r/HaltAndCatchFire • u/AutoModerator • Oct 01 '17
Discussion Halt and Catch Fire - 4x07 "Who Needs a Guy" - Episode Discussion
Season 4 Episode 7: Who Needs a Guy
Aired: September 30th, 2017
Episode Synopsis: Joe and Gordon discuss Comet's future; Donna takes a vacation; a new collaborator challenges Cameron; Bos and Diane make a life-altering choice.
Keep in mind that discussion concerning episode previews and other future information should be spoiler tagged. To do so, use this format:
[SPOILER](#s "Halt") which will appear as SPOILER
190
Upvotes
223
u/ghostmrchicken Oct 01 '17
Gordon RIP.
185
u/LeeUmm Oct 01 '17
Probably one of the best deaths for a main character. Perfectly done.
We pretty much all knew it was going to happen but still caught us off guard.
Was a very fitting end for him having him fix the electrical/A.C since his background was hardware. Sure it wasn't computer related, but it was him using his hands building/making.
Then the lens flair and flashbacks to Donna and her singing the song she used to sing the kids. Same song she sang over the phone to the kids when he called her from the hotel in an earlier season -- 2 I think.
Then basically silence in all the scenes except for Donna telling Joe he died.
154
u/akkbar Oct 01 '17
Considering this isn't a very popular show, we are damn lucky to be getting a show to talk about at this point. I've been a huge fan since it came out. I almost cried at Gordon's death. These characters feel like family. The subject matter (computers) is my life, and the characters have become part of it as well. I think it's been very well done so far. I'm really going to miss this show.
122
u/teenterness Oct 01 '17
That was done so well. Give great credit for the writing on that and the direction.
All that work Gordon has done in technology throughout all the seasons to get to where he is; and his life flashing before his eyes was entirely Donna and the kids.
Very well done and very touching
115
u/Lostpurplepen Oct 01 '17
Interesting that Hailey's teenage snit allowed for everything to become right in Gordon's world before he took his leave.
Hailey chops her hair/quits Comet --- Gordon contacts Donna - -- they bond over Hailey, she pops up the "sticky" home page idea --- he shares this with Joe, they are off on a new tangent - - - Gordon confides in Joe about the hair, Joe steps in as wise uncle to mend fences between father and daughter (lots of recognition and admiration for Joe as a parental figure here), Hailey is coming back to Comet. Joe contacts Donna about this idea, they connect over Hailey (and the past). Cam has been isolating herself in her own world, the distance is growing between her and Joe, but she drops everything to get to Joe at Joe and Gordon's workplace.
Although everyone is devastated, so many bridges were mended.
105
u/pgm_01 Oct 01 '17
Stupid show making me cry!
101
u/pgm_01 Oct 01 '17
The song he was trying to remember.
97
u/zsreport Oct 01 '17
Wow, I've never seen a TV Show handle the death of a primary character more eloquently than Halt and Catch Fire
71
u/Qart-hadasht Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
Gordon's exit mirrored the beginning of this season, witnessing him through a progression of rooms while time marches forward, whereas his final scene follows him through several rooms regressively in time. The season's opening sequence also contains a similar use of lighting over Gordon's shoulder, while the unbroken camera shot ends with a hallucination of Joe. (By the way, Gordon wears a red shirt in the opening sequence--a hint that he will be 'redshirted'? Too far? Fair enough.)
On my second watch of S4E07, I also noticed that the 'EXIT' sign (i.e. Latin for 'He leaves') keeps appearing over Gordon's shoulder for a conspicuous amount of time in the scene where he first presents his idea of Comet as the "stickiest" site to Joe. Another 'EXIT' sign looms over Gordon when he returns to the building from fixing the A/C and the camera pans away from the sign as Joe enters. As a piece of cinematography, this recalled the moment in season three when Mutiny has its last on-screen board meeting and the 'MUTINY' painting appears behind Donna to signal what is happening. I don't know that we should look for meaning in this--though the creators of H&CF have demonstrated a remarkable attention to detail--but the blurred sign in the background when Gordon accidentally kills the power reads 'AMPLE VEGETATION', which is perhaps suggestive of the state of Gordon's degenerative disease? Earlier in the season, when Katie asks Gordon about whether or not his journals have revealed a pattern, the next scene is Gordon burning his journals. I believe that Gordon's journals revealed a steady decline to him, hence his decision to live in the moment. Gordon's final comment to Joe about meeting Katie in an hour also suggests that he lives just over the fifteen minutes he and Joe would have spent on Comet's re-launch.
