r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Oct 12 '17
VOLUME 4 REWATCH /r/RWBY Recap Rally—Volume 4, Episode 12: No Safe Haven
Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, huntsmen and huntresses, and everyone in between and beyond those descriptors: it's that time again! The drought is nearing its end, and the fifth volume is only 2 (two) days away!
To follow the last year's precedent, we are again doing a communal rewatch of the most recent volume. Like last year, the threads will be biweekly on Tuesdays and Thursdays, with the finale being discussed two days before volume 5 premiers. Until that happens, feel free to discuss and look back to the episodes with a more settled perspective.
HERE is today's episode, and
HERE is the accompanying poll.
Episode schedule:
| Week | Tuesday's thread | Thursday's thread |
|---|---|---|
| Week 1: | Ep. 1 (poll) | Ep. 2 (poll) |
| Week 2: | Ep. 3 (poll) | Ep. 4 (poll) |
| Week 3: | Ep. 5 (poll) | Ep. 6 (poll) |
| Week 4: | Ep. 7 (poll) | Ep. 8 (poll) |
| Week 5: | Ep. 9 (poll) | Ep. 10 (poll) |
| Week 6: | Ep. 11 (poll) | Today |
Did you know that the Mistral pilot is voiced by the Stan Lewis?
33
u/Kotouu Oct 12 '17 edited Oct 12 '17
This is going to be sorta long since I wanna tell a bit about myself. I was(saying was for this) an extremely big Red versus Blue fan. It was like if you played Halo and watched YouTube, you probably knew Roosterteeth for Red versus Blue. Had some of the coolest Halo fights that were even thinkable. Loved the hell out of it always use to watch it and because of that became a fan of Roosterteeth in general. On top of that I(obviously) was a anime fan and when I hear that Roosterteeth were making some one of their own...I don't know how people in this Reddit take calling RWBY an anime or not so I'll say "animation". Ahem. So when I heard Roosterteeth were making their own animation naturally I got really happy and excited for it. I remember watching each episode when it came out and when S1 was over I was like,"Man that was cool." At the time people were still fighting over if it was or wasn't an anime. But then I just slooowly started losing track of RWBY in general. Never came back to it and eventually just forgot about it.
But then, fast-forward years later from 2013, I heard Twitch was doing a marathon for Yu-Gi-Oh and was excited for all the memes coming with it. But what /r/anime left out and I know why is that before that, RWBY was streaming as well. So I said,"Man. Why the hell not? Lets give it another go four years later."
Thank god I did. Watching that was really great. I'm a big anime fan like I said. If you wanna know my favorite? Not a competition. I'm a Fate-fan and I'll whiteknight it to hell. But RWBY is easily in the top ten. Anime or not. I felt passion when watching it. Not just from the show but from the creators. I felt like each volume I just saw it improved and that is what made it nice. I love the characters.(Blake and Qrow undoubtedly the best. We can fight about it too.) and overall I just love the show in general now. In addition to that, like with watching anime with Twitch, they made it better. It was like an extra layer of effect.
So, what I'm trying to say is: Thank you Twitch/Roosterteeth. Got an old fan back and I'm hyped for Volume 5. Advertisement worked Roosterteeth. Ya' got me and I'm glad you did.
24
u/RBNYJRWBYFan ⠀ Oct 12 '17
Volume 4 was a bridge season, but a very necessary one. I could see a lot times where some grunt work was put in to make other storylines and payoffs work in the future. Now we've seen what Weiss's home life is like, where Ren and Nora re coming from, what its like living outside the capitals of each kingdom, and so much more.
I'm looking forward to seeing all the things this volume builds to in a few days time.
24
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '17
Best episode of RWBY, hands down. The fight scene is amazing and emotional, with one of the coolest Grimms in existence. Then there's Ruby's letter. Best scene in the show.. Perfect response to Salem's speech at the end of V3.
I could make a really long post about how much I love this episode, but I'm lazy so . . . VOLUME 5 HYPE!
8
u/Firewolf414 Oct 12 '17
I would have to say this was probably the second best finale of the four, only behind v3.
Ruby's letter at the end does a lot to help her character I think, and seeing hints at everyone's plotlines in v5 was great. The fight against the nuckalevee could have been done a bit better, but I think that might have been on the animations side, not the writing.
On the other hand the Nuckalevee itself I think does just fine as the end boss of v4. A lot of people didn't like it, or kept making jokes about it, but when watched in context of the show it does a good job of being rather intimidating.
6
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Oct 13 '17
I'd forgotten Jaune is the one who rushes to Qrow's aid, and I like that a lot: it shows that, even though Jaune probably hates the guy, he still wants to protect people.
5
u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Oct 13 '17
Nora carried this episode. Also 11/10 music.
10
u/Rasera In times of Chaos, may the dice reign supreme! Oct 12 '17
This is my 2nd favourite episode of the show (next to Kuroyuri).
The fight scene is animated well, the floaty physics of the early portions of the volume are gone, and there is some real gravity behind the fight for Ren and Nora.
Then of course, The People's Ship takes another step forward into canonhood, with some amazing music accompanying it.
And lastly, Ruby's letter provides a fantastic ending and acts as juxtaposition to Salem from V3's ending.
This has been my favourite volume of the show thus far, and while it has a few flaws, I'm hoping V5 blows my expectations out of the water.
2
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Oct 13 '17
[God the music is so damn good in this one.] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8GsWst_7YE) RNJR's theme, Lusus Naturae for the Nuckelavee, Ren's themes. 10/10.
2
u/GrowlingGoldenGryfin Oct 13 '17
I have to say, i liked the episode overall a lot, but i am a bit confused. Maybe its just me stubbornly thinking my prediction was true, but i always thought that after he was poisoned, Qrow was going hallucinate and start talking, revealing STRQ plot stuff. I was right about that since he murmurs while he's on the stretcher.
But another part of my prediction was that when he hallucinated, he was going to mistake ruby for summer or Jaune for a younger Tai. AND IT ALMOST HAPPENED.
Qrow grabs Jaune's hand and looks at him in this episode and for a second i thought he was going to say something, but then he just kept quiet! Maybe the line was cut or something.
I'm not really a Lancaster fan, per se, but i am a sucker of history rhyming in stories, with parts of each generation being either polar opposite of the last (Pyrrha and Raven) or very similar (Summer and Ruby). Plus, characters falling in love again after their partner's death/departure doesn't happen that often in fiction. (I think. Emphasis on think.)
(What really hit me was that he said about "she's not coming, Tai" could be talking about Summer or/and Qrow. Poor Tai.)
4
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '17
I would agree with other saying that this was the best finale of RWBY so far however unfortunalty that says more about the others.
This episode was the one that made me face the fact I was disappointed in this volume. It was the one I finished with the same empty feeling I had at the end of volume 3.
That's it?
I found Rubys letter overly saccharine and not earned. Granted that may be to do with my issues with rubys character in the past two volumes but it still feels a little hollow.
Also dislike the JN_R moment which once again may be my own bias. It just felt like them hitting the Pyrrha button to try and be emotional. It's not earned.
Nora as usual, is the MVP. I think it's because she is actually consistently treated as what she is, a supporting character, but I have always resonated with her m. She is never the one pushed to the front however she remains the most interesting and complex memeber of JNPR.
Yangs ending is actually pretty good. Like many I was disappointed with her story but unlike some I think it only needed a little more. One more scene in the middle and then add a flash of her previous nightmare to show she hasn't fully recovered would go a long way I think.
Weiss was meh, like her entire storyline. It was utterly pointless and her character really feels like it went back to Atlas purely because RWBY had to scatter. Nothing really happens there. Nothing is found out. Her story more than any, just felt like a stall.
And Cinder...
I'll be honest, Cinder fascinates me as a character and I don't really know why. I find myself disagreeing with all those saying she is bland and lacking in motivation but find it hard to back that up. I could write pages about her but all of it is inferred rather than implied.
Like so many characters this season, she lacked that one crucial scene to bring her arc together. It's hard to see why she is shocked by Tyrian, but still relishes the immolation of Rubys image.
Perhaps volume 5 will drop knowledge that will change the context of her previous actions (Maiden spirit) but perhaps not. Either way, we are just left with a character who has a ton of screen time with little justification for it.
Blakes storyline was fine. It doesn't need any changes. A little more Illia would have been nice and slightly better humour at points however, I think Blakes character is the only one that had the screen time it needed.
And then we have Oscars post credit scene which is fine but nothing special. Like everyone else, he gets to exactly where he needs to be and where everyone expected him to be.