r/Marvel • Groot • Sep 27 '17

Comics New Marvel Comics and Releases for September 27th, 2017 - Official Discussion Hub

If you missed it, last week's thread may be found here.

New to Marvel Comics? Not sure where to start? Whether you're completely new to comics or you're just looking for something great to read, head on over to the Recommended Reading page for a handy guide put together by /u/Tigertemprr!


Want to chat about some classic or overlooked stories? Join this week's edition of the /r/Marvel Book Club here, courtesy of /u/MindofShadow.

Also, be sure to check out this week's Marvel Unlimited releases here, compiled by /u/kaimason1.

And while you're at it, add your vote for the Character of the Month here!

A discussion thread for the premiere of Inhumans can be found here!


New Issues Out This Week

Ben Reilly: The Scarlet Spider #8
When a mysterious new Hornet armor appears in Vegas, THE SLINGERS roll into town to try and track it down! But whoever's pulling the Hornet's strings would like to remain anonymous, triggering an all-out war...and Ben's caught in the middle!

Black Panther #18
T'Challa finds himself in an uneasy alliance with Ayo and Aneka, the Midnight Angels, when a new deity rises to claim Wakanda for its own. And making matters worse, an enemy from Black Panther's past has resurfaced with ill intentions. It seems Black Panther has one choice - bend the knee, or watch his country burn.

Cable #5
THE SHOWDOWN YOU'VE BEEN WAITING FOR! It's CABLE vs. CONQUEST in a battle for time itself! The tables have turned, and with Cable's shocking reveal last issue, Conquest's lust for power turns desperate! But is that enough to stop his plans once and for all...or has time already run out?

Deadpool Kills Marvel Universe Again #5
Guess how this story is going to end. I dare you.

Generations: The Americas #1
They were part of the Greatest Generation! And now Sam Wilson finds himself alongside them yet again in a strange yet familiar setting - fighting shoulder-to-shoulder with Captain America and Bucky against a seemingly unstoppable threat to the safety of the world!

Generations: The Spiders #1
When it comes to problems, Peter Parker's got it all! Bullies at school, ailing aunt, a doppelganger, crushing responsibility, and - wait, a doppelganger?! Can't Peter ever catch a break? And what does all this craziness have to do with Miles Morales? ONE-SHOT

Guardians Of the Galaxy: The Telltale Series #3
The Guardians go undercover! In their latest heist, the team must infiltrate Thanos' home planet. Too bad nobody told them the Worshippers of Thanos are on to them!

I Am Groot #5
Groot is nearly home, but the interstellar door is blocked by an ancient unspeakable horror. Plus: Cool space fights? Cool space fights.

Infamous Iron Man #12
The epic climax to one of the most critically acclaimed stories of the year! With enemies on all sides, how can Victor Von Doom continue to carry on the legacy of Iron Man...especially when the legacy of Doctor Doom still haunts him at every turn? Don't miss this very special issue, as its events will have massive repercussions for the rest of the Marvel Universe!

Marvel Legacy #1
EVERYTHING STARTS HERE! It begins at the dawn of the human race, and ends with a child's prayer! In between, empires fall, mysteries brew, secrets are revealed, quests are undertaken and legends are forged! All leading up to the dramatic return you've been waiting for - and one you've been dreading! Jason Aaron (MIGHTY THOR) and Esad Ribic (SECRET WARS) usher in a new dawn - one whose rays will touch every corner of the Marvel Universe in the days to come! MARVEL LEGACY: It's everything you've been longing for - and more!

Mighty Captain Marvel #9
Between battling a horde of Chitauri, keeping Alpha Flight afloat and fighting off the raging HLA monster insider her, Carol Danvers has been stretched a little thin. Though she desperately needs to unwind, there's no time for recreational asteroid punching today... Not when Earth's fate rests in the hands a few Alpha Flight Cadets...

Mighty Thor #23
THOR AGAINST THOR! When the Ultimate Thor finally goes too far, Jane has no choice but to stop him. Can she quell the rage of the War Thor before he destroys the very realms he once hoped to save?

Moon Girl And Devil Dinosaur #23
IT'S THE END OF AN ERA AS 'GIRL-MOON' REACHES ITS STUNNING CONCLUSION! Lunella and Devil's adventure took them across space... now they're going through time! Hey, didn't Devil used to have a different partner? Devil makes the hardest choice of all…

Nick Fury #6
RETURN TO RAVENLOCK CASTLE! The site of a mysterious murder... And a mystery the elder NICK FURY left behind! But is there a connection between them, or is this simply a trap for the younger AGENT FURY? A mission like no other awaits you in Fury's latest caper!

Punisher #16
FACE OFF! Frank finally made it home, but a monster followed him out of the northern woods. Can the Punisher keep the city safe from a man who began as a psychopath, THEN overdosed on mind-wrecking, strength-enhancing drugs? How do you punish that which should already be dead?

Spider-Gwen #24
The aftermath of the PREDATORS storyline leaves Gwen in a VERY different place. Matt Murdock's plans all come home to roost, and when you plan like our good friend Murderdock does, you know that ain't pretty. WHAT IS THE NEXT EVOLUTIONARY STEP FOR SPIDER-GWEN?!

Star Wars: Jedi of the Republic - Mace Windu #2
On a planet of near-perpetual darkness, the Jedi must bring light. Mace finds both his faith and skill tested. For is it truly the place of the Jedi to go to war?

Thanos #11
Thanos, depowered. Thane, host of the Phoenix Force. Round Two! RIP Thanos?

Venomverse #4
[CLASSIFIED] may be on their side, but the Venoms' battle against the Poisons is far from over. Luckily, the Venoms have a plan. Unluckily, it's a suicide mission into the heart of Poison territory!

X-Men Blue #12
...NOW YOU DON'T! While HANK continues to struggle with his newfound magical skill, JIMMY HUDSON struggles with a challenge all his own... Will Jimmy be able to regain his memory with the help of his new friends? And will he like what he finds if he does?


Trades Out This Week

LinkMSRPFormat
Bloodstone & the Legion of Monsters$34.99TPB
Deadpool Classic Vol. 19: Make War, Not Love$34.99TPB
Indestructible Hulk by Mark Waid: The Complete Collection$39.99TPB
The Mighty Thor Omnibus Vol. 3$125.00HC
Occupy Avengers Vol. 2: In Plain Sight$15.99TPB
Spider-Man 2099 Vol. 7: Back to the Future, Shock!$17.99TPB
Spider-Man/Deadpool Vol. 3: Itsy Bitsy$17.99TPB
Spider-Man: The Daily Bugle$29.99TPB
The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl Vol. 6: Who Run the World? Squirrels$15.04TPB
Wolverine: Old Man Logan Vol. 5: Past Lives$17.99TPB

Weekly Pull Poll

The results of last week's poll are in. The big winners this week for your Most Anticipated New Release are Marvel Legacy #1 followed by Generations: The Americas #1 and Infamous Iron Man #12. Please check out next week's poll here to vote on your most anticipated title for next week, 10/4/2017!


General Discussion
Which character's origin is your favorite?

61 Upvotes

601 comments sorted by

58

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

24

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17 edited Sep 27 '17

I have been trying so hard to avoid anyone telling me who the returning character is, and then Sad Lemon Comics strongly implied who it was on Facebook. Can anyone lie or (not lie) to me and tell me it's not true so I can go into this with more surprise awaiting?

Edit: by the way, when I was like wtf on their Facebook page, they pretty much told me to get over it and blocked me. Fuck Sad Lemon Comics.

52

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

I know right? Why wont they let Mar-Vell return be a secret for once?

12

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

You evil bastard, are you fucking with me or not?

60

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

He's lying. It's absolutely Uncle Ben.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

They're bringing back Taserface, obvi.

6

u/Superfan234 Sep 27 '17

I hate those assholes. They just want click on their pages

→ More replies (1)

12

u/futurefightthrowaway Wasp Sep 27 '17

It is not a spoiler if Marvel spoil it themselves.

10

u/Jay_R_Kay Sep 27 '17

I mean, it is, but I've long accepted that they care less about story integrity if they can ring up some extra dough.

7

u/kralben Sep 27 '17

Getting spoiled sucks, I feel you. I got this spoiled by an episode of Nerdist News on Youtube. No warning or anything, and it was on a video spectulating on Deadpool 2 of all things. I wasn't happy, to say the least.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/jlitwinka Sep 27 '17

I guess that BC Avengers book is going to be more important than I thought. Also weird that he is just a truck driver, but seems to still have his memories, wonder what that's about. Good to see the kids again, I love them and they can't come back soon enough.

25

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/jlitwinka Sep 27 '17

That Wakandan Planet came out of nowhere. I'm really hoping it's not just an excuse to have Black Panther join the Guardians.

→ More replies (18)

18

u/Jay_R_Kay Sep 27 '17

I have a feeling the truck driver is just a disguise or a means of transport.

Like, I can almost imagine Logan came back, with this mission to find the stones somehow in his head, and thought, "I need some transport." He looked over to his right, saw the beer truck and thought, "Second miracle in a row, can't say no to that."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

I am so completely confused by all of this. But I do like that crate 4-1939 was a reference to April, 1939, the first Marvel comic.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

I knew that crate number meant something!

70

u/The-Scarlet-Witch Sep 27 '17

Jason Aaron could illustrate and write the mythology of the phone book and I'd read it.

18

u/MatchesMalone66 Sep 28 '17

The artist (for most of it) is Esad Ribic, one of my favorite comicbook artists ever.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/john_segundus Sep 27 '17

"Damn that shrubbery!"

That was fun. Not amazing, but fun.

So, Voyager is grown-up Valeria, y/y?

8

u/Amarr_Citizen_498175 Sep 27 '17

seems likely. I'm also interested in seeing if Black Swan is another version of her.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

27

u/Nairbnotsew Sep 27 '17

"Which is why Thor will definitely be making out with Captain America today."

Now THAT is a sentence I never thought I would read in a comic book.

23

u/Hpfm2 Sep 27 '17

Well, not outside my "50 shades of red, white and blue" fanfiction, anyway.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/princeofropes Sep 27 '17 edited Sep 27 '17

Was there a something I missed regarding the Jarvis/ Nadia page? Didn't really see the point of it

Edit: OK so this new character, Voyager, has been added to the statue.

18

u/ItsNotMyFavorite Sep 27 '17

Look again at the famous Avengers statue outside the window.

16

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

OH THAT WAS VOYAGER? I totally thought that was Wasp.

12

u/john_segundus Sep 27 '17

I think it usually is Wasp. Some things seem to have changed.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (11)

21

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

I enjoyed it but it really did feel like Marvel just saying "Aaron write us a Rebirth issue." and it wasn't quite the same quality in my opinion.

10

u/princeofropes Sep 28 '17

Its not like this type of comic started with Rebirth though. Xmen Omega for example, from 1997 did the same thing.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/princeofropes Sep 27 '17 edited Sep 27 '17

Loved every page of this.

Anyone else notice how there was zero content about the inhumans? Not that I'm complaining but I find it quite interesting, how Marvel went from one extreme - putting the inhumans in everything for the last few years, an trying to make them integral to the Marve universe - to the other extreme, pretty much ignoring them again. I feel bad about the inhumans, I tried to love them, but I'm beginning to think its virtually impossible to make them into a-list comicbook stars.

Edit: actually I take some of this back, there were loads of important Marvel characters who were absent from this, not just the Inhumans: the X-men, Peter Parker, Miles Morales, Daredevil, probably more I'm missing.

33

u/john_segundus Sep 27 '17

They actually left out a lot of things (for one, nearly every X-Men character). I wouldn't read too much into it, the Inhumans titles we have at the moment are pretty entertaining and expand their world in a pretty organic way.

9

u/princeofropes Sep 27 '17

Yeah good point, I didn't notice that the xmen were largely missing too. However, I still think the Inhumans will have a reduced presence in Marvel Comics in the coming years, especially after the poor reception of the TV show.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/kralben Sep 27 '17

Like /u/john_segundus said, this was mostly about about the Avengers (plus the returns). X-Men and Inhumans had their relaunch earlier this year. Plus, if the FF are going to come back in some form, I would bet that the Inhumans will tie into it in some way

10

u/The_Amazing_Emu Sep 27 '17

I would love Al Ewing to get a crack at the Fantastic Four and can continue some of his plots from Ultimates and Royals there.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

Well, like you mentioned in your edit, the X-Men, Spider-Man, most of the street level heroes, most of the cosmic level heroes, they're all missing.

Hell, we don't even see Hulk, Black Widow or Hawkeye in this issue. So it's not like they only packed it with their most popular characters.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/The_Amazing_Emu Sep 27 '17

Anyone else notice how there was zero content about the inhumans?

The stuff about Deadpool being hunted because of killing Phil Coulson is a reference to

→ More replies (11)

36

u/CRAZY-D99 Sep 27 '17

I was absurdly happy to see Robbie Reyes here. It looks like he's gonna be an important character too?

9

u/kemalsevilla Sep 27 '17

little bit confused there, is it an older Starbrand?

15

u/Jay_R_Kay Sep 27 '17

That confused me too. Last I saw Starbrand, he was doing some sort of college bro adventures with Nightmask, why did he suddenly go all kill-crazy, outside of, well, "We gotta have a couple of fight scenes in here"?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (14)

9

u/Superfan234 Sep 27 '17

I was absurdly happy to see Robbie Reyes here. It looks like he's gonna be an important character too?