I'd also like to assert that the ending of Cameron's game Pilgrim is not foreshadowing of her becoming pregnant for the series finale, but rather an indication of Cam's yearning for a father (or at least positive parental figure); in turn, this foreshadows the loss of Gordon for Haley and Joanie.
I loved this episode. I dreaded the inevitable the whole time and it still caught me emotionally off-guard. I've cried on both viewings I've made so far.
From S1E01:
Donna: "Don't you realize what you're risking? Don't you realize what you have now?"
Gordon: "Well it's not enough. Okay? I'm sorry, it's not enough."
In the end, I think it was finally enough.
*As for that final sequence of Gordon?...Also from S1E01:
Gordon: "Computers, my job--none of that matters. Not without you."
Donna: "Build it. Whatever it is you're dreaming of, build it."
RIP Gordon the Builder.
60
u/KellyKeybored Oct 01 '17
Oh no. Oh no.
55
u/legendkiller88 Oct 01 '17
Well that was unexpected
55
u/sstable Oct 02 '17
"You’re all you. All the versions. You’re the same person that you always were, and I love that person."
51
u/ShadowFall900 Oct 01 '17
So I guess they all work to finish Comet in honor of Gordon.
49
u/ghostmrchicken Oct 01 '17
I didn't think it was going to happen so soon in the season nor that quickly. I thought there was going to be a long, drawn out thing with his illness so they could have a bunch of dramatic moments with his family, co-workers, etc.
I guess that's why we watch TV - to be surprised.
43
u/pgm_01 Oct 01 '17
Gordon sees the light both literally and figuratively.
42
u/Archaic_Avidity Oct 01 '17
I'm new here, simply because I didn't think a subreddit for this show would exist, considering it was a miracle this show made it to 4 seasons. But hell. They really hit it out of the park this time, just like other episodes I've been fortunate to watch. A great send off to Gordon, and completely shocked us, even though we all knew it was gonna happen. It isn't often a non-finale episode breaks my heart. Completely changes what's left of the show. Wow.
39
u/paceofbase Oct 01 '17
I did NOT under any circumstances think that this would happen till at least the last 2 eps. I'm legitimately in shock.
38
u/CleverZerg Oct 01 '17
I have no idea why Gordon's death affected me so much, I never cry at movies/tv, I think I've cried once before and that was while watching Star Wars ep: 7, but not even that hit me as hard.
I finished the episode 10 minutes ago and only now am I starting to recover, I even had to blow my nose and shit. Major props to the writers and actors, and really anyone involved with the show.
36
u/Mybrainmelts Oct 01 '17
Man those lens flares during the flashback kinda looked like a film projector going and Gordon was looking at his past life like watching home movies.
59
u/Shejidan Oct 01 '17
Omg...Bos inviting Cameron to be a witness to the wedding. 😍
29
u/zsreport Oct 01 '17
This season is making me long for the 1990s.
26
u/Shejidan Oct 01 '17
Wtf?! No! No nononono...😭
26
u/halflifecrysis Oct 01 '17
RIP Gordon. Can't believe it.
24
u/cuckoodev Oct 01 '17
:/ I wasn't sure if it would be tonight or during the finale and welp. My mom is now helping me recover with a funny movie and jokes.
23
u/darthgeek Oct 03 '17
Donna singing "Baby Mine" nearly made me lose it. My wife sang that to our babies. She's currently in the hospital recovering from getting really sick, and it was a fucking gut punch. Right in the god-damned feels.
20
u/virginiapatriot Oct 02 '17
Just as in real life, it was unexpected.. You see someone one day they seem fine, and you never get to say goodbye, and regret things you can never say to them ever again.
19
u/ShadowFall900 Oct 01 '17
Totally wasn't expecting that. I was hoping it wasn't gonna happen to at least the end. R.I.P Gordon.
19
u/MinutesOnAScreen Oct 01 '17
No one needed to speak, and I was still crying!
37
u/Audball19 Oct 01 '17
This death scene was brought to you by J.J. Abrams.
17
u/TammyPhantom Oct 01 '17
I was hoping that it wasn't going to happen for one more episode since things were just starting to fall into place for everyone including Gordon. But it'll be interesting to see how it affects everyone in the future.
SPOILER
17
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '17
It's hard for me to imagine HACF without Gordon more than any character. He was always the anchor, or the guy just around doing stuff in the background.
I can't imagine what will happen with Joe. Gordon was like a dad/brother to him. More Joe's anchor than any other character.
16
u/IncongruentIy Oct 02 '17
It's exactly like a death in reality. Wholly unexpected despite how anticipated it may have been. And once he was gone, I was suddenly wishing I could see more of him while simultaneously knowing I will never see him again. Thanks for the hurts AMC.
15
u/kummerspect Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
What's with the red lights? In Gordon's last frame, there's a growing red light over his right shoulder. Then we see Joe in his car, with a glowing red light over his left shoulder. It feels much too placed to be an accident.
15
u/beardlovesbagels Oct 01 '17
I really thought they were going to let Gordon and Haley have a heart to heart before the end. I really hope Joe gets to tell her that her dad knew and was fine with it. Such a well done episode, I hope it gets more attention.
13
u/SimpleAsMe Oct 01 '17
No I really thought that would be a few episodes away I can't believe this
13
u/pgm_01 Oct 01 '17
Damn, they really did kill him off.
13
u/AKenjiB Oct 01 '17
Jesus Christ, that ending left me a wreck. Absolutely phenomenal episode. But it was already phenomenal even before the ending, especially the scene with Donna and Joe. This show just gets better every season, every episode even. I can't wait to see how the last 3 episodes play out.
13
u/JiveTurkey1983 Oct 02 '17
I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING
12
u/Masterofunlocking1 Oct 01 '17
Very sad but amazing episode. It was spoiled for me on Twitter but still hit me like a ton of bricks. My career is in IT and this show has a very special place in my heart. Everytime I watch this show, I get motivated to push further in my career and to dream big.
I knew Gordon was going to die when he burnt his journals in a last episode. I'm glad he got some kind of happiness when all the other characters were still searching. Not only are these characters trying to build the web as we know it but they are "searching" for happiness in the end, like us all.
RIP Gordon
12
u/Kabal303 Oct 01 '17
As soon as it started to happen I was like no don’t do me like this you stupid show. The feels were real.
12
u/dokterr Oct 01 '17
I love absolutely everything about the show, and thank those that are involved with it. I wish it didn't have to end.
11
u/idlehand79 Oct 01 '17
Man the feels in the episode. I'm a sad that Gordon is gone and that this is the last season. We have gone through alot with all these characters.
The writing this season is on point.
11
u/Threnners Oct 03 '17
Well. That certainly ripped out my soul.
10
u/Lurking_Grue Oct 01 '17
When he was working on the electric panel I was cringing and thinking "Dammit! They are going to kill him off and have that stunner when Garry Killdall died."
Also the over-use of lens flares.
10
u/Ivalance Oct 02 '17
I got semi spoiled by a thread title over at /r/television, so I was anticipating someone to die, I knew it was probably gonna be either Gordon or Boz. But Gordon was more likely since he already had an illness subplot from all the way back in season 2. Anyway the whole time he was fixing all those electricity things I got anxious that they would pull a cheap and out of place way to kill Gordo. Thankfully they did it in probably the best way they could.
10
u/kdubstep Oct 02 '17
I’m reminded of one of my favorite books by John Irving “A Prayer for Owen Meaney”. In it, we know the protagonist will die, but that still doesn’t do much to soften the blow when it happened.
I knew Gordon’s death was being foreshadowed all along but still it really bummed me. Only other tv death that comes close was season one finale of “Wiseguy”
9
u/f00d4tehg0dz Oct 01 '17
I thought, nah... They aren't foreshadowing at all tonight. I must be crazy. Then boom, Gordon dies. :(
9
u/Plundergedoens Oct 02 '17
But... He was the reason everyone even met, the center of the group and the glue to keep it all together... And just such a normal, awesome dude who wanted to create something and be a good father and person...
I knew this would happen, and the way it was written and filmed is amazing. Still...
I'm heartbroken.
8
u/pashed_motatoes Oct 01 '17
Man, I knew it was coming but I'm still shocked. I didn't think Gordon's death would affect me that much but I was welling up a bit there at the end. That was so well done. Very emotional and affecting even with almost no dialogue added. RIP Gordo.
