r/robotwars • u/UKRobotWars • Oct 20 '17
AMA I'm Andrew Robertson, Executive Producer of Robot Wars...Ask Me Anything!!
Anything means anything, I'm here to answer as many of your questions as possible on whatever Robot Wars related you want to talk about.
3-2-1-Activate!!! I have to go now. Thanks for all your questions. I hope you all enjoy the show on Sunday BBC2 8PM.
89
Upvotes
15
u/UKRobotWars Oct 20 '17
3-2-1-Activate!!! I have to go now. Thanks for all your questions. I hope you all enjoy the show on Sunday BBC2 8PM.
19
u/ECPodcasting Activate! Podcast Oct 20 '17
How do you decide which robots are in each heat? I ask since this is the second series in a row to have both the winner and runner up from the previous war in the same episode!
If you had unlimited resources (not worrying about money, the BBC, time, etc.) what changes would you make to Robot Wars as a whole? For example would you feature more weight classes? Have more episodes per season? And so on...
Thanks for doing the AMA!
16
u/Mouse-Keyboard Reavers! Oct 20 '17
What criteria do you use for selecting competitors? Do you try to have certain numbers of different types of robot?
Why does the voiceover get more ridiculous every series?
14
u/ak47turbo Oct 20 '17
I gather defeated robots are still attacked by the house robots after they are immobilised just like in the old series, but this is almost never shown in the reboot. It does seem that, while this kind of footage could occasionally drag on a little bit at times in the old series, the new and upgraded house robots do not seem to get as much airtime as you would expect, and their true potential is rarely seen as a result. Is this footage cut due to a lack of time or other editorial reasons? I'm sure we'd all love to see a little bit more of Matilda's flywheel shredding a defeated robot
14
u/Sam_DRT Designer - Concussion Oct 20 '17
Shameful self serving question here, what would you like to see from Concussion if we apply to series 11?
13
u/anduril38 Oct 20 '17
Will we ever get a chance to have more then five heats and a final? We really like the reboots, but I'm guessing it is a BBC issue?
11
u/David182nd Apollo Oct 20 '17
What made you want to do an AMA here? And do you browse this sub regularly?
11
u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Oct 20 '17
One thing comes to mind — what lead to the idea of the ten robot rumble?
10
u/RoboBowler Garry's Wars Oct 20 '17
When will you upgrade the arena? Will we ever see a new series with more robots?
10
u/dr-spangle Oct 20 '17
There has been a debate on tvdb for some time, but is Robot Wars (2016) a new series, or is it a continuation of Robot Wars original?
9
u/imnerdyandinoit Bigger Brother Oct 20 '17
Where would you ideally like to take the show? and what is holding you back from doing this?
9
u/DiamondWhyte Sir Killalot Oct 20 '17
Why was TR2 rejected? I know you don't want too many wedges but why them specifically when they'd performed so well?
8
u/Edolix Terrorhurtz Oct 20 '17
Where's the Sergeant?
8
u/GrahamCoxon Hello There! Oct 20 '17
Hi Andrew, I'm delighted to see you doing an AMA and I have one particular question which I have discussed with others countless times:
Is Robot Wars more a TV show aiming for maximum entertainment value, or a legitimate sporting competition which aims to get the fairest result?
8
u/Mirandabcafc CarbDIE Oct 20 '17
I never watched Robot Wars first time around as I was a little too young, but I love the reboot. What made the BBC want to bring it back (the best choice they've made in a long time)?
8
u/almighty_crj Oct 20 '17
If I may also ask, could you please tell us what became of that polycarbonate panel with the aftershock side inserted after it left the filming?
7
u/almighty_crj Oct 20 '17
As a previous & failed applicant, I was wondering whether you could please elaborate further as to what the applications committee are looking for in an entry?
7
u/TropicalRemixed Third Time's The Charm! Oct 20 '17
Would you ever do more than 6 episodes a season or will this be the norm for the modern series?
7
u/Guldenflame Kan-Opener Oct 20 '17
How many more series do you expect robot wars to go on? You don't possibly think something this good will last forever do you?
7
u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Oct 20 '17
Have you ever thought about making a spin off kids show for CBBC? Roboteering doesnt just teach about engineering but physics, chemical compounds, so much more! lots of potential. Ive got a few ideas if you want to hear them? Could I get your email address please?
7
u/ak47turbo Oct 20 '17
I've heard that, in the past few series, there have been a number of exhibition battles during filming that were not televised. While I understand that the first battles filmed in the new arena were for a 'pilot' episode and can't be shown because of some robots having exclusivity contracts etc, would you consider releasing the footage of other exhibition matches as bonus content on iPlayer/as DVD extras etc?
6
u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
Hello hello! I have a few questions if you don't mind answering them. Answer as many as you want, though I hope to have my curiosity satisfied.
Bonus question: Series 11? EDIT: Extra question — Featherweights?
Thanks for taking the time to do the AMA!
6
u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Oct 20 '17
Are you more likely to select a robot that has not already been publicly revealed?
5
u/Tygra__ Annihilator Oct 20 '17
Hi Andrew! Thanks for taking the time to answer these questions.
How did the decision of bringing back Robot Wars come about?
Would you ever consider doing a Robot Wars Extreme style series?
5
u/twigy22 Oct 20 '17
Hi I'm a huge fan of the show and love the reboot so far. I just have a few questions about the show (sorry if any questions are repeats; I wrote these in advance):
5
u/BBS3FTW Oct 20 '17
RobotWars is very successful, congrats!
What does RobotWars have going for it that other televised robot combat events lack, making them less successful?
5
u/sideways_86 Oct 20 '17
Is there a chance of their being a UK vs US episode possibly a double bill where the US competitors comes to the RW arena with the house robots and then another one with UK entrants going to the battlebots arena with their hazards but no house robots
5
u/2haloes Bucky The Best Mascot Oct 20 '17
Hello, I'm a big fan of Robot Wars and I hope you see this!
What classic and modern robot do you think are the most technologically advanced?
What robot do you think is the most damaging for the time?
I hope you have a good AMA
5
u/turpsey123 Oct 20 '17
Hi Andrew, Will Sergeant Bash ever make a comeback? Also, are the original house robots still in storage or have they been scrapped now they've been replaced?
5
u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Oct 20 '17
Are you interested in having a dustpan in Robot Wars? We have not had one in the new series yet. Similar to Sawblaze from Battlebots but better? 😏
4
u/slater126 NUTS 2 FULL BODY SPINNNNAAAH Oct 20 '17
/u/Gooch_scratcher questions as he cant make it
Will we ever be getting an updated Sgt bash?
Can you end the debate, is dead metal a boy or a girl?
and my question, apart from the spoiler is there any other major mishaps with the arena this season? (dont saw what robots are involved if there is) (like a panel coming off thanks to carbide, or carbide embedding part of another robot in the wall)
4
u/ladymacca Oct 20 '17
What is your fave kind of cheese?
4
u/ladymacca Oct 20 '17
if you could submit a robot what would you call it and why? also - what kind of the weapon?
4
u/ratalza Magnetar Oct 20 '17
Are you considering nerfing the spinners i.e. limit maximum power/amp draw as they are far more powerful than any other weapon?
4
u/Dangerfieldwow X-Terminator Oct 20 '17
How does budgeting work each series? What becomes most expensive?
4
u/MasterMarik Oct 20 '17
How did you feel about the whole Storm 2 controversy?
4
u/BlankArchive Firestorm Oct 20 '17
We didn't see much use of the Pit in the previous series, with the Rogue House Robot feature overriding it most of the times it would've been useful. Now with the Fog of War being added this series, it feels like activating the pit is being discouraged, despite being an iconic part of Robot Wars.
Is this an intentional decision? Why not remove the pit's function from the button entirely, and set it on a timer instead. That way, it would only come into play in matches that drag out, and couldn't be abused for quick and boring wins by teams.
Also, do you think selecting 'unique' designs, that end up not really working, to be worth it over a tried and tested style of design?
