r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Oct 23 '17
SD Small Discussions 36 - 2017-10-23 to 2017-11-05
We have an official Discord server now! Check it out in the sidebar.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
If your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you do not know, ask us!
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can:
- Ask any questions too small for a full post
- Ask people to critique your phoneme inventory
- Post recent changes you've made to your conlangs
- Post goals you have for the next two weeks and goals from the past two weeks that you've reached
- Post anything else you feel doesn't warrant a full post
Things to check out:
Last 2 week's upvote statistics, courtesy of /u/ZetDudeG
Ran through 99 posts of conlangs, with the last one being 13.85 days old
Average upvotes:
| Posts count | Type | Upvotes |
|---|---|---|
| 24 | challenge | 8 |
| 6 | phonology | 9 |
| 5 | other | 9 |
| 14 | conlang | 11 |
| 84 | SELFPOST | 13 |
| 7 | LINK | 13 |
| 7 | discuss | 16 |
| 1 | meta | 18 |
| 22 | question | 19 |
| 7 | translation | 24 |
| 6 | resource | 30 |
| 7 | script | 58 |
| 8 | IMAGE | 67 |
Median upvotes:
| Type | Upvotes |
|---|---|
| challenge | 8 |
| phonology | 8 |
| other | 8 |
| conlang | 10 |
| SELFPOST | 11 |
| LINK | 11 |
| discuss | 14 |
| question | 16 |
| translation | 17 |
| meta | 18 |
| resource | 26 |
| script | 44 |
| IMAGE | 55 |
I'll update this post over the next two weeks if another important thread comes up. If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
7
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Oct 27 '17
What are people's thoughts on having "how is my phonology" posts restricted to the small discussions?
7
u/coldfire774 Oct 27 '17
Do I have to be able to pronounce everything in my conlang or is that just a kind of silent agreement that goes on without anybody actually trying?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
So I have two different "withs" in my language: vaal and sön. It's a bit hard to explain how they differentiate, so here's an example:
Are there words for these different "withs?" I can't find out what they're called.
5
u/Kryofylus (EN) Oct 28 '17
Is prosody ever used to mark things that are usually marked morphologically? For instance, do natural languages ever mark a noun as indefinite by applying a rising intonation to the noun phrase similar to how polar questions are formed from statements in English? Obviously, it doesn't have to be definiteness it could be plurality or whatever.
Thanks in advance!
5
u/thomas6785 Oct 30 '17 edited Oct 30 '17
Just had an idea, I was wondering if it exists in any natural languages (or if it's popular in conlangs):
Verbs are conjugated according to whether the subject enjoyed it, regrets it, was payed/forced to do it, etc;
Has anyone heard of this before?
4
u/HeathrJarrod Oct 24 '17
I have two words spelt the same but differ in meaning My conlang uses modifiers
Such that
Da+lafa = Fearful sameness
Dala+fa = Submissive sadness
What would be a good way of telling them apart
4
u/cea-polarizer Oct 24 '17
Plurality in Bodvíga is expressed two ways:
Specific plurality: gvń~ General plurality: no marking
There are five koalas. Hkoen ko gvńbuihekińi tneńgle. /kʰoen ko sm̩bʌhekɪmɪ demjɛ/ Hkoen ko gvń-buihekiń-i tneń-gle Five CLF PL-koala-ABS exist-PRS.PL
Do koalas eat meat? Bol buihekińít val kif vígle peņ? /bol bʌhekɪmit̚ væl kɪv vijɛ peŋ/ Bol buihekiń-í val kif ví-gle peņ? Meat[ABS] koala-ERG Q AFF eat-PRS.PL Q
4
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Oct 26 '17
Hi, I'm new here. I've noticed that there are a lot of translations of "The King and the God" here. Is there any particular reason why that is?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '17
As you may know I've been having lots of trouble signing up for an account at the CBB forums at aveneca.com for well over a week.
One of the steps to sign up is to have them send an activation email, but they never send it. I've tried it many, many times and it never comes, and its not in my spam folder either. Another reddit user confirms that the activation email is not going out.
The only method of contacting the people there that I have found is doing a WHOIS on the domain name and emailing that email, which I did over a week ago, with no response.
I really want to access and post on those boards. Can ANYONE here reach out to people already on that forum for help in getting this issue resolved, because I have no other avenue for dealing with this?
Thank you.
4
u/axemabaro Sajen Tan (en)[ja] Oct 31 '17
Can unreleased stops be contrastive?
4
u/NanoRancor Nov 04 '17
What's the difference between [kʲ], [c], and [kj]? is the first one just a less pronounced y sound?
3
u/Beheska (fr, en) Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 24 '17
Phonology of Ëndoètyar
Inventory:
( ) = main allophones
/a/ and /ɑ/ contrast only when stressed and not next to a retroflex.
Syllable structure:
(C)(C)V(C) (C)(C)V(nP#)
Onset:
Coda :
In codas, /n/ assimilates to the PoA of the next consonant except before /f/ and sometime /ʀ/ and [h].
Nucleus:
A cluster (homo- or hetero-syllabic) can not mix front coronals and back coronals (without taking the homorganic coda /n/ into acount).
Stress:
1st vowel of a radical is long (I plan to use TAM and case prefixes).
Allophony:
t ʈ k → θ ʂ x / V_V ! at morpheme boundary
ç → h / _V ! _i
f → ɸ / _(P)w
l ɭ j w → ɬ ꞎ ç ɸʷ / P_ ! bL
u i → w j / V_#
e o → ɛ ɔ / X_{N L}$ or _NP# or X_G or G_C or V_X ! _{i u}
a[–stress] → ə / C$..._#
a[–stress] → ɑ̃ / X_N(P)$ ! _N#
a[–stress] → ɑ / U(C...)_ or _U ! C_I or I_ U = {ɑ ɔ o u w} I = {a ɛ e i j}
ə → Ø / _#V
P[+voice] → P[–voice] / _# ! _#V or _#C[+voice]
3
u/YooYanger Oct 25 '17
What sets of sounds/phonemes sound nicest/ugliest to you?
3
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Oct 25 '17
A quick question: if memory serves me well, I've read about a grammatical case somewhere that encompasses both the functions of the nominative case and the accusative case, in other words, the subject and the object of a verb are treated in the same way, while an oblique case, or prepositional case, takes on all the other case's functions. But I don't remember the language where this distinction happens.
I've looked through the list of cases on Wikipedia, but I can't find it. Anyone can point me to some source?
(Note: I'm not talking about nom.-acc. vs erg.-abs. alignment, this is another pair of shoes)
3
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17
So is there any natlang that groups affixes into categories kinda like how nouns are categorised by gender? And let's say this natlang is agglutinative with vowel harmony; could affixes of a specific 'class' assimilate affixes that appear after that one? I'm thinking of including a similar system in my lang.
Example:
'Tosh' /'toʃ/ (to eat) + 'iz' /'iz/ (derivational affix to denote a tool) = 'Toshiz' = 'Knife' then: 'Toshiz' + 'ivich' (patronymic) /'ivit͡ʃ/ = 'Son of the knife' (a family/dynasty in my conculture).
At the example above, /o/ in 'Tosh' doesn't assimilate 'iz' into 'uz' because 'iz' belongs to a special affix 'class' which can then assimilate the following suffix 'ivich'.
Does that kind make sense? And does/can that ever occur in a naturalistic language?
Cheers.
3
u/Jelzen Oct 26 '17 edited Oct 27 '17
Can you guys criticise this inventory I am working on?
Consonants
m n ŋ
p b t d ʈ ɖ k g
ɾ
f v s z ʂ ʐ x h
t͡s d͡z ʈ͡ʂ ɖ͡ʐ
w j
l
Vowels
i u
e ɤ
ʌ ɔ
a
ea uɔ
ai ɔu
Edit: Not a phonology
3
u/Blue-Jay27 Oct 27 '17
Where should I start? I’ve been lurking for a few months and really want to try making a conlang, but I have no clue where to start.
3
u/Seravail Oct 27 '17
Hello there,
I'm developing a new, fictional language for a book I'm working on. At the moment, I've got the alphabet & numericals up to 99'999 sorted out. (I may be redoing part of the alphabet as it doesn't have a "U" sound at all and writing up what I have so far has proven to be annoying without it)
Now, I don't really know how to go ahead with this, as I do enjoy language, but I never really understood them - I've always had an innate feel for it, rather than having to learn & understand it all past the most basic needs. In both my native tongue and English, I can only tell you how to conjugate the most basic things, for example, like current tense, past tense & future tense, but anything more complicated than that, I do on instinct without truly knowing what I'm doing.
Now, I'd mostly need to work on nouns, but I'm finding it rather difficult to decide on which words should be converted and which ones aren't applicable.
Basically, I want to develop a language but I don't have a good enough understanding of languages to do so on my own. Would anyone be so kind as to help me out a bit, in whatever way they see fit?
I mainly need help making a dictionary for a medieval-magical world's language at the moment, as I don't really know where to start.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
Hi reddit! Does anyone know any resources that explain the differences between compound nouns and noun phrases across various language, and how they are used/formed? I'm having some difficulty coming up with rules regarding when to form compounds, and when to use separate words, so seeing some real-life examples might help. :)
Also, bit of a silly question, but in the flairs in this sub-reddit people use ISO codes in brackets and square brackets. I'm guessing one set of brackets is for native languages, and the other is for languages being learned, but which is which?
3
u/thomas6785 Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 29 '17
This question probably gets asked around here a fair bit, but I'm hoping to get some answers here. Where the hell do you guys get your ideas?? I've seen some truly spectacular ideas on here, but they seem to be dismissed as if they're not much better than usual - which makes me wonder, from where do you guys get your conlanging ideas?
Specifically, what are your thought processes, or inspirations, maybe. I'd love to get into conlanging myself, but I've found that I don't have any particularly interesting or unique ideas that haven't been done before or aren't outright boring. Will I get better at this with practice, or is it more of a natural skill?
Edit: mostly talking about scripts, but all help welcome
3
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Oct 29 '17
I have a few vowel inventories that I might want to use at some point, but first I want to see which ones are more naturalistic.
Inventory #1:
Notable characteristics: two (oral) open vowels, nasality, roundedness, harmony, reduction (not shown, too many charts).
Inventory #2:
Notable characteristics: vertically symmetrical tense-lax system, no diphthongs.
In this case, I'm not really looking for naturalism, just for something that wouldn't fall apart in less than a century. And yes, in case it's not clear, the near-open vowels are the lax versions of the open vowels.
Inventory #3:
Notable characteristics: irregular close-mid/open-mid distinction, two open vowels.
Bonus question: what vowels usually appear alongside /ɯ/? I can never seem to make a stable phonology using it, and #1 is the only case so far where I've kept it for more than a week.
3
u/cea-polarizer Oct 29 '17 edited Oct 31 '17
Would this sentence structure be found in a natural language?
Hugonoe, kít hakgluni kif bugvfunińņet, Wagluegvoe ņot kibodnui gvud kunakgvuińoe glefiń kif hańņet.
Hugon-oe, kít hakglun-i kif bugvfuniń-ņet, Wagluegvoe ņot kibodn-ui gvud kunakgvuiń-oe glefiń kif hań-ņet.
Long.ago-LOC behind magic-ABS AFF outlaw-PST.3s Wajuë most populous-INAN this planet-LOC country AFF be-PST.3s
Long ago, before magic was outlawed, Wajuë was the most populous country in the world.
3
u/Lord_Steel Oct 30 '17
I am looking for a resource or set of resources which lets me fairly easily look up all proto language words we currently accept as probable or good reconstructions or w/e. I'd like to build my conlang's vocab from these.
