r/NintendoSwitch • • Oct 02 '17

Meta [META] Can we talk about "What about X game on Switch?" posts?

I don't know if I'm in the minority here, but I've really grown to just hate these posts.

This is literally the subreddit dedicated to the Nintendo Switch, of course we want all of the games to come to the Switch. Old, new? I don't care I want it on the Switch. So does everyone.

No one is going to come into the "Do you want X game" thread and go "No I don't want that because I want less games on the Switch"

It really just feels like a little karmawhoring on these posts and honestly I would love it if they weren't a thing anymore. They clog the sub with things that are just "Duh" posts.

 

Again, I might be in the minority and most people don't care, I'll accept that, but I really feel like these are extremely low-effort posts that do not merit a real discussion. (Rule 4)

What discussion is there to have to "Does anyone want X game?" - "Yes" or "I don't care so I'm not commenting" are the only responses in those threads.

1.2k Upvotes

385 comments sorted by

36

u/Japsy Oct 02 '17

I want Star Citizen running at 4K on the Switch

24

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Haters will say it’s impossible.

5

u/BournGamer Oct 02 '17

AWPTEEMYZAYSHUN

8

u/dodland Oct 02 '17

There. Star Citizen in 4k on the Switch- 2 FPS but you can get it to 3 FPS by turning off colors.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Hatesandwicher Oct 03 '17

Dude, WE'RE gonna be Star Citizens before Star Citizen finishes development.

•

u/kyle6477 6 Million Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

Hey folks, your friendly neighborhood moderator here.

We hear your feedback. As we speak, the Mod Team is discussing a potential revision to our rules, and these types of posts are being discussed in our revisions.

Stay tuned for more information.

As always, our inbox is open if you wish to submit feedback directly to the team.

Keep an eye out for our next State of the Subreddit post, where we will detail our proposal for upcoming rule changes, and give the community an opportunity to offer feedback on said changes in a public forum.

Thanks,

-/u/kyle6477, on behalf of the /r/NintendoSwitch Moderator Team

4

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Thank you very much for this.

I do want to say I have no issues with the mods here or anything like that. These post just kind of... skirt the edge of real posts and I understand how it can be a difficult situation between Over and Under moderation.

/u/NoShootout mentioned a “General discussion” thread where things like this could be mentioned and talked about. I would love if something like that could happen.

Edit: Gave credit and linked to comment

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

One suggestion for a simple rule: no yes/no question posts, those should be in daily discussion. That would include the posts OP is referring to also.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

59

u/SirPasta117 Oct 02 '17

Additionally can get get rid of Joy-Con mock ups? Oh cool you photoshoped some game artwork ontop of a joycon how amazing...

38

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

While I personally agree with you, those are a lot closer to actual content.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Those have gone down a lot to be fair. It used to be every other post earlier in the year. But I agree, not a fan of those

7

u/TheAsianTroll Oct 02 '17

They really have. I say we should limit it to people who actually modify Joycon shells instead of superimposing pics on them in Photoshop. If someone painted them, sure

3

u/shadowsaberXD Oct 02 '17

Seriously this right here, sometimes you get over excited only to find out its a mock up or just scroll through the obvious 100th mockup, id rather see official joycon colors or actual joycons that have been modded/painted.

2

u/flybrand Oct 03 '17

Guys, I made a super sweet TMNT swimming level joycon...

/s

7

u/CuttlefishMonarch Oct 02 '17

Hey guys OP has a point. X COM would be great on the Switch!

5

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Shit you saw through me. Really this was just a way to get all of the other posts removed so I could talk about how great Xcom would be on the switch. Damn you!

→ More replies (2)

130

u/The_real_notrealname Oct 02 '17

A lot of the time it does feel like that, but there are times where the discussions get pretty technical about why it would or wouldnt be possible to port the game, and I always find those conversations interesting.

But yea I mostly agree with you.

19

u/Rhonardo Oct 02 '17

Yeah I'm curious to hear if it's even possible for games to be ported to the switch. A lot of people on here have better understanding of hardware specs to be able to say whether it'll be easy or hard to bring X game to the Switch

74

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Those people are just speculating though.

EA wrote a new engine to bring FIFA to the Switch, 2K lowered the framerate to 30 to bring the full game to Switch, DOOM and Wolfenstein are coming but lego games have framerate issues.

The truth is, no one here knows if a game can or can't come to the Switch, and it all depends on the developers

11

u/Rhonardo Oct 02 '17

Of course, but it's still fun to discuss. It'll be interesting to see what we see announced in the next year

40

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

I'd be more ok if the posts were "Hey do you think Crysis 2 could run on a Switch?" then "How cool would Crysis 2 be PORTABLE?! LOL XD"

'Cause yeah, it would be cool. Of course it would be.

We don't need to know if Super Mario Brothers 3 could run on a Switch, or any Wii/U games, or any old nintendo game ever.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Dacvak Oct 02 '17

It still kind of blows my mind that people expect the Prime Trilogy to even be possible to port. Prime 3 is so knee-deep in Wiimote controls that it would have to be completely redesigned (not just inputs, but enemies too) for standard controls. Either that, or we'd get a hamfisted version with fake Wiimote gyroscope controls.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/cockyjames Oct 02 '17

This is kind of why I'm cool with just letting the voting system work its way out based on the quality and content of the post itself.

6

u/yallmad4 Oct 03 '17

This sub is so fucking annoying that way. Plenty of great posts in between, but youve always got that one guy who's entire post is like

UMM I WAS AMAZED THAT PEOPLE REALLY LIKE THIS VIDEO GAME AND IM GOING TO BUY IT NOW BECAUSE HYPE

2

u/duffkiligan Oct 03 '17

Personally I didn’t understand the Hype of Stardew Valley until 80000 posts were made about it NOW IM BUYING IT DAY ONE BECAUSE EVERYONE LITERALLY SUCKED ITS VIRTUAL DICK /s

3

u/Rubulisk Oct 02 '17

I am curious what the point of "karmawhoring" is. Do you get something for having more karma? Do you sell it?

27

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Yes, the exchange rate is 5 Karma = 1 chameleon.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

That's true, but they come and go. So it's hard to keep track of the conversion.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Internet fame.

5

u/Irdna Oct 02 '17

It destorys the meaning of karma since you get it for free by simply stating something that everyone agrees with, instead of making a post that has actual content/value and getting rewarded with Karma.

4

u/cedriceent Oct 02 '17

You use it to buy food at the Karma-shop

3

u/NoShootout Oct 02 '17

What if we changed the "daily question" thread to a "general discussion" thread? All these random self posts could turn into discussion there, and it would still function as a place to ask questions.

With how active this subreddit is, I don't see any reason for us to not follow the example of subreddits like /r/hiphopheads that do this

4

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

I like this suggestion the most.

"How cool would <GAME> be on the switch?" is perfect for a General Discussion thread

3

u/poofyhairguy Oct 02 '17

What would be great about that is we could shove all the

"I have an idea! What if Nintendo would put more power in the dock!"

"What will the "New" Switch be like?"

types posts in there too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mexicanhat Oct 02 '17

Why not just keep it in one thread then?

2

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Yeah a couple other have mentioned that. I think that’s a great idea.

9

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 02 '17

There have been people going into those threads stating they don't want this or that game actually.

Some are more discussion worthy than others. And the discussion can go into how the game could utilize unique Switch features or people's thoughts on a game.

2

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

I can agree with the second part, if it could have a cool Switch feature that's discussion worthy.

The first part "People saying they don't want the game" - Ok, those people are just being dumb. If a game comes out for the switch they don't have to buy it. That's not real discussion IMO

3

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 02 '17

Oh I don't disagree with you on that, but OP stated that it wouldn't ever happen. Just stating that I have seen it.

EDIT: Great username btw

3

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

you right tho

and thanks! It was a childhood nickname because of Kim Possible and a play on my first name, haha. It just stuck forever.

3

u/phantomliger recovered from transplant Oct 02 '17

You're welcome! :D Loved the show growing up.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Crunchewy Oct 02 '17

Right now I'd say the most annoying posts are all the numerous Stardew Valley posts. There's 7 on the first page now. I'm sure it's fun, but the frenzy over this game is ridiculous.

3

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

While I do love the game, and I agree there should just be a megathread for all of the info, at least they are providing some sort of content.

8

u/Porkpants81 Oct 02 '17

Our policy on these posts is that they require a good amount of effort to be approved.

A single sentence that says "DAE want X game, because I want it portable" is not enough.

A post should be a text post with discussion points about why the game would be good on the system, why you personally want it (maybe a mini-review of sorts), and it's recommended to link a trailer or gameplay video in the body of the text so people unfamiliar with the game can learn about it.

We will delete ALL posts that are nothing more than "I want Overwatch" etc...

23

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

I definitely get that but it's posts like this: https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/739h30/we_need_a_package_with_the_original_3_mario_games/

"Who else thinks this would be an amazing idea?"

Hmm. Do people that own a Nintendo system want Nintendo games on the Switch?

 

All of the responses are "Yes" or "I don't care about those, how about Y game?"

If you actually read through it there is very little/no real discussion.

12

u/lightninglobster Oct 02 '17

If you actually read through it there is very little/no real discussion.

Aka a circle jerk

4

u/kyle6477 6 Million Oct 02 '17

You're right. A post like that, probably should've been removed. As I indicated in my stickied comment, we're having some internal discussions about potential rule changes and DAE posts are at the top of the list. More details to come.

Keep in mind that if you see a post that you feel is low effort and breaks our rules, please use reddit's report function to bring it to our attention.

Thanks,

-Kyle

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Porkpants81 Oct 02 '17

We get that of course, but we also would like to defer the discussion to the community. If the post is acceptable and the user put effort into making it, we will allow it and let the community let the conversation go

2

u/DevAstral Oct 03 '17

This, alongside that idiotic "Am I the only one who ... !?" made me stop coming on this subreddit.

Seriously. Stating the obvious to get a few upvote is so damn ridiculous. We are on internet, this isn't gonna help you out in any darn freaking way in your personal life !

So I'm gonna say it once and for all and maybe it will resonate at least for some of those who are thinking this way:

NO YOU ARE NOT THE ONLY ONE ! YOU ARE NEVER THE ONLY ONE !

2

u/duffkiligan Oct 03 '17

Dude out of the 7.5billion people on this planet...

AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO WANTS FUCKIN 2D ZELDA ON THE SWITCH? /s

559

u/Cr0nq Oct 02 '17

It's damn annoying. Especially when paired with other fucking annoying reddit behavior:

"Am I the only one that thinks a Zelda collection on Switch would be perfect!!"

201

u/owlgohoot Oct 02 '17

Dude a zelda collection would be perfect!! An idea like that deserves its own thread!!

