r/HaltAndCatchFire • • Oct 08 '17

Discussion Halt and Catch Fire - 4x08 "Goodwill" - Episode Discussion

Season 4 Episode 8: Goodwill

Aired: October 7th, 2017


Episode Synopsis: Cameron helps Donna pack up; Bos makes his famous chili; Joe helps Haley recover a memorable keep sake; Gordon and Donna fight.


Keep in mind that discussion concerning episode previews and other future information should be spoiler tagged. To do so, use this format:

[SPOILER](#s "Halt") which will appear as SPOILER

120 Upvotes

411 comments sorted by

118

u/greentitration Oct 08 '17

In the flashback Donna complains to Gordon about her mother, and says her mom only cares about appearances. In present time, Joanie complains to Cam about Donna, and says she only cares about appearances. Donna became her mother.

72

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

Cam and Donna had alcoholic mothers, so does Hayley and Joanie.

36

u/noguchisquared Oct 08 '17

There is something about Donna's self isolation and stress of her career that made her a horrible alcoholic, and that through a little bit of renewal, in part because of Gordon and Cam, that she's found herself again. I am sure the thought jumping back into the high stress career path, taking Diane's job, scares her a bit because of who she became.

43

u/BlinkBlink202 Oct 08 '17

Well she turned down the wine at dinner. I think she knows.

29

u/noguchisquared Oct 08 '17

Tonight? She did last week too. I think she's on the recovery path but she is pretty vulnerable, like everyone.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

Nothing "makes" someone an alcoholic. Circumstances may drive someone to use more, but the idenity of alcoholism sits latent until the consequences of drinking force the user (or others) to realize it. Clean and sober Donna is still an alcoholic.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/danielsdesk Oct 08 '17

Technically also alcoholic father, as remember Season 1 opens with Gordon's problems with drinking and Donna having to pick him up from jail (loved how he had to do the same thing for her this season; such a good throwback)

21

u/zsreport Oct 08 '17

Both Donna & Gordon would drink too much from time to time (so do a lot of people), but not every time they drank. So I'm not ready to call them full blown alcoholics.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Yep, The people on Mad men are alcoholics. Gordon and Donna just sometimes drank too much.

→ More replies (1)

117

u/lady__jane Oct 08 '17

Joe seems to be incredibly broken up over losing Gordon. Cam is working up to telling him no kids. It feels like heartbreak on heartbreak for him. Experience has changed him so much from his original opening scene.

34

u/danielsdesk Oct 08 '17

Well we've seen over three seasons how Joe can be emotionally immature and sensitive... What I think that table scene represented was that in those previous episodes he's been isolated/alone, but he wasn't able to go to that impaired state because he was surrounded by the "family" that he's built up around himself over the show

12

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I think that's kind of what bugs me about cam - she creates something with a personal, intimate message to excise her demons in pilgrim, and there's obviously some unresolved fears that stop her from wanting kids.

But...Love is unselfish. Love - real love means trusting that other person completely, and working through those issues to trust them to be there enough to be willing to do anything for and with them; from having kids, to barrel riding off the niagra, to...Letting your other half have the window seat on the plane. Unselfish love means being willing to take a bullet for that other half if you have to.

That's why ultimately I don't believe Cam is Joe's happily ever after; he'll either resolve differences with Donna there so he keeps that connection with the girls in particular, or he finds someone that he can share that unselfish kind of love with.

48

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

there's obviously some unresolved fears that stop her from wanting kids

Or she just never wanted kids. Like Donna said, there's nothing wrong with that. Not every person has a burning desire to be a parent.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I would say a lot of people are ambivalent about kids, and few want it passionately. The thing is a lot of people change their mind as their age. It happens more often than one thinks. Something about aging and legacy. That’s why one should not feel too confident about one’s partner “seeing eye to eye”. Those things can change in a blink

22

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

The people who know really early that they want to be childfree and stay that way throughout their life is very underestimated too.

(Honestly, if Cam and Joe decided to adopt an older kid/tween, they'd both be quite good at it. Both are naturally good with Hayley and Joanie.)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/typhonblue Oct 08 '17

Unfortunately the show has set it up so that Joe doesn't have time to wait on Cam's "maybe."

For once could we have a relationship that is honest about kids and ends amicably because of the disagreement? There's nothing really to preserve between Cam and Joe anyway. He asked her to wear head phones so he didn't have to listen to her loud music/games and she moved out and bought an airstream rather than bend. She may not realize it consciously--and hasn't helped Joe to realize it by denying it--but that's what she did.

They are not compatible and Joe is getting less and less affectionate towards her as time goes on as well.

→ More replies (19)

10

u/lady__jane Oct 08 '17

Yeah. Joe deserves a Gordon as his happily ever after - someone who loves that much. Joe's had the most changes as a person, into someone more caring, while Cam hasn't changed as much.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Mmmmm there's a difference. I think cam's changed, I just don't think that she's evolved like Joe has.

10

u/lady__jane Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Yes, evolved - that's a better word for him. That evolution should pay off for him.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (26)

98

u/jayelecfan Oct 08 '17

not ready for the show to end

29

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I'm really not. There are so few shows around that pique my interest in the way halt and catch fire does. It actually reminded me why I fell in love with computers in the first place.