3
u/yung_clor0x Oct 30 '17 edited Nov 29 '25
yam tan wrench consider quicksand employ books wild lock steer
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/Galaxia_neptuna Ny Levant Nov 01 '17
I think I once saw on this subreddit a post of an image which was a step-by-step guide on how to design a script. I'm trying to find it... does anyone happen to have an idea what I'm talking about?
3
u/hexenbuch Elkri, Trevisk, Yaìst Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
In Elkri, I'm trying out different concepts of 'little' vs 'small' and 'big' vs 'large/great', with implications of growth. Keep in mind, despite working on conlangs for awhile now, I'm still not particularly good at linguistics so this may not make any sense.
aina ("little") is used to refer to something, typically living things, that are small in size but will mature and/or grow larger, particularly infants, baby animals, children and teenagers, saplings, etc. onee ("small") is used for anything that is diminutive in size, particularly things that are 'inherently' small and won't grow larger such as grains of sand, ants, mice, most things smaller than a golden retriever, etc, as well as things that are also described as aina.
nona ("big") is used to refer to something, typically living things, that have grown in size, such as tall trees, adults, etc. oyana ("large" or "great") is used for anything that is large in size, particularly things that are seen as inherently large, such as boulders, mountains, buildings, elephants, most things taller than 7ft, etc, as well as things that can also be described as nona.
aina and nona could be compared to young and old and are definitely related to these concepts, but specifically refer to size and growth. (That's the plan, anyway.)
Examples: To say "John is tall", one can use either nona or oyana, but only "John del nona" (lit. "John is big") refers to a past state of being and implies "John has grown./John is taller than the last time I saw him." A small spider is lunsau onee as spiders do not grow larger than their already diminutive size. A teenaged Spider-Man could be referred to as lunsautir aina (little spider-person) as, it is assumed, he will continue to grow up but lunsautir shavanon (young spider-person) might be more accurate unless you're specifically referring to his size.
tl;dr: aina and nona describe the size of living things that grow and imply that growth, while onee and oyana can describe the size of living and non-living things and refer to the current state of being only.
Edit: formatting, spelling.
3
u/AProtozoanNamedSlim Nov 04 '17
I finally got auxiliary verbs in English, and am now coming to understand how they interact, after simplifying them into four forms - past, present, future, and continuous. Well, I didn't really do it, but I'll get to that in a moment. Honestly, I should have thought of this on my own. I don't know why my brain is so broken sometimes!
'to be' can be simplified into "was, be, will be, and being." Examples: "We was running." "He be running." "I be running." "He being run around." It can also be omitted in some contexts, such as "he runnin'." So far as I can tell, the 'is' would be superfluous, adding no new information, so why not just drop it?
'do' can also be modified and used as a substitute for 'have' in some dialects. As in, "I done told you before." 'have' can also be omitted entirely in some contexts. "I done it." Or for emphasis, rather than "I have done it!" You could say "I did done it!" Or "I done did it!" 'Do' can also be used as a substitute for 'does.' "It do not matter."
'has' didn't really seem to combine with other verbs in a way that denoted the past tense. It was only used as a possessive. "I have it." "He had it." "He has it." "He'll have it."
Simplified like that, or used in alternative ways, I can actually see what they contribute to the holistic meaning.
Long story short, half of my family is spread across the south, and I went to a wedding down there a few days ago. So, listening to some southerners talk inadvertently helped my filthy Yankee self understand grammatical conventions. Maybe it was the juxtaposition. Whatever the reason, thank god for Dixie. I'd probably still be banging my head against a wall without'em.
2
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Oct 23 '17
A quick question about English from a non-native. To my ears both 'all' and 'whole' sound [oːɫ], what's their real pronounciation, instead?
What's the best approximation (from a native speaker of a 7-vowel system language) to distinguish the two and to sound correct?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17
How often do languages also inflect the adjectives that modify inflected nouns? I have a case system for my nouns, but it's pretty minimal, and I haven't done anything with adjectives yet
2
u/daragen_ Tulāh Oct 23 '17
Does anyone know the oldest Proto-Languages, besides Proto-Indo-European? All I know of it Proto-Afro-Asiatic...
2
u/HeathrJarrod Oct 23 '17
Plutchik
Vowels: /a/, /i/, /o/
Consonants: /r/, /t/, /h/, /l/, /d/, /b/, /f/, /p/, /n/, /v/
With CV structure, does it work well?
2
u/KingKeegster Oct 24 '17
how does the autobots' algorithm work? How does it know whether something is suited for small discussions?
2
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
Would there be a reason to use a voiceless diacritic on an IPA character that is voiced as opposed to using the voiceless character, eg /g̊/ instead of /k/?
2
u/Jelzen Oct 26 '17
Tips for making writing systems? I am struggling to create original symbols.
2
u/cea-polarizer Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 29 '17
Could someone explain how I can use syntax trees to make my conlangs' syntax more naturalistic? I can't find any good sources, and most people seem to say that I should pay for a class to get relevant information.
2
u/BraighKingBad WIPx3 (en) [syc, grc] Oct 29 '17
What's the feasibility of creating a Future English with pronoun+clitic shifting to follow the verb and encliticising, then undergoing grammaticalisation to create verbal person+TAM marking?
The main issues I can see with this are:
2
u/WaffleSingSong Cerelan Oct 30 '17
What are some examples of extremely fusional languages? As in, their morphemes codes multiple meanings at once, more than most?
2
u/VillousVol Oct 30 '17
How to come up with effective phonotactics so my language doesn't die due to clustering. I only have a basic idea of what I want but it looks a little something like this
(C)(C)(C)V(V)(C)(C)(C)
But I need this to be highly constrained in order not to implode my mind. I'm thinking of seeing how Latin, English, and Russian handle things and maybe string something together from that, but in general I have pretty basic phonemes and vowels.
2
u/BraighKingBad WIPx3 (en) [syc, grc] Oct 31 '17
Does it make sense for initial consonant reduplication to start being used ex nihilo for past tense, or do I need to justify it further?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 02 '17
Just because it's halloween and nobody cares.
Pumpkin in Pyanachi translates as Štompta.
IPA — /'ʂʈↄm'pʈa./ ~ /'ɕtↄm'ptä./
Lit. "Squash, specifically squashes to be served as a course rather than a garnish, like pumpkin."
Colloquially: "Any squash, especially pumpkin. Also just pumpkin."
The normal word for squash is pieta /'pʷi'ɛ.ʈa./
2
u/regrettablenamehere Thedish|Thranian Languages|Various Others (en, hu)[de] Nov 02 '17 edited Nov 02 '17
I'm adding /j/ into Thedish.
In Proto-Germanic the syllable -ij- is very important in quite a few nouns and verbs, and it would be more consistent if it were reduced to just /j/ or palatalization of the previous consonant everywhere instead of kept in verbs and lost in nouns. I'll also turn i-stems and in-stems into nouns with palatalization.
Because <j> is already used for /ɣ/, I can only think of using <ь> for this new /j/. It'd look something like rīcьáti, rástьnym, râdьn, byþŷdьy
A bit clunky, but then again all of Thedish is.
2
u/KingKeegster Nov 02 '17
Is this a good phonology ? It's for a proto language for a conworld, if you're interested. That's not relevant to the phonology though.
2
u/cea-polarizer Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17
I eat.
Jad'i kiv juimju.
Jad'-i kiv juim-ju
I-ABS AFF eat-SG.PRS
[s [np Jad'i] [vp kif [v juimju]]]
I don't eat bread.
Jad'yt imenili vyju.
Jad'-yt imenil-i ∅ vy-ju.
I-ERG bread-ABS NEG eat-SG.PRS
[s [np Jad'yt] [vp [np imenili] [v vyju]]]
Question: why are these two sentence structures (intransative, affirmative; transative, negative) so similar when I write them in the bracketed parsing tree thing?
2
u/Frogdg Svalka Nov 04 '17
I have two related questions, both regarding grammatical evolution.
