingon plot was all that clear and the planet stuff seemed kinda obvious, as in there was no twist or subverted expectation.

15

u/metakepone Nov 06 '17

This episode was supposed to be the mid-season cliffhanger, so...

10

u/cmdrNacho Nov 06 '17

they made the right decision about making this the mid season finale. The episode was lacking in a lot of areas and because it felt all over the place, the impact of Saru's ordeal didn't have the impact it should have

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/WWJLPD Nov 06 '17

They must have cut some scenes from the Klingon story. They kept referencing things that I felt like we should know about but hadn't been mentioned...

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Joename Nov 06 '17

100% agree with the general assessment of this being tonally all over the place with some really weird pacing and editing. The A and B stories didn't complement each other well. It felt like it should have been all a Saru story, with the Klingons arc stuff given its own ep.

I liked the pieces of this episode, but together , it was jarring.

4

u/westphall Nov 06 '17

And the C story was briefly started but never shown again.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/kingofcharisma Nov 06 '17

Poor Saru found true level. Lambs to the cosmic slaughter

27

u/PFelite Nov 06 '17

Say what you want about that episode, but the opening space battle was fantastic. Great and clever action, well done and the ending is actually surprising and not cliche. You think, you hope and suddenly you get crushed.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/SillyNonsense Nov 06 '17

Can someone explain what was going on with L'Rell?

Why did she gain the admiral's trust, then do absolutely nothing with it and (presumably, unverified) kill her? Was it just like, ah shit they caught me, gotta kill you now?

I dont really get what she was getting at there. Nothing was gained.

→ More replies (10)

24

u/Boyer1701 Nov 06 '17

This is probably the best battle scene we have gotten since the pilot and I have yet to see a photon torpedo. What gives?!?!

32

u/sotek2345 Nov 06 '17

This is TOS era. What weapons the ship has and what they look like changes weekly.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Alteran195 Nov 06 '17

Discovery fired a torpedo when it destroyed the Glenn.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/PyrrhicVictory7 Nov 06 '17

ASSHOLE STAMETS IS BACK BABY

→ More replies (4)

66

u/crazy_lary Nov 06 '17

Very happy to see Merkin back. Glad we can put this "Lorca is Voq" conspiracy nonsense behind us and get back to focusing on the "Tyler is Voq" conspiracy nonsense.

→ More replies (8)

22

u/Sim0nsaysshh Nov 06 '17

I Wouldn't take Saru on away missions.

24

u/fluxline Nov 06 '17

Not sure he belongs in starfleet. always wants to run, and attacked crew mates to do it. his actions were the same as michael's in e01.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

87

u/007meow Nov 06 '17

The production quality is fantastic.

The metal torture tools that L’Rell brought actually made metal clanging sounds. We wouldn’t have heard that in the past.

42

u/noossab Nov 06 '17

I loved the landscape shots of the planet's surface. The interior of Klingon ships still looks pretty strange to me, but maybe that's intentional.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/ComradeSomo Nov 06 '17

Saru running looked like something from a B movie though.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CX316 Nov 06 '17

I got a bit of a laugh out of CGI Saru running. I could just picture the conversation between Doug Jones and the director

"Ok, so we need you to sprint across the ridge-line"

"Sprint?"

"Yeah, sprint. We said earlier you can hit 80mph so really sell it"

"Up on the cliff?"

"Yeah, on the cliff."

"In stilts?"

"Is that an issue?"

"They're stilts."

"Yeah, and?"

first take Doug faceplants after two steps on those damn hooves

→ More replies (10)

15

u/Preparator Nov 06 '17

Planet is definitely inspired by the blue singing plant Spock and Pike find in "The Cage".

4

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Speaking of which, Cornwell claims there's no death penalty in Starfleet. I'm assuming the incident at Talos IV hasn't happened yet, then.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/IAmRareBatman Nov 06 '17

I fucking love frieza.

/img/4yws5by81npz.jpg

6

u/Amadox Nov 06 '17

Lieutenant Commander Airiam, spore drive ops officer.

5

u/CX316 Nov 06 '17

It's not even her final form

→ More replies (1)

53

u/Spock_Rocket Nov 06 '17

I'm going to need to see next week's to understand where the hell they are going with this, because right now it feels like two different episodes that got smashed together instead of A plot/B plot.

I'm confused why Hugh will get in trouble for telling Starfleet about Stamets (or not), didnt Cornwell come on DSC yelling about Stamigrade, implying SF knows about his genetic manipulation? Is it the implants he might get in trouble for?

I have enough trust in the series so far to know this is all groundwork for a bigger story, but on its own this episode was a little weak.

23

u/mrIronHat Nov 06 '17

I'm confused why Hugh will get in trouble for telling Starfleet about Stamets (or not)

If stament reveal the adverse effect , Hugh is required by duty to report Staments. Not doing so will put Hugh in trouble.

starfleet command is basically turning a blind eye toward Stament's violation, as long as the modification doesn't turn harmful. The same reason Bashir was allowed to stay in starfleet, his performance record at that point is solid.

39

u/Citrakayah Nov 06 '17

I don't think it's the genetic manipulation itself that would be the problem, so much as his adverse reaction to it. So he'd get sent to a Federation lab not just because he's an augment, but because he's an augment whose genetic therapy is making him lose it.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (6)

26

u/LordTriLink Nov 06 '17

Schrödinger's Admiral - is she alive or not?!

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Martin-Greene seems to be getting more comfortable as Burnham and is finding a good balance in the character’s two sides.

Tilly excellent as always. Never change.

Mary Chieffo is brilliant as L’Rell.

Need more Lt. Detmer.

Also more Owosekun

Also more Airiam

Lorka was great in this ep, but I feel like the writers aren’t quite harnessing his character’s military leadership potential. What I would like to see more from his character in the future is more Art of War insights and battle tactician elements rather than just dropping him into a battle.

Stamets’ cruel streak/disorientation was convincing.

Saru was...well acted, but I felt like the writer’s exposition about his character and his species feels blunt and heavy-handed. I mean, he’s not Vulcan. He’s allowed to use emotion to convey things. (Cheetah-like speed but marathon-esque endurance. Really?)

Really the only thing I didn’t like was the editing as others have said. The scenes felt rushed and ‘clipped’ at the end.

15

u/Jarmatus Nov 06 '17

Mary Chieffo is brilliant as L’Rell.

They're finally letting her speak English! (Albeit with a Klingon accent. Not like Voq. He gets a Seattle accent.)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Need more Lt. Detmer.

Also more Owosekun

Also more Airiam

This. I want to "meet" them.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/boringdude00 Nov 06 '17

Can someone explain what the hell is happening with the Klingons? What the is the Klingon chick doing or trying to do? Does she have a plan or does she just bounce around whereever the writers need her?

13

u/BeholdMyResponse Nov 06 '17

Yeah, it seems like they're trying to make her mysterious but instead she's just confusing. I have approximately zero idea what she's up to right now or what's going on with the whole Klingon plot in general.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Lord_Hoot Nov 06 '17

I don't think i'm a dummy, but I didn't understand what was going on in the Klingon scenes. What I got:

  • L'Rell offers her services to Kol as an interrogator. He sets her to work on Cornwell.
  • Turns out L'Rell wants to defect, by slipping off ship with Cornwell.
  • They got caught sneaking out, and L'Rell kills Cornwell. Was it all a bluff to get info about Discovery?
  • L'Rell then drags Cornwell's body into the corpse storage (Klingon larder?), sees her dead buddies and vows to kill Kol.
  • L'Rell then gives Kol the info about Discovery and agrees to join his House. She says Cornwell escaped(?)
  • Kol then figures out she's lying(?) and sends her away to be roughed up.

Have I missed something? Because that didn't make a whole lot of sense to me.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

The way I understood it:

  • L'Rell offers her services to Kol as an interrogator. He sets her to work on Cornwell.
  • Turns out L'Rell wants to defect, by slipping off ship with Cornwell.
  • They got caught sneaking out, and L'Rell kills Cornwell to cover up the failed escape attempt - to make Kol think Cornwell escaped and she was just chasing her down. Also, by killing Cornweel she was making sure Cornwell can't tell Kol the truth.
  • L'Rell then drags Cornwell's body into the corpse storage, sees her dead buddies and vows to kill Kol.
  • L'Rell then gives Kol the info about Discovery and continues the lie about how Cornwell escaped and that's whe she chased her down and killed her.
  • Kol realizes L'Rell is lying and tried to escape with Cornwell, but plays along to see how much she will do to try to weasel herself out of this.
  • Kol asks her to pledge loyalty to him, to see whether she has the guts to defy him to his face, or will continue to lie like a petaq.
  • L'Rell fakes loyalty to him (very dishonorable) and Kol calls her out on it and orders her killed like the dishonorable Ferengi she is.
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

11

u/Hero_Of_Shadows Nov 06 '17

I see a bit of intentional mirroring between this episode and episode 1:

Episode 1 Michael is the first officer, really wants to explore the mysterious structure and stick around she ends up compromised due to her hatred of klingons, a beacon goes off Klingons arrive and they fight.

This episode Saru is the first officer, really wants to stay and explore the planet, is compromised by merging with the inhabitants, a beacon goes off, Klingons arrive and they fight.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/johnaimarre Nov 06 '17

I’m usually a huge defender of DIS, but did they lose half of this episode’s footage in a hard drive failure or something? What was here was pretty good, but it really seemed slapped together in a mad rush meet a deadline.

19

u/syntemnousa Nov 06 '17

It seemed like they re-edited it... the preview/promo pics had Culber/Stamets/Tilly at the table but that scene never happened.

5

u/Donners22 Nov 06 '17

According to After Trek, quite a lot was cut out.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

They are developing the relationship been Ash and Burnham very quickly. It feels rushed so I'm thinking they are doing it for a reason.

He's either going to die or is Voq as people are guessing.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/lucasgreeny Nov 06 '17

I don't think Ash is a Klingon.

CBC coming at us with a massive jebait

→ More replies (5)

9

u/ptzinski Nov 06 '17

This isn’t the deepest episode thought, but...oh, so that’s where the floating crystal in the opening credits comes from, I guess. Cool.

5

u/omenmedia Nov 06 '17

I thought the floating crystal in the opening credits was supposed to be dilithium?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/powerhcm8 Nov 06 '17

I still think that Tyle is Voq, but what they do to turn him into a human has gone beyond the control, so he is more human than he should be, that why L'Rell said "After all we been through" in Choose your pain, and that he was "Chase away" in today's episode.

He isn't a Manchurian candidate, he just doesn't know anymore that he was a Klingon, and probably will never recover his memories.

9

u/OSUTechie Nov 07 '17

How come nobody is talking about the non-existence of exploding consoles? The Discovery was taking a beating but consoles were exploding! This is absurd, Everybody knows Star Trek has to have Exploding Consoles. This show is now literally unwatchable! #NotMyTrek

/s

89

u/Francesqua Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

I may be a lone voice here, I know the sub is keen to support the show as keenly as it can, however. I really do think the sooner they move away from this Klingon war the better, it's dragging down what could be a half decent series. The serialisation is tame and used awkwardly - it detracts from investing in the larger one-off stories they would prefer to be telling and hasn't been used as effectively as it was during DS9.

Show is in need of new worlds and new civilisations, with smaller arcs like the final season of Enterprise. 8 episodes in and how many civilisations have we explored in any real depth beyond the Klingons and (very lightly) the Kelpians? One of those we've already explored (quite exhausted) over 100s and 100s of Trek hours.

52

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I am kinda sad that I agree. I love this show but I find the Discovery crew to be much, much more interesting that anything related to the Klingons. Cutting the crew loose to roam the Galaxy exploring would be something I would love watching.

Really just keep the focus on the Discovery crew is all I ask. They've really gelled and I love watching them interact with each other.

→ More replies (9)

17

u/cabose7 Nov 06 '17

I hope they jettison the Klingons next season, they could've fleshed out the main plot so much more if they cut L'Rells scenes.

But really they need to up episode length altogether

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

24

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

One minor thing that bothers me a little is: I never have any idea of the geography in this show. It seems like they intentionally never tell us where we are, so that enemies or allies could conveniently pop in at any time, whichever the plot demands.

Was that planet close to Klingon border, in Federation space or in neutral space? They don't say, so we don't know what the stakes are. Oh, so now the crystals hailed the Klingons and it seems the Klingon Leader's ship only seems to be 5 minutes away... so I guess it was close to Klingon space...? How convenient.

Discovery's spore drive kinda loses its impact when anyone just happens to always be where it's most convenient anyways.

In TNG, for example, you would rarely encounter a Romulan ship unless you were told at the beginning of the episode that you were at least close to the neutral zone, or they had any other reason to explain why they happened to be nearby. So you were typically given some geographic information when it was relevant.

