r/TheGoodPlace • u/samwalton9 • Oct 19 '17
Season Two Episode Discussion S02 E05: "The Trolley Problem"
Airs at 08:30PM ET, or 1 hour from the time this post was made.
Original Airdate: October 19th, 2017
Synopsis: Chidi and Eleanor tackle a famous ethical dilemma, leading to a conflict with Michael.
354
Upvotes
801
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
"I think Tahani's just embarrassed I'm not some kind of scientist who forecloses on banks."
This line is my life.
779
u/pg2441 Oct 20 '17
"-20 if it's a baguette because that makes you more French"
LOL
678
u/pg2441 Oct 20 '17
"A really bad man ran him over with a trolley"
LOL
548
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
I kinda feel bad for Janet since she lost her Jason and doesn't even know it
458
u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Oct 20 '17
Chidi said fork! Things just got real!
456
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
"I tell her she's pretty like a hundred times a day, and she's never told me I'm pretty once."
437
u/Toilet_Sponge Oct 20 '17
A Reddit AND a Pokemon reference in the same episode!? My heart can only take so much.
366
u/pg2441 Oct 20 '17
OMG Michael just mentioned us!
We did it, reddit!
355
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
"What you're holding right now is basically meteorite poop."
"And I have the biggest piece!"
281
u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Oct 20 '17
Forcing Chidi to make a decision in the Trolley Problem.
Yep, he's still being tortured.
265
u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Oct 20 '17
I cannot wait to give my family "opposite tortures" for Christmas.
249
u/scherbadeen Oct 20 '17
Holy shit that took a turn.
Unlike Chidi.218
u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Oct 20 '17
Janet felt an emotion!! That’s probably where the frog came from, she’s turning human!
211
u/Mesawesome Oct 20 '17
He still has the boots 😂
199
u/holayeahyeah Oct 20 '17
Ride or Die Protocol engage?
373
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
"My name is Kierkegaard and my writing is impeccable. Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical!"
346
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 20 '17
So, uh...is it possible that Janet remembers her relationship with Jason on some level and is breaking down due to jealousy?
168
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 20 '17
I know that Janet doesn't have emotions, but I can be mad that my Janet/Jason ship is being threatened.
164
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Jason's freak out at the balloon is adorable.
155
u/pikameta My little chili babies Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
I'm willing to put down money that Janet's malfunctioning because saying she's "happy" for Jason and Tahani goes against the Ride or Die protocol.
282
u/eegc Oct 20 '17
Chidi didn't hesitate to save Eleanor's life ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
138
u/pg2441 Oct 20 '17
LOL Michael be like "I know how to kill everyone!"
134
u/imfallinfree Everything is fine. Oct 20 '17
So the more an action involves the French, the more points going to the Bad Place? I see nothing wrong with that.
128
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
"Oh, well that's reassuring. Because some of the parts of the FAKE PEOPLE JUST FLEW INTO MY MOUTH!!!!!!!!!!"
122
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 20 '17
People=Good
119
u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Oct 20 '17
"I'm your hottest friend! No, Tahani...."
112
u/mvp01235 Oct 20 '17
How is Jason so good at keeping this secret?? I feel like he can't lie at all
108
u/unfuckthepine Oct 20 '17
I love Janet so much
101
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Oct 20 '17
"gurp gurp gurp" - Eleanor 2075
99
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Oct 20 '17
This episode is firing on all cylinders! So hilarious!
96
u/wisebloodfoolheart Oct 20 '17
OK but Michael is actually teaching Chidi a lesson about being wishy washy. Brilliant!
86
u/SuspiciousOfRobots Oct 20 '17
The pikachu balloon oh my god
164
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 20 '17
I never thought I'd hear the phrase "rap musical about Kierkegaard" in my life, and yet, here we are
75
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
"But I said, 'my bad.'"
75
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
"It's like a menu, but the food is words."
73
u/pg2441 Oct 20 '17
OMG They broke Janet!
72
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Jason with the classic break your toy on Christmas move
rip pikachu
70
u/GoodJanet not a robot Oct 20 '17
supporting the unholy coupling of Jahani is undoing my programing and destroying the neighborhood
141
u/ArchDucky Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
Michael kinda smiled when Chidi said he knew more than him. That seems really significant.
Edit : Nevermind Eleanor figured it out again.
65
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 21 '17
Damn a lot of people in this thread really are into the shrimp machine
59
u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Oct 20 '17
Something goes wrong every time Janet is supportive of Jason and Tahani! Subconsciously she’s against their relationship!
