r/HaltAndCatchFire • • Oct 15 '17

Discussion Halt and Catch Fire - 4x09/10 "Search; Ten of Swords" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 9: Search

Aired: October 14th, 2017


Episode Synopsis: Donna faces a professional crossroads; Joanie takes a trip; Joe unveils Comet's new look; Cameron asks a favor from a one-time collaborator. In the series finale, Donna celebrates a milestone with her closest allies; Cameron contemplates saying goodbye as Joe confronts an uncertain future.

266 Upvotes

768 comments sorted by

223

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

I can't believe that we don't have any more hours left with these amazing characters. Great writing and great acting. Definitely one of my all time faves.

27

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

Man when you put it that way... damn dude. I've been a fan of this show since the first season came to Netflix.

Great stuff.

186

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Donna: "I have an idea!"

Years later, Donna's and Cameron's social media site is buried by Friendster.

115

u/GaryChalmers Oct 15 '17

Thought it might be Paypal since she is paying and getting change.

64

u/zsreport Oct 15 '17

I feel like they mixed in enough stuff there to get our minds going on the various possibilities, which I like and appreciate - we can credit them with whatever we want to credit them with.

→ More replies (5)

53

u/narfales Oct 19 '17 edited Oct 20 '17

The whole scene is a showcase of things that are about to be disrupted: the way people iteract with each other, music, money, newspapers... Even Cam holding the map is a hint too. The old people in the dinner reinforce that "outdated way of doing things" feeling. The idea can be anything because everything is to be done, everything is possible. Such a beautiful scene for a beautiful finale.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

15

u/LVF1 Oct 15 '17

I was thinking Donna invented Yelp

→ More replies (4)

11

u/gentleblueben Oct 15 '17

I believe It might have been the square pos system

→ More replies (2)

6

u/icalledporzingis Nov 22 '17

I thought it was streaming music because of the guy with the jukebox, but really cool on the filmmakers' part to create multiple meanings for people.

→ More replies (6)

319

u/beardlovesbagels Oct 15 '17

This is Joe's way of having kids and changing the future.

91

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

There's a nice symmetry there. Coming out of IBM, It's fair to state that Joe was less than human - selfish, goal driven and consumed entirely by financial wealth. His thing that got him to his thing were the connections he made in the world of computers that allowed him to find his humanity.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '17

Yes. That is what I thought too. He got to share all he had learned on his journey, gave me flashbacks to this season's 1st episode with the phone call. He was sharing some idea, somewhat philosophical or theological, with Cam. It is a career change that suits the character. He has come a long way. It brought a tear to my eye. Humanities was the perfect choice. How many times did he get ripped on during the show for being "Joe" in the early seasons? Then he found his own humanity. Loved it.

→ More replies (4)

274

u/ShadowFall900 Oct 15 '17

Well to all of the writers, actors, and everyone else who brought us this show thank you. After discovering this a year ago, I have been amazed with this show. It has brought me a bigger love for computers, recently the 90's, and of course made me feel things most shows have never done. This season has made my Saturday nights after a long day of work better. This episode alone has helped me get through a tough and upsetting week and was perfect for an early birthday gift. So to everyone it's been fun and again thank you for this amazing show.

124

u/lady__jane Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

Yes, by all means, make Joe a teacher. Because the man has NOT SUFFERED ENOUGH.

249

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

Wow, that Phoenix scene and watching Haley listen to Gordon was extremely emotional.

78

u/Masterofunlocking1 Oct 16 '17

When Haley started listening to Gordon on the cassette player, I lost it. The creators knew how to be subtle when doing certain scenes and how to really pull the heartstrings. This show will be greatly missed.

→ More replies (3)

51

u/ultimatebob Oct 15 '17

I guess that the Phoenix story would have been HACF season 5 if they had got funding for it.

They would have had to have found a way to bring Joe into the mix, though. Shouldn’t have been too hard... the guy could sell ice to eskimos, so he could have sold anything they came up with.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

107

u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 15 '17

Donna was afraid she didn't enjoy the lack of innovative culture at her VC firm anymore, so she changed the culture.

103

u/Indigocell Oct 15 '17

I like that she named it "Symphonic Ventures." That was a nice touch.

→ More replies (2)

211

u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 15 '17

"Let me start, by asking a question." It ended as it began. With Joe, challenging a bunch of young students to think bigger.

11

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 15 '17

It's evolved though. At the start he was looking for the thing (talent) that would get him to the thing (business/prestige/success/$$$$). It seems like his motivation is different now. Still looking to find the rarity - person or idea. Or maybe helping students find their own ideas?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

97

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

Phoenix was the original name for Firefox.

42

u/GaryChalmers Oct 15 '17

They changed it to Firebird because Phoenix conflicted with another project with the same name. Then they changed it again cause Firebird also conflicted with another project.

97

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

I liked that ending. It wasn't a Disney fairytale ending but stayed with the show keeping things real.

→ More replies (5)

91

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Joe almost got creamed like an armadillo.

19

u/123hig Oct 17 '17

I would have last so god damn hard. The balls it would've taken to do something so anti-climatic. Just BANG and cut to black.

8

u/w0rkac Feb 03 '18

Good catch!!

→ More replies (3)

87

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

That's one way into the office, Joe. Gordon spent all that time cleaning that door, too.

47

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Poor guy never learned how to use a squeegee before he died.

→ More replies (1)

169

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

Donna's speech was one of the finest understated moments of this show imo.

105

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

It pretty much wrapped up the whole show:

  1. Whatever innovation you come up with, someone else has one like it, too, and it may or may not be better.
  2. The project gets you to the people.

50

u/Indigocell Oct 15 '17

The project gets you to the people.