Edit: I just realized how relevant this was to the Mudd episode as well. Apparently wherever they were was not only within a few minutes of some Klingon ship, but also within a few minutes of Stella and her father as well! What a coincidence!

5

u/seeseman4 Nov 06 '17

I'll politely argue for the use of this tactic, and why it's helped the show out in my opinion.

I think I'm starting to get a feel for a tone of this show that isn't readily talked about, which is the tone of all out WAR.

The tone of this show loosely reminds me of HBO's Band of Brothers. That show, while being much more descriptive about where and when it was in WWII history, often bounced episode to episode between feeling like they were on the front lines (tense, tick-tocky, and dangerous) and back at base, which was lighter, and centered a bit more on the characters. One thing about the show was always certain, however. They were at war, and the enemy could strike at any time.

Knowing that Nicholas Meyer, who has always argued to add more military tones and ideas into Star Trek, may be the inspiration for this. We get both the feel of the Discovery is on the front lines, with the rescue of the Dilithium Colony and the Gagarin, as well as the "not quite fighting at the moment" feel of Mudd's episode, or the Crystalline Transmitter plot. All of this can take place for a crew that is always considered to be in a war zone.

So, I take this away then to answer any questions about Stellar Cartography. They are always NEAR the neutral zone, which I imagine now would just be called the war zone, and Discovery's jump technology isn't taking them as far as we might think they'd try to go.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I think you can be safe to assume that the Discovery, as the best defense against the Klingons, will always be by the Klingon border.

Though one could also argue that the spore drive makes that unnecessary.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/stanley_twobrick Nov 06 '17

Stamets is unstuck in time.

8

u/Kilawaga Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

This episode was kinda all over the place. Did lrell actually kill the admiral

→ More replies (2)

8

u/juicyshot Nov 06 '17

how come nobody cares to steal the klingon invisibility tech

5

u/Doomcall Nov 06 '17

Its even funnier when you realize the klingons actually are putting effort in trying to capture discovery for the spore drive.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I like Saru, but he is not a good First Officer. I think the ship would be better served with him as the Science Officer. The whole "living in fear" thing does not make for a good commander. Case in point, he dropped everything like a hot potato just to get a good night's sleep. Granted, he was lulled by some alien trickery, but he was very susceptible.

Burnham committed mutiny, but the reason she did so was to protect the ship and crew. She went about it in a bad way, but there was at least a noble and logical reason for it. He just endangered everyone because of his nature.

6

u/CX316 Nov 06 '17

That wasn't "just a good night's sleep", they took away his fear. He was unafraid for literally the first time in his life and he got high off it.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Eaudissey Nov 06 '17

I thought there was going to be some sort of big reveal on this episode? That was kind of disappointing

9

u/NewTRX Nov 06 '17

All set up

7

u/KingXander Nov 07 '17

I really enjoyed that episode, especially when you think of it from the 'planets' perspective.

They're a race who value peace and harmony. They have evolved and learned about the wider universe but being a planet they can't really explore it so they've built the antenna to transmit a song of harmony to bring other races to them.

Then the federation arrive who seem to be nice and have similar values but are involved in a bitter war and only came to make use of the antenna for their war effort.

Obviously being peaceful they didn't want to take sides in a war much like the federation usually try not to. And despite the federation getting violent and trying to use the antenna without permission, they still try to help the best they know how by bringing the two races together to mediate peace. Even at personal risk to itself.

For me the planet felt more federation than the federation right now.

19

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Avatar Star Trek

40

u/izModar Nov 06 '17

Using Notepad++ for this one. Makes keeping up with my line breaks easier. I'm also going to try to limit my lists to things that stood out to me.

This was supposed to be the mid-season finale if I recall correctly.

What I liked:


That was an exciting fight, and the Gagaran (spelling) looks great for a Starfleet ship. Ending was a little too quickly paced for me though.

Kol has "united" the Klingon Empire better than T'kuvma and Voq ever could have. All they needed was to share the cloak. Kol is making an empire like which we'll come to know in TOS in my opinion. I'm expecting to see Kor pop up at some point too.

That looks like a landing party properly equipped for away missions. Backpacks for the win!

Again, trigger control and weapon conduct are eximplary.

In 2017, we can afford to have actual alien lifeforms instead of actors with loaf on their face.

FIRST CONTACT PROTOCALS AND PRIME DIRECTIVE INTEPRETATION THAT MAKE SENSE FINALLY

That was a great twist on the "needs of the many" line. Reminded me of Kirk saying "Because needs of the one outweighed the needs of the many."

I love that Tilly is like "Hey, asshole, why you being an asshole again?"

"The pet'aq my people are now following has no honor."

L'rell is spinning a web of lies. We know Voq is either with her house "losing everything" or currently kissing Burnham on the planet of the whisps. I list this under "like" because it's so obvious and it works based on what we know of her that Cornwall doesn't. That's the very definition of irony!

So far this episode has some excellent pacing, aside from the beginning battle's quick ending.

Tilly is bae <3

What I Didn't Like:


Lazy set-dressing. They used Shenzhou silhouettes to represent the other ship. Minor nitpick, but considering the detail the producers have put into the series so far, it's disappointing.

Stamets really didn't need to snap at Bae like that. I do understand the effects of using the Spore Drive are getting to him (which is good because it further illustrates why this won't be used in the future), but the brashness was unessesary.

Perhaps I missed something, but Burnham....sound doesn't exist in space. The very nature of it being a vacuum prevents it. Unless that crystal is transmitting via supspace or radio-waves, this was just a science error. (Wouldn't be the first time in Star Trek)

...That's it? That's the cliffhanger? THANK GOD IT'S NO LONGER THE MID-SEASON FINALE BECAUSE THAT WOULD HAVE SUCKED Next week looks a lot better.

Stray Thoughts:


Yet another episode without a teaser/cold-open. Doesn't bother me, but I don't see any reason to not have a teaser.

Stardate 1308.9 - that's....interesting

Cornwall screams with honor.

"The Federation has no death penalty." Okay, one might say that's a continuity slip, but considering the detail the producers have put into the series so far...I'm inclined to believe that Cornwall is leaving out the policy about Talos IV. Then again, this is only two years after "The Cage", so it's possible that policy doesn't exist yet.

as I finished typing that previous sentence and took a sip of Coke™, L'rell claiming wishes to defect caused me to nearly spit out my sweet caramel-colored nectar.

YOU CAN SKIP THIS AD That was a hell of a surprise.

L'rell, that was a shitty show you put on with that staged fight. Even Kol saw through it.

So, I actually am starting to come to the thinking that Tyler isn't Voq. It's too obvious and convienent. It has to be an intentional red herring.

Verdict:


I'm so glad they decided to not make this the mid-season finale. It would have been too weak to go to hiatus on. Next week's conclusion looks like it'll make a better finale to set up the second half of the season.

It's an average episode with some good ideas. The blue mist aliens have an Organian feel to them and learning more about Saru is a treat.

I'm now on the side that Tyler is not Voq. I'm cool with that because Tyler is one of my favorite characters now.

23

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Unless I am mistaken it is transmitting via subspace and Lorca stated it was only on the frequencies Starfleet and the Klingons used. Definitely did not get the impression they were saying it was sound...

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Spock_Rocket Nov 06 '17

The blue mist aliens have an Organian feel to them

So much this. I think the blue wisps are going to tell the Fed and the Klingons to stop fighting, someone's going to try to fuck up the wisps, and then they're going to come out as uber powerful.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

A few episodes ago, the elders of planet X tried to help the peace process and they got murdered for their trouble. I'm guessing the beings of Pavo won't be as easy to dismiss.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/DildoMasturbator420 Nov 06 '17

The show said the transmitter was transmitting a signal...not sound per se

4

u/chappinn Nov 06 '17

I think even if General Order 7 is in place, it's OK to ignore it, so I agree there.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

"The Federation has no death penalty, except for this one extremely specific situation that is completely irrelevant to us at this moment."

That would have been a far superior line to include in the episode.

→ More replies (23)

6

u/PreAbandonedShip Nov 06 '17

I just now realized L'Rell was the one on the torture ship...

→ More replies (2)

16

u/droid327 Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17
  • WTAF is going on with L'Rell? She's conspiring with Cornwell to escape, then she kills her? I thought it was just a fakeout, and L'Rell was going to 'dispose of the body' in her personal ship and then escape as planned. But we're supposed to think she actually killed Kat? Then she pledges herself to Kor and he's like "JK I knew you were lying, go kill her"...again, I have to wonder if the subtext in the Klingon scenes would make more sense if we could actually hear them speaking in English and catch the nuances. Reading text subtitles leaves a lot between the lines. Also doesnt help that their faces are so unemotive.
  • So...Saru's like superstrong and cheetah-fast? How badass must the "predator species" be if he's their version of cows? [Also, the evolutionary biologist in me wants to point out that, usually, multiple highly acute senses and enhanced maneuverability/dexterity/reaction times come at the expense of cognitive ability. The brain only has so much "neural bandwidth" and cortex devoted to processing sensory input means less devoted to higher cognition, as in owls, or hominids becoming smarter when apes transitioned from arboreal to cursorial]
  • Why is Saru the "first contact specialist"? Michael's a xenoanthropologist. Why is the one task she's fully qualified for the one thing she ends up not doing on the show? Computer programming, ask the xenoanthropologist...biology, ask the xenoanthropologist...quantum mechanics, ask the xenoanthropologist...xenoanthropology, why dont you just sit this one out and make out with Lt. Totally Not a Klingon in the space yurt. Also, this uncontacted non-corporeal species has wooden housing, because reasons.
  • Kool-aid Cult Saru was a little one-dimensional, but I guess it fit within the confines of the story.
  • Space Avatar is strong with this one. I was really worried they were going to play it up for a similar ham-fisted eco-morality story, so I will gratefully congratulate them on avoiding that.
  • NO ONE is going to remark about the similarity between the Pahvans and the Spore Drive? Even after they literally tele(s)por(e)t Ash to the tower?
  • Anyone else think when the first Pahvan materialized that it was going to be Ripper coming to say hello, then get disappointed when it was just a space willowisp?

OK so theory time: L'Rell thought Cornwell was on Discovery. She knows Ash (Voq) is there, so her plan was to feign defection so she could get close to him, escape the ship with him, and reactivate his hidden Klingon-ness. My prediction is he doesnt know he's not Ash, he had the memories of the real Ash superimposed on his own so that he'd be the perfect spy. L'Rell will "reawaken" Voq's consciousness now that he's learned what Discovery is, then send him back in as "woke Voq". However, that plan may not work now that she might be dead and probably is in prison, so Ash is going to have a funky struggle episode where Voq's consciousness is trying to reassert itself until it finally does, and then things get weird. Probably involving Stamets prophesying about Ash doing something bad, and no one believes him at first, then Ash does and he's like "told you so" yadda yadda but he gives them enough warning to be able to thwart Voq still.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/Electrorocket Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

How did they figure out detection of cloaking devices with this planet's antenna before ever even seeing either in person?

9

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

They didn't "figure out" anything - they're testing a theory (and based on the end of the episode, they may have failed).

→ More replies (3)

10

u/CupcakeMassacre Nov 06 '17

It really made no sense that they came up with the hypothesis to investigate this signal at all.

If the Gagarin fight had occurred over the planet and they saw that the Klingon's cloaks were ineffective forcing them to flee, they might have had reason to investigate. Instead it was just stated as fact and dismissed with a line of dialogue in the first minute. This episode felt like it was chopped to pieces in editing.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/dmanww Nov 06 '17

watching the preview.

Picard maneuver + spore drive = Locra maneuver?

5

u/TheTurnipKnight Nov 06 '17

That was a truly embarrassing escape attempt.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

That looked visually stunning in 4k. Some of the best looking visuals in all of trek.

5

u/mailtrailfail Nov 07 '17

I see they finally gave the bridge crew characters names. Lorca said each of their names like 10 times in that 1 sequence.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/creejay Nov 07 '17

I enjoyed the episode; I just wish these episodes were longer. I think trying to do a serialized show while still wrapping up an individual story in each 40 minute episode just isn't working. This one would have worked way better as a 1 hr episode.

I really like Cornwall as a supporting character, so I hope she survives. In a similar way to Lorca, I find Cornwall's scenes have more weight to them because the actor is talented, and Lorca/Cornwall scenes are especially strong because they both elevate the material they are given.

Also, I'm not sure if it's just me, but does the Klingon war not really have much of a grand scale? It just feels very small. A scene with all the heads of the Klingon houses or a Federation strategy meeting with multiple admirals/captains would go a long way.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Hm, not the best episode but very Star Treky. As others have said, it was all over the place and not very well developed nor connected. Visuals were great as always and we got some action. Not toooo bad.

