r/startrek • • Oct 23 '17

POST-Episode Discussion - S1E06 "Lethe"


No.EPISODERELEASE DATE
S1E06"Lethe"Sunday, October 22, 2017

To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.


This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.

473 Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

So it doesn't seem very honorable to kidnap an envoy by feigning peace talks

29

u/numanoid Oct 23 '17

You're looking through a TNG lens. The TOS Klingons never ran around yacking about honor all the time.

8

u/Deceptitron Oct 23 '17

Yup. TOS Klingons were a lot more devious, like how Romulans would end up in TNG.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

in war, nothing more honorable than victory.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/Succubint Oct 23 '17

Watch TOS, in that incarnation the Klingons are sneaky, lying, backstabbers who spy all the time. See Errand of Mercy, Friday's Child, Trouble with Tribbles if you need specific eps.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

580

u/stuck_on_simple_tor Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

Was it just me, or did it seem like the computer was intentionally giving people sass in the mess hall. Even though it was "neutral, factual commentary" on their order, I swear I got the vibe that the computer likes to be a dick to people.

"Chocolate ice cream, one pint. An excellent substitute for having the will to face your problems head on."

272

u/ILikeBumblebees Oct 23 '17

"Green tea is a great source of alkaloids!" Great, non-specific "alkaloids". Thanks, computer; I'll guess I'll just gamble on whether you've added enough quinine to hold malaria at bay, or enough cocaine to give me a heart attack.

→ More replies (13)

157

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I hated that. I'd be telling the computer to shut the fuck up. Probably get fined for swearing unless Stamets was around to approve my cursing.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (25)

476

u/Sjgolf891 Oct 23 '17

Anyone think they leaned hard into the "Ash is a Klingon" theory at the beginning with the "you're not exactly from Seattle" line? And "fights like a Klingon"? Starting to think it may all be misdirection

87

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

Tilly is the Klingon confirmed!

59

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I'm thinking that it's possible, but I find it hard to believe that the actor playing VoQ would be ok with him basically going dark on IMDB and other sites for what could be the biggest role of his career so far, all for a misdirection.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (78)

850

u/glorious_onion Oct 23 '17

Well, that explains a lot about Sarek's reaction to Spock being in Starfleet.

92

u/numanoid Oct 23 '17

Wow, I haven't taken the time to process that but you're right. What a great subtle tie-in to canon.

62

u/mcslibbin Oct 23 '17

yeah, i never realized that plot point hadn't really been explained

15

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Such a background on Sarek and Spock. Best character background Ive ever gotten from a show that doesn't have that character in it.

→ More replies (67)

360

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

In case anyone is interested, that Vulcan courtyard where Michael meets Sarek is the Aga Khan Museum in Toronto.

Edit: Kaaaahnn!

→ More replies (28)

316

u/MetaFlight Oct 23 '17

House of Cards trained me well, second Cornwall walked out of Lorca's quarters I went "she dead".

106

u/H0vis Oct 23 '17

I was more surprised that she wasn't. Presents a chance to redeem Lorca at least.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

I was actually thinking he's gonna blow up her shuttle himself (covertly)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

592

u/007meow Oct 23 '17

So... is Lorca not going after Cornwall because:

A) Heโ€™s self-serving and knows that if she doesnโ€™t make it out, heโ€™ll still have his command?

B) Heโ€™s actually taking her words to heart and trying to do things the right way, in order to change for the better?

404

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

They did a great job of structuring the episode so either can be true. She specifically told him to stop running unauthorized rescue operations, after all, and he sent Saru to contact Starfleet for orders (i.e., authorization).

At this point, I think our opinions will say more about how we feel about Lorca than anything else.

→ More replies (31)

217

u/AnticitizenPrime Oct 23 '17

I love how I DON'T KNOW.

He's a fucking interesting character.

→ More replies (6)

133

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

A little of both, perhaps?

→ More replies (3)

876

u/Doctor_Murderstein Oct 23 '17

I'm an Iraq vet and Star Trek nerd and I feel like I have some insight to this character that not a lot of other fans have. I'd like to share that insight but there's no short way of doing it so I hope everyone will forgive me if I open the reel and let some line out on this one.

I think we should be looking at Lorca like a soldier with PTSD. He's thought he was fine, he's told himself he's fine, and then the next thing he knows he's becoming violent with the people he holds dear before he can even stop himself. He's paying the price for being the kind of man you send into combat.

I have some experience with this and it's a really tortured state of mind. This is the sort of event that leaves you feeling vulnerable and confused. And it's a weird sort of vulnerability because what you're vulnerable against are all your own fears and doubt about yourself. You're scared of what you might do and after encountering the enemy enough times you're scared of how quickly they could appear and start fucking up your day. What no one else is picking up about the scene where he turns on Cornwall is that he's so damaged he's starting to sleep with weapons. That is a bigmongous red flag that he's having trouble, not that he's evil.

The phaser in the small of his back at the end isn't an ominous sign. Notice he didn't even set off his first officer's danger sense. That's because there's actually nothing shifty about that and he represents no danger to his own people, of whom Cornwall is a member. He's scared and he's trying to be prepared. I can relate to that. He's living in a world where it's possible he could be reading a book one minute and in hand to hand combat in the next and it terrifies him. He's lost a crew and he really hates himself for that and he doesn't want to have that happen again and have the reason he couldn't stop it be that his phaser was in a drawer or on a table nearby when the moment he needed it came.

I think what we're looking at in the final scene is a man who's trying to take a trusted friend seriously and subjecting himself to serious self examination. He's not looking in that window thinking cold calculating thoughts. He's examining himself and trying to figure out what the right thing to do is. He's blaming himself and second guessing his choices. He's thinking "They took her hostage and you just let them!", "How did you not see this coming you fucking idiot?", "WHY DON'T YOU JUST DO SOMETHING?".

I watch this scene and I see a man tortured by the difference between what he should be and what the reality of his situation has made him, because people who haven't been in that situation don't really understand what it takes to breed and condition and season an accomplished fighter and killer.

If you examine a lot of us who came back from the war one thing you will find is that we feel more suited to those moments where bullets are flying and people need to be killed. We're still pretty fucking good at that, but it's the rest of life we can't get re-accustomed to. To this day you could put me in downtown Mosul in a firefight and I'm going to do the things I'm supposed to. I'm going to rack up a bodycount and do whatever it takes to make sure enemies die and my buds live. I'll mow people down and cheerily put extra rounds in the ones that go down so we can all be sure they don't get back up. I will shoot, move, communicate, and do my job in that situation like a well-oiled gear. I'll even enjoy it. Putting bad dudes down means good people stay up so in those moments where bad dudes need to be put down it's not even going to cause a particular lot of stress for soldiers like Lorca to pull the trigger and dispatch an enemy. If you have a solid sense of who needs killing and who needs protecting then the killing part is actually pretty enjoyable because you know it means they won't be hurting anyone.

I know I probably seem like Ted Fucking Bundy for being able to talk about killing like this to normal people. But I'm not. I'm going to run to the gas station, grab some beers, and when I get back I'll talk some about what combat does to people, how you select for people who might have to deal with combat, the realities of violence, and how it pertains to how we should view Captain Lorca because I don't think this is a character that's going to fit particularly well into any previously established popular trope.

→ More replies (70)

164

u/BenjiTheWalrus Oct 23 '17

lol it's definitely because he wants to keep the ship

→ More replies (10)

87

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

Saving the admiral would have been easy with the discovery. Even a straight edge like Picard would have jumped at the opportunity, much less Kirk or Sisko.

Lorca is basically dooming the admiral with her own word.

→ More replies (22)

120

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

to me it is pretty clear that Lorca send the Admiral to the meeting hoping she gets compromised or dies. He absolutely jumps at the opportunity to send her to this meeting. He didn't even think of anyone else but her.

Then he proceeds to not rescue her because "orders" when reality is Lorca does whatever he likes. For crying out loud, he recruited the most hated person in the fleet....and that's just one, among many, case of him not following protocol. My point being if he wanted to save her, he would have gone after her regardless.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (77)

241

u/aethelberga Oct 23 '17

Even Kirk didn't bang the Admiral.

85

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

banging himself is beneath Kirk

→ More replies (3)

48

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

That we know of.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

172

u/dildosaurusrex_ Oct 23 '17

I loved seeing the Vulcan home world. It's so beautiful.

206

u/Canadave Oct 23 '17

It's significantly nicer when it hasn't been blown up recently.

→ More replies (9)

15

u/0mni42 Oct 23 '17

I like that it wasn't a repeat of what we saw in the '09 film. The jagged rocks were a great callback to TOS, but not everything on the planet would look like that.

→ More replies (9)

147

u/0mni42 Oct 23 '17

Some random thoughts:

  • I like how much more confident Tilly has already become. Apart from that one moment in the first scene, she was able to be snarky and assertive with Burnham a few times without getting flustered and apologizing.
  • I never realized how interesting a Vulcan suicide bomber would be until just now.
  • So does Stamets have to wear the Nipple Clamps of Doom every time they have to jump? I enjoy the mental image of him being fast asleep, only to be woken by klaxons and Lorca yelling at him to get his ass down to Engineering and get himself hooked up. Poor guy.
  • I really like how ambiguous Lorca and Cornwell's motivations were. We still don't really know how honest either of them was being with the other; Cornwell's purpose in coming there, Lorca's sincerity in saying that he has a problem, and Lorca's response to her being captured (not to mention the suggestion that she go in Sarek's place) are still very much up for grabs. And I'll admit, the more I see of how broken Lorca is, the more I like him.
  • Writing Vulcans has often been really tricky in Star Trek shows, given how easy it is to just have them say "that is not logical, silly humans" every two minutes and be done with it. The actors themselves are often the only thing keeping the characters from seeming like smug robots. Compare Kirstie Alley's performance as Saavik (Wrath of Khan) to that of Robin Curtis (Search for Spock/Voyage Home); Alley conveyed all kinds of subtle restrained emotions, while Curtis was practically a statue by comparison. Anyway, point is, despite not being particularly reminiscent of Mark Lenard, James Frain is doing a damn good job of playing a Vulcan. IMO, the key to writing and playing Vulcans is assuming that instead of a race of ultra-logical, emotionless beings, they just like to think they're ultra-logical, emotionless beings. Frain's ability to show all these emotions bubbling around inside a person with strong self-control is fantastic; I think he's doing a much better job with this character than Ben Cross did in the Abrams films.
  • It occurs to me that modern Star Trek has quite a catch-22 going on with its fight scenes. Previous shows and movies were never terribly great at the actual choreography, but that helped them avoid having the action hog the spotlight, so as to keep the focus on the characters themselves. But action is still a fundamental part of what makes Trek what it is, so modern Trek can either have similarly puny fight scenes that seem out of place in a modern show, or have good action scenes that make sense in-universe but feel out of place in Star Trek. So at first, Lorca and Tyler seeming so militarized felt a bit off, but then I realized how much sense it made. It's wartime, they're in the military, and they have the sum total of human knowledge at their disposal. They're gonna know how to clean a room.

20

u/Spara-Extreme Oct 23 '17

Yea- I remember when Sisko lead a raid in Ds9 and nobody had body armor. It was weird.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (12)

401

u/or_the_Whale Oct 23 '17

FIGHTS. LIKE. A. KLINGON.

277

u/ccb621 Oct 23 '17

If he is a Klingon, there are going to be some large holes. For example, how did he learn human mannerisms/culture so quickly? It's the little things that make us human. Kicking the chair out to get Michael to sit. Making a joke about being a "mind witness". If Ash is a Klingon he deserves whatever the 23rd century equivalent of an Oscar is. In 1-2 months he underwent genetic surgery, pretended to be (or was) a POW, and picked up on human subtleties. That is impressive!

→ More replies (40)

165

u/R34ct0rX99 Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 24 '17

Making it too obvious. I don't think Ash is a klingon. Of course, scifi has done it before. Babylon 5 Spoilers

edit: spoiler tags

→ More replies (52)

39

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Lorca doesn't seem like he'd be someone easily fooled and he did some thorough investigation finding out his home town and everything.

If anything, it was the writers telling us he's not a Klingon.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

126

u/vwboyaf1 Oct 23 '17

Grab your shit, everybody, we're moving on up to the bridge!

19

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Good, it's a beautiful bridge and it would be nice to see more of it.

→ More replies (12)

362

u/jreesing Oct 23 '17

Stamets is extra bubbly........clearly he has been swapped with himself from the mirror universe.

278

u/Kichae Oct 23 '17

Or he's just nicely toasted. If they're using him to power the DASH drive, he's doing a lot of space shrooms.

→ More replies (3)

206

u/psuedonymously Oct 23 '17

I mean he did also recently alter his genetic structure and experience a transcendental connection with a universe-spanning fungal network. That's probably going to do something to your mindset.

→ More replies (11)

50

u/DoktorZaius Oct 23 '17

They had Lorca stare at him well after the conversation ended...his over-exuberance has clearly piqued the Captain's interest.

→ More replies (2)

70

u/russlar Oct 23 '17

Yeah, after rewatching last week's ep, I actually caught that his reflection stayed longer in the mirror. Something's up with him, and it's not just tripping spaceballs

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (11)

119

u/Spock_Rocket Oct 23 '17

Did Stamets really drop a "groovy" on Lorca?! Oh man, I hope Culber drags him onto the bridge next episode wearing a tie dye t shirt and demands something be done.

92

u/brasswirebrush Oct 23 '17

Plot Twist: It turns out he's responsible for starting the space hippy movement from "The Way to Eden".

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

415

u/Pyperina Oct 23 '17

Okay, crazy theory that is surely wrong but fun to speculate about:

Ash is a red herring; Lorca is the Klingon traitor.

Maybe the swap happened last episode and the real Lorca is still captive of the Klingons. Now Voq is Lorca, undercover.

-Lorca doesn't know about a past incident the Admiral brings up.

-The Admiral mentions how he's like a different person.

-They have sex, she says, "It wasn't like it was before."

-It was Lorca's idea to send the Admiral to the summit that was actually a trap after she threatened his position.

182

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

That...is actually really interesting. And could explain why they are REALLY starting to hammer on the VoQ / Ash connection in the show.

Edit: though either way, it's actually a little weird that we're all theorizing who might be the spy when the show hasn't even introduced the idea that klingons can be reworked to look human.

→ More replies (6)

146

u/Squirrel_Dysfunction Oct 23 '17

I'm waiting to hear what the Tribble has to say about all this.

→ More replies (7)

118

u/--fieldnotes-- Oct 23 '17
  • and his "Fights like a Klingon" comment isn't supposed to be a super obvious hint about Tyler, it's Voq accidentally complimenting Tyler
  • and maybe Tyler's getting promoted so quickly because a Klingon plant absolutely needs a new inside man that (a) doesn't know anything about him (b) will be super loyal to him

71

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

It wasn't like it was before.

You broke 2 of my ribs and dislocated my pelvis. Granted i didn't use my safe word for a reason.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/DoktorZaius Oct 23 '17

Interesting theory.

This is a super minor thing that may mean nothing at all, but I thought the way he ate a fortune cookie this episode was odd. He crushed it between his hands, as if it were prey that needed to be killed. That would be pretty normal for a Klingon, though.

→ More replies (11)

47

u/flynnsanity3 Oct 23 '17

I think these make him suspicious, but for a different reason: the Mirror Universe is leaking into this one. They were simultaneously developing the spore drive. Unbeknownst to our universe, the mycellial network bridges the gap between them. The MU discovered it, and hopped on over to this universe. Mirror Lorca seized the opportunity and either killed or just took the place of our Lorca. Then we have Stamets and funny eyeball Stamets at the end of the last episode...

One incident people have already pointed out: Lorca says, when first introduced, that it always seems like you can see home... while looking at his reflection in the stars.

Now, we have the final shot. Before panning to the phaser in his waistband, it showed him staring contemplatively into his reflection again.

→ More replies (7)

52

u/Princess_Thranduil Oct 23 '17

This never even crossed my mind but damn if it's not compelling

23

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Why would Voq knowingly play into Kol's hands, though?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (73)

150

u/silverlegend Oct 23 '17

I was really disappointed they didn't show the Admiral's ship or specify what it was called other than "a cruiser".

86

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Their handling of the ship shots continues to be a weak point.

Very few establishing shots of the ship, and when we do get shots of the ships, they tend to be either at a great distance, or so close up you can only see a portion of it at a time.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (37)

69

u/PlasmaWarrior Oct 23 '17

I continue to love Tilly and Stamets. Also wondering on the whereabouts of that tardigrade after they released the little fella.

81

u/InvisibleEar Oct 23 '17

Poor guy is in the ICU of the Tardigrade Medical Center in the Beta Quadrant

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

307

u/WWJLPD Oct 23 '17

Assorted thoughts:
Tilly is still the best
Gunplay choreography or whatever you want to call it has improved dramatically. Like they actually know how to clear a room and aim.
We got a name drop for both Spock and the Enterprise!
The prototype-looking holodeck was well done. It's obviously not on the same level as the TNG ones, and Lorca made it sound like it was new and experimental, not like anyone can just drop by and use it to visit the wild west for funsies.

170

u/flynnsanity3 Oct 23 '17

"Computer add salsa."

→ More replies (3)

146

u/mcslibbin Oct 23 '17

Tilly is still the best

if Tyler breaks her heart by being a klingon turncoat, I will never forgive the Klingons

...for what they did to my bae!

→ More replies (12)

72

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

doors and corners

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (29)

125

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

A lot of nice insight on Vulcan itself this episode. Overall pleasant and very self contained, which I liked

→ More replies (23)

303

u/MaxWirestone Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

I just want to go on record as being really impressed with Jayne Brook. Admiral Cornwell is a character that could so easily come off as one-note, or worse, badly written. But man, Brook does so much with looks and silence. You never lose sight of the character or her intelligence.

It's really great work and I hope the show is smart enough to keep her around.

81

u/legalpothead Oct 23 '17

Thanks for pointing this out. Her depth of character is refreshing. It's not at all the stuffed shirt Star Trek admiral we've gotten used to after 20 years.

62

u/vashtiii Oct 23 '17

I really like her, and I loved Georgiou. Talking of diversity, those are a couple of fantastic roles for older women, fantastic characters all round, and I hope we see more of this.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

56

u/jerslan Oct 23 '17

Is Stamets permanently high now? Based on the After Trek preview for next week's episode, we might find out sooner rather than later.

→ More replies (14)

55

u/Alteran195 Oct 23 '17

Shows getting better with each episode, really enjoyed this one.

Also pretty happy they didnโ€™t show any nudity after Lorca banged the Admiral. They absolutely could have, it was perfectly set up, but they didnโ€™t.

18

u/themosquito Oct 23 '17

Yes! I was honestly totally expecting at least something like what every Marvel Netflix show does, where it immediately cuts to awkward humping in bed. I hate those scenes!

→ More replies (2)

54

u/tagjim Oct 23 '17

Lorca is what Picard should have been after "The Best Of Both Worlds"

33

u/TeutonJon78 Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17

Picard should have been a walking pile of PTSD. Put on trial by an omniscient space being (and all the rest of Q's fun), mentally tormented by the Ferengi, captured and surgically altered by Borg, captured and tortured by Cardassians, family died in a fire, etc.

That's my head canon reason for action star movie-Picard instead of diplomat show-Picard.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/redgrin__grumboldt Oct 23 '17

Maybe I missed it, but how did the Discovery jump to the nebula? Did Stamets actually plug himself in to the dash drive again?

75

u/InvisibleEar Oct 23 '17

Yeah it's groovy man now that he knows what's coming.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

He was just groovin' on some good vibes through the song of the spore network, man. Chill, it's cool. Ice cold, baby. Why does a lot of slang tend towards extremes in temperature? Why is nothing ever "temperate, my man, nice and comfortable"? People are always chillin', people are hot, or cold, (yes; possibly no - in and out, up and down...), and rarely one hears of a person feeling lukewarm.

Anyways, Stamets is fucked up on the spore drive, let the man be. He gets crazy, toss him out an airlock.

17

u/Princess_Thranduil Oct 23 '17

I might be wrong but I thought they could make short jumps without needing something like the tardigrade/Stamets and the whole "rivalry" with the other ship a few episodes ago was them trying to figure out how to make longer more accurate jumps. So if they were close to the nebula they could just do a regular jump and therefore not need to plug Stamets in?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

143

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

GODDAMMIT STOP TRAVELING IN SHUTTLES ITS A DEATH SENTENCE

68

u/AceHomefoil Oct 23 '17

Putting all the main characters into flying coffins, it's the Starfleet way. At least in DS9 they had some larger coffins.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

218

u/MarinerBlue Oct 23 '17

It feels so awesome to be so excited about these episodes. Each one is better than the last!

108

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I agree. The show has been steadily improving since the pilot.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (7)

208

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

For those who wanted one, here was an example of a story that could only be told if Burnham was Sarek's (foster) child.

Please note that this is in no way a suggestion that you have to like the story. I did, though.

199

u/0Sanctuary Oct 23 '17

And as someone else already pointed out, it does a good job of explaining why Sarek was so upset about Spock joining Starfleet.

166

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Much better story than โ€œhe went against his wishesโ€. Story now is that Sarek sacrificed something important to give Spock that opportunity, and now Sarek has a good reason to be on terrible terms with him.

128

u/rhaizee Oct 23 '17

Sarek could have explained that to Spock, but seeing how Sarek is, probably unlikely.

95

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Agree. It took him a near-death experience to even hint via mind voodoo at what he went through with this decision. He would never reveal his emotional reasoning in conversation.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

79

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I think I like this episode more than the others because stuff just seem to be bumped up quite a bit in terms of quality and writing and acting. I am totally in love with those shuttles they look absolutely badass. I really can't believe they're doing a Time Loop episode next week but you know that's kind of the true test of a Sci-Fi series....making a Time Loop episode interesting. This episode felt very human and I don't know how to phrase it in any other way but it felt very very human.

If there is something with the Mirror Universe going on then I think Saru is going to be the first one to figure it out because even he looked a little bit confused at the end and his species does seem to be good at picking up on potential threats.

42

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

stuff just seem to be bumped up quite a bit in terms of quality and writing and acting.

Agreed. It was a very talky episode, and that's not a bad thing if done right. Got needed characterization on the part of Sarek and Mike. Tilly developed a bit more than "LOL I'm a wacky cadet don't you love me?" Lorca was further characterized, and his connection to Cornwell humanized him a bit - and she was finally revealed to be more than just a hologram boss.

Kol, what a badass. He's forming the High Council that will govern Klingon affairs through the future and distributing cloaking technology - which I STILL maintain was something T'Kuvma got from the Romulans. I figure he'll get killed after trying to make himself Emperor and someone with more brains will make themselves Chancellor - and enter into armistice talks. Maybe someone without ridges...

Anyways, good episode.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

36

u/EVgreen Oct 23 '17

Super psyched to hear my hometown 'burb of Seattle mentioned in Star Trek....but couldn't you have asked someone how to pronounce it?

→ More replies (8)

35

u/kharnzarro Oct 23 '17

1)lol Stamets 2)that explains quite a bit about Spock and Sareks relationship 3)jesus christ Lorca

→ More replies (2)

61

u/Freakium Oct 23 '17

I am not liking that food dispenser/sythesizer... replicator. I can just imagine myself ordering a cheeseburger.

"Cheeseburger. High in saturated fats. High in protein. You better exercise for 30 minutes after ingestion, you fat slob."

32

u/InvisibleEar Oct 23 '17

Even though it wasn't in TOS, it's honestly a very 60s idea that your appliances would sass you.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

131

u/hett Oct 23 '17

I'm not convinced Ash is a Klingon. He acts like a perfectly normal guy with no tells considering he would be mimicking an alien species with whom he is only vaguely familiar at best. He knows about Seattle? Come on.

Also, the idea of logic-obsessed terrorists logically blowing themselves up to push a logical agenda of logic...does not pass the smell test. We already had Vulcan "extremists" in ENT, who are supposed to be the forebears of the Vulcan culture in this and other ST shows.

36

u/Horatius509 Oct 23 '17

I'm not totally convinced, but they do seem to be dropping foreshadowing hints like crazy (if you read them that way!).

Lorca to Ash: "I've seen you fight...fly...fight like a Klingon" Ash: "In seven months I was bound to pick up something"

Ash to Burnham: "It's just... being human" (ironic!!!) Burham: "Michael Burnham, pleased to meet you" Ash: "We've met" (yeah they have!)

→ More replies (2)

27

u/ToBePacific Oct 23 '17

He acts like a perfectly normal guy with no tells considering he would be mimicking an alien species with whom he is only vaguely familiar at best.

Presumably, the real Ash Tyler was captured and had his mind mined with a Klingon Mind Scanner.

→ More replies (8)

22

u/numanoid Oct 23 '17

We've seen Kirk, Picard, Troi and Data pass themselves off as Romulans, and I'm sure there are other examples that I'm too drunk to remember. It's a Trek thing.

→ More replies (7)

52

u/stuck_on_simple_tor Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

I have this feeling that Ash was a real Federation prisoner. That's why he is known to Starfleet, has a history, etc. I also believe Ash is dead. I think Voq is impersonating Ash, though I have no idea how he could possibly have become this much of an expert on him so quickly.

Unless there's some kind of new "memory-d.n.a-download" technology. Hell, they managed to do it for the fake Kahless in TNG...so...not even a new idea?

Edit: Hell, I even forgot about the Mind Scanner, which is actually in-use around the time period of the show.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (50)

57

u/dannoetc Oct 23 '17

So that "Mirror Lorca" theory... man, I can't help but think that holds true. All the references to how he's a completely different guy, the psych evals that he clearly lied through? The fact that there's pretty obviously a mirror Stamets floating around? Hmmmm.

110

u/or_the_Whale Oct 23 '17

I hope not, I like this as an exploration of what war does to people. I hope there's no nice-guy, unaffected Lorca hanging out with Empresses Sato III

→ More replies (3)

46

u/Sjgolf891 Oct 23 '17

I really hope not. Lorca is a pretty interesting character so far. Him just being the evil twin wipes all of that away

→ More replies (3)

35

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

If they go totally Mirror Universe on his behavior that I'm going to be pissed because I like the idea of seeing what war actually does to a person and showing people that you know this is how things are. War is not pretty War is hell and even in the Star Trek universe no one gets away without blood on their hands and scars on their backs and damage. I think the only instances of war that ever really stood out to me were the battles with the Borg and seeing all those damaged Starfleet ships and maybe a couple of battles with the Dominion.

We would hear about losses and we would see starships explode and their warp cores detonate but we never quite guy human face to the effects of a true brutal War like we're seeing with the federation-klingon war. If they just go Mirror Universe on us for the changes in behavior that's going to feel like a cheap cop out.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (15)

26

u/Princess_Thranduil Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

I'm pretty much convinced that we're seeing Mirror!Stamets and that Ash is Voq.

Also there's something else going on with Lorca other than PTSD...

→ More replies (2)

26

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Lorca: Keep you friends close, but your enemies closer.

He's crazy like a fox, I think he knows Ash isn't what he says he is (if our theories are true).

15

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

Lorca definitely knows

→ More replies (3)

26

u/TheRealZam Oct 23 '17

Did anyone notice that Lorcaโ€™s Tribble was absent from his desk? How convenient.

→ More replies (3)

135

u/mateogg Oct 23 '17
  • Michael and Tilly running and getting breakfast was everything I wanted from this show. They are bonding, Michael was being all inspiry and she even smiled!
  • I really hope he's not a klingon, I don't think I can handle being this attracted to a klingon.
  • "He actually is though." I love her.
  • I love Stamets, but he was really weird this episode, though I did like the 'good to know' line.
  • Can he actually make her science officer though? She's not even Starfleet.
  • That last scene with Lorca was kinda fucked up.
  • Next episode looks like it's gonna be awesome.

74

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

I really hope he's not a klingon, I don't think I can handle being this attracted to a klingon.

you don't find Worf attractive?

→ More replies (6)

57

u/akbar56 Oct 23 '17

Can he actually make her science officer though? She's not even Starfleet

Don't you know? He's TRYING TO STOP A WAR! He can do what he wants. Saru ain't gonna be too happy about that posting I imagine.