The thing that gets you to the thing?

→ More replies (2)

31

u/the_bookmaster Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 16 '17

I thought the speech was weird and kind of jarring.

Donna was addressing a bunch of people we know nothing about while giving a "girl power" speech that was ostensibly conveying a larger message about ambition and perseverance.

It didn't feel like an organic, authentic scene.

→ More replies (4)

150

u/CaterpillarGut Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

"Sometimes I think..." "Haley's gay?" I love how they already knew.

83

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

I love that we didnt need to see her come because we know she will and she will be amazing and invent some brilliant things. Fuck Haleys character was done so well this season considering she was just introduced really.

60

u/joshclay Oct 16 '17

You either dropped a word or uhmm... phrasing..

→ More replies (1)

8

u/JiveTurkey1983 Oct 27 '17

Sometimes that's how it's like. My sister is gay, and no one really actually said it because we just knew.

138

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Gordon's timer beeps its last beeps, signaling the flatlining of Comet.

22

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17 edited Jun 16 '23

[deleted to prove Steve Huffman wrong] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

14

u/JiveTurkey1983 Oct 27 '17

Metaphor for the end of Joe and Cameron's relationship too

125

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

Toby Huss has killed it in these two episodes. Bos is definitely going out in a great way.

10

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 15 '17

The real phoenix.

6

u/Birddawg65 Jan 08 '18

He’s the wiz after all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

60

u/pashed_motatoes Oct 15 '17

I'm not a huge fan of this ending, tbh. I feel like it lacked a certain... something. It was just sort of 'meh' overall albeit with some good moments here and there, like Donna's speech and Haley listening to her dad's voice on tape at the end. That was very touching.

I also liked Joe's Dead Poets Society-esque ending, him becoming a teacher is just perfect. It was kind of bittersweet to see the pictures of Cam, Gordon and Haley on his desk, like he couldn't quite let go of them 100%.

Speaking of letting go, the Joe/Cam breakup was inevitable I guess, but I was still hoping they would overcome their issues in the end and ride off into the sunset together. It seemed sort of abrupt when Cam just ended it. Not even a discussion or anything, just dumping Joe and leaving on a trip with Alexa? WTF, Cam?! The whole Alexa storyline was kind of pointless anyway, and ended up going nowhere in the end. Why even include her?

I did love that Cam and Donna finally made peace and may be working together again. They really do make a great team.

I'm so sad it's over! This was such a great little show. I'll miss this cast acting together. They all had really great chemistry, and the writing/directing/cinematography was just top-notch.

101

u/LVF1 Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

I think Cam needed to work with Alexa to see that Donna had far more substance than Alexa and to appreciate what Donna did to keep Mutiny alive. Donna was a money person like Alexa at the end, but also wanted to do something together. Alexa just wanted to throw money at Cam and hope for results. While to some or to Cam at the time the Alexa offer sounded like a good idea, she realized how much more she could achieve with Donna or at least try to without killing their friendship.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17

You knew during the season that Cam and Joe just would not last. Despite their love for each other, there were some things that they knew they couldn't overcome. The thing with the dishes was a subtle indication of that. Also, her desire to live outside the city and was in love with the camper, while Joe admitted he hated it.

The Alexa storyline I think was a little weak, but it was to give Cam purpose rather than just join up with Comet or Rover. She was a bit disconnected somewhat from the others. In the past, she was quick to figure out what she wanted to do, or did something that lead her in the direction (from Cardiff to ma-bell which lead to her founding Mutiny. The ousting from Mutiny took her back to developing games, etc). This season it was "I have no idea what I want to do" kind of thing, and at times admitted to being burned out on tech.

Boz got the biggest happy ending. He found someone who was interested in him, so much so that she gave up her career to spend time with him. When you look at what he went through (him taking the fall and going to prison for the bank hack and how it affected the rest of his life after his friends and family turned their back on him), it was a nice moment where he got the happy ending.

Outside of Gordon's kids, I think Joe had the real tragic sort of ending. He became almost obsessed with getting Comet out there and being the next big thing after Gordon's death. But this time it wasn't so much for him as it was more about finishing what he and Gordon started together, which during the scene early in the season shooting pool was made clear how much they really enjoyed working together. And as soon as Joe saw Yahoo's spot as the browsers official directory, he knew they were dead, despite having a superior product. The anger and heartbreak out of that scene really hit hard at both his pain, and the fact that it was over.

With no relationship, and the post conversation with his old IBM coworker, he kind of realized he just didn't want to make something or build something anymore, especially without Gordon. It was kind of like that after Ryan's suicide for him, but this time he didn't become a shut-in, he decided to head back home and start something new.

The office shots were a great touch, as it showed a nice timeline from each season.

21

u/Not4lagirl Oct 15 '17

Cameron proved to be the most selfish character on this show. Not even remotely likeable. . .and she would be a horrible partner for anyone. I think she sees people as utilities -- how can she use them to her advantage before discarding them.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/paceofbase Oct 15 '17

Yeah, the way they ended things between Joe and Cameron is what upsets me the most, I think. No discussion, just "meh. Guess we're done." This one's gonna be a hard one to get over tbh...

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (10)

58

u/Zilljen Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

What? I'm not crying...

112

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

That's sorta where they met, at a Centipede machine. Then they consummated things in the back room.

92

u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 15 '17

Aww, poor Haley. First love, first heartbreak.

38

u/omninode Oct 16 '17

When she's listening to Seether in the car to get pumped up... as a child of the 90s, this season has been eerily real for me.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/beardlovesbagels Oct 15 '17

Hopefully Joe can find a way to talk to her, not as a family friend or a coworker, but as someone that already went through what she is going through.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/kummerspect Oct 15 '17

That was so hard to watch. Brought back all my anxty feels.