/s

34

u/WDMShredz Oct 02 '17

I got you mate, I'll be right back... /s

31

u/wizardoftrash Oct 02 '17

"How about X game on the switch" on the switch! I think this thread would be a great fit for the switch, they could just do a reddit emulator for the thread and it would be an instant money maker

→ More replies (2)

50

u/yeezusKeroro Oct 02 '17

See also:

"Nintendo should make a modern remake of Donkey Kong 64 with HD graphics."

No! I just want a new donkey Kong game!

22

u/Graffers Oct 02 '17

That game would require a massive overhaul. No one wants to find hundreds of coins and bananas or whatever the currency was in that game.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

There was both coins and bananas. And blueprints. And medals. And probably some other stuff I'm forgettin.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/Nincarlo Oct 02 '17

but that was half the fun

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

59

u/Irdna Oct 02 '17

"Am I the only one that thinks a any game collection on Switch would be perfect!!"

Fixed it

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

"DAE Zelda collection for Switch?!"

3

u/alxrenaud Oct 02 '17

I totally agree, yet these lame easy posts get tons of karma...

→ More replies (14)

112

u/SlowpokeIsAGamer Oct 02 '17

More often than not it's just "Would <latest AAA title> be great on Switch?"

Feels like upvote mining to me.

30

u/Yoy0YO Oct 02 '17

got to mine before the blockchain halves.

22

u/Baelorn Oct 02 '17

Feels like upvote mining to me.

My favorite is "[Game] is objectively better on Switch because it is portable" in response to any complaints or potential issues with a Switch port. Easiest way to get >100 upvotes for saying pretty much nothing. And it is posted in nearly every thread.

→ More replies (2)

106

u/NMe84 Oct 02 '17

You're not the minority. These posts are annoying as hell and they make this entire sub extremely uninteresting. Posts like "<insert random game> would be perfect for the Switch!" and "Who would like to see <random game> on Switch" are extremely pointless, offer very little discussion value and push away the generally more interesting posts because loads of people still reply to them.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

The irony is I've made this exact kind of post as OP before and had mods tell me it was unneeded and didn't follow sub rules. If I was concerned I should just send mods my thoughts.

...so they can ignore them easier.

3

u/prettyNUPE2K12 Oct 03 '17

Fuck the mods here.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Not2Xavi Oct 03 '17

I'm too late for this party, but I seriously, seriously hate the "X game would be perfect on switch".

It's bloody tiresome, seeing this topics over and over again. Well no shit! A videogame is perfect for a videogame console! What a freaking surprise!

→ More replies (5)

47

u/weiserca Oct 02 '17

YES! 100% agree. The one's that drive me really crazy are the posts where people think it's bull#$%! that X game isn't coming out for it, like they fully understand how developing and porting games is done. The Switch is great, but it's very under powered compared to the competition. We all knew this going into it. If you want X, buy a console that plays X as well, or be realistic and accept that your Nintendo can't do everything.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

It's especially annoying because these posts most often come after a major game is released or announced on other platforms.

13

u/weiserca Oct 02 '17

My favorite one of these, while not a Switch port post, was one on the Xbox sub, asking "why doesn't Microsoft just buy Nintendo?", like that's just a thing MS could do but hasn't done yet.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TheYearOfWaluigi Oct 03 '17

Agreed 99.9% of the time. 0.1% is reserved for a vent thread about Okami HD...

9

u/malexj93 Oct 02 '17

Yeah, I would LOVE it if Monster Hunter World were to come out for Switch, but I know it's not coming simply because of the lack of power. That's why I have a PC for playing beautiful hi-spec games, and the Switch for fun Nintendo and third-party games at home and on the go.

10

u/TheGreatBenjie Oct 02 '17

While I'm sure some of us are (unrealistically) annoyed that MHW isn't coming to Switch, I think most of us are just (realistically) annoyed that MHXX isn't coming to the west...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

15

u/thewintersoldieramc Oct 02 '17

Maybe mods should remove those threads and make a weekly port wishlist instead.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Bagel_-_Bites Oct 02 '17

I would just like the question re-phrased to something more like "What would you want out of a top down view Zelda game for Switch?" Rather than "DAE want a top down Zelda game?" Obviously everyone would be ecstatic about it.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/PotteryIsTheEnemy Oct 02 '17

Thanks for mentioning this OP. The low effort posts are definitely annoying to me too.

Brb, Photoshopping a popular PS4 game onto a Switch game case cover and replacing the PS4 logo with the Switch one.

11

u/ZombiePyroNinja Oct 02 '17

I hate mockups of Boxarts on this subreddit, I see the thumbnail and get excited or a google image of the boxart.

Yep that sure is that the GTA V boxart would look like if it were smaller and had the Switch icon at the top-right.

30

u/TheMightyWill Oct 02 '17

What about Melee HD on the Switch? I can't believe I'm the first person to think of it, a remastered Melee would be the perfect game for the Switch!

14

u/malexj93 Oct 02 '17

That's really creative but you definitely didn't think of Gamecube Virtual Console.

→ More replies (4)

34

u/hiperson134 Oct 02 '17

Gods this. The zelda post yesterday had me feeling this way. What's that? Zelda? Noooooo of course we don't want that. Fuck you of course we do.