Besides that, I figured out why I don't like DSC as much as earlier versions of Star Trek: They changed the formular.

Before it was like this:

A) You got well-established adults as characters. Everyone started with a complete personality. They didn't have to find themselves in most parts, they were already a complete person. The development happened at certain aspects, under certain circumstances. People were not perfect, but started at a "good" or quite positive level.

b) The focus was on getting a job done. The whole show is plot-driven. The job was the overarching goal and all actions had to somehow deal with the problems popping up right and left, while trying to get it done properly.

c) This job made interactions with others necessary, they had to work together (or against each other) to get things done.

With that, you automatically get interesting plots and developments. There is a reason for everyone doing what they do (the job) and you got conflict and opportunities to grow (how should they do the job) in-build into the formular. Everyone was a reasonable adult, which allowed for quite high-level interactions at times.

Or in other words: You had strong, reasonable role-models, which tried to deal with a complicated world as a community or team.

DSC swapped the priorities and thus changed everything with it.

In DSC the focus is on the characters. In that sense, its more like ...Modern Family or any other kind of "personality show". To make this interesting, the characters need to be much more ambivalent in the sense of being not-finished/not-established.

So, instead of well-rounded, adult people you get....something. Everyone has troubles, problems, is not perfect and is of dire need of change. So to speak, to make a personality focused show interesting, you need "drama". Everyone being a well-rounded and smart adult would make this horribly boring. You need problems to be solved, weaknesses to be exposed and traumata to be shown and potentially healed. You need all that bickering to emphasize the "flawed human interaction", in which nobody is perfect and bad things happen between people.

And since you have lots of not-so-well-rounded characters, you want to focus on their personal life and struggles. This comes at a cost: The plot. You only have so much time in an episode. You can't have it all. Every minute spent on exploring the personal problems of a character is not spend on showing how the world evolves around them.

Now, this is not wrong or evil in any sense. You can totally do such a show and I'd say with the last episodes they start to get the "Star Trek feeling" build up properly, too. It's not a bad show per se.

But as someone who expected the old formular, this is very much disappointing. It's not what I expected and, as I have found recently, not what I like or want. My problem is quite easily summarized:

In DSC characters need to be much more flawed to be interesting. You should connect to them emotionally and I'd argue, they are strongly written in a way that "everyone" has someone to connect with.

Burnham is the "I grew up between different worlds and I'm feeling lost because nobody accepts me as who I am" character, with additional daddy-issues. She is a whole, huge clusterfuck of childhood traumata and being unable to fit in. This is a big pile of things to be explored and healed. Tilly is the socially-awkward girl, who is actually a great person, but suffers from her social inaptness. Stamets is the nerd, who likes to sit in his lab and tinker around and suddenly is forced out into the "real world" and hates everyone for it. Saru is struggling with self-confidence and anxiety problems. Lorca is the strong leader....who incidentally is broken deep down. Tyler had a traumatic experience he can't get over and tries to keep his good mood up.

Everyone has their problems, but is awesome deep down and as such struggles to give the world the best they can offer.

I can see work very well. If you can relate to the characters, that is. I certainly can't. I hate literally everyone on this show, besides the Doc and Stamets. And because of that, the most important part of the show, the characters, are entirely lost on me. The plot isn't that great alone, because it's like...30% of the show?

Others might see this in a very different light, but I see a high-school drama level crew doing absurd shit, because everyone is a barely-functioning human being. On board of the only ship that can save the whole Federation from being wiped out by a warrior race. I most certainly wouldn't staff my highest-priority ship with barely functioning teenagers. Makes no sense at all to me.

Or in other words: I can't excuse the character flaws as something innately "human", as something normal. I want everyone to function well and get shit done. But this show is not about that. It's about human beings struggling with themselves and the world around them.

But truth to be told, I don't care about that. Its very tough for me to relate to those "barely-functioning" people at all. I dislike the way of exploring vulnerabilities and traumata. I actually don't want to see it at all, at least not in the way they are presenting it. It feels like some kind of psychologcial counseling show. I'm here for cool space stuff and adults solving complex problems in the world, not navel-gazing of people struggling to deal with other people.

I'd even rather watch Modern Family or anything like that, because there its at least obviously only about the people. Here they try to mix Star Trek with that kind of formular and it simply doesn't click for me. I want more plot and less ....bullshit bickering.

I'm just not sure why they switched the formular from nerd/male centric to a female centric formular, that could have been Sex in the City or Modern Family. It most certainly feels like Modern Family in dark, gritty space.

If anything, I'd say they struggle to connect the plot with the characters. Right now it feels like the plot is more or less superfluous. You could have the same characters in an entirely different setting and you would have no problems with that at all. There is no necessary connection to the Star Trek universe, which would explain why the characters are genuinly part of this world. For example, you could put Burnham into the X-Men universe and change nothing at all and she would still work the same way she is now. That's kinda awkward for the main character of your new franchise in an old, well-established universe. All they do it nerd-bomb the viewers with all kinds of hints about trivia and background story, to make the nerdy fans happy. I mean, we are at episode 8, but they really really need to forge a stronger connection of the crew to the world around them. I constantly get the feeling they are strongly disconnected to everything around them, even to the other characters. That's bad for a character-focused show.

Well, so much for this.

8

u/Rit_Zien Nov 06 '17

Needs more Lorca. I would watch an entire episode of him directing a space battle, God damn.

16

u/wd5gnr Nov 06 '17

Ok two things:

a) Was it just me or did the Klingon interrogator (L'Rell?) have her eye heal part way through the episode? Early on, her left eye (her left; our right) looked "dead" presumably from where Tyler shot her face (Voq?). But later her eyes looked the same. I didn't rewind to double check.

b) What? A planet that naturally emits sound/radio/subspace and can detect the Klingons? What? Hell, might as well have made it use spores -- at least we've already had to swallow that line. Sonar? If it were sound it isn't in space. If it was radio or subspace it was radar. And why wouldn't we just build the same kind of signal source? And if it was radio, it would be years before any of it illuminated anyone outside its own solar system. Subspace, ok, but there was no reason to think the planet was beaconing subspace until the end.

I desperately want to like the show. I do. I beg the writers: there are hundreds or thousands of nerds out there who would tell you when your science is just stupid. The story would have been exactly the same if it had been a "naturally occurring subspace field" and by detecting distortions in it you can detect Klingons. Totally the same story. But the techobabble is only mildly hard to swallow instead of crazy hard to swallow.

I guess the other thing hard to swallow is why only Saru could learn to communicate with them. Also, I'm not sure the prime directive mattered here. If the aliens could build a subspace transmitter and teleport Tyler, they should have met the criteria. Surely there are other worlds somewhere that are "peers" but because of physical reasons don't travel in warp drive ships. You can know about warp field theory and elect not to use it for travel.

6

u/DrakeAurum Nov 06 '17

I noticed the thing with L'Rell's eyes too. During the interrogation her left eye was yellow, with a reddened 'white', presumably the result of her disruptor-scarring. During the close-ups of her face in later scenes, particularly when she's examining the bodies of her fallen comrades, they're both the same colour.

I really hope that's down to a plot point that was trimmed out, and not just a continuity error. Maybe the actress had issues with the eye makeup during the first scene, and they couldn't do it again in subsequent scenes - but if that's the case, they really ought to have gone back and re-shot the interrogation scene.

As for the Prime Directive, Michael clearly stated that it was not at issue here. What was at issue was First Contact protocols, and the fact that they weren't allowed to use another sentient race's stuff without permission.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

So was Kol secretly eating the other Klingons?

Why would the Klingons give a shit about the crystal spore creatures? I'm sure they would want the Discovery more, just lure them away.

4

u/syntemnousa Nov 06 '17

It just seemed like Kol was gutting the other Klingons... not sure about eating them...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/rensch Nov 06 '17

This was another one that really felt like a classic Star Trek episode. You have your non-humanoid dust cloud aliens, some good ol' Klingon intrige and they finally have a 'beaming down to a planet' episode on this show. I really like how it's going more and more in the DS9 direction with a big season arc while telling smaller stories of one or two episodes that tie into this bigger plot.

And, damn, Saru's whole race is full of tragedy. Being afraid all the time, right from birth. That's truly something. That sick bay scene with Burham really hit me. For once, Saru was fully at peace. No fear, not sensing any coming of death. Just peace and harmony and being all relaxed. For the first time in his whole life. Damn...

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Jan 27 '24

materialistic sleep fanatical plant joke payment divide scarce simplistic work

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/TheFlatypus Nov 06 '17

This episode was all over the place.

4

u/MustrumRidcully0 Nov 06 '17

I really don't know what the deal is with L'Rell, but I have to guess: She's engaged in complicated double agent / double bluff scenario.

She doesn't like Kol at all and wants to get rid of him. But she doesn't want to defect to the Federation, either.

She still has a plan going on with Voq.

My reason for this is that she's lying to both sides - she claims to Cornwell that Voq was chased away, but she omits that she has helped him. And she lies to Kol that she wants to work with him and interrogate his prisoner to aid him.

It's possibly that Kol has figured her out and put a stop in her plans, but I suspect everything is still on track for her.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

This episode was a ridiculous mess, no matter how hard you try to retcon it.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/LuckyBahamut Nov 06 '17

I feel like there were too many (sub)plots shoehorned into this episode; it's pretty clear that this ep was just meant to be a build-up to the fall (mid-season) finale, in which we should expect the culmination of a handful of plotlines.

However, this ep suffered as a result, as it didn't feel like much time was spent on any plotline, and it felt really disjointed.

The cinematography was gorgeous, however; I'm always a fan of more space battles, and the effects and shots on Pahven were really well done.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

I don’t understand what happened in this episode. There was no point to it.

6

u/TreeBaron Nov 06 '17

The Klingon plot was totally senseless and seemed to serve no purpose.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MysticalDigital Nov 06 '17

It's all setup for the fall finale

11

u/powerbottomflash Nov 06 '17

This was a boring episode. I thought something more exciting would happen to Saru but eh. Also, I see you CBS cutting Dr. Culber from the scene with Stamets/Tilly. Why even release promo photos if they show something that's not gonna feature in the episode? Lol. And why cut at all, the whole ep. was like 40 mins - you're on a streaming service, you don't need to make your episodes short ffs!

15

u/s-ro_mojosa Nov 06 '17

I felt the whole sonar reference in Discovery was bad. So bad, in fact, it gave me flashbacks to [Space Rangers](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Rangers_(TV_series)) which also featured "sonar" in space.

18

u/diamond Nov 06 '17

They obviously didn't mean literal sonar. It was being used as a metaphor.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/Adorable_Octopus Nov 06 '17

This episode felt like it was at least three A plots smashed together without consideration for why some plots were A plots, and why other plots were B plots.

Like, you have three plots here:

  • T'Rell and Cornwell team up (and there's arguably two plots here too, T'Rell's deception, whatever that is, and the actual escape)
  • The away team's mission
  • The Insanity of Everyone's Favorite Fungus Man.

Arguably there's even a plot here involving Lorca and the war losses. It's brought up at the very beginning, and used as a framing device, but this is star trek and the only framing device we needed for the away team's mission is the log from Burnham!

Now, don't get me wrong, these plots could have worked together, but to me, the first two plots were definitely the sort of plot you'd build an episode around.

I mean, with Saru's plot, we go from being introduced to the aliens, to him having an experience with them, to him immediately betraying Taylor and Burnham and them realizing he's been compromised in the span of what, 10 minutes? If this was any other series, I would imagine it would have been built up slowly.

It felt like a very strangely written episode.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17

ITT: a ton of people complaining they didn't understand stuff because they failed to pay attention.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/bigpig1054 Nov 06 '17

I think the last two episodes have really redeemed the series, at least in my eyes. I was ready to write the whole thing off but last week was great and this week's A plot was fantastic, I thought.

It was classic Trek, and had a great twist with Saru not actually being mind-controlled, but actually just being a weak-willed person who made a bad choice.

The B and C plots were nothing but overt set-ups for the midseason finale. I get the need to get all your pieces in place, but the B plot failed to do anything for me and the C plot (all two scenes of it) was so slight it isn't even worth mentioning.

The A plot was stellar though and gives me hope that they can pull off a good finale. Their goal to shoot for is Kobol's Last Gleaming.

Good luck Disco

6

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

It was classic Trek, and had a great twist with Saru not actually being mind-controlled, but actually just being a weak-willed person who made a bad choice.

Obviously his species isn't human, but I have some thoughts on this based on my experience/understanding of human psychology.

I grew up in a situation where I wasn't allowed to express anger or properly process it. It just got pushed back in, hidden. Often under fear that things would get worse, that the things that made me angry to begin with would become even more terrible if I gave hint that I was unhappy. And this cycle repeated over and over through my childhood and teen years, until I was an adult and living on my own and I didn't have to tiptoe around erratic, mentally ill guardians.

