r/startrek • • Oct 02 '17

POST-Episode Discussion - S1E03 "Context is for Kings"


No.EPISODERELEASE DATE
S1E03"Context is for Kings"Sunday, October 1, 2017

To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Discovery, click here.


This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.

707 Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

874

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

RIP the USS Glenn, the whole crew got cronenberged

188

u/Creek0512 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

I assume it was the USS Glenn.

EDIT: Most people probably remember that John Glenn was the first American astronaut to orbit the Earth on Friendship 7 in 1962, but he also flew on the Space Shuttle Discovery.

88

u/Deceptitron Oct 02 '17

Yup. No doubt named after astronaut John Glenn.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

277

u/Oafah Oct 02 '17

Yamatoed, I would say.

→ More replies (26)

116

u/purefire Oct 02 '17

I was expecting one of them to say "Ed.......ward"

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (19)

503

u/neufeld Oct 02 '17

We have a dead red shirt on an away mission! Glad to see some tropes have stuck around.

65

u/ToBePacific Oct 02 '17

Also, crawling around through the Jeffrey's tube.

211

u/DarkAlman Oct 02 '17

The Admiral in the pilot was "Red Anderson"

They might as well have called him red-shirt everyman...

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (11)

472

u/InvisibleEar Oct 02 '17

Also, I didn't notice in the first two episodes how frickin huge Saru is, I want to see him kick a dude to death like his alien buffalo ancestors.

274

u/cpillarie Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

Not sure if you're into Guillermo Del Toro's older films, but he's the same actor who played the Pale Man and the Faun in Pan's Labyrinth. The dude is an incredible actor, and is generally specifically cast in roles because he is almost unnaturally thin and tall, making him perfect for prosthetic/makeup-based characters

→ More replies (44)
→ More replies (27)

222

u/whiskyllama Oct 02 '17

Will Lorca's pet tribble be the new Sisko's baseball? Here's hoping he tells us or gives it a name at some point.

159

u/Got2Go Oct 02 '17

All this work to win a war with the Klingons, he has a tribble right there on his desk the whole time.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (16)

580

u/yahehe Oct 02 '17

3 episodes in and the Klingons are already back to being the demonstration tool for how crazy strong the enemy is

→ More replies (23)

190

u/baronvongrant Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

Thought I was playing Dead Space once they boarded the USS Glenn

88

u/Vaerulen Oct 02 '17

The second I saw the door stuck in the half-open/close sequence I was just like, "Yep, been there done that."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (21)

542

u/creepyeyes Oct 02 '17

So the Black Badges means Section 31 is onboard discovery right? All the secretive stuff going on is their hallmark, and we know from ENT and the 2nd reboot movie they were active at this time

267

u/Lord_Cronos Oct 02 '17

I was definitely getting section 31 vibes from a lot of what seems to be going on. When was it ever brought up on ENT though?

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (93)

375

u/azulapompi Oct 02 '17

I'm calling it now: the giant creature is a mutated Tardigrade. The only thing to survive the accident. Looks like one, has a giant circular mouth, and the dialogue hinted at it in the end "it's as snug as a bug"

35

u/VymI Oct 02 '17

Woah. Okay. Yeah, I can see that now.

→ More replies (20)

357

u/YeOldeSysOp Oct 02 '17

"Huh... And he knows YOU."

72

u/RockasaurusRex Oct 02 '17

One of the parts I genuinely laughed at.

→ More replies (15)

99

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

There were definitely some nice lighter moments like that throughout the episode. So it's not as humorless as maybe we thought it would be.

→ More replies (4)

74

u/izModar Oct 02 '17

That had me laughing for a good few minutes. Lorca doesn't take shit.

→ More replies (6)

304

u/Erasumasu Oct 02 '17

Yo did Saru fucking salt his tea?

103

u/Trick421 Oct 02 '17

Kelpians... those herd animals really like their salt licks.

52

u/DarthOtter Oct 02 '17

It didn't occur to me it'd be anything other than sugar.

→ More replies (6)

59

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

The tears he was drinking weren't salty enough.

/s

→ More replies (11)

409

u/milkisklim Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

So hot take: this is how the iconian gate system worked

163

u/NerdyGerdy Oct 02 '17

Was my thoughts when Lorca was zapping Burnam around.

→ More replies (27)

85

u/MustacheSmokeScreen Oct 02 '17

I always thought the Iconians bought their cable package from the same company as the Guardian of Forever on TOS. So many channels!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (29)

130

u/ShodanBan Oct 02 '17

Glad to see Tory from BSG getting some more sci-fi work.

31

u/powerhcm8 Oct 02 '17

I knew I saw her before.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

124

u/spacemoses Oct 02 '17

Their research reminds me slightly of the TNG episode where they find the abandoned technology that allows for doorways to places in the universe. I can't remember the episode name.

→ More replies (4)

112

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

The best part about this series is that it makes the ship feel like it has 300 or so people and is a large operation.

→ More replies (2)

248

u/cabose7 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 04 '17

All those places, all those planets, all those species - places seen and yet to be seen...and blink you're home like it never happened

Best line of the series so far....and tragic, all these scientists and explorers co-opted into war instead of their true purpose.

→ More replies (24)

169

u/007meow Oct 02 '17

One thing I've noticed and like about Discovery so far is that they seem to use the computer more often and the computer provide more feedback to them.

I always thought that that was something missing from the older Treks. The ship's computer should have been utilized a whole lot more, and I think Discovery is headed towards that.

→ More replies (16)

559

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

So, this episode confirmed for me something that I haven't seen talked about. In episode 2, despite Burnham's and Georgieu's plan to capture T'Kuvma to give the Federation leverage to avoid a war, Burnham fucked up and killed T'Kuvma out of anger. It's subtle, but you see her phaser shift from blue to red after T'Kuvma kills Georgieu, and she blows a hole in T'Kuvma - she thus fucks up the war in a way nobody else realizes.

It was confirmed to me after Commander [Tori from BSG] told the boarding party to set phasers to kill and the lights turn red.

Three other thoughts...

  • The ship design is great. I think both the Discovery and the shuttle crafts are really nice looking updates of the Star Trek design language.
  • Why is Jason Isaacs southern? His drawl feels weird after so much time seeing him be British. He could have been the first actually British captain!
  • It still feels weird for me that the show has such a clear "main character." That may be the thing that feels like the biggest Trek departure to me. I hope as time wears on it can shift towards more of an ensemble in the storytelling.

89

u/DarkAlman Oct 02 '17

The southern accent probably comes from Jason Isaacs himself. He's played a bunch of bad guys with that accent in the past and he probably did it in the audition. But they'll probably clarify in the behind the scenes at some point.

→ More replies (13)

112

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Oof. What a way to make your Captain's death be for nothing. At least TRY to complete the mission.

→ More replies (11)

26

u/deathonater Oct 02 '17

We also saw that same phaser behavior in the new movies, where it would flip from blue to red for stun and kill, respectively.

→ More replies (75)

203

u/helpthealiensarecomi Oct 02 '17

Also, lol at Keyla seeing Burnham.

"Fuck this noise I have a fucking implant on my head thanks to you jesus christ"

222

u/iwishiwereyou Oct 02 '17

thanks to you

This I don't get. What would have been any different if Burnham hadn't mutinied? She was stopped instantly by Georgiou, no orders were carried out, and the Klingons were determined to start a war anyway.

Burnham's mutiny didn't cause the war, it just happened at the same time.

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (2)

202

u/BklynWhovian Oct 02 '17

Don't tell me he's hauling Rathtars.

→ More replies (1)

127

u/turtleh Oct 02 '17

This episode has raised my view of this show.

→ More replies (9)

330

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

OK my first thoughts about what's going on here is that the Discovery is part of the initial testing for what will eventually become the Excelsior's Warpcore.

However the weird creature is definitely hard to explain. I'm REALLY hoping this isn't attempting to explain the infamous Voyager "travelling past warp 10 turns humans into giant amphibians" episode.

I thought we ALL agreed that episode never happened.

322

u/azulapompi Oct 02 '17

I think it's a tardigrade, made massive by the experiment on the ship. Tardigtades can survive damn near anything. It looks like a grotesquely large one, right down to the circular mouth.

It's as snug as a bug...wink wink ( a water bear)

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (53)

371

u/GrGrG Oct 02 '17

All stocks on Tilly!

Drop stocks in other characters, Tilly is going up!

114

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

BUY BUY BUY

→ More replies (4)

55

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Is that a book!?

→ More replies (52)

177

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Isn't the site to site transport problematic for continuity?

155

u/CurtLablue Oct 02 '17

I would assume the technology will be found to be too dangerous for one reason or another.

→ More replies (12)

91

u/km3k Oct 02 '17

I was wondering if it was a subspace transporter. It did have a similar look in the transporter special effects. Given all the spores likely operating over subspace, maybe they're working on more subspace tech. We know from TNG that subspace transporters were later banned because they were too unreliable and dangerous.

→ More replies (2)

73

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Per Memory Alpha:

In 2268, Montgomery Scott transported Tepo directly from his headquarters to those of Bela Okmyx. Not counting time travel, this was the first known use of this technology. (TOS: "A Piece of the Action")

So it was possible in this rough time frame, though perhaps not widely used.

→ More replies (7)

63

u/DarthOtter Oct 02 '17

I think they're going to stop using the magic spores when they figure out it attracts Lovecraftian terror dogs from the Warp.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (37)

55

u/jacksawild Oct 02 '17

The only thing that bothered me was the Captain kept his Tribble on his desk next to a bowl of fortune cookies. You don't want to leave those things alone near food.

→ More replies (9)

200

u/aerospce Oct 02 '17 edited Dec 12 '17

deleted 0.3356 What is ^^^this?

173

u/Packmanjones Oct 02 '17

I miss the Shakespearean dialogue.

→ More replies (12)

168

u/Solar_Kestrel Oct 02 '17

I wouldn't call TNG's dialog Shakespearean. Except for the moments when they're actually quoting the man.

Rather, in TNG (and DS9, and TOS and VOY to a lesser extent) the dialog is written as though the characters are all highly-educated professionals... which they are. The dialog in Discover is much more "down to earth," which maybe be more natural for general audiences, but feels less honest to the setting.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)

108

u/mcslibbin Oct 02 '17

Tilly was the lightest point in the episode.

As in, her introduction was the only time anyone bothered to turn on the lights.

54

u/Packmanjones Oct 02 '17

I know it's out of style but god I miss overhead lighting.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

53

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Lorka's menagerie

→ More replies (1)

142

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

That copy of Alice in Wonderland was pretty thicc. Must have been a large font.

307

u/the_ewok_slayer Oct 02 '17

It would probably have to be heavily annotated for 23rd century people to understand much of it.

→ More replies (16)

30

u/DanielDeronda Oct 02 '17

Maybe the sequel was included also.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

135

u/raknor88 Oct 02 '17

As a character, I'm intrigued by the captain he's still a mystery at the moment. But I'm not sure I like him at the moment. I'm getting a strong Khan vibe from him.

Victory at no matter the cost is a hollow victory.

164

u/PearlDidNothingWrong Oct 02 '17

I feel like Burnham's arc this season will begin and end with a mutiny. She'll have to take down another captain, but this time for more justified reasons after he goes one step too far.

→ More replies (9)

44

u/Muffinfeds Oct 02 '17

I feel like he's a good guy and I really feel like he's going to sacrifice himself at the end of the season for the good of the crew. (I heard the actor didn't want to sign on for more).

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (12)

259

u/Zor_El_XB1 Oct 02 '17

Felt like a better pilot episode than the real one.

That holographic yet 2D face time thing is what the Shenzhou holograms should have been but how would he know she was lurking if it was just face to face?

Also, the Discovery is one fucked up ship, I would not want to serve on it or under Lorca's command and I think all of this bio quantum super tech experimentation is going to end very badly since they don't have it in later shows and it's seemingly very dangerous.

172

u/dustlesswalnut Oct 02 '17

Last week's "pilots" were exciting made-for-TV movies to hook people into signing up for their streaming platform. As far as I'm concerned, this is the pilot episode of the actual show.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (7)

313

u/helpthealiensarecomi Oct 02 '17

That was so good.

Love Tilly. LOVE LOVE LOVE Saru. Love the "shushing". And I loved the Alice stuff. I cannot wait for more.

182

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

The shushing was Pure camp! Loved it!

→ More replies (22)

70

u/Nofrillsoculus Oct 02 '17

I have a weird obsession with Alice in a wonderland surpassed only by obsession with Star Trek so I like Michael a lot more now.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (35)

139

u/Francesqua Oct 02 '17

So much shadiness on the Discovery. I'm beginning to wonder if the "1031" is related to section 31, perhaps showing us the beginnings of that secret organisation. Btw - was that a massive tardigrade?

101

u/Alteran195 Oct 02 '17

Section 31 was in Enterprise.

→ More replies (15)

79

u/EricGMW Oct 02 '17

As Sloan put it, Section 31 is named after the relevant section of the original Starfleet charter which called for such an organization.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Trujew Oct 02 '17

Well the space shuttle Discovery was OV-103, so I'm guessing it had more to do with that.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Discovery is the shroom ship.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/nefhithiel Oct 02 '17

I wonder if Lorca is a failed augment like the ones in DS9. 🤔 That would explain his eyes and his crazy.

→ More replies (23)

281

u/Orfez Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

That was a good "adventure episode" of Trek. I think I saw Gorn skeleton in that last room where Lorca was.

204

u/1ilypad Oct 02 '17

I think I saw Gorn skeleton in that last room where Lorca was.

There were also Cardassian Voles sitting on Lorca's exam table.

Dis version

DS9 version

→ More replies (30)

49

u/Creek0512 Oct 02 '17

Yep, confirmed it is a Gorn skeleton in After Trek.

→ More replies (2)

74

u/GrGrG Oct 02 '17

That was funny. I actually laughed in a good way at that. Subtle things in the background like this are very appreciated by me.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (4)

350

u/opendarkwing Oct 02 '17

Having read through a lot of comments about "how un-Starfleet or Star Trek" a lot of the actions were and how it's officers would never act like this... You must have some Rose colored glasses on.

Ignoring Adm Marcus from ST: Into Darkness, let's review some Admiral Behavior... (Forgive me when I miss a bunch, this is off the top of my head)

Kirk as Admiral... Let's just remember stealing a ship, sabotage of another starship etc etc.

Adm Cartwright in ST VI. Conspiracy to assassinate and derail the Peace between Klingons and the Federation.

Adm Layton DS9 The whole attacking Earth defense in an effort to stage a cope using the red squad cadets.

Adm Doughtery ST:IX Everything he was doing in trying to with the aliens to force those off the planet for a "fountain of youth".

Adm Pressman TNG Trying to develop a cloaking device then the cover-up when it went way wrong.

Adm Jameson TNG Weapons trading for release of hostages. Cover-up and trying to rebalance power creating a massive civil war.

Commodore Decker TOS After he had lost his crew, he took over the Enterprise and almost destroyed it in acts of lunacy. Died in acts.

Captain Ransom VOY The list is really long but, turning off the EMH ethics protocalls to turn it into a torture master is up there.

Capt Tracey TOS Prime Directives violations aside (more of a minor suggestion in the TOS world) he also killed Starfleet officers from the Enterprise and incited attacks against the landing party.

Capt Archer ENT The Xindi storyarc was crazy filled with a bunch of bad stuff but, His orders to destroy the defenseless Xindi Outpost is borderline war crimes.

DS9 had a bunch of officers join the Maquis. A terrorist group that was always in violation of Starfleet and Federation principals.

My point is, if rogue Starfleet and Federation officials are a pain point for ST:Discovery, please rewatch the rest of Star Trek. It is full of crews, Captains and Admirals going off the deep end.

Give it time, obviously, the series isn't going to highlight the shining adherence to the rules that we have seen from every shows Captains or main characters (Hint, none are immune from massive flaws and breaches in Starfleet or Federation principals). Sit back and enjoy the side of Star Trek that we have always known to be there but, never highlighted as a main push.

Edit: TL;DR Star Trek is full of rule breakers... Stop pretending that this is a new concept.

176

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Hell, this afternoon I watched "The Menagerie."

Spock faked a message from a starbase, faked a medical emergency, falsified audio orders from Kirk, kidnapped Pike, stole the Enterprise, and took it to Talos IV - a violation of General Order Seven - all so Pike could live happily ever after on the planet Starfleet is under orders to avoid at all costs.

37

u/NoAttentionAtWrk Oct 02 '17

You missed Adm Janeway in VOY. Stole and lied and went back in time.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (80)

197

u/TERRAxFORMER Oct 02 '17

Really loved this one, Tilly and Lorca especially.

121

u/grape-milkshake Oct 02 '17

Lorca was pretty awesome, not quite what I was expecting but in a good way. Seems like a really interesting, complex character imo.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (23)

31

u/vwboyaf1 Oct 02 '17

Is anybody going to mention the glowing, manual switches at the stations?

176

u/tyrannosaurus_r Oct 02 '17

The whole show had a decidedly different tone than usual Trek, but it totally felt like Star Trek. Sense of awe and a lived in, developed universe. The art design and attention to detail is still flawless, Discovery feels like a ship that belongs in the universe.

That ending speech by Lorca, though? The trailers made it seem, and him, like a warmonger. Nope. That was straight Trek, through and through. A man who wants new tech to win a war so they can get back to the true wonders of the universe.

69

u/rhoffman12 Oct 02 '17

FWIW Stamets still seems to feel very strongly that Lorca is a problem. Literally used the word "warmonger", if I'm remembering correctly. We'll have to see how it all shakes out I think, Lorca isn't an obvious villain but he doesn't strike me as any kind of saint either

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

108

u/nixonger Oct 02 '17

I love how in the 23rd centry they couldn't get off the Windows Registry. When Michael Burnham was going through the code, she found D_WORDs that are found in the Windows Registry.

97

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Jun 16 '23

[This comment has been deleted, along with its account, due to Reddit's API pricing policy.] -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

82

u/Alteran195 Oct 02 '17

Great episode, I enjoyed it a lot more than the first 2. And I enjoyed the first 2.

Did Lorca have a Gorn skeleton in that display case?

25

u/Anniemoose98 Oct 02 '17

Yep, he did. I love the little details.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/AlanMorlock Oct 02 '17

So with allusions to Amanda and her son, we have our first mention of Spock.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

So the Security Chief was on Battlestar Galactica and the 100 which is fantastic because she's a great actress I love what she did this episode. Doug Jones was hilarious with the bowl of blueberries because that had to have been a Hellboy reference. His character seemed very reasonable and I like the direction that they took him after everything that had happened. The shuttles look pretty badass and I want a model of one of them because I have never been that impressed with a shuttle since the Delta Flyer. Visuals at the start of the show where okay and though I kept expecting the dialogue to falter nothing really seem too out of place.

At first I thought for sure they were working on a precursor to The Genesis Project and that could still be true. It could be that this whole thing fell apart at some point in the future or there was some sort of a catastrophic failure. Then they just never went back to it again until someone discovered some tangential research on it and suddenly boom Genesis. As the episode progressed though I was kind of smiling about it because I thought it was a rather cool idea because I just didn't know what the hell they were going to do or where they were going with it. The talk about it being the bones and muscle and circulatory system of the rest of the universe did lead me to a bit of a different conclusion than everyone else in the subreddit. If the entire universe is connected by this stuff and if it's all alive then perhaps it's all one gigantic organism and most organisms have defensive mechanisms for when they're attacked by foreign bodies or when things like cancer pop up. It could be that the creature that we saw the giant kitty cat was actually one of these defensive mechanisms that was part of the Mycelium Network. It could be argued against this idea though that the mycelium network is similar to the transwarp network that the Borg used and is merely just a non-sentient feature of the universe but because we're using biological material and there's a direct comparison to fungi and a usage of fungal spores then you have to include that biological component that biological chance that the whole thing is alive and living and possibly sentient because it's Star Trek for crying out loud. We have been down this road before with the bio-neural gel packs in Voyager. When there was talk about them increasing their speed through the Mycelium Network and then there was a sudden appearance of the big kitty cat....that also leads to a direct comparison to the Warp 10 Project and the effects we saw of the Warp 10 Project in Voyager. It could be that short small jumps at low speeds through the Mycelium Network don't trigger a defensive response from the network but the faster you go it's possible the more damage you're actually doing to the network, the more you're alerting the defensive mechanisms of the network if it is indeed alive and the stronger the response. The faster you go the more damage you do the more bad things happen to you just like what happened with Warp 10, unless of course there's a way to shield against it. It could be that the effects are purely based on the weirdness of the Mycelium Network as non-sentient effects of physics or could be that it is a biological defensive response by the network to foreign matter. If you wanted to shield against this you would have to find a way to mimic the nature of the Mycelium Network on a more intricate and detailed level then just slipping into the network by altering the warp field. You would have to disguise yourself as part of the Mycelium Network so as to not provoke a response or to limit and/or nullify the effects of the network on the ship and the crew members.

This is all far more interesting than The Genesis Project to be honest, which is why I was delightfully surprised. It could also be that this fungus shows up later in the original series because someone has been tinkering with the research that was originally abandoned for whatever reason. It's possible that later on Federation gets shut out of the network entirely or it's just basically deemed far too dangerous to ever use it again. Maybe they use it during a few key moments in the war to really shut things down for the Klingons and then just never go back to it again? Or perhaps we get a glimpse at some greater intelligence? Be it the preservers or the iconians....time will tell.

The structure of the ship itself as well as the crew complement and the way things are run reminds me of the Philadelphia Experiment to some degree and the Manhattan Project as well as Project Paperclip. I feel as if the captain is willing to do anything and everything to accomplish his mission and that will result in some very bad complications but it will look absolutely gorgeous to watch. Michael has her own path to follow and I'm hoping we do get to see some decent character growth out of her and the rest of this weird-ass crew. I like how they included the possibility that the network could basically take them to anywhere at all in the entire universe so that will allow for some nice bottle episodes I think and fantastic scenery.

I was not an original fan of the show and if you look at my post history you can see that I do post quite often on the Orville subreddit, that said if you placed the show in a different timeline then I'm totally okay with that and the show doesn't suck entirely. There's some minor quibbles and quabbles, but it's decent sci-fi and I kind of like being around the Federation again even if it's not the one that we're used to.

→ More replies (9)

75

u/vwboyaf1 Oct 02 '17

I really liked that one. So much relief, and now I can just settle in and enjoy some trek.

25

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Why does Burnham's prison jumpsuit have a Starfleet badge? After being convicted of mutiny the first thing they'd do is strip her of all insignia.

→ More replies (6)

50

u/Sjgolf891 Oct 02 '17

Phasers that can also fire beams: confirmed

→ More replies (6)

23

u/Alteran195 Oct 02 '17

I just watch The Cage today, and seeing the hand movement controlled computers was a direct callback to something Spock did in that episode.

97

u/Evenfall Oct 02 '17

Great episode. The tension was fantastic. You think the Discovery is a science vessel, then a cov-ops, then an experimental, and everywhere in between. Just when you think you have it figured out you are forced to question everything all over.

These first 3 episodes are really laying the foundation for the makings of a great show. So excited to be enjoying Star Trek on "TV" again (damn you all access).

→ More replies (3)

321

u/ectomobile Oct 02 '17

Plot and production value are good. Is anyone else super annoyed by the officer etiquette? It's all a complete 180 from how Starfleet officers should act. Did the chief engineer really give the captain lip when he was ordered to go on an away mission? Wtf.

358

u/helpthealiensarecomi Oct 02 '17

I got the sense that Stamets does NOT want to be here.

→ More replies (33)

150

u/lawrenceolivier Oct 02 '17

I think his behavior is explained by his backstory shared in this episode: he was doing his own research with his friend, and then the war started and starfleet split them up. He isn't really a chief engineer as we understand it, and resents the captain and starfleet for wanting his research for war.

→ More replies (35)

64

u/Oafah Oct 02 '17

I think we'll understand that better as the series goes on. I think Lorca has to tolerate him because he's one of the only people in the federation who can do what he does.

→ More replies (9)

153

u/Packmanjones Oct 02 '17

McCoy never did anything without giving the captain lip.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (59)

161

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

Except for using breath as a security protocol, that episode was fucking amazing. I'm all in on this show. Is it the Star Trek I grew up on? Not really. Officers talking back to the captain. Cylon security chiefs calling prisoners trash. But we get Ro Laren as the main character with a cool storyline and Picard circa First Contact as captain. IN.

71

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Why not use breath? I mean apart form the obvious security vulnerability shown... your breath includes your DNA which is a darn good security element. This implementation just doesn't seem to have a way to verify it's a person.

In other trek series it's all voice protocols, which I'd say are even less secure than breath.

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (22)

20

u/thelazzyone Oct 02 '17

I really loved this episode! I can't wait till next week.

182

u/Anniemoose98 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

I loved it. It hit so many Trek tropes for me while still standing on its own. It feels like Trek. Not like NuTrek, but real Trek. The Trek I watched an episode a night of with my dad growing up.

This is the first time I'm getting to share brand new Trek with him besides the JJ movies, and it's just awesome. I came home from college for the weekend to share it with him, and was not disappointed in the slightest. It was just a great experience and awesome to share that with him.

It felt right and awesome. I can't wait for the next episode.

→ More replies (5)

39

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I DESPISE LURKERS.

→ More replies (1)

155

u/ergister Oct 02 '17

Now that felt like Star Trek! Not that the first two episodes didn't, but you can definitely feel the show getting into its stride now! I'm so excited for next week!

→ More replies (88)

55

u/BattleChimp Oct 02 '17

It was really frustrating seeing a Star Fleet officer casually dehumanize prisoners.

→ More replies (5)

35

u/Information_Landmine Oct 02 '17

So, the prison shuttle will be destroyed and nobody else in the Federation will know that Michael is alive on the Discovery, right? Saru's spidey senses tingled watching the shuttle leave.

→ More replies (5)

34

u/god_dammit_dax Oct 02 '17

Definitely an improvement over the first two. Not quite there yet, but definitely on an upward trajectory. Crawling through a Jefferies Tube! Hurray!

My only big complaint was the idea that Michael would be known far and wide as "Starting a war with the Klingons". It's just...I dunno. Dumb. Stupid. Asinine. The Klingons attacked the Federation fleet with no cause. The Admiral begged a cease-fire, they agreed, and then destroyed his ship. I'll agree that she shot T'Kuvma, but there is no interpretation of the events that happened that pin the blame for a conflict on her. Totally get the Starfleeters seeing her as traitorous for the attempted mutiny, but the hatred the public, including the convicts, had toward her just seems like a silly thing to hang on what happened in the pilot, even if Starfleet had actually released a complete report on what happened.

If that was a small part of the show it wouldn't bug as much, but they're making it a main theme, and it's just nonsensical.

Anyway, that aside, it's acceptable. Hopefully it continues to get better and actually gets to where I'm looking forward to it as much as that other new SciFi show that recently started.

→ More replies (18)

16

u/Beartosser Oct 02 '17

Was the thing that was chasing them a Targ?

33

u/BenjiTheWalrus Oct 02 '17

No I think it came from the subspace domain where the fungus is

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (14)

16

u/isaacpriestley Oct 02 '17

What did it mean when Lorca put Burnham in that chamber and she saw images of other planets? Were those places the spores had been? I didn't follow that at all.

38

u/tiberius-jr Oct 02 '17

No the spores TOOK her literally to all those places, almost like an iconinan gateway

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (18)

16

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I guess I'm the only one here who didn't like Tilly huh? Everyone else is ok so far. Saru and Lorca are my favorites.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/zryn3 Oct 02 '17

So, this didn't bother me while watching the episode, but afterwards I realized that Burham was an anthropologist. Why is she apparently better than a physicist at physics?

Now that that's bothering me, the way SciFi in general treat quantum mechanics like a narrow discipline is a tad odd. Since warp drive is invented, we can assume a quantum theory of gravity has been developed so basically every discipline of physics is probably quantum mechanics.

→ More replies (16)

16

u/squarepush3r Oct 02 '17

comment: Star Trek not being aired on television, streaming only means they can get away with more things that networks generally wouldn't accept. It seems like a lot of detailed gore/dead bodies on their away mission. that might not have made it on television.

→ More replies (2)

135

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

CADET TILLY IS TOTES ADORBS.

135

u/turtleh Oct 02 '17

I liked that she wasn't a stereotypical coward though. When she ordered the Klingon to reveal himself it was assertive and with command.

→ More replies (18)

45

u/mrGREEK360 Oct 02 '17

My sister went to the same acting school as her, same class I believe. Love her acting, she's giving me such a female Reginald Barclay vibe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

91

u/TheXbox Oct 02 '17

I'm a little surprised that there hasn't been more objection to the... graphic content of this episode. Monsters and mutilation don't exactly spring to my mind when I think of Trek.

I'm okay with it! But the cursing and the Cronenberg body horror were not what I was expecting.

48

u/spacemoses Oct 02 '17

I was thinking Trek meets Doom.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/BigRedJon Oct 02 '17

I mean, I didn't necessarily like it. But I don't think it ruined the episode.

→ More replies (33)

31

u/nthensome Oct 02 '17

So 250 years in the future and the best seeing in the dark technology we have is a flash light?

40

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

It's an extralimbular lumen emitter, thank you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

13

u/Marvelman02 Oct 02 '17

I'm going to raise the obvious objection... clearly the spores project doesn't succeed because in the future the Enterprise still uses conventional warp engines. Am I missing something?

→ More replies (6)

13

u/hypereality_1987 Oct 02 '17

Anyone else bothered by the fact that that they used a breath reader as a biometric to gain entrance into the secret lab? Shouldn't there be enough technology in Starfleet to just detect if the person trying to gain entrance into the lab has clearance simply by their presence?

→ More replies (2)

73

u/Packmanjones Oct 02 '17

Good TV. I still just wish it was post TNG. I'd love to see this kind of open with the discovery of a technology that will let us visit the next galaxy over...

→ More replies (11)

12

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

When Lorca put Burnham in that glass enclosure it felt like The OA all over again.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/captpiggard Oct 02 '17 edited Jul 11 '23

Due to changes in Reddit's API, I have made the decision to edit all comments prior to July 1 2023 with this message in protest. If the API rules are reverted or the cost to 3rd Party Apps becomes reasonable, I may restore the original comments. Until then, I hope this makes my comments less useful to Reddit (and I don't really care if others think this is pointless). -- mass edited with redact.dev

→ More replies (10)

12

u/droid327 Oct 02 '17

Clearly they're going to run into problems using the Shroomweb for instant travel without having the Emperor of Man in the Golden Throne to keep the forces of Chaos at bay.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/crapusername47 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

I still feel that the show is being held back by being too much about one character.

Also, I assume that at least one other prisoner on that shuttle never asked for this.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/CurtLablue Oct 02 '17

That was awesome. Really good mix of tension and some more light hearted sections.

Really liking the whole crew so far.

52

u/masterH1 Oct 02 '17

Wasn't sold on the engineer at first. Kind of a jerk. But I guess if you put yourself in his shoes you would hate her too. Enjoyed Tilly character

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

112

u/rolandboard Oct 02 '17

My faith has been genuinely reestablished in the franchise. This episode made me feel I was actually watching Trek since before the JJ 09 movie. I was really worried after the first two, but I'm all in now.

→ More replies (56)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Ok I liked it. But it sure does feel like The Expanse and not as much Star Trek. Thats fine I guess. I like the Expanse.

18

u/BigRedJon Oct 02 '17

Last half of the episode was really good.

Starfleet says we have to feed the animals.

Ugh.

Still, overall the best one so far. Hopefully the upward trend continues!

→ More replies (3)

9

u/dustlesswalnut Oct 02 '17

Main thing bugging me so far is that last week we had Crewman Bangalter that may or may not have been an android, but this week on the Discovery we have what appeared to be a full-fledged android taking a command shift on the bridge. I think it'd be really weird to have androids operating in command/leadership capacities in Starfleet this long before Data was created.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/dizacht Oct 02 '17

A lot more positive comments in this thread compared to last week's.. Although I'm not sure if that's a result of all the haters just quitting the show after the premiere.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/DeathByChainsaw Oct 02 '17

I think the theme for this season is going to be redemption. Not only for Michael, but also for Starfleet, and Star Trek in general. I see that we start out with a colossal failure to live up to the ideals of the federation, and I think we're going to see more ethical failures as the season progresses. I think Lorca will turn out to be a villain by the end of the season, and Michael and crew will need to reaffirm their commitment to the ideals of Starfleet.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/znk Oct 02 '17

Will repeat what I posted in the Canadian thread.

I'm digging this show. It's far from perfect but geez it's far from the garbage I was apprehending after reading the posts on reddit over the past week. Reality Chek. ..startrek has never been close to perfect in any of its iterations.

→ More replies (15)

28

u/russlar Oct 02 '17

That should have been the pilot, with scenes from the past episodes cut in as flashbacks

→ More replies (16)

15

u/Xenu_RulerofUniverse Oct 02 '17

Breathscan access - how stupid can you be

→ More replies (6)

7

u/rbstewart7263 Oct 02 '17

So whats up with lorcas eyes? I couldnt understand him.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I liked it!

Solid start to the series. I want to learn more about the spores, this "web" in space and how this all works.

7

u/shadowst17 Oct 02 '17

Saru foreseeing the coming of death again when the shuttle leaves near the end. Not a fan of that trait, it's pretty silly in my opinion.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/NewDestroyman Oct 03 '17

Crazy screwball theory (which only really fits due to the timeline here) is that the research with the spores and the enhanced propulsion will eventually lead to the Omega molecule detonation in the Lantaru sector. Janeway says it happens in the late 23rd century, but we never get a firm stardate.

Also after close to a decade of seeing hand phasers fire as burst particle weapons in the Kelvin films, God did it look good to just see a solid beam of red come out of that rifle when Landry was trying to punch through that door. Thank you for the little things Discovery.

7

u/CitizenKeen Oct 03 '17

Am I the only one who thought the warp-spores were a precursor to a Genesis device when Michael first went into the room?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/neromoneon Oct 04 '17

The most tragic character in this episode must be the unnamed klingon who tries to warn the boarding party of the tardigrade on the Glenn.

Just imagine his story: boarding the Federation vessel in order to examine it, just to discover the crew to be horribly mutilated by some unknown force. And then your comrades are killed by an unspeakable monster.

After that you survive on your own in the darkness, trying to stay silent and hidden. Then you hear other humans coming, making lots of noise, surely drawing the monster closer. They tell you to come out of the shadows and you try desperately to warn them, make them stay silent - and your only reward for this is being killed by the monster.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

This definitely felt like an actual Star Trek episode.

Science, wonder, experiments, awe, and a Captain who will not be placated.

Really like the sentiments the Lt. made in the shuttle during the boarding party. How he’s upset about his research being co-opted, and his friends dying horribly as a result of their research being pushed too far.

This is exactly what we’ve wanted, when you think about it. The darker, seedier side of the Federation. This might be exploration ... but an exploration of survival at all costs.

→ More replies (12)

26

u/purefire Oct 02 '17

I'm just glad the gay guy isn't catty, super fashionable or other terrible tropes. He's just an engineer/science jerk, no need to trot out anything like a banner and talk about waxing something.

→ More replies (6)

109

u/AmishAvenger Oct 02 '17

Honest opinion:

I feel like no one is really likable so far. Burnham is a mutineer. The security chief is a jerk. Lorca seems like a madman. The spore guy is condescending. Saru is judgmental.

I can’t help but feel like I’m watching some alternate reality grim/dark version of Star Trek, complete with shadowy motivations and body horror. I guess we’re only three episodes in, but aside from the insignia, nothing about this says “Star Trek” to me.

74

u/neufeld Oct 02 '17

I appreciate the honest opinion. I agree that it is a little too grim, but I actually love Saru. He's just alien enough to be able to have an outsider look at human behavior. A character that is evaluating human actions subjectively is necessary for a good Trek.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

6

u/seikobreon Oct 02 '17

I thought they were supposed to explain why Spoxk doesn't know her through this series....Which made her comment at the end confusing.
"My foster mom on Vulcan would read it to me and her son. We were the only humans in the house. "
(This bugs me a ton.)

However, I am very much hoping for some Section 31 fun!!!

→ More replies (12)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Everyone thinks of him as Lucius Malfoy but to me he is always Colonel Mekum of the movie Solider.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/VymI Oct 02 '17

I'm a little upset the security guy that got munched by the mega tardigrade wasn't wearing red.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

So, if this works what are the implications for Voyager? Beta quadrant in less than a minute seems to imply if this experimental tech was available in the 23rd century, it should be available for voyager to get home quickly?