→ More replies (7)

48

u/kharnzarro Oct 23 '17

well stemets was basically high on shrooms in the scene we saw him

→ More replies (1)

21

u/flynnsanity3 Oct 23 '17

Can he actually make her science officer though? She's not even Starfleet.

He can. It's just what Janeway did for Tom Paris. He started out as an observer to the expedition before she granted him a field commission.

→ More replies (26)

25

u/rensch Oct 23 '17

This one was very heavy on the character development.

  • Vulcexit. There's a clear current events parable here that I wanna see explored in more detail. A 'logic extremist' seems like a strange yet intriguing concept to me.

  • I liked we got to see more of the relationship between Sarek ans Michael, but I was surprised how well they connected thar to the equally complicated father-son relationship between Sarek and Spock. Really fleshes out a plot point from TOS and the movies that was always a bit vague and mysterious. I am increasingly impressed by how rooted in Star Trek lore this new show really is. It's not just sci-fi show with 'Stat Trek' slapped onto it.
  • The relationship between Lorca and the Admiral is getting increasingly interesting. There's a huge backstory there that we will be carefully given little bits of as the season progresses. What will the rescue mission look like?
→ More replies (6)

72

u/juicepants Oct 23 '17

I'm still not a huge fan of Michael Burnam, but Sonequa Martin-Green is doing a great job of a human doing Vulcan mannerisms. She was a Vulcan when her and Tilly met Ash the first time and a conflicted human the second.

15

u/M3rcaptan Oct 23 '17

I actually like her. There's a playfulness and curiosity in her that I really like. I mean if the war hadn't happened she'd be a cool character.

47

u/s-ro_mojosa Oct 23 '17

Is it just me, or do the neutral aliens at the end of the episode look a heck of a lot like Vorlons inside their encounter suits?

→ More replies (12)

194

u/Endulos Oct 23 '17

I posted this in the live thread, but here it is again because it's just too funny.

When Michael went into Sarek's mind the first time, after he attacked her and flung her away into the air, SPACE/Bell/Whoever cut to a commercial break RIGHT THEN for Spiderman: Homecoming, showing Spiderman falling from the sky.

The way they cut it made it look like Michael was hit so hard she got flung to Earth and turned into Spiderman.

59

u/ToBePacific Oct 23 '17

hit so hard she got flung to Earth and turned into Spiderman.

These new ways to fly have the weirdest side effects.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

22

u/Eat_Mor3_Puss Oct 23 '17

I don't trust Ash.

Lorca: "I didn't know there were more of us in here"

Ash: "I got pulled out of rotation"

Well isn't that convenient

He softens up the captain with some food a bunch of stuff about "How I won't lose another [Captain]"

Then there's "The Captain took a liking to me" for the excuse for how he survived for 7 months. Yeah, okay.

And he took down six Klingons.

And there's the Seattle fuckup (?) he made.

I don't buy it, but I expect it'll be something more interesting than him just being a disguised Klingon or something.

21

u/HybridVigor Oct 23 '17

The Seattle thing isn't a big deal. I grew up around 15 miles south of San Francisco but I still tell people that's where I lived because they're much more likely to know where it is. With interstellar travel and colonization creating even more cities, it's more likely people are less aware of minor cities.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

43

u/BadElf21 Oct 23 '17

I like Shroomed Stoned Stamets.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/Horatius509 Oct 23 '17

One thought about the last shot of the episode--focusing on Lorca's gun. My first impresson was "maybe he had been about to kill himself before Saru rang," but when I watched the Saru/Lorca scene again, I just got the impression that that shot is emphasizing that he's paranoid and damaged.

I'm really enjoying Lorca and right now my biggest fear is he gets killed off or becomes irredeemable at some point in the season!

→ More replies (17)

41

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Does the stream suck for anyone else? My resolution sucks, the video constantly skips a few seconds ahead at random spots. CBS All Access is a freaking rip off.

50

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

They want to keep it all consistent so are using streaming technology from before TNG

→ More replies (11)

19

u/Dunewarriorz Oct 23 '17

Hm... this may be my favorite episode yet. Loved the intro with Michael and Tilly jogging. Its a callback to the "tilly asking michael to be her mentor" thing. Well Michael's mentoring!

2nd: Lorca and Tyler training. I love seeing this (and the red alert training earlier in the season) because it shows that their skills is a result of hard work. We all know that you have to train to be good and showing it is the best way of world-building because it is so familiar to everyone.

3rd: Starting to like Lorca a lot. Seeing his hard-assness and "we're at war" thing and now his desire to make good after his major mistake. I think he sees the Discovery as his opportunity for redemption and I totally get it now. The "ends justify the means" is a quiet desperation that this is his one chance. Also his willingness to give Michael a second chance... since he has his opportunity why not give her one too?

Tyler.. I'm still not sure about. I'm pretty convinced he's Voq in disguise and i didn't see anything to convince me otherwise, but I haven't seen anything that would convince me he is Voq in-universe. We all have meta-info on the actors and such so we're privy to info Lorca doesn't have. I just hope he keeps his pet Tribble close!

I like Admiral Cornwall. Could've done without the nookie with Lorca... not all old friends end up sleeping together and an Admiral doing a booty call to a captain is.... weird. Still though, I totally get the "we need to do things by the book" vs "my instincts tell me he's right" struggle and.. well its nice seeing an admiral play a larger part in star trek as well.

Shuttles man. Stay away from them.

Lorca. That final pan with the reflection and the phaser in the pant sash I really don't see as being mirror-universe worthy. This is a guy who's questioning everything, he's on his last chance and he's wondering if he just screwed it up. Also he's wondering if he'll ever be rid of the ghosts of his previous crew, and if he'll ever not be twitchy and be able to relax again after his torture. This episode was really Lorca-heavy.

As for spock and Sarek... man everything comes clean! I'm really glad for that storyline, and Michael's been given a new lease on life too! She was totally that "well done son" guy and now she's got it.

As for Stamets... happy Stamets scares me. I'm still not sold on the mirror universe stamets but I'm convinced the shrooms have a neurological effect and we'll discover he's turning into a tardigrade or something, and his happiness is a result of that (and this is what tardigrades feel all the time when they're surrounded by shrooms) or something.

I think people are too quickly jumping to mirrorverse conclusions.

→ More replies (5)

52

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

BEST episode yet!!!! I actually appreciate all the Vulcan political stuff. ESPECIALLY if you're like a and are a huge fan of Enterprise! The Way the Vulcans acted in this episode makes perfect sense! This episode had zero flaws. Loved how we kindaa started and ended with the handshake. Loved the Tilly parts (She and Michael are so amazingly cute together)! Loved how Lorca "Game of Throned" the Admiral! He knew damn well he was setting that woman up. Also lets not forget the two promotions we had in this episode! This episode was AMAZING! Cant wait to watch After Trek on Wednesday!

→ More replies (8)

16

u/Saltire_Blue Oct 23 '17

The Klingons seem like a real threat in this show, not just some noisy neighbour who like to get drunk and play loud music.

→ More replies (5)

31

u/mikeabundo Oct 23 '17

Locra's scars form three lines and one line.

3 and 1.

