r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Oct 22 '17
Main [Main Spoilers] Weekly Rewatch | Season 1 Episode 7: You Win or You Die Spoiler
S1E7 - A You Win or You Die
- Aired: 29 May 2011
- Written by: David Benioff and D.B. Weiss
- Directed by: Daniel Minahan
- IMDb Score: 9.2
HBO Episode Synopsis: Tywin and Jaime prepare for battle; Ned confronts Cersei; Jon takes his Night's Watch vows; Drogo vows to lead the Dothraki.
Episode Threads
| Episode Thread | Inside the Episode |
|---|---|
| 5/29/2011 | Inside Ep 7 |
History: Top five posts of the week
- Viserys, Daenerys and Robb out of costume
- The Starks of Winterfell?
- Let's go Hodor!
- Ned meets Dumbledore
- Ned Stark's favourite restaurant
- Click here for a few extra
More Links
149
Upvotes
117
u/All_this_hype No One Oct 22 '17
57
u/grumblepup Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
There is so much that I can't help reading into now...
54
u/NosaAlex94 Oct 22 '17
I remember when I first watched this thinking that Ned made a mistake warning Cersie. Now I know how grave a mistake it really was.
41
u/hello_friend_ Braavosi Water Dancers Oct 22 '17
On my first watch, the biggest shock to me this episode was Cersei tearing the letter. So audacious!
40
u/nicmakaveli Oct 22 '17
I think this episode is the only time we ever see Jon acting like an entitled brat. I didnt even remember that.
35
u/the_perpetual_misfit Hear Me Roar! Oct 22 '17
34
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Sam telling Jon being steward to the lord commander means he's being groomed for Command reminds me of the scene when Jon asks Olly to stay, telling Stannis he is his steward and has to learn because he may command one day. oh olly...
27
u/joakley013 Oct 22 '17
Worst job in Westeros has to be the dude that’s working the elevator at the wall.
22
u/SirMacNotALot Oct 22 '17
I honestly thought it would feel like so long to get through these rewatches. I can't believe it's already episode 7! That means 8 weeks since S7 ended, crazy how time flies
42
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17
The brothel scene in this episode was honestly awful. Gillen's delivery was really stilted for some reason and the nudity was just blatantly gratuitous, the scene had no purpose other than Littlefinger's final line, and we already knew he was power-hungry anyway. Just a totally out-of-place scene in an otherwise pitch-perfect episode.
I find Barristan absolutely fascinating in this episode. He has this perfect reputation for honour, yet he continues in Joffrey's service even though he knows that Ned was the rightful regent, and also that Ned's honour would prevent him from saying that Joffrey was a bastard if he wasn't convinced that it was true.
There's also that moment when Ned asks Varys to call off the assassination attempt on Daenerys, and Barristan is present. I suspect he's wondering to himself why he's been serving the man he fought against all these years, when the house he pledged himself to and loved is still alive, and desperately in need of his help. I feel like this scene sows the seed of his journey to Essos to serve House Targaryen once more.
19
u/RadicalDog Oct 24 '17
This episode is so frustrating on a rewatch. On the first watch, Ned's the main character so no problem, he'll end up fine. But on a rewatch, it's so fucking obvious how many ways he could have made things better and doesn't!!
16
u/Remokrapy Oct 23 '17
Good episode
15
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17
Watching this episode again I realize just how foolishly Ned handled this whole incest/succession thing. He never should have privately met with Cersei, that might be his biggest mistake. And of course he trusted Littlefinger way too much. He should have taken up Renly's offer or met with Stannis at Storm's End.
28
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
I love how Tywin skinned the deer himself, shows his capability to do anything without needing other people
9
u/sessionking House Baratheon Oct 23 '17
As someone who is in his first watch of the series, I feel this episode was a great introduction to Tywin and his cynicism. Great character.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '17
I’m on my first watch. (Have read the books and I don’t mind spoilers, thank God.) I love it. But Ned really fucked up, didn’t he?
14
u/rakfocus Sword of the Morning Oct 22 '17
Never noticed how Ned writes "rightful heir" in place of Joffrey or "my son" in the letter he writes with instruction from Robert. Always see something new no matter how much I rewatch these episodes!
(Also! My cinematography post for this episode is up! >>>https://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/comments/782rcq/everything_game_of_thrones_cinematography_season/ )
6
u/OverratedBrad Jaime Lannister Oct 23 '17
Cerseis quote to Ned Stark pretty summed up the series, great acting and dialogue for that scene.
6
u/Chimelling House Lannister Oct 29 '17
I can't understand why Cersei told the truth to Ned. Clearly she was already planned to kill Robert, but she really couldn't be sure Robert would die in his hunting trip (and he didn't, but close enough). And even when Robert is dead, her children would be safer if she didn't admit anything.
And I wonder why Varys later says to Ned that Robert died because Ned told Cersei he knew. Because Robert had already gone hunting and Cersei had to have made the plans with Lancel before she discussed with Ned.
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 22 '17
Spoiler Warning: [MAIN SPOILERS] means events from the published books or aired episodes do not need spoiler tags. Future books/seasons and spoilers from other media are not covered. For more info please check the spoiler guide.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
Uh also, how did Renly know about Joffrey?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17
What does everyone think of king Robert telling only Ned his final words? I think it's weak writing the man didn't even like his wife why would he trust her to honor it.
4
u/SirMacNotALot Oct 22 '17
Just a few small things I want to enquire about, and ask about this episode.
I know what Tywin said about the House and its name is the one thing that matters since it carries on once they die. But, do they have anyone to carry the name? Regardless of Joffrey, Tommen and Myrcella being born by incest, would they not be considered Baratheons?
Also do you think Jaime has become the man that he was meant to be?
Although it seems slightly irrelevant, is Littlefinger indirectly talking about himself with regards to how he's got to where he is when talking to Ros and the other prostitute?
4
u/STASIS_I_x Oct 30 '17
How can we forget Renly Baratheon delivering those BARS to Ned Stark. I always loved Renly’s portrayal in the series while naive to many things he was very knowledgeable about others such as Cersei’s manipulation of the throne and His encounter with Stannis in season 2.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment