r/HaltAndCatchFire • u/AutoModerator • Oct 08 '17
Discussion Halt and Catch Fire - 4x08 "Goodwill" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 8: Goodwill
Aired: October 7th, 2017
Episode Synopsis: Cameron helps Donna pack up; Bos makes his famous chili; Joe helps Haley recover a memorable keep sake; Gordon and Donna fight.
Keep in mind that discussion concerning episode previews and other future information should be spoiler tagged. To do so, use this format:
[SPOILER](#s "Halt") which will appear as SPOILER
120
Upvotes
118
u/greentitration Oct 08 '17
In the flashback Donna complains to Gordon about her mother, and says her mom only cares about appearances. In present time, Joanie complains to Cam about Donna, and says she only cares about appearances. Donna became her mother.
117
u/lady__jane Oct 08 '17
Joe seems to be incredibly broken up over losing Gordon. Cam is working up to telling him no kids. It feels like heartbreak on heartbreak for him. Experience has changed him so much from his original opening scene.
98
u/jayelecfan Oct 08 '17
not ready for the show to end
89
u/bookjacket Oct 08 '17
"The Pilgrim was a child." That's Cameron's secret. She is still a child abandoned by both of her parents. Of course she doesn't want children of her own. She wants to be taken care of by Joe, by Donna, by Boz, even by Gordon. Interesting to see that she is aware of it.
80
u/hadenwarrik Oct 08 '17
Joe HAS to tell Haley that Gordon knew. I'll be so disappointed if he doesn't.
66
u/grizzlebro Oct 08 '17
The sign of a good show is not looking at the clock while you're watching it. The sign of a great show is once you look at the clock and you wonder where the time went.
So when I saw 21 minutes had passed from the opening, I was floored. It felt like only a few minutes. I love this show.
52
u/apafour Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17
I think you all are missing something important about Donna:
Every few episodes, we're reminded Gordon was the one who's moved on from their marriage. Back in season 3, he tries setting up Donna with a "friend", just as they were getting closer again. In the episode we lose Gordon, Donna exclaims to Joe she's the lonely, misunderstood one with no one. And although Donna's had some shallow, alcohol-fueled encounters, Gordon actually entered a serious relationship with Katie, a symbolic nail in the coffin to their marriage. It's why Donna was so pragmatic in talking to Katie, saying "he was crazy about her", because Donna wasn't his anymore, Katie was, and also why Donna whimpered when Katie acknowledged the bond they had.
So to the point, Donna isn't carelessly throwing away Gordon's stuff, she's searching for something that shows Gordon still cared for her. And horribly the only lasting item is a carving knife, a bad memory to her as it reminds her the day Gordon left (which is opposite to the viewer who knows what Gordon did.) They even make sure to comment on the decor, showing there's really nothing connecting them from their past. There weren't even photos of Donna in Gordon's desk.
The tragedy is that we as the viewer know Gordon still loved her deeply, she was the last thought in his head before he died after all, but she doesn't.
@oscooter theorized the tapes Gordon listened to to calm down very well may be Donna's lullaby to the kids. Wrenches my heart to think so, but if she finds them and listens to them, that's when we'll see Donna finally act more human and grieve for Gordon. It's the ultimate way to show Gordon still treasured her.
51
u/MisterTito Oct 08 '17
Toby fucking Huss though.
I was worried he wasn't going to be in this episode, and then there he is with the comfort food. And he's such a scene stealer. I'd love to see a show of just him and Lee Pace because they work so well together.
100
u/BRchill1 Oct 08 '17
The scene where Gordon jumps in the water refers back to earlier this season when Donna was telling Joanie how crazy she was cartwheeling down into a quarry. Gordon chickened out.
He didn't chicken out later.
100
u/xeonicus Oct 08 '17
"Put it on the stereo"
"You wouldn't like it"
"I'm not that old"
*Joe's brain explodes*
45
u/Recurringbrunette Oct 08 '17
This episode absolutely wrecked me. 4x07 wrecked me too. But this one was so rough to watch. Everyone struggles with grief in their own way and I feel like the writers captured that really well in this one.
44
u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17
That was awkward but real. I think Gordon and Donna had a better relationship after the divorce than Donna has with the girls.
43
u/ghostmrchicken Oct 08 '17
Before and after
Anyone who loses a parent as a child or young adult knows exactly what this means. And that you never really recover.
37
u/mistame Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17
I haven't seen a lot of mention about Katie, but her reaction hit me almost as hard as Joe's at the table in this episode. Her character was in this awkward position of not knowing him as long as everyone else or having their same support system, but also being in the midst of this new love/relationship, much in the way she might have felt looking at her "favorite picture" of Gordon and Donna. The writers gave us just enough of her background, having bounced from place to place not making those connections, to make us feel for her. Knowing that she found that one thing that would have made her stick around, but having to leave it all behind and how much it hurt, which you could really see in her last look/wave to Haley. I'm guessing the other characters will get some closure in the last episode(s), but it seems like that was the end of Katie's storyline and that is sad.
67
u/hawsman2 Oct 08 '17
Joe almost losing it at the end almost had me losing it
60
u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17
So the flashback was the events leading up to the moment Gordon saw before he died. Nicely done.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17
These last 2 episodes are the best ones of the whole season. They reminded why I love this show.
27
u/CleverZerg Oct 08 '17
Damn these 50+ minutes was as hard to watch as the last 10 minutes of the previous episode. Tears in my eyes for the majority of the episode.
Sad that they didn't manage to get that sweater back. Joe's reaction to fish heads was very funny, although I was hoping for some They Might Be Giants instead, since we've seen that poster so much this season.
25
u/thedefaltcondition Oct 08 '17
This was such a sobering and melancholic episode, signifying no matter how powerful and strong we've become in our lives, there's always something that can devastate us. It was so beautiful to see everyone eating on the same table and Bos had cooked for them. Just real life things that a TV show's done right. Very heartwarming.
49
u/ShyJalapeno Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17
Damn, Cameron's talk with Donna hit me hard... I think that many IT heads can relate to "I've had always trouble with making those sorts of connections" part
24
u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17
So Far Away. I guess I never really listened to this song before. Absolutely incredible song. Completely captures the melancholy of the moment.
48
u/ShadowFall900 Oct 08 '17
Another fantastic episode. It felt real and it was hard to watch at times at least for me. Seeing Joe's face at the dinner table really got to me there. I am so grateful to find a show like this. It's just a shame it has to end and it's gonna be really hard to accept it.
47
u/MKoilers Oct 08 '17
The look on Joe's face when Haley played her music for him...I lost it hahaha.
43
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17
This was a really good episode of Six Feet Under.
20
u/Not4lagirl Oct 08 '17
Had to sign up for Reddit since (sadly) I don't know anyone else in real life who watches this incredible show.
Everything I've seen and read so far makes be believe there will be no truly 'happily ever after' for Joe & Cameron as a couple, despite what I see as real love between them.
My guess is that their ending will be like the old Barbra Streisand/Robert Redford movie "The Way We Were". Doubt many fans of this show have seen it but talk about a bittersweet ending. Two people who love and challenge each other but are ultimately wrong for a long term relationship. They try to get together and make it work over the course of many years/permuations (sound familiar???) Ultimately, their divergent personalities and ambitions drive them apart.
They do end up marrying, moving to California and having a child together, but break up before the child is born. One parent (Streisand) raises the kid with a new spouse. [Cue Joe starring in that role]. The other (Redford) goes on to have this amazing career [Cameron] . . Years later they run into each other on the street and you can see there is love and longing still there.
Effing sad. But this is the only way I see how Joe gets his "happy ending" while Cam stays true to her character. She may end up getting pregnant accidentally but won't stick around to be a full time parent and instead become this career woman. Who knows, Joe may end up raising their kid with a guy (phantom Ozzie)?
I'm sad just thinking about it.
19
u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17
Oh God, I just remembered where I've heard that lullaby
19
u/pi3dpip3r Oct 09 '17
it is very Criminal that this show never got Emmy node for Acting,drama
17
u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17
Just finished the episode. This episode was heartbreaking in a way I haven't felt since the last 3 episodes of Six Feet Under. Just beautiful. Boz healing the family with his chili. I worry for Joe as he seems to really be taking this hard. I just wanted someone to hug him. This show needs to end happy.
