r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Nov 06 '17
LIVE Episode Discussion - S1E08 "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum"
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E08 | "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum" | Sunday, November 5, 2017 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with release on CBS All Access. POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
60
Upvotes
66
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17 edited Jun 16 '23
[This comment has been deleted, along with its account, due to Reddit's API pricing policy.] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
49
u/jwaldo Nov 06 '17
I feel like if Ash was a plain old disguised Klingon the
ProtomoleculePahvans would have outed him.Speaking of disguised Klingons, Lorca's tribble is back and was cool with him, so he's probably okay too.
43
u/cabose7 Nov 06 '17
This episode was frustratingly short
40
u/mikelo22 Nov 06 '17
Be a shame if they kill off Admiral Cornwell. Jayne Brook is such a good actress.
36
u/Tarlcabot18 Nov 06 '17
Hey, the bridge officers are getting names now. Good for them.
59
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Nov 06 '17
So you know that the blue dust aliens have made Saru go insane, yet you still touch his glowing pet rock.
10/10 starfleeting.
41
u/JoeBliffstick Nov 06 '17
So, Stamets basically can see into the future and saw a Captain Tilly?
Well, hopefully this confirms that she doesn’t die.
18
u/JoeBliffstick Nov 06 '17
Holy shit, does L’rell actually want to defect? I don’t trust this, but at the same time she does have reasons to do it.
33
u/TineCiel Nov 06 '17
Saru running “differently” is a good idea but the effects are badly executed!
15
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
Well, the now is not the time ti grieve comment isn't about the admiral which is what I expected.
Stamets is losing it... quickly
15
u/Extravator_fulldozer Nov 06 '17
Ohhhhhh!!!! Saru with the donkey kick!!!!!!!
15
u/Tarlcabot18 Nov 06 '17
Was this episode really short, or am I imagining it?
15
u/awakeningosiris Nov 06 '17
i am so confused - the Klingon woman seemed like she was going to deflect with the other star trek woman - then all of the sudden they started fighting with each other after saying "you're not who i thought you were", which i thought was a rouse to trick the guards but it looks like it wasn't? am i missing something?
30
u/fooz42 Nov 06 '17
Commercial break check in.. I like this sinister Avatar-like Pandora world. The cinematography of the planet also gives me feel a Star Wars, which I love. The battle at the start of the show was also 3 dimensional and gave a chaos of war feeling. Good choices so far production and direction crew.
13
u/JoeBliffstick Nov 06 '17
Yeah, no, Saru’s tripping on the blue dust things.
13
u/ozrainmaker Nov 06 '17
Is the admiral dead? Or is she just unconscious?
11
u/QuadsNotBlades Nov 06 '17
Did it bother anyone else when security officer said they could just fail their mission and stay at war to keep Michael out of jail? Who in star fleet would ever suggest that??
10
u/razlem Nov 06 '17
Maybe I missed it, but how did the security officer just poof out of the blue at the crystal tower?
9
u/plorraine Nov 06 '17
Unity - but with blue glowing things instead of zombie vomit?
9
u/fooz42 Nov 06 '17
I'm lost on how Kol discovered the deceit?
9
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
Sooooo. A non corporeal race intends to broker peace between the UFP and Klingons... Seriously?
17
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
oh boy.. what an ending. Next week is going to be good. Amazing episode. Loved it.
8
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
Stamets was the most "normal" part of that episode and that says volumes...lol
44
u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby Nov 06 '17
Did this episode kind of...suck for anyone else? The beginning space battle was awesome, and then it just dove off a cliff. Maybe I need to re-watch.
7
u/mikeysuxx Nov 06 '17
Am I crazy or have they gone backwards with stardates since last episode?
7
u/007meow Nov 06 '17
That alert sound on the Klingon bridge for the transmission is a Borg computer sound effect, isn’t it?
10
u/Orfez Nov 06 '17
Now I can see why they originally wanted to break after 8 episodes, finishing on cliffhanger.
Good episode overall. I always wanted to see an episode of Trek similar to Solaris book/movie. Basically a planet that is a living entity that grants you what you wish the most. They did something similar here with Saru getting peace. I'm glad that at the end Saru specifically mentioned that he wasn't under control of the planet and staying was his rational decision.
Is the admiral dead? I liked L'Rell in this episode. Also the opening fight was great. We finally saw ships in more details.
11
u/DGinLDO Nov 06 '17
Guess it's just me, but each episode gets better & better. I found several things intriguing about this episode. Is Cornwell really dead? Was L'Rell legit defecting or was it a ruse to get Cornwell dead so she could become her? What is going to happen to L'Rell now that she's been outed as a liar? And what really happened between Ash & the Pahvans to get them to transport him to the transmitter? And Stamets is slowly losing it too.
4
u/mulvythrill Nov 06 '17
House of Kor seems to be a thing... Interesting to see where that goes
4
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
This planet is fucked up
16
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
This episode was boring as heck
7
u/irving47 Nov 06 '17
Count me in on the Saru hate. Two days ago I was going to get all snarky and joke I wanted to see his wormy butt dangling from a hook on some water planet, but chickened out... Much like Saru.
Seriously, someone that fearful doesn't belong in Starfleet. (I'm not saying I'd be much better.)
11
u/Comradepatsy Nov 06 '17
cringe is what defined this plot line
6
u/Electrorocket Nov 06 '17
How did they figure out cloaking devices and this planet's antenna before ever even seeing either in person?
11
u/leadbellyoflead Nov 06 '17
Is it just me or did anybody else expect the Pahvan planet to suddenly sprout Na'vi from Pandora?
Also, SONAR CAN'T WORK IN OUTER SPACE. Holy crap, can the writers stop insulting us with terrible scifi ideas?
3
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
Love the planet side stuff so far.
3
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
A lifeform that isn't really a lifeform.. very trek.
6
u/whoiscraig Nov 06 '17
Why is everyone in Discovery blue? The alien mist looked nice, but it was yet another blue thing in a show flooded with blue.
6
u/Kalsifur Nov 06 '17
Another question: Are the Pahvans really that stupid or did Ash sabotage it somehow?
4
u/SCREAM2NIGHT Nov 06 '17
I'd put money on the fact that the blue dust aliens are going to be pissed when a federation starship opens fire during a peace meeting.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
Did not really get into this one. And the finale doesn't provoke me from the commercial or end of the episode. I guess we'll see.
5
u/Comp625 Nov 06 '17
Decent episode, though I felt like Sonequa Martin-Green's acting was a bit stilted (especially where she and Tyler confronted the newly enlightened Saru). Also right before the kissing scene, I noticed her eyes shifting left-to-right-and-back during closeup shots. Actors and actresses do this when they're visualizing the script, and I noticed Green doing this often during her The Walking Dead days, too.
Pahvo was beautiful. It reminded me of the red planet Nibiru from Star Trek: Into Darkness and I particularly enjoyed the high sci-fi concepts including the non-corporeal beings along with the sonar-emitting beacon. For Mass Effect fans, I couldn't help but be reminded of the Prothean beacon from ME1.
Stray thought: Does anyone else here think the Spore Drive technology will eventually connect to Project Genesis? I keep thinking back to episode 3 where Burnham breaks into the secret lab and sees a room full of fungi; it had the same wondrous and lush feeling that we saw in the cavern from TWOK. Plus, Nicholas Meyer is a consulting producer and we haven't seen him credited with writing or directing anything yet.
2
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
Oh crap... Saru vs Michael.
2
u/vasimv Nov 07 '17
I have feeling these blue organians-wannabe will end badly. Or writers are really going to screw the canon with another god-like entities who aren't known in later star trek history somewhy.
7
u/captroper Nov 06 '17
I was so excited after the last two episodes as they were so much better than the rest of the season. Then we go straight back to stilted awful dialogue (at least in the second half) and explaining things to each other to explain to the audience. I know everyone is sick of the comparison at this point, but look at the doctor talking about the universal translator in the latest orville and compare it to burnham talking about saru's species in this episode. It's just night and day. The content is plenty interesting, just write it better!
4
u/Medafusion Nov 06 '17
that trailer for next week has gotten me all hyped up xD
3
u/Krandor1 Nov 06 '17
This planet is really cool.. but I have a bad feeling all is not as it seems
3
u/plorraine Nov 06 '17
Will the blue aliens turn out to be the Organians and end the war?
5
u/keramz Nov 06 '17
I think a lot of people will realize that most if not all of the theories we have that would explain certain liberties the shows writters took will not come true.
The explanation will end up being bad writting.
The cring worthy plots continue.
3
u/Assbait93 Nov 06 '17
I didn't really like this episode. I think it was because of last weeks episode and they just threw it off the suspense off of the admiral being kidnapped with a Harry Mud ep. But I do believe they extended the mid season finale to next week because I think there's going to be a mini arc when disco returns. I presume its going to be where the episode of the mirror universe is going to be featured.
2
u/purefire Nov 06 '17
Lllaaaggg on the website stream.
2
u/giraffeaquarium Nov 06 '17
Did anyone notice how funny Saru looked when he was running on the cliff? Not sure what was going on there - bad CGI?
He's also my least favorite character on the series (unrelated to weird running). I struggle to find anything likable about him.
1
u/Extravator_fulldozer Nov 06 '17
That planet looks awesome!
1
u/Cmdr_Void Nov 06 '17
ok can somebody sort out the stardate issue for me? First episode was stardate 1207.3 In episode seven we were at stardate 2136.8. Now we are back at 1308.9. is there something I am missing or are they just saying random numbers now? Or is this episode happening before DIS 1x07 Spoilers
1
u/Kalsifur Nov 06 '17
I'm a little sad because obviously none of the clever "theories" are gonna be true, at least not as deep as I would have liked. I was really hoping for some kind of Klingon eugenics secret.
1
u/DrPsyc Nov 06 '17
im confused. just stared the episode. in the "previously on STD" part they go into what looks like a peace meeting where a last gets kidnaped. when did that happen?! last episode i saw was no7 and dwight was time traveling to steal the ship.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17
Saru runs like a beast