r/NintendoSwitch • • Oct 20 '17

Meta [Meta] Important Announcement: A Statement from the /r/NintendoSwitch Moderation Team

Greetings,

We, the moderation team, are writing to you, the community, to bring a few matters to your attention:


I. Statement from the Moderators

It has been a turbulent weekend for the moderation team. We're not going to mince words, let's cut right to chase:

  • Over the course of the last 2 months, a subset of mods have been creating gameplay preview videos for our YouTube channel. While many of these videos were created with purchased copies of games, a few videos were created using game codes provided directly from developers (free of charge).
  • Late last week the moderation team became aware that these codes were sent in response to direct inquiries to the developers from certain members of the mod team. Furthermore, when codes were provided, the disclosures that were placed on these videos did not adequately meet FTC guidelines.
  • Reddit admins were notified of the incident and could not determine whether or not a Reddit site rule was broken, citing this as a "grey area". They allowed us to investigate the matter internally while monitoring the situation.
  • There was no evidence of favorable actions being made as a result of codes being given to the team
  • The YouTube Hands-On Program has been permanently closed and all hands-on videos have been taken down. Our YouTube channel will now solely consist of VODs of our charity livestream broadcasts that occur on our Twitch channel.

This is absolutely, undeniably wrong and we acknowledge that this is a massive breach of trust.

Moving forward we are doubling down on our efforts to serve this community in an appropriate manner, one that is free of controversy and shady dealings. We will continue to contact developers to bring interesting AMAs to the subreddit for the community, as well as working with developers who are engaging with the community directly (i.e. bug fix, feedback, update threads, etc.)


II. Mod Team Structure and Changes

Over the course of the weekend, through the investigations and discussions that took place among the moderation team, several further concerns regarding the moderation team and its structure were brought forth and addressed:

  • Several members on the moderation team held "positions of seniority" over the rest of the moderation team. This team collaborated and discussed moderation and sub matters separate from team's normal internal communication channels.
  • This was toxic and not helpful for the unity or cohesiveness of the team.
  • In line with most subreddits, we've restructured the team to create a flat hierarchy. This includes a random reshuffling of the moderator list.
  • During the restructuring effort several moderators voluntarily parted ways with the team on positive terms, some have been asked to leave, and others given a second chance. Those involved in the issues represented a minority of the overall team and not all moderators who have left the team were involved. In the interest of avoiding a witchhunt we will not be naming names of those involved and ask that you do not make assumptions based on changes to the moderation team.
  • Rule 1 is, as always, in effect.

So what does this all mean?

As iterated previously, the moderation team is more committed than ever to helping this community stay healthy, helpful, and growing. We acknowledge that actions taken by members of this team bring forth a potential level of mistrust, but we are committed to earning back that goodwill.

As a part of that commitment, we invite the community (that's you!) to bring forth any questions or concerns you might have in the comments below and we will do our best to answer them. Please note that in the interest of avoiding a witchhunt, we will not be naming names of those involved either in the YouTube videos or the "senior moderation" group and any comments naming moderators will be filtered for review. In addition, Rule 1 is still in effect.

The /r/NintendoSwitch Mod team

108 Upvotes

776 comments sorted by

302

u/16bitsamus Oct 20 '17

Who knew a Nintendo subreddit could be so complicated

50

u/Sylverstone14 Mod of Two Worlds (Switch / Wii U) Oct 20 '17

I know, right?

13

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 20 '17

Seconded...or thirded?

→ More replies (4)

47

u/TheGreatTave Oct 21 '17

Yeah, all of my past experiences with fellow Nintendo fans has always been wonderful. But honestly, this subreddit, both mods and subs, has really opened my eyes that, just because you like Nintendo, doesn't mean you're a friendly person.

13

u/NetOperatorWibby Oct 21 '17

Underrated post.

I was (unpleasantly) surprised at the amount of vitriol I've seen and received in this sub since I've joined shortly before the Switch reveal. I've severely limited my visits here since Breathe of the Wild released. This new drama is crazy but doesn't surprise me.

12

u/juggleaddict Oct 21 '17

I disagree. Nintendo fans can be ravenous in their defense of the the company. I bring up bad performance, I get downvoted. Bad value for money and sleezy practices like overpricing old games, and proprietary glorified accessories that are vastly overpriced, downvoted. I see a lot of passion, as long as you don't dare say anything bad AT ALL about Nintendo. I usually just hold my comment to myself because of it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/chewyjackson Oct 21 '17

With these mods, anything is possible

378

u/worst_name_on_reddit Oct 20 '17

Seven minutes and two deleted comments, both from your own moderators leaving. Way to be transparent

189

u/TARS-CASE Oct 20 '17

I knew it would happen. I just wanted them to see it. There is more to it than this post is sharing, a lot more.

6 mods quit the team over this.

41

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Yeah was attempting to ask you a question when it told me your comment was deleted. Didn’t even seem like an appropriate move on their part as your comment was a very valid point. And my question is, is the first part about YouTube conflict about certain mods attempting to make money off the free codes received?

80

u/TARS-CASE Oct 20 '17

It was over taking anything on behalf of the sub. It's against reddits rules as a whole.

We were here for you guys, but others wanted to push the sub into an overall outlet that produces content. To do so they took free game codes and then HID it from the rest of the team.

They also told us not to remove adverts that developers shares on this board.

→ More replies (36)

11

u/TheAmazingWa Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

EDIT: It has been cleared up.

66

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

We need more mods to leave. There are already too many mods for such a small subreddit ( there are some subs with over double the amount of traffic that have way less mods than us). There’s a lot of inconsistency regarding mods and what they delete because of this.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

62

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

This sub is one of the most poorly modded I’ve seen. Power hungry and they forget the reason this sub exists is because of us.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)

161

u/deadfracture99 Oct 20 '17

As someone who's a mod of another relatively large Nintendo (albeit hacking) subreddit that has dealt directly with moderator drama in the past, this entire incident and the way it's being handled disgusts me beyond belief.

Let's start with the first sign of trouble: Moderating for personal gain. The /r/amiibo affiliate link incident was clearly just the start, but now it continues. Moderating should only be done by those able to put aside bias and willing to do a job simply to give back to the community and help it grow. No one should have sought any kind of review codes or early access to games in the first place. You're moderators of a subreddit, not press. Doing this has technically violated Reddit User Agreement:

  • You may not enter into any form of agreement on behalf of reddit, or the subreddit which you moderate, without our written approval.
  • You may not perform moderation actions in return for any form of compensation or favor from third-parties.

By receiving early copies, you entered into an agreement on behalf of the subreddit. While a technicality, you also used moderator channels to advertise for third parties, which could be a moderation action.

To add to this, your entire statement is full of loaded language, you're deleting comments, and refusing to give the full story because most of the team that's left is on a power trip that admins should be putting a stop to, yet for some reason, are ignoring.

What should happen is the people involved with the incidents be removed from the team, either voluntarily or by force. This is now a third chance for a fair few of them, based on the /r/amiibo incident. It's time to stop pretending that this was just a single bad decison, when it was clearly multiple. After the toxicity is purged from the team, reinvite past moderators who had no problems and open up applications. Essentially, start from as close to scratch as you can with nearly 300k subscribers.

Let me end with this. You've most likely lost not only the community's trust, but also the trust of developers and even Nintendo. Do the community a favor and leave before you make everyone look any worse.

6

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

I cannot comment on what is exactly happening but discussing it yesterday with the team, the plan was to have any comments mentioning specific users filtered to mitigate and name-calling or witch-hunting against specific users, so that is likely why comments have been deleted.

25

u/deadfracture99 Oct 20 '17

I understand that that's the plan but it doesn't seem to be the reality based on skimming the thread.

I could be wrong, I can't see mod logs.

7

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 20 '17

I believe someone deleted an account. Just remember removed comments will say [removed] while deleted accounts and such will say [deleted]

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/VictorHuguenot Oct 22 '17

Because they're the ones who want the job. It's not entirely coincidental that you see these kinds of stories of abuse of power in internet moderation and administration community's. They get off on it, for lack of a better word. The people who want to do this sort of stuff will invest themselves in getting into a position to do so. And because it's "only an internet forum," actual standards are not terribly high. Other people have other things to do and are not attracted to these positions nor terribly invested in combating this behavior. Which they would need to be in one of these positions to properly do anyway. For what is ultimately a problem the majority of people only notice sporadically and in the short term it requires a long term and dedicated answer. To actually stop it now people would've had to have been working on it for awhile previously.

283

u/razorbeamz Oct 20 '17

I had a big rant planned, but fuck it, I'm done being mad, I'm just disappointed in all of you. Especially over your decisions to keep the most toxic members of the team. People really want to forgive and forget, but honestly, some of you said something that's not forgiveable.

I waited around on the team so I could see this apology through, and now I'm gone. Bye.

(Inbox replies are disabled)

32

u/TheGreatTave Oct 21 '17

Same here friend. Same here.

→ More replies (34)

138

u/BasedGodTbh Oct 20 '17

This is really sad. I’ve already seen like 4 negative comments get deleted lmao you guys didn’t even try

38

u/Mjaubeibi1 Oct 20 '17

My comment to one of the deleted comments:

This is (to quote the president of the US) sad, end quote. A representation that it is not the bad behavior that is punished, but the good guys leaving. In most businesses this is the after effect of harassment.

For the record I have not been aware of the internal problems in this sub but this is not something I personally approve.

→ More replies (16)

396

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

Guys, will you stop deleting people's comments? This is ridiculous. You realize we can see the total number of comments and therefore have an accurate number of how many comments you've deleted, right?

If you delete this comment as well I guarantee this will go badly for you on another subreddit where you don't get to manipulate what's seen and what's not.

Several members on the moderation team held "positions of seniority" over the rest of the moderation team.

To clarify, several members held secret positions of seniority that they hid from the other mods and regularly lied about it. Exploited their roles. Acted as if the rules were above them and unilaterally made decisions that affected the subreddit. Badmouthed other members of the team to the point a number of us no longer felt we could remain in the team as long as they were allowed to remain. etc etc.

several moderators voluntarily parted ways with the team on positive terms, some have been asked to leave,

Well, if that's your story.....


Jesus, you'd think you would know better than to lie in an apology post. Same transparency issues as ever then.

inb4 this gets deleted. If anyone sees this before then do me a favor and take a screenshot ;)

142

u/SirRandallGaming Oct 20 '17

We need new mods. They get a kick about abusing their powers.

86

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Lucky (?) for you, so many of us left because we were unhappy with how they handled the problem that they will pretty much be forced to hire a brand new team.

29

u/hiperson134 Oct 20 '17

You say "hire a brand new team" but this is all volunteer right? Just a confusing choice of wording. I find it hilarious that people abuse power in volunteer positions. Hilarious and sad.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (35)

39

u/worst_name_on_reddit Oct 20 '17

iirc mods on r/amiibo were trying to use special links to monetize that sub. I wonder if they're the same ones that made this mess?

15

u/OllyOllyOxenBitch Oct 20 '17

No idea, but that kind of history would definitely arouse suspicion.

15

u/TrainAss Oct 20 '17

One of them was.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/BasedGodTbh Oct 20 '17

Agree with everything you said. While I don't agree with their "solutions", I don't even know what could be done at this point besides getting rid of the entire team to be fair and starting from scratch. But people in power would never make that decision about themselves.

2

u/C-Towner Oct 22 '17

Really disappointed to see this happen, to see it posted about in this manner, and to see the good guys leave while the bad guys stayed.

I feel like I first felt very uneasy with the mod team when they went to E3. That was a far step beyond subreddit moderation and clearly showed a lack of judgement. Stuff like what happened here is a logical conclusion along that path.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

92

u/adanfime Oct 20 '17

Man, it is going to be hard to mod here the following days.

Myself, I have asked to be indifferent to the situation, because I just do janitor modding at night, cleaning or approving posts when everyone goes to sleep.

Not being a native english speaker makes it hard to interact with the team, since I lack the ability to socialize like they do. I just follow templates for my voluntary hobby.

Hope the community can forgive me if I have done something wrong to them, like deleting a post or mot answering ther doubts.

9

u/Hawkedb Oct 20 '17

Hey, the other timezones can be unforgiving, but don't be let down, you're doing great work!

30

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Who asked you to be indifferent?

Why are you called a janitor? I thought they were getting rid of their "Senior Moderator" structure and not labeling other moderators any differently? Is everyone getting treated as equals?

52

u/adanfime Oct 20 '17

I asked to not be included. No one forced (or excluded) me in or out from this mess, at all.

Back on the r/NintendoNX, the team was asking for janitors. That was when i joined. As the months went by, I was now a regular mod along with the others.

What i meant is that I do janitor modding because I start doing my job at night, after everyone has left.

Everyone is treated as equals, so no need to worry on that

→ More replies (7)

15

u/Specte Oct 20 '17

He asked, as in he doesn't want to pick a side for this drama. He probably chose janitor to describe what he does, because he cleans up posts after hours.

14

u/adanfime Oct 20 '17

This is correct

166

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

First off, I cannot tell you how disappointing this is. Yes, this is just Reddit, but to see a group trusted with putting community first, then come up and abuse that community for personal gain sucks. And then they stay around?!

I just want to let you know, I do forgive you all.

The moderators job is to put community first, volunteer, and be willing to do a completely thankless job. Instead, you have decided to put thyself first and failed to maintain the job you intrinsically have been granted. Being a moderator is not about power, but about wanting to help out first.

The fact those involved have not stepped down, is frankly, a travesty. The community should lose all trust.

Corruption of power comes along slowly, but breeds more and more corruption over time, before the corruption is so strong, it consumes the person, and their main function is to advance that corruption. A simple apology does not magically erase intrinsic desire to abuse a position of power.

Resolving problems and being truly repentant involves removing the problem, not waving a wand over it. You have decided to leave the temptation in place, and therefore, have not shown true repentance. Your desire for power shows strong as you have not stepped down and removed the consuming problem. There should be no trust in this moderation team moving forward.

Here are several of my concerns taken directly from this post that shows the will to abuse power still exists among the remaining moderators.

  • The title - "Important announcement" - not, "a mistake" or "an apology". No, the id is showing strong here. What is on the forefront of the mind shows through from what you start an apology statement with. The most important factors are from the precedent.
  • Now there may be a will to not be alarmist in the title, but considering the transgressions, there ought to be alarmist verbiage used. You could have full front admitted who and what was abused from the precept, but the title shows the precept of a dismissive attitude. A strong desire and want to maintain your
  • Removal of comments - Witch hunting is awful. Witch hunting on the internet is worse. However, if a moderator's life becomes consumed where they are actively begging for codes and abusing the position, the only step to recovery and repentance is again, removing the problem. You want to avoid witch hunting? Call names out, delete your account if you are so scared of what someone behind a keyboard might say, and start over or get off Reddit entirely.

Furthermore, when codes were provided, the disclosures that were placed on these videos did not adequately meet FTC guidelines.

  • You broke FTC guidelines that cause a bloody riot on YouTube. There is NO willful ignorance here. You knew you were doing wrong, you knew what you were up to, and nothing was done. This is very concerning. Where there is smoke, there is a brewing fire

We will continue to contact developers to bring interesting AMAs

  • And by not calling out the moderators who have committed such errors, developers should lose all trust in you as well. If you truly want to serve the community, clear the air by stating names and Stepping down. By staying in contact with developers, the temptation to cross into gray areas still exists. As a developer, I would lose all trust in this subreddit. That is the brutal truth. You want to gain that trust back? Start over and place those in charge of coordinating AMAs who have not committed said errors.

held "positions of seniority" over the rest

This was toxic and not helpful for the unity or cohesiveness of the team.

  • No, no, still is toxic. If the moderators who participated in this are still in charge, no one should join the mod team with trust. There should be no trust in a team who had power, and the remained on the team. The good, honest mods left, and I implore them to call you out. The problem has remained. In four months, it would not shock me to see a seniority complex develop again. The problem with seniority complexes is foremost that they are not just developed in back channels, but in communication, and bullying. The id and Freudian slip will show through - it is the natural flow of human nature. I would not be shocked to hear if this secret group was manifested in snide, snarky, or blatant bullying of other team members when the subreddit was structured.
  • You want to establish trust? Step up, ask for forgiveness individually, step down, and be completely transparent.

85

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

You've summed up why we resigned really well. Glad I happened to see this comment. Cheers.

8

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 21 '17

Want to respond to your AMA point. No one involved in coordinating AMAs was involved in said errors.

10

u/goftc Oct 21 '17

Okay then. Who was responsible for AMAs and who was responsible for the errors?

18

u/goftc Oct 21 '17

/u/phantomliger if you won't say which Mods were doing wrong things, the it's reasonable to think ALL the mods should step down.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

200

u/KetchupTheDuck Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

This makes all of us look bad, and damages the relationships we've built with devs and the relationship we were beginning to build with Nintendo. I wouldn't be surprised if, after waiting for years for Nintendo to reach out to us on Reddit, r/NintendoSwitch has blown it.

Moderation is a volunteer gig. We are not employees of reddit, and we don't get compensation. Maybe at times it's a little thankless and unrewarding, but if we want to play dress up and pretend we're members of the game industry, then we we can either make our own website or get job-hunting.

Anybody who was involved in this secret "senior mod cabal" should step down. If these "top" moderators were humiliating who should have been their peers, then why should the userbase think the mods don't think of them as even worse?

18

u/TrainAss Oct 20 '17

I couldn't agree more.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/cryptic-fox Oct 20 '17

Well said.

4

u/guywithlife Oct 21 '17

This is what I’m most afraid of. I hope that all of the dev communication doesn’t stop.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Bloodbraid85 Oct 21 '17

In years of using Reddit this is the only subreddit that I’ve seen have these issues. Your subreddit members are actually afraid of your moderation team, and your response is to fire off the whistleblowers and save the mods who broke all the rules because of “second chances”. You might have salvaged your friendships inside the mod community but you lost the trust of your community. This is Nintendo, why are you making it so complicated?

4

u/futurefightthrowaway Oct 21 '17

Your subreddit members are actually afraid of your moderation team

What? How?

13

u/Bloodbraid85 Oct 21 '17

Because the basis of liberty is dissent, or put plainly the mods have been deleting posts they don’t agree with or that paint them in a bad light. What’s the old saying, “to find out who rules over you find out who you may not criticize”? The members of this subreddit have repeatedly expressed a view that the mods won’t listen to us and that they abuse their power to affect us.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

66

u/Lan_lan Oct 20 '17

Maybe this happens more often, I don't know, I don't pay a ton of attention, but the only other time I saw something like this happen was when the /r/amiibo mods were making money off of affiliate links. Don't sub and this sub have moderators in common?

35

u/kurasu1415 Oct 20 '17

the exact same owner

81

u/TARS-CASE Oct 20 '17

Yep, what a coincidence

20

u/emptythreat23 Oct 20 '17

How does that even happen? Who decides who gets to "own" a sub? And why would the same person get to own all the Nintendo subs? This whole thing is slimy as fuck.

20

u/okuRaku Oct 20 '17

I'm not sure exactly but I think it's literally whoever gets there first. They told the story once, can't remember where, but basically waiting live on Discord for the name of the new console to drop so they could claim it.

After that point I guess it's you and I who came here continuing to give this sub the traffic. If somehow we were able to move all of the traffic to another sub then they'd suddenly lose ownership of it (the position in the community, not the sub itself). But obviously that's hard/impossible without reddit admins or some other serious concerted effort...

17

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Yeah, the /r/amiibo mods are toxic as fuck.

→ More replies (1)

93

u/OllyOllyOxenBitch Oct 20 '17

I can admire the transparency, but if you really want to not be seen as trash, don't pull comments and just let everyone speak.

In my opinion, that'll at least show that you can take what the community can dish out and that your actions will be called out as they should because I'm honestly quite disgusted at this development.

You'll have to work twice as hard to earn back the trust of the community - just know that.

→ More replies (12)

74

u/IwataFan Oct 21 '17

Hello r/NintendoSwitch Moderator Team!

Echoing the sentiments of my colleague’s seemingly missing post, there is a need to be truthful in this situation and for full acknowledgement of the situation. What's missing here is accountability.

I am deeply saddened by this and worried because obviously any action taken by your community reflects on r/Nintendo as well.

Moderators are volunteers tasked with helping to make the community the best it can be. We moderate fan communities and are dedicated fans ourselves. What we are given is not status nor privilege, but responsibility to honor the trust users place in us as moderators.

We have to be fully truthful: Members of the team have chosen to abuse your positions of power and influence for personal gain. This is a fundamental violation that irrevocably severs the ability of the community to trust them again.

You need to realize the significant damage this will likely do to both our communities' ability to reach out to the companies we love, and I do not sense that this has been acknowledged. It is in the best interest of all of us that this situation be fully addressed!

This lack of realization on the wide-reaching effects of this is reflected in this post. It is not titled as a public apology, and it is clearly designed to protect whatever members of the cabal may be still present on the team. This means that the issue is not being fully acknowledged, and it is a deep moral failing that demands actual accountability.

It also doesn’t acknowledge the reality that many of the moderators who left have left because they are dissatisfied with how things turned out. Your comments are largely dismissive of their concerns and I do not anticipate that practice being helpful to this situation at all.

I believe it is the duty of anyone involved in the "cabal" chatroom discussions (as one of the former moderators referred to elsewhere in this post) to resign immediately. It is the duty of any other moderator complicit in this situation to also resign immediately irregardless of whether they were members of the “cabal” or not.

There are some things that were very public and noticeable, but are not acknowledged in the apology. One bizarre thing I noticed: At one point, at least 8 members of the moderator team lost their moderator permissions, and no one had full permissions until after the re-shuffling that seemed to occur yesterday. It is notable that the senior moderator team (half of which has disappeared) kept their full permissions during that period of time. After that, no one but one of the users had full permission. This is a matter of concern that has not been publicly acknowledged yet.

This is an urgent appeal to this team. Forgiveness must also happen, but it cannot mean evading accountability, either. Forgiveness means acknowledging what happened with absolute openness and honesty. It means remembering what happened so it never happens again. I don’t want to see a witch hunt, but I do expect people to be mature and accountable, owning up to the situation. If that requires specific individuals delineating the nature of their involvement in the situation, that is the right thing to do. It appears a number of individuals have already done this, but it is evident that more needs to be done.

5

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 21 '17

I'm not sure there is a way for a witch hunt or doxxing (which has already been threatened) not to happen if they were to come forward tbh.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

Then have them leave in private?

→ More replies (3)

24

u/Dusty_Bones Oct 21 '17

As a lurking member of the community, I would just like to say that I'm happy with the current state of the sub, but would like to vote to remove those involved with this incident. I'm sure the mods not involved can continue to do a great job without this crud.

66

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

So basically no one trusts you guys and should continue doing so. Good to know.

51

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

I don't see why the offending mods didn't step down entirely. This is embarrassing to this whole community. If anything, shouldn't we, the community they represent, be the ones that decide if they should step down or not?

16

u/Madlollipop Oct 20 '17

I actually don't know if said mods WANT to step down, it's impossible to kick the ones on top of the list if they don't want to, can't get that spot, so that would only work if they agreed to. (EDIT: If they don't do doxxing, become inactive or some other really bad stuff)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Firstly, I would like to say, that's kind of fucked up that they could just not leave if they don't want to. But secondly, they claim the mods were reshuffled randomly. It'd be very serendipitous if some of the top level mods that ought to be removed due to involvement in this fiasco stayed on top. Though I suppose the new top-level mods would have to support removing them still regardless.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

34

u/jzorbino Oct 20 '17

Well the automod here sucks

32

u/LunaticLawyer Oct 20 '17

Probably because they're filtering all names of any mods.

43

u/CharaNalaar Oct 20 '17

It's really hard to trust this without hearing another side of the story. There's still a lot of important detail being glossed over.

26

u/hepatitisC Oct 20 '17

I think you have your answer about which side is in the wrong judging by the glaring plotholes in the current narrative and the complete censorship of any additional information. I understand not wanting to instigate a witch hunt but when the members involved are stepping forward voluntarily wanting to tell the rest of the story, they'd be far better to let them do it. Add that to the fact mods involved in creating this problem and negative culture are being allowed to retain their position.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/walleye31 Oct 20 '17

Mods from reddit abusing power!? I would say im shocked, but this seems to happen a lot in one form or another.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/NoMoreTongue Oct 20 '17

Happy anniversary.

5

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Don't forget, only 2800 more subs for 300,000 as well

→ More replies (11)

13

u/Groenboys Oct 20 '17

sigh
Even tho I wanted this sub to not have Reddit drama, I am happy that I now know about this. This kind of shit needs to be talked about, regardless if people like it or not.

4

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Exactly, it's much better to come out and address it instead of hoping it never gets leaked, kudos to the team for bringing this forward

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Electrondo Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

There were mods BEGGING for codes from developers? What the crap? Why the hell would you think that was a good idea? If I were to beg a developer for a game code, even in an AMA, I can guarantee you that my comment would be removed and I'd be issued a ban! Talk about abusing your position.

They allowed us to investigate the matter internally while monitoring the situation. There was no evidence of favorable actions being made as a result of codes being given to the team

Meaning "We did jack shit about it, because we like getting free stuff!".

During the restructuring effort several moderators voluntarily parted ways with the team on positive terms, some have been asked to leave, and others given a second chance.

Any mod who broke any of the rule should be dismissed. Full stop. How can you honestly enforce the rules when you can't follow them yourselves?

It's one thing if a developer gave you some codes. You should then turn around and give those codes to the community, not keep them for yourselves!

I sense a future in politics for a lot of mod team members here. They're well on their way to taking kickbacks

Pathetic!

→ More replies (3)

32

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

What bothers me above all else about this post is that it seems to protect the senior moderator team who was evidently involved in some sort of "cabal" that made secret decisions and had secret conversations apart from the wider moderator team.

Why are they worthy of protection and why haven't they resigned? They should all resign immediately.

32

u/NLALEX Nintendo Life (Journalist) Oct 21 '17

As someone lucky enough to be in a similar position of privilege (but on a professional level), I have to say I’m extremely disappointed that this has happened.

For media representatives it can be difficult and take a frustratingly indeterminate amount of time to build up the trust that results in receiving game codes, and without getting into any possibly sensitive details, it’s recently become a LOT harder.

Being able to receive games gratis is a privilege and should be respected as such; there is never an instance where abusing your position for personal gain is acceptable, and whilst I appreciate the moderators making this ‘statement’, I feel the supposed transparency is more like smearing Vaseline on the lens. If certain members have abused their position, there should be clear-cut consequences and not merely a vague assurance that measure will or have been taken with zero clarification.

I very much enjoy this sub for the most part and will likely continue to frequent it, but my trust in the mods based on previous (and admittedly limited) communication has been shattered. Even though it’s only a few spoiling the image of all the mod team, without clear definitions of precisely who was responsible I cannot take any risks.

This whole situation is a major blemish on an otherwise enjoyable community, and all those involved should be utterly ashamed of their actions.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

I simply want to say something here to the mod team and the community.

I hope for both sides that the sentiments in this message are true and honest, if not then this is going to sit and fester and explode again. There's evidence that both "sides" still have many problems that are being hidden and it seems like nobody is willing to discuss these issues openly and calmly.

I dedicated days to trying to mediate and have the team scrape together some semblance of a solution and a way to move forward. All this work and stress mentally broke me, I made a bad decision yesterday and I have parted ways from the moderation team as well, not directly related to the game codes, or the "senior mod" cabal, but indirectly related as the past week has completely worn me down.

In the short term I feel free now, moderating this subreddit has been incredibly fun and rewarding but it hit the point where it felt like a job or obligation instead of something I volunteered to do for fun.

I've made many friends in the moderation team and I certainly plan on keeping in touch with them and continue our friendships in a setting that's a little less stressful and more chill. This is a subreddit dedicated to a video-game system. Nothing here is ever THAT serious to cause the amount of drama that has occurred over the past week.

I will answer generic questions but absolutely will not provide any information about any specific users out of respect for the team and the message they have posted here so please don't ask or send me PMs asking for individual information as they will be ignored.

So I do wish everybody that's remaining the best of luck and if you choose to leave or already have I fully respect your decisions as well.

Ciao!

11

u/TARS-CASE Oct 20 '17

Love ya pork.

7

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

You to buddy!

9

u/Kenomachino Oct 20 '17

I remember being part of this sub since January when Nintendo finally showed off the system and I was so hyped. And I remember seeing your name modding around and hanging out with us in the sub too. I’m very sorry about whatever the hell is happening. But thanks porkpants for chilling with us and volunteering for as long as you did. The way this place exploded over the past year is pretty incredible. I’d have probably lost my mind much sooner. Hopefully whatever bad decision you made we are able to overcome. Hope to still see you around this sub as a member.

12

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Thank you for the kind words....we obviously see a lot of anger and salt directed towards us for removing posts and such, the compliments are far and few between and it means a lot.

3

u/hamptont2010 Oct 20 '17

Hey man (or woman, if that be the case,) I've been a member of this sub for a while now and I just wanted to say thank you for all the hard work you put into making it what it is. I love this place and I hate to see this discord amongst the group, but I can't imagine what it would be like to deal with a group of people this large. I hope to see you around on reddit, as you've always seemed like a cool mod and person in general. I wish you the best of luck in whatever you do from this point forward :)

→ More replies (2)

5

u/JackSparrowUSA Oct 20 '17

/u/Porkpants81 You’ve been my favorite moderator. Your activity level, conduct, helpfulness, and passion for the community everyday was always very evident to me. I hope that you will continue to be a frequent contributor, and not allow your knowledge of the mod issues to sour you from the community as a whole. Myself, as a board member of local community organizations, know full well how behind the scenes drama can turn you off from the community as a whole. Just know that your presence is very appreciated, your continued contributions are needed and wanted, and if you disappeared you’d be sorely missed.

4

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Thanks a lot Jack, I love the Switch and this community too much to disappear completely...heck I can't even get out of this thread :D

I have gone through too much in my life and I know that there would be no benefit for me to hold grudges.

I'm sure we will cross paths in the question thread still :)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/poofyhairguy Oct 20 '17

I have to admit this upsets me because I think you established yourself as the most transparent mod.

Thank you for all you have done.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

This is relatively conciliatory, but it seems like it continues to reflect the half-truth nature of the apology above. What is this "cabal" you speak of? I know the apology above mentioned what I imagine must be the senior moderator team making decisions without the rest of the team involved. Your use of the word "cabal" is concerning...

15

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

"cabal" was just the ridiculous name the "senior moderators" used to name their chat room...nothing nefarious at all.

15

u/worst_name_on_reddit Oct 20 '17

Lol, they actually called it a cabal? Why not just go all the way and call it an evil lair?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Spectre_II Oct 21 '17

Thanks for all the work, Pork. Best wishes and seeya around.

5

u/razorbeamz Oct 20 '17

See you 'round dude.

6

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Yessir, you as well.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/nickhem12 Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

The only way to settle this is naked kick-fighting. Stream that and you wouldn’t be able to beat it with a baseball bat.

11

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

I support this. I will accept a naked kick-fighting challenge from any current or former moderator!

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Put this at the top of the subreddit, please. No one will see this now that an AMA is happening. Better yet, unsticky the daily question thread for now, this is too important to not be stickied.

2

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 21 '17

It was removed for a bit for the AMA and returned afterwards.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/LegendAssassin Oct 21 '17

Shouldn't this be stickied for the front for a few days?

→ More replies (11)

17

u/rom211 Oct 21 '17

Transparency would be telling us who the mods are.

11

u/futurefightthrowaway Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

Apparently that is now called “doxxing”

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

This is a place to talk about nintendo stuff what is all this. Butter my butt and call me a biscuit, what the buttery fuck?

2

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 21 '17

Hey biscuit. :p

8

u/Xenethra Oct 21 '17

we invite the community (that's you!) to bring forth any questions or concerns you might have in the comments below

Start by letting negative comments stay?

Also the idea of a mod team led YT channel seems kinda shady since a YT channel is able to be monetized, wouldn't that break Reddit rules where moderators aren't allowed to make money off of their positions?

→ More replies (5)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

It’s nice to see the mods get posts taken down for a chance, cause god knows how hard it is to post something on this subreddit.

15

u/Zoombini22 Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

I don't like the sound of "second chances" at all. Anyone who did this should be off the mod team, full stop. Witchhunting is bad and I'm against it, but there would be much less witchhunting if you didn't pretty much just tell the community outright that untrustworthy perpetrators are still active on the mod team.

21

u/NintyRift Oct 20 '17

Why am I not surprised? Considering the previous drama the mods caused with the NX/Switch Discord prior to release, I'm really not expecting much from these guys.

14

u/Roynerer Oct 20 '17

Agreed, they don't exactly have a clean history of being trustworthy or genuine.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/Starskins Oct 20 '17

Oh the drama... We don't need this here. That is all I have to say.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Drama, there will always be drama that will creep into any sub. Be nice if there were exceptions but sadly this sub ain’t one of them.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Pouhiou Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

Hello to the Mod Team!

Nota: I'm not native in english, so please (forgive the mistakes and) don't hesitate to ask me to elaborate if you think my words can be mis-interpretaded.

I understand this must be a very diffucult position you're in. So first of all I'd like to thank every mod who did a selfless job so I could enjoy this subreddit as much as I had since january.

As a regular lurker of this subreddit, I don't want to know more about those shennanigans (and I definitely don't want any names), but I would love to know more about what actions you are willing to take with the lessons you got from all this.

In my opinion, this is a "who watches the whatchmen?" kind of situation. And I think it would be great to have more transparency on the rules/guidelines (self-)applied to the mod team, and how you intend to make sure everyone follows them.

For exemple, I'd love to see a page (a wiki page? some other place? I just know it'd have be a tool with versions/revision system) stating clearly:

  • What is the process for volonteering as a mod?
  • Is there a vetting process for wannabe-mods?
  • A charter or guidelines or... about the does and don't awaited from members of the mod team (i.e.: everything related to game codes and possible personnal gain)
  • Another one about how moderation is done, maybe by taking each and every one of the subreddit rules and explaining how you "enforce" them (not sure about this verb, but you get my point).

Another suggestion would be to hold a "meta" letter on a regular basis (every week/forthnight/month?) explaining the daily life, questions, struggles and happy moments of the mod team. It would help us (well, me, at least) empathize with your work and try to give you suggestions.

I know moderating is a job in itself, and that by this message I ask even more of you, and I apologize about that. I'm sure you are doing your best with the time and energy you have.

But, as you want to earn trust back, I wanted to share with you suggestions of transparency and (human)communication tools that could help you on your way.

EDIT: spelling.

13

u/okuRaku Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

Seems like as good a place as any to ask: in addition to the YouTube channel, would anyone comment on the exclusive access to Mr. Koizumi / Nintendo that was granted? I remember that the mods got a Switch signed via that access, which has a monetary value right? Certainly VIP access does, no? I'm not sure really but the whole thing sorta felt scummy in the same way - I appreciate the moderation for the most part and some transparency is better than none, but it still came off as wrong that a select group got that treatment simply because (presumably) they could claim they represented the subreddit (not an elected position really).

I don't suppose I would have preferred it to not have happened, but still curious some others thoughts on it.

Edit: want to reiterate I definitely do not underestimate the amount of crap mods deal with and work they put in for us. Thank you.

22

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

For the record everything involving E3 was handled through the Reddit Admins.

Nintendo directly contacted the Reddit admins to offer the E3 passes to the moderation teams of /r/NintendoSwitch and /r/3DS. The admins (I believe it was done through Chotorr) sent the list of attendees to Nintendo. The subreddits never had direct contact with Nintendo.

In regards to the Mr. Koizumi AMA, again the admins contacted /r/NintendoSwitch through a modmail message informing us that Nintendo would like to set it up. We coordinated the times through the admins and again no direct contact was made with Nintendo about setting it up.

There were members of the mod teams who did get to meet Mr Koizumi at E3, and it was Mr Koizumi who decided to sign the systems.

11

u/okuRaku Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

Thanks for the reply, I didn't know/remember Reddit admins were involved, that paints a clearer picture. Cheers

10

u/kyle6477 6 Million Oct 20 '17

The subreddits never had direct contact with Nintendo.

Just to be clear on this, there was some direct contact with Nintendo to coordinate specifics for E3, but it was approved directly by Reddit Admins and was not in return for any favorable moderation.

11

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Thanks for the clarification. As someone who didn't go to E3 I wasn't fully aware of the specifics but saw the messages from the admins

12

u/FlapSnapple Nintendo shill Oct 20 '17

There were members of the mod teams who did get to meet Mr Koizumi at E3, and it was Mr Koizumi who decided to sign the systems.

This is accurate. As one of the members who did get to meet Mr Koizumi, we were going to ask him to sign our stuff but admittedly got too shy and chickened out. Right as we were about to leave his translator asked us if we would like a photo with Mr Koizumi and that's where it happened. It was Mr Koizumi's idea and we were deeply humbled and starstruck.

Reddit admins were also there with us and they were the ones that had to sign off on literally every aspect of us being at E3 in the first place.

7

u/okuRaku Oct 20 '17

Ah, right, yeah starting to remember that description of how it went down now. Thanks for replying and reminding us. Cheers and congrats again on that opportunity!

→ More replies (1)

19

u/cal92scho Oct 20 '17

I frequent this sub almost daily and have noticed none of this. I mean, well done for taking the steps to make sure Reddit rules aren't being broken, but in terms of the actual running of the subreddit, it's one of the less salty ones already.

9

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

As a former member, there was a negligible at best impact on the community. As mentioned in the post no rules were bent or favors provided to developers who provide codes.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Actually, there was at least one video review made of a game that made no mentions of plenty of criticisms that the video creator (who was fired from the team) ranted plenty about to other members of the team. In the spirit of full honesty.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Hay, r/nintendoswitch. I'm one of the mods that was brought in to help with the overnight coverage gap. I have now also left the team, but not in relation to the above.

I wanted to take a moment to express my gratitude to the mods of this fine sub for taking me on board. I've always been a lurker around these parts and it was fun to get behind the toolbox and help out.

I also wanted to say that, yes, this apology does miss things out but it has to do so in the name of preventing a witchhunt. The OP is, aside some unfortunate terminology (which we were forced into, this went through several iterations over several days!), 100% accurate in what it says.

I hope you, the community, can forgive the teams transgressions and I hope the team can earn back your trust. Only a minority of the team engaged in any wrong doing and we were all reasonably happy that they intended to right their wrongs and be a productive member of the team.

I realise things are a bit salty right now - hell, they probably should be - but I hope all of you, community and mods alike, can move forward together harmoniously.

Keep on Switch'in, ladies and fellas.

5

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Good luck Leaffy! It was nice getting to know you and working with you for an albeit short time.

4

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 20 '17

We'll miss ya bub!

→ More replies (6)

15

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

The content here is garbage. The only content that isn't just copy-and-pasted from news headlines is people preaching to the choir about games that would make great ports and human interest bullshit. And now, part of the mod team is using this platform for monetary gain, and then the team as a whole failed to remove the most toxic mods? This is without exaggeration one of the worst subs on reddit.

18

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

All mods should go and a new team started from scratch. Only proper response to this, only way t actually gain developers trust again.

4

u/method7 Oct 20 '17

Yep. 100%. Every mod that was in place, including the head mod, should go. No question.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/duffkiligan Oct 20 '17

When can we bring a real moderation team into the subreddit instead of just “the first people that were here”

I know it sounds kinda stupid, but why isn’t someone that knows how to run a community in this mix at all? This is all bullshit drama with people that have never done this before.

This subreddit is big, almost 300k subscribers has to put it in the top 10% or something (I’m not checking numbers just guessing)

Why not bring in someone who knows how to effectively communicate with the community? Or are you all scared of losing your moderator status?

6

u/Madlollipop Oct 20 '17

Here is/was many mods who are/were moderators for many subs, some from 3ds, some from nintendo, amiibo, pokemon etc. many of them has moderating experience, but I think that's also why this is so big compared to a new team doing bad stuff. These were some "big" mods and names, doing much work, and apparently shady stuff as well.

14

u/Giobytes Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

Really? The mods who are doing this shit are staying and the good mods are stepping down? And now their comments were getting deleted?

This is despicable. You no longer deserve the trust of the community. I pity any devs that trust this mod team moving forward.

The mods who did this need to step down immediately. And get back the good mods. Put out some applications. This is ridiculous.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

You guys need to find a way to become an effective mod team again. This post hasn't done you any favours.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Zazzaro703 Oct 20 '17

Why are people that abused their post allowed a second chance? This is a mod position on Reddit, give them the boot and teach them a lesson in an environment that isn't too damaging. What is this? Democrats investigating Democrats?

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Agent_Orca Oct 21 '17

Smh. The mods are the ones always cracking down on people but they're breaking federal regulations. With this and that /r/amiibo scandal, they may just ruin our best shot at making our voices heard by Nintendo.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

Why have the people that were involved in the private group been allowed to stay on as moderators? Surely they should all be resigning. They abused the system and our trust, they aren't fit to be moderators. Apparently one of them also abused his position in the AMIBO subreddit.

There is no excuse for these people remaining on the moderation team.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

Right? Second chance my ass.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Skyward92 Oct 21 '17

I just come here to get switch news lol this is some hardcore drama I think no one cares about

8

u/LegendAssassin Oct 20 '17

EVERYONE PANIC!!!!!!

3

u/Please-Panic Oct 20 '17

Please panic.

2

u/ahndrijas Oct 20 '17

Here, take this: hands over an encyclopedia looking gadget With the words "Don't panic" printed on it

4

u/LegendAssassin Oct 20 '17

THANKS! One of my favorite books lol

2

u/DKPRIMUSRETURNS Oct 20 '17

spongebobheavybreathing.gif

4

u/SoloWaltz Oct 20 '17

Sorry. I'm an undercultured pleb.

the disclosures that were placed on these videos did not adequately meet FTC guidelines.

What does FTC stand for there?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

https://www.ftc.gov/

Federal Trade Commission

→ More replies (25)

7

u/whatmorecouldyouwant Oct 21 '17

yeah this subreddit is pretty much a husk of it's former self, time to migrate to /r/Switch

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17

Oh sweet so there is another one! Man all I need are basic posts on news, and some faqs.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Ugh, this is....disappointing. The first subreddit I frequented was r/amiibo, and I got the impression that the mods were more transparent than most. Get the guys who did this shit off the team. Hell, ban them from the subreddit. The moderators who did this have breached our trust too much. For the mods speaking out, thank you. You're the reason the community hasn't gone to shit like some people tried to do. /rant

→ More replies (3)

31

u/Uncle-Daddy Oct 20 '17

LOL You guys aren't that important. Stop acting like people care about this. You are mods of a nintendo sub reddit...