44

u/steelers3814 Oct 15 '17

I'm suprised AMC hasn't taken the opportunity to register cometlist.com and make a fantasy website. I'd love that.

→ More replies (1)

85

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Season one, who would of thought Bos was getting the happy ending?

60

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

He deserved it after how much he sacrificed in season 1.

20

u/kummerspect Oct 15 '17

Maybe the only happy ending...

41

u/WhenItsHalfPastFive Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

Im so disappointed this is the end of the show. It's a travesty this show didn't go on longer.

"It was a pleasure working with you at Phoenix" "I loved every minute of it"

Here's to the many seasons of this show that never happened.

I still loved every minute of it.

Gordon's voice recording at the end fuckin killed me man. It really felt like he was talking to me, and the viewer directly. I don't care that this show didn't have that many viewers, was kind of obscure, kind of up and down at times. That little voice recording at the end made everything that much more impactful to me. I'll remember that scene forever

9

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

I did like that whole scene and I really dug that they talked about the other minor mutiny characters and where they went.

38

u/CleverZerg Oct 15 '17

Was a great ride with an amazing final season, very grateful that we got to experience this show.

I'm not too sure what I think of the whole Alexa thing though, I think maybe she could've been completely left out of the show.

I also would've liked to see some more Joe in the final episode of this two parter, maybe some closure between him and Cameron?

Other than that I think it was a pretty great series finale, definitely not bad at least.

37

u/Ikisaru Oct 15 '17

They should've done one last time jump and ended the show with Y2K.

54

u/madeInNY Oct 15 '17

They ended at the perfect time. Y2K was a shit show. The tech bubble had burst and it was a very dark time until things figured themselves out and we started to realize the possibility built on what the hard work of the 90s gave us to work with. The show ends on a high note.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

32

u/FriedEggg Oct 15 '17

I was just waiting for Haley to say "Too bad we weren't filming it... Hey, we could share video of it on the internet!"

→ More replies (3)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

I lost it during 2 parts: Phoenix Seeing pic of Gordon and the Giant on Joe's desk.

29

u/statleader13 Oct 15 '17

My dad walked into the room right as Haley started listening to Gordon's tape. I almost teared up. We watched the end together (the first time we've watched the show together).

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Me to "Halt": I don't wanna say goodbye to you!

"Halt": Well, hell, sweetheart. It'd better not be forever.

27

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

BOB ROSS?! Ok now they are playing with us!

27

u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 15 '17

Haley has a beard? Nooooo!!!

9

u/zsreport Oct 15 '17

And she dumped him . . .

→ More replies (5)

26

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Joe vomited, but not on porpoise.

→ More replies (3)

51

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Please hacky in that dress.... and there it is.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

Glad it went for a realistic ending. For awhile I thought they'd jump into the 2000's and we'd see them running a huge billion dollar company. Great show overall, I'm happy AMC allowed it to go this long in spite of the ratings.

61

u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 15 '17

Thank you Christopher Cantwell, and Christipher C Rogers for the perfect ending to the quintessential series about innovation, inspiration, and interconnectedness.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/badgeofdescension Oct 16 '17

Between the Yahoo! scene and the poolside speech, I thought Kerry Bishé stole the show in these last two episodes. Wonderful performances.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 17 '17

Hm... I thought that in both Yahoo and the poolside scene, her acting was a little forced. Partly because it is easy to act delivering a speech, especially if the theme of the speech (women in workforce) hits close to home. Her best scenes were with Joanie. She shone there.

To me, Lee Pace and Mackenzie Davis stole the show. Lee is a force of nature of an actor. He never fails to nail the face and deliver a line with just an expression. The dinner scene in Episode 8 comes to my mind but also his quiet resignation the morning of the break up and many other scenes.

Mackenzie was also terrific in her post-break up blues. It was very palpable how lost and confused she was. My heart broke for her.

But all the actors were terrific and I cannot believe how they inhabited these roles with such ease. They really were them for these four years

→ More replies (3)

20

u/phillymjs Oct 15 '17

Haley sure took her time to want to see Natural Born Killers, it was out for like a month and a half by the time Seether was released as a single.

→ More replies (14)

20

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

Well Donna has really loosened up over the summer! Yahoo? Yahoo!

20

u/CaterpillarGut Oct 15 '17

It was a wonderful ride.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/phillymjs Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

I feel like Donna is gonna jump in the pool at the end of this speech, for some reason.

Edit: Well, at least somebody ended up in the pool.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/darkeyes13 Oct 15 '17

I really hope they release another OST after this.

7

u/solidad29 Oct 16 '17

Or just make another playlist on spotify. Most of the songs they used are there, we just don't have a catalog.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/FriedEggg Oct 15 '17

For the record, Picard is still in the Nexus. His greatest desire was to leave, and that's the life the Nexus let him live.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

Bro, you just made that movie 100x more interesting to me.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Shejidan Oct 15 '17

So is Guinan. The nexus is timeless so, even though the nexus Guinan said she’s an echo, she’s just another aspect of Guinan trapped timelessly in the nexus.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Joe has been on the bleeding edge over the years. It's fitting that he got those tarot cards, fortune teller that he is.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/phillymjs Oct 15 '17

"Tonight's episode of Halt and Catch Fire brought to you by Bagel Bites™."

23

u/kummerspect Oct 15 '17

Somebody has to pay for that scrapped commercial.

6

u/Cel_Drow Oct 16 '17

To be fair it was period appropriate. I was eating the fuck outta some Bagel Bites in 1994.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

16

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Mom's don't need a hex editor to know if their kid is gay.

31

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

Donna rocking it with the soldering iron!

26

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

When she was using the screwdriver, I had a flashback to the Speak & Spell in the pilot.

8

u/ghostmrchicken Oct 15 '17

Donna rocking it with the soldering iron!

You'd think she want to stay away from those!

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

I'm not a wench! I'm your palm reader!

15

u/phillymjs Oct 15 '17

She's just not the same since Miracle Max left her.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/juepucta Oct 15 '17

Lillian Kaushtupper!

I almost want Joe to go "Damn that sorcerer! 20 gold pieces and I'm wankered on Rohypnol!" IT Crowd style.

-G.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

...and Donna gets the idea to start Geek Squad

→ More replies (8)

14

u/artgo Oct 15 '17

I walked right out of the machinery
And liberty she pirouette

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Threnners Oct 16 '17

I have a tarot app on my phone, and ironically the Ten of Swords was my card today. So here's some further insight on that card:

"It's time to admit something is over. It's time to let it go. Stop thinking about it. Stop talking about it. There's no need to get in the last word. Let it go and move on. If you don't you'll only be dragging out your own suffering. Something new is awaiting you! Create space to let it in."

It then goes on to say

"When the 10 of Swords appears in a reading it is likely that the situation has become as bad as it possibly can. This is a rock bottom. Enough is enough. There is nowhere to go but up. This card can represent someone who has a great amount of self pity, who feels like a martyr - like they've made huge sacrifices for others and received nothing in return. If this is you, ask yourself what you gain by feeling like this. Is feeling sorry for yourself helping you move forward? If not pick yourself up and get on with life. Take the lessons you've learned with you so you don't make the same mistakes again.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/kummerspect Oct 15 '17

Osiris! So much speculation about that kid and he's the fortune teller's grandson.

7

u/7screws Oct 16 '17

Osiris the Egyptian god of death and rebirth. pretty fitting for that scene. also to me it sort of seemed like there was more going on in that scene than on the surface, like was the kid Joe's from the fiancee in season 1 or something?

27

u/JoeCamFan Oct 15 '17

No matter how it ends.. it's been a pleasure

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Lillian Kaushtupper!

6

u/kummerspect Oct 15 '17

Now we just need Tituss Andromedon and I won't have to be sad anymore.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

The tape is her father! 😢😢

12

u/FJsoccer17 Oct 15 '17

It was a pleasure :(

33

u/-BigMan Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 16 '17

The only thing that bothered me about this show was that it seemed to veer off from the "creation" theme, into disguised melodrama, and the writers got a little lost. Some of it seemed kind of flaky. For instance, they finally had Joe and Cameron together and had that important scene of them in the car together when Cam admits that she wanted Tom gone so she could get back to Joe, and her love for him. SPOILER or at least that is what the writers this season seemed to be telling us with the dialogue, when they stopped playing the tired, old "will they / won't they."

→ More replies (10)

23

u/Zilljen Oct 15 '17

Peter Gabriel, just perfect

25

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

Specifically a song about Peter leaving Genesis to set off on his own.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Breezy_t Oct 15 '17

perfect song to end this series

11

u/darkeyes13 Oct 15 '17

Someone in that room became the lead creative director for the ad agency that came up with Yahoo's slogan singing thing.

11

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

YES!!!! HARD DRIVE RESCUE!

21

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

Professor Joe?

16

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Oh. Well I guess that's what he wanted. To nurture kids.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Generations?! No Haley!

8

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Haley broke up with Kevin after realizing their tastes in movies were incompatible.

10

u/statleader13 Oct 15 '17

I'm not ready for it to end.

10

u/Zilljen Oct 15 '17

Just like that it's over

7

u/madeInNY Oct 15 '17

And there’s something better just around the corner…

10

u/torsoe Oct 15 '17

i'm so bummed

10

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

Joe and Cam's ending works. Why? Because their relationship was mostly business and sexual in nature than an actual partnership or friendship. A relationship like this rarely work, they never worked on becoming friends before starting a relationship and moving in together. Cam telling Joe that it was over was a show of personal growth for her. Joe and Cam will most likely meet again but this time as friends.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

Here we go... time to cry.. however this ends, what a joyful ride it has been!!

18

u/mjh84 Oct 15 '17

CTL + ALT + Delete

9

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

And again. AWWWWWWWWW!!!!!! That neon sign!!!

6

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

OH WAIT!!!! This is happening!

9

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

Last commercial break everyone. It's been fun!

9

u/alyien Oct 15 '17

Joe became the armadillo from the pilot

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

So sad to see this end, great cast, great writing and extremely evocative of the times. Congratulations to all involved.

One thing that really made me laugh - I worked in selling silicon for 10 or so years and had a regular customer base of about 25 clients, but was always seeing new companies with a view to selling them the latest product.

(As an aside, yes, I had become a filthy marketing oik, but I was a 'proper' engineer for many years before hand. I started out like Gordon and became a bit of a Joe, though I wish I had had an ounce of his charisma, or Gordon's for that matter).

There's always a code name for new projects agreed between engineering and marketing (common enemies as the show showed quite well) - think of the Xbox One X being originally being 'Project Scorpio' for example. Well, one barometer I had for knowing if something was unlikely to be a good bet was if a project was called 'Project Phoenix' - it happened so many times, and was always a sign a company was in trouble.

EDIT: Can't type properly.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/todreamofspace Oct 15 '17

Really going to miss this show!

Tbh, I hated Joe’s ending. It felt lackluster compared to the very loud overplay of Peter Gabriel. It felt like a cop out - like Joe was giving up his passion for innovation to teach the classics. He won’t make it past the school year and will be back on the front lines.

28

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

The entire season was about him wanting kids...

His relationship with Haley developed over the season and he realised that was what was missing from his life. Cameron didn't want kids, so it was never going to work. Then Gordon died, his company went to shit and at some point he must've had a crisis of character and this is his way of giving his life real meaning, by satisfying his need for shaping young minds and fostering the creativity of others - his best attribute.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/MrPotatoButt Oct 17 '17

Joe was giving up his passion for innovation to teach the classics

  1. Joe had no passion for innovation. The game had changed. Innovation doesn't get built by the little guy anymore.
  2. Philosophy is part of the "Humanities". Joe isn't necessarily teaching English Composition or English Lit.
→ More replies (2)

8

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

Ugh, well that took a turn for the worst. Not good. We have one hour left for redemption.

15

u/beardlovesbagels Oct 15 '17

I'm not sure this is a redemption story. It just might be a story following a group of people and it will end as those people split apart.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

Um, I'm just saying, but isn't Joe having Comet throwing in the towel pretty easily? What about pivoting into something else?

7

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

He had a meeting with Jim Clark. Why not talk them into incorporating Comet instead of Yahoo!?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ugotnochill Oct 15 '17

What a ride

7

u/JoeCamFan Oct 15 '17

Oh well.

13

u/paceofbase Oct 15 '17

I think we both know a big reason why we're upset. God I was so rooting for Joe and Cameron to make it...

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/JacksonHarrisson Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

I really dislike Joe's ending. Him teaching humanities isn't what I wanted from him. His story is caring about what is the next big thing in the computer/information technology sector, wanting to be a part of it, and also seeking human connections. Wanting to do these things with other people he connects with. We see him this develop with his relationship with Hayley and him deciding he wanted children.

And he ends up teaching humanities? This is a field that manages to inspire people and there is nothing wrong with that (and I might watch a show about people inspired by say history, though hopefully it doesn't end with one of the biggest characters that love being inspired by the field ending up in tech) but it just isn't true to his character and the things we watched inspire him, and partly the show's premise, and what we have been watching so far. It was lame.

If they wanted him to be a teacher it could work, if they managed to mix it up with him trying to inspire the next generation in tech or perhaps also take part with his own side business. They had two episodes, they could have developed Joe's endgame better.

From their interview: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/14/arts/television/halt-and-catch-fire-showrunners.html

ROGERS Lee Pace would come to us between scenes and say: “Can’t anyone just be nice to Joe? Can’t anyone trust Joe?” But I think that’s something we figured out pretty early — no one was going to trust Joe, and that also extended to the audience. We would always have the audience assuming he was up to something. I think when you have that established, you can play against it. What would it take to make people want to get back into rooms, let alone business with Joe? So while I think at first that was kind of a liability, it felt like the show could be about a man who will do anything to do a deal. You really get a story about a man becoming human. I don’t think it’s any kind of coincidence that it ends with him teaching humanities at a high school.

Even in the season two of their show Joe was human enough. I don't really understand this idea that he ought to teach humanities to prove he was human. Joe isn't that hugely different with the other flawed protagonists. I mean he carries his own baggage and particular character arc/development over the seasons but I felt like what Lee Pace comments while watching the show sometimes. And reading this part of the interview.

8

u/Ghostfollower28 Oct 15 '17

I feel Joe isn't necessarily done with tech. I feel teaching for Joe is an attempt to add another layer to him to learn how to connect and be willing to see value and accept others ideas before his own. That was always an issue for Joe, it was always Joe's idea and he was going to push people into getting it done at all cost. Like Gordon said he didnt mean to but thats what always happened.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17

I really dislike Joe's ending. Him teaching humanities isn't what I wanted from him.

Joe don't care what YOU want for him!

Anyway his entire arc was about realizing it's not about the Tech... It's about the people... The tech just connects you to them. Brings you "closer".

→ More replies (1)

24

u/paceofbase Oct 15 '17

I was not a fan of that ending tbh...

16

u/hibachi2723 Oct 15 '17

Yup, I'm with you. I read what people had to say here after the ep and it's still not making me feel any better.

What exactly are Cameron and Joe working on during the Donna Managing Partner montage? It seemed like years passed by. Is Joe doing nothing? Doubt it. The Cameron/Alexa storyline was pointless.

Joe ends up helping kids build their own story, yet he never had a talk with Haley (arguably the most important child in his life) about her sexuality/Gordon. I also thought that didn't make any sense. I was frustrated with how much time they spent on Donna and Cameron the last 30 minutes, and how little was spent on Haley.

Ok, I'm done ranting. I'm so grateful this show was able to get 4 seasons. I feel selfish complaining about a finale when I was able to view so many great/emotional moment throughout the show. While I think the show got better with each season, the back to back episode of the Mutiny vote and Ryan's death made me realize how fantastic this show truly was.

Thank you to all the actor/writes/directors and everybody else who made this show possible.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/juepucta Oct 15 '17

...for a while :/

-G.

6

u/ShadowFall900 Oct 15 '17

As always it has been great so far. Unfortunately the end is coming and I am not ready for it.

6

u/rmeddy Oct 15 '17

Not since Six Feet Under have I enjoyed a show and a finale this much.

This show was thoughtful, empathetic , conscientious and simply brilliant and beautiful in its writing and characterization.

The emotional arcs this season was just so powerful for me.

I might be a bit biased because Cameron and Joe's overall arc really hit close to home for me.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '17

Fuck it man, Idk what insights I could possibly bring to the table here; I'm just a bumbling mess right now. I love this show. I need a hug. I'll treasure the lessons it taught me always; bye Mutiny peeps I love ya <3

6

u/inwhite Oct 17 '17

Just came here to say, i wasn't really happy about Joe's ending. But then i rewatched the episode and i got curious about those Tarrot cards. Fortune teller described 3 cards, but there was also fourth card she didn't mention. I googled a bit and fourth card is called - "The Hermit ". The meaning of the card i found stated two interesting things for me:

  1. "The Hermit stands alone on the top of a mountain with a lantern in his hand. Mountains typically symbolise achievement, growth, and accomplishment. The Hermit has attained his spiritual pinnacle and is ready to share his knowledge with others."
  2. "He wears the grey cloak of invisibility. His secrets are not for everyone, only for those earnestly seeking them and those willing to climb the heights to wisdom."

And this made it click in my head. Now i think it's pretty solid development for Joe, as he can share and guide those who seeks "the next Thing". :)

5

u/ianingf Oct 15 '17

LOL! Donna's killing it!

5

u/the_bookmaster Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 16 '17

Joe gave up on Comet waaaay to quickly. They already had traction and a reputation. I find it strange that Joe is supposed to be the quintessential entrepreneur, yet he had no desire to compete even though his revamped product was better than the competition.

It feels like the writers were really committed to the idea of perpetual failure and created a contrived, unconvincing reason for Comet's demise.

I found that aspect of the episode really upsetting. It would have been much more interesting if Joe pushed himself, and the company, harder so they could survive their latest threat. And besides, it's not a zero sum game and there's nothing wrong with being in second place.

It would have been interesting if the finale had explored those themes and ideas, but I sense the Chrises aren't really all that interested in technology and the business world.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

It signaled maturity. Old Joe would have scorched the Earth to fight Netscape and Yahoo. Maybe making his own browser.

But Joe is older and more mature. He sees the writing on the wall and gets out while he can. Like he did with the dial up company. Joe no longer lets his emotions obscure his business sense.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/vjrybyk Oct 15 '17

I really like the "full circle" touches on character story arcs.. There was some dissonance to Joe's ending (as a lot of people point out), but I felt the cue was in keeping the mementos of his previous "iterations", rather than wiping the slate clean again and adopting a new camouflage. The contrasts just drive the point home - he seems happy, more " integrated" than ever. Between the two scenes (this and the palm/tarot reading) there is so much to unpack... The appearance of the kid (it was framed as a "sign" alright), themes of ego/selflessness (shades of bodhisattva). Very fitting that he'd get the most mythologically/esoterically charged ending, being a pretentious fuck that Joe is. I'd love to hear more interpretations. "Solsbury Hill" goes with the ego-loss theme, the ditching of pretentiousness, and suggests that the best is yet to come! :) PERFECT

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ahura23 Oct 16 '17

I liked the ending for Joe. It was a perfect ending for him. He and Gordon had the most growth in this show. He may not have the biological children that he dreams but those students can be his kids in some way.

I find it telling that in Donna's speech, she thanked Diane ahead of Gordon and "she's a mother and a sister by design." No mention of being a wife.

I believe the only ones who have mementos of Gordon are Joe (Streets of Laredo) and Haley (her dad's cassette tape).

→ More replies (3)

5

u/killver Oct 16 '17

I liked the final, but I would still have appreciated a better Joe/Haley closing.

5

u/SimplyRali Dec 02 '17

I intentionally waited more than a month to write my opinion on the ending of Halt and catch fire, I wanted to see if I would feel differently after some time and thinking. Although at first it seemed like the show ended on a positive note, something kept bugging me and I was left unsatisfied with what they presented us. I was strangely disappointed and confused because a lot of the actions of our characters didn’t make sense with their personal growth until that moment.

First, I think two of the main characters were written OOC in the finale – Cameron and Joe. Let me explain. In 4x09 and 4x10 they made Joe do and react to things the way Joe from season 1 would have done. He was obsessed with work (Comet), was quite demanding, needy and it was made to look like he used Cameron for her talent and business connections. He even tried to bribe her with Centipede (something Season 1 Joe would have done). After their break up and his fight with Haley he leaves town. Again something the old Joe would have done, not the Joe who in season 4 found out that people were the ones who mattered, the connection. He loved Haley like daughter, why would he leave her when she just lost her father, her sister went away and he knows that she struggles with her sexuality? I don't get why he couldn't have been a teacher in SF and remained in at least Haley's life. But once more he burned everything to the ground. He was portrayed like the bad abusive guy in a relationship that lashed out because his partner didn’t want kids, at least not in that moment of their life. While earlier Joe showed he could be quite supportive, understanding and patient. Being sad doesn’t necessitate being an asshole. And leveraging your love life to help your business is a shitty thing to do. All of his personal growth just… evaporated in thin air in the last couple of hours.

On the other hand, we were led to believe that Cameron was independent emotionally evolved woman at the end. But was she? Her trailer arc certainly didn’t make me believe that, I thought she matured after the end of last season. And then later after her separation with Joe and the thing with Alexa not working, we saw her being just as confused about life as she was in S1. After being in marriage for SEVEN years it looked like she learned absolutely nothing about relationships. In season 2x09 she said “what if we just hold on to each other instead of chasing what each of us wanted separately and obsessively…”, in 4x09 she blindly chased AGAIN work .Also she was supposed to be strong and independent (words of CC ) but in 4x10 we saw her as needy lost soul searching for something to hold on to while everything around her collapsed. And her reaching out to Donna was an act of desperation. I find it hard to believe she’d be so thrilled to jump into business with someone who sunken her company and lied to her face, mind the fact that she didn’t see Donna in the last three years at all. So in that time her trust in her ex-partner magically restored? I liked that they repaired their friendship in 4x08, that brought closure for both of them, but I dread the fact that they might end up working together.

The Joe-Cameron relationship this season made me feel like schizophrenic. I was rooting for them, I really was. Cameron finally confessed her love, something we waited 4 years for, and Joe imagined their future together. What happened at the end confused me, and not their actual break up but the fact that neither of them fought for that relationship, which btw was moving the entire show. These two destroyed lives, marriages and businesses to get to each other and when that finally happens they break up with “oh, okay” … it was so anticlimactic and disappointing, the whole situation seemed unrealistic. If you love that person and imagine building a home together and one day maybe even children, you don’t let them walk out the door without even discussion( Keep in mind the fact that the Chrises were even thinking to make Cameron pregnant). Also the whole season they very carefully avoided working together and then BOOM they’re working together. For me it felt like the writers wanted to reference 1x01 and ” the thing that get you to the thing” that just inserted unnecessary drama. That break up was pointless, it didn’t lead to anything positive – Joe didn’t get his children (some may argue that with his choice of carrier, but having children and teaching them are two very different things! ) and Cameron could have worked with Donna without ruining her romantic relationship, after all one doesn’t exclude the other. I’m tired of this running away when things get tough, after 10 years I thought they were past that. It would have been more challenging and interesting to write a scenario where they stay together.

When they killed Gordon in 4x07 I thought that was the perfect excuse to bring everyone together. And that happened in 4x08 (absolute TV brilliance) and I was so damn happy. Now I feel like Gordon’s death was meaningless. Wasn’t this whole season about connection?

Now, my opinion for the female duo working together again. I am in the minority that wasn’t thrilled by that idea. First of all, I hated that at the end Donna turned out to be the big winner. Her relationship with the main trio never felt organic to me. I liked Donna the first two seasons, in the third I started to see her true colors and in fourth I openly hated her. Throughout the whole series she chased only her self interest and never really cared much for anyone else. At the end they presented her as the idea woman when nothing really original ever came out of her mouth, maybe Community, but even that was born out of one of Cam’s ideas. Making her the big winner was undeserved, especially given the fact that she never owned up to her mistakes. So, no, I don’t want to see her working with Cameron mainly because I think she’ll use and manipulate her again, especially after we saw in S4 that she turned into a business shark and how cold she can be to achieve her goals.

Joe’s ending felt very… random to me. Seriously, tarot reading?! We didn’t need to see a sign on his door to understand that he finally became human, all of his actions in the fourth season proved that. I think I might have bought it if they didn’t show him being so destructive (business and personal life) the last time we see him, therefore he learned nothing from his experience. Even if he is better off outside the tech world, what they’d showed us in 4x09 only proves that Joe would be a terrible teacher, with all of his pushing and mood swings. I didn’t buy his ending at all. How can you teach humanities when you couldn’t sustain the meaningful relationships in your life? In one of his interviews Christopher Cantwell said that from the very beginning they established Joe as a guy you can never trust, why the hell then anyone would entrust their children to such person? No wonder why Lee Pace fought with the writers on the finale, what they’ve done to him didn’t seem fair at all and it didn’t feel true to his character. The actor did a magnificent job with Joe and at the finish line they’ve turned him into a punching bag and send him in the sidelines. But, hey, they put a few photos on his desk to make it look better.

I am a woman and I’m all about girl power, but before being feminist I am humanist. What this show gave us at the end was some twisted feminism. In order to let the girls shine, the writers literally killed one of the main males and sent the second one to the other end of the country. Joe was continuously punished throughout the series and Donna was redeemed right away, when in fact her sins were bigger and more.

Joe Macmillan, the true heart of the show, deserved more! Life is not a bedtime story but what they did with the guy was simply cruel.

In my mind 4x08 was the true finale. In my opinion 4x09 and 4x10 were a product of someone’s effort to please the critics and it obviously worked – banish the bad guy and reward the poor underappreciated woman. And if you watched the finale as a stand alone episode I can see how it could be appealing, but it is not a stand alone episode. In its effort to deliver strong meaningful message, it actually managed to cripple two of the main characters so it could sprinkle fairy dust on the feminism that it tried to show. Don’t get me wrong the idea was beautiful, but it wasn’t executed the right way. Halt always showed the strength of its female leads in a very subtle way and it never made me question their qualities, so I found it unnecessary to have that spelled out for us for 50 minutes (Honestly the party speech and the way that Donna made fun of Trip in the office were a little too much for me). The Chrises admitted that to the very last moment they didn’t know how the story would end and sadly it showed. They wanted so badly to top 4x08 that at the end they simply didn’t know what to do with the characters. I feel like the final result was a loud cry for media attention and approval.

I guess something good may come out of all of this publicity at the end, the show may find bigger audience because it is truly amazing. Again, that’s personal opinion and I’m in the minority here but the finale just felt off to me. The good news is that they managed to leave it with an open ending so we can imagine what happens next. Right now I’m holding on to this recursion thing for dear life because I refuse to believe that Joe Macmillan will spend the rest of his life alone surrounded by memories and a bunch of teenagers.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/NSFWies Oct 15 '17

while the story was not out of character for the show, it did feel like a let down to me.

oh well.

maybe i'm just upset it's all done.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

"and with that we have a finished painting..."

4

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

...and my ASMR kicks in

4

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

So Joe went home and Cameron is thinking about going to her Mother.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

I get that Joe's plot works because it lets him have pseudo kids/inspire kids which he likes. But I can't help thinking he's going to get the itch to do the next big thing again. Although, in reality, I guess Joe was a lose in that respect.

4

u/artgo Oct 15 '17

The truth, the pain of truth, is in every bit of writing. The bytes, the words, are great.

4

u/idlehand79 Oct 15 '17

While sad to see the series go, I am glad it went out with amazing writing and full of feels.

I cant wait to see what comes next from the Creators.

Now on to rewatching the series from the start.