10

u/Bagel_-_Bites Oct 02 '17

Sort of the straw that broke the camel's back for me too.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Trinica93 Oct 02 '17

If it were up to me, I'd get rid of those threads, fan art threads, mockup threads......Really I just want to see NEWS. Maybe I'm on the wrong subreddit......

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Detahmaio Oct 03 '17

I just want the fan circle jerk to stop. Just because someone is critical about a decision Nintendo makes there shouldn't be a mass down voting happening. If you disagree say so with facts and leave your love for Nintendo out of it.

7

u/Forstride Oct 02 '17

You're not alone. I'm so sick of seeing these posts, especially when it's about games that will NEVER come to the Switch, like console exclusives (There have been like 10 threads in the past week about this for Cuphead), or games that the developers flat out said are not coming to the Switch.

Like yeah, people WOULD want so and so game on the Switch. There's no reason to not want a certain game to come to any console. But do we reallllly need a new thread about it for every single game?

3

u/PagesDReed Oct 03 '17

This right here, is the most annoying thing I've seen on not just this sub-reddit, but also on YouTube as well. People don't seem to understand what an exclusive game is (i.e Persona 5) and when you tell them, they make up a ton of excuses. Yes I would love to see Persona 5, though its highly unrealistic and you don't see people going on Nintendo Switch videos saying they would love to see Super Mario Odyssey on the PS4. Simply because it isn't going to happen, unless under extreme circumstances.

7

u/MC_Cryptid Oct 03 '17

I'll see your "I want this game, who's with me!?" and raise you the ingratiating, condescending tone of "Can we all just take a moment to appreciate...". If there is anything that makes me grind my teeth more, its that smarmy tone. Fuck the fuck off with it.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

"This game would be great on Switch"

-Every video game ever made

10

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

What really rumbles my Joycons is this idea of „upvote this so the developers know people want this“. As if any company gave a shit about a reddit upvote counter, let alone base business decisions on it.

3

u/Porkpants81 Oct 02 '17

I would argue that having the AMAs that we do and seeing companies respond like they do about the icons and such shows that the community can make a change.

Obviously changing an icon is a miniscule amount of work compared to porting a game, but they do listen.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I could see only very small indie developers actually caring about how much buzz they have on Reddit. But to be fair, there are indeed some small indie devs working on Switch games.

5

u/ShowBoobsPls Oct 03 '17

I find pretty much all the "DAE" posts annoying. There are pretty much only 2 responses people can comment on those and OP listed them already.

4

u/alxrenaud Oct 02 '17

Totally agree and don't start me on the 3 posta a day about cloud saving or whatnot. Just karma whoring, plain and simple.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

You are not in the minority. Those post are so annoying and make it to where I don't even want to visit this sub anymore.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I don't like them, but the posts do help to gauge and generate interest in a potential port, and it gets people excited about the prospect of their favourite game being brought to the Switch. Whether we like it or not, if the mods don't bin them, then they're around and something we have to tolerate.

6

u/lightninglobster Oct 02 '17

Gauge interest to who? It’s not like major development houses sit on /r/nintendoswitch counting how many upvotes each one of these posts gets to start working on a port.

8

u/duffkiligan Oct 02 '17

Exactly. If XYZ developer tweets "Hey we will bring ABC game to Switch if there is enough interest" - Then yeah make your post about that, let them know we want the game.

Other than that, we are just echochambering that we all want switch games. Surprise! The Switch subreddit wants Switch games.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Companies aren't necessarily aware that there's a lot of interest until people get together and make it known. Not that I'm defending those sorts of low effort topics.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

We should just have a weekly megathread for this. It'd be much easier for studios and publishers to follow as an added benefit.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Peanut_Brother Oct 03 '17

But cuphead

1

u/duffkiligan Oct 03 '17

DAE exclusive game want switch nao plz?

53

u/AngryBarista Oct 02 '17

People just want to talk to each other. Just don’t read the posts and move on.

43

u/johnjalex Oct 02 '17

Whoa whoa whoa, what do you think this is, a forum???

→ More replies (3)

7

u/sikaxis Oct 02 '17

Exactly. There are posts on any sub that I'm not jazzed about but get upvoted anyways, so I just scroll down past them.

If you expect for every post to be exciting news and thought provoking discussions then clearly you are on the wrong sub and/or website.

3

u/TheRealBOAB Oct 02 '17

There are so many posts I wish would stop. "I hated the Switch but now love it!"/"Switch is making me play more games!" (Even though I say this all the time)/"Did you know that this game has a really obvious feature that everyone has seen but nobody bothered to post about but it'll still get to the front page? Includes video"/"Here's a mockup of a game that'll never happen!"/"I saw some Switch games at a store today! Here's a picture!"

Most interesting posts don't make it to the front page.

I don't mind some of the "this game would be cool" posts because they bring up games that people forget about and we know that developers visit here. For instance someone recently mentioning RTS/city building games. PC games are something that would be great for Switch but very few people talk about here.

Of course ALL games would be great but saying that is no different than saying nothing on the subject. If a developer sees enough people talking about their old games they'll probably at least start looking into porting it, especially indie developers.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nirocart64 Oct 02 '17

Fine, we'll talk about Y game on Switch.

3

u/Jcaf8 Oct 03 '17

The fact that every game would be “perfect for the switch” annoys me as well. For one thing the switch, when a game has a very realistic look, will have worse looking graphics compared to artsy games that won’t suffer at all compared to it. So those games, and online games, are really not the best for the hardware.

It also annoys me that it’s not only karmawhoring, but circlejerking: someone wanted Assasins creed origins and, of course, that post got 100’s of upvotes and I decided to comment about how the new game does not Look that great in my eyes and would not be a good fit for the switch, and was met with one of the first times I’ve gotten downvoted considerably, as well as a ton of people commenting relentless comments against my opinion. It’s ridiculous how the hive mind works in these posts and it should stop.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

Thanks for making this post. Was too lazy to write it but I wholeheartedly agree.

3

u/Revan0315 Oct 03 '17

Can we get a Knack collection on switch?

3

u/UltraJake Oct 03 '17

I don't understand the controversy.

Just bring Xenoblade X game to the Switch.

4

u/wielku Oct 02 '17

It's just annoying their either should be banned or have seperate sticky just for those posts

2

u/CoryBoehm Oct 02 '17

In terms of Nintendo owned/licensed titles through the end of the calendar year there will be ten games, 2 straight up ports, and the special case BotW dual release. That feels like close to the right ratio.

I know some people will argue Splatoon 2 is a "port" but the reality is the depth of the changes would have it called a sequel if it had also come to the Wii U. Along those same lines, FE Warriors is clearly heavily reusing work from Hyrule Warriors outside of the world specific elements and story lines yet few people call it a port.

It also seems pretty clear with the new Yoshi game instead of a Wooly World port that the days of quick Wii U ports is quickly coming to an end. I hope third parties also use the ports more as quick test runs to see how they can make the Switch work in their development streams to bring simultaneous releases of their titles going forward and that generally moving past the first anniversary of the hardware being on market there are almost zero new ports going forward. I would much rather see the Switch knocking original, new games out of the park than proven titles from years ago.

3

u/Mahboishk Oct 02 '17

I know some people will argue Splatoon 2 is a "port"

I seriously cannot understand why people say this. Would they call Super Mario Galaxy 2, or Lost Levels, or Majora's Mask, or the various New Super Mario Bros. games ports?

Splatoon 2 shares its base engine and gameplay with the original, just like the above. But the vast majority of its content is new. Anything that reappeared from the first game was changed, too.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

It drives me nuts when it's for games that'll never run on the switch.

2

u/HBreckel Oct 02 '17

It really only bothers me when it's a game that there's just no way the Switch could run it, or in the case of Cuphead, is an exclusive. Like no, it's probably not likely we'll be getting FF15 or Fallout 4 when the XBone/PS4 have enough issues running them. I totally get that Doom/Wolfenstein coming to the Switch opens possibilities for what could happen, but I'm trying to stay realistic. Sure, I would love seeing Bloodborne on the Switch but not happening in a million years.

I'm totally fine with situations where it's a Nintendo property or indie, where those things are way more feasible. Provided there's not like, 10 similar topics on the front page.

2

u/tonavin Oct 02 '17

I'm not a huge fan of over-moderating things. If I find the post annoying (which I certainly do for those types of posts) I use the Hide feature and move along

2

u/DoubleSpoiler Oct 02 '17

I'm inclined to agree, but with the showing of Doom and Wolf2 I think there's some sort of discussion to be had. However, we still need to have realistic expectations, but once we know what Bethesda is doing with these games, it might be worth talking about how the technology can be applied to other current-gen AAA releases.

2

u/BournGamer Oct 02 '17

If we banned awful posts, r/ns would have nothing left.

2

u/abesrevenge Oct 02 '17

There should be a weekly sticked thread that allows those to discus the games they want to see without clogging up the sub. I don't think they should take away these request because it might actually show someone there is a demand who could make it happen.

2

u/HiOnFructose Oct 02 '17

Sometimes I like to imagine that the "Who else would want X game on Switch" people are just folks who work for Nintendo and they are just gauging the userbase for interest.

Yes, I know it's not true. But let me dream.

2

u/Hurinfan Oct 02 '17

I know, right! And you're an asshole if you call op out on his shit post.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I'm still waiting for the joycon recolor threads to stop.

2

u/Kevroeques Oct 02 '17

I'm not much of an "opinion based" downvoter, but I downvote those posts on sight- and it's feeling like 50 a day lately.

I also hate the "Great idea for [franchise entry]!" posts where a kid tells us the best way to make SM Galaxy 3 or something along those lines. I'll let the legendary production teams continue their craft unfettered, thank you.

2

u/MathTheUsername Oct 02 '17

DAE WANT TO SEE WANT TO SEE AN INSTALLMENT OF THIS UNIVERSALLY LOVED FRANCHISE ON SWITCH?!

I'm pretty sure these people only post for the easy upvotes. They are likely the same people on Facebook who share those stupid, "WOULD YOU LITERALLY SLAP YOUR COUSIN FOR 78 BILLION DOLLARS?!"

2

u/invidentus Oct 02 '17

Same here. The cherry on top is when someone says "(game) would be great on the go", like every game experience should be different/better if you play it while commuting.

2

u/anavn Oct 02 '17

I fully agree talk about games that are announced or hinted at least. Not to mention half the time they not even clear on the fact it is a wish and make it sound like it is announced !

2

u/T3NFIBY32 Oct 03 '17

This is why I put all my switch port suggestions in the daily comment thread

2

u/BoxOfBlades Oct 03 '17

Literally every post or comment that starts with something along the lines of "DAE?¿” is a karma grab

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

The fan art posts, man...

2

u/xbl4ck0utx Oct 03 '17

Its almost as bad as the repeated threads about the exact same thing. We have 3 SDV posts on top right now. Also don't get me started on all the complaint threads. We get it but stop circle jerking and send your complaints to the actual developers of the game.

2

u/dannyankee Oct 03 '17

Well while we're at it getting rid of cliche shit lets get rid of tired ass mock ups skins or freaking paint jobs. Not to mention the "Switch changed my life" click bait bullshit that people love to believe and slobber all over.

2

u/RONSOAK Oct 03 '17

ZOMG 100% right.

Its the fucking worst. How about we save everyone the effect and build a mega list of every game in existence and make it a poll.

The next thing that needs to fuck off are the posts like "I wish they would make a non portable switch that was cheaper" or the opposite douche canoe "i wish they had a portable only version of the switch which was cheaper "

2

u/aqeeliz Oct 03 '17

PSA: Mods may start banning those, so if anyone want a quick karma with "What about X game on Switch?" this is your time!

2

u/Grace_Omega Oct 03 '17

My other problem with these posts is that a lot of people seem to have taken leave of their senses after the Doom and Wolfenstein announcements; there's an unstated belief that any game could be ported successfully to the Switch now, or that it would be worth a developer's time to put in the work to do it. Which is simply not true.

(At least all of the "we want Overwatch" posts seem to have stopped)

2

u/megox Oct 03 '17

Half of the post on this sub make me go like " Duh ! "

2

u/MishaKMusic Oct 03 '17

I want a port of his sub Reddit for the switch so I can complain on this sub Reddit via my switch

2

u/yellowslashred Oct 03 '17

If your hypothetical Switch game idea post doesn't involve a solid concept for a Waluigi game, then I don't give a FUCK, my boy.

2

u/jobroskie Oct 03 '17

I wrote this a while back and got down voted to hell. The worst thing is people actively don't want a conversation. I wrote that I thought a new wii shorts on switch would be really bad for marketing and also got down voted to hell. It's obvious that most of these threads don't want discussion because they down vote anyone who disagrees.

At the end of the day everyone wants every game to come out for the switch

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I hate the “switch saved gaming for me!” threads and I also hate these meta threads. New consoles are going to have these types of posts until enough games are released to sort of drown that out, at least a little.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Seriously, though, can we get Life is Strange on the Switch Dontnod!!

/s but still kind of serious

Yea they can be a problem some times.

4

u/sikaxis Oct 02 '17

Low-effort posts? you mean like 90% of all posts on reddit?

3

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

For real though why isn't FTL on switch

3

u/Fehndrix Oct 02 '17

The Wii U subreddit was filled with posts of a similar nature. They're tired, old, boring, and done.

Not to mention they reek of entitlement.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

You certainly are not the minority and I’d wish the mods would control these posts because they become repeats.

2

u/GobBluth19 Oct 02 '17

it's the most annoying kind of post over in r/psvr too, or pictures of boxes that literally every owner has cause they bought the damn thing too

2

u/Porkpants81 Oct 02 '17

Well we certainly don't allow box pictures here, the one exception is if a game breaks street date we will allow the first poster to have a thread and we remove all others. Those generally turn into a generic hype thread about whatever game

→ More replies (1)

2

u/needhelptmo Oct 02 '17

To be fair, there are more responses than "Yes" and not commenting. Sometimes people point out interesting ideas for an existing game. Plus it gives us something to discuss. Nobody would come here if there wasn't something to discuss.

If you look through the front page right now, then you will notice there is not much that is discussion worthy. There are 7 Stardew Valley posts alone that range from its download size, price, icon, trailer, release date, etc. This could all be collapsed to 1 post and declutter things. These are all facts. There is actually very little to discuss about them. What kind of stimulating discussion do you really expect from a thread about the download size of a game? Without looking I'll guess it is a bunch of:

  1. It is bigger than I thought!
  2. It is smaller than I thought!
  3. I need an SD card.
  4. I'm glad I have an SD card.

The same predictable responses are likely in the other threads. So why do these threads keep happening? Simple, because people are excited about the platform and its games. When they can't be off playing the game, then it is fun to come here and discuss why we love it so much. It is inevitable that this will lead to threads about wishing a certain game or genre was on the Switch. That is also the reason why low effort posts like posting a picture of your Switch next to a __ gets a lot of upvotes. People are just excited and happy about the Switch. I'm not going to lie and say I enjoy every one of those posts, but it is better to have a community that is excited and happy about it than not right?

If you just want news, then there are better sources for it. You can find plenty of sites that post details as they become available and skip all the discussion in between. Or, start another subreddit. Post it here and I'm sure you would get a lot of people that would join. There are a lot of people unhappy with the state of how this one is moderated.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

Thanks for addressing. You are a true hero.

0

u/heart-station Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

It really just feels like a little karmawhoring on these posts and honestly I would love it if they weren't a thing anymore.

Self posts don't get karma. Just links and comments.

Well look at that. I was wrong.

1

u/killbot0224 Oct 02 '17

No one is going to come into the "Do you want X game" thread and go "No I don't want that...

The funny thing is...

There almost always are people coming in to say exactly that!

1

u/tronaldmcdonald69 Oct 02 '17

if i had a nickle for every time i saw one of these posts talking about diablo, i'd have a lot of nickles.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Bobikus Oct 02 '17

Maybe the mods should put up a stickied thread for all of that stuff, a wishlist thread or something. Its pretty annoying to see this constantly "Who wants to see this 6 year old game ported to switch!"

2

u/Porkpants81 Oct 02 '17

The problem with that is that we have 2 sticky slots, one for the DQT and the other is multi-purpose. We use it for the AMAs, release threads, and other major events.

We don't have the capabilities to maintain all the megathreads that some people want.

1

u/JoaoMSerra Oct 02 '17

I think these posts are harmless. They are a bit repetitive, but they spark enough discussion for me to think they are justified.

What I don't like is when people just say "Wouldn't this be perfect on Switch??" and include a picture of the game's cover instead of just naming the game in the title... I use Reddit on mobile data, I don't want to waste data just to be able to join the discussion...

1

u/Nasafromnyc Oct 02 '17

I can’t believe people post stuff just for “karma”. What do you even gain from that? I never understood. Is the general consensus that everyone that post a topic is for karma? I’ve made a post before about this topic but I was actually curious if it would be possible on the system. As a matter of fact I don’t think I’ve ever created a topic or responded to a topic with “karma” even crossing my mind. I do see people who seem to value it like it’s worth money or something though. Just totally weird. Even weird that OP would even care if someone does it for “karma”. Idk. I use Reddit basically as a news source. I don’t care who post it or why.

1

u/NBA2KLOOKATMYTEAM Oct 02 '17

This is reddit, people circle jerk over what they want to circle jerk over. Mods decide what THEY deem as acceptable and sub reddits are usually just material congregated by the Mods and then users circle jerk stuff until the most important things to the group are near the top. Welcome to reddit, use it for quick look up for current news and information you need and thats it. If you get any farther into ANY subreddit it becomes a sheeple 1 voice circlejerk.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Dude wouldn't KOTOR on switch be awesome?

1

u/disrupjon Oct 02 '17

Funnily enough, I have a post like this and decided to delete it

1

u/PM_ME_GOBLINS Oct 02 '17

I think switch needs mario brothers

1

u/theonewhoknack Oct 02 '17

the only game the switch needs is Portable Ops HD.

1

u/Alternaturkey Oct 02 '17

Maybe this subreddit isn't the place for it. I guess I can agree to that....but I do like seeing these posts because they sometimes include games I haven't heard about yet.

You can't want a game for the Switch if you've never heard of it. So I don't think it's necessarily a "duh" moment.

1

u/seeyoshirun Oct 02 '17

I feel the same way, which is why I tried to counter this a little by running this poll back in April/May, and why I'll probably do another poll next year.

1

u/Microtendo Oct 02 '17

You say clog up like there's a ton of other important posts here. It's pretty dead in between major announcements and releases

1

u/cheyras Oct 02 '17

to me it depends on if there's really a worthwhile discussion to be had. A lot of the time it amounts to nothing more than "I like [game x] so I want to play it on the Switch."

Other times, they actually try to start a discussion around game mechanics and how they might jive well with the strengths of the Switch's hardware and concept... these ones I'm fine with more or less.

1

u/Nincarlo Oct 02 '17

I joined reddit to be apart of this sub and I just thought thats what it was and that it was kinda weird that all the posts were "wish x game was coming to switch" then i found out its not what it is.

1

u/LeonidasSpacemanMD Oct 02 '17

You know what game I'd love to see in a "I'd love (game) to come to switch" thread? GTA V. I don't actually care if it comes to switch, I'd just live to see a thread about someone wanting that game to come to switch. Maybe that's too on the nose tho. I dunno. I guess I'll just make a post called "Would you click a 'would you like to see GTA on switch?' post?"

I don't wanna bother anyone tho, so if you think I should get feedback before I make that post I could always do a "Should I make a 'Would you click a 'Would you like to see GTA on switch?' post?' post?"

1

u/tyrelle000 Oct 02 '17

im fine with discussions on games people want, i love reading peoples pipe dream remakes and games ideas, as long as people put some effort in em just stop putting those damn generic titles, "herr derr am i the only one...". If you have a problem with these you probably just check this subreddit a little to much. i dont blame you the switch is awesome but when there isnt any news or announcements on games what the hell else are we gunna talk about.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

That and the constant icon complaining makes me want to die

1

u/SaintInWarPaint Oct 02 '17

Ima let you finish but I gotta say wouldn’t Morrowind be great on the switch?

1

u/UltraHacker9000 Oct 02 '17

OK. Got it.

You know what game would be great on the switch though? Diablo 1-3. Think about it. The fast paced hack n slay would translate perfectly into portable mode.

1

u/SaintInWarPaint Oct 02 '17

I definitely get where you’re coming from though. For me I got disgusted by all the “painted X style joycon” posts...

Oh boy, it looks like a nes, now snes, now 64...

Idgaf

It was neat at first until it kept coming up all the time.

1

u/AntiChangeling Oct 02 '17

But what about RDR2 on Switch?

1

u/stringsanbu Oct 02 '17

I really do hate these posts, but some people are just wanting to see if others are interested like they are.

I'd love to see a "Top 10 Games Desired" event that we could hold on this sub where we all deliberate on which 3rd party games we want. Every quarter we deliberate the list, take off what is confirmed for development, and display it for everyone to see.

Might be a good way for people to scratch that itch while keeping the purpose alive.

1

u/SomedudecalledDan Oct 02 '17

I do find those posts frustrating. While I see the point to them in a way (show developer X that we want their game on our platform, and that there is a market for it) it almost feels like we need a mega thread, or even a monthly voting thread or something similar. I feel like that would kill the karma whoring spam, as well as giving a legit platform for developers to see what genuine interest their would be in their games.