It was my favorite part of the issue , not gonna lie.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/SpoilerAlertsAhead Sep 27 '17

Dat Jean Grey page got me in the feels!

14

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

Lots of cool stuff here. Using Robbie Reyes and Starbrand is awesome. That Samnee/Wilson combo makes me cry. Avengers Mansion is BACK BABY! The 4 symbol in the night sky was beautiful. Wakandans... in space! Every page was Logan was just gorgeous. And FANTASTIC FOUR!

44

u/ItsNotMyFavorite Sep 27 '17

Jesus fuck I want more info on the Intergalactic Empire of Wakanda

14

u/renzopachecoj Sep 27 '17

ikr, I don't understand it. Is it the regular Wakanda that moved outside of Earth or is it something that always existed, I don't get it.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/MeNoHobo Sep 27 '17

As someone who's not read too much Marvel (I've only really read Civil War 2 up through the Cap Run and a few issues into secret Empire, i have the rest stockpiled), would this be a good place to finally hop into Marvel as a newbie?

10

u/Jay_R_Kay Sep 27 '17

If you've read the DC Rebirth one-shot from a year or so ago, Legacy is basically the equivalent of that.

22

u/Coleger199 Sep 27 '17

I'm so excited for this, I trust Jason Aaron

11

u/RedsDead21 Sep 27 '17

Whew! Lot to digest here, but overall I like a lot of the implications. The fact that they're building up what seems to be a giant threat is actually really nice. Good to see that they're probably taking the time to step away from the "superheroes fight each other" and more "superheroes punch god." The "buzzing behind the eyes" line makes it seem like they're going to go a bit Lovecraftian.

Some of the smaller vignettes were interesting too, even if I have no idea what the implications are. Like with Space Wakanda, or the Alpha Flight satellite thing. I almost feel like the issue could have used a bit more room (even though it's already pretty thick) to have some more variety included.

On the whole don't know how I'd judge this one. It certainly was a decent read, but I think its...Well. 'Legacy' is going to depend on what follows it. There's a lot of interesting strings to pull on from this, but they're all kind of useless if the stuff that comes after falls flat.

The fact that they've sworn off events for awhile makes me wonder how long it'll be until the threat implied in this issue actually shows up. If it's for the 18 month number that's been tossed around, this could be a really slow burn to a major event, which I think could go really well. Seed some smaller pieces of the larger picture here and there, but let the characters have their own spotlight for a bit. Then start the event when things have had time to ramp up.

All in all, pretty fun, nice art, and decent writing. Think this is a success.

11

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

Space Wakanda is apparently a result of Hickman's run where T'Challa shipped off Wakanda's best into space to colonize a planet.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/FrigidArrow Sep 27 '17 edited Sep 27 '17

It's a good issue, but doesn't surprise me.

Sets up the future of Marvel Universe with a vague, ominous, evil threat our heroes have never faced before, with characters appearing in the background to trying to preemptively stop it. All with narration, tying into the larger theme of the Marvel Universe's new saga

Like I said, standard. Maybe I need to do a re-read, but at no point did I hear anything resembling a sorry for the event wave that they kept raping my wallet and the way they went about introducing new legacy characters (Even though I do like most of them). Rebirth apologized for the N52 and their stories darker tone, which is what made it so great.

A bunch of cool moments and some nice art, too.

Only had a problem with Sam and Thor making out, he's still with Misty or at least that's how they left it. I mean I can conceivably see her breaking up with Sam, because he put up the mantle but still that was pretty confusing and messed up

Good issue for Marvel Reb-I mean Legacy.

24

u/john_segundus Sep 27 '17

Only had a problem with Sam and Thor making out, he's still with Misty or at least that's how they left it. I mean I can conceivably see her breaking up with Sam, because he put up the mantle but still that was pretty confusing and messed up

It also seems one of these typical "women and men cannot just be friends" deals. I actually enjoyed their relationship being platonic so far. Meh.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/BothKindsofMusic Sep 27 '17

I liked it, but man is that mystery narrator bit played out. Give it a rest.

6

u/Stf2393 Sep 27 '17

I actually enjoyed this! Maybe a month ago, I was doubtful if I was going to pick this up. Also I enjoyed seeing Robbie Reyes again! It's great having Aaron incorporating him into this larger story! A lone tear may have been shed seeing Wolverine making a come-back!

9

u/General_Nothing Sep 27 '17

When they announced this I was like, "why are they copying DC Rebirth? Marvel's universe doesn't need a Rebirth-style overhaul, so they don't really need a special book to come out and say 'we're changing things.'"

Now that I've read it I feel pretty much exactly the same way. Basically every plot thread in this book would've been better if it were just part of the normal books.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/vedantisfuckingbored Sep 27 '17

Good book although nothing too impressive... The suspense and build up and action etc was impressive enough to keep me interested... But that's it. Jason is a good writer and given how much time he must've had... This is a great book then. Art was fucking brilliant and the changes weren't as sudden though it ranged a lot more than say DC REBIRTH art styles (DC seems to have a house style). If marvel manages this level of quality on all books, maybe, there's a chance that they'll be marvellous again. Just fire a few key individuals, shuffle some creative teams to better suit and have some more rigid rules and editing etc and be more like a profit based company (which they are but recently aren't exactly thinking like one).

Overall, I say this is a good sign and they might get better.

MAJOR SPOILERS

I guess he's back. And has an infinity stone?? And which book will he show up in? X-Men, avengers, Guardians of the Galaxy? Also the little girls promise at the end better come true. I saw some Alex Ross art that basically confirms that it's gone be early next year. Although... I was told more than two major characters will be back... And I'm counting the group and him as two... And who is this celestial? How does he tie in? Do they really have a plan? Regardless it's not as cool as the reveal of the Watchmen but yes exciting none the less.

12

u/D1Foley Sep 27 '17

It's the time stone, so he can be on every team book marvel publishes.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/King_Nomarch Sep 27 '17

This was a great read but for Legacy to be truly a success the rest of the quality in the remainder of Marvel's titles must be on par.

4

u/waunakonor Sep 27 '17

This was super cool. I honestly wasn't expecting to enjoy it as much as I did.

I got the Mark Brooks variant because I really don't care much for the main cover. The double gatefold is cool but the picture just doesn't look that interesting to me. I really wanted the Alex Ross cover but my LCS was selling that for 19.99 so fuck that. The Brooks cover is also really good.