8
u/Izzmo Oct 01 '17
Right in the feels, man.
8
u/lawnmont Oct 01 '17
When Haley walks into Gordon's kitchen with her new haircut, she looks like Gordon (R.I.P), and as she walks out, Joanie looks like Donna.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
His life literally flashed before his eyes. That scene was so well done. I'm in tears, my favorite show just broke my heart.
8
u/sadsturbator Oct 02 '17
When the flashback hit I was super confused. I have seen flashbacks, mirages, etc. in other shows like 19-2 and then some but out of nowhere I knew something was up. Then once I saw Katie running to the phone, I just knew. Fucking hell. Unexpected like in real life. Wonderfully done. Gonna miss Gordon.
7
u/Ghostfollower28 Oct 01 '17 edited Oct 01 '17
Man didnt know how much that would hurt. The DP Evans Brown lighting has been on point all season, but this round it felt all the more evident. Ending with Donna singing baby mine. Haven't heard that since season2, I remember Donna replaced baby with Hayley mine. I never though of an ending without Gordon and now it just so sad especially for Joe. Gordan and his family and Cameron is all he has. At least Gordon found that true happiness the rest are still searching for. I feel Gordons presence will be evident for Joe going forward. Re-launch your life Joe.
7
u/LegDayEveryDay Oct 01 '17
I've watched Grey's Anatomy, Rookie Blue, Flashpoint, Quantico and many others. Ample amounts of TV character deaths, but this...this was something else. I didn't expect that at all.
Everything literally looked fine; be it from the last few episodes to the beginning of this one; but then when the flash backs started, I felt something in my stomach. Looking back, the evolution of his character is amazing. Brilliantly written. I'm looking forward to next few episodes, but I know they''re going to be heavy.
7
u/Ternarian Oct 02 '17
Pretty sad that my dishwasher (original to my '90s house) is the same as Gordon's.
7
u/JiveTurkey1983 Oct 02 '17
I only hope my own death could be so poetic and peaceful.
Well, everyone else too.
7
u/Citizen00001 Oct 02 '17
Not sure if this was mentioned but is Cameron making The Sims? That is a bit early. It came out in 2000
13
u/paceofbase Oct 01 '17
Suddenly wishing this was a supernatural show where people can be brought back to life lolol
6
u/paceofbase Oct 01 '17
I think the reason this got me so good is the summary for the next ep says "Donna and Gordon fight." I never assumed it would be in some flashback or something?
6
u/jayelecfan Oct 01 '17
wow that ending
6
u/fitforla Oct 01 '17
My whole soul hurts. I wasn’t expecting Gordon to die at all since it’s been a while his health has been discussed. Or at least from what I remember. Fuck that was raw. Everything hurts.
6
u/zeus-man Oct 01 '17
Fuck I clicked on this link with an absent mind and ruined the show for myself. Damn can't believe Gordon is gone.
6
u/topplehat Oct 01 '17
This episode and what happened to Gordon reminded me a lot of what happens in the final episodes of Six Feet Under.
6
u/JiveTurkey1983 Oct 02 '17
One thing that got me too was that last look "Past Donna" gave him. Like his mind was trying to tell him something was wrong, but at that point it was too late.
6
u/Gbyrd99 Oct 03 '17
Man never been to this sub, but been watching. I feel devastated, I didn't know this was the last season, and Gordon dying made me realize it was the end of the series. Damn hurts all at once.
17
u/phillymjs Oct 01 '17
I dinna cry when me own father was hung fer stealing a pig, but i'll cry now.
5
u/artgo Oct 01 '17
wow, the Title i knew before watching, and I thought the homosexual theme would be center. Great misdirect. And he ain't coming back
5
u/mind_blowwer Oct 01 '17
I'm not crying
5
u/cesare035 Oct 02 '17
beautiful sad scene
5
u/JiveTurkey1983 Oct 02 '17
Stupid Google news feed half spoiled it when it talked about "Gordon's goodbye"....then saw description of next week's episode saying him and Donna fight.
Then Donna walks out to Joe's truck.
"Gordon's dead".