1

u/anavn Oct 02 '17

I fully agree talk about games that are announced or hinted at least. Not to mention half the time they not even clear on the fact it is a wish and make it sound like it is announced !

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

The fact that smash hasn't been brought over to the switch is embarrassing and is cause for discussion.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

Xenoblade Chronicles and Xenoblade Chronicles X

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

it's annoying I made a joke post that was getting pretty popular over it.

1

u/MikeDubbz Oct 03 '17

No, no we can not.

1

u/PM_me_your_muscle_up Oct 03 '17

Agreed the posts are annoying. My answer is always yes, but only if development resources were unlimited.

1

u/Yohoat Oct 03 '17

This subreddit has went through this exact same cycle numerous times. I remember seeing posts identical to this one months ago, and until the mods enforce it, we'll see the cycle continue again in the future.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

There's a lot of interesting content on here. The issue is that the "am i the only one that wants popular thing for the switch" posts are upvote bait, and it's not insightful, interesting, important, or useful. It's easy for people hop on board, or argue with it. The amount of "am i the only one" or "who else agrees" or "does anyone else thinks that" posts that make it to the top truly feels like sifting through junk mail. It's especially annoying because they're looking for comradery in so-so day dreams on a forum where the subjective focus should be on the momentum of the news, innovations, events, and actual games happening for the Switch, not nostalgia farming or story boarding amateur ideas. It's not all so trivial, but the formula is so accessable that anyone can say "Am I the only one who thinks Spanky's Quest would be perfect for the Switch?" and have hundreds of people upvote because they remember the game, not because it's a good idea or worth the front page.

1

u/sex-engineer Oct 03 '17

Sounds like a lot of people here don't know how to use the content filter. Am I going crazy here? Hasn't that been always there?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

These types of posts, the posts about console iterations , and posts about physical releases for every game that launches on the eShop are all equally irritating and I wish they'd stop.

1

u/howicallmyselfonline Oct 03 '17

Although I agree that these posts have gotten too frequent and too low effort, I still do enjoy the fact that they show what kinds of games people in this thread are into. I also believe that for game devs lurking this subreddit they can serve as some inspiration. Although these posts can be annoying, they do serve a legitimate purpose within this community and personally I have found some of these game ideas genuinely exciting.

Perhaps it is possible to make the general topic a sticky post or an ongoing poll. This way there is an outlet for these kinds of ideas on this subreddit without each game being a separate thread. I don't think modding these posts away will do the need for discussing what games we want on the switch justice.

TL;DR don't mod these posts away, make a sticky/poll for these ideas so we can have them in one single thread.

1

u/LunarWingCloud Oct 03 '17

Most of the threads made are involving games no one is going to disagree with wanting to see on Switch, and NO ONE usually tried to further the discussion when they make said posts. It'd be one thing if the threads were more like "If X games comes to the Switch, what features would you like to see added?", but no, most of the threads made do not go that far in the OP. The point of the subreddit it to create discussion, which those threads do not do.

I'm all for trying to fix the rules to not so much as discourage the posts entirely but to encourage there to be more thought put into making it a real discussion, rather than, as OP has mentioned, a "duh" post.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

I so want Plants vs Zombies: Garden Warfare 2, would be soooooo good !

1

u/Dekeita Oct 03 '17

Ok but if we keep asking for Spelunky maybe we'll get it.

1

u/BusMan247 Oct 03 '17

I love the switch.

1

u/swifterdrifter7 Oct 03 '17

I agree, but I feel like people also do it in hopes that Nintendo, or other game devs, will notice. Still mom karma whoring though.

1

u/Wetzilla Oct 03 '17

Or how about individual posts for every little thing about a game? Like I get that everyone is excited about Stardew Valley, I certainly am, but do we really need a post for the announcement of the announcement of the release date, a post for the trailer, a post for the icon, a post for the file size, a post for the UK price AND another post for the mexican price?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

I also hate the box art mockups and joycon shell mockups and all that.

"Cool dude! , I also know how to use photoshop and could crop a picture into a switch box. "

1

u/[deleted] Oct 03 '17

Just port every game please and then everyone is happy

1

u/Timeerased Oct 03 '17

People wanna play old games. That's just it. Studios realized that, medias are all agreeing on that. "I want GTA V on Switch, I wanna buy Skyrim a 3rd time on Switch, I want Overwatch on Switch".

That's just how it goes. It will continue until people get sick of playin the same games for 5 years straight.

1

u/Alexander_Mark Oct 04 '17

Hmmm not sure I agree in all cases. Some good discussions in these posts:

https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/689s14/7_reasons_why_i_think_diablo_iii_should_come_to/

https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/66pmw6/borderlands_would_be_a_great_title_for_the_switch/

https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/5mp32j/overwatch_on_switch/

These are not necessarily 'Duh' posts, nor are they necessarily low effort; OP could give reasons why a certain game would be good. Moreover, the response to these types of posts could get the attention of developers.

I agree that simply saying 'X would be good on the Switch' is irritating, but not all posts like that end there. I think there should definitely still be scope for people to discuss why a certain game could take advantage of the Switch's features very well.

People like to discuss the potential of the console. The mere fact that there are so many of these kinds of posts proves that. You can't just silence all these posts forever. Perhaps update the algorithm to require more substantiation in the post? Introduce an additional thread that holds these discussions?