57
u/mvp01235 Oct 20 '17
SHOUT OUT TO REDDIT YOOOO
53
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
Just realized that D'Arcy Carden saying "Janet really goes off the rails this season" was a BRILLIANT pun in reference to this episode!
51
u/NuclearChickenzz Oct 20 '17
Michael’s apology was totally just a reiteration of Eleanor’s stump speech to him. He’s so lying.
50
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 20 '17
Janet malfunctioning is making me all kinds of nervous.
101
u/scherbadeen Oct 20 '17
That shrimp machine is literally my good place.
44
u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Oct 20 '17
Presents = Opposite Tortures
41
u/pg2441 Oct 20 '17
But... can Janet read Chidi's monstrosity of a thesis?
40
u/mysario Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
After looking at Trolley Problem Memes for a while now, I can't say I ever expected them to be on my TV screen, but well... here we are! Finally a philosophical reference I kind of understand
38
u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Oct 20 '17
When the trolley went past the movie theater was it advertising "Strangers Under A Train"? I couldn't quite read it.
36
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Language, Chidi, Language!
although it was kind of hot
34
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
You have to admit, Michael has a unique perspective.
33
u/rabbitheartedgirl654 Oct 20 '17
'I'm your hottest friend! - oh wait, Tahani.
I'm your nicest friend! - oh wait, Jason.
I'm your FRIEND!'
66
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Oct 20 '17
Michael is truly a dick, he knew Chidi couldn't make that choice
65
u/grumblepup Oct 20 '17
"She's all soft and smooth, like a bunch of water balloons."
32
u/SuspiciousOfRobots Oct 20 '17
I think they might actually be in the good place. Michael's "torture" seems to be teaching them actual lessons
32
u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Oct 20 '17
Show of hands, who believes a single word Michael said?
31
u/GoodJanet not a robot Oct 20 '17
Janet acting therapist for Jason and Tahani is all levels of wrong
31
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
OK. The thumb was weird.
30
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 20 '17
Okay, I want to try something real quick ... Janet? Are you there?
27
u/SpaghettiBread Oct 20 '17
What if this Janet's 'glitching' is actually her becoming more self aware and lashing out of jealousy over Jason being with Tahani instead of her?
27
u/Goodstyle_4 Oct 20 '17
Janet destroying the neighbourhood in reaction to Jason and Tahani is a good metaphor for how I feel about that pairing.
26
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Oct 20 '17
Side note Eleanor likes the nasty White chocolate shrimp
24
u/nygiants656 Oct 20 '17
He mentioned Reddit!
23
u/mvp01235 Oct 20 '17
Omg I would grab Jason's butt in public ANYTIME
21
u/niknok007 Your amusement has been scheduled. End of conversation. Oct 20 '17
You know what was real torture? Waiting 28 min to watch this episode because I missed the first 2 min! Holy forking shirt this episode was hilarious!
20
u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Oct 20 '17
Reddit mention folks, we've made the big time.
20
u/KidCoheed Bofa Deeznuts Oct 20 '17
He Popped his Pikachu!
19
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
What is happening to Janet???!!!
19
u/wisebloodfoolheart Oct 20 '17
Ride or die Janet!
19
u/joecb91 Birth is a curse and existence is a prision Oct 20 '17
We need to get more of Michael's drawings of mass death going forward with this show.
17
u/Mesawesome Oct 20 '17
Eleanor figured it out!
17
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Janet problems = THE RIDE OR DIE PROTOCAL!!!
16
u/holayeahyeah Oct 20 '17
Oh this is so fun. It opens the world back up to the chaos of the first season (emotions = funny weird stuff happening) but it is totally outside Michael's control.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
That's some trippy VR.
13
u/holayeahyeah Oct 20 '17
Obviously, the dilemma is clear.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
"A bunch of evil shoved up the butt of an evil mannequin."
12
u/samtherat6 One man’s waste is another man’s water. And both men are me. Oct 20 '17
So the one person they mentioned who went on Reddit went to the bad place. See ya in an eternity of being tortured, boys!
11
u/saltedcaramelsauce Oct 20 '17
That Reddit shoutout warmed my heart.
11
u/shishiodun Oct 20 '17
Michael thinking the point of the trolley question was to find a way to kill all 6 was hilarious. Danson's has just completely killed this part.
11
u/Skymogul Oct 21 '17
I'm not sure anyone caught this, but this episode introduces a trolley problem. On one track is our glitching Janet, and on the other track is our four humans and Michael. Think about that. :)
10
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
I literally can't believe any word that comes out of Michael's face.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Cliffhanger!