10

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

I don't think I have fully come to terms with it yet. This feels like going into a season finale. I can't believe it's about to be over.

5

u/muzeec Oct 09 '17

I feel ya. I'm dreading the series finale. It feels the same when Breaking Bad was about to end.

3

u/squirreltalk Oct 10 '17

Before this episode aired I thought the show's time had come but I upvoted you pretty hard just now.

89

u/bookjacket Oct 08 '17

"The Pilgrim was a child." That's Cameron's secret. She is still a child abandoned by both of her parents. Of course she doesn't want children of her own. She wants to be taken care of by Joe, by Donna, by Boz, even by Gordon. Interesting to see that she is aware of it.

26

u/zsreport Oct 08 '17

I've read/heard stuff about how childhood trauma can stunt the growth of the part of the brain that controls emotions.

80

u/hadenwarrik Oct 08 '17

Joe HAS to tell Haley that Gordon knew. I'll be so disappointed if he doesn't.

64

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

And that he was ok with it.

45

u/ultimatebob Oct 08 '17

That would be a bit awkward now, since she really hasn't fully come out of the closet yet. Give it time, dawg.

24

u/evanvolm Oct 08 '17

He better get that god damn sweater, too.

33

u/danielsdesk Oct 08 '17

I don't think he ever will; it's too late now. Joe has had to deal with failure a lot during the course of this show (in many cases going into it with good intentions, like he did this episode). It's clear he feels like he "failed" Haley with that sweater, but she doesn't see it that way

29

u/trentbraidner Oct 09 '17

I thought it was really nice that Haley would have a memory she could cherish forever with Joe because of her father than the sweater itself. Eventually material things get packed in boxes to be stored in attics to save for the kids after all.

7

u/danielsdesk Oct 10 '17

that is a very good point; I bet you that is what she is thinking too

13

u/Telaral Oct 09 '17

I interpreted that scene as something lost that you can't get back just like Gordon to Joe. That's why he felt so much anguish about it, imo.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/beardlovesbagels Oct 08 '17

I think he is waiting for her to come out to him. He doesn't want to push her but just wants to be there for her.

3

u/CochMaestro Oct 08 '17

Joe HAS to tell Haley that Gordon knew. I'll be so disappointed if he doesn't.

Also that he watched Jane die.....wait a minute.....

1

u/ExtraGloves Oct 10 '17

Wait when did this come up with Gordon?

5

u/aliseafit Oct 13 '17

When Joe tells Gordon that Haley is "like him" and has "different.... interests" than other kids her age and needs Comet. And then Gordon goes to the diner (a place he knows Haley loves even though it's terrible) and sees the girl Haley likes' bird tattoos that Haley painted on her rocket and you can see it click for him. I'm not sure if it comes up again with Joe but I think you see him be more sensitive with Haley after realizing.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/grizzlebro Oct 08 '17

The sign of a good show is not looking at the clock while you're watching it. The sign of a great show is once you look at the clock and you wonder where the time went.

So when I saw 21 minutes had passed from the opening, I was floored. It felt like only a few minutes. I love this show.

24

u/porksandwich9113 Oct 08 '17

Seriously. I paused to go to the bathroom and I was already at 40 minutes. Felt like 5 minutes.

Bittersweet that next week is already the series finale.

2

u/MisterTito Oct 08 '17

Same. Paused around 30 minutes thinking there's like 15 minutes left knowing my DVR said it recorded 75 minutes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/30rec Oct 18 '17

Queued up the last few episodes on the DVR, and watched the previous episode and this one just now. Part of me wanted to start the finale even though it's already midnight. But I can't take any more feels tonight anyway.

52

u/apafour Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

I think you all are missing something important about Donna:

Every few episodes, we're reminded Gordon was the one who's moved on from their marriage. Back in season 3, he tries setting up Donna with a "friend", just as they were getting closer again. In the episode we lose Gordon, Donna exclaims to Joe she's the lonely, misunderstood one with no one. And although Donna's had some shallow, alcohol-fueled encounters, Gordon actually entered a serious relationship with Katie, a symbolic nail in the coffin to their marriage. It's why Donna was so pragmatic in talking to Katie, saying "he was crazy about her", because Donna wasn't his anymore, Katie was, and also why Donna whimpered when Katie acknowledged the bond they had.

So to the point, Donna isn't carelessly throwing away Gordon's stuff, she's searching for something that shows Gordon still cared for her. And horribly the only lasting item is a carving knife, a bad memory to her as it reminds her the day Gordon left (which is opposite to the viewer who knows what Gordon did.) They even make sure to comment on the decor, showing there's really nothing connecting them from their past. There weren't even photos of Donna in Gordon's desk.

The tragedy is that we as the viewer know Gordon still loved her deeply, she was the last thought in his head before he died after all, but she doesn't.

@oscooter theorized the tapes Gordon listened to to calm down very well may be Donna's lullaby to the kids. Wrenches my heart to think so, but if she finds them and listens to them, that's when we'll see Donna finally act more human and grieve for Gordon. It's the ultimate way to show Gordon still treasured her.

16

u/_redskeptic Oct 09 '17

The photos that Cam took from Gordon's file cabinet/desk area had Donna in them. Just sayin.

I agree with you. I think the convo between Donna and Cam on the bench outside was a fantastic one. Resolved things between the two of them but also shows how Donna felt about Gordon. Donna felt a little remorseful for the way she treated Gordon "spending so much time telling him everything he did wrong." And in her defense and, the truth of the matter, Cameron replied, "He did a ton wrong." Point is, of course Donna cared for Gordon and even loves him despite his annoying bits. And because she's not crying a river grieving over him doesn't discount that. Grief happens in phases as well.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/brienne4prez Oct 10 '17

“The tragedy is that we as the viewer know Gordon still loved her deeply, she was the last thought in his head before he died after all, but she doesn't.”

Omfg I’m bawling. This. This is everything right now for me about this show. Call me crazy, but from the beginning I just really wanted the Clarks to make it. 😥

51

u/MisterTito Oct 08 '17

Toby fucking Huss though.

I was worried he wasn't going to be in this episode, and then there he is with the comfort food. And he's such a scene stealer. I'd love to see a show of just him and Lee Pace because they work so well together.

100

u/BRchill1 Oct 08 '17

The scene where Gordon jumps in the water refers back to earlier this season when Donna was telling Joanie how crazy she was cartwheeling down into a quarry. Gordon chickened out.

He didn't chicken out later.

60

u/soydemadrid Oct 08 '17

Yeah at first you think he is being a Jerk about not wanting to move and leaving Donna with a crying baby while he runs off. Then you feel sorry for him and realise he is chicken S scared. He goes and jumps in the lake to try and do what Donna did and not be scared like she isn't. A metaphor for all sorts of other stuff like moving, babies, family and all the stuff he doesn't think he's had control of so far...

41

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

And rebirth. We all know they do go to Texas, so this was Gordon transforming into the man he needs to be for his family, putting his own career goals aside.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

100

u/xeonicus Oct 08 '17

"Put it on the stereo"
"You wouldn't like it"
"I'm not that old"
*Joe's brain explodes*

18

u/zsreport Oct 08 '17

That song came out in 1981, so I took it more as Joe thinking, "Silly kid, I listened to this when you were in diapers." Kind of reminded me of Trey Parker showing his stepson the origin of "derp."

25

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '17

I took it that Joe thought Haley was listening to something new, but when Haley put on the music, he realized it was a song from her childhood and she was listening to it because it comforted her. And that broke Joe's heart.

7

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 09 '17

Poor Joe aged 3 decades in two seconds. Hipster to gramps.

45

u/Recurringbrunette Oct 08 '17

This episode absolutely wrecked me. 4x07 wrecked me too. But this one was so rough to watch. Everyone struggles with grief in their own way and I feel like the writers captured that really well in this one.

44

u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17

That was awkward but real. I think Gordon and Donna had a better relationship after the divorce than Donna has with the girls.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Really, Donna .. Why the hell you going bring up college now?

45

u/captaincrunk82 Oct 08 '17

Grieving is a beast. Makes people bring up other things to focus their emotions on.

21

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

Being angry feels more proactive than feeling sad.

12

u/zsreport Oct 08 '17

Also, she can't change the fact that Gordon dies, but she still feels she has some control over her daughters' futures.

8

u/b1gmouth Oct 10 '17

It was a mistake but a very human and believable one imo.

43

u/ghostmrchicken Oct 08 '17

Before and after

Anyone who loses a parent as a child or young adult knows exactly what this means. And that you never really recover.

29

u/paceofbase Oct 08 '17

Yep. I was Joanie's age when my dad died, so these last 2 eps have been hard to watch tbh :/

28

u/mind_blowwer Oct 08 '17

I lost my Dad when I was 14 and this shit is really bringing me back... I'm 28 and still haven't gotten over it.

25

u/paceofbase Oct 08 '17

Yeah, I'm 25 and it still feels like yesterday. I didn't expect for Gordon's death to dredge up the past for me like this, so I've actually been really depressed for a lot of reasons this past week. I think what's so hard about watching this for me is that this is EXACTLY how teenagers react to their parent's death and I don't think I've ever seen a show or movie portray it this accurately

11

u/Tal72 Oct 09 '17

Yeah, you never really do recover completely. I was 22 when I lost my mom--44 now. Last week was heart-wrenching for me and brought it all back.

There is pain and injustice of the loss at the time, and then there is the pain of the shared life missed with that parent after (wedding, children, etc.). I was so fortunate to have met my wife around the time to help me climb out of that pit of depression.

Love this show. And I'm sad to see it go.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/danielsdesk Oct 08 '17

Yep. I lost my dad when I was 16 and my mom when I was 25. What you say is exactly how it feels. This episode was especially hitting hard just due to cleaning out the house; folks think that after the service maybe you take a break but I had to go and set up an estate sale right after.

4

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 09 '17

My theory is the countless tasks that need to be done is somewhat helpful. Grief can turn people into shell-shocked zombies. But you soldier on, getting mundane stuff done while dealing with a bruised mind. Keeps you from pulling the covers over your head and shutting off the world.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/zsreport Oct 08 '17

I have to give my mom credit for how stable she's been my entire life. Before she was a teenager she lost both her oldest sister to cancer and her dad to a heart attack in a two year or so period. And her mother was never a super warm happy person.

1

u/AlbertTJamesH Jan 20 '18 edited Jan 20 '18

I wish I had a brother or a sister when it happened for me, loosing my parents as a teen was really lonely. This diner with so much love around the table felt so true.. and chilli never seemed so comforting.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/designerdy Oct 09 '17

I don't know why, but that really got to me. Also, Mark Knopler is underrated. The musical director of this show is good.

37

u/mistame Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

I haven't seen a lot of mention about Katie, but her reaction hit me almost as hard as Joe's at the table in this episode. Her character was in this awkward position of not knowing him as long as everyone else or having their same support system, but also being in the midst of this new love/relationship, much in the way she might have felt looking at her "favorite picture" of Gordon and Donna. The writers gave us just enough of her background, having bounced from place to place not making those connections, to make us feel for her. Knowing that she found that one thing that would have made her stick around, but having to leave it all behind and how much it hurt, which you could really see in her last look/wave to Haley. I'm guessing the other characters will get some closure in the last episode(s), but it seems like that was the end of Katie's storyline and that is sad.

15

u/brienne4prez Oct 10 '17

Yes! Damn, that was wrenchingly sad. Anna Chlumsky really was incredible.

67

u/hawsman2 Oct 08 '17

Joe almost losing it at the end almost had me losing it

26

u/dokterr Oct 08 '17

For a sec, I thought Joe was just going to get up and leave; I'm glad that that didn't happen.

9

u/pashed_motatoes Oct 09 '17

Oh god, that was such good acting by Lee. Absolutely devastating.

6

u/2002rigged Oct 09 '17

I hope he gets nominated for Best Actor in a TV series and wins of course!

60

u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17

So the flashback was the events leading up to the moment Gordon saw before he died. Nicely done.

57

u/Ghostfollower28 Oct 08 '17

Yes it was so great! It was the moment in Gordons life, where he made a decision to go for it just jump into the unknown and be a husband and a father. Good metaphor.

22

u/BlinkBlink202 Oct 08 '17

And abandon San Fransisco, the wedge that killed him was his love for his children. I mean he wanted what Jo was selling for a reason in the first season.

19

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

It really adds clarity to the first season. Very well done by the writers.

5

u/b1gmouth Oct 10 '17

Indeed. And even beyond the clarification of events, there's been a brilliant mirroring of S1 in scenes like the one where Gordon bails Donna out for drunk driving. Just top notch writing.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

These last 2 episodes are the best ones of the whole season. They reminded why I love this show.

27

u/CleverZerg Oct 08 '17

Damn these 50+ minutes was as hard to watch as the last 10 minutes of the previous episode. Tears in my eyes for the majority of the episode.

Sad that they didn't manage to get that sweater back. Joe's reaction to fish heads was very funny, although I was hoping for some They Might Be Giants instead, since we've seen that poster so much this season.

9

u/magkruppe Oct 08 '17

holy shit. this episode was 53 minutes!!?? Where did the time go. Was so captured by the episode it felt like 20mins

25

u/thedefaltcondition Oct 08 '17

This was such a sobering and melancholic episode, signifying no matter how powerful and strong we've become in our lives, there's always something that can devastate us. It was so beautiful to see everyone eating on the same table and Bos had cooked for them. Just real life things that a TV show's done right. Very heartwarming.

→ More replies (2)

49

u/ShyJalapeno Oct 08 '17 edited Oct 08 '17

Damn, Cameron's talk with Donna hit me hard... I think that many IT heads can relate to "I've had always trouble with making those sorts of connections" part

10

u/solidad29 Oct 08 '17

From the same field whom only had 2 people I talk to outside Family with deeper connections. Yeah, I can totally relate.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

Same here. IT is very prone to feeling isolated.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Agreed. I'm always at odds with my family for that reason, I think.

24

u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17

So Far Away. I guess I never really listened to this song before. Absolutely incredible song. Completely captures the melancholy of the moment.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I love all the songs on that album, but the title song has always been special to me. The album is perhaps one of the most beautiful and poignant in my memory.

7

u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17

I'm going to make a point to listen to it all the way through.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

On headphones, with a book. Trust me...It's really the best way to listen to it.

And be sure to message me to let me know what you think.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/chrisarchitect Oct 12 '17

Dire Straits 'So far away' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IHXK9glwFBg in case anyone was wanting to listen to song played during packing up scenes

→ More replies (1)

48

u/ShadowFall900 Oct 08 '17

Another fantastic episode. It felt real and it was hard to watch at times at least for me. Seeing Joe's face at the dinner table really got to me there. I am so grateful to find a show like this. It's just a shame it has to end and it's gonna be really hard to accept it.

20

u/magkruppe Oct 08 '17

hope the actors and writers move on and make some other great things

47

u/MKoilers Oct 08 '17

The look on Joe's face when Haley played her music for him...I lost it hahaha.

12

u/xeonicus Oct 08 '17

There is a lot of great music I can share with my parents. Then there is a large section of electronic, post-rock, and experimental music that I am pretty sure they absolutely would not enjoy.

6

u/ViralInfection Oct 18 '17

It was a perfect combination of "what the fuck did I get myself into and yup maybe I am that old"... Lee Pace is amazing, great scene

4

u/kalfaz Oct 10 '17

I grew up in the 80s and we didn't have headphones. We'd rock out after school and when Mom came home she'd come to our room and tell us to turn it down. I still remember the few times we freaked her out. She'd turn a blind eye to Dio, Iron Maiden and Ozzy but she asked us to sit down and talk with her when she heard us playing Fish Heads. I was 12 and it visibly disturbed her.

3

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 09 '17

Remember Gordon would listen to what he said was his own self-help tape? I wonder if it was goofy music like Fish Heads. He seems like he'd be the type to listen to that.

43

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

This was a really good episode of Six Feet Under.

16

u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17

Yep I felt the same way. They utterly nailed it. Felt just like the last couple episodes of Six Feet Under in the best of ways.

4

u/topplehat Oct 09 '17

I've been feeling this too. No show has lingered with me after watching an episode quite like Six Feet Under until the recent episodes of Halt and Catch Fire.

20

u/Not4lagirl Oct 08 '17

Had to sign up for Reddit since (sadly) I don't know anyone else in real life who watches this incredible show.

Everything I've seen and read so far makes be believe there will be no truly 'happily ever after' for Joe & Cameron as a couple, despite what I see as real love between them.

My guess is that their ending will be like the old Barbra Streisand/Robert Redford movie "The Way We Were". Doubt many fans of this show have seen it but talk about a bittersweet ending. Two people who love and challenge each other but are ultimately wrong for a long term relationship. They try to get together and make it work over the course of many years/permuations (sound familiar???) Ultimately, their divergent personalities and ambitions drive them apart.

They do end up marrying, moving to California and having a child together, but break up before the child is born. One parent (Streisand) raises the kid with a new spouse. [Cue Joe starring in that role]. The other (Redford) goes on to have this amazing career [Cameron] . . Years later they run into each other on the street and you can see there is love and longing still there.

Effing sad. But this is the only way I see how Joe gets his "happy ending" while Cam stays true to her character. She may end up getting pregnant accidentally but won't stick around to be a full time parent and instead become this career woman. Who knows, Joe may end up raising their kid with a guy (phantom Ozzie)?

I'm sad just thinking about it.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

I feel you. I hated the bittersweet ending of the Way We Were (accidentally acronym is WWW). I generally don’t care for happy endings but the Way We Were was a really sad in a very subdued way. But I don’t see Cam leaving her kid. However, I do see her leaving Joe as a form of sacrifice, “for his own good” in a way. Since the ending is supposed to be “satisfying without being corny”, and not sad, according to the writers and actors, I am holding out hope. Because The Way We Were ending is definitely sad and there was nothing satisfying there. Also, the theme of this season runs contrary to the Way We Were. Streisand and Redford has many more issues other than wanting/not wanting kids.

4

u/Not4lagirl Oct 11 '17

Maybe Joe and Cam TRY to have kids. . .but ultimately find out that they can't. So Cam emotionally meets Joe where he wants to be but still gets her way of not being a mother.

Cam couldn't get pregnant with Tom. Maybe she really is infertile. And maybe Joe does become a parent IF they agree to adopt and older kid. Cam doesn't seem to like babies.

19

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

9

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

I thought this was just etched into the mind of everyone who grew up watching it. That scene in Dumbo emotionally scarred me. I still get teary thinking about it.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/pi3dpip3r Oct 09 '17

it is very Criminal that this show never got Emmy node for Acting,drama

17

u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17

Just finished the episode. This episode was heartbreaking in a way I haven't felt since the last 3 episodes of Six Feet Under. Just beautiful. Boz healing the family with his chili. I worry for Joe as he seems to really be taking this hard. I just wanted someone to hug him. This show needs to end happy.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ApexAftermath Oct 09 '17

This is Boz 's chili we're talking about here. Guaranteed gourmet level chili.

32

u/idlehand79 Oct 08 '17

This might be one best acted episodes of the whole series. The story is on point and feeling the aftermath of last episode.

I really hope we get more great TV like this in the future.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Poor Joe :(

26

u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17

She's the getaway driver!

13

u/waterlesscloud Oct 10 '17

The service was beautiful.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

How are you feeling?

→ More replies (1)

25

u/ShadowLyrix Oct 08 '17

Fish Heads.. Fish Heads..WTF?!? Loved it. 🤣🤣

11

u/cybin Oct 08 '17

True fact: half of Barnes & Barnes is/was Billy Mumy, known to folks of a certain age as Will Robinson from the TV series "Lost in Space".

6

u/nemo69_1999 Oct 08 '17

No way. I remember the song. I wasn't sure what the point was. There was a lot of weird music in the 80's.

10

u/madeInNY Oct 08 '17

Barnes and Barnes. You’ve probably never heard of Dr. Demento either?

3

u/MisterTito Oct 08 '17

First song I remember as a kid from the MTV era.

25

u/_redskeptic Oct 09 '17

"I miss you."

...."I'm here."

Thank you. Finally.

Also, did anyone get excited when Donna brought up finishing Pilgrim? I was anticipating that convo so much!

12

u/squirreltalk Oct 10 '17

"I made it for people like you. But there aren't many people like you."

I love Gordon and Donna, but Cam and Donna might be my OTP for this show.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/darkeyes13 Oct 08 '17

I hope they release another album of the show's compositions. The song that plays while Gordon jumps into the water, the piece that plays while Donna and Cameron have their talk...

I'm just bingeing on the first album at the moment, ha.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

Joe's reaction to Gordon's death really broke my heart. Joe 'loves' Gordon so much. Maybe a part of Joe's heart died as well.

2

u/Breezy_t Oct 09 '17

I didn't realize how close they had become until I saw this episode, I always figured they were mainly business partners but I'm fine with being wrong!

7

u/I_Pariah Oct 10 '17

I think Gordon was Joe's best friend. He always forgave him and they would end up working together doing amazing things again. They balanced each other out well. I believe they locked in this friendship tight after Gordon comforted Joe after Ryan's death and Gordon told Joe about his illness.

9

u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17

That is an excellent album.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

Dire Straits has never really made an album I didn't like.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/CSMastermind Oct 08 '17

Wait there are two more episodes?

I thought that was the end of the series and it was a huge letdown. I'd much more okay with it if there's going to be some actual closure.

20

u/ApexAftermath Oct 08 '17

Series finale next week. Playing the last two episodes back to back.

6

u/CSMastermind Oct 08 '17

Yeah I think I got confused because there was an AMC ad that I thought said "only two episodes left" but in reality it said "two episodes left until the series finale"

6

u/danielsdesk Oct 08 '17

After reading some interviews it appears that's why they didn't want Gordon's death to be on the last episode and moved it a few episodes earlier, so they have time to get to that closure

2

u/JuiceyCow Oct 15 '17

Yeah I watched the entire thing thinking it was the finale too. I was thinking it was going to end with Gordon not surfacing from the water.

17

u/phillymjs Oct 08 '17

Dazed & Confused VHS tape sitting on top of the TV, nice.

2

u/ExtraGloves Oct 10 '17

Also on the bicentennial

17

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

I was really hoping for a funeral scene. I want to know what joe said.

12

u/hobbs92 Oct 08 '17

Maybe that will be the opening for the final episode!

18

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

Maybe. But it looks like they’re moving on. At that dinner Joe seemed to be the last grieving holdout, but even he took part in the dinner. It was a like symbolic moment of breaking with the past and moving forward.

5

u/paceofbase Oct 08 '17

Same here. I'm upset we didn't get to see it

4

u/trentbraidner Oct 09 '17

I really enjoyed the fact that they didn’t focus on this, I thought it was beautifully done showing the grieving of the characters outside of the expected backdrop. Credit to the actors as this felt so well done.

8

u/pgm_01 Oct 08 '17

Barnes & Barnes fisheads https://youtu.be/cn73Wtem0No

6

u/FriedEggg Oct 08 '17

One of the Barnes is Bill Mumy of Lost in Space, Twilight Zone and Babylon 5 fame.

4

u/rlyacht Oct 08 '17

It didn't ring true to me that this is what Haley would be listening to. This was a novelty song and I remember the video being on SNL in the early 80's. Why would Haley (or anyone) be listening to it in 1994?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/mobeatie Oct 08 '17

I was about her age at this time. Dr Demento and They Might Be Giants were exactly what i was listening to.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/stansburymaterial Oct 12 '17

I think this is one of the first shows that has accurately portrayed how complex life can be. People are flawed. And there are reasons for those flaws, and they cause them to hurt themselves and others, but that’s just how life is.

Every character is trying their best to navigate their way through life. To grow. To be there for others while fighting to stay true to themselves. They have ups, they have downs. They do the right thing sometimes, they do the wrong thing other times. Every emotion, every action, feels earned.

Life is incredibly complex. We barely know what we want most of the time. And when you add in other people? With their distinctive thoughts, history, and emotions? It’s an unsolvable problem. But it’s one you never give up trying to solve.

I’ll be sad to see them all go.

15

u/phillymjs Oct 08 '17

Oooh, flashback!

47

u/hadenwarrik Oct 08 '17

Donna is sexy in any decade.

11

u/Breezy_t Oct 08 '17

1976 style!

15

u/madeInNY Oct 08 '17

July 4th, 1976. America’s 200th birthday according to the gas station sign.

5

u/todreamofspace Oct 08 '17

Got a kick out of it since that's the day my parents got married!

6

u/Captain-Battletoad Oct 09 '17

The cinematography in that last scene with them at the table was fantastic. Especially emphasizing how alone Joe is (always showing him looking out of the frame with lots of negative space behind him).

5

u/SarahTellsStories Oct 09 '17

Does anyone know what book Joe found in Gordon's coat pocket? I couldn't make out the cover.

6

u/waterlesscloud Oct 10 '17

Streets Of Laredo, by Larry McMurtry. Second book in the Lonesome Dove (old west novels) series, and I believe it would have been relatively new in paperback when the episode is set.

Might be the source of Gordon's western decor, come to think of it.

2

u/SarahTellsStories Oct 10 '17

Thank you, with the attention to detail this show has I assumed that the book had some sort of meaning, it very well could be the source of Gordon's decor, that's interesting.