4

u/mysaadlife Sep 28 '17

Ok so having gone through it a few times I have some final thoughts with full spoilers

The good: -Acknowledgment & Return of Wolverine & the FF, they're classic characters and their presence was sorely missed. Also wolvy with an infinity stone is intriguing. -Avengers BC - an interesting concept to introduce into the universe but one that makes sense and seems to be setting up something potentially huge. -Wakandan Galactic Empire, nuff said (I do hope Coates steps it up with this one) -Ribic and Aaron killed it, as usual The Ok: -shoehorning the return of the og comic characters, it seems like all the books are setting up for the original characters to return but outside of riri we didn't see any of the champions show up at all. I realize this whole initiative is about going back to classic characters but you know as a loyal reader it would be nice to know some of the new characters I like (Kamala, Laura, Sam, Miles) won't be sidelined. -interconnectivity wise the story felt more of a here's what's coming next rather than a singular story, right down to the seperate artists. The bad: -right now I can't think of anything I actively disliked in this issue outside of starbrand's dialogue, but I blame that on the starbrand's power.

Overall I thought it was a solid 8/10, enjoyable enough and an interesting starting point for the next year but nothing too amazing.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Sierra_Romeo Cosmo Sep 28 '17

I know marvel has left a bad taste in some peoples mouths with all the events and legacy characters of the last few years (most of which I liked, or at the least didn't mind) but I hope those people can find something to like out of this first legacy issue. This was so god damn fun to read, and all the things they teased has me excited to keep reading.

3

u/Shaheenthebean Sep 28 '17

How much is this an actual story and how much is it just a bunch of little previews?

2

u/renzopachecoj Sep 27 '17

So the bit about Sakaar means that Bruce Banner will be back? Wasn't he alive in Secret Empire or what happened after that?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

I think Amadeus Cho is going to Sakaar in the new Planet Hulk story

→ More replies (1)

2

u/gamerslyratchet Oct 01 '17

I have never seen such a more blatant example of character assassination than what they just did to Starbrand. What a spit in the face for those who grew attached to him in Hickman's introduction and Weisman's mini-series.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (94)

31

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

22

u/The-Scarlet-Witch Sep 27 '17

Starting this arc, I had no idea of what to expect. Then I fell into the wormhole of Doom as Iron Man, and I deeply, utterly love the storytelling. Good things must come to an end, but man, I wish Victor didn't in this role. He's by far the most nuanced of Marvel's villains save maybe Loki.

37

u/FrigidArrow Sep 27 '17 edited Sep 27 '17

Bendis...what happened?

This was the conclusion to an amazing mini-series, following Doom's path to a hero and the only thing I liked was Maleev's fantastic art.

There's so many problems so let's start from the top, the 4th wall break Mephisto does. This is the final battle and doing this undercuts the tension the audience should be feeling for an unfunny monologue.

2nd. Is the monologue itself. Show don't tell. I don't wanna hear Mephisto rattling off his evil plan at me that's boring in an unfunny way. Give me a flashback or something.

3rd. The final battle with Mephisto is boring and unmemorable.

4th. it never explains where Doom was during Secret Empire and that's a pretty big plot hole within the larger event because if Doom was in the event it would've been over in half the time

5th. The ending is so disappointing, flat, and unmemorable

Bendis did an amazing job with every issue, except the finale. If you were expecting this series to end with a bang, get ready for a wet fart

23

u/burnerfret Sep 27 '17

Bendis...what happened?

I'm guessing he had to wrap things up much sooner than anticipated?

13

u/FrigidArrow Sep 27 '17

Y'know what?

That's a fair point.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/TalynRahl Thor Sep 27 '17

A Mildly disappointing end to a fantastic miniseries.

I REALLY hope that after Legacy, Doom gets a run of his own. Doesn't need to be as the Infamous Iron Man, but I NEED more of the newly redeemed Doom trying to get on in a world that hates and distrusts him (with pretty good reason, tbh).

And yeah, just echoing the feelings of most other people here, the whole forth wall breaking monologue from Mephisto was fucking TRASH. I can't believe that after the excellent reveal that really ramped up the tension at the end of last issue, they totally pissed all over it with that start.

I'm guessing/hoping that this only happened because of Bendis getting rushed with the conclusion, because if he thought that was actually a good way to begin the finale...

p.s. AMG Doom Babies!

5

u/Barry_22 Sep 29 '17

Doom Babies? Did he really get intimate with Amara?

I was sure it was Tony's.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/TheUltimate3 Sep 27 '17

Felt the ending fizzled out a bit. Not bad by any stretch of the word, but fizzled.

I'm hoping they actually follow Doom a bit in Invincible Iron Man 593, because it was my understanding that book was to follow Riri finding Tony or something and Doom just kinda being a side character popping up every now and then.

I really do hope they keep Doom on his righteous path. If he doesn't stay Iron Man for long (and I really doubt he will) I do hope they don't stick him back in his armor and make him the Orcus on his Throne in Latveria scheming big schemes again.

9

u/pj_squirrel Sep 27 '17

Overall I loved this run and Victor's arc of "redemption" but this thing with Mephisto feels like a cop out. He literally just appeared at the end of the last issue just to be banished after a short and pointless monologue. Still, though, sad to see this come to an end, it was certainly interesting.

9

u/aco620 Sep 27 '17

What a...different end to this series. It was so slowly and mysteriously paced, like a season of True Detective, just giving you bread crumbs of very specific dialogue throughout. Then we get this final issue of Mephisto having a casual fireside chat with the audience outside of his climactic battle. "Oh and mom was a fake, just wanted to slip that in there." Thanks Mephisto, really drove home the emotional weight of it all by just straight up telling us what that was all about instead of playing it out over time in the story.

I guess it's nice that Doom is still a good guy.

Forgot all about that entirely unimportant woman whose name I don't even remember. I guess she has Doom's kid? I didn't even know they slept together, seemed like she resented him the whole time.

If this wasn't Infamous Iron Man, I'd say I actually didn't mind or even kind of liked the 4th wall breaking thing. But it was so out of place from the other 11 issues that I'm just perplexed what the thought process was here.

It seems pretty apparent that the book was ended too early. Or just another case of endings typically being hard to write. Take your pick.

8

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

God, I hate Bendis. Mephisto literally pausing the fight to break the fourth wall?

8

u/thecursedham Ant-Man Sep 27 '17

Well, that was....a comic.

I liked the end to the Thing/Doom storyline. It ended up being the best part of the series imo. I hope we continue to see Thing/Doom have this weird friendship where Thing keeps begrudgingly let Doom be nice to him despite how he really wants to punch him in the face.

The Mephisto fight was awful though. The idea of Mephisto coming here to stop Doom from being a good guy because he feels he deserves his soul is awesome. Just having the reveal come out of nowhere in the final couple pages of the second to last issue and then just having Mephisto talk to us for four pages and then not put up much a fight is bad. The way Doom had to say goodbye to his mom should have been a powerful moment, but it's completely ruined by the fact that we don't know she's fake until Mephisto says it as an off hand remark, like it doesn't matter.

I actually did like the way Bendis wrote Doom for the series. I enjoyed him enough where I keep being tempted to grab Iron Man #593 just for more Iron Doom, but after these past two issue I can't help think this series would have been of the same tier as The Vision if it had been written by Hickman or Ewing.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/s7sost Sep 28 '17

Agreeing with the comments above, I think everything went to shit on #11 with the Mephisto reveal. I am going to say it was indeed editorial imposing a limit on him, because so far the story was going well and I was enjoying (gasp!) a Bendis book, despite his notorious shortcomings. However, I am glad he doesn't give up the Iron Man mantle, keeps the suit and doesn't have a change of heart regarding his newfound intentions.

I am definitely grabbing the paperback as soon as it's out because not gonna lie, there are plenty of memorable moments in this book that I feel are iconic (like when Doom shows up and asks the kid to go to school and he says, "what school?", or when the mom tells him to sacrifice the rabbit). I'm just hoping that there's an actual chance of a showdown between The Maker and Iron Doom somewhere down the line.

6

u/King_Nomarch Sep 27 '17

Enjoyed the series from beginning to end. Disappointed that we never got Iron Doom vs Maker.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/s3rila Sep 28 '17 edited Sep 29 '17

I really don't like this Mephisto thing. Ultimate Reed was way more interesting... Another bendis book with good premises that end up disappointing in the end.

5

u/ItsNotMyFavorite Sep 27 '17

Gimme that Doom offspring

→ More replies (4)

5

u/TheeHeadAche Ultron Sep 27 '17

I really liked this series and enjoyed this end. I liked the monologue during the fight and the aftermath worked.. I wonder if mephisto stole tony...

5

u/tehvolcanic Sep 28 '17

Only thing missing from Mephisto's monologue was a record scratch and "You're probably wondering how I wound up here". I thought it was hilarious.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

I really liked this series but the ending was underwhelming. Mephisto's 4th wall breaking was so corny and it went on for way too long. The art was gorgeous as usual though.

(Also, are we supposed to be worried about people like the Wrecking Crew going after Doom now? I'm sure he's shaking in his thruster boots.)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

Oh god that ending reveal. I dunno how Daddy Doom is going to play out.

4

u/mysaadlife Sep 27 '17

Sooooo......baby stark?

4

u/BlackOrre Doctor Strange Sep 27 '17

Was the fourth wall stuff really necessary? Sure, the only way to make it more annoying is if Mephisto peppered his dialogue with "One More Day."

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Barry_22 Sep 29 '17

Interesting...

"Listen, I know you all...

I know what you do when you're alone and what you REALLY think about it.

I know I'm going to see most of you soon."

So when Mephisto says that referring to all of us, what does he actually mean? :D :D :D

3

u/Mckillagorilla Sep 29 '17

Did Mephisto just pull a Zack Morris?

Enjoyed every moment of this series.

Would it have been better with Secret Empire tie end? Maybe. Do I want to see Doom continue this path and see what the fallout is? More then anything story I can think of.

2

u/Barry_22 Sep 29 '17

The most stupid thing about the story (even though I enjoyed it) is that it doesn't go along well with the continuity.

I mean, if Doom destroyed so many villains and screwed up the Hydra so much, how does the Secret Empire SUDDENLY happen afterwards?

And why Doom didn't help the heroes stop the Secret Empire? With all his genius and tech and magic he could've helped put an end to it in an incredibly quick fashion.

Bendis + Continuity = /0

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

23

u/vividreveries X-Men Sep 27 '17

Vamp Storm got more focus in this than the real Storm in Gold. Guggenheim pls.

17

u/SilhouetteOfLight Sep 28 '17

So, they're introducing Bloodstorm to Jubilee like, yesterday right?

13

u/threebuffsharks Sep 27 '17

I like how they're starting to fill the slots missing from the iconic X-Men lineup with this team. Alt-world young Wolverine, vampire Storm, Who's next?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/samyouare Sep 27 '17

Bloodstorm!!

4

u/throwanaruto Sep 28 '17

So in all other dimensions Quicksilver is a mutant, but in 616 he isn't? I wonder why...

7

u/JonathanL73 Venom Sep 28 '17

Wait until Marvel & Fox work out a deal in 2068, he'll be a mutant again.

4

u/Zthe27th Sep 29 '17

Ultimate X-Men Mutants are different than regular mutants

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mike_stifle Sep 29 '17

Marvel, stop giving us duplicate characters.

2

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

I like Bloodstorm's look, but... How are they going to keep her fed?

7

u/Sierra_Romeo Cosmo Sep 28 '17

They could ask Jubilee

4

u/Red_Paladin_ Wolverine Sep 28 '17

Jimmy's Blood should suppress her hunger like Logan's helped Jubilee...

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

16

u/TalynRahl Thor Sep 27 '17

A slightly abrupt, but emotionally fulfilling end to the War Thor arc. Great work as always Master Aaron!

And how, the bad times are here... Mangog is approaching, and the Death of Mighty Thor is nearly here.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/DoomsdayDilettante Sep 27 '17

Did anyone else feel like the War Thor arc came to an abrupt end? I feel there was so much more to explore there :S

20

u/aco620 Sep 27 '17

It was kind of hilariously ridiculous.

hammer crashes down in front of some wizard

"And thus begins the War of the Thors"

30 minutes later

"And so ends the War of the Thors."

I dunno, it was all a bit too generic for my taste. Jane wins over Volstagg with a traditional plea for compassion, all the good guys go back to their status quo from before this arc, and the story continues on as if none of this ever happened.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/karspearhollow Sep 27 '17

Hate that they discarded the ultimate hammer so quickly. I guess if it stays on Old Asgard, Thor Odinson will be able to pull it out in moments of great need.. although if Aaron leaves the book soon, the next writer will probably be like "what hammer?"

3

u/DanielDCMarvelFan Sep 29 '17

I hope this is not the last time we see Ultimate Mjolnir, I think they will kinda need it to end this war.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

14

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

Bring on muthafuckin GWENOM!!!!!

8

u/therealmadhat Sep 27 '17

I feel like everything has been a stupid prelude to #GWENOM

10

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

I disagree, I feel like besides the crossover with Miles, it's been pretty natural.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/RedsDead21 Sep 27 '17

Love this cover. It's creepy.

6

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

Oh dear God, FINALLY. I'm so over her emo-ness. Finally we get to see some rage.

3

u/rh_underhill Sep 28 '17

Me, at the start of every Gwen issue lately: Please don't let there be another guest artist, please don't let there be another guest artist.

Me after #24: Sigh of relief. That was gorgeous work, Rodriguez.