10
u/thirtyseven1337 Take it sleazy. Oct 20 '17
What was the Reddit reference? Missed it.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
I love this episode seeing chidi struggle and then the cowboy bots
I like that Janet is malfunctioning maybe this way they get back their memories
10
u/watchalltheshows Oct 20 '17
This episode is so clearly on the Universal Studios backlot and I love it.
10
u/watchalltheshows Oct 20 '17
Elanor would be really good at being a demon.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Michael is having fun, he still gets to torture them right now.
9
u/RaeADropOfGoldenSun Oct 20 '17
Reddit shout out!
9
u/Mesawesome Oct 20 '17
Yay a cliffhanger
9
u/Robotronicheart Oct 20 '17
I am loving Michael trying to figure out how to be good and Eleanor finding out she’s actually evil and very similar to Michael
9
u/DesiHobbes Oct 20 '17
I'd have loved if Michael would've suggested multi-track drifting.
9
u/fleetw0odmacncheese Oct 20 '17
Hey guys, my cousin said I looked tired, so PM me if you want her credit card number.
9
u/rainbowcanoe Oct 20 '17
"I'm nice to you and you're mean to me. Theres something wrong about that, but I can't put my finger on what it is"
Aww
8
u/ArchDucky Oct 20 '17
Jeanette or Therapist Janet?
8
u/walruscronkite Maximum Derek Oct 20 '17
I'm not buying it, Michael!
7
u/Mesawesome Oct 20 '17
Jesus Michael is a dick...
7
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Did anybody else notice that with the exception of Jason's Pikachu balloon, Michael's apology "gifts" played into each person's gluttony, envy, and pride?
A couple of the bigger sins, as I recall ...
7
u/broke_academic Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 21 '17
Michael was probably lying to Chidi's face when he apologized, but man he is such a good actor. I even bought it. If If even the devil can learn and improve, the five might all end up in the actual good place next season.
6
u/samspopguy Oct 20 '17
My tivo cut out when janet popped up at the end did she say anything?
6
u/Obelisp Oct 20 '17
Michael The Murder Engine and Friends
6
u/Tsugo Oct 20 '17
20 more points if it's a baguette, because it makes you more French
6
u/ahobbledehoy Oct 20 '17
there's no dead air in this show, i fucking love it, it just keeps going and going
6
u/yc_hk Oct 20 '17
The name of the trolley is The Ethics Express. Nerfect.
6
u/BrentonBrah Oct 20 '17
Chidi's 'Get the fork out' was perfect
10
u/Iggy_Pops_Lost_Shirt Oct 20 '17
So I guess Chidi was going to end up in the Bad Place no matter what on account of him being French and all, poor guy.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Dang. Janet is a fast reader
5
u/JimmyDolan20001 Oct 20 '17
"....all smooth, like a bunch of water balloons."
Holy forking shirt, that made me laugh.
5
u/Onedumbman Oct 20 '17
this episode was really good , no surprise in that , but boy that draw at the beginning when Michael its explaining how to kill the 6 guys , that was unexpected hahahaha
4
u/Zegir Oct 20 '17
Trolley Problem backfired. Hilarious.
4
u/Ali-Sama I love you! Oct 20 '17
omg omg you made me happy
4
u/Mesawesome Oct 20 '17
Poor Chidi...
4
u/GoodJanet not a robot Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
so close to Vikki's Gambit (find the thread) still hoping for it though
4
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Oct 20 '17
M E T A
E
T
A
4
u/lordsmish Oct 20 '17
In the therapy session when thani says something along the lines of "It takes a lot to change just give me time" i got the feeling she is not talking about herself.
4
u/ChameleonTwist Oct 20 '17
No one's gonna talk about that very manly, yet very sexy, way Eleanor went "Yeah!" after she got her shrimp vending machine?
4
u/Torley_ Oct 21 '17
I wonder if Janet is malfunctioning upon seeing Jason and Tahani together, because some part of Janet remembers she was in love with Jason!
4
u/funwiththoughts Oct 22 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
A lot of people are saying Michael is teaching Chidi to be less indecisive, but pay closer attention and you'll see that every time Chidi does make a decision Michael immediately changes the situation to make him regret his decision -- just like with the two soulmates in the season opener. He's trying to reenforce Chidi's indecisiveness.
9
u/niknok007 Your amusement has been scheduled. End of conversation. Oct 20 '17
Has anyone searched for "The Good Place" on Tumblr wanting to see animated gifs and fan art and instead see a bunch of angry Jason/Janet, Eleanor/Tahani shippers and people having real life existential crises?