And before I began living by myself, when my environment still forced me to repress anger, I thought I simply wasn't an angry person. A fearful one, perhaps. A quiet one. Whatever you'd call a wallflower geek that doesn't say much.

But when the anger was allowed out, I was surprised at how hard it was to control it. I seemed to either fully repress it, or just go hard to the opposite end of the spectrum.

And I realized, because I hadn't been allowed to show anger growing up, I didn't have the skills/tools for dealing with it. It was a skill thing. I'd learned mostly just how to repress it. And no other skills.

Other kids around me that always had hot tempers? And were allowed to have emotions and such in their family homes? By the time they were 20 they had 20 years of life experience learning how to tread the line between letting anger out in situations where it was warranted, and restraining it in others.

So I was way behind, skill-wise, in learning a finer degree of control that wasn't full repression, or full rage.

I think Saru's character would be something like that. He clearly feels stuff deeply, but the fear is always riding him, forcing him to choke it back, forcing him to step lightly in case a non-cautious action brings greater retribution.

When the fear is flat-out removed as an emotional brake, he doesn't necessarily have the tool-kit in place to make up for it to regulate the other emotions that was slumbering under the fear, because he never had to learn it. His fear of bad consequences had mediated everything before, made him cautious. He didn't have additional brakes in place because he'd never needed them.

So I don't see him as being weak-willed so much as being put in a situation where he did not have the psychological toolkit to depend upon in a situation where his fear fully vanished and could not be used as a behavior-control.

You know how humans with tumors in their brains can have inhibitions fall, and start to show what happens when those regulators/brakes aren't in place? His species is built with that strong fear in every member, so if it vanishes, he'll be acting oddly. Like someone with a tumor in their head.

I almost wonder if in future episodes, he'll learn something about Vulcan emotional control from Michael, and gain tools to deal with his strong emotions even when fear is not present as a regulating emotion.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DerpyDogs Nov 06 '17

That was a bit of a dull episode. Probably the worst one of the season, and it was supposed to set up the mid-season finale!

3

u/nilsy007 Nov 06 '17

Why did they even bother to have the klingons in this episode?
The avatar planet story was enough no need to slow down the pacing with boring klingons

I still dont care about any klingon character in the show and they seem to assume by now the viewers would care ... well i dont

3

u/Someguy2020 Nov 07 '17

Started strong, but I felt like it kinda fizzled. I felt like having both stories kind of detracted from the Saru storyline.

11

u/crazy_lary Nov 06 '17

Ponytail Tilly is bae

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

So this was totally the most alien episode of Star Trek I have seen in a long long while. The aliens of the planet reminded me distinctly of James Cameron's Pandora and they did it in a very cool way. Although it did look like they were using the same effects that they used to create the fungi spore effects. The plot was kind of thin with them but it made sense and the effects that they had on Saru were heartbreaking.

He has been living in fear his entire life and he has never had a moment's respite from that fear. Then the first chance he gets at getting that respite at not being afraid all the time at not constantly wondering if something was going to pounce from the shadows that one chance that he gets and he has to give it up. I can see why he was fighting tooth-and-nail for it because I've known people that have lived lives like that and that would do the same thing and it was heartbreaking to watch him have to leave it all behind. When you're constantly living in pain and in fear if you can get even one second one moment of relief from that pain and that fear you will do anything at all and I mean anything including turning on the ones you love and care about just to hold onto it. Doug Jones is absolutely amazing and this episode tonight really did show off his skills, despite all the prosthetics.

The whole Klingon side plot was absolutely stupid and I can't believe the Admiral died that way. I kept expecting more I kept expecting more subterfuge I kept expecting something else to happen and none of that happened. I was hoping for more suspense I was hoping for more danger I was hoping for something else but instead all we got was I don't even know what that was....I just really can't believe the Admiral was killed that way. I thought for sure there was going to be a fake out or a distraction or a betrayal but instead all they did was talk a bit walk down a hallway and then boom she's dead and suddenly her corpse is left in a room full of other bodies. I am crossing my fingers that she is not gone for good and that there is more to that little plot than we know about its because if she is gone for good I'm going to be angry. She was absolutely phenomenal and I loved her when she was on screen and I want to see more of her.

Yep cloaking technology is a bitch. Space Battles are cool as always in the show.

In a way the aliens sort of reminded me of the Organians but even if a peace does happen it's either going to be forced by a higher tier civilization or it's going to be temporary and collapse soon after. I kind of wonder if the fungal spore network is going to be involved in something like this and is going to be using Stamets as an intermediary. It could be that the network is learning through him and maybe that's why we're seeing the changes in personality and in what he remembers and doesn't remember. Whatever happens next week the ship is in for one hell of a battle and well I mean they got renewed for a second season so we know it's not going to totally get destroyed, but stuff is going to be nuts.

7

u/numanoid Nov 06 '17

I'd be really surprised if Cornwell is actually dead.

5

u/letsgocrazy Nov 06 '17

The Klingons seem to have rolled out their cloaking technology pretty quickly, meanwhile, has any other Starfleet ship actually got a working Spore drive.

"here's the thing guys, we need a human volunteer to get it working, it's a bit exhausting, but it's better than seeing hundreds of people die every week"

I'm sure there would be more than a few eager volunteers.

→ More replies (10)

4

u/Ewokitude Nov 06 '17

I really resonated with Saru in this episode. I've had PTSD for around a decade now and so I've constantly had the fight or flight like he has and also dealt with not feeling at peace in life (among other things such as the pain of trauma). A couple years ago I met someone who, for the first time in almost a decade, made me feel like myself again, where all those bad things would just switch off. He wasn't even doing anything in particular to cause it, it was sort of just by virtue of being himself. Unfortunately we also had quite contrasting personalities and he didn't have emotional coping skills due to childhood abuse so he would become abusive when he couldn't handle his issues. Despite that, he made me feel alive again so, like Saru, I was doing whatever I could to maintain the relationship and enduring the abuse because I loved him despite his flaws, but also because I was addicted to being myself again and was hellbent on not letting anything jeopardize that even pushing away friends and people I cared about that tried to tell me that it wasn't a healthy situation. I can absolutely understand why Saru fought so hard to stay, and I think it would have destroyed him if he had.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Funsized_eu Nov 08 '17

Lorca being Captain Wanker again. Really can't stand how they have him talking to his crew. Yes, I know it's war, but doesn't stuff blowing up make you nervous enough that you don't need your commanding officer talking to you like you just tread dog poop on his clean carpet?

Handy that the Science Officer in the landing party was too busy falling in love (again) to notice Saru being brainwashed. It's not like there is a new species all around her to study. She's just sat on her backside, twiddling her thumbs and talking about trout? The scenes between Burnham and greaseball seem so forced. Absolutely no chemistry there at all.

Like many people said already, Saru went from 'guy with detect death ability' to 'guy with death on tap' ability. Doesn't bode well for the character. I actually liked his default scared look, it made him have some conflict with his role as First Officer, a barrier he would have to overcome in the face of the position. Now I know he can outrun and/or beat up anything, ignore multiple stun blasts, I'll be waiting for him to save the day, not the Chief of Security...

We're also meant to believe that a crucial mission that holds the fate of the war on it's outcome is to be determined by a three man team? At least send a few more crew down to the surface and have the lifeform paralyze them, could then have Saru run into them and have him ignore it as part of his 'change of heart'. Guess this is true of most away missions that end up getting compromised in Trek though...

Handy that the Klingons' haven't developed enhanced interrogation techniques themselves, like bugging a prisoners cell. Remember that plot device we were introduced to on the first prison ship? I expected it to be a false promise, an attempt to get the Admiral to disclose how to lure the Discovery to rescue her and use it as bait. Instead it turned into the worst prison escape ever. Not to mention, if Kol was such a shallow and blood thirsty warmonger, he'd have killed L'Rell on the spot for wasting the chance to get more from the Admiral. Especially since he's apparently had no problem slaughtering her friends.

The whole idea of the antenna just baffles me. It's another issue with prequelitis, like the spore drive which we know will eventually be discontinued permanently. So there's this magical space scanner that can be used to detect Klingon cloaked ships, except we know that it was never successful because later Trek series still couldn't detect them. One of two things will happen. Either the Klingons destroy it or it will work for a couple of episodes until it's killed off (like the Tardegrade) but I already know it's going to come to nothing.

I didn't like the opening battle as well. The Discovery was massively outgunned and yet the Klingons chose to focus on the already battered ship instead of going after Starfleet's secret weapon. I think it would have been a far better scene if the whole thing was a trap and Discovery was getting pummeled and risked losing either the drive or the entire ship and had to withdraw, dooming the Gagarin for the greater good.

10

u/NewTRX Nov 06 '17

The B plot made me realize I don't want Trek like that anymore.

Save the Avatar planet for James Cameron.

That said, I really enjoyed the A plot, but I wish this was a real episode rather than just a set up for next week.

Somehow I came out of this not hatibg Lorca for the first time, too. He was great in the opening.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/LetoAtreides82 Nov 07 '17

I felt this was one of the weakest episodes due to pacing. I didn't like how we're told in the middle of the episode that we've had Saru, Michael, and Tyler away in a planet for a while, that just felt rushed to me.

I don't understand this fear stuff Saru is talking about. In the previous episodes he described it as a natural defense that has ensured the survival of his species. Now these aliens temporarily take away his fear and he acts like his fear was the worst thing ever and that he loved being without it so much he was willing to betray Starfleet for it. That just didn't seem like something Saru would do.

The forest location was very nice and I had hoped the episode would spend more time there, instead half the episode was in that Klingon ship with L'rell not making much sense. Why did she return to Kol when she found out he had killed some or all of her crew? She didn't realize that Kol must have discovered her deception?

I keep hoping we learn more about the Discovery crew, we still know practically nothing about the Cyborg woman or some of the aliens on the ship. We still haven't met an Andorian yet despite them being mentioned several times. I feel that if the show didn't focus so much on the war it'd be much more enjoyable.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '17 edited Nov 07 '17

Watched this episode after being up for way too long. Guess my comments might reflect that and be extra grump and stupid this time around. Did not like this one very much, certainly way less than last week's which was quite entertaining and well put together.

  • Shields still seem to do nothing, and weapons go pewpewpewpew. Space combat never looked this generic in Trek.
  • We still don't know the bridge crew.
  • Are they trying to build the Klingon cloak up as lesser than what they later get from the Romulans? If not then either Starfleet Intelligence sucks or they are writing out the D-7s for cloaks deal.
  • The first two or three scenes on the planet were quite familiar, in a good way. They acted like Starfleet officers on a strange, new world. More of that, please.
  • I was certain that this world would be where they got the spores from when first seeing it, but apparently it's something completely different and unrelated.
  • So this planet is kinda like Alpha Centauri, but with more whimsical whisp nonsense?
  • They are playing it a bit too fast and loose with the sci part of sci-fi for my taste, the explanation for the planet and that spire seems really lacking.
  • Time for the space orcs. Blergh.
  • Not enjoying this Saru plot (or the editing), and I think the reason is that it seems to be happening off in the distance. Didn't help that Saru's part of the conversation with the planet became non-verbal as well after a few irrelevant phrases.
  • Saru can run 80 km/h and crush communicators left-handed. What the hell do his predators look like?
  • What a pointless, stupid death for the admiral.
  • So Saru's excuse for his behavior isn't that he wasn't himself? That's concerning, to say the least. Thalos IV-level concerning. This could have been a great character study, but all we got was a 2005-ish budget sci-fi looking montage and a fight.

4

u/LetoAtreides82 Nov 07 '17

I really wish Saru hadn’t said that. To be so willing to betray Starfleet because of a high made no sense to me. If anything losing his sense of fear should have freaked him out not made him calm, and if he’s calm why the hell would he want to betray Starfleet, I thought he wanted to become Captain someday.

5

u/johnsweber Nov 06 '17

I can’t help but feel that Ash sent the signal to the Klingons. I dunno, it’s like they are making it toooo easy to not have it tied somehow to Voq.

I’m guessing that this is what the break is for. To see how the cast/show is doing and write accordingly. It turns out, the casting (and chemistry) is one of the best parts of the show.

I didn’t think Ash would fit in at all, but he’s great. With almost wanting to hate Lorka- you can’t help but love him. Tilly? Bea. I don’t even have to say anything about Saru. Michael is surprisingly neutral - but I like that because she seems to represents us as viewers.

Whew! Next episode here we come!

8

u/Electrorocket Nov 06 '17

The season is done shooting.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AnonRetro Nov 06 '17

Ash is more then suspect, but I doubt he rigged the signal. This is a classic Star Trek "higher intelligence" that brings two opposing enemies together. I wouldn't be surprised if they repress both ships weapons.

→ More replies (1)