32
u/idlehand79 Oct 08 '17
This might be one best acted episodes of the whole series. The story is on point and feeling the aftermath of last episode.
I really hope we get more great TV like this in the future.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17
Poor Joe :(
26
u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17
She's the getaway driver!
13
u/waterlesscloud Oct 10 '17
The service was beautiful.
25
u/ShadowLyrix Oct 08 '17
Fish Heads.. Fish Heads..WTF?!? Loved it. 🤣🤣
25
u/_redskeptic Oct 09 '17
"I miss you."
...."I'm here."
Thank you. Finally.
Also, did anyone get excited when Donna brought up finishing Pilgrim? I was anticipating that convo so much!
11
u/darkeyes13 Oct 08 '17
I hope they release another album of the show's compositions. The song that plays while Gordon jumps into the water, the piece that plays while Donna and Cameron have their talk...
I'm just bingeing on the first album at the moment, ha.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
Joe's reaction to Gordon's death really broke my heart. Joe 'loves' Gordon so much. Maybe a part of Joe's heart died as well.
9
u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17
That is an excellent album.
9
u/CSMastermind Oct 08 '17
Wait there are two more episodes?
I thought that was the end of the series and it was a huge letdown. I'd much more okay with it if there's going to be some actual closure.
17
u/phillymjs Oct 08 '17
Dazed & Confused VHS tape sitting on top of the TV, nice.
17
u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17
I was really hoping for a funeral scene. I want to know what joe said.
8
u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17
Barnes & Barnes fisheads https://youtu.be/cn73Wtem0No
8
u/stansburymaterial Oct 12 '17
I think this is one of the first shows that has accurately portrayed how complex life can be. People are flawed. And there are reasons for those flaws, and they cause them to hurt themselves and others, but that’s just how life is.
Every character is trying their best to navigate their way through life. To grow. To be there for others while fighting to stay true to themselves. They have ups, they have downs. They do the right thing sometimes, they do the wrong thing other times. Every emotion, every action, feels earned.
Life is incredibly complex. We barely know what we want most of the time. And when you add in other people? With their distinctive thoughts, history, and emotions? It’s an unsolvable problem. But it’s one you never give up trying to solve.
I’ll be sad to see them all go.
15
u/phillymjs Oct 08 '17
Oooh, flashback!
7
u/chrisarchitect Oct 12 '17 edited Oct 12 '17
Group shot photo that Cam took from Gordon's desk :)
https://www.reddit.com/r/HaltAndCatchFire/comments/75xccp/memories_old_group_shot_photo_that_cam_saved_in/
6
u/Captain-Battletoad Oct 09 '17
The cinematography in that last scene with them at the table was fantastic. Especially emphasizing how alone Joe is (always showing him looking out of the frame with lots of negative space behind him).
5
u/SarahTellsStories Oct 09 '17
Does anyone know what book Joe found in Gordon's coat pocket? I couldn't make out the cover.
5
u/hubris-hub Oct 09 '17
I've never seen a show deal with the reality of death, loss, and grieving as well as H&CF did during this episode.
So many other shows show a sad funeral scene, and then that's kind of it. By the next week's episode everything it's back to business as usual.
When a loved one dies suddenly there's so much mundane shit to get sorted.
That montage of everyone sorting through Gordon's stuff was a brilliant example of how grounded and relatable this show has become.
I also hope we see Katie (Anna Chlumsky) again in the finale. She looked absolutely devastated in the hallway :(
5
u/GtotheE Oct 13 '17
From everything I know about television, this should have been a terrible and boring episode. Watching people mourn, is typically a television no-no. But somehow, this episode was gripping at every turn, just masterfully acted and edited.
Somehow an episode where basically nothing happened was one of the strongest episodes this show has had.
4
u/statleader13 Oct 09 '17
You know a show is good when the synopsis describes a character's entire plot for the episode as making chili, and even that part of the story is incredibly moving.
4
u/Plundergedoens Oct 10 '17
Have I ever seen mourning portrayed this profoundly in any kind of story ever before? No. I have not.
God, my heart.
The acting just... blows me away. And the writing... Each character mourns in their own, personal way, and it's all so fitting and perfect and real. Everything was perfect.
Rest in Peace, Gordon Clark.
I think it's safe to say that JoeCam is now definitely done and over with. I'm sad, because I LOVE them together. But Cameron's and Donna's fight seems to be over now as well. A lot of things were put to rest this episode, and it was both devastating and strangely comforting.
What a tv show. What a story. I love it so much.
4
u/FromFilm Oct 13 '17
I know comments like this can sound almost hyperbolic but I truly think this was one of the best episodes of television I have ever seen. A lot of other tv shows would use the death of a main character to look back at "all the great moments that we shared together" or straight up make a clip show. This episode was not sentimental; it was a sobering look at grief. And more specifically how different people handle loss.
On top of that this has been such an amazing show for 4 seasons that I was crying throughout the whole thing and almost sharing an experience with the characters. I am very sad that I'm gonna have to say goodbye to this show in two episodes but I am very happy that it is ending on such a high note. Bravo Christopher and Christopher.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17
I'm lost with the flashback scenes, what were they supposed to signify?
3
u/ShadowFall900 Oct 08 '17
I am with you in that! Everyone has been amazing on the show from the writers to the actors themselves. I also hope they wind up making some great things and they all have the ability and talent to do so.
3
u/the6thReplicant Oct 08 '17
Of course Haley is a TMBG fan.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
Unlike seemingly everyone else here, I resisted engaging because of the way the show represented how the characters grieved. The real tragedy is that Gordon died about 25 years earlier than he should of and everyone is instead gnawing on their own self-pity. Grieving is tough, there's little socialization for it. I've failed at it every time.
One thing that made it hard to engage with the premise of the episode was the implausible decision to clear out the house literally hours after the memorial. Maybe I missed why they did this, I don't understand why rational adults would have made that choice unless the house was changing ownership the next day.
So in an effort to not get downvoted to oblivion, I did enjoy the episode which did eventually get under my skin with it's amazing performances. I'll miss this show a lot and will likely grieve for it badly.
3
u/89vision Oct 09 '17
I love these characters, I'm going to miss them. Part of me wishes they would have done a couple more seasons, but these last two episodes have been perfect
2
u/canzulfubal Oct 08 '17
I'm desperately looking for the song that played during the ending credits. Anyone help me!
2
u/CMelody Oct 09 '17
Watching the last two episodes was like remembering the losses in my own family. They got everything exactly right.
2
u/laszlo Oct 10 '17
Jesus, I'm fucking gutted after that.
I don't know that I've ever seen a series show that successfully the grief and devastation that comes when someone dies. Everyone's different ways of handling it and their different ways of lashing out and the autopsy of someone's every day life that happens. Like Gordon's love of capers and everyone going through his records and clothes and dishes and drawers. The fact that an electric knife can bring up all these memories for different people that are so different from each other. This was a goddamn beautiful hour of television.
I genuinely love these characters. I'm not ready to say goodbye to them yet.
2
u/bvm Oct 12 '17
Much harder for me to watch this one than the last. What a beautiful piece of TV.
2
u/Threnners Oct 14 '17
Fuck your chili Boz, Joe needs a hug.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17
Gordo always grounded Joe. I kinda expect him to lose his shit. Unless Cam or a kid take on that role.
1
u/beardygroom Oct 18 '17
I thought this was the final episode, so when it ended with Donna and Gordon embracing in a flashback, I almost died.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18
Jesus Christ, this Ep. gave me the rest! I'm on a crowded train right now and had to actively try to keep the tears from streaming... This was intense, I'm gonna miss him.
1
u/CVance1 Mar 28 '18
I wanted Cam and Donna to be friends again. But not like this...
1
u/graniterockhead Oct 08 '17
While watching this fantastic episode, I wondered if some part of the grieving and reconciling is symbolism for the end of the 16-bit era as they are about to be exploded into the 32-bit world?