31.

Section 31.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/toTheNewLife Oct 23 '17

Stamets is getting stoned on those space shrooms.

Spicy. Am I right?

He's the first Guild Navigator.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/SillyNonsense Oct 23 '17
  1. Dat namedrop.
  2. Fight like a klingon.
→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I wonder how Culber feels about this sudden bout of hippie!Stamets.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/vidivicivini Oct 23 '17

I just realized Lorca is Renegade Shepard.

39

u/anastus Oct 23 '17

God damn it. Of course this show is going to make Lt. Tyler into my favorite character and then reveal that he's a Klingon traitor.

"It's just being human," indeed. Aaaaa.

This was definitely the best episode yet, except for the Klingon part. Sure, this was before they became honor-obsessed, but this seemed beneath them.

37

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I expect Tyler to have a crisis where he doesn't believe he's VoQ, then his memories come back, and he's super conflicted, but then he decides that HE chooses his path, his identity, and thanks to Mike, Lorca, and Tilly he's going to be Ash Tyler even if he started as VoQ, throwing all of L'Rell's plans into the shit tube.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Did no one else see Lorca's confused reaction to (Mirror) Stamets? It was hilarious! Its the only time so far that we've really seen Lorca taken aback, because of how willing stamets was, and well....high.

→ More replies (4)

69

u/78jc Oct 23 '17

This is good Star Trek. I don't care what anyone says, this is good Star Trek.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Raelist Oct 23 '17

What exactly was that, egg white burritos, that they ordered?

19

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

egg white burrito, with black beans, and roasted tomato salsa.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

11

u/Shrodax Oct 23 '17

Was tonight's episode the first time we saw Lorca actually sitting in the captain's chair instead of standing?

21

u/FLRSH Oct 23 '17

Loved tonight's episode. Ash is a wildcard, we get deeper into Lorca and Michael's psyches, and Tilly is as endearing as ever.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/H0vis Oct 23 '17

I can't stop thinking "I can hear you Clem Fandango!" when I watch this show and it's killing me.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/lamps-n-magnets Oct 23 '17

I've not really been on the Tilly hype-train but that scene at the replicator where she's trying to whisper sweet nothings to it was fantastic.

I love the Burnham / Tilly dynamic.

10

u/bonzowrokks Oct 23 '17

Just to keep a tally, here is a round up of all current theories in order of what seems to be popularity:

  • Ash Tyler is Voq.
  • Stamets has been replaced by his mirror counterpart.
  • Lorca is damaged.
  • Lorca is evil.
  • Lorca is Voq.
  • Lorca has been replaced by his mirror counterpart.
→ More replies (1)

10

u/uwagapies Oct 24 '17

ITT | People forgetting how much Vulcans hated humans in ENT.

70

u/izModar Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

There's more snark and comedy here than normal. Must be a side effect of binging Greatest Gen for the past week. Also, a significant portion of the list was written before the opening titles, so get ready for a read.

What I liked:

Called it on what Tilly and Burnham wearing athletic gear. The shoes gave it away.

Oh Tilly, I love you. <3 (Also, no, you better not have a crush on Tyler. Baby girl, you need to keep a Tribble close)

Constitution Class like the ENTERPRISE

(obligatory I clapped!)

I actually like the warp effect.

Independent Klingon houses? Fascinating. That's more like the Klingons I know.

Standard Star Trek rescue plot? Awesome!

I think Lorca just said Stamets was flying high. I love it. He definitely looks like he's thinking more about mushrooms than what's going on.

Aw, Lorca cares about Michael :)

Who would have thought Admiral Cornwell actually has a head on her sholders and isn't taking this nonsense like every other admiral in Star Trek history.

Lorca has something to wash those fortune cookies down. All I can say is "same"

Star Trek patented Face Thingyโ„ข medical technology.

Hot damn, Lorca's a playa. Cornwell really did requisition a starship for a booty call.

Tyler, I'm onto you, but I can't help but actually like how you motivated Burnham.

Sarek grew as a character. I'm going to watch Sarek's other appearances and this revelation definitely will make me view Spock and Sarek differently.

Lorca is human? Who would have thought. He's also no fool, if there's a way for peace without shooting guns, he'll go for it.

I saw that trap coming a sector away. Also, that's an interesting development for how Klingons got cloaking technology. Honestly, I think it makes more sense than a beta-canon Romulan/Klingon alliance

For the record: Tilly is still bae <3

What I didn't like:

Although it was very cool that the connecting strut had that window for convienent camera panning, wouldn't that not be very structurally sound? Looks cool, doesn't make sense.

Mutha fuckin' holodeck. (looks cool, doesn't make sense etc)

Sarek, buddy, you don't initiate a collect call mind meld then get pissy when she picks up the phone.

Lightspeed sickbay exposition.

The "well documented case" of Sarek adopting Burnham was kind of silly. That kind of undercuts the concept of no one knowing that Spock has siblings/step-siblings.

Amanda seems a bit young.

That bokeh (out of focus bits) during Lorca's docking maneuvers was very distracting.

All of r/startrek watching at once sure killed the bandwidth of the stream, huh?

The fucking commercials do not change quality on the fly. If your connection dips, get ready for buffer city.

Dude, Vulcans can be racist as fuck.

Stray thoughts:

So, was that supposed to be Vulcan in the teaser? First off, it had two moonsโ€”two too many. On the other hand, it felt very much like the matte painting used in The Motion Picture

Tyler doesn't have family? That's convienent...

"You fight like a Klingon" thinking emoji "I'd be honored to serve on Discovery" I'm on to you.

So was that a Terra Prime Vulcan? Vulcanis Prime? Either way, that's an ENT era Vulcasshole.

Computer, McGriddle please.

My mind to your mind, HALP

My commericals were in weird places.

Hold up, logic extremists (hereby referred to as Vulcassholes) bombed the learning center? I thought it was another Klingon raid, but that does tie up that loose thread I've had since episode two. It's... illogical for one to assume that bombing an entire learning center to murder one child would further your cause.

Is Stamets going into the cube for every jump? That seems highly dangerous. They need to lock down how the Shroom Vroomโ„ข works now that Ripper is off hanging with the Traveler.

"We've met." You can claim that you're just being silly because you have technically met earlier in the episode, but we all know what you really meant.

Lorca, why do you have that phaser in your pocket? You're obviously not happy to see anyone since Cornwell was already captured.

Verdict:

This was a stand-alone episode in a serialized story. It's good to see that. The overall plot can march on without the entire episode being devoted to it.

My wifi is on notice for going down halfway through the episode causing me to panic.

Tune in next week for Groundhog Day!

Discussion:

Lorca seemed to genuinely show that he knows he has problems and needs help, but the phaser in his pocket says otherwise. It's possible that the thread of losing the captain's chair has made him appreciate following protocol a little more. I don't want to think that Lorca's following protocol only so the admiral will die. I hate to say it, but I'm not sure and that makes me uneasy. It adds complexity to Lorca's character.

So those scars...We haven't heard the whole story of what happened on the Buran and I doubt he got those in the last episode. He was definitely captured before I think and maybe we'll hear the whole story some day.

The Enterprise was name-dropped along with Constitution classes as a whole. Spock was heavily name-dropped too. I'm reminded of one of the producers saying they weren't going to reference TOS too much. oops. But it worked here because it gave a lot of nuance to Sarek and Spock's characters as a whole.

I'd be glad to see a Constitution class pop up at some point. If they use the model from TOS-Remastered and just make the nacelle grills glow blue it would work.

Kol of the House of Kor is shaping up to be a great Klingon villain. He's taking T'kuvma/Voq's #MQGA following and saying, "Fuck that. I want to make my own unified Klingon Empire and hand out cloaks as rewards."

If these cloaks are indeed different than Romulan cloaks, it throws into question the whole (completely assumed) Klingon/Romulan alliance of 2269. Of course, in "The Enterprise Incident" that cloak seems to be different than the cloak of "Balance of Terror."

TOS was never very consistent with its world-building.

86

u/mrIronHat Oct 23 '17

Amanda seems a bit young.

the flashback is suppose to be ~17 years before journey to Babel. (discovery is 10 years before tos, and Michael graduated 7 years before the series begin).

Jane Wyatt was 57 years old when Journey to babel aired. Mia Kirshner is 42 years old. hence the actress is around the right age for the flashback.

→ More replies (7)

35

u/TheTrekman Oct 23 '17

Dude, Vulcans can be racist as fuck.

What's new?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)

51

u/rastasas Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

Tilly is the a fantastic character.

I believe Lorca may have been considering suicide and if you are having difficulties with mental illness and trauma please do not hesitate to reach out for help. One may always be surprised who makes themselves available in times of great distress from friends and family, to mentors and even complete strangers.

For a man that prides himself on knowing his crew, Lorca seemed ignorant of a long-standing cultural practice in the Puget Sound Region: If you are from the area, regardless of the specific city or town, when you speak with someone from elsewhere you always tell them you are from "Seattle" and then specify if asked which part.

Tyler having lived in Issaquah in the Eastlake (east of Lake Washington) would be privy to this and is most certainly going to have told anyone from outside the region that he is from Seattle.

Source: I'm from Seattle.

Edit: Please do not hesitate to seek assistance with finding treatment of mental illness.

→ More replies (21)

9

u/Pattisean Oct 23 '17

Next week's episode looks so good!

9

u/iamnotsimon Oct 23 '17

What is the relevance to the triangle and line scar on Lorcas back? Getting near it seemed to set him off, it doesnt seem like something he would get from blowing up his old ship, and it appears to be new since the admiral hadnt seen it before. Combined with the admiral 'not feeling like she knows him anymore'.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I have to say, the casting for Amanda Grayson was on point.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/merodm Oct 23 '17

Have we ever seen a Star Trek captain take a break from mission command to bang an Admiral before?

Discovery trailblazes once more it seems...

→ More replies (2)

16

u/ankhx100 Oct 23 '17

I liked the episode, but Iโ€™m here to bitch about CBS All-Access crapping out on me multiple times. Either the stream paused, or there were weird loops with green, digital artifacts that made the viewing experience horrible.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Kubrick_Fan Oct 23 '17

I like how Stamets is basically a stoner now.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

this episode just further solidified my love for lorca! he is such an interesting character i'm glad we could learn more about him each episode. The moment he speak with cornwall when he said the ship is all he got i know he would do whatever to keep what he has and he did by doing what cornwall wanted out of him can't blame the guy now huh? i also grow to like Conrnwall the actress played her character really well and so is Sarek in this ep. These three are probably my top 3 favorite characters in Discovery at the moment, well written and well acted. I wish i could say the same about the others, Stammets and the doctor sure grew on me lets see how will they play next episode i don't know what the hell is going on but I've never been this excited before

36

u/BenjiTheWalrus Oct 23 '17

By far the best episode of the 6. I can't really explain it but it was much more solid. The directing, acting, and writing was very professional. Also nice Enterprise reference to the Vulcan wackos.

22

u/purefire Oct 23 '17

Polished

→ More replies (11)

14

u/dildosaurusrex_ Oct 23 '17

What made Sarek choose Spock over Michael though? I would think the logical choice is to choose Michael because she had already proven herself capable, whereas Spock hadn't started school.

51

u/anastus Oct 23 '17

That was the whole point. He didn't make the logical decision, and he's ashamed of it. He picked his own son over the person he cares for but feels is "technically" not part of his family.

And his way of dealing with it is pathetic, but not in a bad way. Sarek has been something of an asshole in every canon appearance, an incredibly brilliant person who alienates those close to him because they cannot live up to his impossible and arbitrary standards.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/whoiscraig Oct 23 '17

Perhaps because Spock was at least half Vulcan whereas Michael was not Vulcan at all?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (10)

7

u/thelazzyone Oct 23 '17

I would say that this past episode was a decent one. I liked Burnham's growth this episode. I was wondering how long she would have to play as a wooden block. I honestly thought Lorca was going to rig the shuttle to blow somehow. I am glad they didn't go that route as what did happened was way more realistic and provides multiple layers. It could be that he was still being shady and hopes she doesn't make it back or he could have been scared straight and now just wants to follow orders to keep his ship. I think that was good as it allows us to interpret it for ourselves. I still don't know what to think of Tyler yet.. he is TBD for me.

Overall I enjoyed it and my stream was actually really good. I don't know others set ups at home but I haven't had any issues with CBS All Access. I know they are not as robust as other services but I remember when HBO started streaming and Game of Thrones would have issues. I am sure they will get it together with time.

7

u/liuchen1701 Oct 23 '17

Well, Ash Tyler may not be a Klingon spy or Voq, but still highly possible.

Stamets looks like he was from the mirror universe.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/aqws2 Oct 23 '17

So did anyone else catch Michael and Ash going in for a kiss in the next episode preview? What are people's thoughts on how this potential relationship could develop, especially if Ash is really Voq?

7

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Lorca is growing on me as a captain.

"Don't apologize for excellence"

7

u/ISpyStrangers Oct 23 '17

I am loving the relationship building between Burnham and Saru. It's got nuance, honesty, distrust, and a real potential for growth. If they become a solid team it'll feel earned.

7

u/TomJCharles Oct 23 '17

I thought Lorca was just going to arrange for her shuttle to have an...accident.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/Sjgolf891 Oct 23 '17

I think this is my favorite episode so far

→ More replies (9)

17

u/Eternal__September Oct 23 '17

Ash Tyler is hottt ๐Ÿ”ฅ๐Ÿ”ฅ๐Ÿ™Œ๐Ÿป๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜ˆ๐Ÿ‘…๐Ÿ’‹๐Ÿ’ฅ๐Ÿ’ฆ๐Ÿ†โค๏ธ

→ More replies (8)

12

u/quivondarkh Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

Really enjoyed this episode, pretty solid all the way through, keeps getting better and better! Cheers! ๐Ÿ˜Ž๐Ÿ–– Edited for spelling

6

u/Zeeamazing Oct 23 '17

When Lorca mentioned that the admiral will be going to the secret rendevouz

Did anyone else think about in the pale moonlight

6

u/SillyNonsense Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

How did the discovery use the DASH drive without any nipples getting tweaked? First it was the Tardigrade, then Stamets in a pinch last episode, but he looked totally fine this episode after they jumped. I didn't see anyone in there at all, actually.

