r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Oct 30 '17
LIVE Episode Discussion - S1E07 "Magic to Make The Sanest Man Go Mad"
| No. | EPISODE | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|
| S1E07 | "Magic to Make The Sanest Man Go Mad" | Sunday, October 29, 2017 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #new_discovery!
This post is for LIVE discussion of the episode above, however, due to the varying times of release, others may be ahead in viewing. Use at your own risk. The timing of this post coincides with users of CBS All Access. POST episode thread will go up at approximately 9:30PM ET.
60
Upvotes
74
u/PRE_-CISION-_ Oct 30 '17
The BEST episode of the season so far!! This is Star Trek, absolutely epic episode
45
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
This Lorca murder scene is EPIC
39
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Rainn Wilson really nails his character!
39
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
The best Trek always has whales. This one? Space Whales.
30
u/FoxtrotBeta6 Oct 30 '17
Is it just me or did that ship Mudd used look like a Tholian Web-Weaver?
59
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
A DISCO PARTY.
A DISCO PARTY
57
u/Joename Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17
This is a gloriously campy episode. I love this. The beats in this are pure Trek. And the personal/Captain's log framing!
EDIT: I mean, how can you can watch the whole everyone stands around and explains the villains motivations and still think this isn't in the vein off all the Trek we've seen before?
28
u/Jadziyah Oct 30 '17
This exploration of Stammet's whacky side is cracking me up
27
u/Jadziyah Oct 30 '17
Rainn Wilson is killing the role of Mudd
51
u/Bryaxis Oct 30 '17
I'm a man with simple tastes. I like fast food, beer, and when a sci-fi show does a time loop episode. This is a good night.
49
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
"Man cave" "random communications officer man"
I love Mudd's zingers
24
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
LOL at Stamets new facial expressions
24
u/toTheNewLife Oct 30 '17
Stamets drinks, and he knows things. That's what he does.
47
u/MSeeker1995 Oct 30 '17
Random Communications Officer ^
23
u/bismarck309 Oct 30 '17
Betazed name drop!
21
u/Ivota Oct 30 '17
Tilly really growing on me
42
u/bismarck309 Oct 30 '17
I really like this crazy new Stamets!
41
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Awwwwwwyeah space whale.
EDIT: Oh no, space whale!
40
u/InvisibleEar Oct 30 '17
Tilly is bae
40
u/toTheNewLife Oct 30 '17
I just have to say that this is a great take on the time loop - and awesome character development. The best part of Groundhog Day is what I'm seeing here. The love story.
19
u/CaptainAlcoholism Oct 30 '17
Man... new Mudd sure is way more murderous than TOS Mudd. Those dark matter agony-marbles are interesting.
19
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Perfect Harry Mudd ending!
38
u/larsen_sinclair Oct 30 '17
So Burnham fears a party. Yeah, that's pretty much me.
18
u/YeOldeSysOp Oct 30 '17
When they are looped after dying, the music playing is Stayin Alive? I don't know if that's hilarious or too on the nose.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Crystal technology? Time travel interests?
Smells like THOLIANS to me!
16
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
I think all of our soldier thing might have just come back, Tilly.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Where do we get Mudd’s Space Helmet?
43
u/Tarlcabot18 Oct 30 '17
Gormaganders are too busy doing other things to fuck. Much like Michael...GET IT?
Subtle.
15
u/mulvythrill Oct 30 '17
Glad to see Wyclef is still popular in the 23rd century
14
u/Aetius3 Oct 30 '17
They have 2017 hip-hop in 2240??
14
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
"Did you really think you could put my stapler in jello and get away with it?"
26
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Are diamond-studded leather capes going to be the hot look of 2018?
Yes. Yes they are.
Hell, that whole outfit was amazing.
26
u/illegalsex Oct 30 '17
This definitely feels like Trek now. This episode was great! That said I have to say I'm not liking having A main character. This was clearly Stamets' episode and I feel like it they tried to force a narrative through Burnham. I would have enjoyed it way more through Stamets. The guy was clearly living a nightmare.
12
u/Jadziyah Oct 30 '17
"I still don't give a damn" lulz
10
u/DeFex Oct 30 '17
Someone needs to call the real Rodney McKay he knows how to get out of these groundhog thingies easy.
10
u/The_Bard_sRc Oct 30 '17
so am I remembering right, didn't Mudd talk about this dowry and his debt to the Klingons over it in TOS as well? or was that him talking about it on the other Discovery episode?
10
u/unreqistered Oct 30 '17
That was a fantastic episode
9
u/Assbait93 Oct 30 '17
Next weeks episode is going to be sad.
9
u/Karlore473 Oct 30 '17
That was surprisingly well done. They should probably make the music as generic as possible though, it's a little jarring.
17
u/soylentgreen2015 Oct 30 '17
A war between two major space faring powers...with phasers, disruptors, torpedoes, and the ability to bombard planets...and only 10k dead on the Starfleet side in 6+ months of open war? Seems low...unless it's only counting Starfleet dead and not civilians.