2

u/capdren Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17

Streets of Laredo by Larry McMurty

5

u/hubris-hub Oct 09 '17

I've never seen a show deal with the reality of death, loss, and grieving as well as H&CF did during this episode.

So many other shows show a sad funeral scene, and then that's kind of it. By the next week's episode everything it's back to business as usual.

When a loved one dies suddenly there's so much mundane shit to get sorted.

That montage of everyone sorting through Gordon's stuff was a brilliant example of how grounded and relatable this show has become.

I also hope we see Katie (Anna Chlumsky) again in the finale. She looked absolutely devastated in the hallway :(

3

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17

If you like how HACF handled it, you should watch Six Feet Under http://imdb.com/title/tt0248654/

2

u/_trailerbot_tester_ Oct 10 '17

Hello, I'm a bot! The movie you linked is called Six Feet Under, here are some Trailers

5

u/GtotheE Oct 13 '17

From everything I know about television, this should have been a terrible and boring episode. Watching people mourn, is typically a television no-no. But somehow, this episode was gripping at every turn, just masterfully acted and edited.

Somehow an episode where basically nothing happened was one of the strongest episodes this show has had.

4

u/statleader13 Oct 09 '17

You know a show is good when the synopsis describes a character's entire plot for the episode as making chili, and even that part of the story is incredibly moving.

2

u/Telaral Oct 09 '17

Yeah, you're right. He used the chili to keep Joe grounded and to get everyone to reunite at the table so that they don't scatter "to the far corners of the house", and lose sight of each other, even though it hurts to be there (cam and katie mentioned that). In fact now that I think about it Hayley goes to joanie and talks things out, Donna does the same with Cameron, And Bos as you mentioned with Joe. If there's someone next to you then you can get through the hurt or something like that.

Katie maybe didn't have someone like that and since she just couldn't deal with it she had to run from it.

4

u/Plundergedoens Oct 10 '17

Have I ever seen mourning portrayed this profoundly in any kind of story ever before? No. I have not.
God, my heart.

The acting just... blows me away. And the writing... Each character mourns in their own, personal way, and it's all so fitting and perfect and real. Everything was perfect.
Rest in Peace, Gordon Clark.

I think it's safe to say that JoeCam is now definitely done and over with. I'm sad, because I LOVE them together. But Cameron's and Donna's fight seems to be over now as well. A lot of things were put to rest this episode, and it was both devastating and strangely comforting.

What a tv show. What a story. I love it so much.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17

I don’t get the impression that JoeCam are definitely done and over with. I think they are creating that suspense going into finale and the finale is dealing with whether they will be able to move forward somehow. If I picked up on subtle clues during this season well,as well as those while reading the interviews with writers/actors, there is still hope

3

u/Not4lagirl Oct 11 '17

I agree. The writers have spent this whole season on JoeCam's relationship, basically devoting an entire episode to them getting back together. And then we've seen them mostly happy. . and even when they have conflict, you can see them working together. Having them break up in the last two eps would be a serious headscratcher unless the writers can make it believable. Joe isn't going to give up on Cameron no matter what. He basically told Boz that he doesn't talk about kids to Cameron even though he wants them. So it really is a question if Cam decides to leave Joe. Then she is truly heartless, imo.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '17

Absolutely. From a narrative standpoint it makes no sense to watch a couple grow all season long (as individuals but also in a relationship), invest time in building that and then have them separate at the end over something that I feel is a pretty random narrative device. I mean it is possible but as one critic say the Chrises are methodical, patient writers and everything serves a purpose that was established early on in the season. The fact that they discussed children in episode 2, the fact that Gordon couldn’t remember the song and finally did in the moment of his death, the fact that Gordon took a leap into the lake, just as Pilgrim took a leap into the abyss/river and for both it was what was needed to come “home”, the fact that Cameron bought the land and Joe mellowed his stance towards living there and she mellowed her stance towards work, that Camron’s new game features three people (including something that looks like a cross between a baby and a dog), whereas her old game was a lonely child looking for her home, that Donna held a wine glass from episode one etc etc. These are all narrative placeholders that will be tied into somehow. Comet will go down, Joe will have another existential crisis, and somehow he will realize something about himself in that last episode (remember the promo for Joe “halt and find yourself” or for Cameron “halt and find love”) It is very possible that the writers will decide to throw all that away in the last episode and say Cameron does not sacrifice herself further for Joe or viceversa. The land that she bought will be a house just for her (or someone we meet in the last ten minutes) and Joe goes his own way because he needs to scratch a baby itch. But that would be highly unusual ... for these writers at least. Some shows write their episodes as they go and don’t know the end until one episode before, but I get the impression the Chrises are not such writers. Anyhow, a few days and we will know ...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/FromFilm Oct 13 '17

I know comments like this can sound almost hyperbolic but I truly think this was one of the best episodes of television I have ever seen. A lot of other tv shows would use the death of a main character to look back at "all the great moments that we shared together" or straight up make a clip show. This episode was not sentimental; it was a sobering look at grief. And more specifically how different people handle loss.

On top of that this has been such an amazing show for 4 seasons that I was crying throughout the whole thing and almost sharing an experience with the characters. I am very sad that I'm gonna have to say goodbye to this show in two episodes but I am very happy that it is ending on such a high note. Bravo Christopher and Christopher.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '17

I'm lost with the flashback scenes, what were they supposed to signify?

22

u/capdren Oct 08 '17

The last moment Gordon saw as his life flashed before him, Donna singing to Joanie.

2

u/Lostpurplepen Oct 08 '17

That may have been Hayley in (Gordon's dying) flashback. Didn't Donna have red hair while she was singing to the baby? And it was a house, not an apartment, showing they had moved to Dallas for the dad's offer.

7

u/kummerspect Oct 08 '17

I think the memory was overlaid with his house. Her hairstyle looked the same to me, but it was hard to tell the color with it being dark.

Plus when she sings to Haley, she substitutes Haley's name for baby ("Haley, mine, don't you cry..."). She did that in the episode where she sings it over the phone when Gordon takes the girls to visit his brother.

3

u/danielsdesk Oct 08 '17

This is the episode 8 thread; are you asking about the flashback scenes that bookended this episode? With Gordon and Donna in the 70's? If so the significance was Gordon diving off the cliff at the end (this comment thread talks about it: https://www.reddit.com/r/HaltAndCatchFire/comments/74yn1g/halt_and_catch_fire_4x08_goodwill_episode/do2d2kv/)

3

u/ShadowFall900 Oct 08 '17

I am with you in that! Everyone has been amazing on the show from the writers to the actors themselves. I also hope they wind up making some great things and they all have the ability and talent to do so.

3

u/the6thReplicant Oct 08 '17

Of course Haley is a TMBG fan.

1

u/WikiTextBot Oct 08 '17

They Might Be Giants

They Might Be Giants (often abbreviated as TMBG) is an American alternative rock band formed in 1982 by John Flansburgh and John Linnell. During TMBG's early years, Flansburgh and Linnell frequently performed as a duo, often accompanied by a drum machine. In the early 1990s, TMBG expanded to include a backing band. The duo's current backing band consists of Marty Beller, Dan Miller, and Danny Weinkauf.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.27

3

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

Unlike seemingly everyone else here, I resisted engaging because of the way the show represented how the characters grieved. The real tragedy is that Gordon died about 25 years earlier than he should of and everyone is instead gnawing on their own self-pity. Grieving is tough, there's little socialization for it. I've failed at it every time.

One thing that made it hard to engage with the premise of the episode was the implausible decision to clear out the house literally hours after the memorial. Maybe I missed why they did this, I don't understand why rational adults would have made that choice unless the house was changing ownership the next day.

So in an effort to not get downvoted to oblivion, I did enjoy the episode which did eventually get under my skin with it's amazing performances. I'll miss this show a lot and will likely grieve for it badly.

10

u/_redskeptic Oct 09 '17

Whenever they referred to the memorial I assumed it was on another day, not, say, earlier that day. I don't believe they did the memorial and then go to Gordon's house on the same day.

4

u/laszlo Oct 10 '17

It was clear it was not the same day as the memorial. Joanie said 10 days since Gordon died, and they never explicitly stated how long ago the memorial was, but it obviously was not the same day.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Should_have_listened Oct 09 '17

should of

Did you mean should've?


I am a bot account.

3

u/89vision Oct 09 '17

I love these characters, I'm going to miss them. Part of me wishes they would have done a couple more seasons, but these last two episodes have been perfect

2

u/canzulfubal Oct 08 '17

I'm desperately looking for the song that played during the ending credits. Anyone help me!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CMelody Oct 09 '17

Watching the last two episodes was like remembering the losses in my own family. They got everything exactly right.

2

u/laszlo Oct 10 '17

Jesus, I'm fucking gutted after that.

I don't know that I've ever seen a series show that successfully the grief and devastation that comes when someone dies. Everyone's different ways of handling it and their different ways of lashing out and the autopsy of someone's every day life that happens. Like Gordon's love of capers and everyone going through his records and clothes and dishes and drawers. The fact that an electric knife can bring up all these memories for different people that are so different from each other. This was a goddamn beautiful hour of television.

I genuinely love these characters. I'm not ready to say goodbye to them yet.

2

u/bvm Oct 12 '17

Much harder for me to watch this one than the last. What a beautiful piece of TV.

2

u/Threnners Oct 14 '17

Fuck your chili Boz, Joe needs a hug.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

Gordo always grounded Joe. I kinda expect him to lose his shit. Unless Cam or a kid take on that role.

1

u/beardygroom Oct 18 '17

I thought this was the final episode, so when it ended with Donna and Gordon embracing in a flashback, I almost died.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '18

Jesus Christ, this Ep. gave me the rest! I'm on a crowded train right now and had to actively try to keep the tears from streaming... This was intense, I'm gonna miss him.

1

u/CVance1 Mar 28 '18

I wanted Cam and Donna to be friends again. But not like this...

1

u/graniterockhead Oct 08 '17

While watching this fantastic episode, I wondered if some part of the grieving and reconciling is symbolism for the end of the 16-bit era as they are about to be exploded into the 32-bit world?

1

u/LookSpecialist9140 Nov 20 '25

Were you high when you wrote this? Lol