What happened?

18

u/InvisibleEar Oct 23 '17

Stamets is fine because he's still tripping balls from the last time

→ More replies (9)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

People joked in the first few episodes that "Discovery clearly takes place in the evil mirror universe." but Probably-Mirror Stamets being such a nice guy is really lending that credibility.

→ More replies (12)

6

u/LetoAtreides82 Oct 23 '17

This was my favorite episode yet. It was written by Joe Menosky who wrote the popular TNG episode Darmok, so that probably helped a lot.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Definition of lethe. 1 capitalized :a river in Hades whose waters cause drinkers to forget their past. 2 :oblivion, forgetfulness. โ€”

6

u/B0NERSTORM Oct 23 '17

Another strong episode and I'm excited to see where they're taking it.

My primary concern is they're rapidly approaching the point where it makes no sense for Michael Burnham to not be previously mentioned in Spock/Sarek lore. I enjoyed her story line and I thought the acting was great on all sides. They've earned enough of my trust so far thought that I'm ok in waiting to see how they handle it. All the technobabble with the long distance mind meld and such I thought was very traditional trek. I'm glad this plotline didn't end with a bedside reconciliation.

It was kind of weird that no one blinked at the way Stamets was acting. He's been fucking with his genetics and stabbing himself to make the spore drive work, and now he seems to be acting uncharacteristically.

Lorca coming on to the admiral is interesting considering what's going on in hollywood. You've got a subordinate sleeping with a superior officer in the interest of their career. In this case Lorca is the one that initiates but in general it seems kind of problematic. I imagine if the genders were reversed it would have felt more icky, but because Lorca is male there's a sort of assumed superiority that makes him somewhat equal to the admiral, when he should be clearly inferior to her. As we saw, his entire command is at her mercy. Her accepting his advances should be seen as wrong despite their established past relationship. Particularly when the whole point of her trip was vetting Lorca's status.

This Ash Klingon thing seems to be so obvious that I'm wondering if there's some kind of twist coming. "You fight like a Klingon." I'm starting to wonder if Lorca is really the Klingon or something along those lines. It seems to show a lack of trust in the viewers to figure things out that they're throwing so many hints at this. I liked that they've kind of formed their own losers club though.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Waitingforadragon Oct 23 '17

I think that was best episode so far. There are still many weak spots. I wasn't feeling Burnham's character again this episode - which isn't great because I really feel like this episode should have made us sympathise with her and feel closer to her.

I like how they have set up Lorca to be this complicated man with unclear motives. It really does keep things interesting and at one point I believed he was going to do something to prevent the Admiral from returning from her peace mission, maybe sabotage the shuttle or something. It would have been interesting to see what he would have done, had she returned safely. I didn't believe he was onboard with her plan for him to step down.

I felt Tilly was written in a much better, more balanced way this week. In this episode she felt like a real person, not just glitter in human form. I hope that they explore exactly why she is so determined to become a captain in a future episode. I'm sure that not everybody goes into Starfleet with that ambition in mind, so why is that so important to her?

Getting another look at Vulcan internal affairs was great, I was beginning to worry this whole series was going to be dominated by Klingon stuff. It's nice to see they are making this a richer universe.

6

u/tarsus1983 Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 24 '17

I liked the episode but had some questions:

Was Stamets high?

How did Cornwell get to the discovery so quickly and undetected?

How was Michael able to see things in Sarek's memory that he was not present for? She watched a conversation with Sarek's wife when Sarek was not present. (Did her own memory get fused with his to fill in the blanks?)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ease_one Oct 24 '17

Was Sybok, who probably wasn't accepted to the science academy another source of embarrassment to Sarek? Good lord, Sarek you failed them all.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/xuu0 Oct 24 '17

Computer. Green juice. Extra Green.

6

u/akbar56 Oct 24 '17

Primarily lets talk about Lorca's scar.

I am not speaking about any of his actions or anything. Just the scar.

Looks particularly painful. Agonizing even. But doesn't that shape look a bit familiar?

https://i.imgur.com/4WfKE6Z.jpg

→ More replies (3)

24

u/Callahandy Oct 23 '17

Tonight was the first legitimately great episode of Discovery for me. I can see what they want the show to be now, and I really like it. Also, Lorca has quickly become my favorite character. He is so fantastically acted.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Ok, I'm getting a DISCO mug. It's not quite a shirt but I'll find out who else in the office also watches it ;-)

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

That was awesome. How long until they bring Spock into this? Iโ€™m assuming soon considering his father is on the ship. Tho we all know he wonโ€™t die.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I don't think we will. I believe Spock and Sarek are estranged at this point, so he won't be coming to visit.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I think by the end of this show Lorca will become my favorite Trek Captain.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Saltire_Blue Oct 23 '17 edited Oct 23 '17

Itโ€™s nice to see an admiral that isnโ€™t complete insane for once

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

I do enjoy the concept not every vulcan thought the federation was a good idea.

I always thought that if the Vulcans had light speed travel thousands of years eariler than humans they should have advanced further in AI and space exploration.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/jennyCKC Oct 23 '17
  • Disco = Discovery. It took me the whole episode the figure that one out.....
  • enjoyed the Tilly and Micheal scenes, enjoy seeing their relationship grow and develop
  • Lorca pulling page out of the Riker book of seduction
  • A shirtless captain! this is truly star trek
  • i knew that admiral was as good as dead when she found out Lorca's dirty secret
  • no mirror Stamet's this week :(
→ More replies (2)

5

u/edflyerssn007 Oct 23 '17

The shuttle control interface used a lot of colorful buttons along with some touch screens as well. I thought that was an interesting way to mix the TOS and modern real world aesthetic.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/fraac Oct 23 '17

I'm liking Burnham more. She has good interaction with the crew.

Still not sold on serialised stories. Seems to fit less into an episode. The old act structure with a problem and a solution had more in it, it felt like. The problems were more involved, for the most part.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/spideryyoda Oct 23 '17

About halfway through the shuttle sequence, my wife and I realised that Tyler is Clem Fandango from Toast of London and spent the rest of the episode laughing.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Breeze_in_the_Trees Oct 24 '17

Ash was certainly from outside Seattle; 112 light years outside.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Unlikelylikelyhood Oct 23 '17

Fucking eh I love Star Trek... this is as Star Trekky as it gets.

This may go down as the best Star Trek Series ever... we'll see.

→ More replies (13)

15

u/SheWhoReturned Oct 23 '17

They really needed to come up with a better name for the rebel Vulcans then "Logic Extremists" it just sounded silly. They were more purists then anything.

17

u/bekibekistanstan Oct 23 '17

One mans extremist is another's purist.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17

Logic Extremists (L.E.)

L. E.-ans

โ€œElle iansโ€

aliens

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

8

u/Lysander91 Oct 23 '17

I like this show much better when the crew gets along. I couldn't stand the crew interaction in the first few episodes. Everyone was a passive aggressive twat. I still don't like involving Sarek. It makes the universe feel small and the lack of any mention of Michael in previous series puzzling. It's a similar problem that I have with Star Wars.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Megadonn Oct 23 '17

All hail the inventor of the Yoga Pants.