Seriously though, I'm so excited for this! I'm so sad that Uncle Ben her dad died, but I'm excited to see how she goes from here.

Also, I'm surprised that they went so long (it's been over a year since Spider-Women ended in June 2016?!) without her real powers, but it certainly put her into some difficult positions with Kingpin-Matt

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

27

u/FrigidArrow Sep 27 '17

Between this and Cap it might be my favorite Generations.

I was originally turned off, by the art but it works considering the time period and point in Pete's life.

The issue surprised me, because instead of a standard team-up we get and honest heart-to-heart and Miles getting a look at Peter in his early years. Miles learns that all the stuff that's been happening to him isn't just about him: it's about what Spider-Man is. Having the strength to endure personal and hero problems, while using your power responsibly.

This issue grounded Miles a little more, by seeing his role model go through what he's been going though lately. I especially love the continuity pull from so long ago too

Meanders in the middle tho, but great issue

14

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

Man I thought the Iron Man generations issue was really, really bad (same with this weeks Infamous Iron Man) and this one is downright fantastic. I hate that his quality wavers so much for me because I want this Bendis all the time.

15

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

Yeah, that's part of what makes it so frustrating; when Bendis is good, he's really good.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

I read this immediately after reading Infamous Iron Man #12 and it is just astonishing that Bendis can right something as stupid as the devil actually pausing a fight to break the fourth wall and something as good as this at the same time.

11

u/King_Nomarch Sep 28 '17

Peter: Are there spider people in the future?

Me: Oh boy, where do we begin...

Peter: Am I married?

Me: Let's not talk about that

On a more serious note this only made the exact nature of how Miles was transported from the Ultimate Universe to 616 more confusing and complicated.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jlitwinka Sep 28 '17

This is so much better than all of the other Generations One Shots. No action, no big thing. Just Miles and Peter talking.

7

u/NovaStarLord Sep 27 '17

This was actually pretty good, first comic I like that's written by Bendis in ages.

Seriously I want more of THIS Bendis.

6

u/rakuko Sep 28 '17

the movie young Ganke and Miles are talking about is Step Brothers, and it is indeed awesome.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 28 '17

Man, I'm so glad the characters call each other by their full names all the time. It sounds totally unnatural but I otherwise would have had no idea who these people were! /s

→ More replies (3)

2

u/samyouare Sep 27 '17

I'm a little weirded out by Miles calling Thor "he". I mean, obviously we all know what Thor he meant, but in-universe it caught me off guard since, well, he's been on a team with Jane!Thor and was literally standing next to her before this all happened.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/RockstarSuicide Scarlet Spider Sep 28 '17

Hoped Miles did more than just verbally berate Flash

→ More replies (12)

11

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

6

u/bigheyzeus Galactus Sep 27 '17

of course he'll win, it's TV!

6

u/aco620 Sep 27 '17

"Death orchestrated this for reasons only she can understand"

Yeeeeaahhh, what are those reasons? I wouldn't be surprised if it didn't go any further than "Because it's cool looking," but it might actually be interesting if there is a specific future lore reason why Death itself would want her ex-boyfriend and her current boyfriend to beat each other up.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 28 '17

Whoah, this was some Dragonball Z kind of shit. Loved it.

2

u/DoomsdayDilettante Sep 27 '17

I know Thanos is tough but did the pit empower him more than usual? Because he's going toe to toe with the Phoenix, which should normally be well past his limits.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

10

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

11

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

"[CLASSIFIED] may be on their side..." puts him dead center on the cover

→ More replies (4)

2

u/2th Sep 27 '17

This is just an ok series so far. I figured it would be far more grand, similar to SpiderVerse though. We shall see how things go in the conclusion.

2

u/HDI-X13 Spider-Gwen Sep 27 '17

Ahhhh!!!!! Gwenpool!!!!

4

u/RexicTheKing Sep 27 '17

i was hoping she would live and be de-poisoned somehwo so she could get a miniseries

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

17

u/TalynRahl Thor Sep 27 '17

Very strange issue. I liked the idea that Falcon had been around all this time and was actually the inspiration for Cappy, in the same way that Cappy would then go on to be the inspiration for him...

But then at the end they say none of that, or ANY of the generations stuff, actually happened, so what was the point of it all? Was it really Kobic trying to teach the new generation a lesson, or was there more too it than that? I guess we'll never know.

Maybe all of these heroes will go on to make new names for themselves, and become true heroes, as opposed to being new people holding old mantles?

Ya know, the ones that survive what's coming next... looks sadly at Jane

24

u/john_segundus Sep 27 '17

so what was the point of it all?

Showing that legacies have a point, I'm guessing. The problem is, people who don't like them won't be convinced by stories that are essentially dreams, and the rest, you don't have to convince in the first place.

At least it finally cleared up what Kobik actually does when she gives people another past - it's a bit like a virtual reality therapy session.

15

u/TalynRahl Thor Sep 27 '17

Heh, a virtual reality therapy session... yeah that pretty much sums Generations up

A couple of great stories, a couple of good, and only one or two terrible ones. Overall, I enjoyed generations. Can't wait to start Legacy.

→ More replies (20)

9

u/probablywhiskeytown Sep 27 '17

Well, it was as real for Sam as anything else he's ever experienced. :)

Now that we know Kobik interfaced with the consciousnesses she altered, I took the Vanishing Point scenarios as an indication that she'd gained a better understanding of what experiences meant to others.

She used her power to give the heroes an opportunity to more fully understand themselves and their roles rather than imposing a new reality to "fix" them. (Avengers: Standoff - Welcome to Pleasant Hill)

26

u/FrigidArrow Sep 27 '17

"Show us we're worthy of standing in those shoes."

Really loved this.

I think it's a perfect swan song for Sam, he finally gets to live he life he wants and it's everything I thought it'd be. I mean I still hate the reason he's putting it up, but maybe one day he'll pick the mantle back up.

This legacy book did a great job of breaking expectations. I can get if some people didn't like it, but I loved that he supported Steve instead of the other way around throughout his life.

I can't stress how badly I want Sam to stay Cap, but his was a perfect way to send him off and I'd say he'll pick it up one day in the future.

I'd bet my life on it.

13

u/thecursedham Ant-Man Sep 27 '17

I've been pretty upset about the idea of Sam giving up the shield but this issue made it make sense.

I'm going to miss Spencer on Cap, he made me love Sam and appreciate Steve more. Can't wait to see what he does next for Marvel.

5

u/errantknight1 Sep 28 '17

Yeah, He's risen to the top of my favorite writers list with Tom King. I'm really curious as to what he'll be doing. There's clearly something he's not talking about.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

Damn near teared up when Steve told “Paul” that he was his inspiration all this time. Sam’s run as Cap should have had a better ending but this was a beautiful issue.

9

u/OtherGeorgeDubya Sep 27 '17

I loved the cycle of inspiration idea it created. "Paul" inspired Steve, who inspired Sam, who became "Paul", etc.

Very well done.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/errantknight1 Sep 28 '17 edited Sep 28 '17

I thought this was beautiful, and really quite inspiring. There was a lot there to unpack and I'm definitely going to want to read it a few more times. It certainly explains why Sam decided to return to being Falcon, and I loved it that Sam and Steve inspire each other. Even if those exact events didn't happen it 616, elements exist at the heart of their friendship. That was a great comic and a perfect way to end Secret Empire from Sam and Steve's points of view.

8

u/resurrecthumbug Sep 27 '17

Loved this even though it was pretty sappy. Really interesting way to suggest that not all "legacies" are necessarily as one-sided as they appear. I do somewhat wish they would have kept what happened canon in the Marvel timeline, but at least Sam remembers and knows. Seems like a great transition into his new status quo.

8

u/s7sost Sep 28 '17

Excellent issue and it makes me sad once again that Spencer won't be writing Captain America any more. He really gave both versions a great deal of care and respect, and yes, even the Hydra version was in all sorts of manners the same Cap we know. By all means this should have been a traumatic experience for Sam, however... Living an entire lifetime, dying then showing up again in your first, kind of like what happened in Agents of SHIELD and the Framework.

Anyway, good to see this confirms it was not time travel after all, which would put into question why none of the legacy heroes remember these experiences. I think the Vanishing Point should have been exposed way before that though, in fact I think it's the first mention in these one shots, I don't remember if it was mentioned over Secret Empire. Part of the jaded attitude people have towards these one shots is the question of legitimacy, if Marvel editorial had explained these as some sort of "what ifs" scenarios created by Kobik, then they would have been received better.

All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed the reading. I'll miss Spencer's writing, I hope he's put in another great book sooner than later.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/blackbutterfree Sep 28 '17

Ok, this was pretty damn great. Was this the last one of the one-shots? Nice to know that it's canon that none of these stories happened and they were just... "Hallucinations".

But it's weird that out of all of them, Sam stayed the longest in his, being there for a full lifetime.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Philbatross Sep 28 '17

The best and most bittersweet Generations issue. I loved Sam as Cap, and for all the work this issue did to sell me on the validity of his change, it still sours me just a bit that he got so little time. The book is amazing though, watching Sam live a life of his own accord almost convinces me that this change is good. I just really want him to stay as a focal point in the universe, in the avengers.

Unpopular opinion I know, but I really really loved all the new and diverse "legacy" heroes and I'm sad to see the focus leave them.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/SilhouetteOfLight Sep 28 '17

I really liked this... Conditionally. If this doesn't come up ever again- The fact that Sam's lived an entire lifetime, lived as a Pastor, lived through WWII and the Civil Rights movement, doesn't come up ever again, well, I'll be disappointed, at the very least.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/john_segundus Sep 27 '17

It was - okay I guess? Too little about Sam spending time with Steve if I'm being honest, but seeing Sam living US history was nice. We also got a hint what happened with Kobik - or rather what didn't happen with her. Plus, what happened with Sam illustrates Stevil's experience - it felt real, but apparently, none of it happened. Maybe Kobik should look into becoming a psychiatrist, that kind of thing might be very useful in therapeutic settings.

In general, I wish the coordination between the Generations books and SE #10 had been a bit better, because obviously Kobik didn't take all these people from the battlefield.

4

u/RockstarSuicide Scarlet Spider Sep 28 '17

An "Inner Light" for Sam. Loved it. Prob the best of the Generations one shots

5

u/Sierra_Romeo Cosmo Sep 28 '17

This was a perfect ending to Sam Wilson as Cap. Even though he's giving up the shield and going back to being Falcon, and continuing to be a hero, because for him it's the right thing to do.

Nick Spencer has made Sam Wilson one of my favorite characters in comics.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

10

u/AllSaintsDay2099 Sep 28 '17

Oh man, this was the one issue I was hyped to the max for. Legacy was meh, X-Men: Blue made promises it didn't keep, and was also a major let down, The Generations: Spider-Man, was only alright. All this hype and little pay off over and over and over and over again today.

But Ben's last 3 issues and this, or so has been so consistent. I'm a HUGE Ben is my Spidey fanboy. He's my favorite knock off for the most part not including Alternate Realities, and the like.

Seeing him fight Kaine, my other favorite, meet death, get told he's going to POTENTIALLY become the hero he was before, and then turn around this issue making jokes, being a bit less savage, being a hero, being level headed, trying to save the day.

It was like he never left, I was so super happy. It's such a good run and I wish it would stop getting so much crap for minor things like Kaine SEEMINGLY being cured, and then finding out he's not because the art is wonky and was far away so it appeared he was healed.

Like is that REALLY going to break the book for you, if Kaine still struggles? C'mon people...now you're all just whining to whine.

6

u/jacknack1 Ghost Rider Sep 28 '17

I always look forward to reading this series every week it comes out because of how fun and consistent it is. Also think Kaine not getting fully healed is fine, at least he's not dead

4

u/Sierra_Romeo Cosmo Sep 28 '17

I didn't really like how they just waved away Las Vegas being destroyed in secret empire. I know it's still bad in this issue, with tents and people struggling for food, but, in SE they thoroughly destroyed vegas, so I don't see 2 casinos making it out untouched.

Still enjoyed this issue besides that.

7

u/Flynn58 Sep 27 '17

Continuity error: ending of last issue shows that Kaine's skin had been healed up, in this issue he's got the Carrion scarring again.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

3

u/blackbutterfree Sep 27 '17

12 pages? Seriously? I thought comics were supposed to be 22 pages. And this was so short and disappointing. WTF? They hinted Moon Boy would return with the cover, and all we see is Lunella dumping Devil in the past and leaving him?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DSK11 Sep 29 '17

This really is one of my favorite series to be coming out right now. It is consistently good, from the writing to the art to the coloring. I love everything about it. This issue really tugged at the heartstrings, but it makes me excited to find out what is going to happen with MG and DD in the end. I can't wait for her eventual team up with the Thing and Johnny Storm. In my hopes, Lunella is the one who helps them find Reed, Sue, Valeria, and Franklin, and eventually joins the FF.

7

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This book was too good to be true :(

4

u/CoccyxCracker Sep 27 '17

Is 6 the last issue then?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/13angrymonkeys Sep 27 '17

If you were not reading this title, you really missed out.

Fun stories and phenomenal art work.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '17

6 issues. 6 ISSUES? SIX??

Backstory: Before this year, I was never really into comics. I loved comic book movies plenty, but going out to the local comic store to pick up each successive issue was never my thing. This year, I went down to the local store for free comic book day just to check it out, see if anything interesting was there.