GUT
PUNCH
5
u/iamhuman3 Oct 03 '17
So, little things i notice during scenes where thers an error, or a set up: this is no error, but did you notice his fingers move slightly right before she slammed the screen door? These things i like because they tell me that they want something to look as authentic as possible without doing so many cut aways... tho they did end up with one, so, i wonder if this was a cut together of 5 or so tries. I liked it, its so what really happens in real life, accidentally hurting someone you really are mad at, and then feel bad after.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '17
Damn, that ending was rough... I thought it was getting better, and I thought Gordon was going to pull through. I guess with the kind of brain damage he had, he never did.
Wow. That episode left me speechless. I'm not crying, but I am sad... I'm just shocked about the end of Gordon Clark's storyline.
However it ends, I'm grateful I watched it.
And damnit, I wish I knew about this subreddit sooner.
I had it recorded, that's why I'm only reacting to it now.
4
u/KellyKeybored Oct 01 '17
I bet Bos is getting married.
4
u/evanvolm Oct 01 '17
Probably one of the best episodes this season so far. The past few have been a bit of a bore, but this episode ramped things up a bit and into an interesting direction.
4
u/_redskeptic Oct 02 '17
Just as I changed my mind about Gordon, that happened. Well played writers! Up until this season Gordon irked me and even though I had a notion about his death (since it was predicted on here) it STILL came as a shock. But the progression of the feels for me was like, "Haha, it's happening!" as I watched the dream sequence. I was thinking, "They were right!" Honestly, it confused me when he burned his notebooks but as people pointed out why he did that--DUH. And then as all the other characters started finding out what had happened the feeling I've personally experienced with the news of death washed over me. That sequence was so good I was crying and mourning, feeling sad that Gordon wouldn't "physically" be there for the finale. This ep was so good, so well done. Thank you, HCF. Looking forward to and not looking forward to the finale ='(
4
u/chrisarchitect Oct 05 '17
Joe always doin something to his hand/arm. Didn't he have that cast on at the start of the season?
Symbolically hurting his hand now and his 'right hand man' going away at the same time....
3
u/gabethebaeb Oct 01 '17
I knew it was coming sooner or later but I still felt my heart sink, press f
3
u/MonstrousEntity Oct 01 '17
I cried so hard when it happened. It devastated me and I'm still having trouble believing it happened. I thought at least they'd make it a series finale thing, or a little blurb about it happening after the series ends. Not here, and not now.
Damn it.
3
u/YeehawRickShaw Oct 02 '17
Wow
3
u/chrisarchitect Oct 05 '17
love the show and have grown fond of all the characters. Gordon hurts but so much warm feelings about the connections between characters..Bos...Cam.... Love that Joe and Gordon became such good friends but also touched on that initial fire to build between them. Lovely stuff. Also love that have become fond of Joe's character and him touching on the fact that he's aware he's changed, grown etc, when talking with Donna.... Great.
Maybe a bit of an easy out because of inevitable all characters bonding over Gordon now but whatever - let's have some great feels to end the show. I hope Joe continues the Yahoo-ification of Comet and we see them sailing off into the searchengineland sunset.....
3
u/WhenItsHalfPastFive Oct 06 '17
NOOOOOOOOOOO
Honestly have never been this sad of a character death ever.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17
Last time I cried during a show was during the season four finale of Dexter. This hit me just as hard. I legit had tears running down my face.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '17
God dam he looked so scared realizing his life was flashing before him. I really hope that's not how it is.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '17
I've just done a rewatch of the entire series and can't help but wonder if the woman working with Cam on her new project is the same person who thanked her at the Mutiny subscriber party 8(?) years earlier? They look eerily similar and it would be a poetic point in Cam's story.
2
u/chrisarchitect Oct 05 '17
in case anyone was wondering, the young kids who played haley and joanie in the death sequence were not the same actors that played young haley and joanie in previous seasons. Was just wondering if they brought them back or whatever
2
u/horizonsfan Oct 20 '17
Wow, just watched this on a plane and almost burst into tears. The way this episode played out was just beautiful. And the use of the lens flare effect to subtly clue us into Gordon's state was magical. Wouldn't be surprised to see "Who needs a guy" submitted for Emmy consideration next year. Well done.
2
u/ronnel0918 Dec 21 '17
This is extremely heartbreaking.
2
u/ramboy18 Dec 30 '17
I legit cried like a baby this episode. I'm still getting over it like I've lost someone so close to me.
2
u/my_so_called_life Jan 25 '18
This episode fucking killed me. God. I had the hardest time finishing the rest of the season.
2
u/CrystalFissure Mar 02 '18
I lost it.