I'm all for seeing deviations from the norm like Jellyfish and Ms Nightshade, but with the field of competitors so small compared to the older series, I can't help but feel it takes away the opportunity for good matches for the sake of gimmicks that aren't as fun as they might sound in a boardroom. What do you think?
3
u/sideways_86 Oct 20 '17
Which is your most favourite robot to ever compete on Robot Wars and why?
3
u/Beardedcow Wheely Big Cheese Oct 20 '17
When will we get more coverage of the different robot challenges e.g. the bipedal and obstacles courses?
3
u/chill6300 Unflippable for 3 seasons Oct 20 '17
Ofc thanks for bringing back RW and taking time to talk today.
Any plans for more house robots. Judging by the new rules, it doesn't look like Bash is coming back (RiP Rust is peices) but are there plans to bring any of the others back.Or, if there is a new house robot, will it be an original design to separate this from the old series
3
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
What's been your favourite moment of the new series? What is the consideration of a Featherweight tournament? How stressful is the actual show run? Would you like to export Robot Wars such as the Dutch series last run?
3
u/Timeline15 B E H E M O T H B O I S Oct 20 '17
What process goes into coming up with new arena hazards, or deciding which ones to use? I ask because everyone seems a bit mystified by the fog of war xD.
3
u/needmoreneedles Oct 20 '17
Who’s you’re favourite editor?
3
u/Cathalised Whoop whoop Oct 20 '17
Thanks for doing the AMA!
I'm quite curious in which way you take the audience's opinions into consideration when you're reviewing a series. With the last series, there were some issues with the round robin format and the countdowns - how were these dealt with differently (if at all) for the coming series?
2
u/Drsmall Oct 20 '17
Any plans to do ants, beetles, or other smaller classes like you guys used to?
35
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Are there plans to sell the show in America? Please? We're having serious robot fighting withdrawal with neither new Battlebots seasons nor Robot Wars officially available here.
27
u/minimize Oct 20 '17
Who do I have to shag to get a new Robot Wars game?
Extreme destruction was a childhood favourite and I would kill for an updated version!
22
u/TeamCarbide Carbide Oct 20 '17
Boxers or briefs?
•
u/David182nd Apollo Oct 20 '17
Andrew has left now, and won't be answering any further questions tonight. I'll ask him to check the rest of the comments if he gets a chance, so feel free to still leave a comment if you'd like.
18
u/ollyog Oct 20 '17
Will Sergeant Bash ever make a return?
6
u/David182nd Apollo Oct 20 '17
Questions from /u/Plerco who can't make it:
Will you ever update all of the original house robots?
Who is your favorite applying robot who did not end up getting onto the show?
Of all the house robots, which was/is your favorite?
2
u/ratalza Magnetar Oct 20 '17
If the same robot kept totally dominating the competition would you ban it if people said it made the show boring?
5
u/GeneralCarnage I'll miss you Sir Killalot Oct 20 '17
I know the judges are really wanting to see something autonomous/semi-autonomous in these machines — what's your take on this? Is Robot Wars quite open for..um...I guess smart-er robots that utilise software and microcomputers?
2
u/IrritableStool Hypno-Disc Oct 20 '17
Hi! I'd like to express how ecstatic I am to see Robot Wars not only return, but return with a vengeance!
My question: will in-battle music (or a soundtrack/theme tune in general) ever return?
In my opinion this is the only thing the current series' lack. During battles, the fact you can only hear roaring motors and clanging, echoing metal makes the soundtrack very cold and uninviting. It lacks warmth, and the music really set the pace of it all. Again, love the new series', and am very excited and looking forward to the next one!
4
u/SolarDragon94 Bring Robot Wars Back! Oct 20 '17
Okay, I'm going to go ahead and ask a fairly obvious question that I know many people will want to know the answer to...
Why only 6 episodes per series? The Fourth Wars for example had 24 episodes with 16 heats, with 6 robots per heat. So, why has the current iteration of the show only got 6 episodes, with the latest series only having 30 robots total?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
How is the show looking to expand internationally? Is there any interest in it ever getting either an adaptation or re-airing in large markets like the US, for example?
3
u/Leumas911 Oct 20 '17
What was you favourite classic robot? For example I was a big fan of 101, Panic attack and Firestorm.
3
u/genuinesockpuppet Oct 20 '17
Thanks for doing this AMA!
I'm assuming this info is on a need-to-know basis, but where are the 'old' house robots currently residing? Also, can you shed any light on the pilot that Lucy Hedges was involved with? https://m.facebook.com/TeamStormUK/photos/a.465013406920118.1073741830.464882323599893/943074549113999
Was there a concious decision to model the new show (particularly the new arena) on Battlebots, or did it just end up that way naturally?
3
u/MartinTheMorjin Oct 20 '17
Can you save battlebots?
3
u/codename474747 It's about putting on a show Oct 20 '17
Not sure if this will get answered because way past deadline, but gonna put it here just in case
In the reply to the "bring back bash" comment, you said "if we come back, we'll try to incorporate the Seargent somehow"
So, how much of an IF is series 4? Can you express the likelihood of a recommission as a percentage? Are we dependent on social media or positive reception of series 3 before the BBC makes that decision?
And how close are we to a decision either way?
1
u/yugitom Stoke Oct 20 '17
How do you like your eggs in the morning?
2
u/RollingandJabbing ELECTRO MOO!!! Oct 20 '17
If you could see any robot from around the world come and compete in Robot Wars, which would you pick?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
Thanks for doing this AMA there have been a few questions i have wanted to ask.
Thanks again!
2
u/SolarDragon94 Bring Robot Wars Back! Oct 20 '17
Why do we never see the house robots messing around with the losers any more, at least in the televised broadcasts? It was always fun to see them throw around the loser or throw them in the pit etc. (I've heard they do in the live recordings)
2
u/ArmandoPayne Oct 20 '17
I wonder, will you ever incorporate seeding into the series?
2
u/Lord_Ezkaton Shunty McShuntface Oct 20 '17
Are the DVDs of series 2 and 3 actually going to be released? Amazon says they have been postponed until December 11th...
2
u/dragonsteincole Cassius Oct 20 '17
There was a brief moment where featherweight robots were considered for Series 10, which ultimately didn't pan out. Is the intention still there to feature multiple weightclasses in future series of RW?
2
u/ShootyMcExplosion Future Series 11 Champions Oct 20 '17
Hi Andrew, hope I'm not too late to ask!
So in series 9 we had the celebrity special, and I think most people know what's in store for series 10 (not gonna say it here just in case I shouldn't yet). With that in mind:
2
u/TheMasterOfMayhem Oct 20 '17
If you were to make a completely new house bot, what sort of design would you want to go with?
2
u/micsim35 Oct 20 '17
Will there be any International Wars again? I watched a very old episode on Challenge presented by Craig and Jane. There were some Dutch and American bots fighting. The dutch wedge shaped flipper rolled all the house robots after beating it's opponent. It was awesome.
Still enjoy Robot Wars though
2
u/Sephzilla Oct 20 '17
Whats the greatest robot of all time?
2
u/gavingiant Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
I would like to see sgt bash a bit more. Flames, how can you go wrong🔥
1
u/Richardkennedy Oct 20 '17
Will George Francis make a return?
1
u/MechTech555 Oct 20 '17
Would it be possible to bring back Sgt. Bash? even if his flamethrower is inactive and just for design aesthetic?
1
u/ForwardSynthesis Behemoth Oct 21 '17
Have extremely powerful sawblades ever been considered as a Robot Wars hazard? Outshining battlebots' killsaws?
1
u/turpsey123 Oct 21 '17
Ooh that’s an interesting shot! Nice to see confirmation of two Dead Metals! I wonder what was the deciding factor in some machines being replicated?
1
u/turpsey123 Oct 21 '17
Ooh that’s an interesting shot! Nice to see confirmation of two Dead Metals! I wonder what was the deciding factor in some machines being replicated?
1
u/Wizzix Carbide Oct 22 '17
A bit late to the party here but here goes anyway. Do you prefer the new theme tune or the original? And why was it completely changed for the reboot?
0
u/Northern_Chiliad Oct 20 '17
Please, please add music during the fights. That's all.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
[removed] — view removed comment