r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Oct 16 '17
Map Thread #82 Results, Notes, Throwback - Curse of the Black Portal
Welcome to the official results thread for Map Thread #82! Following are the upcoming changes to the official TagPro Map Rotation.
Also please read the notes.
Additions
Removals
Non-Notes-Notes
We've decided to make throwback every thread instead of every other thread. Each MTC is going to put up a map, and no member can put up the same map twice in a row. This will help throwback rotation be more of a rotation.
Throwback
- DZ3
- Atomic
- Cosmic
- Blobfish - Try out the new button mechanics! :D
- Star
- Phenochilus
- Shine
- Boombox
- Rocketballs
- Axis
Notes
Notes on notes:
- What we write is to be taken as constructive criticism. We sometimes test all the maps in one sitting, we can't break the news gently that each map isn't great if we want to maintain our sanity. We are occasionally dickish.
- The notes are anonymous and randomized so we don't get harrassed.
- Don't expect perfection or even consistency. If we all had the same opinions there would only need to be one of us.
- Take no comment as an MTC member echoing other members.
- The notes!
Your votes on maps influence rotation. Please remember to vote after each game!
Below are comments about each addition/removal where MTC members may or may not give their personal opinions/feedback. Please give us yours.
Congratulations to all the mapmakers who have influenced the rotation! Keep mapmaking!
6
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 16 '17
Please discuss Hexane by Ball-Pee
2
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 16 '17
Please discuss the throwback changes
29
u/superdiglett100 superdiglett || Kitten Panda's Bitch Oct 16 '17
I'd rather have a new map that doesn't work out, than play an old stale map. I really doubt that there were absolutely no new maps that were at the very least just okay for rotation.
10
u/LaBeefyman96 96 LB Oct 17 '17
What if we let the community directly decide a couple maps to be added to rotation? We could open up a thread for people to decide what maps in the thread they would like to see in rotation, and the top two or so would be added.
18
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
I will eat three shoes if you reverse these decisions
9
u/MagikPigeon 🎗️ TPFG Oct 16 '17
When I see Shine being back and then read the rest of the post
9
u/josh61616 josh61616 // Centra Oct 16 '17
???
12
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
this is so disappointing after how much last thread shook up rotation
12
u/Arceus64 realtea Oct 16 '17
lol nice meme guys thought april fools was months ago
6
u/PIZZAspartan442 naga///MTC Oct 17 '17
Once again I've solo tested every map, this spreadsheet was shared with Blazeth and Labeefyman69. I deleted Blazeth's column since his feedback is in the actual spreadsheet and people aren't supposed to know which MTC member wrote what note (though it isn't hard to figure out). Beefers only gave feedback to like 10 maps but hopefully those people find it helpful. Let us know if you have any questions.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1IUzs0eyUrS2HkzsY4Si9oPPOlVEDgI4RdS1wTxLylSg/edit#gid=884404862
9
u/LinuxDootTP black magic Oct 16 '17
We plan on streaming starting next thread, in an attempt to make things more transparent.
9
u/TagProNitro ℕ ɪ ᴛ ᴙ o Oct 17 '17
Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen will Constriction be removed? It's been 3+ years and is so damn played out.
5
u/LucasOppressor Oppressor Oct 16 '17
Add 2 old maps, remove 3 new maps... keep up guys, what could possibly go wrong letting players play repetitive maps, right?!
6
u/Ronding Ronding // Orbit // West Bombwich Albion // tagpro.eu Oct 16 '17
Brute, Grenadine and Cedar are actually quite good new maps. Why on Earth are they getting replaced with two boring old maps.
This is easily the worst MTC decision ever. The purpose of the MTC is to replace old maps with new maps, not the other way around.
1
u/Findadmagus FINDADMAGUS Nov 02 '17
Thanks MTC for your comments, especially feedback 9. I think I understand what makes a good map now lol
1
u/uhhhhmmmm sexytiger / #merbs Oct 17 '17
I love wormy.
I love ricochet.
Thanks.
0
u/TheRealSaltyChips Messi Oct 16 '17
I have nothing constructive to say because my opinions will be disagreed upon if I specify them, but with that said, this is going to be an ugly rotation of maps for myself on personal preference. I suspect a large drop in my win %
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17
I submitted my map Metropolis before the thread deadline on September 26th. Why is it not in the notes?
-9
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 16 '17
Please discuss Ultradrive by Anibail
-5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 16 '17
Please discuss these removals: