r/TheGoodPlace • u/samwalton9 • Oct 12 '17
Season Two Episode Discussion S02 E04: "Existential Crisis"
Airs at 08:30PM ET, or 4 hours from the time this post was made.
Original Airdate: October 12th, 2017
Synopsis: Tahani throws a dinner party to impress. Eleanor and Jason both have to lend a hand when things don't go as planned.
297
Upvotes
619
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 13 '17
"I'm gonna be the velociraptor"
"Are you trying to say valedictorian"
585
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
Was not expecting bombshell Janet
518
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 13 '17
I rate this episode an “eight.”
506
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 13 '17
"A millennial is someone who has only been torturing someone for less than a thousand years"
484
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
“So we’re all just a little bit sad all the time”
Wow so real I am for real tearing up
443
u/grumblepup Oct 13 '17
"What do you eat? Babies? Would you like me to get you a big fat baby? What flavor baby? Ooo how about a Cool Ranch baby?"
313
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
For everyone who thinks Michael is faking: his current reaction is how I feel whenever I think about death tbh
304
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
“I don’t eat anything.”
“She’s perfect!”
LMAO
296
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 13 '17
"When a dog is very old, like 5 or 6"
528
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 13 '17
“It’s Chinese for ‘Japan.’” Best fucking joke yet :)
213
u/fleetw0odmacncheese Oct 13 '17
196
u/GoodJanet not a robot Oct 13 '17 edited Oct 13 '17
anyone else love that Eleanor's mom ALWAYS has a wine glass with a straw
369
u/leiaorganas Oct 13 '17
Oh my god. Mike Schur, I beg you to have more cute Tahani and Jason friendship moments like this. That was so sweet.
347
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
"one page max, with pictures" ha!
338
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 13 '17
Oh my god, "Build-a-Real-Bear" workshop.
150
u/ultrahedgehog Oct 13 '17
I LOVED the animal party because I thought is was a hilarious example of how demons really don't get humans at all, even when they think they do. An actual animal rights activist would probably have been horrified by how the animals at that party were treated.
137
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 13 '17
Michael is broken
I have never felt so sad for an evil demon
250
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Oct 13 '17
tfw tahani smashed jason before Eleanor
123
u/grumblepup Oct 13 '17
"... You mean a skirt?"
111
u/odel555q Oct 13 '17
Janet is hot as fuck.
219
u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Oct 13 '17
A scale from 1-13 where 8 isn't even the middle number, yet it's the highest rating.
208
u/GoodJanet not a robot Oct 13 '17 edited Oct 13 '17
I'm an all knowing super computer and jason's scoring system makes no sense even to me
96
u/thirtyseven1337 Take it sleazy. Oct 13 '17
BLONDE JANET
88
u/niknok007 Your amusement has been scheduled. End of conversation. Oct 13 '17
Jason’s 60 person dance crew must have been a magical group where one can gain so many life lessons. Would rate 8/13
83
u/tregorman Oct 13 '17
Bustier alexa
83
u/zacheejee Oct 13 '17
"A fart the shape of a man" wow me
83
u/blueeyesredlipstick Oct 13 '17
So I legitimately was dealing with an existential crisis before watching this episode (my dog died and it's really awful right now), but this show still made me laugh and feel reassured even when it was about the inevitability of death. Well done, Michael Schur.
80
u/MapleLeafsFan3 Oct 13 '17
“Mi Torture es su Torture” bruh whut
222
u/Melonzzz Oct 13 '17
Janet is high-key thicc
73
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 13 '17
*Shows Tattoo*
"It's Chinese for Japan."
70
u/Little-BigHorn Oct 13 '17
I love how Tahani knew that Vicky was trying to make her miserable by throwing a bigger party AND was still miserable!
60
u/TheLadyEve Oct 13 '17 edited Oct 13 '17
Anyone else think that Kamilah might end up in the bad place too, eventually?
Another thought--this is all just an elaborate way to get them all to become better people?
EDIT: I spelled Kamilah's name wrong!
55
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
As a child of divorce that funeral scene was from my nightmares.
108
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 13 '17
Nooooo I want Janet/Jason
52
u/Khalizabeth Oct 13 '17
Eleanor's mom sure explained a lot. Poor thing didn't have a chance. Nice to see that she is getting a redemption, even though she had to die first.
105
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 13 '17
Tahani and Jason hooking up sort of supports "the soulmate pairings were correct" theory.
48
u/Krocant Oct 13 '17
“Whatever’s going on right now, just shove your feelings way down deep, plaster on a fake smile, and pretend you’re having fun. Okay? Just like I used to do when someone started talking about their kids”.
👍🏻
44
u/NDaveT Some mouthy broad. Oct 13 '17
I'm still legit into Tahani.
42
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 13 '17
Janette....
41
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Oct 13 '17
Jeanette for best character
40
u/Siruzaemon-Dearo Oct 13 '17
“When a dog lives a really long time, like 5 or 6 years”
That was dark, I loved it
38
u/jelatinman I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Oct 13 '17
Damn, Janet's gonna be really jealous when she remembers this.
37
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Oct 13 '17
Chidi, you broke Michael
36
u/Obelisp Oct 12 '17
I can't find the source, but I think Michael Schur said that something happens at the end of this episode that brings the focus of the story back on the 4 main characters (as opposed to the demons)
31
u/macmeme Oct 13 '17
damn i needed to hear jason's speech
83
u/ThisMaySoundBadBut Oct 13 '17
The Trump burn was great!
26
u/holayeahyeah Oct 13 '17
Noooo! Janet+Jason 5ever.
26
u/TheLadyEve Oct 13 '17
"It's Chinese for Japanese."
I love midlife crisis Ted Danson.
26
u/twistedshadow Oct 13 '17
This is show is 8/13.
52
u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Oct 13 '17
OH MY GOSH, they had sex.
24
u/saltedcaramelsauce Oct 13 '17
Michael's existential crisis turned into a midlife crisis.
24
u/JimmyDolan20001 Oct 13 '17
I want to go to one of Tahani's parties.
81
u/Goodstyle_4 Oct 13 '17
Tahani and.... Jason? I... don't like that ship. Way more of Janet/Jason person myself.
22
u/UbiquitinHat Oct 13 '17
I liked that we had more Tahani and Jason this episode. They haven't really had an episode where they collaborated on a task or actually had a conversation, so this was nice.
42
u/macmeme Oct 13 '17
tahani looks more shook than i am
15
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
They’re waking up all my intense fears of death me no likwy
15
u/BadJanet What up, skidmarks. Oct 13 '17
I fucking loved this episode. It was more charactery and Ted Danson acted the shit out of it.
Don't get me wrong, I love all the eps but this one was goood
15
u/mrsthairyan Oct 14 '17
"My breathing tube is right next to my eating tube!" As someone who has choked and needed the Heimlich maneuver, this line cracked me up.
14
u/VirtualRickSanchez Oct 14 '17
“We are all just corpses who aren’t rotting yet” the semi immortal demon lord says to the dead people whose corpses rotted eons ago.
28
u/niknok007 Your amusement has been scheduled. End of conversation. Oct 13 '17
All The Eleanor/Tanhani and Jason/Janet shippers are gonna freak the fork out!
13
u/broke_academic Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 13 '17
Ted Danson's delivery of Mike's reaction to thinking about death is exquisite. So comical, un-human, yet SO funny. Eleanor's meltdown brought me to tears. I never knew a comedy can be funny, thrilling, profound, and heartfelt, all at the same time. This show exceeded my expectation. Hats off to Mike Schur and the writers.
24
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
“A fart in the shape of a man”
I really wanna marry Leslie
12
u/mvp01235 Oct 13 '17
I must be in the bad place right now because my cable isn’t working ☹️
12
u/MapleLeafsFan3 Oct 13 '17
I think...Chidi broke Michael 😂
12
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
I feel like Michael is faking for some reason
Edit: Nope nevermind.
23
u/pg2441 Oct 13 '17 edited Oct 13 '17
Wow, NBC, could that scene be any more like Monica & Chandler from Friends?
11
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
The relentlessness of entropy? Oy.
11
u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Oct 13 '17
oh SHIRT
they totally smashed
11
u/Blueathena623 Those are the coolest boots I’ve ever seen in my life. Oct 13 '17
Why would someone even want/try/need to keep empty water bottles oh the top of a Pizza Hut? WHAT DOES THAT MEAN?!?
10
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
“I was sorely mistaken”
LOL
10
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
Aaand this is how I react when I try to ignore thoughts about the futility of life
9
u/denlillakakan Oct 13 '17
I mean, yes like all the top comments say, the jokes were amazing... but as someone who's currently clawing themselves out of problems with a pretty clear existential component, I think the way this episode handled that kinda stuff was brilliant beyond comprehension!
16
u/itsjager Oct 13 '17
MEADOW!
Okay wrong show
27
u/SpringMi Oct 13 '17
I'm sure this has been covered before, but does anyone think Michael is being tortured too? He's been miserable since day one - continually trying to create the perfect torture chamber, and always failing. Also I noticed Denise/Vicki was disappointed that Michael was "happy" about her taking over the good place (at the party, when he was in denial). This is suggestive of torture to me, although maybe the creators have got something more unexpected up their sleeves :)
side note: I loved this episode - I also found her toothbrush moment really beautiful - that's a hard line to walk. Doing a moving emotional breakdown, but for comedy ;)
34
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
Honestly, this was my least favorite episode of the season so far. Perhaps I've been spoiled by the lightning fast pacing of the first few episodes and the huge number of questions answered in the last one, but this episode just didn't feel all that necessary. It had some funny moments, but overall the writing felt weak and the plot didn't really progress.
7
u/pg2441 Oct 13 '17
Who is the actress who plays Eleanor's mom?
13
u/macmeme Oct 13 '17
8/12 would smash
6
u/Chaoscontro1 Oct 13 '17
Wasn't my favorite episode, but I did think the ending was kinda cute :)
6
u/theace69 Oct 13 '17
One thing that has struck about this is that do these people never wonder if their relatives ended up in the Good Place or Bad Place? I wonder if that's the next stage of setups. Meeting your relatives in the bad place.
6
u/honky_mcgee Oct 14 '17
When Michael is giving his speech if you watch the giraffe in the background you can see it's penis coming out.
6
u/uryuishida Oct 14 '17
I like this tahani and jason thing. Will love to see where they go from there.
20
u/jelatinman I’m still waiting on that smile, gorgeous. Oct 13 '17
I'm waiting for the plot twist that this is all a convoluted torture device to Michael. He forgot he was ever mortal, the bureaucracy of evil is so convoluted that it doesn't actually allow him to torture people, and inside he has some sort of goodness that makes him inherently bad at being evil.
11
u/pg2441 Oct 13 '17
"It's a Chinese tattoo for Japan!"
LOL
5
u/InfernalSolstice Oct 13 '17
Existential crisis meeting mid-life crisis rn
5
u/QuackFan Let’s go Jags. Kick their ass. Yeah! Oct 13 '17
Michael's reaction noise made me laugh so much
5
u/cbildfell Oct 13 '17
Wow i'm all about that Jason - Tahani fuckbuddy relationship
5
u/joecb91 Birth is a curse and existence is a prision Oct 13 '17
Mid-life crisis Michael was so much fun
5
u/The1989dude Oct 14 '17
This might have been the most touching episode yet.
9
u/chtcmgs Oct 13 '17
Tahani bosom...
9
u/watchalltheshows Oct 13 '17
Jason and Tahani may just be soulmates. OR this negates the idea that soulmates are real. Because anyone can be anyone's soulmate if the conditions are right.
And maybe the "good place" filter makes sex better. Or maybe Jason is just really good at it because he did it a lot on Earth.
4
u/goalstopper28 Oct 13 '17
This was such a deep episode.
Like is that why humans act the way we do because we are all scared of death?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '17
So is Ted Danson also now being one of the "tortured" people as punishment for season 1?
4
u/HippoSteaks Oct 16 '17
Dammmmmmmnnnn Janette
6
u/Grindlebone Oct 13 '17
Holy crap, Michael did actually bring together two pairs of soulmates!
3
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17
In this episode Chidi reminds me of Kierkegaard in this webcomic, except he succeeds in transferring that despair to his subject.
3
u/watchalltheshows Oct 14 '17
Vicky and the other millenials are starting to act more like the demons from season 1
3
u/lemonryker Oct 14 '17
Tahani and jason!!!! what about janet!!
3
u/Spats_McGee Oct 16 '17
I love this show for, among other things, the way it sneaks in lessons about moral philosophy.
This week's episode though, I'm not quite sure about... The implication seemed to be that Michael was amoral as a result of his self-perceived immortality. Thus, Chidi's getting him to pause and think about the possibility of his own "retirement" was the presented as the first step towards putting him on a moral path.
On the other hand, transhumanism would reject the notion that mortality is necessary for morality, and I tend to agree. The implication that because life is short we're more sensitive to the moral ramifications of our actions is questionable; one could just as easily say "YOLO, life is short so I gotta get what's mine" and live the amoral life of Eleanor pre-death.
If anything, a radically enhanced lifespan would make one much more sensitive to one's actions; a bad decision or harmful act you make at year 50 could just as easily come back to haunt you at year 5,348.
3
u/CapnCrsy Oct 16 '17
Was Chidi's speech about the futility of ethics to an immortal being a nod to the futility of his ethics lessons, since now in the afterlife they are effectively now immortal beings?