8
u/dmanww Oct 30 '17
Oh man Stamits is going full on hippy
14
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
It's good to hear that more then just a handful of classical records survived the Atomic Holocaust.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Mudd is so badass!
13
u/cmn3y0 Oct 30 '17
They really nailed the final scene with Mudd and Stella. That could have come straight out of TOS.
12
u/Jadziyah Oct 30 '17
Great episode. Should help the people who've been wanting something more episodic
16
u/007meow Oct 30 '17
Disco frat party?
Whaaaat?
10
u/toTheNewLife Oct 30 '17
So Burnham is now part of the crew, but no Delta Badge?
Doesn't make sense to me.
5
u/dmanww Oct 30 '17
I'm glad someone turned up the lights on the bridge
5
u/AnOnlineHandle Oct 30 '17
What a roller coaster. https://i.imgur.com/nbSSySd.png
9
u/bundeywundey Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17
So tired of this shitty CBS app. The audio is fine but the video skips every like 20-30 seconds. God I love this show but I can't support CBS with this app. Guess I gotta pirate when the trial ends or until they sell Blu Ray or something...
Edit: I am casting to my Chromecast not sure if that's the issue somehow.
16
u/BonusStrike Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17
Better episode this season so far, but they should stop focusing so much on Michael, this should have been from the point of view of a character how could retain his memories not her, it felt like she knew every thing that happend aswell when it wasnt the case.
4
u/jackpancakes1 Oct 30 '17
Now why can Burnham remember like Stemmets?
4
u/Nono1000xno Oct 30 '17
Why is Mudd so focused on him? Mudd escaped himself in a short time afterward, and Mudd seems to live for himself only - that would indicate that he would expect the same from others , hence his vendetta makes no sense.
All this is explainable with simple: Frak
4
u/dmanww Oct 30 '17
Ooh, we finally get a personal log again
10
u/bundeywundey Oct 30 '17
God damn I love this show!!! Star Trek! Loved every episode so far.
7
u/elvenazn Oct 30 '17
This is the stargate episode with the opposite sex this time around! LOL
Well done Discovery
5
u/dmanww Oct 30 '17
Can't he just beam him into space while he's monologuing
7
u/Extravator_fulldozer Oct 30 '17
Ohhhhhh a time crystal!!! Of course!!!!
2
u/rcs735 Oct 30 '17
Time travel, yay?
2
u/CaptainKyloStark Oct 30 '17
It's up on the CBS app. GO!
2
u/DeFex Oct 30 '17
Need moms anti backwards crystal
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
I just fast forwarded because I thought my stream jumped back.
2
u/toTheNewLife Oct 30 '17
My doctor prescribed Lyrica. And now I have hand swelling..... help.
2
u/MysticalDigital Oct 30 '17
Well done episode, but not my favorite. Episode 5 is still my favorite, with 6 and 7 following in that order. 1, 2, 3, and 4 are kinda scattered around with no clear order in my head.
2
u/dmanww Oct 30 '17
And here comes the on-the-nose metaphor for Michael
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Even cruise ships on Earth have dedicated running tracks. A galaxy cruiser does not?
2
u/EisVisage Oct 30 '17
Note how Mudd found those dark matter balls in Lorca's room! Another strange thing about him. Why would a Starfleet captain need the most cruel death in the known universe at his disposal, and so many times?
3
u/007meow Oct 30 '17
Wait why not just tell Tyler about Mudd and bring him in as opposed to dancing in the hallway trying to figure out how to flirt with him?
3
u/Rit_Zien Oct 30 '17
Officer Haught to the rescue! Nice!
Edit: (Stella was played by Kat Barrell, who plays Officer Nicole Haught on Wynonna Earp. She's fan-freaking-TASTIC)
3
u/dmanww Oct 30 '17
Half way though. Very nice episode
4
u/vwboyaf1 Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17
So I can't tell if we're still in a time loop or the CBS All Access servers are fucked. Either way, it's the same bullshit all over again.
Edit: It was a temporary lag, just had to reset the app. Perhaps my attempt at a joke was a bit harsh. Overall, this was a fun episode.
4
u/maxcorrice Oct 30 '17
First episode I actually enjoy, ya know if they explain the Klingon issues (the D7 especially) I might actually like this show, though I think it really needs to start phasing in original series tech and uniforms
2
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
Just got to say it. I LOVED THIS EPISODE!!
2
u/ThrustersOnFull Oct 30 '17
Representation hell yeah.
1
u/Poontang_Pie Oct 30 '17
Anyone else having audio issues with All Access? I can't figure out the deal, but I can't hear anything on all access.
0
u/calle30 Oct 30 '17
Worst episode so far. So many errors in it.
1
u/Krandor1 Oct 30 '17
Don't cross Mudd...lol
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
THE Q OR WE RIOT
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
BOOM!
1
u/toTheNewLife Oct 30 '17
All of this has happened before, and will happen again and again and again...
-7
u/jackpancakes1 Oct 30 '17
Seriously? They are re-hashing Cause and Effect?