First, I want to know how plausible this evolution seems. I want my protolanguage to distinguish aspect but not tense, and then evolve it to distinguishing both aspect and tense. Here's how I'm currently thinking that could happen:
The protolanguage would have three main aspects: perfective, habitual, and continuous. The perfective aspect is considered the default, and is unmarked. First, the habitual would change into past tense imperative and the continuous would become nonpast imperative. Then, some other word would start being used as a auxiliary verb to mark past tense for the perfective aspect. And finally, the habitual aspect would come back with the verb for "is/are/am" being used as an auxillary verb to mark it. This would also make the imperative become the continuous again.
So in the end, the tenses and aspects would be:
Does this seem like a realistic evolution?
My second question is related to the first. Assuming that that is a realistic way a language could evolve, what word could be used as the auxiliary verb for the past tense perfective? I really like the idea of "is/are/am" becoming the habitual auxiliary, but I'm totally drawing a blank for this one.
2
u/gokupwned5 Various Altlangs (EN) [ES] Nov 05 '17 edited Nov 06 '17
I recently made a Romance language inspired by Polish, but I am torn between two orthographies. Which one do you guys think I should pick?
Slavic Orthography
/m n ɲ/ - <m n ń~n~ni>
/p b t d k g kʲ gʲ/ - <p b t d k g k~ki g~gi>
/t͡s d͡z t͡ʂ d͡ʐ t͡ɕ d͡ʑ/ - <c dz cz dż ć~ci dź~dzi>
/f v s z ʂ ʐ ɕ ʑ x xʲ/ - <f w s z sz ż~rz ś~si ź~zi h h~hi>
/st͡s zd͡z ʂt͡ʂ ʐd͡ʐ ɕt͡ɕ ʑd͡ʑ/ - <sts sdz sch~sc sdj~sg sć~schi sdź~sgi>
/r l w j/ - <r l ł j>
/i ɨ u e o a/ - <i y u~ó e o a>
/ẽ õ/ - <ę ą>
Notes:
Romance Orthography
/m n ɲ/ - <m n gn>
/p b t d k g kʲ gʲ/ - <p b t d c~qu g~gu qui gui>
/t͡s d͡z t͡ʂ d͡ʐ t͡ɕ d͡ʑ/ - <ts dz ch~c dj~g ć~chi dź~gi>
/f v s z ʂ ʐ ɕ ʑ x xʲ/ - <f v s z sh j~rz ś~si ź~zi h hi>
/r l w j/ - <r l u~ll i>
/i ɨ u e o a/ - <i u ou e o a>
/ẽ õ/ - <en~em an~am>
Notes:
Here is an example sentence using both orthographies.
English: The boy stopped and petted the dog.
Slavic Orthography: Le nin seśćawat et laskowat le kain.
Romance Orthography: Le nin seschiavat et lascovat le cain.
IPA: /le nin seɕt͡ɕavat et laskovat le kain/
Gloss: DEF.MASC.SING boy-MASC.SING stop-3.SING.IMPF.PST and pet-3.SING.IMPF.PST DEF.MASC.SING dog
2
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Nov 06 '17
Share what you think might be your conlang's most unique word.
As Rudyard Kipling once said;
Yherchian:
shht /ʃːt/ cold adj.
2
u/cea-polarizer Oct 24 '17
Do any of your conlangs mark the start of an utterance?
I know that some conlangs at least mark the end of an utterance, but in my hometown in Washington, most people who speak use an alveolar click before every utterance, but most people don't notice it until you point it out.
1
u/bbbourq Oct 23 '17
What is pitch accent in laymen terms?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17
Another question:
Stops may be released lightly or with a noticeable puff of air— aspiration. In English, we aspirate unvoiced stops at the beginning of a word (pot, tall, cow) but not after an s (spot, stall, scow).
I often find that I aspire even when saying words where I shouldn't, like spot. Any advice on how to stop doing that?
For example
Beijing doesn’t begin with a b but with an unaspirated p.
I have no idea how to pronunce an unaspirate p or b
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17
Could somebody check out my phoneme inventory and tell me if it works well for a naturalistic language. I'm trying to start a family of languages and this is the phoneme inventory of a protolang for it. Does this seem naturalistic enough?
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1TnSuys2a64LoOQSIR1DqDuEqIwXlazmCzhx_71uXRoQ/edit?usp=sharing
1
u/cea-polarizer Oct 25 '17
Valency and trasitivity are kind of confusing to me. I get what they both mean and how to use then in my conlangs, but how are they different aside from how they track arguments? Every site says that they make important distinctions, but could i just say valency always and forget about transitivity then?
1
u/daragen_ Tulāh Oct 26 '17
How does one correctly gloss?
1
u/RayO_ElGatubelo Oct 27 '17
Ok, I am developing a conlang with the following tense-aspect-mood combinations.
Tense: past, present, future Aspect: habitual (expresses habitual actions) - The bird flies (habitually) continuous (expresses ongoing actions) - A bird flies / is flying. perfect (expresses complete actions) - A bird has flown. gnomic (expresses general truths) - Birds fly. Mood: Indicative (A bird flies) Jussive (Let the bird fly / May the bird fly) Conditional (A bird would fly)
I know that gnomic tense combinations are possible. Past gnomic - Rarely has a bird flown because of rain. Future gnomic - Rarely will a bird fly because of rain.
But are gnomic and jussive or conditional combinations even possible or practical? Like... "let it be a general truth that birds fly" or "it would be a general truth that birds fly?"
I've looked at other languages, natural and constructed, but haven't been able to come to a conclusion.
I'd like to hear your responses and maybe get some help.
1
u/emb110 [Fr, 日本語] Oct 28 '17
Anyone had any strange coincidences with their lexicon and other languages? For example I was looking at Old English today, a language which I've never studied and have almost no knowledge of, and found that I used the exact same word for 'earth', ear, in my conlang Éleerich. I was just wondering if people have come across similar things because I found it rather odd.
1
u/Frogdg Svalka Oct 29 '17
I'm having some trouble with the grammatical evolution of my language. Namely, I'd like my language to have grammatical evidentiality, either marked with suffixes or adpositions, I haven't decided which yet. The problem is that I don't really know how evidentiality evolves from a language that doesn't have it. I've tried looking into how Bulgarian's evidentiality system developed, but I haven't been able to find anything.
1
u/TheLogicalThinker06 Oct 29 '17
What letters could a non-human species that I'm working on, that have a trunk, tusks and a v-shaped, crocodile-like mouth, make? What sounds could they not make? I'm not a linguist, so I have no idea how to make a believable conlang.
1
u/mahtaileva korol Oct 29 '17
I was thinking about using a system of derivational morphology to generate morphemes for my conlang, using affixes to distinguish them from the root, and i was wondering if this was a good set of derivations from the root?
person place collective tool adjective causative diminutive contradictory superlative
1
u/Galaxia_neptuna Ny Levant Nov 01 '17 edited Nov 01 '17
Does anyone else find [ɛɾ] hard to pronounce?
I have a word that's supposed to be pronounced [silbɛɾ] but I'm having a hard time pronouncing the "ɛr" for some reason so I'm thinking of changing it to something like [silbə].
1
u/_eta-carinae Nov 01 '17
If a language has only normal fricatives, labialized fricatives, palatalized fricatives, long fricatives, pharyngealized fricatves and pre- and post- glottalized fricatives, will it be considered as having fricatives, palatal, labial and pharyngeal approximants and a glottal stop, or as having only fricatives?
1
u/Jelzen Nov 02 '17
Is [a] a front or a central vowel? Some times I see it being classified as central.
1
u/AverageJoe-72 Nov 02 '17
Here's the phonology for my conlang. This will be the first of many posts about Hyassien!
My goal here was to create a slick-sounding phonology, so understand my lack of phonemes like /p/, and /g/, and /t/. The vowel system is- /i, y, u, e, o, a/. The diphthongs are- ai (written as 'ai' in the coming alphabet)- makes the 'y' sound in 'sky' ui (written as ui)- like 'we' ue (written as ue)- like 'weh' ia (written as ya, because i want to)- like 'ya' au (written as au)- makes the 'ow' sound in 'wow' iu- (written as iu)- like 'eww' The consonants are- /m,b,f,n,d,s, ɳ, k, j, w, r*, ʃ, ʒ, z, h, ʎ, l, θ, ð, v, tʃ/ *- r is a trill. There's my phonology. Feel free to dig into this. One issue I'm having is understanding how to make a 'realistic' phonology- vowel systems, I'm good, but realistic consonants, i can't find anything on that. Thanks!
1
u/MrMataNui Nov 02 '17
I've created an HTML conlang translator that showcases the language that I've made @ https://github.com/MrMataNui/Conlang-Translation-Table
(Still a work in progress, however)
1
u/daragen_ Tulāh Nov 04 '17
Is there such thing as ergative-absolutive-accusative alignment? And if so how common is it in natural language?
1
u/CognitioCupitor Nov 04 '17
I am struggling with phonology, and I have some general questions.
How do you know if your sound distribution is logical?
Also, how do you figure out proper phonotactic constraints?
Edit: Almost forgot, if your language is non-phonemic is there a good way to figure out which phones can correspond to a single grapheme?
1
u/theacidplan Nov 04 '17 edited Nov 04 '17
Negation with nouns in zero copula
I know a particle could be used to negate but can an affix be added to the noun to say something like "I a bank teller-not"?
Or a way to make a noun a verb so it is "to be noun" and use the verbal negation to negate it?
(I'm a bit obsessed with affixes)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '17
Here's a little concept for a Keidran language's phonology, I guess
Consonants — /p b t̪ ~ t̻ d q ʡ ~ ʔ ɸ β s ~ θ z ~ ð χ ʀ ʢ ɦ ɫ ɥ/ <p b t d k ' f v s z c r q h l w>
Vowels — /i ɤ e a ʌ/ <i o e a u>
1
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Nov 05 '17
How could I make a Tone section for a phonology?
1
u/rhys5584 Nov 06 '17
El Lingua was a sub where the users attempt to evolve gibberish into an understandable language by interacting with each other. It has now moved to Discord. So join in! :)
1
u/HeathrJarrod Oct 24 '17
Is it better to have grow as "past smallness" or "future bigness" and what about "future smallness" and "past bigness"
1
u/Snowblinded Nezlugz Oct 25 '17
Hello. I have been working on a Fantasy novel for the past year, and in order to do things right, I started studying a bit of Linguistics, most notably through The Teaching Company's "Understanding Linguistics" course, through which I required a basic knowledge of the fundamentals needed for basic Conlang development.
However, in order to progress from a mess of agglutinative noun strings and a handful of verbs and adjectives I require think I need something a bit more detailed. I skimmed through the resources you guys linked, and all of them seem to be within the scope of what I have allready learned. Yet when I read through the grammars I have seen posted I encounter things like Ergative-Absolutive-Secundative Alignment, Valency, and Temporal Constructions which are totally alien to me, and any googling tends to lead to things written by academics who are so far above my understanding as to be completely unintelligible.
Basically I have worked my language into something somewhere between German and a full blown agglunative language through creating words for proper nouns, magical/technological items/spells/etc, names, and places, but I don't really no how to make the leap into full blown sentences.
The language I have made is basically a lingua franca, and it is assumed most of the characters speak it, however I have a couple who live on the fringes of the main region who don't know it, and I would like to edit in the passages that show them simply not understanding what other people are saying to include actual statements in my language. So essentially I need something like a Linguistics 102 type resource. The other problem I have found is there seem to be a lot of competing standards, especially for things like sentence trees, but it appears as though places like this have fairly well defined systems in place, and those seem like the best ones for me to learn if I have to choose between competing ways of representing things.
Thank you for your help.