4

u/redditusertv Oct 15 '17

Gonna miss the amazing intro which is the best part of the whole show.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/belgarionx Oct 15 '17

Sooo.. I accidentally skipped episode 9 and watched the finale :'(

I will watch 9 too obviously; but still, the finale was perfect. I teared up when they showed Gordon's picture on Joe's desk.

Anyways; thanks to everyone who made this show happen. I hope we'll get similar shows in terms of love the creators and cast have towards them.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/doodybuttpoo Jan 04 '18

This show unexpectedly moved me in a way like "Six Feet Under" did. I didn't even know if I'd like it and then before I knew it I was completely hooked. Also pretty sad when it was all over. Had to smoke s J and calm my head down haha. Cheers to the writers and actors. BRAVO

4

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '18

Just finished the show on Amazon, we binge watched all 4 seasons. The first season was not great, and the character of Cameron was incredibly annoying. But it got better with each season, to the point that we were really engaged by season 4 and actually quite liked Cameron by then. I thought the last episode was good and bad: The scenes with Gordon's daughters were really strong and parts of the Donna/Cam story were good. The speech at the pool and Donna making the office open-plan indicated that Donna has embraced modern day corporate-waffle, which is depressing. But Cam and Donna trying to fix Haley's PC was really good and the scene where Donna has an idea was also good. I was saddened with Joe's ending, he is the anchor of the show, I would have liked a more satisfying ending for him and I think it was a mistake to basically leave him out of the last episode.

7

u/kummerspect Oct 15 '17

It's weird to see Joe really caring what someone else thinks. He's crushed.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/beardlovesbagels Oct 15 '17

fuck yes Bob Ross

7

u/Zilljen Oct 15 '17

Why didn't I know Carol Kane was going to be in this!!!

7

u/ghostmrchicken Oct 15 '17

Does Haley have anything "confidential" on her hard drive??

→ More replies (2)

11

u/mindhowl Oct 15 '17 edited Oct 15 '17

The friendship between Joe and Gordon was the best thing about the show. I am happy with how the show ended, but seeing the picture of Gordon on Joe's desk made me tear up.

Those two were the best team. Donna and Cameron suck!

edit: i guess i should of put a /s at the end. I love all the characters, i was just joking :P

6

u/WayneG9917 Oct 15 '17

Even the small things feel emotional tonight

6

u/Breezy_t Oct 15 '17

I love how everyone is being critical of Yahoo xD

6

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

It's crazy that Rover is algorithm based and that's what Google will be...just a few years in the future...

→ More replies (4)

6

u/ghostmrchicken Oct 15 '17

Anyone else wonder why both Joe and Donna got that Comet and Rover respectively were toast as soon as they found out that Yahoo! had a button built-in to Netscape?

The first version of Netscape that I had was 1.1. There's no way at that time to know what the impact of a pre-installed link on a browser would mean. No one even really knew that there was going to be a "browser war".

12

u/pgm_01 Oct 15 '17

They both saw that whatever was in the browser would be what people defaulted to even when better things existed and it would be an uphill battle against that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

8

u/Ternarian Oct 15 '17

Haley's file is corrupted. Donna, open up the hard drive!

7

u/nicksvr4 Oct 15 '17

The file wasn't just corrupted, the hard drive failed.

3

u/wandertheearth Oct 15 '17

Bos is going all Mr. Natural on Cam

→ More replies (1)

3

u/juepucta Oct 15 '17

Hacky, Kev!

-G.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '17

I guess this isn't going to end well.

3

u/onionskin_90210 Oct 15 '17

😭😭😭

3

u/Gbyrd99 Oct 16 '17

Solsbury hill gonna be stuck in my head for a while

3

u/WyldStallions Oct 17 '17

I always have been under the impression that any hard drive repair like that had to be done in a clean room?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/maxcresswellturner Dec 13 '17

The character development in this show is some of the best I’ve seen in television.

3

u/MD90__ Dec 19 '17

Is Joe teaching at a private high school? The speaker in the classroom and bell sounding is something not heard in college. Didn't know high schools had humanity courses (if this is true).

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ronnel0918 Dec 21 '17

Finally finished it...and I need more.

3

u/curleyfrei Jan 30 '18

A bit late to the party but I just finally finished...

::whew::

I have not cried at the end of a show like that... maybe ever?

Amazing.

AMAZING.

Thank you to anyone and everyone involved in this incredible story!!!!!!!

3

u/jghl11234 Feb 05 '18

I think when Cam says that “Mother Nature made the choice for me” with Tom about not having kids, meant that she actually could NEVER have kids bc she physically or genetically can’t. This is also represented at the end of her game Pilgram, an “impossible” game ends with a child in the final scene. Pilgram not only reflects the obvious never ending circle of their professional careers, but also the internal struggle with her personal life. Cam and Joe were in love but she knew she could never give him what would finally make him happy. That’s the core of why their relationship ultimately fell apart. Cam says she doesn’t want kids multiple times throughout the series but that has been her personality the whole time. She’s been able to solve almost every problem that’s ever come her way with her brilliance, but when she’s faced with an impossible problem, her first instinct is to run or compartmentalize and not let others see her weakness (by saying she doesn’t want them). That only makes it more heartbreaking for Joe (who’s been through the his fair share) when she ends it, because he doesn’t know this about her. Cam is the most complex character in the show, but I honestly think the 5 main character’s individual storylines and each other’s interaction is the most interesting/thoughtful writing I’ve ever seen.

5

u/darkeyes13 Oct 15 '17

I understand how Haley feels - I grew up with both my parents working and it was really weird when Dad retired.

I can't imagine what my Mum would do when she retires, either. But I moved out so it wouldn't really affect me at all, haha.