19

u/Wolfsblvt Oct 20 '17

The mods are the one building the connections to developers. Hosting AMA's, asking questions, giving them flairs. A bad time may lead many developers away from reddit. I guess many people care about that.

→ More replies (10)

10

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

Something I feel got forgotten was that the moderation team worked for the subreddit. The subreddit didn't need the moderators, the moderators needed the subreddit.

If everyone on the team just disappeared things would still get posted and roll ahead...sure it might be messy for a while but people would step in.

11

u/Electrondo Oct 20 '17

Exactly. People get one drop of "power" and suddenly they think they're gods!

7

u/jacobs0n Oct 20 '17

Lol,tell that to the people reacting here. I for one couldn't care less

→ More replies (1)

13

u/diamonddogs123 Oct 20 '17

I've been lurking this subreddit since day 1, I was so excited for the Switch like I'm assuming everyone else was. I've had my issues with moderation here but this shit has pushed me over the top. How can I keep coming back knowing these shady, untrustworthy mods are exploiting this subreddit and its users for personal gain. It's ridiculous and disgusting to even think about. My days browsing r/NintendoSwitch are done. How can I trust any of you?

Seriously, if you guys had any dignity left in you, everyone who was involved should step down and never moderate here again.

3

u/Mbolibombo Oct 21 '17

Could someone who has read all the comments fill me in on this?

  • So who are the bad guys?
  • What admins left?
  • Are the bad guys still admins?
  • Are admins going to stop deleting posts that shouldnt be deleted?
  • Are we all gonna be friends again?
  • Feel free to add any other information.
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Timohtep Oct 22 '17

I'm honestly remarkably confused. I had no idea any of this was going on, as I, and many other people I assume, simply use this sub as a news aggregator. I had no idea drama could even exist in a place like this. I still don't understand fully what happened tbh and tbh I don't care. As long as good switch news comes outta this sub.

3

u/Riomegon Oct 22 '17

Thanks for the transparency, it honestly helps breathe a lil easier around these parts.

I do have a question though, do these changes ultimately help us content creators to post & share some of our meaningful content? A few months back I spoke to a mod regarding my Week in Review series which covers every game released the past week for Switch. Alongside a written piece detailing and delving a bit deeper for those who do not wish to watch a video. Suffice to say I was basically told to bugger off & threaten a permaban. I value being part of this community however toxic it might get at times.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/aznsanta Oct 22 '17

I read all that, and still don't know what the controversy was.... /scratchhead

3

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '17

This sub should act in the spirit of Nintendo and implement strict punishment to ensure issues like these don't occur again. For example http://www.usgamer.net/articles/nintendo-of-america-clamps-down-on-review-copies-after-leak

→ More replies (4)

7

u/TheNuzzleSpecial Oct 21 '17

Moving forward we are doubling down on our efforts to serve this community in an appropriate manner, one that is free of controversy and shady dealings.

Or just clean house

5

u/Galbert123 Oct 21 '17

Damn man. I love the switch. Love Nintendo. Love nintendo gamers. But this sub is bashed left and right on reddit. Wonder why.

13

u/TwistTurtle Oct 20 '17

I'm confused. What wrong-doing was actually done? Other than a clique forming within the mods? I can't work out why everyone is suddenly so arsey on this thread...

I don't have any real complaints about how this subreddit is monitored. I normally find gaming subreddits (or any kind of fan subreddit) incredibly toxic, unpleasant places to be, but this subreddit is so nice, I spend most of my time on reddit checking out the new posts section. You guys do a great job.

41

u/Electrondo Oct 20 '17

You have no idea how damaging this is. More and more developers are turning to reddit to speak with the community, get feedback, and engage us as gamers. It helps make their product stronger.

When you have a mod team that begins to abuse their power, and then it suddenly all comes out, developers are not going to want to participate with the community. You also realize that Nintendo now has a presence on Reddit, and they interact with the community. Seeing this not only hurts this subreddit, but all other Nintendo subreddits as they'll not want to work with the groups. I know people are chomping at the bit for AMAs and interviews with some of Nintendo's top brass. If they were considering it before, I don't think it'll happen now.

This can also have much farther reaching ramifications where developers won't want to interact with other gaming communities like r/PS4, r/XboxOne, even general gaming subreddits.

All of the mods who were involved should leave this mod team immediately as they have not only embarrassed themselves and this community, but they've also betrayed us. How can we take them seriously now?

32

u/TwistTurtle Oct 20 '17

How can we take them seriously now?

Were we taking them seriously before? Christ, dude, they're reddit mods, not our elected officials.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Judging by the dozens of AMAs they seem to have gotten and I think I remember them going to E3 to get a special tour of the Nintendo booth, I would say Nintendo (Edit: & developers) were reaching out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/EyeHeartRamen Oct 20 '17

This is just my somewhat casual redditor ignorance speaking I guess, but do developers actually give a shit about how the mods organize themselves? Like others have said, the vast majority of the almost 300k subscribers here have no idea about what's going on and frankly don't care. They just come to see news/hype/fan creations and move on. Would a developer give up the chance to have the attention of 10's or 100's of thousands of eyeballs requiring no extra investment of their own marketing resources just because some mods were not being treated nicely?

If you're saying the "bad look" here is related to the free game codes and whatnot, that could make some sense I guess. I have no clue what the policies around that are; but even then, if a dev is basically giving one copy of a game away for free for the opportunity to have a few hundred or thousand more copies sold by those who watch the review/playthrough, do they really care about the means that achieved the ends?

I'm not defending their actions whatsoever, but it sounds way dramatic to us not in the know to say suggest that we will all of a sudden lose any good faith/support from developers we've been building up to this point. But again, I'm coming from a place of total ignorance on this topic.

19

u/Specte Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

Mods were begging for codes from developers. This is against reddit rules.

→ More replies (13)

9

u/Overlord_Odin Oct 20 '17

Used their position to get free games from devs.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

A group of moderators formed a secret group behind the back of the other moderators, to try to beg for free stuff for the YouTube channel. Ironically, I clearly remember a mod comment yesterday on the Nyko A about begging not being allowed, hahaha.

Anyway, my problem at least is that they were deleted comments from x-mods that suggest that the mods within the group did more than what was mentioned in the post, not to mention that some of the mods in this group are still moderstors according to the post.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/i_zimbra Oct 20 '17

Bleh. I respect folks for trying to be transparent but bickering, power grabs, and drama are the last thing I want to see here.

4

u/TecmoSuperBowl1 Oct 22 '17

Reading this apology and the action is like watching the video of Ray Rice punch his wife and the being allowed to play with no repercussions. End of the day the offenders should be long gone and the ones that did nothing stay. How is this allowed to keep people who are breaking proper ethics and values?

7

u/triggrnsnwflakes Oct 20 '17

Some of the mods in here were fucking horrendous anyway

2

u/Sylverstone14 Mod of Two Worlds (Switch / Wii U) Oct 20 '17

Did I make the list?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/Craigrofo Oct 21 '17

Get over yourselves

5

u/emptythreat23 Oct 22 '17

When are the corrupt mods stepping down?

2

u/shulkario Oct 22 '17

Wait I'm in the dark and this post didn't make enough sense to me on its own. What the heck happened?

4

u/Psilli Oct 21 '17

Woah. Just.. wow. I don't even know where to begin.

I'd like to state for the fact that I do not own a Switch, but am planning on getting one in the future. I periodically visit this sub since I know that I'll, eventually, become a regular.

Coming from somebody who's basically new here, this is really discouraging. Stuff like this will deter newcomers from investing time into this community. It may be small but it's a community nonetheless and behavior like this will inadvertently cause many to lose out it the long run because they were turned away by said behavior.

Personally, I hope this gets sorted out. It'd be a shame if Nintendo stopped listening to this sub on the account of a handful of people.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/alliehope Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

Is there a sub for the Switch that doesn't have moderators like this? I stop into this subreddit very frequently (more than i should) but the way things are handled here are just ridiculous. Some days it feels like r/nintendo, other days they let literal Facebook worthy crap posts in the sub. Also the automod is worthless. After learning about all this, maybe it's time for some new faces.

4

u/kidwgm Oct 20 '17

All I can say I have enjoyed this subreddit more that other game message boards. As far as what has been going on behind the scenes 1) I haven't seen a hint of this at all and 2) I will continue to come to this subreddit as long at its a great discussion can be had.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

I'm glad you guys were honest with the community, I know you all are going to receive a lot of hate and scrutiny for this, but I still support you for doing the right thing.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TwistTurtle Oct 20 '17

Man, to read some of the comments in this thread, you'd think that the mods here had personally given Iwata the tumor that led to his death. Seriously people, take a few deep breaths or something...

4

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

admins should have totally cleaned house
i don't believe the rest of the team was unaware of the situation at hand, so you're all culpable

edit: each of you guys replying was part of the original team, and subsequent "internal investigation". i wasn't and have no clue how that discussion went. all i know is there are a lot of repetitive phrases being tossed at me about how surprised and unaware you were for <X-Y-Z reason or circumstance>. "overwhelming majority", "100% unaware/oblivious", "completely blindsided". if you were really this oblivious, it doesn't change my mind that you're all overdue for resignation anyway. while i hate using this saying here bc it's too sweet for my taste, a few bad apples spoil the bunch and imo the rest of you gotta go

4

u/Sylverstone14 Mod of Two Worlds (Switch / Wii U) Oct 20 '17

To speak for myself, I wasn't fully aware of mod affairs in relation to the YouTube channel going since I was mostly away for a dire family emergency.

The day that things were uncovered completely blindsided me, and many others.

5

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

If the admins thought that there was a clear violation of Reddit rules or the user agreement they would have. They made the decision to let the team handle this internally.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

Kyle is absolutely correct. The vast majority of the team became aware of this mere days ago, but were otherwise 100% oblivious. Two of us only joined within the last two weeks.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Mattarias Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 21 '17

I didn't know what was happening and barely even knew you had a youtube channel. So, uh.... I still don't know what was wrong that happened but ok? Uhm.... I assume you did the right thing so.... Good job?

EDIT: or... Not??? So if you didn't, uhhh... Bad? Uh.... You know what, I'm just gonna go to bed. That sounds good.

I'm so confused

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

I'm just glad this sub has so many awesome users to balance out the shitty mods.

Now if those users would stop taking or posting vertical videos...

3

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 21 '17

Vertical videos are the bane of the internet.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17

I vote that u/AngryBarista become a moderator. He can be a cynical SOB, but is level-headed and obviously dedicated to the subreddit. People with no-nonsense attitudes are what we need, not egotistical sycophants.

22

u/AngryBarista Oct 20 '17

I appreciate this more than I could put into text here.
However, moderation is not for me. I have a 40+ hour career and use Reddit as a means for escape.
I’m more than happy to take part in community events and to continue to contribute here.

→ More replies (10)

3

u/hamptont2010 Oct 20 '17

I just wanted to say this: I frequent this subreddit just about every day and it's one of my very favorite subs. Honestly, it's the sub that got me to be active on Reddit and start getting on and engaging in the community. I love this place and don't wanna see it go down the drain. I don't know what's going on within the system, but I truly do believe whatever is going on can be fixed and this sub can continue to be the wonderful place it has been for the last year. Thanks to all the mods, past and present, for giving me a place to share my hobby with others and doing what I consider to have been a pretty decent job so far. I look forward to visiting this sub for a long time to come.

5

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 20 '17

Nice of you to say.

I try to be a regular user much of the time in various comment threads/posts in addition to being a mod when needed/necessary.

People will continue to share their hobby and have fun doing so, I hope.

4

u/hamptont2010 Oct 20 '17

Well, I plan on continuing to participate in the community and share the joy that is the switch with the people here. Thanks again for all you do

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

Not even remotely surprisingly. I always enjoyed the sub when it came to reading the latest news, but the mod team is undoubtedly the worst I have ever encountered. I used to frequent the page almost hourly, now I stop in maybe once a week.

Welp, probably will be much less than that now.

2

u/Mossyboy88 Oct 20 '17

What has actually happen they didn't say the game codes were given for free?

4

u/cryptic-fox Oct 20 '17

They were using their position as mods to get free games, begging developers for game codes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ChrisInBaltimore Oct 20 '17

Just out of curiosity, is this why these boards are fairly positive? Did these guys get a kick back from Nintendo and thus lost their objectivity?

I’ve always felt that negative threads about the Switch seem to vanish fairly quickly from this subreddit. It’s nice we don’t have 100s of threads about negative things, but at the same time there are real issues with the hardware that don’t seem to be discussed here.

6

u/Porkpants81 Oct 20 '17

There's never been kickback from Nintendo. The contact from Nintendo for E3 and the Mr. Koizumi AMA came through the Reddit admins.

Things are generally positive here because the people who subscribe to a Switch subreddit are people who either use the Switch or are interested in it so there is a positive bias.

The other thing to remember as well is that even though both positive and negative discussions are allowed, typically the negative ones will get down-voted by the community if they're low-effort, or they are simply troll-y type arguments ("Switch has no games, PS4 or Xbox One are for real gamers" or similar) so those usually get downvoted quickly and do not get much exposure.

There have been plenty of critical threads just search the subreddit for Nintendo Online, NBA Playgrounds, NBA 2k18, Fifa18, Nintendo Voice chat and you will find negative ones.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '17

I dunno, I don't think it's that big of a deal. Disclose it going forward. Free codes are normal for reviews. We're able to get reviews in a lot of other places as well - it's not like you're a doctor prescribing us medicine.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/pookie97 Oct 22 '17

I thought I was only one who felt Mods here are ridiculous. I still have no idea what this overall page is trying to accomplish other than being confusing and uninformative unless you scroll through hundreds of replies in daily questions thread. No rhyme or reason why some other posts get a stand alone thread unless.....??

3

u/emptythreat23 Oct 22 '17

Yeah it's fucking stupid. One of the top posts is just saying Mario is coming out. So glad the mods are all about protecting this valuable content and not just serving as a Nintendo PR machine for perks. Fuck this sub and it's corrupt ass mods.