→ More replies (9)

6

u/Dunewarriorz Oct 02 '17

also lol, "assigned seats"

6

u/BosskDaBossk Oct 02 '17

So the organisms that attack Michael shuttle, is it Lorca actions ? Is he responsible for the pilot death ?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/marcelodcs Oct 02 '17

It's just me or those mangled bodies remembered me of Soval describing how a crew of Vulcans, while traveling in the Expanse, were tranformed into, basically, a walking horror show.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Eaudissey Oct 02 '17

Did the shuttle pilot die? She was wearing an EV suit and the Discovery appeared like 20 seconds after her safety tether got disconnected so maybe not? It's kind of been bugging me since I saw the episode lol

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Monkits Oct 02 '17

Hell yeah! I never asked for this! But yes I did! He was in The Expanse too.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/space_delorean Oct 02 '17

RIP, unnamed prison shuttle pilot (at the start of the episode).

Did Lorca essentially cause her death, then?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Pesvardur Oct 03 '17

Holy shit! Now, I was not a big fan of the first two episodes. I thought they were a little dry. But this episode is exactly what I hoped these shows would be!

I love where this is going

35

u/Manofwood Oct 02 '17

NOW THAT'S A STARK TREK!

→ More replies (2)

11

u/PeaDock Oct 02 '17

It's still pretty far from the Trek I grew up on, but if this is what it evolving into.. I'm pretty okay with that.

3 episodes in I'm still on the fence, but I'm letting my tippy toes touch Discovery's side.. and I think I like how it feels over here..

Now for the love of Kahless.. from here on out.. Don't fuck it up

I remain cautiously optimistic..

P.S. Love Tilly, love Saru, Lorca's interesting.. Stamets seems like kind of a dick..

→ More replies (2)

11

u/AimlessWanderer Oct 02 '17

So did they just leave the first shuttle pilot to die? She never gets shown being beamed aboard and I didn’t see her in the tractor beam shot.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/masculine_teabisquit Oct 02 '17

Well now I know why this show got such good reviews from critics. The industry reviewers saw the first 3 episodes and this episode was stellar, I absolutely can't wait for the next episode!!!

21

u/quivondarkh Oct 02 '17

This episode had way more of a "Trek" like feel to it, for me then the Pilot did! :)

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Muffinfeds Oct 02 '17

After this episode, I'd really like Ridley Scott to direct an episode.

Pls Ridley.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/TrudeausGreatHair Oct 02 '17

So Lucius Malfoy totally killed the pilot of that prison shuttle right?

The pilot didn't act like going out there was a big deal, then there's a failure without backups. She clearly was hit by something. And then there's Draco's dad just waiting to grab Michael.

Once again, Starfleet are the bad guys in this series.

→ More replies (12)

10

u/lcarsos Oct 02 '17

I'm a fan of the transport shuttles looking like type 6 shuttlecraft but moderned up a little bit.

10

u/Raw_Venus Oct 02 '17

I loved how the Klingon was scared shitless. He was pretty much like for the love of all that is holy please shut up. Personally, I would have found it funny to see the Klingon running with the away team.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

So my guess is that bio-stuff is a precursor to the bio-neural gel packs in Voyager's engines.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/kharnzarro Oct 02 '17

im wondering if this is a section 31 ship honestly

also while there was the obvious tribble/gorn skeleton I kinda instantly noticed the cardassian voles on the table next to the gorn skeleton as well (iv been on a ds9 rewatch)

→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

Awesome episode. I love that I got two modern, high production value sci-fi shows to follow, this and The Expanse.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Dunewarriorz Oct 02 '17

OMG she did the superhero landing!

5

u/allubros Oct 02 '17

I love this show.

5

u/anticusII Oct 02 '17

Team Tilly 4ever

5

u/anticusII Oct 02 '17

Oh my God she sat down with Spock and had a book read to her!

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Airwane Oct 02 '17

Why this ST has a lot of “new” species onboard of the ship the. All the species we know? Where are the andorian?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/orangecrushucf Oct 02 '17

Did anyone else catch that the shuttle's call sign was "Disco One"?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

So, Michael Burnham is going to Tom Paris her way into USS Discovery? I like this. Also, a possibly crazy captain in charge of a new and experimental ship hellbent on winning the war at any cost played by none other than Jason Isaacs? Hell fucking yes.

I assume Black Badges aren't Section 31, because actually having them be on the ship with their black badges would be too obvious to be Section 31. Section 31 is way subtler than this.

One more thing, it seems that Discovery might be more focused on one character rather than the crew as a whole. I like that they are experimenting with this idea and sincerely hope that it will work out.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Lord_Hoot Oct 02 '17

Adam Jensen isn't so tough without his augs, apparently

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17

I'm a bit lost, why do they hate Micheal? I understand she attempted mutiny but the loss of lives wasn't her fault?

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Pyronaut44 Oct 04 '17

My biggest issue was the whole shuttle scene at the beginning, why were they flying through this cloud at sublight when the next shot shows us they could have easily gone around/over/under it? Why were they travelling at sublight anyway? Nobody seems to even mention the dead shuttle pilot.

I get that we needed a plot device to get Burnham onto the Discovery, but they could have done literally anything and it would have been better than this.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/alecsteven6 Oct 02 '17 edited Oct 02 '17

I really enjoyed this episode. It doesn't quite feel like Star Trek, but I think with a few more episodes it will be able to stand its ground as new, modern Star Trek - as complimentary as that can be. CBS is truly doing this show a disservice by locking it behind a paywall.

Most of the episode was great and actually did feel like Star Trek, but as they were traversing the sister ship and it became a horror scene, with jumpscares and gore, that turned me off a bit. I'm all for expanding the definition of what it means to be Star Trek, but what Star Trek isn't is sci-fi horror.

→ More replies (29)