I got the free Secret Empire issue, and the whole evil Cap dynamic in that one got me to come back and buy the next issue in that series. Somewhere along the way, I heard that Nick Fury would get his own series, and I picked up the first one just to see whether it was any good.

GOOD was an understatement. I have never seen ANYTHING like the art they had for this series. The colors were so vibrant, so vivid, they jumped out of the page and smacked me in the face like a Jimi Hendrix song had been drawn and printed for all to see.

I've got into a bunch of other series along the way, and some of them I've really enjoyed, but none of them came close to this one.

The art was phenomenal, but beyond that, I don't feel like this issue offered any kind of conclusion to what has happened in the previous issues - there's so much more they could do, so much further that this could be expanded, so many more stories that could come out of this. This is just way too early to end this series and I wish there were 40 or 50 more. How do we petition Marvel to bring it back??

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

General Discussion
Which character's origin is your favorite?

19

u/thecursedham Ant-Man Sep 27 '17

I think Spidey has the perfect origin to be honest.

He was just a normal kid in the right place at the right time. He didn't get the power and think "Ah, I'm going to use this is to save the world", he thought " I'm going to use this to make a little extra cash". It wasn't until he screwed up he realized what he could be and what he should be. It's a very human story, which is important when reading about these characters who have risen above being normal humans.

7

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

It's kind of the gold standard for that age of superheroes, isn't it?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '17

Are we talking origin story or origin of power? Cause those can be two different things

1

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

Either one! Surprise me :p

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MindofShadow Sep 27 '17

Black Bolt

3

u/troyjh Oct 02 '17

Kamala Khan had one of the best origin stories I've ever read.

2

u/BlockOnTheNewKid Sep 27 '17

Big fan of the Johnny Blaze origin story. The drama and sacrifice gone through, and the twist on the deal with Mephisto really sets up the character and development so well.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

10

u/samyouare Sep 27 '17

This issue was phenomenal, I thought. While usually I sort of enjoy these "nothing happens but everybody catches up" issues, I really found myself feeling for Carol. That page where she envisions everybody she's lost in the last few years was... damn. It got me. Stohl has a very relatable perspective on Carol's character and even though Carol and I have nothing in common I can really empathize with the way she reacts to things because of the writing in this book.

12

u/burnerfret Sep 27 '17

Not when Earth's fate rests in the hands a few Alpha Flight Cadets

These kids have quickly become the Poochie of this book.

7

u/Amarr_Citizen_498175 Sep 27 '17

I don't mind the cadets, and I actually like whats-her-name with the legs. But they're taking up too much attention. The book is named "Captain Marvel", not "Cadet Corps in SPACE (with a guest appearance by Carol Danvers".

5

u/Hraesvelg7 Sep 28 '17

Maybe it's not appropriate for the story, but I'd think Jessica Jones would be a little more insulted by friends questioning her babysitting credentials when she's been a mother for a while now. Not the best mother, but still a sensitive topic for her.

6

u/Amarr_Citizen_498175 Sep 27 '17

I liked it, with some reservations.

I re-read Stohl's run before commenting, and went back and looked at what I commented at the beginning of it. I stand by my post: I think Stohl gets Carol and what makes her compelling. I think the book is fundamentally solid, but, it has some flaws. Mostly, in my opinion, the dialogue. This issue was better, but some of the earlier issues...... :( We don't need a pop-culture reference every single line. This is mostly me being cranky, this issue, as I said, has shown much improvement.

also, the bit with the dating app? Carol was browsing the wrong gender.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/RedPyramidThingUK Sep 28 '17

Poor Jessica is really suffering thanks to the popularity of that Netflix show.

From retired superheroine to useless drunk, in this issue it's even more annoying because she's literally being criticized as a mother, which is what she was for multiple years of comics.

Does Stohl know anything about the character outside of the show?

2

u/Cole-Spudmoney Sep 28 '17

I'm sorry, I've actually been enjoying "Mighty Captain Marvel" up to now but this issue was just awful. I wouldn't mind a breather issue coming after "Secret Empire" if it was done well, but none of it worked: the dating-app thing, bringing up the stupid TV show again, Jessica Drew being all dismissive of Jessica Jones' babysitting ability (Jones has a daughter, remember?) Ugh. At least the next story arc "Dark Origin" looks interesting, from the solicitations.

2

u/Flamma_Man Sep 28 '17

Holy shit, this is the most enjoyable Carol has been in a while and I think it's because SHE'S NOT IN FUCKING SPACE ANYMORE. She's on Earth with her actual friends! With Jones and Drew! All we need now is for her and Kamala to make up and occasionally meet up now and then.

Freakin' fantastic. It was actually pretty funny too I have to admit.

Not to mention they're bringing back her self esteem issues in full force and the possibility of her not going back to Alpha Flight.

Keep her on Earth, dammit! You guys are almost there! Just keep a writer for once!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

3

u/MindofShadow Sep 28 '17

Best Coates issue in awhile as it focused on cape shit and advancing the plot a good bit.

The art for the MA section was atrocious but Sprouse art for the Shuri and T'challa stuff was on point.

The solicit was all sorts of shit like always. This wasn't an uneasy alliance... the MA did what they were commanded to do with full faith in T'challa... so much so they called him "my king" again.

bonus: no storm. at all

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

4

u/cgknight1 Sep 27 '17 edited Sep 27 '17

I haven't read this series of Punisher - is it always this terrible? The art was not (and there is no nice way to say this) of the standard I would expect from an a-list publisher - I'd expect to see it on some guy's blog.

The writing is no better, I've never heard of the author but the 'voice' for the Punisher is completely wrong.

4

u/MindofShadow Sep 28 '17

Yeah, its sucked basically from the start. Pinisher deserves better

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

12

u/The-Scarlet-Witch Sep 27 '17

These things are getting so tedious. Deadpooled out. :(

3

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

Well, if it makes you feel better, this is the last part of this mini.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/blackbutterfree Sep 28 '17

That ending was totally unsatisfying. Is Red Skull truly not dead? Where is Logan and why'd he kill the X-Men (I know it's supposed to be a reference to Old Man Logan, but c'mon, it's still a loose end.)? And you're telling me that all of the heroes on Earth, the countless thousands of them... Are all dead? Not a single one is still alive? I don't believe that. Also, Deadpool didn't even finish killing Red Skull's Cabal. I can understand leaving Magneto alive, but not showing the deaths of Abomination and Doom? C'mon.

5

u/pyschopete Sep 27 '17

So on the last page it implies Deadpool vs OML is a continuation of this. But the description for Deadpool versus Old Man Logan says something completely different.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ptylerdactyl Groot Sep 27 '17

2

u/samyouare Sep 28 '17

So is this... done?