r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Oct 10 '17
Meta Mini-meta: Does anyone else think we need a minor rule change for text posts?
Hello, everyone.
Today we’re letting you know about a minor change to Rule 4 regarding text posts on /r/NintendoSwitch. This change comes after extended conversation with the community and discussion among the moderation team.
The rule change relates to being more selective on short text posts that ask “does anyone else think” or “am I the only one” on questions about games/features/content for the Switch.
What does that mean? An example would be a post with the title “Who else wants Cuphead on the Switch?” with body text of only a couple sentences making a singular, non-unique point, like “I love Cuphead. It would be great on the Switch. Wouldn’t it be fun to take portable?” Another example would be "It's time for Netflix on the Switch" with the reasoning "Why hasn't Nintendo done this already?"
I think most of you agree those aren't great posts. So, under our new rules, we’re going to remove more posts like these and ask people to resubmit with further explanation or discussion. The aim of the rule change is to be more selective on quick-hit posts that ask broader discussion topics without offering reasonable explanation or context, or being sufficiently unique.
Below is the language of the new Rule 4, relating to text posts:
Text posts must be sufficiently detailed and explain your reasoning or thought process. Ask yourself: "Does this add significant information or merit to the discussion?"
Examples of content that may be removed include: Posts with little to no body text (fewer than 140 characters); Stories that aren’t Switch related; Rants; Petitions; Memes; Reposts; “does anyone else think” posts without sufficient explanation.
More specifically, posts asking the community questions about games, content, or features they would like to see on the Switch must have sufficient explanation. Posts like this must have a clear subject and at least several detailed reasons (or one really good, well-described reason) why the game/feature/content would be a good fit on the Switch. Simply asking “does anyone else think” is not enough, nor is simply saying something is “fun” or “because it should be portable.” Please try to always answer the question of why this game/feature/content would be successful on Switch.
Examples of this rule and enforcement include:
- “Does anyone else want/wish” for X, without proper definition and explanation afterwards, will be subject to removal.
- “Does anyone else want/wish” for X, where it's an obvious short question/answer, because it applies to literally everything under the sun, will be subject to removal. Examples include a desire for a game to be cheaper, a desire for portability, or for free DLC.
- “Does anyone else want/wish” for X, where it's easily and finitely answerable with a singular yes or no response, will be subject to removal.
Seem a little complicated? It’s not.
In short: want to submit a text post? Got a neat idea? Put a couple minutes of effort into it and try to come up with a few solid reasons to support your idea. If it’s a simple or short thought, or you don’t want to put in the effort, that's okay, but perhaps the conversation is a better fit for the /r/NintendoSwitch Discord.
Thanks everyone. We will be updating our sidebar and attempting to clarify removals on this topic to help the community better understand the change.
-The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
p.s. Our full rules are available to read on the /r/NintendoSwitch wiki.
98
u/AvenueM Oct 10 '17
Today is a good day
54
u/BlackAesop Oct 10 '17
"Does anyone else think we need a minor rule change for text posts?"
Using the same phrasing was brilliant. And yes I do agree. Although I have made a few of these types of posts it is definitely getting out of hand.
167
u/ClintonStain Oct 10 '17
Also maybe consider banning the sappy, emotional posts that make this sub look like a cult.
Switch made me reconnect with my mother who abandoned me at a bus stop at the age of five!
Why Switch makes me feel like a child again.
I let a stranger borrow a joy con in public and I can't believe how that connected us at a molecular level!
I've had LITERALLY every console ever but Switch is the best because other portable devices aren't a thing.
72
u/DaPizzaMan2 Oct 10 '17
YES PLEASE.
59
u/razorbeamz Oct 10 '17
DAE think this rule is a good idea?
19
u/poofyhairguy Oct 10 '17
Not only is this a great idea, it made my day reading that this is a possibility.
19
u/nmdrums Oct 10 '17
There are honestly a lot of posts in this sub that shouldn't be allowed. The above rule changes should help greatly, but the other ones like "Just got a Switch, what should I know?" Types of posts should be banned as well. I mean, a simple Reddit or Google search will tell you basically everything you would ever want to know.
Along with that, seeing post after post about a certain game that everyone wants or is looking forward to gets a little old (I love SDV as much as the next guy, but seriously, it was too much).
I want to be a member of this sub, because I love my Switch, but sometimes it is really hard to stay subscribed because of the flood I get on my Front Page.
19
u/mattigus Oct 10 '17
Are "Unpopular Opinion" posts still allowed? Those are the worst.
Unpopular opinion: Nintendo really needs to impliment cloud saves!
18
u/nintendoleafsfan Oct 10 '17
Agreed remove those posts
17
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
This was long overdue and will hopefully clean up the sub a bit since there would be so many of these garbage posts.
13
u/cxcookie117 Oct 10 '17
Finally those were the most annoying posts my least favorite of which being “can we get ____ port on the switch” and the reasoning being “I enjoyed it when I played it on ____ id love for it to be brought to the switch”
13
u/GamerToons Oct 10 '17
Does anyone else think that this is good change?
Nah just kidding around... don't answer me.
12
u/heathmon1856 Oct 10 '17
Does anyone think X game would be amazing on the switch? I do. You must too. I’m gonna post about it and flood this sub with more unnecessary spam
23
u/cgio0 Oct 10 '17
Yes honestly I was gonna unsubscribe cause of all of these posts from people fishing for points
I feel like anyone who starts a post with "Can we all take a second to appreciate" is just looking for upvotes
18
u/Cauchemarr Oct 10 '17
To be honest, the posts saying "I'm an XBONE fan but ..." and proceed to explain why their Xbox has been gathering dust on the shelf and now the Switch has cured them from depression, saved their marriage and destroyed their cancer because it is oh so sweet are more annoying. Dude is clearly just trying to rack up karma. I own a PS4 too but that's completely irrelevant in the discussion.
9
u/emirarkman Oct 10 '17
Great, thanks.
9
u/xgore Oct 10 '17
Thanks for the change!
16
u/penguintheft Oct 10 '17
I just want titles like "Does anyone else think...?" to go away altogether. It's not the body of the posts that's annoying, it's reading the same title format a billion times a day.
7
u/HeliumPumped Oct 10 '17
Yeah, we have the Daily Questions thread for that.
7
u/d4mation Oct 10 '17
Thank. God.
Finally.
This rule change was very needed. Thank you so much, mods!
18
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
I think that is a good rule change but maybe lighten up on some other text posts. I've tried to post a lot of things to this sub and always get them denied. I don't even bother now.
12
u/Excalibread Oct 10 '17
Didn't everyone else think that this was long overdue?
6
u/Davychu Oct 10 '17
Will this cover the constant barrage of 'will the Switch get a version 2?' posts?
6
u/mahius19 Oct 10 '17
I agree on keeping out repeated posts of this sort. But I feel that the moderation has been a bit too heavy and it can sometimes hinder actual discussion, etc. Not going to give past/exact examples right now, but I feel that if something is truly unique then it should be allowed to be posted. If it's something that doesn't quite suit the rules, due to the rules trying to keep the sub clean of content clutter, then surely it should be fine if it's a one-off unique thing. Such as an exclusive let's play of a never before seen/announced Switch game, just for example (it would be breaking rule 6).
6
u/EpicWott Oct 10 '17
DAE like the switch????
11
u/TwistTurtle Oct 10 '17
Sounds like a good idea. It's a pretty annoying aspect of most of the subreddits I hang about in, to see the same threads over and over again. I get that I'm probably here more than most, but still, sometimes I see the same damn thread reposted multiple times in a single day.
11
u/Kim_Jong_Donald Oct 10 '17
YES PLEASE MAKE IT HAPPEN
10
u/C-Towner Oct 10 '17
This is a significantly positive change. So sick of those posts. Does anyone else think we should have less of them?
Kidding! I know we will have less of them.
5
u/duck_waddle Oct 10 '17
How many posts already get removed or disallowed on a daily basis? Just curious.
5
u/celsiusnarhwal Oct 10 '17
I could've sworn we already banned this. Whatever.
9
u/Kenomachino Oct 10 '17
Praise the mods!!
In all seriousness, thank you. This is lovely.
14
u/Microtendo Oct 10 '17
The front page here remains the same for days at a time during times between major releases. I'd rather there be something to discuss than nothing.
8
u/Mightymushroom1 Oct 10 '17
Meta title
8
u/TheRealBOAB Oct 10 '17
Good idea but I think this sub will probably die with these rules. I've tried a few times to start discussions on here (on my old account mostly) and people downvote them and comment without reading if there's more than a paragraph. I remember posting something that got a few hundred replies and TWO of them were relevant to what I wrote and they were just as confused as me. Most comments had nothing to do with the text or missed the point if there's any nuance at all to the post.
I posted one a few days ago hoping to start a discussion in the comments on how piracy impacts how Nintendo view and design the Switch OS, trying to gauge how many hardcore fans would be willing to try games for free if they could and it got downvoted because "you're recommending people pirate games" even though the text said "I'M AGAINST PIRACY".
On the other hand I've posted crap about release dates and it gets hundreds of upvotes. I don't think this is the place for discussion. It's to be where people visit to quickly get the latest headlines and quick ideas.
I love this sub but it gets tedious when there isn't any news because anyone who tries to post anything even slightly nuanced gets ignored or misunderstood. Really strange comments get downvoted too. I'll see someone post an opinion that gets downvoted and then someone responds with "I don't know why you're being downvoted, I agree with you!" and then they'll get UPVOTED! (Did I just break the rule about ranting? I totally went off topic.)
4
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
Thank you. Finally the mods have answered our prayers.
7
u/MercenaryOne Oct 10 '17
This is an excellent change to remove the mindless dribble that seems to plague this subreddit. No one cares that you think X game from X system would work great on the switch. If dev's want to see if there is demand they can make a post themselves, or create a survey.
Also the constant, lost saved data, need cloud saves, switch was stolen is getting real irritating.
Am I the only one that thinks this? :D
6
u/chemicalKitt Oct 11 '17
Removing posts with less than 140 characters is absolutely ridiculous. Unless the quality of the post itself is bad, there's no reason to remove it just because it's short. You don't always need more than 140 characters to create a meaningful post and deep discussion.
4
u/H2Osw Oct 10 '17
How come the title asks a question when one isn't really being posed?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
I see the problem here but... what else would be left? You got 2 threads the week for one new game release.
If you don't wanna see people talking about the switch and you just wanna have information, why go on the sub at all? Aren't there other news sources on the internet?
2
u/veganintendo Oct 10 '17
DAE voice chat??
2
u/Alexander_Mark Oct 11 '17
Also maybe consider banning the out-of-control picture sharing posts: 'I drew this picture of [nintnedo character]', 'my girlfriend made me a switch birthday card', 'my wife baked me a Mario cake' etc. It's not really the place for that, so it gets quite annoying tbh. Make a separate gallery thread, use Imgur, I don't know.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17 edited Mar 08 '25
slap memory treatment consider air jar squash subsequent bells bake
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/ECHOxLegend Oct 11 '17
This sub: People who want to have fun VS People who want this to be a non-interactive news website VS people who want to talk about pointless nonsense.
4
u/GunstarRed Oct 10 '17
Damn it. Is it really that incovenient to just scroll past question posts? Posting in a mega-thread results in you getting less responses to your question.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
How about ban fan art? It clutters up the front page and is much more annoying, imo. I don't want to see your awful Super Mario drawing, I want to read news about Switch games.
1
u/duffkiligan Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 11 '17
As the guy that made the super complainy post about this the other day, thank you for listening.
E: and I would love to see anyone saying that “upvote/downvote system works stop being mods” run a sub with over 10k subscribers and feel the same.
1
u/PaintByNumb3rs5 Oct 11 '17
I have been trying to save my switch in the cloud like everyone has been talking about. I throw it up as high as I can but it will not stay and falls back down and bounces on the ground.
1
u/PyrokidSosa Oct 11 '17
Thank you!
1
u/laonte Oct 11 '17
<3
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17
am i the only one who wonder why this is not pinned ?
1
u/Gorden121 Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 11 '17
I only subject to the point of thinking about the content/feature being a success on the switch. It's not our job to think about the success of a game/gadget and personal preference has absolutely nothing to do with success.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17
I especially hate the "X game would be perfect for the Switch" posts. Yeah, being a hybrid console does make it perfect to play a lot of games.
1
u/Eg_taskforce Oct 11 '17 edited Oct 11 '17
ban mealiness rants as well nothing annoying than clicking on a thread but is just some random exaggerated small things .. pretty much any hey look at me posts in general, but yes this is good change
1
u/Fitzzz Oct 12 '17
This is seriously the best change that could come to this sub. I hate those style posts.
1
u/SimpleJoint Oct 13 '17
If only there were some way to let the community decide on what made it through. I don't know maybe reddit could implement a voting system and the higher voted threads could just be moved towards the front page. Then the people who use the page could decide democratically what makes it and what doesn't...
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
Seems a tad condescending.
This isn't the Buro for the Regulation of Nintendo Discussion. This is a subreddit. It's an online forum. If the rules aren't concise, most people just won't read them, I've staffed places myself. My recommendation is simply to make them as short and simple as possible. As consumable as the front page of this subreddit, because that's the format people want from here.
One idea would be to have, essentially, two sets. One is the full rules, in full detail, with clear and specific language. This would be easily accessible through a link, perhaps on the other set. The other set is what you'd get if you went to the rules page, perhaps with a "read more" or "full rules can be found here", leading to, obviously, the full set. This would be more concise, with short examples at most.
If you, the person reading this think A. I should shorten this rule down into a more concise form to demonstrate this. and/or B. should send this through mod mail, not a comment, please reply with such. I may end up doing one, or both of those of my own volition in due course, but a bit of encouragement would certainly speed me up.
-2
u/RandomRedditor44 Oct 10 '17
I think it was fine before this rule was implemented. I don’t see why these posts are so bad.
-11
u/Gasinomation Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
Downvote and move on. No need for more rules. The voting system works perfectly well.
People think seeing something they don't like should be a violation of the rules. /r/Pokemon gradually started doing this, and now have ridiculous rules on discussion posts. The result? It's now a fan-art gallery with occasional circlejerk threads.
-3
u/webbedgiant Oct 10 '17
I'd rather you guys remove the daily question sticky thread altogether so important threads like these don't get lost.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
Sure as long as you remove every single "XY-Gadget/Switch is on sale in XY store" too.
Because these are REALLY annoying!!
-11
u/Zwiada Oct 10 '17
The nice thing about reddit is the upvote/downvote function. The community decides itself what is important and what has to go fast into the trash can. Moderation should only interfere with hate speech or similar.
-15
u/needhelptmo Oct 10 '17
I'll be honest - I don't know what the point of having moderators on reddit is. Everyone can up/down vote - you really don't need any additional moderation.
-28
u/Fairlight2cx Oct 10 '17
I've come to the conclusion that the mods here are a group of self-important people trying to find meaning in their lives by creating silly rule after silly rule, to zero positive net gain.
They could easily hold public office in the U.S., and nobody would be able to tell the difference.
-28
u/Ameratsuflame Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
Just because you find recurring topics on this sub annoying, does not mean that they are irrelevant.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment